Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Marriage Dissolution Practices Laws and
Marriage Dissolution Practices Laws and
Islamic Teachings
Abstract
The institution of family occupies a highly important position in Islam. Besides
regulating human marital relations it plays a key role in the development and progression
of a well-entrenched social order. Unlike certain other religions, Islam however does not
regard marriage above dissolution and gives this right to both the spouses. It considers
this relationship a social contract between two independent and pubescent persons and
introduces checks and balances to protect and secure the rights of all stakeholders in this
matter - husband, wife, children and the society large.
Pakistan is a Muslim majority state with different laws in practice concurrently such as,
Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), Muslim Family Law Ordinance (MFLO), Hadood
Ordinances. In addition to some conflicts in implementation of different sets of laws,
ignorance of Islamic teachings, prevalent laws and local culture and traditions too play a
very significant role in the matters related to separation between couples in the society.
With this in the background, the present paper, discusses the marriage and its dissolution
in the light of Islamic teachings, contemporary practices and prevalent laws in Pakistan.
The paper also attempts to put spotlight on the issues emerging as a result of the conflict
between the three said factors and their impact upon the stability and integrity of the
institution of family. In the end recommendations are provided to remove discrepancies
between laws to bring the sufferings to a common person to a minimum.
9/18/2014 1
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
Islam treats marriage as a permanent institution with specific roles and responsibilities
assigned to each member of it. Islam disallows all forms of extra-marital relations, both
before and after marriage and declares them a culpable crime.5 In other words, its concept
of establishment and integrity of family is diametrically opposed to the viewpoint which
stands for sexual laxity in the garb of human rights such as reproductive rights,
legalization of abortion, prostitution and homosexuality, etc.
This also stands a unique feature of Islam that unlike certain other religions it does
not rule out the possibility of dissolution of marriage as a last resort between
estranged couples. Describing divorce as the most detestable act among the
permissible things,6 Islam gives both the partners the right to terminate it, though in
different ways and conducts under different circumstances and situations. In the
proceeding pages, we shall discuss termination of marriage issue in the light of
prevalent practices in the Pakistani society, country laws and the teachings of Islam.
2.1 National Laws
Establishment and dissolution of marriage take place under different laws and ordinances
issued at different occasions by different governments in Pakistan. Lack of awareness
regarding them often creates problems for couples entangled in different disputes,
restraining them on the other hand to struggle for their rights. With reference to
dissolution of marriage, following Family laws (FLs) are in practice in the country: 7
Guardian wards Act (GWA) 1890
Child Marriage Restraint Act (CMRA) 1929
Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act (DMMA) 1939
Muslim Family Laws Ordinance (MFLO) 1961
Muslim Family Law Rules (MFLR) 1961
Reconciliation Courts Ordinance (RCO) 1961
The West Pakistan Muslim Personal Law, Shariat Application Act
(WPMPLSAA) 1962
West Pakistan Family Courts Act (WPFCA) 1964
West Pakistan Family Courts Rules (WPFCR) 1965
Hadd-e-Qazaf Ordinance (HQO) 19798
Notwithstanding the fact that most of the articles and clauses of these laws are in
conformity with the teachings of Islam, there are also certain areas where the conflict
among these creates an awkward situation in particular for women.
5
AL Noor : 2
6
Abu Dawood, Al-Talaq chapter 131
7
Muhammad Aslam Hayat, Manual of Family Law,Khyber Laws Publishers, Lahore.
8
Law & Practice of Islamic Hadood, Emmanuel Zafar, Khyber Laws Publishers, Lr
9/18/2014 2
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
9
Al – Nisa : 129
10
Al Baqara 229
9/18/2014 3
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
divorcing her, it even allows a woman to remarry if her husband has gone missing11.
Similarly, in the case of eila, a husband cannot stay away from her wife for more than
four months,12 failing to revert during this period, results in one irrevocable divorce
(talaq-e-bain). Re-solemnization of marriage becomes inevitable to keep the marriage
bond intact.13
Prevalent family laws in Pakistan also do not approve of this kind of separation. For
instance, section 2 of DMMA 1939 says that a woman can annul her marriage on
thirteen grounds in addition to any other ground recognized by the Sharia. This
clearly implies that she can finish her marriage in the above mentioned situation.
