Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter V
Chapter V
THE ACT
You make moral decisions daily. However, have you noticed that some decisions are
automatic responses and that you are not consciously deciding at all? For example, you help
an elderly cross the road. Without thinking, you ran to the opposite side of the road, away from
some perceive danger. Your desire to help and your fear of danger are gut reaction while
reasoned argument is just swirling beneath conscious awareness.
General Objectives:
1. Discern the two general forms of acts
2. Discuss the philosophical insight of feelings and its influence in decision making
3. Explain why reason and impartiality are requirements for morality
4. Determine a situation where there is a need for moral courage
Not all acts are to be taken as formal objects of ethics. Certain acts are of some value to
ethics, while others are expendable to ethical analysis. These become clearer if we consider the
two general forms of acts in the light of their moral value: the acts of man and the human acts.
Follow closely the discussions below and study whyhuman acts are considered to be the formal
object of ethics.
WHAT TO EXPECT
Lesson Outline
Acts of Man
Involuntary Natural Acts
Acts of Man are of two types: the first type is called involuntary natural acts. These
include the involuntary intuitive or reflex acts exhibited by man, such as the blinking of the eye,
the beating of the heart, sneezing, yawning, breathing, scratching, and others. When eating, are
you always aware of the way you chew or swallow your food? Probably not, unless you just had
dental surgery, or are suffering from tonsillitis (inflammation of the tonsil). or gingivitis
(inflammation of the gums). Try doing the following and confirm for yourself if they are indeed
involuntary:
Human Acts
The second general form of act is called human acts. Human acts include actions that
are conscious, deliberate, intentional, voluntary and are within the preview of human value
judgment. Human acts are either moral or immoral. These actions are products of man’s
rationality and freedom of choice like telling the truth, helping others in distress and caring for
the sick. Since moral acts contain the elements that allow for moral judgment and setting of
moral responsibility. These acts are then said to be the formal object of ethics.
WHAT TO EXPECT
Lesson Outline
Max Ferdinand Scheler was an important German Ethical Philosopher distinguished for
his contribution in phenomenology, ethics, and philosophical anthropology (Davis and
Steinbock, 2016). As a phenomenologist, Scheler sought to know what comprised the structures
of consciousness, including that of mental acts such as feeling, thinking, resolve, etc. – as well
as the inherent objects or correlates of theses mental acts such as values, concepts, and plans
(Frings, 2013).
Scheler presented four strata of feelings. He claimed that these strata or levels are
constant and it follows and exact order of importance. He called these levels of feelings as the
“stratification model of emotive life”:
Sensual Feelings – involve bodily pleasure or pain.
Vital Feelings – are the life functions such as health, sickness, energy, fatigue, etc.
Psychic Feelings – are about aesthetics, justice and knowledge.
Spiritual Feelings – deal with the Divine.
According to Scheler, of the four, it is the spiritual feeling alone that is intentional. This
means that the spiritual feelings are directed to a particular special object or a higher being that
he attributed to as the Divine. He believed that values of the holy are the highest of all values
because it has the ability to endure through time.
Reasonis the basis or motive for an action, decision, or conviction. As a quality, it refers
to the capacity or logical, rational, and analytic thought; for consciously making sense of things,
establishing andverifying facts, applying common sense and logic, and justifying, and if
necessary, changing practices,institutions, and beliefs based on existing or new existing
information.t also spells the difference of moral judgments from mere expressions of personal
preference. In thecase of moral judgments, they require backing by reasons. Thus, reason
commends what it commends,regardless of our feelings, attitudes, opinions, and
desires.Impartialityinvolves the idea that each individual’s interests and point of view are equally
important. Itis a principle of justice holding that decisions ought to be based on objective criteria,
rather than on thebasis of bias, prejudice, or preferring the benefit to one person over another
for improper reasons.Impartiality in morality requires that we give equal and/or adequate
consideration to the interests of allconcerned parties. The principle of impartiality assumes that
every person, generally speaking, isequally important; that is, no one is seen intrinsically more
significant than anyone else
WHAT TO EXPECT
Lesson Outline
How impartiality is requirement for morality? According to philosopher and professor, Dr.
James Rachels, for your decision to be moral, you should think how your answer will affect the
people surrounds you, and how it will affect you as a person. An impartial choice involves
basing your decision on how all the person in the situation will be affected and not to advantage
of a particular party that you favor.
WHAT TO EXPECT
Lesson Outline
Moral courage is the courage to put your moral principles into action even though you
may be in doubt, are afraid, or face adverse consequence. Moral courage involves careful
deliberation and mastery of the self. Moral courage is essential not for only a virtuous life, but
also a happy one because integrity is essential to self-esteem.
However, according to philosopher Mark Johnson, acting morally often requires more
than just strength and character (Drumwright& Murphy, 2004). Johnson added it is important to
have “an ability to imaginatively discern various possibilities for acting within a given situation to
envision the potential help and harm that are likely to result from a given action”. This ability
called moral imagination.
Moral imagination is “ability in a particular circumstance to discover and evaluate
possibilities not merely framed by a set of rules or rule-governed concerns”.
What is Will?
Generally, “will” is the mental capacity to act decisively on one’s desire. It is the faculty of
the mind initiates action after coming to a resolution following careful deliberation (Joachim,
1952). Within Ethics “will” is an important topic along with reason because of its role in enabling
a person to act deliberately.
On the concept of the “will” in Classical Philosophy, Aristotle said: “The soul in living
creatures is distinguished by two functions, the judging capacity which is a function of the
intellect and of sensation combined, and the capacity for exciting movement in space.” (Hett,
1964)