Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Handout On Comparative Essays
A Handout On Comparative Essays
Use the
knife to extract peanut butter from the jar and spread it evenly on both
pieces of bread.
The writer uses transitional expressions to lead the reader through the steps of the
process.
Finally, put the two pieces of bread together; the peanut butter will make
them stick to each other. If you wish, you can then use the knife to cut the
Alternating method:
sandwich in half for ease of eating.
POC 1
Both-
A- individual difference
B- individual difference COMPARE AND CONTRAST ESSAY
POC 2
'' '' Compare and contrast essays may be required in many different classes—
POC 3
""
literature, history, social sciences, art, and others. Whatever the topic of
your essay, the ability to compare and contrast is an essential skill involving
critical and analytical thinking.
- facts of the literary work
Introduction - strong transitions
- equal attention to both works
- keep strikethroughs to a minimum
The purpose of a comparison and contrast essay is to analyze
the similarities (compare) and differences (contrast), usually
between two things and sometimes among three or more things.
Your reader will be looking for a clear and organized
presentation of your facts, with strong transitions, to make the
relationships easy to understand. You can begin brainstorming your essay
by compiling two separate lists: one a list of the similarities between the
two subjects and another a list of the differences. Making these lists can
help you narrow the focus of your paper and identify the points of
comparison you want to explore. For instance, if you are comparing two
statues, you might look at the medium, the time periods in which they were
produced, their size, the materials used, their subjects, and so on.
Comparison and contrast essays are typically organized in one of two
ways: the block method or the alternating method. For guidance, see the
box “Organizational Structures for Comparison and Contrast Essays” (page
278). You may find that you develop new ideas as you write your draft.
That’s fine. Make a note of them and decide if you want to incorporate them
in your next draft. It’s wise to write a complete draft and leave it alone for a
day or two. Go back and reread what you’ve written. Are the similarities
and differences clear? Have you given more or less equal attention to the
subjects you’re comparing? Is there information missing? Revise to ensure
your essay is clear, complete, and free of errors.
There are two common organizational approaches for the comparison and contrast
essay: the alternating method and the block method. Each has its own pattern.
A- Manto
Alternating Method B- Oedipus/TCITR
The alternating method can be most successful when you have closely related ideas
and information about both A and B that lends itself to a point-by-point style of
comparison.
• Introductory paragraph
• Discussion of A and B with reference to first point of comparison
• Discussion of A and B with reference to second point of comparison
• Discussion of A and B with reference to third point of comparison
• Conclusion
Block Method
The block method is most useful when your content does not lend itself to a point-by-
point comparison between A and B. The block method is also useful when your ideas
about B build on your ideas about A. It’s a sensible structure to use when you want to
compare and contrast three or more subjects. To help your reader follow your
argument, present the different points of comparison in parallel.
• Introductory paragraph
• Discussion of A
• Point 1
• Point 2
• Point 3
• Discussion of B
• Point 1
• Point 2
• Point 3
• Conclusion
DO DON’T