Section 8 of MFLO also deals with means other than divorce, to dissolve a marriage,
where as it’s Section 6, declares striking second marriage without the prior permission of
first wife a crime punishable with imprisonment or fine or both. In such case this very
section implies payment of the entire dower, whether prompt or deferred to the existing
wife or wives. Present wife can also claim her maintenance if the husband wriggles out
of this responsibility. However if the wife herself opts to leave husband’s house the
maintenance is denied to her.
Thus, if looked into closely, one comes to the conclusion that notwithstanding clear
provisions of country laws and Islamic teachings, the prevalent practice survives.
Options for most of the women in such cases are quite limited and they are forced to
live with this trauma hoping that things take a positive turn one day.
3.2 Divorce
Divorcing wife is unfortunately seldom a smooth affair as it more often than not is given
in a mode of aggression, against the prescribed way of sunnah. Pronouncement of three
divorces in a breath is a common practice in the society In addition to character
assassination, women are denied their accommodation and maintenance rights during
iddat (waiting period). Because of the pronouncement of three divorces in a stretch, a
divorcee does not live in the house of her husband as is asked by the Quran if
divorced is pronounced during three separate sittings over a period of three months.
Withholding of dowry and other belongings of divorcee is also a common practice in the
society at such occasions. Custody and maintenance of children remain as two most
contentious issues between the separating couples, resulting to take the matter to court by
them respectively.
Islamic teachings on the other hand are quite different. In fact the Quranic
injunctions for talaq were set out to eliminate the exploitation of women kept in a fix,
confining them to permanent torture, even if the marriage was not working. The essence
It should always be a well thought out decision delivered in the period of tohar
of the Quranic orders in this regard can be briefed as follows:
11
Ashraf AliThanawi “Ahkam-e-Talaq o Nizam Sharai Adalat”p108, Al Faisal, Lahore
12
Al Baqara 226
13
Justice. Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, IRI. IIUI.
14
Sura Al Talaq : 1
9/18/2014 4
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
It should be pronounced in such a way to guard the iddat period, so that the
provision of rejoining can be utilized.15
The husband has the right of pronouncing talaq twice only, with iddat period in
between, and then either he has to rejoin or separate his wife with kindness.16
Wife should spend the iddat period in the case of revocable divorce with her
husband17 with a view that it might help them reconcile with each other
It is obligatory upon husband to provide maintenance and accommodation during
the iddat period.18
It is obligatory upon husband to provide maintenance to a pregnant or lactating
woman, till that period is over, both in the case of revocable or irrevocable
divorce19
Based upon Quranic teachings Prophet Mohammad (SAW) explained the procedure
and mode of divorce clearly. In the light of these guide lines Muslim jurists set out
the detailed rules for all matters related to divorce. Some of them are discused.as
follows:
Discussing the effects, any talaq given for the period during which the husband
can revert back to his wife even without her consent, is called talaq-e-rujaee.
After one or two pronouncements even if the iddat period expires the husband has
the option of taking her back by re solemnization, with the consent of the wife.
This type of divorce is called talaq-e-bain. Where as after three pronouncements
the divorce becomes final called talaq-e-mughalaza, excluding all possibilities of
rejoining between the couple, except with an extra ordinary condition of halala.
In the course of halala the divorcee woman, who remarries another man in a
regular manner with the solemn intention of living with him, but again
unfortunately separates from him due to his death or divorce, is allowed under
Islamic law to remarry her former husband.20 However the ugly custom of pre
planned halala is a mockery of the divine law and is cursed by Prophet
Mohammad (SAW).21 Caliph Omar and Abdullah bin Omar considered such
marriages as adultery.22
The best kind of sunnah way of divorce is talaq-e-ahsan, means pronouncement
of divorce once in tohar with no conjugal relations in that period, and then
waiting for the entire iddat period, completing the divorce. During the iddat
23
period the husband has the absolute right of ruju either through.
