Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Psychosomatic Approach
Psychosomatic Approach
ISSN: 0874-4696
revista@sppsicossomatica.org
Sociedade Portuguesa de Psicossomática
Portugal
Ierodiakonou, C.S.
The psychosomatic approach in childhood disorders: some psychodynamic and psychotherapeutic
issues
Revista Portuguesa de Psicossomática, vol. 3, núm. 1, jan/jun, 2001, pp. 45-55
Sociedade Portuguesa de Psicossomática
Porto, Portugal
How to cite
Complete issue
Scientific Information System
More information about this article Network of Scientific Journals from Latin America, the Caribbean, Spain and Portugal
Journal's homepage in redalyc.org Non-profit academic project, developed under the open access initiative
Revista
Portuguesa
45 Revista
de The psychosomatic approach in childhood disorders
Portuguesa
Psicossomática
de
Psicossomática
C.S. Ierodiakonou*
Investigators directed their stud- changes occur in, say, fear than in rage
ies towards the personality of the or grief, and so on. Others, like
child, the character traits of the par- Kaufman(4), accept the ps/s process as
ents, the special mechanisms of a double one, having first symbolic
defense, and in a parallel manner they representations (like in peptic ulcer,
studied the pathophysiological re- those of deprivation) and secondar-
sponse of the neurovegetative (n/v) ily n/v changes (e.g. increased secre-
system, the vulnerability of an organ, tion of stomach enzymes).
and nowadays the implication of The direct influence of emotions
psychoimmunology in childhood. on the n/v and secretory functions
The first writers on the subject was studied experimentally in chil-
were psychoanalysts, and it was only dren. The case of Monica, a little child
natural for them to be influenced by of 20 months with a congenital atresia
the studies on hysteria and to accept of the oesophagus and a stomach fis-
a symbolic meaning of ps/s manifes- tula, remained classical. G.L. Engel
tations. Abraham(1) connected a fixa- and F. Reichsman measured the acid
tion of libido at the oral and anal stage secretion of the stomach and found it
with certain gastrointestinal condi- to be statistically lower when the child
tions. Fenichel(2) accepted a constitu- was under experimental conditions of
tional predisposition and, at the same unpleasure or depression, and signifi-
time, that subconscious fantasies cantly higher when in rage. The af-
about an organ, its usefulness, its role fective changes correlated to the ob-
in a crisis and the possibilities for ject relations of the child with certain
symbolic expression are determining persons of the staff during the experi-
factors. mental period (5).
Franz Alexander (3), one of the pio- Other experimenters, like Lacey
neers in ps/s medicine, separated and Malmo (6,7), claim that because of
symbolism from the ps/s symptoms a "neurovegetative instability"
and said that these are not a substi- (which, according to some, may be
tute for an emotional expression; they constitutional) any stress produces
are only accompanying functional the same organ reaction in a particu-
manifestations. He contrasted the lar individual ("autonomic response
hysterical (symbolic) somatization, specificity"). In the past, some spoke
which relieves the patient from anxi- about a "physiological infantilism",
ety to that in ps/s cases, where symp- i.e. that a certain organ stays in a stage
toms coexist with anxiety. He was also of "minor resistance" (8). But again the
in favour of a "specificity theory" ac- question remains whether the vulner-
cording to which "every emotional ability of an organ does not depend
experience produces its own ps/s re- solely on its physical past history (lack
action". This was based on Cannon’s of development, illnesses, injuries
physiological findings of the Chicago etc), but on the way it was emotional-
School showing that different bodily ly invested as well (fear of death from
its injury, invalidism, parental sym- Stress reduction methods (like re-
bolism, etc.). laxation, biofeedback, psychotherapy,
Regarding the above issues, an ex- music, etc.) were applied with the
perimental research of ours with pae- question of whether they could acti-
diatricians showed that the n/v re- vate immunological functions. There
sponse depends on the CNS matura- have been encouraging studies (12,13,14)
tion. ln normal children of different in which increase of lymphocytes, of
age (newborn, babies, infants) a pain- B-and T-cells, IgG, IgM, of salivary
ful stimulus (prick by a needle) was immunoglobin, etc., were observed.
