Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

Buccal Nerve Dissection Via an

Intraoral Approach: Correcting an


Error Regarding Buccal Nerve
Blockade
Joe Iwanaga, DDS, PhD,* and R. Shane Tubbs, PhDy
Purpose: The buccal nerve (BN) supplies sensation to the skin over the anterior part of the buccinator,
buccal mucosa, and buccal gingivae corresponding to the second and third molar teeth. Some dental
anatomy books depict the main trunk of the BN coursing over the buccal shelf of the mandible, which
leads to a serious misunderstanding of this anatomy. Therefore, this study aimed to show the course of
the BN on the retromolar area and establish new evidence-based anatomy for appropriate BN blockade.
Materials and Methods: Twenty sides from 10 fresh-frozen Caucasian cadaveric heads were used in
this study. The closest distance from the BN to the injection site of the BN blockade (Dis A) was measured.
Results: The mean Dis A was 12.69  2.95 mm. On 16 of 20 sides (80%), Dis A was longer than 10 mm. In
most specimens, the injection site of the BN blockade was too far from the course of the main trunk of the
BN and the injection site should be changed to 10 mm superolateral to the injection site based on the
present results and those of other previous studies.
Conclusions: Although the distribution of the BN is variable, in most specimens, the current injection
site for BN blockade was too far from the course of the BN.
Ó 2019 American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons
J Oral Maxillofac Surg 77:1154.e1-1154.e4, 2019

The buccal nerve (BN) is one of the branches of the between the maxilla and mandible. Anatomically, the
anterior division of the mandibular nerve (cranial buccal gingivae of the lower molar teeth are
nerve V3). It travels between the superior and inferior supplied by one of the terminal branches of the BN,
heads of the lateral pterygoid muscle, descends antero- not its main trunk. Some dental texts show the main
laterally, and perforates the tendon of the temporalis as trunk of the BN running on the buccal shelf of the
it inserts onto the anterior border of the ramus.1 The mandible and this creates confusion of this
BN supplies sensation to the skin over the anterior anatomy,4 which is due primarily to the lack of
part of the buccinator, buccal mucosa, and buccal anatomic study of the BN by intraoral dissection.
gingivae corresponding to the second and third A nerve blockade procedure is defined as a local
molars.2 Most anatomy textbooks and atlases depict anesthetic solution placed near a main nerve trunk.5
the course of the BN with a lateral view,2,3 which In dentistry, there are several different nerve blockade
also displays the course of the main trunk of the BN techniques, such as inferior alveolar nerve, greater
as running along the middle of the buccinator palatine nerve, and posterior superior alveolar nerve

*Anatomical Researcher and Educator, Seattle Science Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr Iwanaga:
Foundation, Seattle, WA; Dental and Oral Medical Center, Kurume Seattle Science Foundation, 550 17th Avenue, Suite 600, Seattle,
University School of Medicine, Fukuoka, Japan. WA 98122; e-mail: joei@seattlesciencefoundation.org
yProfessor and Vice President, Seattle Science Foundation, Received December 9 2018
Seattle, WA; Department of Anatomical Sciences, St George’s Accepted January 22 2019
University, St. George’s, Grenada, West Indies. Ó 2019 American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons
Conflict of Interest Disclosures: Neither author has any relevant 0278-2391/19/30113-2
financial relationship(s) with a commercial interest. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joms.2019.01.038

1154.e1
IWANAGA AND TUBBS 1154.e2

injection into the mucous membrane of the anterior


border of the ramus, just lateral to the third molar
area and in line with the occlusive plane.7,10
Based on the anatomic findings described earlier,
BN blockade techniques might not anesthetize the
main trunk of the BN but rather its small terminal
branches to the buccal gingivae of the molar area. To
the authors’ knowledge, to date, there have been no
anatomic studies of the BN by intraoral dissection to
show the BN in the same view as the dentists see in
their daily practice. This anatomic study aimed to bet-
ter describe the course of the BN in the retromolar
area for improved BN blockade.