15
Sura Al Talaq : 1
16
AL Baqara : 229 , 231
17
sura Talaq 1
18
Al Talaq : 1
19
AL Talaq : 6
20
Al Baqara : 230
21
Tirmizi,Book of Nikah,894/ Ibn-e-Maja,Book of Nikah,1572
22
Ibn-e-Abi Shaiba, 4 / 294 / Safia Iqbal, “Woman and Islamic Law”p 202, Islamic Publications. Lr.
23
Abdul Jalil Qasmi, Islam ka mukammal nizam-e-Talaq”p34,Tayyab Acadmy,Multan
9/18/2014 5
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
Jurist call the second kind of sunnah way of divorce as talaq-e-hasan, meaning
pronouncing divorce three times with a gap of one tohar period of women,
between each pronouncement,24 so that each party could have ample time at its
disposal to review and re examine its standpoint regarding the dispute between
them.
Three divorces pronounced in a stretch against the sunnah way has been termed
as talaq-e-biddat, by the Muslim jurists. With reference to the effectiveness of
three divorces at once, two opinions among Muslim jurists prevail. One is
considering such divorce as one pronoucement and the other as three.and final
called talaq-e-mughalaza.25 It is however unanimously agreed upon that such
divorce is against suunah and highly disliked. Once Prophet Mohammad (SAW)
was informed that a man had pronounced a triple divorce on his wife, he rose in
anger and said, “Is the book of Allah being played with although I am still present
among you26
Dower has to be paid to the divorcee if it is not already paid. It may involve
following situations27: she would get full dower if it was fixed and the two had
conjugal relations; it will be on the basis of precedence in the family if not fixed
but conjugation has occurred; it will be half if fixed but there was no conjugal act;
some gifts will be given if there was neither fixed dower nor conjugal relationship
Wife will have a right on her belongings. Same will be the case with the things
given to her by her husband28
God fearing people are asked to give muta-e-talaq (parting gift) to their ex-wives
at such occasions according to their own financial status.29
Iddat period for pregnant, non-pregnant and above fertility age woman is
different. For the last two it is three months30 but for the first one till the birth of
the child31. There is no waiting period for a woman who had no conjugal
relations with her ex-husband32
In case of separation, mother has the right of the custody of child 33while husband
is under obligation to provide maintenance to the child/children.34
24
Ibid p36,
25
Salahuddin Yusuf. Aurtun kay imtiazi masail o qawaneen. Pp 185 to 189, Darussalam, Pak.…
26
Sunan Nisai, Al Talaq,hadith no. 3430.
27
Syed Jalal ad din Omari, “Musalman aurat ke haqooq aur un per aitrazat ka jaiza”pp123,124.al Faisal
Lahore
28
Al Baqara : 229
29
Al Baqara : 241, 236
30
All Baqara : 228
31
Al Talaq : 4
32
Al Ahzab : 49
33
Abu Daud lil AlbaniHadith 1991 / Hidaya, p, 138.
34
Al Talaq :6
9/18/2014 6
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
35
Al Baqara : 229
36
In the present district Govts. System, Nazim of every union council has been given the additional powers
of Chairman Arbitration Council.
9/18/2014 7
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
37
Al Baqara 228
38
Allah Dad vs Mukhtar 1992 SCMR 1273
39
Al Ahzab : 49
40
Syed amir Ali, Qanoon Sharah Mohammadi, p93,nazir sons publishers Lahore
41
Sir Dinshah Fardunji, Mullas Muhammadan Law 2003,p398,Mansoor Book House Lr.
9/18/2014 8
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
separation reaching out at a mutual transaction.42 This divinely granted right of khula is
expressly stated in the Quran as follows;
“If you, (judge) do indeed fear that they would be unable to keep the limit ordained by
Allah, there is no blame on either of them if she gives something for her freedom. These
are the limits ordained by Allah, so do not transgress them.”43
There is a consensus among jurists that it is unjust44 for a husband to receive something
from her wife if he is oppress ant. However, if a woman is guilty and seeking divorce,
the husband can receive something from her which should not be more than he had given
her or was supposed to give her as the dower.45
Effect of dissolution of marriage through Khula is like talaq-e-bain following it the two
cannot rejoin each other without a fresh solemnization of marriage. 46 The jurists of four
top sects in the Muslim world hold that Khula can be decided at bilateral level but to
some it can only be obtained through a competent court47. Iddat period after khula is one
menstrual cycle as described by Prophet Mohammad (SAW) and his companions.48
Using the right of khula without reasonable and logical grounds is disapproved in Islam
as according to a saying of prophet Mohammad (SAW) such women will not be able to
get even the fragrance of Jannah.49
Family laws of Pakistan are very clear about this issue and it is dealt with under
Section 8 of the MFLO. Khula comes into effect by an offer from the wife to
compensate the husband, to release her from marital rights. With mutual consent she can
get released through talaq-e-mubarat.50 In the light of a judgment of court, production of
evidence by a woman is not necessary to establish that she cannot live with her husband
anymore51. Effect of Khula is talaq-e-bain, following the two can join only after re-
solemnization of marriage.
