Blanca García Fuente

uo277840@uniovi.es
Workplace diversity & job satisfaction
Exploring their relationship and its implications for organizations

Workplace diversity is an increasingly important issue in modern organizations, and its

importance is growing as the workforce becomes more diverse. Diversity can include a
range of factors such as age, gender, race, ethnicity, culture, religion, and sexual
orientation, among others. Exploring the relationship between workplace diversity and
job satisfaction seems crucial as organizations seek to increase employee well-being,
engagement, and productivity. Promoting workplace diversity and inclusivity is not only
morally and ethically justifiable, but also makes good business sense by improving job
satisfaction, enhancing employee well-being, and boosting organizational performance.

1 Introduction

This essay explores the existing relationship between workplace diversity and job
satisfaction and how this can affect organizations, reviewing a variety of literature on the
topic. The theoretical foundations of workplace diversity and job satisfaction are
reviewed in Section 2. Section 3 explores in depth this link, its positive impacts, and the
role of inclusion regarding the posed research question, emphasizing how diversity can
both help a team's ability to perform effectively. In particular, Section 4 provides the
organizational perspective on this topic, looking at the main drivers for enterprises to take
action on diversity and inclusion and analyzing the outcomes and possible challenges
when managing diversity.

2 Main concepts: Workplace diversity and job satisfaction

2.1 Workplace diversity: definition and benefits

Diversity in the workplace refers to the presence of individuals with diverse backgrounds,
perspectives, and experiences. It includes, but is not limited to, factors such as age,
gender, race, ethnicity, culture, religion, and sexual orientation. Diversity in the
workplace is essential for many reasons. First, it can increase creativity and innovation
by bringing together individuals with diverse viewpoints and concepts. It can also

1
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
improve problem-solving skills by providing access to a broader spectrum of skills and
knowledge. According to research by Reynolds and Lewis (2017), diverse teams with a
wider range of viewpoints are more likely to analyse material thoroughly and accurately.
They are more likely to be inventive and solve issues more quickly.

Additionally, diversity can expand market reach by enabling businesses to better

comprehend and accommodate diverse consumer requirements. It can also improve
decision-making by promoting diverse perspectives and decreasing the risk of
groupthink. Lastly, it can increase employee retention by fostering a more inclusive and
supportive workplace culture.

Diversity in the workplace has been shown to have a positive effect on organizational
performance. A 2020 McKinsey & Company study, for instance, found that companies
with more diverse executive teams are more likely to outperform their competitors. The
study also discovered that diverse companies are better able to innovate and attract top
talent. Therefore, promoting diversity in the workplace can result in numerous benefits
for businesses.

2.2 Job satisfaction: definition and affecting factors

Job satisfaction refers to the extent to which individuals feel fulfilled and content with
their employment. It is a complex entity that can be affected by a variety of variables.
Fair treatment, positive work relationships, opportunities for career advancement,
effective communication, and flexible work arrangements are some of the main factors
that can influence job satisfaction.

The perception that individuals are treated fairly and with respect in the workplace is
referred to as fair treatment. This may involve pay, promotions, and access to training and
development opportunities. Positive work relationships refer to the character of the
connections between employees and their coworkers, supervisors, and other stakeholders.
Opportunity for career growth refers to the extent to which individuals believe they have
the chance to advance their careers and develop their abilities. Good communication is
the quality of interaction between employees and their coworkers, supervisors, and other

2
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
constituents. Lastly, flexible work arrangements refer to the ability to work flexible hours,
work from home, or otherwise adjust work arrangements to suit the needs and preferences
of an individual (Robbins and Judge, 2013).. When scrutinizing the connection between
workplace diversity and job satisfaction, it is crucial to consider the previously mentioned
factors.

3 The Link Between Workplace Diversity and Job Satisfaction

Diversity in the workplace has been found to have several benefits, including improved
organisational performance, higher problem-solving abilities, extended market reach, and
better decision-making. It has also been discovered that diverse teams lead to better
results, stimulate innovation and creativity, and improve organisational culture (Jackson
& Ruderman, 1995). These benefits can be attributed to the fact that diverse teams are
composed of individuals from a variety of backgrounds. But how exactly does diversity
in the workplace affect job satisfaction?

There has been a significant amount of research in literature into the relationship between
diversity in the workplace and overall job satisfaction. In this section, some of the most
important discoveries that emerged from the research conducted on this subject will be
discussed.

