Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Metal Additive Manufacturing Magazine Autumn 2023
Metal Additive Manufacturing Magazine Autumn 2023
3 AUTUMN 2023 THE MAGAZINE FOR THE METAL ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY
METAL
AM
in this issue
HOW AM IS CHANGING AEROSPACE
METAL AM THE NORWEGIAN WAY
HOT ISOSTATIC PRESSING & AM
•
•
METAL
Publisher & Editorial Offices
Inovar Communications Ltd
ADDITIVE
11 Park Plaza
Battlefield Enterprise Park
Shrewsbury SY1 3AF
MANUFACTURING
United Kingdom
Tel: +44 (0)1743 469909
www.metal-am.com
Assistant News Editor Sometimes we have to look to the past to see just how far we’ve
Charlie Hopson-VandenBos come. For those readers who are at Formnext for the first time
charlie@inovar-communications.com
and have just picked up a copy of Metal AM magazine, it is
Editorial Assistant hard to appreciate the metal Additive Manufacturing industry’s
Amelia Gregory, amelia@inovar-communications.com
journey to this point in its relatively short history.
Technical Consultant
Dr Martin McMahon
When I look back to 2015 – the year of the very first Formnext
Senior Digital Marketer and the year that we launched this magazine – and consider the
Swetha Akshita, swetha@inovar-communications.com
progress that has been made in the intervening years, the indus-
Digital Marketer try’s transformation is deeply impressive. From a landscape
Mulltisa Moung, mulltisa@inovar-communications.com
that was dominated by one AM process, Laser Beam Powder Bed
Production Manager Fusion (PBF-LB), we now see a multitude of processes that are
Hugo Ribeiro, hugo@inovar-communications.com
ready for industrial use. Many of these ‘new’ processes have the
Operations & Partnerships Manager advantage of being built on the foundations of other industrial
Merryl Le Roux, merryl@inovar-communications.com
technologies, for example welding in the case of wire-based
Office & Accounts Manager
Directed Energy Deposition (DED) or Metal Injection Moulding in
Jo Sheffield, jo@inovar-communications.com
the case of Binder Jetting (BJT).
Subscriptions
Metal Additive Manufacturing is published on a Back to 2015, it was very much a case of a ‘technology looking
quarterly basis as either a free digital publication for markets’ at Formnext. Today, there is a real sense that it is
or via a paid print subscription. The annual print
subscription charge for four issues is £150.00
now the major end-user sectors that are taking the initiative and
including shipping. Rates in € and US$ are available laying the groundwork for the widespread adoption of AM. In this
on application. issue we offer insight into two distinct area of application – aero-
Accuracy of contents space, and oil and gas. To say that AM has been transformative
Whilst every effort has been made to ensure the in aerospace engineering is an understatement, with a new
accuracy of the information in this publication,
the publisher accepts no responsibility for errors
generation of engines being designed around AM.
or omissions or for any consequences arising
there from. Inovar Communications Ltd cannot be The story of oil and gas, and the related maritime sector, is
held responsible for views or claims expressed in many ways the opposite to aerospace. Both are leveraging
by contributors or advertisers, which are not
necessarily those of the publisher. very different opportunities presented by AM. As our feature
Advertisements
on Norway highlights, here much of the value of AM is for
Although all advertising material is expected to larger parts that were designed for conventional manufacturing
conform to ethical standards, inclusion in this processes. However, they can now be produced on demand and
publication does not constitute a guarantee or where needed, avoiding the need for vast spare parts ware-
endorsement of the quality or value of products or
of the claims made by its manufacturer. houses - a major shift to faster, greener and more cost-effective
Reproduction, storage and usage ‘digital’ spare parts solutions.
Single photocopies of articles may be made for
personal use in accordance with national copyright So a vision made real, thanks the efforts of all players in the AM
laws. All rights reserved. Except as outlined above,
industry, from machine producers to those developing industry
no part of this publication may be reproduced,
modified or extracted in any form or by any means standards, software innovators to materials developers.
without prior permission of the publisher and
copyright owner. Nick Williams
Design and production Managing Director
Inovar Communications Ltd.
ISSN: 2057-3014 (PRINT)
Cover image
ISSN: 2055-7183 (ONLINE)
A wire/plasma Directed Energy Deposition
This magazine is also available for free (DED) build at Norsk Titanium (Courtesy
download from www.metal-am.com Norsk Titanium)
© 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd
Contents
145 Metal AM in the aerospace sector: 161 Slowly but surely: Industrialising
from early successes to the metal Additive Manufacturing the
transformation of an industry Norwegian way
Across the world, a new wave of aerospace While the Norwegian market for Additive
engineers are designing and building Manufacturing has long revolved around
the next generation of aero engines prototyping and polymer materials, metal
and systems around the revolutionary Additive Manufacturing has seen rapid
capabilities of Additive Manufacturing. development in recent years. This is in large
part thanks to the opportunities that the
Twenty years ago this was a vision, but
country’s oil and gas industry is now seeing in
today it is a reality. From fuel nozzles to
the technology.
Stage 5 and Stage 6 low pressure turbine
(LPT) blades, housings to structural In this article, Joppe N Christensen considers
elements, in this article Metal AM why it has taken so long to get started
magazine’s Technical Consultant Martin with metal AM in Norway and introduces
McMahon reviews the progress that has companies and individuals who are now
been made, shining a light on selected leading the way. >>>
applications that offer insight to those in the
aerospace industry who want to get up to
speed with progress. >>>
Regular features...
11 Industry news >>>
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 5
REALIZE
SUPPORT-FREE
3D PRINTING NOW
Introducing Smart Fusion with intelligent
heat management trough closed loop
Learn how!
Download
whitepaper
177 Hot Isostatic Pressing and AM: How 189 The convergence of Additive
to improve product quality and Manufacturing and Artificial
productivity for critical applications Intelligence: Envisioning a future that
Metal Additive Manufacturing is rapidly
is closer than you think
gaining momentum across a broad range of The frenzy of media attention surrounding
industries and is often used for producing Artificial Intelligence (AI) dwarfs the past
components for challenging applications hype surrounding Additive Manufacturing
such as medical implants and rocket (AM). Whether you look to the future with
engines. fear or excitement, there is no escaping the
wave of change that is coming.
To maximise the mechanical strength and
fatigue resistance of such critical AM parts, Whilst we once again hear words like
they must be processed by Hot Isostatic ‘revolution’ being used – to which so many
Pressing (HIP) to eliminate any residual have become immune – Dr Omar Fergani
porosity, and heat treated. believes that we are now at a crucial point of
convergence for AM and AI. Here, he explains
Jim Shipley from Quintus Technologies
why AM is in an especially strong position to
provides an overview of HIP and High
leverage the potential of AI, with the power to
Pressure Heat Treatment technology for
transform many areas of our industry, from
Powder Bed Fusion AM and considers the
part design to machine operation, quality
opportunities that a new generation of HIP
management and beyond. >>>
equipment presents. >>>
SUBSCRIBE
TO OUR NEWSLETTER
www.metal-am.com/subscribe-to-the-metal-
additive-manufacturing-e-newsletter
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 7
Quality, Experience and
Customer Relationships
We are driven by these values.
Elnik’s innovations and experiences in all areas of temperature and atmosphere
management have led us to become the leaders for the Batch-based Debind and Sinter
equipment industry. We have applied these core competencies across a wide variety
of industries through our 50 year history and look forward to the emergence of new
technologies that will continue to drive demand for new innovative products.
We offer:
First Stage Debind Equipment (Catalytic, Solvent, Water)
Debind & Sinter Furnaces (All Metal or Graphite)
Regular features...
11 Industry news >>>
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 9
Osprey® online
The metal powder
webshop
Imagine being able to order Osprey® metal powders at any time,
from any device. Imagine hassle-free ordering, fast shipping,
and premium quality straight from the source. Osprey® Online is
open for business – stocked with powders and expertise! And
now we’ve made the check-out process easier, accepting credit
card payment for even faster expediting. Browse our online alloy
selection optimized for additive manufacturing, including titanium,
maraging steel, nickel-based superalloys, and stainless steels.
Just add to cart, and we’ll ship within 48 hours!
Shop now
metalpowder.sandvik/ospreyonline
10 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Summer 2021 © 2021 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 7 No. 2
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Industry news
PBF-LB titanium
hinge part
highlights AM’s
potential in high-
volume consumer
electronics
The recently launched Honor Magic
V2 folding mobile phone is reported
to be the first high-volume 3C device
to use Additive Manufacturing in the
final production stage. The phone is
a new generation of mobile device
that features a foldable screen, with
the hinge using titanium compo-
nents manufactured via Laser Beam It is reported that around one million Magic V2 phones have been ordered so
Powder Bed Fusion (PBF-LB). At far, double that of the previous generation model (Courtesy Honor)
just 9.9 mm thick when closed, and
weighing 231 g, it is reported to be compared to a more traditional metal printing in terms of enhanced
the thinnest and lightest foldable manufacturing method, this cost was product design and functionality.
phone currently available from any said to be affordable and the process The growing trend of integrating 3D
manufacturer. more efficient. metal printing in various 3C products
Being one of the key components “Honor is very confident in this emphasises its increasing importance
in the phone, the hinge has been product and is currently placing an in the consumer electronics industry,”
tested to operate for 400,000 folds – order. The volume has doubled from added Xie.
which equates to being opened and that of the previous generation, and www.hihonor.com | en.hb3dp.com
closed over one hundred times a day the first batch of orders is about www.eplus3d.com
for ten years. one million units,” added Eplus3D,
The hinge was developed by quoting an unnamed supplier in the
Honor, with the involvement of mobile phone supply chain.
several Chinese Additive Manufac- Celine Xie, Overseas Business
turing companies, including HBD and Development & Marketing Manager
Eplus3D. The hinge shaft cover is at HBD told Metal AM magazine that
made of titanium alloy, which makes the significance of this achievement
the component lighter and thinner extends beyond the Honor Magic V2.
and is crucial to reducing the overall “Reports have surfaced indicating
thickness and weight of the folding that the next generation Apple Watch
screen. Ultra will also incorporate titanium
After the shaft cover has been 3D printing, partially replacing tradi-
additively manufactured, it is sent tional CNC milling technology.”
to a further supplier for grinding Although the use of metal Additive
and polishing before being delivered Manufacturing in the Apple watch
to Honor. Eplus3D stated that the is currently unconfirmed, it would The hinge shaft cover is additively
cost of the additively manufactured represent a major breakthrough for manufactured using aerospace-
raw part was approximately $4, with the technology. “This transition high- grade titanium alloy, key to reducing
the cost of grinding and polishing lights the industry’s recognition of the overall thickness and weight of
stage adding around $40. However, the immense potential offered by 3D the folding screen (Courtesy Honor)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 11
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
12 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
AM METAL POWDER
MANUFACTURER
Ti64 Al
ALLOYS
W Ta Ni
ALLOYS
CHARACTERISTICS
Plasma Quality Powder
High Sphericity
High Purity
Traceability
Tekna.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
14 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Our CV.
additiveindustries.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
16 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Velo3D reports 28% revenue increase in systems have become the majority
of our quarterly shipments, we are
second quarter 2023 now seeing the benefits of scale
in our production processes. This
Velo3D, Inc, headquartered in profitability remains clear and with scale, combined with the continued
Campbell, California, USA, has the announcement of our registered improvement in materials costs and
announced its financial results for direct offering of $70 million of senior manufacturing efficiency, has enabled
its second quarter, ended June 30, secured convertible notes, we believe us to improve our gross margin in
2023, reporting a revenue of $25.1 we have strong liquidity to reach our the second quarter. We also remain
million – a 28% increase from the goal of sustained profitability.” committed to managing our expense
previous year. Operating expenses Buller continued, “Operationally, structure and expect to materially
for the second quarter were $28.7 manufacturing cycle times continue reduce our operating costs in the
million, compared to $27 million in to improve for our Sapphire XC and second half of the year.”
the first quarter of 2023. Non-GAAP Sapphire XC 1MZ systems. As these www.velo3d.com
operating expenses, which excludes
stock-based compensation expense of
$6.5 million, was $22.2 million.
The net loss for the quarter was
$23.2 million, which included a gain
of $2.7 million on the fair value of
warrants and contingent earnout
liabilities. The non-GAAP net loss,
which excludes, among other items,
the gain on fair value of warrants
and contingent earnout liabilities, as
Cut your inefficiencies.
well as stock-based compensation
expense, was $19.3 million for the
three months ended June 30, 2023. Maximize your throughput.
Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter,
excluding the same metrics, was a One AM software tool.
loss of $17.5 million.
“Our second quarter results reflect
strong execution as we expanded our Emerson Additive Group are reaching new heights in
global footprint, improved manu- efficiency, productivity and repeatability with 3DXpert,
remains strong as we booked a maintain reach our goals of maintaining top data integrity and
orders during the quarter and Tom Gabriel - R&D Manager, Additive Manufacturing, Emerson Automation Solutions
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 17
AM Powder for volume
production.
Find us at
Formnext
Visit equispheres.com and connect with our team Hall 11.0, B31
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 19
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
20 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
WHEN ASTRONAUTS WALK ON THE MOON,
THEY CAN SEE WE ARE UP THERE!
C103,
HIGH EFFICIENCY FOR TARGETED PARTICLE SIZING
Nb521,
SHORTER PRODUCTION CYCLE
Gr Cop 42
In718,
In625,
Ti64,
CPTi + More.
l
strong customer demand,” stated Emile de Rijk, founder
me
for geostationary orbit that is approximately three to five
times smaller and lower cost than conventional geosta-
tionary satellites, while still reliably delivering critical
l
services. We’re excited to build on customer demand from
i a
global satellite operators and national governments with
r
our innovative geostationary communications satellites
in
over €50 million in venture capital, with prominent
l
Swiss and European investors including Constantia New
a
Business (CNB Capital), Swisscom Ventures, Swisscanto,
n t
and Zürcher Kantonalbank (ZKB).
de
Pär Lange, partner, Swisscom Ventures, added,
“SWISSto12 is the first ever growth-stage company to sell
a whole geostationary satellite to global satellite opera-
tors – testament to the uniquely transformative market
potential of the HummingSat platform and the team’s
technical and commercial acumen. Having generated over
21
all 12.0 / D €200 million in customer orders, SWISSto12 is also one of
22 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
I
MIM & BINDER-JET
SO
AM METAL
SEE US AT
90
01
POWDERS
:20
BOOTH H11.0 E38
15
CE
Unique inert gas atomizing
technology produces highly
RTI
AS9100:2016 specified, spherical metal powders
FIED
for MIM and AM applications.
CERTIFIED Team with history of developing
and producing fine gas atomized
powders since 1990.
FIED
ERTI
w.
5 C
1
ww
1 :20
0
90
O
IS
www.novametcorp.com
The
Part Journey
Discover how Metal Powder Works
assembled a team to produce and 3D print
a high-strength aluminum suspension
bracket, utilizing MPW’s safe, high-yield
DirectPowder™ process.
metalpowderworks.com/teamarrow
24 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
26 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
SPECIALIZED
The MX Metal AM System can be enhanced with several
additional sensors, such as advanced thermal cameras,
3D scanners, weld pool cameras, and acoustic emission
LASER sensors.
“The MX Metal AM System is an impressive production
system and by far the largest AM system MX3D has
SOLUTIONS
Glabeke, CPO of MX3D. “We specifically configured it for
our customers in the heavy industry markets, and we
engineered it to ensure speed, quality, and cost-effective-
ness for the production of large-scale metal parts.”
www.mx3d.com
28 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Visit us at
7-10 November
Frankfurt, Germany
Stand E81 - Hall 12.0
30 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
The right solution for every
metal AM application
VISIT US AT FORMNEXT:
NOVEMBER 07–10, 2023
www.trumpf.info/iqnedj
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
AMEXCI to invest in
state-of-the-art Additive
Manufacturing facility
AMEXCI, headquartered in Karlskoga, Sweden, has
announced it is investing in a state-of-the-art Additive
Manufacturing facility in Örebro, Sweden, to streamline
operations for high-volume serial production, and create
space for future growth.
“We feel that the time is right to expand,” Edvin
Resebo, CEO of AMEXCI commented. “Having built
AMEXCI from the ground up over the past plus five years
AMEXCI is investing in a state-of-the-art AM facility in
together with our partners and customers, we have
Örebro, Sweden (Courtesy AMEXCI)
tuned our processes to fit a variety of different indus-
tries and specialised towards serial production. Our
greatest asset is the talented team we have formed, with support companies to take the next step in their produc-
deep knowledge across various AM verticals. It is key for tion, allowing for the next generation of great products.
our expansion to continuously invest in the latest tech- We are glad to be part of this journey and think its rele-
nology, enabling us to offer unique industrial 3D printing vant to build competence and capacity within the area of
capabilities in Europe and the Nordic region.” AM in Sweden.”
The key stakeholders in AMEXCI, include FAM, Saab, Saab serves the global market of governments, authori-
Scania, and Ericsson, leading the investment. Håkan ties and corporations with products, services and solu-
Buskhe CEO of FAM, stated, “FAM are great supporters tions ranging from military defence to civil security. Micael
of AMEXCI’s expansion. We think it’s a good next step Johansson, CEO of Saab Group, added, “Additive Manufac-
for the company and believe it will create value for the turing is of strategic importance for Saab and the number
whole industry. We hope that AMEXCI will be able to of applications in our product portfolio constantly grows.
We see the AMEXCI expansion as a way to support our
growth and to enable technology to increase our competi-
tiveness.”
The expanded capabilities of AMEXCI aim to equip
the company to act as an enabler for future innovations.
“Expanding our AM capacity with AMEXCI is not just a stra-
THERMAL PROCESSING SYSTEMS
tegic move, but a testament to our commitment to innova-
tion and delivering superior products to our customers.
BATCH, CONTINUOUS, ATMOSPHERE, The key to successfully embracing this transformative
AND VACUUM FURNACE EQUIPMENT technology lies in the knowhow we have diligently built
FOR ANNEALING, DEBINDING, together. This expertise empowers us to push boundaries,
SINTERING, AND STRESS RELIEVING drive progress, and shape the future of manufacturing,”
Börje Ekholm, CEO of Ericsson commented.
Christian Levin, CEO of Scania and TRATON GROUP,
shared his view on the investment, “Since the start of
AMEXCI, the company has been important for us providing
knowledge, training, and competence within the area of
Additive Manufacturing. We believe these technologies will
be even more important in the future, both as a possibility
to manufacture parts with a complex design, a quick way
to produce short series and contribute to our transforma-
tion towards the sustainable transport system.”