Thus, the fact of the matter remains that this right is seldom exercised by a woman
out of court and in many cases she has to surrender not only the gifts given to her by
her husband but also the belongings and property gifted to her by her parents to
avoid court litigations and character assassination.
42
Ibid
43
Al Baqara :229
44
Justice. Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2,. IRI. IIUI.
45
Justice Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, pp574,575. IRI. IIUI.
46
Mohammad Taqi Usmani,Fiqhi Maqalat,vol.2 pp141,142.Memon Islam Publisher Al Faisal, Lahore.
47
Mohammad Taqi Usmani,Fiqhi Maqalat,vol.2 ps140.Memon Islam Publisher Al Faisal, Lahore.
48
Justice. Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, pp599,. IRI. IIUI.
49
Tirmizi, Book of Talaq,1187,/ Abu Daud,Book of Talaq, 1947
50
PLD 1969 Lah.
51
1991 CLC Note 284
9/18/2014 9
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
Muslim jurists believe that a judge under certain circumstances can terminate a marriage
even without the consent of a husband. For instance, husband has gone missing, lost
sanity, not paying maintenance rights or is impotent. Similarly, if he is unwilling to fulfill
marital obligations, the court can intervene and, despite his unwillingness, can separate
him from his wife52. The effect of dissolution of marriage through court is like talaq-e-
bain i.e the two can always rejoin by fresh solemnization of marriage.
DMMA 1939, section 2 provides a woman the right to terminate her marriage if her
husband:
is missing,
has failed to provide maintenance,
is sentenced to imprisonment for seven years,
has failed to perform marital obligations,
is impotent,
is insane,
is suffering from leprosy or venereal disease,
is cruel,
is associated with women of evil repute,
attempts to force her to lead an immoral life,
disposes off her property,
obstructs her from religious practice,
She can also dissolve the marriage on the basis of option of puberty and any other ground
recognized by shariat law, under the section mentioned above. As discussed above, the
issue has been under discussion in different circles since long and was consequently
duly taken up by MFLO under Section 8. That said, it needs to be underlined that
approaching judiciary by a woman for the dissolution of her marriage is granted
both in Islam and the country laws. The society however does not approve of it
while litigations at courts also make it a rarely availed option for women.
52
Abdul Jalil Qasmi, Islam ka mukammal nizam-e-Talaq”pp209,210,Tayyab Acadmy,Multan
9/18/2014 10
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
53
Justice. Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, pp392,393,. IRI. IIUI.
54
Al Noor :6,7
55
Al Noor : 8
56
Justice. Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, p735, IRI. IIUI.
57
Justice. Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, p737, IRI. IIUI.
9/18/2014 11
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
58
Js. Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, p739, IRI. IIUI.
59
Sir Dinshah Fardunji, Mullas Muhammadan Law 2003,p414,Mansoor Book House Lr.
60
AL Baqara :226
61
Jsustice Tanzil-ur-Rahman, “ Majmooa Qawaneen-e-Islam”, vol.2, IRI. IIUI.
9/18/2014 12
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
In shot, there can be certain cases of this practice but they seldom come to the fore
as people mostly avoid discussing such matters in public.
3.8 Khiar-e-baloogh (Option at Puberty)
62
Sadrudin Islahi,Islam mein nikah ke qawaneen,pp63,64.Islamic Publications Lr.