Materials and Methods


Twenty sides from 10 fresh-frozen Caucasian cadav-
eric heads (7 female and 3 male) were used in this
study. The mean age at death was 71.5  13.4 years
(range, 57 to 93 yr).
First, the BN blockade injection site was marked on
the anterior border of the ramus of the mandible and
FIGURE 1. Measurement of closest distance from the BN to point A
1 mm lateral to the third molar area (point A). The initial
(Dis A). BN, buccal nerve; Dis A, closest distance from buccal nerve incision was made from point A to 3 to 4 cm superiorly
to injection site of buccal nerve blockade; MM, masseter muscle; along the anterior border of the ramus. The mucosa and
point A, anterior border of mandibular ramus and 1 mm lateral to
third molar area.
buccinator muscle were incised and the buccal fat pad
was exposed. Second, blunt dissection was performed
Iwanaga and Tubbs. Correcting an Error of Buccal Nerve
Blockade. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2019. to identify the BN. Once the BN was identified, it was
traced to find the closest point to point A. The closest
distance from the BN to point A (Dis A) was measured
blockade.6,7 BN blockade, also referred to as long BN (Fig 1) and the relation of the BN to the tendon of the
blockade,8 is often applied to patients who undergo temporalis muscle was recorded. All BNs were traced
third molar extraction as supplemental anesthesia proximally to confirm their identity.
owing to the lack of the distribution of the inferior One oral and maxillofacial surgeon (J.I.) and 1 clin-
alveolar nerve on the lower buccal gingiva.3,4,7,9 BN ical anatomist (R.S.T.) performed all dissections and
blocks are performed in the retromolar area by measurements. All measurements were performed

FIGURE 2. Closest distance from injection site to buccal nerve.


Iwanaga and Tubbs. Correcting an Error of Buccal Nerve Blockade. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2019.
1154.e3 CORRECTING AN ERROR OF BUCCAL NERVE BLOCKADE

by the authors’ institutional ethics committees and


was performed in accordance with the requirements
of the Declaration of Helsinki (64th World Medical As-
sociation General Assembly, Fortaleza, Brazil,
October 2013).

Results
Dis A ranged from 8.54 to 19.51 mm (mean,
12.69  2.95 mm; right side, 8.54 to 16.00 mm
[mean, 13.05  2.49 mm]; left side, 7.31 to
19.51 mm [mean, 12.34  3.45 mm]). On 16 of 20
sides (80%), Dis A was longer than 10 mm (8 sides
on the right and 8 sides on the left). There was no sig-
nificant difference between genders or sides (P > .05).
In addition, on 11 sides (55%), Dis A was longer than
13 mm (7 sides on the right and 4 sides on the left;
Fig 2). On all sides (20 of 20), the BN ran anterior to
the tendon of the temporalis muscle (Fig 3).

Discussion
BN blockade is a well-known procedure for
dentistry and many dentists perform this technique
to anesthetize the buccal gingivae of the lower molar
area. Previous anatomic studies on the BN are the basis
for this procedure. Hendy et al11 investigated the dis-
FIGURE 3. Example of BN crossing anterior to the TT. BN, buccal tance from the site where the main trunk of the BN
nerve; TT, tendon of temporalis muscle.
crosses the external oblique ridge to the deepest con-
Iwanaga and Tubbs. Correcting an Error of Buccal Nerve cavity of the external oblique ridge, which is a familiar
Blockade. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2019.
landmark to dentists for performing inferior alveolar
nerve blockade. In this study, the main trunk of the
with micro-calipers (Mitsutoyo, Kanagawa, Japan). No BN crossed within 3 mm from the deepest concavity
scar or pathology was observed in the areas dissected. in 70% (14 of 20) and 7 to 12 mm below the deepest
The present study protocol did not require approval concavity in 30% (6 of 20).

FIGURE 4. Correct and incorrect illustrations of the course of the buccal nerve.
Iwanaga and Tubbs. Correcting an Error of Buccal Nerve Blockade. J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2019.
IWANAGA AND TUBBS 1154.e4