An important component of this expansion is the brand-
new factory being built in the industrious region of Örebro,
Sweden. This significant investment underscores Örebro’s
standing as an industrial hub in Sweden, particularly for
AM. The new factory will not only boost AMEXCI’s opera-
tional capabilities but also enable deepened research
collaboration, opening up further engagement with Örebro
www. g asbarre . c o m University.
www.amexci.com
32 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
on-board metal Additive commented Rear Adm Jason Lloyd, deputy commander
for NAVSEA’s Naval Systems Engineering & Logistics
Manufacturing Directorate. “I am excited to see how Bataan embraced
this technology to enhance readiness at the point of
The crew of USS Bataan (LHD 5), a Wasp-class amphib- need.”
ious assault ship in the United States Navy, supported The AM machine was installed as a joint effort
by the Naval Sea Systems Command (NAVSEA), has between SURFLANT and the NAVSEA Technology Office.
additively manufactured and replaced a sprayer plate It includes the Phillips Additive Hybrid system, which
used in a de-ballast air compressor (DBAC) while at sea. integrates a Laser Metal Deposition (Material Extrusion)
Completed in just five days, this was the first time the build head from Meltio3D onto a Haas TM-1 computer
crew had used the ship’s permanently installed metal numerical control mill. The Haas TM-1 platform has
Additive Manufacturing machine under these conditions, been proven to operate reliably in an afloat environ-
and enabled the ship to mitigate the time spent obtaining ment aboard several aircraft carriers. By integrating
a replacement assembly. the Meltio3D deposition head with the Haas TM-1, the
“This success story shows the self-sufficiency we can system provides both additive and subtractive manu-
achieve when our Sailors are provided with cutting-edge facturing capabilities, which increases efficiency and
technology,” shared Rear Adm Joseph Cahill, commander, reduces waste when compared to typical machining.
Naval Surface Force Atlantic (SURFLANT). “The impact The repair effort was led by Machinery Repairman
technology like this can have on operational readiness, First Class Mike Hover. He began by creating a
particularly in a combat environment where logistics computer-aided design (CAD) model of a sprayer plate,
capabilities will be challenged, is critically important.” using a functional sprayer plate from one of the ship’s
The metal sprayer plate is used to force pressurised other DBAC systems as a reference. After creating
air through saltwater tanks and discharge the accumu- the preliminary CAD model, Hover utilised NAVSEA’s
lated saltwater. These tanks are filled to lower a ship’s ‘Apollo Lab’ to obtain engineering and fleet support and
draft for amphibious operations. training.
In 2018, NAVSEA established the ‘Apollo Lab’ to
provide engineers with better support for forward-
deployed sailors. The lab is led by NAVSEA field activity
Naval Surface Warfare Center, Carderock Division,
34 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Make Impossible Parts In-House
With Metal Paste Deposition.
LEARN MORE
info@rapidia.com
www.rapidia.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
From Powder
eliminating the need for support
structures. Additionally, Trumpf’s
new AM machines feature improved
to Performance
gas flow, resulting in uniform
processing conditions and support-
free manufacturing.
“When we 3D print a part, we
want as much control as possible
over when and where the material
melts and re-solidifies. The skill lies
in choosing the right exposure strat-
egies to prevent internal tensions
and overheating in the overhang
region,” stated Timo Degen, product
manager for Additive Manufacturing
at Trumpf. “Users from any industry
can benefit from the ability to 3D
print parts without supports. The
advantages of support-free printing
are particularly appealing for
parts that feature large cavities
or challenging overhangs,” Degen
added. Examples include tanks, heat
exchangers, hydraulic blocks and
tool moulds.
The new technology also enables
new applications that were not
feasible when support structures
were necessary, such as additively
manufactured radial compressors
and shrouded impellers. Previously,
manufacturers could not build
ZEISS Additive Manufacturing Solutions support-free impellers due to their
overhang angles. “The need for
ZEISS Additive Manufacturing Solutions is a holistic quality
supports meant that 3D printing
assurance solution that provides a comprehensive understanding of
component quality and causes of failure, drives sustainable process wasn’t an economically viable
improvements, and sets standards for future series production. alternative to conventional manufac-
www.zeiss.com/metrology/solutions/additive-manufacturing.html turing. But now things are different,”
Degen concluded.
www.trumpf.com
36 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
UNLOCK THE POWER OF PRECISION
www.pureairemonitoring.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
38 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industrial 3D printers
Setting the industry standard for
mass production
Meet us at Formnext
Hall 12.0 Booth E138
www.freemelt.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
toolcraft acquires 50% stake in PT YPTI toolcraft will also benefit from
the partnership, enabling the
to establish presence in Asian market company to use PT YPTI as a base
in the Asian market.
toolcraft AG, located in Geor- The move will bring toolcraft’s “This will allow us to avoid
gensgmünd, Germany, reports it AM experience to PT YPTI. “This long and costly transport routes,
has acquired a 50% stake in PT partnership marks a new chapter in saving both time and resources
Yogya Presisi Teknikatama Industri our company’s history. Through it, as well as helping us to operate
(PT YPTI), based in Yogyakarta, we will extend our areas of compe- more sustainably,” added Christoph
Indonesia. toolcraft has maintained tency, become more competitive, Hauck, Chief Technology and Sales
long-standing links with Indonesia expand our foothold in the market Officer at toolcraft. “Our aim is to
and has a successful working and be in a position to offer our build a vibrant partnership from
relationship with PT YPTI, said to customers the best possible solu- which both sides will benefit.”
make the acquisition of a stake in tions,” stated Petrus Tedja Hapsoro, www.toolcraft.de
the company the next logical step. Managing Director of PT YPTI. www.ypti.co.id
40 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Surface Technology
ENESKApostprocess
The safe postprocessing system
for all materials and work steps
100
made in %
German
y
42 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Innovations in
Additive Manufacturing
JEOL Introduces JAM-5200
E-beam Metal Additive Manufacturing Tool
JEOL builds on more than 6 decades of technology leadership
in electron microscopy and e-beam lithography
with its new Additive Manufacturing technology for 3D printing.
Our technical expertise and dedicated customer support are the
basis for this revolutionary new system that offers:
Desktop Metal releases Live Monitor parts, such as those in the energy
industry, visibility and traceability
software for real-time production data of AM part production,” Valeria
Tirelli, president and CEO of Aidro,
Desktop Metal Inc has launched Live “At Desktop Metal, we’re shared. “The variables are visible,
Monitor™, a software application committed to driving Additive customisable, and recordable and
that provides real-time data from Manufacturing into production, this is the basis for having a qualified
Additive Manufacturing machines and Live Monitor is a vital tool process. Thanks also to this tool, DNV
and ancillary equipment to monitor for managing a single productive has awarded Aidro AM manufacturer
and improve efficiency of either one printing system, such as a Shop certification in accordance with the
or a full fleet of AM machines. System and Furnace, or an entire DNV-ST-B203 standard. Compared to
As part of the Live Suite™ fleet,” stated Ric Fulop, Founder and other systems, Live Monitor can be
package of software from Desktop CEO of Desktop Metal. “Our goal is customised in a simple and efficient
Metal, Live Monitor provides to help users improve their Overall way depending on the specific needs
access to system data from any Equipment Effectiveness (OEE) to of the user.”
web browser at any time. This new optimise their utilisation and scale Live Monitor will be available as
software includes dashboards that their business with ease.” an optional add-on feature to Live
allow for fleet management and Aidro srl, a subsidiary of Desktop Studio users for the Studio, Shop,
detailed analysis of AM machine Metal, based in Taino, Italy, has and Production System AM machines,
or furnace performance, features served as a beta tester for Live as well as Desktop Metal branded
which support capacity planning Monitor in its Desktop Metal Shop furnaces. This feature will also be
and maintenance management. System and Furnace for the past introduced in the future to users of
Real-time information provided by year. other Desktop Metal and Team DM
Live Monitor includes job and event “Live Monitor is an essential equipment sold under the ExOne,
status, time reporting, and consum- tool for keeping the most important Desktop Health, and ETEC brands.
able usage, among other important process variables under control www.desktopmetal.com
metrics. and giving customers with critical www.aidro.it
44 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
ELEMENTAL ANALYSIS OF
METAL POWDERS & FEEDSTOCK
ELTRA’s new and innovative ELEMENTRAC series is a mile stone for C/S and O/N/H analysis in Powder Metallurgy and
Additive Manufacturing: easy to use, fast analysis times and reliable results for metal powders and processed samples.
www.eltra.com
46 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
VACUUM
and the fact that our planet’s resources are not endless,
it is more important than ever to consider utilising the
approximately 600 tonnes of recycled aircraft parts that
METAL PARTS Robert Higham, CEO and founder of AMS, said, “The
UK was once a leader in AM technology, and we have
since seen a stagnation period, with our work alongside
the output of this project we aspire to enable a vibrant
AUTOMOTIVE - AERONAUTICS - MEDICAL and highly-profitable UK-source of feedstock and catalyst
for material producing parts for our defence, space,
aerospace, and automotive industries. Having Innovate
UK support our research and development in this field
is a significant and crucial step in our plans as AMS. If
we are to continue with our ambitious plans to promote
and increase on shore manufacturing, it is crucial we
enable a secure and sustainable supply chain of product.
This project is the first step in providing valuable data as
to the true possibilities of high-value circular economy
A GLOBAL OFFER development. We are honoured to be awarded the funding
ONE SUPPLIER to allow us to take this idea to an industrial feasibility
state.”
The project is currently underway and expected to
conclude in November 2023. AMS plans to recycle scrap
aerospace parts into powder, which will be tested and
used to manufacture new parts. These parts will provide
crucial data to evaluate the effectiveness of this process
in providing recycled materials for high-quality feedstock
for Additive Manufacturing in the UK.
www.additive-manufacturing.co.uk
48 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
EN 9100 Certified AM Metal Powder
Made in Germany
– Aerospace-Approved – Metal Powders
Elevate your AM projects with ECKARTʼs multi-faceted powder portfolio including aluminum alloys such as
AlSi10Mg and A20X as well as copper alloys like CuCrZr or pure copper. In addition to the well-known Ti64,
we specialize in titanium alloys, namely Ti-6242, Ti-6246 and Ti-5553, designed for the most demanding
structural applications.
ECKARTʼs flexible production concepts are distinguished – from large-scale production to small scale lines for
specialties. Discover our standard metal powders of the highest quality as well as our tailor-made customer-
specific solutions!
Visit us at formnext, booth 12.0 – A101, Frankfurt / Germany, November 7 – 10, 2023
For further information please contact:
ECKART GmbH · Guentersthal 4 · 91235 Hartenstein · Germany
E-Mail: info.eckart@altana.com
www.eckart.net
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
See us at
50 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
I Mass-related surface area as specific surface area (m²/g) is an important parameter in the evaluation of metal powders
with regard to their processability.
I Simultaneous measurement of up to 4 samples with high precision.
I Rapid determination of BET surface areas with up to 12 analyses per hour - perfect for quality control of fine powders
with high sample throughput.
www.microtrac.com
52 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
YOUR AM SUPERHERO
With great powder comes great possibilities
PowderRange
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
54 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
For a sustainable tomorrow
www.hoganas.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
56 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
S1 WET – THE VERSATILE WET BLAST SOLUTION
FOR CLEANING AND SURFACE FINISHING
Cleaning
Surface
finishing
Polymers
Nabertherm celebrates 30
years of DIN ISO 9001 quality
certification
Nabertherm GmbH, headquartered in Lilienthal,
Germany, reports it has successfully recertified its
quality management systems, marking the thirtieth year
of the company’s adherence to DIN ISO 9001 quality
assurance standards. Nabertherm was an early adopter
of the original standard, where a lean corporate organi-
sation and the manufacture of high-quality products had
been a central corporate philosophy. This meant there
was already a good basis to implement the corporate
goal of a quality assurance system.
In May 1987, the first edition of the DIN ISO 9001
standard on the subject of Quality Assurance Systems Nabertherm offers a range of furnaces for the heat
was published. Five years later, Nabertherm received treatment of metals, including hot-wall retort furnaces
customer enquiries as to whether it would comply for debinding and sintering MIM components (Courtesy
with this standard. At that time, only few companies Nabertherm GmbH)
in Germany had set up a quality assurance system in
accordance with the requirements of DIN ISO 9001 and
had it certified by an external body. The topic of ‘quality
assurance’ was increasingly discussed, but detailed In 1992, the Bremen Chamber of Commerce organ-
knowledge was not widespread. ised an ad hoc working group on quality assurance.
A group of companies from the Bremen economic
area came together at the event. Although not every
participating company understood what DIN ISO 9001
required in detail, the opportunities that could result
from the introduction of a quality assurance system
were recognised.
COMPLETE ADDITIVE SOLUTIONS The day after the event, Conrad Naber set the corpo-
METAL POWDERS | PRINTED COMPONENTS | SERIES PRODUCTION rate goal that Nabertherm should be the first furnace
manufacturer in the world to introduce a certified
quality assurance system. Together with three other
companies from the working group, and the advisory
support of Dr Günther W Diekhöner and his team from
the Denkfabrik in Bremen, Nabertherm began to set
up and introduce the quality assurance system in the
summer of 1992.
Thanks to a good starting point, and the excel-
lent support from the Denkfabrik, the QA system was
introduced and in June 1993 an initial certification by
Lloyd’s Register Quality Assurance could be submitted.
On June 24 th, 1993, Nabertherm received the first
DIN ISO 9001 certificate. At that time, fewer than 500
companies in Germany were certified accordingly. “It
has never been possible to reliably determine whether
Kennametal brings deep expertise to every Nabertherm was really the first furnace manufacturer
layer of the AM process — from powder to in the world to be certified, but the probability is very
finished part — unlocking the full value of high,” the company stated.
Over the years, the term ‘quality assurance’ has
3D printing for demanding wear, erosion, become synomymous with the term ‘quality manage-
corrosion and high-temperature applications. ment.’ The requirements of DIN ISO 9001 have also
changed, though the basic idea has remained the same:
quality means recognising and fulfilling the needs and
expectations of customers.
www.kennametal.com/am
www.nabertherm.com
58 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Quintus Purus®, working with
industry to set a new standard
for clean HIP-ing
www.quintustechnologies.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Athena Manufacturing
rebrands as A3D Manufacturing
Athena Manufacturing, a certified AM service provider
based in Tempe, Arizona, USA, has rebranded as A3D
Manufacturing. The company serves industries such as
aerospace, military and defence, life science, transporta-
AM Specialty Grades - Composition (wt%) tion, and consumer products.
Grade C Mn Mo Cr Ni Si “Rebranding as A3D Manufacturing will open many more
possibilities for us,” said Jon Toews, Senior Vice President
ATOMET 0.20-0.35 0.70-0.90 - - - 0.10-0.25
1025
of A3D Manufacturing. “It allows us to continuously
evaluate our mission and add bleeding-edge technologies
ATOMET 0.38-0.43 0.60-0.80 0.20-0.30 0.70-0.90 1.60-2.00 0.10-0.25
and expertise to our portfolio, so our customers can
4340
harness these new capabilities to grow their business.”
ATOMET 0.55-0.60 0.15-0.20 0.80-0.90 - - - The company was established in 2019 with the aim of
4405
creating high-quality parts with production volume and
pricing through Additive Manufacturing. Since then, it has
expanded services to include various AM methods, as well
as post-processing services, CNC machining, Injection
Moulding, cast urethane, and more.
The company now specialises in creating custom metal
and plastic components using Fused Filament Fabrication
ISO 9001 IATF 16949
and Markforged technology.
www.a3dmfg.com
60 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
OUR EXPERTISE – YOUR SUCCESS.
MATCHING SOLUTIONS FOR YOUR NEEDS:
Increase the productivity and safety for your industrial 3D printing – Grenzebach is your reliable
partner for automating and networking individual process steps in metal-based Additive
Manufacturing – for higher performance, a safe working environment and smooth workflow.
Improve ergonomics
» Ergonomic depowdering while the next build job is already in progress
IperionX receives key permits for Ti The design of the TDF and TCF-1
are based upon a scaled-up version
powder production in Virginia of the current Industrial Pilot Facility,
in Salt Lake City, which has been
IperionX Limited, Charlotte, North (tpa) of titanium metal within the successfully operated by IperionX
Carolina, USA, has received all existing building in Virginia. since January 2022. IperionX has
permits to commence construction All major engineering works for upgraded this facility, and improved
and operations at its planned the planned Stage 1 TDF (titanium operational processes, to achieve a
titanium metal production facility in demonstration facility) are now significant increase in the titanium
Virginia, USA. The permits include complete, with key long lead time production capacity with higher
the Industrial Wastewater Discharge equipment ordered and procurement efficiency and consistency.
permit issued by the Halifax County underway. First titanium production IperionX now plans to build the
Service Authority, and the New is planned for Q1 2024, and IperionX largest recycled titanium metal
Source Review (air pollution) permit expects to reach a production powder production facility globally,
issued by the Virginia Department of run-rate of 125 tpa by Q3 2024. A and reportedly the only titanium
Environmental Quality. They meet the planned modular Stage 2 expansion plant that uses 100% titanium scrap
requirements to scale to the planned to the TCF-1 level would lift titanium metal as feedstock. The titanium
TCF-1 (titanium commercial facility) production capacity to 1,125 tpa by production facility in Virginia is
capacity of 1,125 tonnes per annum the end of 2025. designed to have zero Scope 1 & 2
emissions and is expected to produce
UL validated 100% recycled titanium
metal powder with the lowest carbon
intensity on the market.
“IperionX is uniquely positioned to
re-shore titanium metal production
to the USA, reducing the acute
reliance on titanium imports from
foreign nations and lowering the
significant environmental impacts
from producing titanium metal using
the existing ‘Kroll Process’ – which
is energy intensive, high cost and
generates excessive greenhouse gas
emissions,” explained Anastasios
IperionX has received all permits to commence construction and operations at (Taso) Arima, IperionX CEO.
its planned titanium production facility in Virginia, USA (Courtesy IperionX) www.iperionx.com
62 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Aheadd ®
Aluminium powders
Specifically designed and optimized for Additive Manufacturing
Aheadd®
Expanding the boundaries of your application
aheadd@constellium.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Blasting
Frankfurt, Germany
November 7-10, 2023 Post processing, redefined.