9/18/2014 13
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
63
Al Baqara 228
64
Al Baqara : 229, Al Talaq : 4, Al Ahzab : 49
65
Al Talaq : 6
9/18/2014 14
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
66
Report of the Inquiry Commission for women 1994,published 1997,pp37,
67
safia Iqbal, Women and Islamic Law,p217,Islamic publications.
68
Syed Jalal ad din Omari, “Musalman aurat ke haqooq aur un per aitrazat ka jaiza”pp119,120.al Faisal
Lahore
69
Hidaya p 138
70
Ibid
71
Safia Iqbal, Women and Islamic Law,p207,Islamic publications.Lr.
9/18/2014 15
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
(not a relative), her right to hizanat is lost72 but recovered again if the marriage is
dissolved.73
A father can have his children after the lapse of hizanat period since by that time the
child can live an independent life with the help of his father. According to Hanafi school
of thought, after 7 years of age the hizanat period of a male child lapses, however he can
opt to live with any of his parents out of his free will once he is pubescent74. At this point
obligation upon his father to provide his maintenance is over which can be continued out
of his own choice75, though, he can necessarily keep him in his custody for the
supervision and training requirements of the child.76 Similarly, a mother is free to take
her child in her custody or refuse to do so77.
There are two worth noting points behind the transfer of the custody of child to father
once the hizanat period is over.
Being an earner, a father can better support his children to pursue his/her
education and life career at this age.
Possession of children on permanent basis minimizes the prospects of second
marriage for a divorced mother. It is a kind of injustice to her in that case.
Furthermore, jurists unanimously agree that either the father or mother cannot keep
the children beyond the access of the other78
The hearing of child custody cases is the sole prerogative of district level FCs under
WPFLR 1964 and GWA Act 1890. A district judge can hear such a case himself or
transfer it to a court situated in the area where the appellant woman comes from.
In short, this is among the most contentious issues between parting couples and both
religious teachings and country laws are blatantly violated for personal ends. Court
litigations further aggravate the situation.
3.14 Maintenance Rights of Children
The prevalent practice that a father refuses to comply the maintenance rights of his
children if they are in the custody of a divorced mother. In such situation, the mother
experiences heterogeneous problems to make both ends meet. Islam on the other hand
makes it incumbent upon a father to provide maintenance to his children either parents
are living together or separated through any means. Maintenance rights of an expecting
divorcee, lactating mother after divorce & maintenance of children during hizanat period,
discussed earlier, clearly support this claim.
72
Abu Daud book of talaq, 1991
73
Safia Iqbal, Women and Islamic Law,p207,Islamic publications.Lr.
74
Fatawa Mufti Sayah ud din Kaka Khail,Tafheem ul Ahkam,vol. 1,pp319, Maarif-e-Islami Lr.
75
Ibid
76
Ibid
77
Safia Iqbal, Women and Islamic Law,p209,Islamic publications.Lr.
78
Muslim, chapter Al bir wa sila,2555
9/18/2014 16
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
Noteably, Section 9 of MFLO in the same vein makes it an obligation upon a father to
provide maintenance to his child if he/she is in the custody of his ex-wife. In the case of
a male child, father is responsible till his pubescence, while in the case of girl till her
marriage. If denied, FCs can force him to provide maintenance to his child including his
education expenses, with no consideration to the present financial status of his ex-wife.
However, if the male child prefers to live with his mother even after puberty, the law in
that case is silent about his maintenance rights from his father.
3.15 Issues Related to Mehar (Dower)
The payment of dower is considered to be linked with divorce and very few people pay it
at the occasion of solemnization of marriage or afterwards. In some cases it is fixed
heavily as a deterrent to divorce instead of a right of the wife ensured. On the other hand,
a meager amount is settled as sharai mehar, misunderstanding the Islamic Law. Such
practices cause hurdles in the smooth termination of marriage and a woman in many
cases has to approach courts for Khula.