3.1 The Positive Impact of Diversity on Job Satisfaction

Multiple studies have found that diversity in the workplace has a positive effect on job
satisfaction. It has been found that diverse teams are more likely to attain success than
homogeneous teams (Jehn, Northcraft, and Neale, 1999). This is due to the fact that
diverse teams bring together a diversity of perspectives, experiences, and skills that
enable them to generate more innovative solutions to problems. By contributing to a more
likely-to-be-successful team project, employees can feel more engaged and satisfied with
their work when they are part of a diverse team.

Personal growth and development opportunities may also contribute to the positive
relationship between workplace diversity and job satisfaction. When employees are

3
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
exposed to diverse perspectives and ideas, they are more likely to acquire new skills and
knowledge, which can improve their job performance and career opportunities (Williams
and O'Reilly, 1998). This can result in increased job satisfaction and a sense of
accomplishment.

In addition to having a direct effect on employee well-being, employment satisfaction can

also have significant effects on organisational outcomes. Research has demonstrated, for
instance, that job satisfaction is positively associated with employee engagement,
performance, and retention. In addition, job satisfaction can have an effect on customer
satisfaction and organisational performance as a whole (Robbins and Judge, 2013).

As previously stated in this essay, employees from diverse backgrounds and viewpoints
can bring new ideas and perspectives to the table, resulting in new approaches and
solutions to problems. This can create a stimulating work environment in which
employees feel challenged and engaged, contributing to greater job satisfaction and
performance (Jackson & Ruderman, 1995). When employees perceive that their
organisation values diversity and is committed to establishing an inclusive workplace, for
instance, they may feel more engaged and committed to their work.

Moreover, diversity in the workplace can foster a higher sense of connection among
employees. When employees believe their employer values and respects their cultural
origin and unique experiences, they are more likely to feel a sense of belonging and
attachment to the organisation. This can lead to an increase organisational commitment
and job satisfaction because employees will feel valued and respected for their individual
contributions. Additionally, a culture of diversity and inclusion can aid in attracting and
retaining a diverse workforce, thereby enhancing organisational performance (Andersen
and Kennedy 2018).

In addition, workplace diversity can help reduce discrimination and bias, leading to a
more positive working environment. Employees are less likely to experience
discrimination or prejudice based on their race, gender, ethnicity, or other personal
characteristics when they believe their organisation values diversity and is committed to
creating an inclusive workplace.

4
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es

In conclusion, workplace diversity can significantly influence job satisfaction. When

employees perceive that their organisation values diversity and is committed to creating
an inclusive work environment, they are more likely to experience greater job satisfaction
due to increased creativity and innovation, a greater sense of belonging, increased
learning and development opportunities, and decreased discrimination and bias.

3.2 The Role of Inclusion in the Relationship Between Diversity and Job
Satisfaction

Research indicates that diversity in the workplace may have a beneficial effect on job
satisfaction; however, it is essential to keep in mind that this link is mediated by the degree
to which individuals are included within the organization (ILO, 2022). To put it another
way, it is not sufficient to merely have a diverse workforce; rather, it is essential to
promote an inclusive workplace in which workers have the chance to feel valued and
supported, regardless of the demographic characteristics.

It can be difficult and confusing to understand and evaluate inclusion. The degree to
which an employee feels included depends on her or his own thoughts and actions, those
of those around them, and the environment in which she or they operate. Consequently,
it is a dynamic experience that is never static. However, it's crucial to comprehend and
assess inclusion. While an organisation may be successful in attracting and hiring a
diverse mix of employees, inclusion affects how long these employees are retained, how
well they can thrive, and how much they can contribute. Measuring inclusion enables
businesses to pinpoint the steps they may take to further enhance diversity in the
workplace (ILO, 2022).

According to the outcomes of different studies, one of the most significant indicators of
an employee's level of job satisfaction is whether or not they view their workplace as
being inclusive. As an illustration, Harrison et al. (1998) discovered that workgroups that
had high levels of surface-level variety (such as demographic features) but low levels of
deep-level diversity (such as values and beliefs) reported lower levels of cohesion and job
satisfaction. This was the case even if the workgroups had high levels of overall diversity.

5
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es

Additionally, there are several benefits of full inclusion for the workplace. One of them
would be an increase in commitment, according to research by the multinational
consultancy McKinsey & Company (2020). Employees who feel very included are nearly
three times more likely than their peers to feel devoted to their organisations and more
likely to pursue career advancement and promotion.