Depowdering
Hall 12.0, C42
Recycling
addiblast.com
64 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
SPECIALTY
MATERIALS SHAPING
THE FUTURE OF
MANUFACTURING
PERFORMANCE
Primary powder producer
Global manufacturing network
Aluminum, Copper, Titanium & custom alloys
Flexibility for custom development with ability to scale
Control of powder attributes for greater performance
Specialized processes tailored to your needs
INNOVATION
Deep technical expertise and vast R&D capabilities
Powders for Binder Jetting, Powder Bed Fusion & DED
Customized services, including Cold Spray & Coatings
Proprietary atomizing technologies
Extensive sintering knowledge
Investment in equipment and parts production
PARTNERSHIP
Trusted global leader in metal powders and alloys
Premier development and production partner
Decades of experience producing high quality materials
Specialized powder morphology, chemistry & particle sizes
Support of critical applications at an industrial scale
Primed to fortify the rapidly growing AM market
www.kymerainternational.com | info@kymerainternational.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
ADDITIVE ended June 30, 2023, and the paths the company may
take to scale. The company’s financial results showed
a Q2 2023 revenue of $128.2 million and year-to-date
BLT-S800 (20-laser)
BLT-S800 (20-laser)
More Lasers for Low-cost & Efficient Production
MoreLasersforLow-cost&EfficientProduction
BLT-S800 &
BLT-S800 & Automatic
Automatic Power
Power Circulation
Circulation System
System BLT-S800
BLT-S800 &
& Power
Power Circulation
Circulation System
TikTok
TikTok Instagram
Instagram
No.1000
No.1000 Shanglinyuan
Shanglinyuan Seventh Road,Hi-tech Zone,Xi’an City,Shaanxi Province,P.R.China 710000 @brightlaser.technologies
@brightlaser.technologies @bright_laser_technologies
@bright_laser_technologies
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
COMBINE
METAL & CERAMICS
—
EXPERIENCE THE
CERAFAB MULTI
LIVE AT FORMNEXT
HALL 11.1 | BOOTH D48
BOOK A
MEETING PURE COPPER & PURE COPPER &
ALUMINA GLASS CERAMIC
68 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
The Standard for automated
depowdering of medium-sized parts
SFM-AT350 ee
t us at
M
NEW
42
12
.0, D
SFM-AT350-E with piezoelectric excitation
Enhanced functions of the Digital-Factory-Tool with carbon footprint
Compatible with intelligent SPR-Pathfinder® software
SPR-
PATHFINDER®
solukon.de
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
70 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Multiply Your Production Efficiency with
16 Lasers
(optional to 25 lasers)
72 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 73
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
74 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
At HBD, our future direction is firmly set on advancing additive manufac-
Booth No. Hall ��.�, E��.
turing to shape a greener and more innovative future for industry. ��-�� November ���� Frankfurt am Main
HBD Comprehensive
Metal Additive Manufacturing
Solutions
Tailored Consultation
At HBD, we understand your unique needs. Our pre-sales experts collaborate with you to guide equipment, material, and software choices for
informed decisions.
Ongoing Support
Beyond the sale, HBD's dedicated after-sales support team ensures smooth operations with maintenance, troubleshooting, training, and timely
updates.
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
76 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
additive
AFX
Productivity activated.
Ultrasonic Atomiser
BLUE POWER.
powered by
AMAZEMET Air Classifier
AC series
www.bluepower-casting.com
75045 Walzbachtal · Germany · Phone +49 7203 9218-0 · E-mail: info@bluepower-casting.com
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 79
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Additive Manufacturing drives spherical nature. The gas flow energises the
powder (fluidises) so it appears to the
powder development at PSI naked eye as a pot of boiling liquid.
Heat treatment of metal powders
PSI Ltd, based in Hailsham, UK, is several other processing technologies. and FBRs are not new but, in combina-
probably best known for the design, These all relate to gas atomisation tion, offer a range of intriguing
manufacture and installation of gas in that they have rapid solidification opportunities to produce powders with
atomisers to make spherical powder science in common, generating high sophisticated properties targeted at
for use in metal AM and other Powder performing material microstructures. the advantages and challenges that
Metallurgy applications. Atomisers For the R&D team at PSI, metal metal AM presents. These include
supplied range from small laboratory Additive Manufacturing has, over the use of coatings that can modify
ones, processing a few kilograms, up the past five to ten years, thrown the behaviour of powders when being
to large, sophisticated plant delivering up a whole series of interesting and introduced to the build zone, during
multi-thousand tonnes per year. unique challenges. PSI has developed melting and the mechanical, electrical
What is less well known, however, process equipment with specific and magnetic properties of the
is that PSI is also active in designing advantages to the AM industry. finished part. Another use is for the
plant for a diverse range of other heat treatment of powders to modify
processing technologies. In the field Fluidised Bed Reactors (FBR) their rheological properties to suit
of advanced engineering materials, PSI has been working in fluidised a range of different AM powder flow
these are often complementary to bed technology for several years in requirements.
its PM activities. These technologies the processing of metal and ceramic The recycling of AM powders is
include Chemical Vapour Deposition powders. In very simple terms an FBR another advantage of FBR. Regard-
(CVD) used to coat powders, Electron is a container of powder, generally less of the particular AM technique
Beam Physical Deposition (EBPVD) housed in a pressure or vacuum employed, powder not incorporated
to coat aerospace turbine hot section containment vessel. At the base of the in the build may become oxidised or
components, melt spinning and strip container is a porous plate through experience modified flow properties.
casting to make high performance which a whole variety of heated gases FBRs can be used to regenerate such
(FeNdB) magnetic powders and may be passed, inert or reactive in powders.
±3°C uniformity
Sizes from 0.25 to 16ft3 (7-453l)
Work loads from 50 to 1,600lbs (23-726kgs)
Operating pressure 10-6 torr to 6 bar Super Series High Vacuum Furnace
80 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
PSI has also used its in-house FBR Such classifiers are generally fed
to process aluminium powders for a with very large volumes of air to
non-AM process, namely Cold Spray, suspend and transport the powder.
where a novel alloy composition and This has no cost consequence if a
heat treatment resulted in enhanced powder is not sensitive to oxidisation
properties in the coatings. Here, the in the air flow. However, when reac-
powders were extracted from the FBR tive and possibly explosive powders
and subjected to a cold gas quench, are required to be processed, argon
thus retaining the soft, solution heat is the process gas of choice. Here, the
treated structure. The advantage of cost can become prohibitive.
FBRs in contrast to other powder To solve this, PSI has extended
modification processes is that the its range of gas classifiers from lab
fluidising action gives a very uniform scale to those handling hundreds of
process environment in terms of kilograms per hour under inert gas.
temperature and process gas distribu- Operating in a highly-automated way,
tion. Furthermore the process can be these efficiently recycle the argon,
scaled up to tonnage quantities and limiting the cost to just the initial
can be operated on either a batch or charging of the system.
continuous basis.
External melt delivery
Gas Classification As with most manufacturing
Generally, after atomisation, metal processes, when efficient use of
powders are graded into the familiar feedstock within the process is
size fractions depending on the approaching optimum, the focus turns
requirements of each particular AM to reducing the input cost of metal.
technique, whether it be PBF-LB, PSI has introduced the ‘Contipour’
typically at 15-45 µm or 15-60 µm or atomising process whereby two
coarser cuts for PBF-EB use. furnaces alternatively feed molten
Sieving at the finer cuts (in the size metal to a central holding tundish
range 10-25 µm) can be particularly that supplies the atomising zone.
problematical. It is true that advances Rather than using the pouring
in sieve technology have occurred furnaces to melt the desired alloy,
over past years leading to shorter those furnaces merely act as holding
process times and reduced incidence devices into which metal from an
of sieve ‘blinding’. However, the external source. These are adjacent
problem still essentially remains. to, but operationally separate from,
A solution exists in the use of gas the atomisation unit which then
classifiers to remove the undesirable operates on a continuous basis.
fines in a powder distribution whilst Thus when one furnace is empty it
retaining a sieving operation at the is removed and refilled while the
coarser cuts where sieving rates are other furnace continues to top up the
much faster. tundish.
Gas classifiers are cyclone-like This technology is particularly
devices which are a standard method attractive to operators of large
of separating a powder distribution melting equipment, such as steel
into coarse and fine fractions. electric arc furnaces, where existing
However, simple cyclones are not use of melt is currently directed
capable of precisely dividing atomised towards other processes such as
metal powder into the desired casting. Here, having already invested
fractions and rejecting oversize and in the melting plant, the operator
undersize. Gas classifiers generally may wish to divert part of the output
have a slotted rotor inside a cyclone to the relatively high value adding
body which rotates at high speed operation of metal powder production.
and greatly enhances the sharpness Analysis of the CAPEX and OPEX
of cut and, therefore, improves the components of powder cost when
economics of production and allows liquid metal is introduced in this way
powder producers to meet the shows a disruptive reduction in those
exacting specifications of those using costs.
the powder. www.psiltd.co.uk
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 81
Industry News
Additive
Manufacturing
Services to Help
You Scale
While the world is busy imagining the future of
Additive Manufacturing, Burloak is busy living it.
ISO9001 ISO17025
certified certified
AS9100
certified
NADCAP
accredited
ITAR
registered
CGP
registered
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 83
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
www.cmfurnaces.com info@cmfurnaces.com 103 Dewey Street Bloomfield, NJ 07003-4237 | Tel: 973-338-6500 | Fax: 973-338-1625
84 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
TANIOBIS
Based on our 60 years expertise in
manufacturing and development of refractory
metals, we have developed AMtrinsic®
atomized tantalum and niobium spherical
powders and their alloys for demanding
additive manufacturing technologies. Our
ability to adjust specific intrinsic material
properties enables us to push the limits
according to the requirements of your
application.
C103 FS-85
86 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 87
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Ry
year period to $56 million and allow the company to
n a
io
achieve positive cashflow in 2026. Amaero expects that
u t
required funding for capital expenses (facility, tenant
o l
R ev
improvements and equipment) will remain unchanged
from the previously proposed project at KEZAD.
“This is a seminal event for Amaero and a corner-
stone development for Amaero’s shareholders, our
Results demand RevolutionaRy powdeR
employees and our customers. With this development,
Due to the efficiency of our cutting- we expect the cadence of material announcements and
edge technology we can offer the tangible milestones to accelerate,” stated Hank J Holland,
POWDER lowest priced powder on the market Amaero Chairman and CEO. “Amaero is appreciative of
with no compromise in quality. the many stakeholders in Tennessee who quickly mobi-
Our powder is:
lised resources and proactively developed a compelling
• Spherical business case and competitive value proposition for the
• Free-flowing
• D50 of 35µm for most materials
re-location of our flagship titanium powder manufacturing,
• D50 of 20µm for titanium super alloys research & development and corporate headquarters.”
• Has high tap density “After nine months of all consuming efforts in the UAE,
We process directly from: after advancing the build-to-suit planning at KEZAD and
• Raw elemental material after recent receipt of the Term Sheet from Emirates
• Pre-alloyed stock Development Bank, it was difficult to consider last minute
• Sponge advances for alternative locations in Tennessee or other
• Recycled chip States in the Southeast US. At the same time, circum-
• Recycled parts stances are fluid and we have a fiduciary duty to decisively
• Over-sized powder
• We can handle refractory and reactive alloys pursue opportunities that are in our shareholders’ best
interest. We appreciate the efforts and support of so many
www.arcastmaterials.com stakeholders in the UAE and remain interested in pursuing
ISO 9001:2015 and AS9100D Certified other strategic opportunities,” Holland concluded.
A division of Arcast Inc. www.amaero.co.au
88 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Ti6Al4V AM
made easy
Combining years of experience,
collaboration and the power of
Electron Beam Melting (EBM).
T I TA N I U M A D D I T I V E M A N U F A C T U R I N G U S I N G E L E C T R O N B E A M M E LT I N G
www.zenithtecnica.com engineering@zenithtecnica.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Table 1 Measured results of additively manufactured samples The absorption rate of a green laser to copper is
with green laser form pure copper (Courtesy Safina) 35-40% (Courtesy Safina)
90 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Messe Frankfurt Group
ries overview
Visit our booth
7 – 10.11.2023
HALL 11.0
FRANKFURT / GERMANY
BOOTH A55
Reconfigure
manufacturing!
Proterial Metal Powder ADMUSTER® series overview
Demand for increasingly complex and customized parts is rising,
product cycles are becoming shorter, established supply chains
are being called into question and sustainability is playing an
ever greater role.
Oil&Gas/Energy/ Aerospace/
Early bird discount
until 10 October 2023
Mold/Tooling Aerospace/Energy
rospace/Energy Semiconductors
Secure tickets!
Semiconductors
formnext.com/tickets
Honorary sponsor
C W H R
ADMUSTER series ADMUSTER
with wide &® uniqueoverview
variations enable innovation in ind
®
Resistant & Refractory
Proterial
vation in industries
Metal Powder
C21P (UNS N06210)
Superior corrosion
YAG350AM (Maragingseries
350) H718P (UNS N07718) R01P
High strength maraging alloy
Lightweight
High-strength superalloy Highly Spherical W powd
Oil&Gas/Energy/
resistance than UNS N10276
Aeros
Semiconductors Mold/Tooling Aerospace/Energy Semic
Aerospace/ YAG285AM1* H44P (UNS N06044) R02P*
ADMUSTER® series
C01P withLo-Cobalt
wide maraging
& unique
alloy variations enablecorrosion-resistant
innovation in industries
R L
High-temp. Highly Spherical Nb powd
Semiconductors
Corrosion resistant Ni-Cr alloy
Oil&Gas/Energy/
high-strength Aerospace/
Mold/Tooling Aerospace/Energy
Semiconductors
high entropy alloy (HEA) H05P Semiconductors
FeCrAl heat and
C02P oxidation resistant alloy
Corrosion resistant HEA
Corrosion
with improvedresistant Wear resistant Heat Resistant & Refractory Ligh
18)
toughness
and creep resistance R01P L61P*
H713P (Modified Alloy713C)
Creep-resistant superalloy
*
Lightweight
lloy Highly Spherical W powder &Aluminum 6061 based alloy
C W H R
Corrosion
C574P*resistant Wear resistant Heat Resistant Refractory
H929P Lightweight
Higher hardness than Co-6
4)
alloy
C21P (UNS N06210) CL R02P* YAG350AM
W (Maraging 350) HH718P (UNS N07718) R R01P L L61P*
-resistant
Superior corrosion
C21P
L61P*
resistance than UNS
(UNS N06210)
Highly Spherical
N10276 YAG350AM Nb powder
High strength maraging alloy
(Maraging 350)
High-strength superalloy
H718P (UNS N07718) R01P
Highly Spherical W powder
L61P*
Aluminum
*Coming soon
Superior corrosion YAG285AM1*
High strength maraging alloy H44P (UNS N06044)
High-strength superalloy R02P* Aluminum 6061 based alloy
Highly Spherical W powder
r Aluminum 6061 based alloy
C01P
resistance than UNS N10276
Lo-Cobalt maraging alloy High-temp. corrosion-resistant
R02P* Highly Spherical Nb powder
YAG285AM1* H44P (UNS N06044)
Corrosion resistant
C01P Ni-Cr alloy
High-temp. corrosion-resistant Highly Spherical Nb powder
Lo-Cobalt maraging alloy
er high-strength
Corrosion resistant Ni-Cr alloy
high entropy alloy (HEA)
high-strength H05P
high entropy alloy (HEA) H05P FeCrAl heat and
C02P
C02P
FeCrAl heat and
oxidation
oxidation resistant alloy
resistant alloy
Corrosion
Corrosion resistant
resistant HEA HEA
oy withimproved
with improved toughness
toughness H713P
H713P (Modified Alloy713C)*
(Modified Alloy713C)*
andcreep
and creep resistance
resistance Creep-resistant
Creep-resistant superalloy superalloy
C574P* H929P
C574P*
lloy713C) * hardness than Co-6
Higher hardness than Co-6
Higher
alloy
alloy
H929P
ralloy
*Coming soon
www.proterial.com
© Proterial, Ltd
92 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Your Industrial AM Partner
Explore our Industrial AM Solutions:
High Quality | Series Production Ready | Cost-Efficiency.
Combustion Chamber
Metal in Rocket Engine
Part Size: 550x550x780mm
Material: IN718
You can help accelerate the realisation of a zero-carbon society through additive
manufacturing, while generating new value for your business.
Are you ready to embrace the future, today? Contact Ricoh 3D using the QR code to discuss
how our Aluminium Binder Jetting technology can take your business to the next level.
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Sigma sells its Additive Manufacturing ship and path forward to accelerate
growth. As NextTrip continues to
quality assurance software business roll out key technology develop-
ments and grow our footprint in the
Sigma Additive Solutions, Inc., based the company’s relationship network travel space, we believe the rela-
in Santa Fe, New Mexico, USA, has and industry knowledge, the team tionship with Sigma will bring addi-
announced plans to sell the assets is believed to be well-positioned to tional leverage and momentum. The
of its Additive Manufacturing quality establish NextTrip as a major player efforts of the NextTrip team to drive
assurance software business to in the travel space. the business forward have estab-
an unnamed strategic buyer. The As of 2023, NextTrip has estab- lished the brand and positioned it to
company also announced it will lished over 200 direct relationships be a disruptive force in the industry.
acquire 100% of NextTrip Holdings, with blue-chip travel organisations We look forward to continued
Inc., a travel technology company and major industry suppliers for growth and product development.
based in Sunrise, Florida. air, hotel, and other travel-related NextTrip’s commitment to customer
“With our focus on increasing services. This ensures a robust service, our deep supplier relation-
shareholder value as we explored product offering of more than 2 ships and proprietary technology
a variety of strategic alternatives, million hotels worldwide. uniquely position us for a strong
we believe a transaction with Next- “NextTrip’s recently acquired trajectory across multiple segments
Trip provides a significant opportu- scalable booking engine and plat- of the travel market.”
nity to participate in a leading travel form offers numerous proprietary The transactions are expected to
brand with an array of product offer- booking solutions allowing trav- be completed in the fourth quarter
ings and concierge services,” Jacob ellers to customise itineraries to of 2023, subject to the negotia-
Brunsberg, president and Chief Exec- meet their needs. We believe Next- tion and execution of the definitive
utive Officer of Sigma, stated. “The Trip’s leadership team is addressing acquisition agreement, regulatory
transaction would imply a solid valu- a clear underserved demand for and shareholder approvals, and
ation for Sigma and good positioning a differentiated and tailor-made other customary closing conditions.
in public markets. As well, we have a approach in the online travel space. As part of the transactions, Sigma
clear path to add value from the sale Our ambition is to allow NextTrip is expected to change its name
of Sigma’s current assets in the busi- the ability to amplify its growth to NextTrip, Inc. and be listed on
ness of process monitoring with our plans and expand its reach into new Nasdaq under a new trading symbol
signed letter of intent from a stra- markets for the benefit of Sigma reflecting the NextTrip name.
tegic buyer to acquire the assets.” equity holders, while tying the issu- Until the NextTrip transaction is
NextTrip has recently formed a ance of additional equity to clear finalised, Sigma Additive Solutions
new management team with exten- business objectives for NextTrip,” and NextTrip will remain separate,
sive experience in key areas of the added Brunsberg. independent companies, and will
travel industry, including online Lyndsey North, president of Next- continue to operate as such.
travel distribution, wholesale distri- Trip, commented, “The transaction www.sigmaadditive.com
bution, and travel technology. With with Sigma will establish a partner- www.nexttrip.com
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 95
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
96 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Navigation and Support
In a complex industry, we’ll guide you the entire way.