It should not be over looked that It is an obligation upon a husband to pay mehar to
his wife 79unless she willingly forgoes it80. No amount of mehar is fixed in
sharia,81but the best according to a hadith is the one which is easily paid.82 Mehar
has to be paid to the divorcee if it is not already paid. It may involve following
situations: she would get full mehar if it was fixed and the two had conjugal relations;
it will be on the basis of precedence in the family if not fixed but conjugation has
occurred; it will be half if fixed but there was no conjugal act; some gifts will be
given if there was neither fixed dower nor conjugal relationship83
Payment of mehar is so important that even if a man passes away without doing so, it
is obligatory upon his heirs to pay it to the wife.84. Similarly, if the wife dies, her
heirs can make demand for it.85
Section 10 of MFLO states that in case the mode of payment of dower is not defined at
the occasion of marriage, the full amount of dower shall be payable on demand at the
time of divorce.
The point however remains that the payment of dower at the occasion of marriage is
not so common for various reasons. As a matter of fact, it also causes a delay in the
amicable separation between estranged couples, both at bilateral as well as judicial
level.
79
Al Nisa : 4, 24, Al Ahzab : 50.
80
Al Nisa : 4
81
Bukhari, Book of Nikah / Muslim, Book of Nikah.
82
Abu Daud, Book of Nikah, 1859
83
Syed Jalal ad din Omari, “Musalman aurat ke haqooq aur un per aitrazat ka jaiza”pp123,124.al Faisal
Lahore
84
Abu Daud,Book of Nikah, 1859/Tirmizi, 1145.
85
Women Aid Trust, Wirasat ki taqseem, kia, kyoon aur kaise? P, 24.
9/18/2014 17
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
9/18/2014 18
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
husband who implicates them in adultery cases under HZO 1979. As stated earlier the
decision of SABSC used as authoritative precedence 91has eased the suffering
In short, in an utter disregard to the Islamic teachings the society does not
encourage the remarriage of a divorcee. Conflict in different country laws also
contributes to aggravate the situation.
4 Recommendations
Importance of the institution of family as the foundation stone of Pakistani society
cannot be denied for obvious reasons. It is also a fact that family laws, with
certain exceptions, as practiced in Pakistani society are in line with the teachings
of Islam and provide a good mechanism for the amicable separation between
estranged couples. Therefore, a close look at the issue reveals that while certain
improvements in the family laws aside, the nub of the problem is not the existing
laws but the failure to implement them in letter and spirit. Similarly, it also stands
as a sad reality that awareness about true Islamic teachings vis-à-vis prevalent
practices also makes the situation problematic for a common person. Last but not
the least, due importance has not been given to the issue and scientific analysis
based on relevant data and statistics regarding the reasons and causes behind such
cases in the society is missing. Statistics regarding provision of mehar,
maintenance and accommodation during the idatt period specially pose a big
challenge in this regard.
Considering all this the following recommendations are made to improve the situation:
Improving Laws
A fine balance should be maintained between legal experts and religious scholars
in the constitution of different committees and commissions formed for the
appraisal of laws.
The state should ensure to remove flaws in FLs in keeping with the teachings of
Islam but should avoid unnecessary intervention in family code, just as it was
recommended in the report 1997 of IQW 1994, to incorporate the FLs of the
United Nations and other countries in Pakistan’s FLs. FLs practiced in other
Muslim countries be examined from the point of view of shariah and benefited
from.
In addition to delegated right of divorce (point 18), some other points can also be
added for the attention of groom and his family in the marriage certificate i.e.,
provision of maintenance during iddat period in case of divorce, payment of
mehar and division of property made during this relationship, possession right of
wife on the things bought or earned by her during marriage period. It should be
properly made known through media. One can find a precedence of it in a 12-
point marriage certificate practiced in Iran
91
Allah Dad vs Mukhtar 1992 SCMR 1273
9/18/2014 19
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
. The preventive action that can be adopted in the spreading epidemic of mindless
triple divorces is to attach a harsh penalty, under tazeer. In the era of caliph Umar
(may Allah be pleased with him).such a person was ordered to be flogged.
Punishment should be fixed for non-payment of mehar and maintenance as well.