applied and various measurements Personality factors (like loneliness,
were then carried out: blood pressure, pessimism, etc.) were also studied in
pulse, temperature, sweating, blood elderly people, widows and others;
glucose, dilatation of the pupils, tears there was no general correlation, but
and intensity of crying. It was found many subjects exhibited a reduced
that the reactions were more abrupt NK cell activity, lower reaction to
and intense the younger the age. In a PHA, more T-suppressor cells, etc (15).
similar research in children with en- It would be of interest to see in the
cephalopathy, their n/v system was future similar studies in special age
found to be more sensitive and un- groups of children, which could elu-
steady when compared to that of nor- cidate various ps/s issues.
mal children, – overreacting, espe-
cially in severe cases (9). Psychodynamic issues
Psychoimmunology is a new From a psychodynamic point of
promising field which is being re- view the issue of "organ choice" oc-
cently and intensely investigated in cupied the interest of investigators
an effort to have better answers for very early. Dunbar (16) , in the 40s,
ps/s conditions. Stressors, especially spoke about a "personality profile" for
in animal studies, exhibited an inhibi- each ps/s condition (e.g. patients
tory effect on immunological re- with migraine being insecure, rigid,
sponses. The mutual relationship be- very conscientious with repressed ag-
tween the n/v system and neurohor- gression). Others restricted their
mones, and their action (following a search to finding only certain person-
stress) on the immune system results ality traits for each disease (Gressel et
in a marked reduction of lymphocyte al., 17) and others argued that, in spite
proliferation. Stressors like noise, of some apparent differences in the
sleep deprivation, death of a spouse behaviour of patients suffering from
and academic examination, were the same condition, their deeper Ego-
used by researchers in humans; some Superego structure formed during
studies (10,11) showed a decrease of NK childhood had many similarities. This
(natural killer) cell activity, decreased view coincides with Alexander’ s
numbers of T-cells and other immu- theory that there is a "nuclear conflict"
nological reactions. unique to each disorder.
cant finding (in 48 out of 65 cases) was dition have common psychopatho-
a definite traumatic precipitating fac- logical findings; these may concern
tor, usually producing a terror reac- the personality profile, or the type of
tion. Most parents (47 fathers and 50 precipitating factors, or the mother-
mothers) were very anxious or -child relations and so on. One can as-
perfectionistic making untimely re- sume, therefore, that for every disor-
marks to the child, thus aggravating der there is one psychopathological
the situation. route (or more?) which is followed in
In Psychogenic Vomiting of ado- the pathogenetic process. In the chain:
lescent girls under psychotherapy, predisposing factors – main aetiologi-
subconscious difficulties of accepting cal factors – stressors – precipitating
their female role were uncovered, as conditions – defense mechanisms –
well as symbolic denial of their am- psychic economy, some parts have
bivalent attitude towards male sexu- been revealed by modern science, but
ality, which they considered aggres- we are still far from having all the an-
sive. In a similar way, in other cases swers and the whole truth.
of our Department, Oversweating
served the psychic economy by pre- Psychotherapeutic issues
venting contact with the opposite sex Psychotherapy of ps/s conditions
which was unconsciously feared. in children is much more effective
Another research of ours (38,40) con- than in adults for various reasons: the
cerned 60 late adolescent girls, stu- onset of the symptomatology is usu-
dents who suffered from non-organic ally recent, the intrapsychic conflict
secondary amenorrhoea when they is in its first stages (sometimes undif-
first came from the countryside to city ferentiated but ongoing), the family
schools. A significantly greater num- members are alive and present (and
ber of these (compared to the control not merely representations of the
group) were emotionally labile, with past) and during therapy the non ver-
tension in their paternal family, and bal communication is more applica-
had sexual relations which proved ble (play –, art therapy, etc.) (41).
frustrating instead of helpful. A striking example of the possibili-
We had ps/s cases in which the ties of psychotherapy is shown in
choice of organ was determined by a some cases of enuresis in which, as
mechanism of defense, e.g. identifi- all clinicians know, wetting stops af-
cation in cases of adopted children ter the first few sessions, or sometimes
with Headache, a symptom from even after the first diagnosis. The
which the adoptive mother was also whole procedure, – confrontation of
suffering. Symbiotic needs and se- the problem by the child, involvement
condary gains were involved. of the family etc. –, mobilises new in-
From the ps/s conditions de- terpersonal and intrapsychic proc-
scribed above one can gather that esses which help abolish the symp-
most of the cases in a particular con- tom.