We’ve got one mission, to support as many metal part makers in the MIM and Metal AM
industry as possible. Our team of processing experts utilize 20+ years of experience to share
all our knowledge and help you overcome challenges, develop better processes and become
successful part makers. We help develop real world, practical solutions based on many lessons
learned along our journey. Being the ONLY debind and sinter service provider with full sized
production equipment, we are honored that we have been able to support every industry
currently utilizing MIM and Metal AM. DSH is the only source for the best process support,
toll processing and educational resource for your MIM and Metal AM applications.
We offer:
Remote Process Engineering, Small/Large Toll Processing,
R+D projects, Educational Support on Total Process Management.
98 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Integrated
Lifecycle Partnership
100 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
ADDING VALUE
TO ADDITIVE
MANUFACTURING
Bodycote provides a complete service solution
for metal parts built by the additive manufacturing
process, including stress relief to minimise
distortion and residual stress, EDM to prepare
the component for hot isostatic pressing (HIP),
heat treatment or HIP to remove microporosity,
and associated quality assurance testing.
www.bodycote.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
102 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
104 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
www.indo-mim.com
Material Options
17-4PH, SS 316, Tool Steel M2 & S-7, Inconel 625, 4140
(Metal)
Material Options
Alumina 99.5%, Zirconia
(Ceramics)
Build Envelope ~ 300 grams max, Footprint equivalent of baseball size or less,
0.02” (0.50 mm) wall thickness minimum
I-Break project aims to grow UK’s with current methods using large-
scale forging.
aerospace presence via DED AM I-Break is being delivered through
the Aerospace Technology Institute
A new £22.5 million project known The project aims to develop and (ATI) Programme and is being funded
as I-Break (Landing Gear Industrial manufacture major landing gear from a larger UK government initiative
Breakthroughs) has launched to structural components using innova- in which £218 million has been allo-
develop lower-emission technology tive techniques such as metal Addi- cated to ground-breaking R&D aero-
and increase the UK’s share of the tive Manufacturing, Hot Isostatic space projects, supporting jobs and
global aerospace market. The project Pressing, and composites, which are growth across the country. The joint
is led by Airbus Operations Ltd and expected to reduce aircraft time to commitment with industry to invest in
involves collaboration between fifteen market as well as industrial CO 2 foot- new aircraft and manufacturing tech-
other partners, including industry print by 30%. This is believed to be nologies is set to help secure at least
leaders, small businesses, academics, the first time such components will £20 billion of further private invest-
and research organisations. be produced using these techniques, ment in aerospace in the UK and
support over 100,000 jobs.
Gary Elliot, CEO of the Aerospace
Technology Institute recently said,
“The investment through the ATI
Programme that the Industry Minister,
Nusrat Ghani announced at the
Paris Air Show will support a range
of world-class research projects in
technologies to improve the sustain-
ability of aerospace, from new design
processes to new materials.”
Metal Additive Manufacturing
company WAAM3D is a partner in the
POST-PROCESSING FOR METAL & CERAMICS COMPONENTS project, and its role will involve the
industrialisation of higher produc-
Hiperbaric 20 tivity Wire DED Additive Manufac-
Created to cover small volumnes turing variants; control of micro-
of parts processed with HIP structure and mechanical properties
technology as well as R&D.
C for high-integrity structural applica-
tions; industrialisation of online non-
M
Hiperbaric 30-38-42
destructive-testing (NDT) techniques;
Y
Designed for covering production
and production of demonstrator parts
volumes out of modern AM
CM
components manufacturers. of relevant size and complexity on its
MY upgraded RoboWAAM machines.
CY Hiperbaric 67 The I-Break project consists of
This unit is a complete plug-and-play several work packages; partners
CMY
Meet us at:
NDT hardware systems
The I-Break project is currently due
to be completed in 2026.
GLOBAL LEADER IN
www.hiperbaric.com HIGH PRESSURE TECHNOLOGIES www.waam3d.com
106 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
108 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 109
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
110 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
112 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
114 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023
OP_BeamPeek_Metal_AM_91x255_E_2_RZ.indd 1
115 03.08.23 12
n ew p r o d u ct finder!
Tr y our e n /p rofinder-en
t .t e c h /
y xlon.come
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
NEW
Precision Cut-Off Machine
www.qatm.com
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 117
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Atherton’s metal AM bikes win gold and Atherton Bikes celebrated both first
and second place, with the UK’s
silver at World Championships Charlie Hatton taking first place
with a time of 4.26.74, and Austria’s
Atherton Bikes, a specialist bike silver medals at the UCI Downhill Andreas Kolb coming second, just
producer that utilises metal Mountain Bike World Championships +0.599 behind Hatton.
Additive Manufacturing in its frame (Elite) men’s competition held in “To win the World Championships
construction, has won both gold and Fort William, Scotland. is unreal!,” stated Hatton. “But to
win in front of the home crowd, on
a British-built bike designed by my
friends on the team, with my training
partner taking the silver… it just
hasn’t sunk in yet, I’m lost for words.”
Hatton’s bike, an AM.200, is
custom built by Atherton Bikes at its
facility in Machynlleth, Wales. The
company has its own in-house metal
Additive Manufacturing capability,
with a Renishaw RenAM 500Q Laser
Beam Powder Bed Fusion (PBF-LB)
machine being used to produce the
titanium nodes that are integral to
the bike frame. The nodes are used
to connect the carbon fibre tubing of
the bike frame, and are joined using
Atherton Bikes is a specialist bike producer that utilises metal Additive aerospace grade adhesives.
Manufacturing in its frame production process (Courtesy Atherton Bikes) www.athertonbikes.com
118 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Outstanding
performance
Special stainless steels, nickel and
cobalt alloys produced by VDM Metals
are used in many of today‘s key techno-
logies for the safe and reliable handling
of corrosive and high-temperature
processes and procedures. In addition
to exceptional materials, available as
powder for additive manufacturing in
a wide range of particle fractions, we
offer you various first class services.
vdm@acerinox.com
www.vdm-metals.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
120 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Hybrid Additive Manufacturing
Seamless Metal Laser Sintering & Milling Process
COMPLEX GEOMETRY
3D Cooling Channels
Internal Features
Build Volume: HOLLOW
(D)250mm x (W)250mm x (H)185m
(D)250mm x (W)250mm x (H)300m * VARIABLE DENSITY
(* Option) Gas Venting
Gas Assist
POROUS
LAYER MACHINING
High Aspect Features
Reduced EDM Processing
NO EDM
PROFILE MACHINING
High Accuracy
Precision Finished Parts
TIME SAVING
One Process Manufacture
Reduced Lead Times
TIME
The Matsuura LUMEX Avance-25 is the world's first hybrid powder bed fusion
machine. The combination of additive technology and Matsuura's 80 years of
subtractive high speed milling technology into one seamless process, enables the
production of complex, high accuracy molds and parts in a method that has never
been possible, nor imagined. Further adding to Matsuura's expertise in the Hybrid
metal AM field, this technology is now available on the new Matsuura LUMEX
Avance-60 possessing the largest powder bed platform available on the market.
info@matsuura.de matsuuraLUMEX@matsuurausa.com
matsuura.de Hall 12.1 D31 matsuurausa.com
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
122 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
www.metalpine.at
Frankfurt
Visit am Main
us at 07.—10.
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 123
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
124 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 125
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Concept to Reality
Layer by Layer
- What did one 3D-printed turbine Don’t just manufacture, innovate with IAMG!
blade say to the other?
- Stop being so two-dimensional!
126 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
VIBENITE
REDEFINING WEAR RESISTANCE
® VIBENITE®
Alloys that redefine
wear resistance
IS WEAR RESISTANCE
ON THE AGENDA?
With our patented Vibenite®
materials you get:
• exceptional wear
resistance
• extreme heat resistance
• complex geometry
Whether you choose the
world’s hardest steel or our
hybrid carbide, you will expe-
rience a new performance in
your application.
Our material
Your application
A new performance
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
America Makes announces largest that can benefit the AM industry, this
ever funding with two project calls project aims to increase the number
and type of pedigreed, statistically-
worth nearly $12M based, and industrially-relevant Addi-
tive Manufacturing material datasets.
The National Center for Defense improvements in application-specific The RFP also encourages the growth
Manufacturing and Machining performance criteria. of these learnings, practices, and data
(NCDMM), headquartered in The PADAM request for proposal to a more expansive cross-section
Johnstown, Pennsylvania, USA, and (RFP) is separated into two topic of the AM supply chain by requiring
America Makes, based in Youngstown, areas: partnerships with small businesses.
Ohio, have announced two new open • Topic 1: High-Temperature The Proliferation of AM Material
project calls worth a total of $11.75 Refractory Alloys ($3.6 million) Datasets RFP is also separated into
million. These projects are funded by two topic areas:
the Office of the Under Secretary of • Topic 2: High-Temperature • Topic 1: Aluminum Alloy Material
Defense, Research and Engineering Nickel-Based Superalloys ($2.4 Dataset ($2.875 million)
Manufacturing Technology Office million)
(OSD (R&E)) and the Air Force “For the better part of a decade, • Topic 2: High-Temperature
Research Laboratory (AFRL). the additive community has been Nick-Based Superalloys ($2.875
This is the largest funding advocating for funding to direct million)
opportunity that America Makes has research and development to estab- “This project is a great opportunity
launched since its inception in 2012. lish proven methods for applying the for America Makes and our members
Each project call has two areas of best attributes of novel AM materials. to lay the foundation for ground-
focus, and one award is anticipated The materials that project partners breaking development and incorpora-
for each topic area. The maximum will be working with are incredibly tion of alloy-based refractory metals,
funding request varies depending on important to the future of the which are extraordinarily resistant to
the project topic. applications used in the aerospace heat and wear, into AM applications
The first project call, Powder and defence communities,” shared used in the aerospace, defence,
Alloy Development for Additive Brandon Ribic, Technology Director and energy industries,” stated John
Manufacturing (PADAM), is worth $6 at America Makes. “Our organisation Martin, Additive Manufacturing
million and is being funded by the is incredibly fortunate to have the Research Director at America Makes.
AFRL. America Makes, its members, support of the Under Secretary of “Additionally, data and best practices
and government stakeholders have Defense and AFRL and the engage- formulated and shared as a result of
assessed the benefits and strategic ment of the brightest minds in the this project will help expand the AM
opportunities offered through the country who will be collaborating to supply chain through the inclusion of
development and scaling of novel revolutionise this technology.” smaller businesses from across the
Additive Manufacturing materials The second project call, Prolifera- country.”
at the Alloy Development Workshop tion of AM Material Datasets, offers Proposers for the project calls are
in 2021. This project call aims a total of $5.75 million in funding advised to reference the RFP for full
to accelerate the maturation of through OSD (R&E) and the AFRL. details and guidelines.
high-temperature metals for AM, in Recognising that there are additional www.ncdmm.org
order to demonstrate measurable material systems beyond Ti-6Al-4V www.americamakes.us
128 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
STILL REMOVING 3D
METAL PRINTED PARTS
LIKE FRED FLINTSTONE?
EDM Network Inc.
(630) 466-5588
1974 Bucktail Lane
Sugar Grove, IL 60554
Or using 1920’s
technology?
Schoeller-Bleckmann Oilfield
Technology adds Velo3D Sapphire XC
Velo3D, Inc, based in Campbell, Inconel 718. The addition of the
California, USA, has announced that Sapphire XC machine looks to enable
Schoeller-Bleckmann Oilfield Tech- SBOT to easily scale the production
nology (SBOT), an Austrian provider of parts previously additively
of high-precision components for the manufactured and qualified on the
oil & gas industry, has purchased Sapphire machine.
a large-format Sapphire XC Laser “Additive Manufacturing continues
Beam Powder Bed Fusion (PBF-LB) to see growing adoption and through
machine to expand its Additive Velo3D’s Sapphire XC 3D printer, our
Manufacturing capabilities. team can scale up the production
The new Sapphire XC machine is of parts for customers with the
Schoeller-Bleckmann Oilfield Tech-
calibrated to manufacture parts in Sapphire XC’s 400% throughput
nology has acquired a Sapphire XC
Inconel 718 and looks to enhance increase over the original Sapphire,”
(Courtesy Velo3D)
production capabilities, delivering said Campbell MacPherson, SBO
high-volume parts at a reduced cost. EVP of Advanced Manufacturing.
Furthermore, it supports the manu- “It will also increase the address- “We are thrilled to partner with
facturing of large-scale components able use-cases for metal Additive SBOT and expand our presence
up to 600 mm in diameter and 550 Manufacturing by unlocking the in Europe with our first Sapphire
mm in height. capability of producing larger parts, XC installation at a contract
SBOT has expertise in manufac- allowing us to maintain our position manufacturer,” shared Benny
turing high-quality components for as a leader in the industry.” Buller, founder and CEO of Velo3D.
the oil & gas industry, including It is stated that the Sapphire XC “SBOT’s commitment to delivering
more than a decade of experience machine will provide SBOT with high-quality components aligns
offering its customers Additive the geometric design freedom to perfectly with our mission to
Manufacturing capabilities. In precisely and efficiently produce enable manufacturers to unlock
addition to its operations in Europe, highly complex, mission-critical the full potential of their products
SBOT’s subsidiary, Knust-Godwin, parts with a large build volume. The through Additive Manufacturing.
operates a fleet of Velo3D machines contract manufacturer also offers We are confident the Sapphire XC’s
in its Katy, Texas, facility. In conventional manufacturing capabili- advanced capabilities will empower
November 2021, SBOT became the ties such as CNC milling and turning, SBOT to achieve new heights of
first Velo3D contract manufacturer heat treatment, material testing, and innovation and excellence in their
in Europe with the purchase of polishing. This aims to allow SBOT to manufacturing processes.”
a standard Sapphire machine deliver finished, ready-to-use parts www.velo3d.com
calibrated to manufacture in to its customers. www.sbo.at
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 131
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
132 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Industry News
additive manufacturing
technical ceramics
powder metallurgy
C
M
hard metals
Y
CM
MY
CY
CMY
high vacuum, inert gas, hydrogen
K
benchmark for cleanest atmosphere
136 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Carbonyl Iron Powder
w w w. y u e a n m e t a l . c o m
o v e r s e a @ y u e a n m e t a l . c o m
Industry News | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
After
Before-and-after photo of PECM as both a finishing and a secondary machining PECM’s finishing capabilities on
operation for an additive turbine part (Courtesy Voxel Innovations) Inconel 738 (Voxel Innovations)
138 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
JSJW
JSJW TITANIUM
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
TITANIUM
We Smart Focus on Creation and Manufacturing of Titanium Alloy
We Smart Focus on Creation and Manufacturing of Titanium Alloy
We sincerely invite agents worldwide to grow together
info@jsjinwu.com
SJW TITANIUM
production capacity. In metallographic analysis, samples
printed with JSJW New Material TC4 powder showed a
e Smart Focus on Creation and Manufacturing of Titanium Alloy
SJW TITANIUM
140 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
FROM CONCEPT
TO COMPONENT
The next dimension in tooling for the
plastic injection moulding industry
As a global steel and technology leader, we offer the full suite of production techniques
and services throughout the value chain, supporting and driving innovation and
development based on lengthy experience around materials and processing. Starting from
the alloy development and metal powder production, to design and manufacturing and
including post-processing. We offer the end-to-end solutions to reduce waste and mitigate
risk in the supply chain with the goal of being your trusted and reliable business partner.
We deliver tailormade solutions from concept to component.
Canada funds Additive markets, create jobs, and even access new technologies
like 3D printing. PacifiCan is proud to be a partner in
Manufacturing technology helping Burnaby build a thriving, inclusive economy,
(AAMTECH) prototyping hub one that leverages the diverse skills of these talented
entrepreneurs and others throughout BC.”
as part of $20.8M investment Ministers Sajjan and Beech announced the funding
at the Centre for Applied Research and Innovation at
PacifiCan is the Government of Canada’s new economic the British Columbia Institute of Technology (BCIT).
development agency, dedicated to promoting growth While at BCIT, the ministers also announced over $1.9
and diversification in British Columbia’s economy. Its million in support for the establishment of AAMTECH,
mission is to enhance innovation, improve business an advanced Additive Manufacturing prototyping hub.
competitiveness, and promote inclusive growth. As part This funding is intended to address the financial barrier
of this mission, Harjit S Sajjan, Minister of Emergency faced by many businesses seeking to develop and
Preparedness and Minister responsible for the Pacific commercialise new concepts.
Economic Development Agency of Canada (PacifiCan) The project aims to provide small- and medium-
and Terry Beech, Minister of Citizens’ Services, have sized enterprises in the local area with access to
announced funding of over $20.8 million to seven state-of-the-art technology and expertise. This will
Burnaby-based businesses and organisations in the life enable them to build prototypes using advanced
sciences, manufacturing, and technology sectors. This Additive Manufacturing technology, with a wide variety
funding looks to help the recipients commercialise new of materials including advanced composites, metals,
products, acquire advanced technologies, and increase foods, and bio-manufacturing. The hub will support
sales. approximately sixty businesses, help bring ninety
Minister Sajjan shared, “Across British Columbia, products or services to market, and provide training
organisations and businesses are working hard to opportunities.
propel BC forward. PacifiCan is supporting these “Today’s announcement furthers the important
innovators to reach their goals to expand to new work of the BCIT Centre for Applied Research and
Innovation – creating practical learning opportunities
for BCIT students, while providing practical solutions
to industry challenges. With the PacifiCan funding for
the new Advanced Additive Manufacturing Technology
(AAMTECH) 3D Printing Hub, BCIT continues to grow
our breadth of support across multiple manufacturing
sectors including metals, composites, foods, and
Integrated bio-manufacturing. Businesses, organisations, and BCIT
InductIon researchers and students now have a truly state-of-
alloyIng the-art space to build innovation in the 3D printing
arena,” added, Dr Jeff Zabudsky, president, BCIT.
and atomIzatIon This funding is being provided through three
SyStemS PacifiCan programmes: the Regional Innovation
Ecosystems program, Business Scale-up and
Productivity programme, and the Jobs and Growth
Fund. These programmes support advanced
manufacturing, digital technology, clean technology,
and business growth.
www.canada.ca/en/pacific-economic-development
Arcast Atomizers are custom built and competitively www.bcit.ca
priced to meet the growing demand to produce high
quality, low cost, technically advanced metal powders
fulfilling the requirements of today’s pioneering
manufacturing processes.