Distribution of the BN in the retromolar area has report, Panas mentioned that the BN was found by
been well documented. Hendy and Robinson12 map- making a 2- to 2.5-cm mucous incision on the external
ped the distribution of the BN by performing BN oblique ridge and dividing the buccinators.
blockade in patients. This study showed that the To the authors’ knowledge, this is the first study us-
most anterior limit of the anesthesia on the lower ing intraoral dissection of the BN in fresh cadavers.
buccal gingivae was between the first molar and the Although the distribution of the BN is variable, in
second premolar teeth. Takezawa et al1 presented most specimens, the injection site for BN blockade
detailed anatomic dissection of Japanese embalmed was too far from the course of the BN. Therefore,
cadavers to show the distribution of the BN to the based on these findings, the authors recommend an in-
buccal gingiva, cheek, and lip. jection site 10 mm superolateral to point A as a real
The BN is often described as it penetrates the tempo- ‘‘BN blockade.’’ Moreover, illustrations in many books
ralis tendon. Merida-Velasco et al13 studied the relation depicting the BN incorrectly should be amended (Fig
between the temporalis tendon and BN during the pre- 4). Clinical studies are required to support the present
natal period. The origin and course of the BN were var- cadaveric findings.
iable; 49.4% (89 of 180) of BNs were located medial to
the temporalis tendon and 40.1% (73 of 180) penetrated Acknowledgments
the temporalis tendon. In the present study, the BN
The authors thank all those who donate their bodies and tissues
crossed anterior to the temporalis tendon on all sides. for the advancement of education and research.
The mean distance from point A to the BN on the
external oblique ridge was 13.05  2.49 mm on the
right side and 12.34  3.45 mm on the left side, with References
a wide range. To anesthetize the main trunk of the
BN, the aforementioned traditional BN blockade pro- 1. Takezawa K, Ghabriel M, Townsend G: The course and distribu-
tion of the buccal nerve: Clinical relevance in dentistry. AusT
cedure seems to be too low. This method can block Dent J 63:66, 2018
small branches to the gingivae of the lower molar 2. Standring S: Gray’s Anatomy E-Book: The Anatomical Basis of
but cannot block the main trunk of the BN. Takezawa Clinical Practice. London, UK, Elsevier Health Sciences, 2015
3. Netter FH: Atlas of Human Anatomy. London, UK, Elsevier
et al1 also was concerned that the block of the distal Health Sciences, 2018
part of the BN (not the main trunk) might not anesthe- 4. Norton NS: Netter’s Head and Neck Anatomy for Dentistry E-
tize the lower buccal mucosa of the molar area based Book. London, UK, Elsevier Health Sciences, 2016
5. Malamed SF: Handbook of Local Anesthesia—E-Book. London,
on their anatomic findings. As the present study and UK, Elsevier Health Sciences, 2014
the findings of Hendy et al11 showed, most BNs course 6. Iwanaga J, Simonds E, Oskouian RJ, Tubbs RS: Cadaveric study
much higher than the point that is currently used for for intraoral needle access to the infratemporal fossa: Applica-
tion to posterior superior alveolar nerve block technique. Cur-
the injection site of BN blockade. Therefore, based eus 9:e1761, 2017
on the present findings, for ideal BN blockade, the in- 7. Bassett KB, DiMarco AC, Naughton DK: Local Anesthesia for
jection site should be 10 mm superolateral to point A. Dental Professionals. Boston, MA, Pearson, 2015
8. Drum M, Reader A, Beck M: Long buccal nerve block injection
However, the current BN blockade site is still benefi- pain in patients with irreversible pulpitis. Oral Surg Oral Med
cial for vasoconstriction around the surgical field, Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 112:e51, 2011
especially for lower third molar removal. This site of 9. Aker FD: Blocking the buccal nerve using two methods of infe-
rior alveolar block injection. Clin Anat 14:111, 2001
injection could be referred to as an ‘‘infiltration’’ tech- 10. Wongsirichat N, Pairuchvej V, Arunakul S: Area extent anaes-
nique of the BN branch rather than a ‘‘blockade.’’ thesia from buccal nerve block. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg 40:
Merida-Velasco et al13 found that 1.7% (3 of 180) of 601, 2001
11. Hendy C, Smith K, Robinson P: Surgical anatomy of the buccal
BNs arose from the inferior alveolar nerve. Such an nerve. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 34:457, 1996
aberrant nerve could emerge from the retromolar fora- 12. Hendy CW, Robinson PP: The sensory distribution of the buccal
men located in the retromolar fossa of the mandible. In nerve. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 32:384, 1994
13. Merida-Velasco JR, Rodriguez-Vazquez JF, De La Cuadra C, et al:
adults, 8 to 40.4% of mandibles have a retromolar fora- The course of the buccal nerve: relationships with the tempora-
men that might contain a retromolar nerve.14-16 The lis muscle during the prenatal period. J Anat 198:423, 2001
retromolar nerve might innervate the lower buccal 14. Kikuta S, Iwanaga J, Nakamura K, et al: The retromolar canals
and foramina: Radiographic observation and application to
gingivae of the molar area. In a clinical setting, oral surgery. Surg Radiol Anat 40:647, 2018
Kikuta et al14 reported on a case of postoperative sen- 15. Truong MK, He P, Adeeb N, et al: Clinical anatomy and signifi-
sory paralysis of the lower buccal gingiva of the molar cance of the retromolar foramina and their canals: A literature
review. Cureus 9:e1781, 2017
area after the retromolar nerve was cut in a patient un- 16. Motamedi MH, Gharedaghi J, Mehralizadeh S, et al: Anthropo-
dergoing third molar extraction. Thus, the innervation morphic assessment of the retromolar foramen and retromolar
pattern of the BN is variable. In 1874, Panas17 reported nerve: anomaly or variation of normal anatomy? Int J Oral Max-
illofac Surg 45:241, 2016
on a case of buccal neuralgia treated with neurotomy 17. Panas: On section of the buccal nerve from the mouth. Edinb
(or neurectomy) with relief of symptoms. In this short Med J 20:82, 1874

You might also like