Registration of divorce and its effectiveness and the role of AC under MFLO be
made compatible with the teachings of Islam. To this end following steps should
be taken:
o The validity of divorce be not linked with the registration of divorce. The
ordinance itself does not link validity of nikah with the registration of
marriage. As stated earlier the decision of the SABSC in this regard has
maintained this.
o Easy ways should be found out for registration of divorce such as registration
of it at ward level with nikah registrar. Similarly, both husband and wife
should be entitled to register it. Under MFLO presently the husband can file
the divorce notice only, and if the wife verbally or in writing receives divorce
directly from her husband, she cannot report it to the CAC.
o AC be established at UC level to mediate before the pronouncement of
divorce, instead afterwards to remove all sort of discrepancies regarding iddat
period, revocable state of divorce and others.
Alike to solemnization ceremony, presence of two witnesses be made compulsory
at the time of the pronouncement of divorce also. It can be deducted from the
verse 2 of sura Talaq which says:
“And take for witness two persons from among you, endued with justice, and
establish the evidence (as) before Allah, such is the admonition given to him who
believes in Allah and the last day. And for those who fear Allah, He (ever) prepares a
way out”
Deriving a principle from this verse some jurists declare presence of two
witnesses compulsory, both at the time of pronouncement of divorce and at
revoking time. The four famous schools of thought however believe that it is not
an obligation but just a persuasion. Shia school of thought believes in the
presence of witnesses in the said case.
In case of failure to give divorce notice to CAC and to take permission for second
marriage, the complainant can only be the CAC and not the wife, except in Punjab
province after an amendment in law. Following the Punjab amendment of law
(MFLO) other provinces should also make such amendment.
Muta-e-talaq to the divorcee be ensured through legislation, which has been
established as a sign of piety for men.
Regarding the maintenance right of children, the father should be made
responsible till the completion of their education.
9/18/2014 20
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
Awareness campaign
A crash program to educate the masses in the basics of FLs, will help effectively.
People should be made to realize that the only correct pattern of every action is
the Quranic way set out by the Prophet Mohammad (SAW).
General awareness should be created in married people about their mutual rights
and responsibilities. There should be pre-marriage education of spouses through
different means such as curriculum and orientation courses. Specially created
institutions or institutions involved in training at different levels, should be used
to impart this orientation.
All important matters related to marriage and divorce should made part of the
syllabus starting from secondary level of education.
Masajid, madaris and educational institutions must play their due role as social
institutions to guide people in family issues on regular basis.
Nikah Nama should contain precise information on divorce procedure, issues of
iddat, and other related matters to educate both members of the contract. Bride
and bridegroom should be informed about FLs on the occasion of marriage.
Counseling institutions be established at different levels to help married people in
maintaining a smooth family life. Non-governmental organizations, district and
union counselors and people at large should be motivated to provide their services
in this regard. Elders and senior citizens be motivated and trained to provide
counseling and mediatory services to estranged couples at village and mohalla
level.
Information related to marriage, family life and divorce in the light of shariat
should be provided in the form of simple and uncomplicated way through
electronic and print media.
Orientation to Professionals
Lawyers, judges, parliamentarians and executioners of laws should be apprised of
national laws alongside the teachings of Islam.
Ulama and religious scholars must develop a good understanding of national laws
regarding family issues and help legislature to introduce laws in this regard.
ABREVIATIONS:
GWA Guardian wards Act 1890
9/18/2014 21
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
GLOSSARY OF TERMINOLOGIES:
Abu Daud
Aurat
Balooghat
9/18/2014 22
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
Bari
Bukhari
Caliph
Dower
Dowery
Eila
Hadd
Halala
Hanafi School of Thought
Hazrat
Hizanat
Iddat
Jannah
Jirga
Khiar-e-Baloog
Khula
Lia’an
Majmooa-e-Qawaneen
Mehar
Mohalla
Muslim
Muta-e-talaq
Muttaqeen
Nasab
Nazim
Nikah
Nikah Nama
Qawaneen
Shafi
Shariat
Sunan Nisai
9/18/2014 23
Dissolution of Marriage: Prevalent Practices and Laws vs. Islamic Teachings
Sunnah
Talaq
Talaq-e-Ahsan
Talaq-e-Bain
Talaq-e-Bidat
Talaq-e-Hasan
Talaq-e-Mubarat
Talaq-e-Muggaliza
Talaq-e-Raj’ae
Tazeer
Tirmizi
Tohar
Ulama
9/18/2014 24