Advertisers’ index &
buyer’s guide
We can supply machines to atomize titanium alloys,
super alloys, refractory and reactive metals, and ferrous
and non-ferrous alloys in high vacuum purged vessels
with inert gas replacement atmospheres.
We have installed machines all over the world, from Looking for AM machines, metal powders or
1 kg research furnaces to 1000 kg production units. part manufacturing services?
Discover suppliers of these and more in our
www.arcastinc.com advertisers’ index and buyer’s guide, pages 217-222
142 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
LARGE FORMAT DED BASED
METAL 3D PRINTERS
GANTRY & ROBOT BASED SYSTEMS FOR
ADDITIVE & HYBRID ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING
7 – 10.11.2023
FRANKFURT / GERMANY
Reconfigure
manufacturing!
Demand for increasingly complex and customized parts is rising,
product cycles are becoming shorter, established supply chains
are being called into question and sustainability is playing an
ever greater role.
Honorary sponsor
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
Cast your mind back twenty years aircraft and satellite technology. Following a truly rapid expansion
and imagine a list of all the compa- This now ranges from engine of the adoption of AM technologies,
nies capable of producing parts for components to structural assemblies the sector is starting to report on
the aerospace sector using Additive in safety-critical applications. In the lower costs, faster lead times, and, in
Manufacturing. That list would not be past three to five years, the industry the new era of digital manufacturing,
very long at all. However, there are has experienced a huge increase in vast improvements in flexible design
now suppliers on every continent and the number of use cases where AM and development methods based on
entire programmes where Additive parts have been designed to replace simulation and generative algorithms.
Manufacturing is at the heart of inno- conventionally manufactured parts. With this use of metal AM, the avia-
vation and development – as well as
being responsible for keeping ageing
fleets airborne. Although, in reality,
metal Additive Manufacturing has
been in development for a consider-
able amount of time, it is only in
the past two decades that it has
made headway as a groundbreaking
technology. This development has
transformed the aerospace sector's
ability to produce lightweight,
intricate and high-performing parts
in ways that were not previously
deemed possible.
The ability to create complex
geometries with the internal features
required for cooling effects and to
reduce weight through newly opti-
mised designs has started to enable Fig. 1 The GE9X turbofan is the ultimate demonstration of the capabilities of
improved efficiency and enhanced AM, containing more than 300 metal additively manufactured parts. The engine
performance in numerous areas of has been selected by Boeing for its 777X airliner (Courtesy GE Aerospace)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 145
Metal AM's aerospace journey | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 2 GE Aerospace's LEAP fuel nozzle, produced for the CFM International LEAP 1A and 1B engines. Each engine
uses 18 or 19 additively manufactured fuel nozzles, depending on the specific engine model. The engines are used
on the Airbus A220, A320neo, A321neo, Boeing 737 MAX and COMAC C919 airliners. In 2021, it was reported that the
parts have achieved over 10 million flight hours and more than 100,000 nozzles had been manufactured (Courtesy GE
Aerospace)
tion sector anticipates reporting on examples such as turbine blades in a review of those parts that are
lower levels of CO 2 emissions, both engines and complex communication already approved and in use today.
in manufacturing processes and end devices in satellites. No mean feat We will also broadly limit our scope
use through lower fuel consumption, given the deep insecurities that exist to aircraft applications, with the rapid
and views attractive pathways for within the sector, and the armour-like growth of AM for space applications
greater sustainability. GE Aerospace's protection placed around any new being regularly featured on the pages
LEAP fuel nozzle (Fig. 2), which will use of AM. This in itself is very of Metal AM magazine.
be covered here in greater detail, can puzzling, even to many that work
be regarded as the first high-volume with the sector, or are part of the AM
application to prove these claims true. value chain. Laser and Electron Beam
All this has not happened over- We won’t dwell on explanations Powder Bed Fusion: the
night, and the aerospace industry's for each of the AM processes that are technologies that led the
steady adoption of 'disruptive' metal mentioned as there is an abundance revolution
AM processes, such as Powder Bed of information elsewhere. Similarly,
Fusion (PBF), Directed Energy Deposi- even though there are now many new Laser Beam Powder Bed Fusion
tion (DED), and Binder Jetting (BJT), alloys that have been developed for (PBF-LB) and Electron Beam Powder
has paved the way for unprecedented the purpose of AM in the aerospace Bed Fusion (PBF-EB) are the domi-
innovation in part design and alloy sector, there is insufficient space to nant metal AM technologies used in
development. The world has already include detail about these here. In the aerospace sector. Very simply,
witnessed the first tentative steps by fact, there is sparse information in the process takes advantage of the
the major OEMs and Tier 1 suppliers. the public domain to support this. ease to rapidly scan a 2D image with
In this article, we explore the remark- Instead, the ability of metal AM to a laser or electron beam to selec-
able successes achieved through deliver mass produced airworthy tively melt metal powder one layer at
these technologies, highlighting key parts is brought into focus through a time from a 3D CAD model.
146 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 147
Metal AM's aerospace journey | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
has changed the product design and Safran of France, has stated
that its additively manufactured fuel
cycle, Northrop Grumman completed nozzles are up to five times more
durable than the previous designs,
drawings for this part in January 2022 which has been attributed to the
and delivered functional hardware by way in which Additive Manufacturing
technology has allowed them to
August 2022.” create a simpler design with a
reduced number parts in the nozzle,
vastly reducing the amount of brazing
and welding required in the finished
assembly.
In the years that followed this first ware by August 2022. It has since GE Aerospace took on the respon-
qualification of PBF-EB Ti-6Al-4V, delivered sixteen of these complex sibility for the production of this fuel
Northrop Grumman has gone on to parts that are assembled into multi- nozzle, made using PBF-LB and a
certify numerous components on function apertures which consolidate cobalt-chrome alloy, at its Auburn,
several air and space programmes, multiple functional parts into a single Alabama, site, which began full scale
with one of the most recent being a sensor, decreasing both the number production in 2015. In the following
sensor coldplate used in its Mission of apertures needed and the size, year it entered into revenue service
Systems Sector and produced weight, and power requirements that and now it is used on the Airbus
in AlSi10Mg via PBF-LB (Fig. 4). are normally associated with such A220, A320neo, A321neo, Boeing 737
Caleb Martin, a Mechanical Design advanced capabilities. MAX and COMAC C919 airliners. The
Engineer, remarked, “The agility It is clear how metal AM has airline operators are reportedly expe-
made possible by AM allowed us to enabled Northrop Grumman riencing 15% better fuel efficiency
design, iterate, and deliver coldplates to quickly leverage technology than previous generation engines,
in a quarter of the time of traditional developed for other programs and lowering the overall environmental
manufacturing.” adapt them to multiple capabilities, impact of commercial flights.
In a testament to how metal AM such as in Electronically-Scanned During the summer of 2021, the
has changed the product design Multifunction Reconfigurable partnership announced that the metal
cycle, Northrop Grumman completed Integrated Sensors (EMRIS). These AM parts had achieved 10 million
drawings for this part in January critical devices are used to perform flight hours and that the Auburn site
2022 and delivered functional hard- functions in radar, electronic warfare, had produced it’s 100,000 th metal
148 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
Fig. 5 The final assembly of LEAP engines at Safran's Villaroche, France, location. The GE Aerospace metal AM fuel
nozzles used in the engines contribute to a reported 15% better fuel efficiency than previous generation engines,
lowering the overall environmental impact of commercial flights (Courtesy Adrien Daste/Safran)
AM fuel nozzle. It is by no means an critical parts like the Stage 5 and performance, and have been
exaggeration that this does indeed Stage 6 low pressure turbine (LPT) produced by Avio Aero (acquired by
herald the first mass production blades. GE in August 2013) at its plant in
of aerospace parts using metal AM These unique blades are made Cameri, Novara, Italy, since 2014.
technology. With an output of several from titanium aluminide, chosen for Using PBF-EB, to date Avio Aero has
hundred parts per week since 2019, its exceptional high temperature produced all the LPT blades that
and taking into account the reduced
part count into a single piece part,
it is very strong evidence that metal
AM has been accepted as an economi-
cally viable production method.
GE Aerospace has also been on
several other development journeys
using metal AM and now produces
more than 300 metal additively
manufactured components for the
GE9X turbofan, which was selected
for use by Boeing for its 777X airliner
(Fig. 6). This latest generation of
aircraft engines include AM parts that
have evolved to combine multiple
components into single designed
units, such as the fuel nozzles,
heat exchangers, sensor housings, Fig. 6 The GE9X turbofan uses metal AM for parts including fuel nozzles, heat
combustor mixer, and inducer, as exchangers, sensor housings, combustor mixers, inducers and Stage 5 and
well as being used to produce large Stage 6 low pressure turbine (LPT) blades (Courtesy GE Aerospace)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 149
Metal AM's aerospace journey | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 7 An Avio Aero turbine blade made on a GE Additive Arcam PBF-EB machine and used in the GE9X engine (Courtesy
GE Additive)
have been required to achieve the to be a 'game changer' for its MTU Aero Engines
FAA certification of the GE9X engine segment in the industry. In terms
(achieved in September 2020), and of performance, GE introduced two MTU Aero Engines come very close
to support the certification process stages of variable stator vanes, to the top of the list of the early
of the Boeing 777X aircraft. cooled high-pressure turbine blades adopters as well. It leveraged
The development of these TiAl and a FADEC (Full Authority Digital PBF-LB Additive Manufacturing to
LPT blades, as shown in Fig. 7, has Engine Control). It performs at an manufacture a borescope boss for
also resulted in them being half industry-best 16:1 overall pressure the Pratt & Whitney PurePower
the weight of traditional nickel ratio, enabling the engine to deliver PW1100G-JM engine that powers the
alloy turbine blades. Dave Abbott up to 20% better fuel efficiency and A320neo (Fig. 8). The application was
of GE Aerospace stated, “For the 10% higher cruise power compared developed over several years before
GE9X engine, this means a fuel to a competing turboprop engine. production commenced back in 2013.
consumption reduction of 10%,
and therefore lower emissions.”
Abbott also went on to explain
how Additive Manufacturing has
provided Avio Aero engineers with
“...the new Catalyst turboprop engine, a
more creative freedom, resulting in product of GE's Avio Aero, is the first to
a change to how it approaches new
designs and allowing more complex
be conceived, designed, and produced
components. with additively manufactured parts.
Furthermore, the new Catalyst
turboprop engine, a product of This engine was always intended to be
GE's Avio Aero, is the first to be a 'game changer' for its segment in the
conceived, designed, and produced
with additively manufactured parts. industry.”
This engine was always intended
150 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
Liebherr
Safran
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 151
Metal AM's aerospace journey | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 11 An additively manufactured thrust reverser cascade array (Courtesy Collins Aerospace)
unit destined for use on the LEAP on a LEAP-1A engine. However, Collins Aerospace
engine, and optimised for Additive unlike GE Aerospace, Safran had
Manufacturing. Safran Aero Boosters no internal production capability RTX group company Collins
has produced the new parts in the at that time and instead chose to Aerospace has also been very
same F357 aluminium alloy as the develop an external supply chain, active in the deployment of AM
original casting, and achieved TRL entrusting the manufacture of and has, to date, produced more
6 with PBF-LB when one of the parts to external metal AM service than seventy-five different parts.
lubrication units was first used providers. As a major Tier 1 supplier, it has
the opportunity to seek out many
different applications for AM, and
successes include parts for thermal
management, engine, nacelles,
and various nozzles, housings and
sensors. Through the application
“Through the application of the of the principles behind 'Design
principles behind 'Design for AM', for AM', Collins reports that it now
routinely achieves weight savings
Collins reports that it now routinely of 10-30%, with corresponding
152 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
Fig. 12 An AM tail bearing housing (TBH) used on the first Rolls-Royce UltraFan® demonstrator engine (Courtesy of ITP
Aero)
Rolls Royce
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 153
Metal AM's aerospace journey | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Eaton
Fig. 13 United Engine Corporation (UEC), Moscow, intends to produce up to Elsewhere in the very widespread
70% of the VK-1600V helicopter engine using Additive Manufacturing supply chain of the aerospace sector,
(Courtesy UEC) critical parts suppliers like Eaton
have been developing their own AM
capabilities. Over a number of years,
the company has been developing
AM processes with titanium, Inconel,
stainless steels and aluminium alloys,
and recently teamed with Airbus
to develop an internal qualification
framework for Eaton’s manufacturing
fuel scavenge jet pumps using
PBF-LB technology (Fig. 14). The
process also had to demonstrate that
Eaton’s newly manufactured pumps
would perform in accordance with
original component specifications,
customer requirements and EASA and
FAA airworthiness standards.
Mike York, Director of AM and
Fig. 14 An additively manufactured fuel scavenge jet pump and, inset, an Digital Engineering at Eaton said,
exploded view of the conventionally manufactured pump “Eaton Aerospace is leveraging the
(Courtesy Eaton Aerospace) power of AM to produce superior
product and system solutions for
our customers leading to increased
10X engine that has been developed number of temperature hotspots market share. In addition, we have
for Dassault’s Falcon 10X business which enhances the output from the harnessed the technology to dramati-
jet. This part has been produced on engine’s high-pressure turbine, which cally reduce the weight, number of
a multi-laser PBF-LB system and in turn should lead to greater fuel components and assembly required
consists of AM tiles that are then efficiency whilst reducing nitrous leading to significant operational
assembled to form the body of the oxide emissions at the same time. savings.”
combustor unit. The advantage Following an extensive
that AM is said to have provided qualification period, Eaton’s additively
to Rolls-Royce relates to previous United Engine Corporation manufactured fuel scavenge jet
engine combustors, produced by pump has been approved by EASA for
casting, that required cooling holes Engine development using metal commercial flight and is in service
to be drilled into them. AM provided Additive Manufacturing has also today. In its additive process the
more freedom to design the required become a global priority. United company not only reduced pump
holes directly into each component, Engine Corporation (UEC) based weight by 30%, but also decreased
all of which could be fully optimised in Moscow has declared that it component assembly time and elimi-
for the flow of the cooling air intends to produce up to 70% of the nated potential leak paths, such as
required by the combustor unit. VK-1600V engine, its first fully 3D seals and threaded joints, resulting
In terms of performance, the new modelled and designed engine, using from the consolidation of eleven parts
design is claimed to have a reduced Additive Manufacturing (Fig. 13). into a single part (Fig. 14).
154 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
Fig. 15 DED Ti-6Al-4V structural components in the as-deposited and finish machined state produced in high volumes
for the Boeing 787 Dreamliner by Norsk Titanium (Image courtesy of Boeing)
Following on from its longstanding used either in free-form from an Norsk Titanium and Boeing
pedigree in casting and machining, initial build platform, or applied
Eaton is now incorporating AM directly to pre-existing parts. This Norway's Norsk Titanium is reported
technology across the business to makes this group of AM technologies to be the first company to receive
complement its existing manufac- particularly suitable for repair and approval from the FAA to manufacture
turing processes, as well as using large-scale production applications. AM components using DED, but only
additive processes such as Cold However, despite being one of the as recently as 2017. This came as
Spray to improve repair options for oldest AM technologies, first devel- a consequence of being tasked by
of older and more unique parts for oped in the 1980s as laser cladding, Boeing to produce the parts for the
aftermarket customers. "These exam- there have been fewer integrations 787 Dreamliner (Fig. 15).
ples show that the aerospace primes into mainstream production. Instead, Metal AM magazine recently
and the supply chain are now actively repair has been the dominant use, spoke with Matthew Crill, Associate
working together to implement metal particularly for the laser-based Technical Fellow for AM at Boeing, to
AM solutions, and we should only deposition processes developed by learn more about the outcomes from
see more of this in the future", York the likes of Trumpf and Optomec. the story that was originally reported
added. The latter has claimed that they in January 2018. Crill explained
have installed hundreds of systems that as AM started to gain traction
in many countries with certified in the sector, Boeing looked to its
Opportunities for Directed processes for the repair of turbine supplier base for a solution for the
Energy Deposition (DED) blades using DED and, to date, 787 passenger floor galley diagonal
there have been a great number of fittings. There are four parts per
Directed Energy Deposition encom- repairs, perhaps tens of millions. shipset and Norsk Titanium became
passes a wide variety of metal AM Instead, it is the wire-based tech- its qualified supplier, with industry
technologies that melt either wire or nologies that have seen the most success recognised in 2018 with the
metal powders to effectively form 3D take up by the aerospace sector Aviation Week Network 2018 Laureate
objects by overlaying welds, layer for new production, and several Award for the first structural titanium
by layer. DED offers the advantage companies are developing products AM parts to be included in any
of high deposition rates and can be and processes. commercial aircraft.
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 155
Metal AM's aerospace journey | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 16 RF antenna parts made by PBF-LB for Low Earth Orbit (LEO) usage (Courtesy of Optisys)
These parts were installed on the Propulsion Engineer at NASA to Mars has eleven metal AM compo-
first aircraft in June 2017 and have Marshall Space Flight Centre, have nents used in two of its instruments.
since been in full-rate production. frequently presented and published However, metal Additive
Crill stated, “Where many have their findings. However, despite a Manufacturing was first used in
sought to radically change designs, staggering amount of research and less-challenging space applications
this part intentionally kept the same development activity, there is limited and the AlSi10Mg alloy has been used
final geometry, whether machined information available on launched on several satellite programmes. In
from plate or from a near-net wire- parts used on missions by NASA. these instances, it is the supply chain
DED preform.” For Boeing, the main that seems to have responded well to
focus was on buy-to-fly reductions for using metal AM for these advanced
both cost and sustainability benefits. Satellite and antenna applications, supplying the likes of
Following on from this success, solutions Airbus Defence and Space (AD&S)
Boeing has implemented several various passive structural and
other wire-DED parts produced using Further afield, in the space sector, active communication devices. The
the Norsk Titanium technology, and Additive Manufacturing has almost UK-based company has contracted
all fitted on the 787 programme become the norm. With rocket external AM service providers to
through its sub-tier suppliers. engines aside as a subject in its produce parts like the well-publicised
Crill added, “The proven benefits own right – components that have TMTC antenna bracket from 2015,
have come from the typical 80% been routinely produced include probably the first fully-qualified
reduction in buy-to-fly ratios when the oxidiser valves in the Merlin 1D part to be used on a launch mission
comparing machining the part from engines used on SpaceX’s Falcon 9 on the Eurostar E3000 satellites
a near-net preform opposed to rockets, the Super Draco engines that and, more recently, over 500 radio
machining it from plate. This reduc- provide a fault-tolerant propulsion frequency waveguide components for
tion has provided benefits in terms system for the escape system of the two Eurostar Neo-series satellites,
of part cost and sustainability by SpaceX Dragon 2 rocket capsule, and HOTBIRD 13F and 13G. These satellite
reducing waste.” turbines supplied by GKN to Ariane programmes have all been success-
Perhaps the most comprehensive Group for the Prometheus engine on fully launched prior to 2022 to
investigation and development of the Ariane 6. NASA has also been at support Eutelsat’s TV relay services
DED has been conducted by NASA, the forefront in the adoption of metal over Europe, the Middle East, and
and experts like Paul Gradl, Senior AM, and the Perseverance rover sent North Africa. The TMTC bracket
156 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 157
Metal AM's aerospace journey | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
“Though much of its time is spent greater functional parts, with more
complex intricate geometries, to
on design verification, which isn’t improve fuel efficiency, reduce emis-
sions, and increase durability.
unique to AM processes, it is As the aerospace sector continues
working with fewer parts, meaning to explore the capabilities of metal
AM throughout the entire value chain
the design, documentation, release, of producing its parts, there will be
158 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Metal AM's aerospace journey
industry body for standards in the for certifying the airworthiness of AM are still just in the early days of
sector, SAE International, also has parts. The recent meeting in Köln, adoption. As this article goes to press
its ASM AM – Metals working groups. Germany, of these organisations that there are already announcements
Although the SAE has been a little have been holding a joint conference of multi-million dollar, pound, and
late to consider standards for the on AM for several years already, euro-funded programmes to further
production of aerospace parts, since emphasised that in-situ monitoring the use of metal AM in the aerospace
2016 it has now published a total of has to be a key area to be developed sector. This will see an even faster
thirty-three Standards and Recom- further by system vendors and users take up and development of AM, all
mended Practices. Following this are alike. A working group, 'Developing largely driven by a desire to be more
a further thirty-six documents that a Five-Year Plan to Allow EASA/FAA sustainable in manufacturing, or to
are currently being worked on, with acceptance – Machine Monitoring' create more efficient use of fuel,
half a dozen or more very close to and now in its third year, will be or cleaner forms of power. It is a
being published later this year. These setting out the measures that will certainty that we can anticipate even
cover everything from metal powder enable the supply chain to pass the more impressive advancements in
and wire feedstock composition FAA/EASA acceptance criteria. This the years to come, further solidifying
and physical properties, process very much lays down the gauntlet to the role of Additive Manufacturing in
minimum requirements and specific all the AM machine OEMs; they must shaping the very future of aerospace
documentation of records, and even respond by taking their technology engineering.
the requirements to monitor and past the level of simply creating data
re-qualify the recycling and re-use of from builds, to turning this into fully
feedstock materials. meaningful build reports that assure Author
Furthermore, the future of metal part quality.
Additive Manufacturing is assured Metal Additive Manufacturing has Dr Martin McMahon
now that organisations such as disrupted aerospace manufacturing Technical Consultant, Metal AM
the FAA (in the USA) and EASA (in far more quickly than any other magazine, and founder of MAM
Europe) are working together to group of manufacturing technologies, Solutions.
ensure there is a robust foundation and yet even after twenty years we Martin.McMahon@MAMSolutions.uk
www.metal-am.com
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 159
Accelerate
Learn more at
www.AmericaMakes.us
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
After oil was discovered on the industry-based projects together. The So, if there is a lot of activity in
Norwegian continental shelf in University of Agder, the Mechatronics academia, why have manufacturing
December 1969, much of the coun- Innovation Lab (MIL), and the Norwe- companies in the country waited
try’s industry has centred around gian Defence Research Establishment until now to embrace metal AM? If
oil and gas; this sector is more than (FFI) also focus on metal AM. The we are to find the reason, we must
seven times the size of all other latter has produced a report on look at the composition of Norwegian
industries combined. This is the first the current use of the technology, industrial companies and what they
and foremost thing that has to be research fronts, and market forecasts produce. Here we see many small
taken into consideration when looking up to 2045 [2]. businesses, 90% of all businesses
at the development of metal Additive
Manufacturing in the country.
As in many other regions, the
earliest activities around metal AM
were led by academia and research
institutions. In Norway, this was
towards the end of the 1990s, when
the SINTEF, based in Trondheim and
one of Europe's largest independent
research organisations, started
conducting research into metal Addi-
tive Manufacturing. Since then, the
academic community in Norway has
done a good deal of AM research, and
the Research Council of Norway has
supported nearly 300 AM projects
since 2004 [1]. Fig. 1 After oil was discovered on the Norwegian continental shelf in
SINTEF and the Norwegian December 1969, much of the country’s industry has centred around oil and
University of Science and Technology gas, a sector that has played a defining role in the growth of metal AM in the
(NTNU), Trondheim, now have a joint country. This image shows the NorSea Polarbase in Hammerfest, now a hub
AM lab where they actively work on for AM technology (Courtesy NorSea Polarbase)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 161
AM in Norway | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 2 Norsk Titanium worked for more than ten years on materials research and process control before it was able to
commercialise its wire/plasma Directed Energy Deposition (DED) technology (Courtesy Norsk Titanium)
components for the aircraft industry. That of materials and process research,
the company perfected its wire/
is impressive, especially when you know plasma Direction Energy Deposition
(DED) process in which titanium wire
that the aerospace industry has some of is melted in an inert argon atmos-
the strictest quality requirements.” phere to quickly and accurately build
layers into a near-net shape part that
was ready for subsequent machining
(Fig. 2).
Through its process, Norsk
that produce metal components have as widespread in Norway as in other Titanium opened up the possibility
fewer than fifty employees [3]. For European countries? of additively manufactured struc-
purposes of comparison, it must be The answer is that it is actually tural titanium components for the
noted that the small businesses that the oil and gas industry in Norway aircraft industry. This is impressive,
are very active in the oil and gas that has lagged behind, but that is especially when you know that the
industry have little to no influence on about to change. aerospace industry has some of the
how the industry actually develops. strictest quality requirements. Norsk
Most subcontractor companies Titanium has several AM patents and
regularly receive orders with many Early success with titanium is certified according to AS9100C,
variants and small series, i.e. mainly AS9100D and NORSOK M-650. Later,
piece production, which would speak Before we take a deeper look at the the company established production
for the use of AM technology. But Norwegian oil and gas industry, we in the USA and, in 2021, Norsk Tita-
why has this technology not become must mention the industrial success nium went public.
162 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
NORSOK
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 163
AM in Norway | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
There was a lot of talk about how were solving with metal,” stated Brede
Lærum, Head of the AM Center of
wonderful the technology was, but were Excellence, the AM venture of Equinor.
Lærum has been a keen promoter
there really any gains to be made? "From of Additive Manufacturing for many
Equinor's perspective, we looked at what years and has a strong profile within
the Norwegian AM community. He
AM technology could do for the end users, believes there are several reasons to
what we were solving with metal," stated use the technology, both within and
outside of the oil and gas industry.
Brede Lærum.” “Additive Manufacturing is a tech-
nology that is exclusively based on
digital information. Without a 3D
164 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 165
AM in Norway | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
“In collaboration with DMG MORI, that allows for the local produc-
tion of spare parts, thus reducing
FieldMade rebuilt a Lasertec 30 to inventory build-up and improving
operational efficiency. The solutions
withstand the shaking and vibrations that the company delivers also aroused
occur while transporting the container interest in the oil and gas industry.
“We have a good collaboration with
without affecting the quality of the AM Equinor, who challenged us by
parts. Over time, tests with a container on giving us a field assignment. They
wanted to see if it was possible for
a truck driving off-road have resulted in us to demonstrate the technology
166 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 167
AM in Norway | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 9 NAM partnered on a project to build this Fig. 10 NAM produced this demonstration propeller to show
100 kg DED impeller in duplex stainless steel in what the DED technology can offer. Here, shown with 'raw
collaboration with Equinor and Eureka (Courtesy build', finish machined and surface-treated blades (Courtesy
Joppe N Christensen) Joppe N Christensen)
this technology. This puts NAM in a 3 m turning length and diameter of “Among other things, we have
unique position and paves the way 300 mm. This type of machine is large; received orders from customers
internationally,” stated Sture H Sørli, it weighs 31 tonnes and, in addition where we have repaired broken and
General Manager of NAM. to being a five-axis milling-turning worn parts, as well as cast prod-
centre, it also has the option of laser/ ucts from China which have not
Årdal Maskinering powder DED Additive Manufacturing. been according to specifications,”
Årdal Maskinering AS, based in The machine was delivered in 2020, explained Frode Hegle, quality and
Nærbø, in Rogaland, is the first and but its use was delayed until 2022 due HSE manager at Årdal. “In another
only company in the world with the to the pandemic. Now, Årdal carries assignment, the customer delivered a
Mazak Integrex i500-AM, featuring a out successful repairs in exotic alloys. part of 3,100 mm in length on which
a thread was torn. We removed the
thread, applied new material, and
machined a new thread to specifica-
“In another assignment, the customer tions. The result was a success and
the customer avoided scrapping
delivered a part of 3,100 mm in the part. In this way, they avoid a
length on which a thread was torn. long delivery time and the possible
long transportation of a new part,
We removed the thread, applied new in addition to reducing material
material, and machined a new thread to consumption: this is sustainability in
practice,” Hegle stated.
specifications. The result was a success
and the customer avoided scrapping Aarbakke
Aarbakke AS, based in Bryne, also
the part.” in Rogaland, is Norway's largest
machining company with over 300
employees. Here, 70% of the orders
are for new parts (i.e. a lot of piece
168 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 169
AM in Norway | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Investment in Northern
Norway
AM North AS
In the summer of 2023, AM North AS
started metal Additive Manufacturing
Fig. 15 "In the long term, we will look beyond the region and the country, and operations in Hammerfest, northern
we believe in becoming a global player", stated Jan-Inge Kongsbak, General Norway. The city is located at Longi-
Manager of AM North AS (Courtesy AM North) tude 70.7°, so the metal AM machine
located there is perhaps the most
northerly of its kind in the world. The
“Our location is perfect in several ways. machine that AM North has invested
in is a DMG MORI Lasertec 30 Dual
Not only are we physically located in SLM with the intention of making
parts for the oil and gas industry, but
the same building as the spare parts at AM North there is a bigger vision.
warehouse for the oil and gas production “Our location is perfect in several
ways. Not only are we physically
ship Johan Castberg, all seagoing located in the same building as the
customers from outside the oil and gas spare parts warehouse for the oil and
gas production ship, Johan Castberg
industry also come to the Polar base. We (Fig. 16), all seagoing customers from
are talking about fisheries, farming and outside the oil and gas industry also
come to the Polar base. We are talking
all other maritime players.” about fisheries, farming and all other
maritime players. We are also close to
mining and other industrial activities
170 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
Fig. 16 The Johan Castberg is behind schedule, so AM technology is helping to reduce delays and errors during its
completion (Courtesy Joppe N Christensen)
in the region. In the long term, we footprints and the benefit of readily latest advanced design optimisation
will also look beyond the region and available expertise and capacity. technologies. The company’s team
the country; we believe in becoming automates product design work-
a global player,” explained Jan-Inge Korall Engineering AS flows to reduce engineering and
Kongsbak, General Manager of AM One of the few companies within lead times, and redesigns existing
North. AM engineering in Norway is Korall industrial products through the use
Engineering AS, a design engineering of Artificial Intelligence to reduce
Industrial AM AS company that is part of StartupLab material waste, production costs,
Industrial AM AS, in Mo i Rana, Bergen, a member of the GCE Ocean and environmental impact, whilst
Nordland, is also staking a claim Technology Cluster, that uses the increasing efficiency.
to become a preferred supplier of
industrial metal AM components
(Fig. 17). Owned by Momek Robotics,
Testpartner and Kunnskapsparken
Helgeland, the company’s plan is
to develop a complete value chain
with 3D scanning, construction, Addi-
tive Manufacturing, machining, heat
treatment, testing and certification.
Industrial AM will collaborate with
leading companies and research and
development players within modern
manufacturing technology and Addi-
tive Manufacturing.
Equinor and Aker BP are
supporting the establishment of the
operation, recognising the need for
AM production in Northern Norway.
The drivers for this are reducing Fig. 17 From left: Kyrre Sørensen, Aker BP, Thomas Borgen, Ocean Cluster
stock, shorter delivery times, short- Helgeland and Hans Holand, Equinor, entered into a cooperation agreement
distance deliveries, lower CO 2 regarding the establishment of Industrial AM (Courtesy Industrial AM AS)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 171
AM in Norway | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
172 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
Fig. 20 The leader of the industry association, Norwegian AM, Jan Tore Usken, is happy about the great commitment
within metal AM in Norway (Courtesy Joppe N Christensen)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 173
AM in Norway | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 21 AM activity in the Mechatronics Innovation Lab (MIL), showing a DMG MORI Lasertec 65 hybrid machine in action
(Courtesy MIL)
as a service struggle with recruiting there are several initiatives from This collaboration between industry,
designers and operators. Many metal individual actors. Below are some academia, and the public sector has
AM projects start with either reverse examples: made MIL today a technological hub
engineering or the transfer of tradi- Mechatronics Innovation Lab of international standard.
tional technology to AM. There is a (MIL) was established with the aim MIL offers technology, test equip-
long way to go before true Design of increasing companies' competi- ment and expertise for innovation in
for AM (DfAM) becomes ‘general tiveness through the use and mechatronics and associated disci-
knowledge.’ understanding of new technology. plines, such as robotics, sensors,
Although there is no educational Through involvement and grants autonomy, Artificial Intelligence,
course on AM from a vocational from private business and the public virtual reality, and industrial Addi-
school, college or university which sector, MIL has built up Norway's tive Manufacturing in all types of
can give any form of qualification, largest and strongest technology lab. materials. As a partner in the Future
Materials catapult, MIL participates
with equipment and expertise in
materials development.
MIL is part of the national
“The network seeks to promote the infrastructure for innovation, pilot
development of an ecosystem and testing, experimental development
of industrial products, systems, and
knowledge around AM in Norway, services for introduction into the
connect relevant stakeholders across market.
In line with what MIL offers in
industries, and stimulate growth, Grimstad, in Southern Norway, the
174 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM in Norway
Conclusion
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 175
“M a ke a b et te r w o r l d w i t h P M ”
WO R L D P M 2 0 24 i n YO KO H A M A J a p a n
WORLD PM2024
International Powder Metallurgy
Congress & Exhibition
13-17 October 2024 Y O K O H A M A , J A PA N
The World Congress on Powder Metallurgy was held in Asia in 2006 in Busan, South Korea, in 2000 in Kyoto, Japan,
and in 2012 in Yokohama, Japan.
It is an excellent opportunity to exchange the latest information and deepen friendships in Yokohama Japan.
Advanced technologies and information for "Carbon Neutral", "Electrification" and "Energy Saving"
Organized by Japan Powder Metallurgy Association (JPMA) Japan Society of Powder and Powder Metallurgy (JSPM)
Supported by European Powder Metallurgy Association (EPMA) Metal Powder Industries Federation (MPIF)
Asian Powder Metallurgy Association (APMA)
w w w. w o r l d p m 2 0 2 4 . c o m
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Modern HIP technology
Over the past decade, metal industries such as automotive, aero- tion of oxidation, and alpha-case
Additive Manufacturing, and in space, defence, energy and medical, discolouration
particular Laser Beam Powder Bed where performance and safety are • Digitalisation
Fusion (PBF-LB), has become an crucial. There are four technologies
established technology in a number that will be covered in this article: Understanding the benefits offered
of industrial sectors. Without some by these technologies allows manu-
• Hot Isostatic Pressing facturing companies to optimise their
of the limitations of traditional
production methods, Additive Manu- • High Pressure Heat treatment production, improve product perfor-
facturing has enabled engineers Technologies for the minimisa- mance, and reduce cost.
to design products with higher
performance, lower production cost,
longer service life, reduced weight,
and a potentially reduced environ-
mental impact.
Before HIP After HIP
In parallel to the advancement of
AM technology, methods to improve
mechanical properties through
post-processing have been adopted
by the industry. Post-processing
methods such as Hot Isostatic
Pressing (HIP) and High Pres-
sure Heat Treatment (HPHT™) can
significantly improve durability and
fatigue resistance while offering the
potential for shorter overall produc-
tion times.
Companies in a wide range of
industries are rapidly adopting this Fig. 1 HIP treatment closes pores and cracks in AM parts, improving
new technology, especially for use mechanical strength substantially. X-ray tomography showing pore closure
in critical applications in demanding (Courtesy A Du Plessis, E MacDonald) [1]
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 177
Modern HIP technology | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
rerun runout
components. The HIP treatment of
700 AM parts can mitigate this problem,
resulting in a homogenisation of
600 the as-built microstructure and a
P=50%
minimised variation in mechanical
500 properties. HIP treatment leads to
σ=528 MPa
more predictable minimum design
NG limits, and, in turn, offers the poten-
400 tial to save weight and cost. This is
5 10 5 2 5 10 6 2 5 10 7 2 not only relevant for industries where
Number of cycles [-] weight is an important factor, such as
Fig. 2 S-N curve of specimens with hatch distance of 0.15 mm (initial RD aerospace and automotive, but also
= 98%) after HIP with in-HIP quenching and ageing (Graph courtesy of A means that all types of products can
Kaletsch from work leading to publication [3]) be manufactured using less material
and, thus, be more sustainable.
HIP for increasing the HIP process, the manufactured New HIP cycles promise
mechanical strength and parts are subjected to both high even better results
temperatures and very high pres-
improving quality sures in a controlled atmosphere, HIP has been successfully used to
usually argon or nitrogen gas. densify castings for many decades.
The mechanical strength of AM parts The combination of high tempera- The nature of the Additive Manu-
in their as-built condition is generally ture and pressure closes the pores facturing process is quite different
extremely good, although, as with and cracks in the material, eliminates from conventional casting, resulting
all manufacturing processes, there residual stresses, and ensures the in different microstructures in the
can be quality considerations. The metal is properly fused. The result is as-manufactured condition. For
process of adding layer after layer up to a hundred times higher fatigue example, the solidification and
may give rise to pores, pockets of resistance, and often significantly cooling rates in Laser Beam Powder
unfused powder, and micro cracks. higher ductility and fracture tough- Bed Fusion (PBF-LB) are very high
These defects cause stress concen- ness compared to as-built parts. compared to a few degrees per
tration and act as crack initiation A well-calibrated AM process can minutes for castings, resulting in
points, having a detrimental effect on minimise the risk of porosity in AM microstructural differences even for
fatigue resistance and ductility [2]. components to an acceptable level the same alloy.
Hot Isostatic Pressing is a well- for some applications. For critical Despite these differences, some
proven technology for minimising applications, however, porosity must of the commercial HIP treatment
porosity in AM components. During be eliminated as it can lead to differ- cycles used for AM parts today are
the same as for cast and wrought
material and are not optimised for
AM [4]. Several studies have shown
“Hot Isostatic Pressing is a well-proven that there is potential to achieve
significant improvements in material
technology for minimising porosity in strength when optimising the HIP
178 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Modern HIP technology
a) b)
500 µm 500 µm
Fig. 3 Micrographs of Ti-6Al-4V produced by PBF-EB showing the results of two different tailored HPHT cycles to tailor
micro-structures depending on end use (Courtesy Quintus Technologies)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 179
Modern HIP technology | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Fig. 4 Quintus’ Uniform Cooling technology (URC) reduces production time Boosting productivity
dramatically by shortening the cooling time (Courtesy Quintus Technologies)
with High Pressure Heat
Treatment
HIP is often combined with different
heat treatments (e.g. quenching,
HIP SHT solution heat treatment and ageing)
Temperature
Aging
to further enhance the mechanical
Stress Relief
strength of AM parts. The latest
generation of HIP equipment from
Quintus Technologies offers the
possibility to perform heat treat-
Time
ment directly in the HIP unit. This
technology is called High Pressure
HIP Heat Treatment (HPHT) and not only
Aging reduces energy and operational
Temperature
treatment and ageing) to further enhance The gas circulating in the furnace
acts as an intermediary cooling
the mechanical strength of AM parts. medium between the HIP treated
objects and the cooling water and has
The latest generation of HIP equipment a temperature similar to the payload.
from Quintus Technologies offers the This makes the cooling process much
gentler than oil or water cooling, for
possibility to perform heat treatment example, and minimises the risk for
180 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Modern HIP technology
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 181
Modern HIP technology | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
the partial pressure of reactive gases of materials with high oxygen affinity,
such as aluminium, titanium and
such as oxygen becomes very high, chromium, as well as a wide range of
alloys containing these elements. This
resulting in oxidation on the surfaces of oxidation can cause discolouration,
materials with high oxygen affinity...” and, more importantly, have a nega-
tive effect on corrosion and fatigue
resistance.
182 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Modern HIP technology
Fig. 8 Stainless steel AM parts processed with traditional hot isostatic pressing (left) and Quintus Purus processing
(right). The surface oxide is clearly visible in the left image (Courtesy Quintus Technologies)
Titanium alloys are among the oxygen species in the HIP vessel with high affinity for oxygen, such as
materials that are most affected by before running the cycle. Purus chromium, aluminium and titanium.
oxidation. The high pressure and comprises a special control soft- Quintus Purus reduces the need
temperature during HIP, along with ware, well-defined best-practice for costly post-processing after the
potential contaminants, can cause routines, and a hardware compo- HIP cycle, as well as the need for
surface oxidation. Oxygen can also nent. It is available with all new wrapping or bagging parts to shield
diffuse into the material to cause Quintus compact HIP equipment and them from the HIP atmosphere.
alpha case, a brittle phase that is can also be retrofitted to existing The result is a time- and resource-
detrimental to fatigue performance. compact HIP units from Quintus efficient manufacturing process with
Alpha case is often removed electro- Technologies. significantly lower cost and shorter
mechanically or through machining, The result is extremely clean production time. Fig. 8 shows the
adding cost and production time [8]. parts. Quintus Purus makes it effect of using and not using Quintus
However, for some complex struc- possible to produce titanium parts Purus technology on two samples
tures with internal channels and with significantly reduced oxida- of additively manufactured stainless
complex structures, removing alpha tion problems, and the same is true steel parts. The left sample shows
case afterwards is very challenging for stainless steel and nickel-base clear discolouration resulting from
or impossible. The consequences of alloys where oxides are an issue due oxidation, whereas the right sample
this should not be underestimated to high alloy content of elements is unaffected.
– for example, in trabecular struc-
tures on medical implants for bone
ingrowth in cementless systems
where strength and fatigue resist-
ance are critical (Fig. 7) [9].
The traditional way of minimising
oxidation is to wrap components
in high oxygen affinity foil such as
titanium. However, protecting all the
parts individually adds to produc-
tion time and cost while reducing
productivity. Oxidation under certain
conditions can also damage the
heaters in the HIP unit and carbon
oxides can form soot that must be
removed between batches.
The aforementioned problems can
be addressed with Quintus Purus®, Fig. 9 Large-scale HIP system from Quintus Technologies featuring integrated
an innovative solution that allows High Pressure Heat Treatment technology for maximum productivity and
the user to control the amount of product quality (Courtesy Quintus Technologies)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 183
Modern HIP technology | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Increased productivity
Insourcing vs. Lean processing in state-of-the-art
through digitalisation
AM production is made possible by
outsourcing HIP on-site digitalised HPHT equipment.
The digitalisation of HIP equipment
treatment introduces new possibilities for auto-
Control over quality and process
mation, increased productivity, higher
Many manufacturers outsource improvement
operational reliability, and lower
their HIP processes to external With the full HIP and heat treat-
operating cost. Quintus Technologies
service providers rather than ment process inhouse, the quality
offers digital capabilities for its HIP
having the HIP process inhouse. system can be further developed
equipment that allow customers to
This is a cost-effective alterna- to avoid mistakes and the number
fully integrate their HIP units in a
tive when volumes are relatively of inspections can be reduced.
digital production line and leverage
small, since a service provider Issues that may arise with external
the benefits of Industry 4.0 and IoT.
can consolidate AM parts from HIP treatment can include a loss
The processing data from a
different customers in one HIP of traceability, components being
Quintus system is collected and
cycle. As the HIP market continues treated with the wrong HIP param-
stored on the customers’ servers,
to grow, so does the number of eters, and surface contamination
but can also be accessed in a
HIP service providers. Quintus such as surface oxidation and alpha
private cloud as needed. This
can assist in connecting you casing. Internal know-how and
enables instant access to data to
with relevant partners. Many are expertise on how to run the HIP
create tailored reports, product
operating modern Quintus HIP process will be developed over time
overviews, and updated documenta-
equipment and offer the possibility to avoid quality issues and delays.
tion. Analysing the data allows for
to run customised HIP cycles and
process optimisation and an increase
HPHT, meaning the question of Optimised HIP and HT processes
in productivity (e.g. by rationalised
whether or not to insource often When operating the HIP process
production flows and improved
comes down to factors such as inhouse, manufacturers are not
production planning). Operating data
flexibility, control, and lead times. limited to the standard HIP cycles
can also be exported to a quality
However, an increasing number generally offered by service
system for automatic creation of
of manufacturers are insourcing providers. Instead, the HIP process
quality documents, eliminating
HIP treatment. Their most common can be tailored for the needs and
substantial amounts of administrative
reasons for this include: requirements of specific parts and
work and reducing human error.
materials to achieve maximum
Quintus’ connected services allow
Shorter production time performance and quality. This
the condition of a machine to be
Since transport time to and from possibility is extremely important
continuously monitored to ensure
the service provider is eliminated, for AM parts since optimised HIP
the highest operational reliability
the lead time for HIP treatment can cycles specifically designed for AM
and safety possible. Customers can
be significantly reduced. Investing materials can result in significantly
perform condition-based, predictive
in a modern HIP press where HIP improved mechanical properties
maintenance instead of relying on set
and heat treatment are integrated, compared to the standard HIP
service intervals in order to maximise
can often eliminate certain process cycles. This can also lead to the
uptime and reduce service costs.
steps, reducing production time development and control of their
As part of the agreement with the
even further. own IP.
customer, the predictive maintenance
package is connected to the Quintus
Risk reduction Lower total production cost
Care Portal for quick and easy access
Since transportation to and from a Having a high utilisation rate on an
to spare and wear parts.
service provider is eliminated, so inhouse HIP system yields the lowest
are the risks related to transport operating cost for the HIP process.
delays and damaged or lost goods. The cost for heat treatment can be The route to more
reduced if a combined HIP and heat
sustainable production
Production flexibility treatment approach can be used.
Insourcing HIP gives manufacturers Since transportation to external sub-
The development of modern HIP
full flexibility over their produc- contractors can be avoided, the cost
systems where HIP and heat treat-
tion schedule and lead times. When of transportation is eliminated, as
ment can be performed in one cycle,
needed, time-critical deliveries well as insurance during transport.
and the process can be controlled
can be fast-tracked through the There are also potential indirect
to prevent oxidation, has resulted
internal schedule. This can be very cost savings from improved quality
in substantial gains in productivity,
valuable in industries where short control routines, more flexible plan-
product quality, and production
lead times and flexibility are key. ning, and shorter delivery times.
economy. There are, however, also
184 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Modern HIP technology
and carbides on AM parts. Even at low ment since the produced parts are no
longer cooled and reheated for every
concentrations, the partial pressure of step in the process.
Another important sustainability
reactive gases such as oxygen becomes factor is reduced powder consump-
very high, resulting in oxidation on the tion and waste. Adding HIP with heat
treatment capabilities to a produc-
surfaces of materials with high oxygen tion line enables stronger materials
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 185
Modern HIP technology | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
components with longer service life. [2] Shipley, James, HIP Treat- Technologies whitepaper, 2021 -
It also ensures consistent product ment of Additively Manufactured https://quintustechnologies.com/
quality and minimises yield loss due Inconel 718 Components for knowledge-center/developments-in-
to fluctuating quality. The combina- Aerospace Applications, Quintus post-treatment-technologies/
tion of Additive Manufacturing, HIP, Technologies whitepaper,
[8] Shipley, James, Magnusson,
and High Pressure Heat Treatment 2020, https://quintustechnolo-
Anders, and Beamer, Chad, Latest
has already proven to result in gies.com/knowledge-center/
developments in High Pressure
substantial sustainability benefits. As hip-treatment-of-additively-manu-
Heat Treatment of aerospace
development continues to accelerate, factured-inconel-718-components-
components, Quintus Technolo-
the combination of these technolo- for-aerospace-applications/
gies whitepaper, 2022 - https://
gies holds great promise for future
[3] A. Kaletsch, S. Qin, S. Herzog, C. quintustechnologies.com/
enhancements in both productivity
Broeckmann, Influence of high initial knowledge-center/latest-develop-
and sustainability.
porosity introduced by laser powder ments-in-high-pressure-heat-treat-
bed fusion on the fatigue strength ment-of-aerospace-components/
Contact of Inconel 718 after post-processing
[9] Magnusson, Anders et al.,
with hot isostatic pressing. Additive
Quintus Purus®. Enabling clean
Manufacturing 47 (2021) 102331
Jim Shipley processing in Hot Isostatic Pressing,
Manager for Business Development [4] Ahlfors, Magnus and Beamer, Quintus Technologies whitepaper,
Quintus Technologies Chad, Hot Isostatic Pressing for 2023 - https://quintustech-
Quintusvägen 2, SE 721 66 Västerås, Orthopaedic Implants, Quintus nologies.com/knowledge-center/
Sweden Technologies whitepaper, whitepaper-quintus-purus-enabling-
2020 - https://quintustech- clean-processing-in-hot-isostatic-
james.shipley@quintusteam.com
nologies.com/knowledge-center/ pressing/
www.quintustechnologies.com
hip-orthopedic-implants/
[5] Optimum HIP temperature for
PBF IN718, presentation, Quintus
References Technologies (2020).
[6] Introduction to HIP and HPHT™,
[1] Hot isostatic pressing in metal
Quintus Technologies whitepaper,
additive manufacturing: X-ray
2021 - https://quintustech-
tomography reveals details of pore
nologies.com/knowledge-center/
closure. A Du Plessis, E. Macdonald
introduction-to-hip-and-hpht/
Additive Manufacturing, Volume 34,
August 2020, 101191 https://doi. [7] Developments in Post Treat-
org/10.1016/j.addma.2020.101191 ment Technologies, Quintus
186 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Additive Manufacturing Users Group
2024 AMUG
CONFERENCE
March 10 - 14 | Chicago
DON’T MISS
The 3D printing experience
everyone raves about.
EDUCATION TRAINING
Technical, Panel & Hands-on Workshops &
Keynote Sessions Training Sessions
REGISTER TODAY!
www.amug.com
#AMUG2024
NETWORKING COMMUNITY
Breakfast through Users Supporting
Dinner Users
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM and AI
Much like the advent of electricity for AM experts, corporate decision learning and deep learning models
or the internet, the blending of makers, and engineers. to bring a new level of efficiency
Artificial Intelligence and big data I believe that right now, rather to AM processes, operation and
is not just an incremental improve- than in the distant future, there is businesses, co-piloting Additive
ment. Instead, it represents a an opportunity for the AM industry Manufacturing on the path to
foundational shift that is reshaping to leverage the power of machine industrialisation.
the bedrock of our industries and
society. As we harness this unprec-
edented convergence, we are not
just building better tools – we are
redefining the very essence of how
we work, think, and live.
In this article, we will explore
in depth how AI will impact
the Additive Manufacturing
industry, from a new wave of
advanced design possibilities
to autonomously controlling AM
machines and ensuring part quality
and repeatability. We will share
insight gathered from those at the
cutting edge of the convergence of
AI and AM, whose voices are not
often heard in the media but who
promise to transform our industry
through their research. We will
also offer advanced use cases, Fig. 1 AI will impact the Additive Manufacturing industry, from a new wave of
insight into existing products and advanced design possibilities to autonomously controlling AM machines and
services and, by the end, hope to ensuring part quality and repeatability (Base image credit: Connect world/
have presented a clear picture Shutterstock.com)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 189
AM and AI | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
190 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM and AI
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 191
AM and AI | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
192 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM and AI
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 193
AM and AI | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
194 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM and AI
Fig. 6 Located an hour south of Berlin, BTU's first AM research and pre-production facility is fully equipped with
end-to-end hardware and an AI-enabled software platform from 1000Kelvin for generating optimal build files. BTU is
collaborating with 1000Kelvin to develop next-level monitoring capabilities for closed-loop feedback and advanced
material characterisation. This advanced integrated environment is aimed at unlocking new capabilities in Laser Beam
Powder Bed Fusion (PBF-LB) (Courtesy Brandenburg Technical University)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 195
AM and AI | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
196 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM and AI
Fig. 8 AI-based defect detection is leveraged across multiple software and monitoring systems. A large amount of
training data enables the detection of failed builds and various other defects. The primary business cases currently
focus on stopping nonconforming builds to save both time and materials, as well as reducing the costs of quality
control – often a requirement in high-end industrial applications. Challenges remain in the transferability of these
solutions from one system to another and in their level of reliability. However, these issues are expected to be over-
come soon due to the increasing volume of available data (Courtesy Materialise)
algorithms, offers a transformative critical decision-making instruments, sensors and monitoring techniques,
solution. enabling manufacturers to either halt particularly their spatial and
These AI systems provide a failing build – thereby mitigating temporal resolutions, is an ongoing
real-time insights into the integrity the cost of failure – or enhance debate among experts.
and quality of the part being quality control measures dynamically. Moreover, the issue of measure-
manufactured, allowing for immediate This further solidifies the role of AI in ment error is often underestimated,
corrective actions and resource transitioning from build-then-check to calling for a more rigorous approach
optimisation. By integrating sensor build-and-check, adding another layer to uncertainty quantification. Further
data and machine learning analytics of performance and cost-efficiency. complexities include the standardisa-
directly into the manufacturing The efficacy of this AI-driven tion of measurements for precision,
process, AI sets the stage for not in-situ monitoring is underpinned and the interpretation of data to
only higher reliability but also for by process signatures – data assess the holistic health state of a
the operational agility required amalgamated from machine control PBF-LB system. There is an evident
in next-generation manufacturing systems and an array of sensors. need for more focused research
ecosystems. This essentially evolves These process signatures serve as to comprehend the intricacies of
AM from a 'build-then-check' to a real-time health indicators of the adopting either on- or off-axis process
'build-and-check' paradigm, marking PBF-LB process, enabling nuanced sensing and monitoring, considering
a significant leap in both performance control over structural integrity and variables like accuracy, frequency,
and cost-efficiency. surface roughness. Ideally, a fully- and spatial-temporal resolutions. In
Moreover, commercially available realised in-situ monitoring system a recent comprehensive review of
image-based analysis tools from will promptly detect and rectify the state of the literature, Dr Tuğrul
companies such as Materialise anomalies, thereby auto-calibrating Özel, a full professor at Rochester
(Fig. 8), Zeiss (in collaboration PBF-LB process parameters or even Institute of Technology (RIT), New
with EOS), Addiguru, and Additive the machine itself. Jersey, USA, stated, “The long-term
Assurance are accelerating this However, challenges persist. aims for in-process monitoring can
transformative shift. Utilising diverse Correlating these process signatures include utilising machine learning
machine learning methodologies, with user-defined quality attributes and Artificial Intelligence to develop
these tools offer turnkey solutions for accurate anomaly and defect processes that are self-learning and
for real-time defect detection during characterisation remains an open intelligent, and also transferable from
the build process. They serve as research question. The selection of machine-to-machine.”
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 197
AM and AI | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
198 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | AM and AI
Given these complexities, the circles or niche applications. It is potential to simplify complex tasks
emergence of Text-to-CAX (Computer- an enabling technology that's infil- and democratise technology is vast.
Aided Design, Manufacturing, and trating every aspect of AM, from Now is the time for action. Every
Engineering) solutions is on the design and simulation to quality stakeholder in the AM ecosystem,
horizon. However, it comes with assurance and beyond and is from engineers and designers to
some caveats. Companies venturing already being leveraged by leading decision-makers and investors, is
into this space should be prepared companies within our industry. encouraged to recognise the trans-
for substantial time and resource We’re at a crucial inflection formative potential of integrating AI
investment to nail the true value point. The challenges facing into their processes. The question
proposition expected by customers. AM – efficiency, quality, and is not whether AI will revolutionise
Therefore, while it's tempting to standardisation – are not trivial. AM – I can see that it is already
jump on the AI bandwagon by merely Yet they are not insurmountable happening. Those who embrace the
integrating a chatbot into a product, either, especially with the AI tools synergistic potential of AI and AM
stakeholders should be cautious. at our disposal. Companies such as have, I believe, the opportunity to
Such a simplified approach risks Navasto and SimScale are already place themselves at the forefront of
diluting the meaning of AI and could using AI to cut simulation times an industry on the cusp of extraor-
lead to customer disillusionment, from hours to seconds, opening dinary change.
particularly when the technology fails a huge world of opportunities to
to deliver on substantial, industry- DfAM and reduction of time-to-
specific challenges. market. Leveraging deep learning Author
to optimise thermal management
Omar Fergani
and enable predictive first-time-
A call to action: seize the right outcomes improves part
CEO & co-founder at 1000 Kelvin
GmbH
AI-driven future of Additive quality and reduces cost per
Manufacturing now part, allowing AM to be more omar@1000kelvin.com
competitive. Multiple monitoring www.1000kelvin.com
The convergence of AI and AM companies are leveraging their
represents more than an incremental understanding of data and
upgrade – it is, in my view, a seismic reinforcement learning to enable
shift, capable of reshaping industries. in-process quality control. And the
As we've explored in this article, AI role of LLMs such as GPT-4 is just
is no longer confined to academic beginning to be understood; their
WWW.PIM-INTERNATIONAL.COM
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 199
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Reducing complexity in robotic AM
ADAXIS: On a mission
to reduce the layers of
complexity in robotic Additive
Manufacturing
Necessity is the mother of invention. facturing, an EU-funded institution interest from numerous companies
This centuries-old proverb still has backing the most innovative manufac- and also got the attention of the team
a ring of truth to it, even in the 21 st turing projects in Europe. at ESTIA. None of us knew each other
century. It often proves to be a key At a match-making event hosted at this time, but we joined together
driver for taking many new busi- in San Sebastian, Spain, Johansson, for an applied research project that
ness ideas into commercial reality. who was only in attendance because was granted funding.”
In the case of ADAXIS, necessity was his manager was unable to be there, The project itself highlighted a
certainly one driver to the founding “presented a pitch that sparked number of things, not least the frus-
of the company, accompanied by
passion.
To explain, ADAXIS was founded
early in 2021 when four people,
Henri Bernard, Guénolé Bras, Emil
Johansson and Vasan Churchill,
were driven by a shared frustra-
tion towards the time-consuming
and complex task of programming
industrial robots for Additive Manu-
facturing and the resulting access
barriers within the industry.
Prior to 2019, Bernard and Bras
(at the ESTIA Institute of Tech-
nology in France) and Johansson
and Churchill (at the RISE Research
Institute of Sweden) simultaneously
undertook years of applied research
into using industrial robotics for
advanced manufacturing. In 2019,
serendipity brought all four together Fig. 1 The ADAXIS founders, from left to right: Guenole Bras, Vasan Churchill,
following the launch of EIT Manu- Emil Johanson and Henri Bernard (Courtesy ADAXIS)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 201
Reducing complexity in robotic AM | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Technical challenges in
robotic AM
“The challenge that the company is
addressing is that with each industrial Today, it is possible to use most
metal DED technologies on a
robot there is different control software, robotic arm to provide flexibility in
deposition rate, surface finish and
and with each Directed Energy material choice – from stainless
Deposition (DED) technology, there is and carbon steels to aluminium
and titanium alloys. Each tech-
different control software, with different nology has its own unique control
202 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Reducing complexity in robotic AM
• Orientation of material deposition pivotal. The approach adopted for This is where AdaOne stands out: it
piece fabrication substantially influ- enables users to precisely and easily
• Trajectory generation strategy
ences the final result. Parameters configure all of these parameters.
• Homogeneity of heat distribution such as fill methods, pause durations, The ability to seamlessly trans-
• Variation in bead height and arc restarts, and modes tailored to late this outcome into a precise
width each specific component are indis- robotic language (whether KUKA,
pensable. None of this is easy, but ABB, Yaskawa, Fanuc, et al) to opti-
• Variation in workpiece distance
these features in AdaOne empower mise trajectory (position, orientation,
These factors directly impact the users to rapidly, effortlessly, and speed, acceleration, interpolation)
final quality of the part, for example efficiently program their robots and the process itself (material
dimensional tolerances, internal according to their specific application feed, power, etc.) becomes vitally
stresses, and porosity. requirements.” important.
AdaOne has been specially
developed to handle the above chal-
lenges through its custom-built path “AdaOne has been specially developed
planning engine. It can handle state-
of-the-art trajectory generation on to handle the above challenges through
planar and non-planar substrates and its custom-built path planning engine.
optimises layer height variation and
tool orientation to follow part geom- It can handle state-of-the-art trajectory
etries. Each layer can be segmented
to adapt deposition strategy and
generation on planar and non-planar
path traversal, and dynamic process substrates and optimises layer height
control can be used to optimise the
different deposition phases.
variation and tool orientation to follow
Henri Bernard further explained, part geometries.”
“The mastery of thermal control,
and thus process control, becomes
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 203
Reducing complexity in robotic AM | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
204 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Reducing complexity in robotic AM
Talking applications
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 205
Reducing complexity in robotic AM | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Successful partnerships
components of any size. It is also a very tions with Procada based in Sweden;
Fortius Metals based in Colorado,
flexible technology that can cater to a USA; and Exafuse based in Germany;
as well as partnerships with leading
wide variety of material specifications.” universities and research institutes,
206 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Reducing complexity in robotic AM
such as Politecnico di Milano, Italy, designed specifically for wire DED Contact
Technalia and AIMEN in Spain, CCAT Additive Manufacturing processes
in Connecticut, USA, Tampere Univer- using arc, laser and electron beam
Ulf Lindhe
sity of Applied Sciences, Finland, and energy sources. The company has
Chief Marketing Officer
Nagaoka University of Technology, a complete wire manufacturing
ADAXIS
Japan. capability located at its Lafayette,
Procada is a startup specialising Colorado, facility and utilises ulf.lindhe@adaxis.eu
in controller solutions for large AdaOne software. www.adaxis.eu
scale laser DED — with wire feed-
stock — for critical applications in
Conclusion Author
sectors such as energy, marine and
aerospace. Petter Hagqvist, CTO
at Procada AB commented on the When the ADAXIS team say they Rachel Park
partnership between Procada and want to keep it simple and acces- rachelp@rp-editorialservices.co.uk
ADAXIS, stating, “At Procada, we have sible, they really mean it. Bernard www.rp-editorialservices.co.uk
identified the process of turning a rounds up, “We deliver AdaOne
CAD-file into robot movements as a as an on-premises software, and
critical link in the chain for realising we keep it really straightforward
reliable DED builds. For our wire/ — one key allows AdaOne to be
laser DED process, tool positioning activated on one computer and
and build path planning is especially program an unlimited number of
crucial due to the unforgiving process robots. It is competitively-priced
dynamics. ADAXIS’ solution to these and as a company we offer ongoing
problems, for us, seems to be a support and encourage community
particularly competent and flexible engagement and sharing. This
one that suits our needs very well.” means that robotic AM becomes
Fortius Metals has developed accessible, cost-efficient, and easy
proprietary robotic AM welding wires to use.”
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 207
ABSTRACT SUBMISSION DEADLINE EXTENDED: OCTOBER 27, 2023
Call for
Presentations
MANUFACTURING INNOVATIONS:
• Part design • Part Inspection
• Tooling • Secondary Operations
• Molding • Simulation
• Debinding • Competing Technologies
• Sintering • Coatings
MATERIALS ADVANCEMENTS:
• Metals & alloys • Binder Technologies
• Ceramics • Mixing
• Hardmaterials • Mechanical Properties
TARGETED AUDIENCE:
• Product designers
• Engineers
• End users
• Manufacturers
• Researchers
• Educators
• Students
Conference Sponsors:
In the dynamic landscape of metal the quality, production time and growth of parameter complexity.
AM, the quest for optimised and rapid cost of an additively manufactured So, when there is such complexity,
process development is a prevailing metal part. As with all metal forming why should an AM user even think
trend. There are currently only a few processes, complexity increases about optimising their standard
dozen materials that are qualified further if raw material production or parameter sets? The simple answer
for industrial metal AM applica- complex heat treatment cycles are is that if they don’t, they are not
tions. Conventional manufacturing considered. With new developments leveraging the full potential of their
processes, however, have the option such as beam shaping, high-temper- expensive hardware.
to choose from thousands of iron- ature preheating or multi-material Process parameters can be
based alloys, for example. This leads manufacturing, there are additional optimised not only for higher produc-
to slower AM application develop- factors that contribute to a further tivity. There is a wide range of
ment, among other things, resulting
in a reduced speed of industrial
adoption despite the tremendous
technological potential of the tech-
nology. In addition to this, we have
yet to consider the development of
new materials with previously unob-
tainable properties that can only be
processed by metal AM.
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 209
The value in your AM data | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
210 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | The value in your AM data
Fig. 3 An example of a parameter set for the aluminium alloy Aheadd® CP1 from Constellium for a SLM® Solutions 280
2.0 system (Courtesy Rosswag)
optimisation and development Leveraging metal AM's tivity for non-critical components.
is the world's first process full potential This eliminates the need to invest
parameter marketplace for PBF-LB: in new machinery or extensive
AddiMap. This platform introduces A noteworthy advantage of the parameter studies for enhanced
a novel approach to expedite AddiMap model is its potential productivity. The metal AM industry,
process parameter development to unlock previously untapped ripe for innovation and collabora-
and material data acquisition. avenues for leveraging metal tion, can substantially benefit from
Companies armed with self- AM's full potential. Companies can this shift away from protectionism
developed process parameters can acquire process parameters that toward broader market growth
list their parameters on AddiMap, cater to specific needs, such as and the exploration of exciting new
alongside relevant material and thin-walled parts or high produc- applications.
process data. The uniqueness and
quality of data influence the pricing
of these parameters.
The platform's approach raises
a pertinent question – why not Data Provider
offer initial parameter sets with
preliminary results? Particularly Data Monetissation
in the context of new materials, New Business Models
any data foundation serves as a
valuable asset for subsequent
optimisations. Enhanced data
quality paves the way for data
monetisation, including scenarios Plug & Print
where certification necessitates Cost-Efficient
the use of data, effectively enabling
businesses to recover their Data Buyer
investments. This novel approach
transforms into an entirely new
business model for experienced AM Fig. 4 Advantages for data providers and data buyers by using the AddiMap
users. platform (Courtesy Rosswag)
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 211
The value in your AM data | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
212 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
Events guide | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Industry events
Metal AM magazine is dedicated to driving awareness and development of metal Additive
Manufacturing and its related technologies. Key to this aim is our support of a range of
international partner conferences and exhibitions. View our complete events listing on
www.metal-am.com
2023
Scotland Manufacturing & Supply Chain Conference Asean Ceramics
& Exhibition November 28–30, Hanoi, Vietnam
October 25, Glasgow, UK www.aseanceramics.com/vietnam/
www.manufacturingexposcotland.com
214 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Events guide
2024
Military Additive Manufacturing Summit & 3D Print Lyon
Technology Showcase June 4–6, Lyon, France
January 16–17, Tampa, FL, USA www.3dprint-exhibition-lyon.com
www.militaryam.com
TCT 3Sixty
TCT Japan June 5–6, Birmingham, UK
January 31 – February 2, Tokyo, Japan www.tct3sixty.com
www.tctjapan.jp
EPHJ
Additive Manufacturing Strategies 2024 June 11–14, Geneva, Switzerland
February 6–8, New York, NY, USA www.ephj.ch
www.additivemanufacturingstrategies.com
PowderMet2024 / AMPM2024
Digital Twin & Smart Manufacturing Summit June 16–19, Pittsburgh, PA, USA
February 21–22, Berlin, Germany www.powdermet2024.org | www.ampm2024.org
www.digitaltwintechsummit.com
PMTi 2024
MIM2024 September 4–6, Madrid, Spain
February 26–28, Raleigh, NC, USA www.pmti2024.com
www.mim2024.org
EURO PM2024
AM for Aerospace, Defence & Space September 29– October 2, Malmö, Sweden
February 27–28, Bristol, UK www.europm2024.com
www.defenceiq.com/events-additivemanufacturing
World PM2024
AM China 2024 / PM China 2024 October 13–17, Yokohama, Japan
March 6–8, Shanghai, China www.worldpm2024.com
www.amatex.cn / en.pmexchina.com
AMUG
March 10–14, Chicago, IL, USA
www.amug.com
2025
Hannover Messe DDMC 2025
April 22–26, Hannover, Germany March 12–13, Berlin, Germany
www.hannovermesse.de www.ddmc-fraunhofer.de
Rapid + TCT
April 23–25, Anaheim, CA, USA
www.rapid3devent.com
If you would like to see your metal
Additive Manufacturing related event
AMC 2024
listed in this magazine and on our
April 25–27, Antalya, Turkey
websites, please contact:
www.amctr.org
Merryl Le Roux
Operations and Partnerships Manager
Space Tech Expo US
May 14–15, Long Beach, CA, USA merryl@inovar-communications.com
www.spacetechexpo.com
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 215
DDMC 2025 | Berlin | March 12-13, 2025
Advertisers’ index
& buyer’s guide
Our advertisers’ index and buyer’s guide serves as a convenient guide to suppliers of AM
machines, materials, part manufacturing services, software and associated production equip-
ment. In the digital edition of Metal AM magazine, available at www.metal-am.com, simply click
on a company name to view its advert, or on the weblink to go directly to its website.
Farsoon Technologies 93
www.farsoon.com Binder Jetting (BJT)
Guangdong Hanbang 3D Tech Co., Ltd. 75 Desktop Metal, Inc. OBC
en.hb3dp.com www.desktopmetal.com
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 217
Advertisers’ index / buyer’s guide | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Directed Energy
Alphabetical index Deposition (DED)
Addiblast by FerroECOBlast. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64 BLT - Bright Laser Technologies 67
www.xa-blt.com
Additive Industries. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
AM China 2024 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 187 Hybrid Manufacturing Technologies 46
www.hybridmanutech.com
AM Solutions - Rösler Group . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57
m2nxt 143
AMAZEMET Sp. z o. o. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134
www.m2nxt.com
AMCM GmbH . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27
MetalWorm AM Technologies Inc 44
America Makes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 160
AM MACHINES
www.metalworm.com
AMUG . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 188
Nikon Corporation 107
Arcast Inc . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88/142 www.nikon.com
assonic Dorstener Siebtechnik GmbH . . . . . . . 136
TRUMPF SE + Co. KG 31
ASTM - Wohlers Report 2023 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 www.trumpf.com
ATM Qness GmbH . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117
ATO by 3D Lab . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110
PRE & POST-PROCESSING
Avimetal AM Tech Co., Ltd . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113
AZO GmbH + Co. KG . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132
TECHNOLOGY, PROCESS
BLT - Bright Laser Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 AUTOMATION
Blue Power Casting Systems GmbH . . . . . . . . . 78
Addiblast by FerroECOBlast 64
Bodycote . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 www.addiblast.com
Burloak Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82 AM Solutions - Rösler Group 57
CADS Additive GmbH . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 www.solutions-for-am.com
Carpenter Additive . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53 AMAZEMET Sp. z o. o. 134
Centorr Vacuum Industries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 www.amazemet.com
218 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Advertisers’ index / buyer’s guide
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 219
Advertisers’ index / buyer’s guide | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
PART MANUFACTURERS
Novanta Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
Ophir Optronics Solutions Ltd . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 115 AM Solutions - Rösler Group 57
www.solutions-for-am.com
Oqton, Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
Phoenix Scientific Industries Ltd. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 BLT - Bright Laser Technologies 67
www.xa-blt.com
PM China 2024 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 213
Pometon S.p.A. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76
Burloak Technologies Inc. 82
www.burloaktech.com
PowderMet2024 / AMPM2024 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 200
GKN Additive 129
Prima Industries S.P.A. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
www.gknadditive.com
pro-beam . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 79/81
Hybrid Manufacturing Technologies 46
Process Sensing Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70 www.hybridmanutech.com
Proterial, Ltd. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91
Indium Corporation® 34
PureAire Monitoring System, Inc. . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 www.indium.com
Quintus Technologies AB . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59
Indo-MIM 105
Rapidia Tech Inc . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 www.indo-mim.com
Ricoh UK Products Ltd . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 Kennametal Inc. 58
Rio Tinto . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 www.kennametal.com
S&S Scheftner GmbH . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Ricoh UK Products Ltd 94
Safina, a.s. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 114 ukproducts.ricoh.com
220 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
| contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter | Advertisers’ index / buyer’s guide
Vol. 9 No. 3 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 221
Advertisers’ index / buyer’s guide | contents | news | events | advertisers | print sub | newsletter |
Atmosphere analysis
Process Sensing Technologies 70 EVENTS & COURSES
www.processsensing.com
AM China 2024 187
Laser calibration www.amatex.cn
AMUG 188
Ophir Optronics Solutions Ltd 115
www.amug.com
www.ophiropt.com
DDMC 2025 216
www.ddmc-fraunhofer.de
Formnext 144
nLIGHT, Inc. 77 www.formnext.com
www.nlight.net MIM2024 208
Novanta Inc. 28 www.mim2024.org
www.novanta.com PM China 2024 213
en.pmexchina.com
ZEISS International 36
www.zeiss.com
8-9 WEBSITE //
AM 10
12-13
E-NEWSLETTER //
RATES //
14 CONTACT //
Jon Craxford
Advertising Sales Director
Tel: +44 207 1939 749
jon@inovar-communications.com Media Pack
// 2022
222 Metal Additive Manufacturing | Autumn 2023 © 2023 Inovar Communications Ltd Vol. 9 No. 3
We have solutions
for your manufacturing challenges
Desktop Metal’s 3D printing solutions are trusted worldwide by the Our portfolio of metal
printers offers 20+
world’s biggest and smallest companies — to solve the toughest
metals, including
challenges and enable once-impossible innovations ceramics
Complex Geometries
Affordable Solutions
GET STARTED
INSIDE:
• Learn the benefits of binder jetting technology, which requires no
expensive lasers and prints at high speeds
• Explore how binder jetting is similar to long-trusted Metal Injection
Molding (MIM) processes
• Review details on final part density and quality of binder jetted parts
• See the incredible flexibility for printing stainless steels, nickel-based
alloys, and other metals, including aluminum, titanium, and copper
• Read about customers using Desktop Metal systems Download the Guide at
TeamDM.com/BinderJetGuide