Another effect of inclusivity for enterprises could be a rise in productivity, as the

productivity of the entire workforce has frequently been observed to increase in
workplaces that are more inclusive of people with disabilities (Andersen and Kennedy
2018).

There are also several effects of inclusion on personal well-being, according to Lorenzo
et al. (2017), people report feeling more trusted, engaged, and collaborative with
coworkers when they feel included at work. Numerous studies show that inclusive
workplaces not only promote higher levels of employee well-being, but also that inclusive
employees are more well-rounded (Culture Plus Consulting, 2018). Stress brought on by
encounters with bias, harassment, and discrimination is decreased by inclusion. Through
the experience of social connection and belonging with others at work and in an
environment that is aware of and supportive of individual needs, whether they are linked
to health, disability, religion, family or caring responsibilities, it promotes high self-
esteem and a positive sense of self.

This sense of belonging experienced by workers is one of the many reasons why inclusion
plays such an essential role in the relationship between workplace and job satisfaction.
An employee's likelihood of experiencing job satisfaction increases when they believe
they are a valued member of a community and that their individual contributions are
recognised and appreciated (Akafo and Agyekum Boateng, 2015). In addition, inclusion
has the potential to help eliminate instances of discrimination and bias in the workplace,
leading to a working climate that is more upbeat and encouraging for all employees.

6
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
4 Organizational perspective

4.1 Drivers and approaches to diversity and inclusion

According to a survey by the ILO on Diversity and Inclusion, covering 75 countries and
12,087 responses, the main drivers for business to take action on this matter in to comply
with legal obligations, followed by improving the well-being of employees and attracting,
developing and retaining the best talent as the second and third most common reasons.

Complying with legal obligations is a crucial driver for promoting diversity and inclusion
in the workplace. Equal employment opportunities must be provided to all people,
regardless of their gender, race, ethnicity, religion, or other traits, according to laws and
regulations in many different nations. Businesses can avoid legal repercussions, such as
fines or litigation, and enhance their reputation as ethical employers by adhering to certain
regulatory requirements. However, to develop a truly inclusive company culture, one
must go beyond simply taking into account the demographic factors. Enterprises must
build complete diversity and inclusion efforts that take into account the needs and goals
of their workforce in addition to merely adhering to the law.

Improving the well-being of employees is another key driver for promoting diversity and
inclusion in the workplace. A friendly and supportive work environment may be produced
through a diverse and inclusive workplace culture, which can enhance employees' job
satisfaction and general well-being. Businesses may support staff members in feeling
valued and appreciated, regardless of their origin or identity, by developing a culture of
respect and appreciation for diversity. Increased employee engagement and productivity
as well as decreased absenteeism and turnover rates may result from this.

Attracting, developing, and retaining the best talent is the third most common driver for
promoting diversity and inclusion in the workplace. A varied workforce can provide
unique viewpoints and concepts that can spur innovation and development. Employers
may access a larger pool of knowledge and experience by luring diverse personnel, which
can increase their competitiveness on the job market. Businesses may gain from the

7
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
distinctive views and ideas of employees from various origins and identities by cultivating
and keeping a diverse talent pool.

It is important to remember that these factors are connected and can complement one
another. Businesses may, for instance, enhance employee wellbeing by fostering diversity
and inclusiveness, which can help them draw in and keep the greatest talent. Businesses
may foster a work environment that recognizes and respects diversity by adhering to
regulatory requirements and implementing complete diversity and inclusion efforts. This
can result in a staff that is more engaged and productive.

In conclusion, the key drivers for promoting diversity and inclusion in the workplace, as
identified by the ILO survey are complying with legal obligations, improving the well-
being of employees, and attracting, developing, and retaining the best talent. Businesses
may gain from a more engaged and productive staff, increased competitiveness in the
labour market, and a better image as ethical employers if they put their focus not only on
the legal aspect, but on the personal side as well and develop comprehensive diversity
and inclusion strategies.

4.2 Challenges of Managing Diversity

Dealing with the cultural gaps present in a diverse workforce is one of the most difficult
aspects of managing diversity. Differences in cultural backgrounds can result in
misconceptions and communication difficulties in the workplace, both of which can
contribute to increased conflict and lower levels of productivity (Hauret,and Williams,
2020). Having to contend with unconscious bias is another another obstacle. The term
"unconscious bias" refers to the tendency to form judgements about other people based
on preconceived notions and assumptions rather than facts. Unconscious bias can result
in discrimination in the workplace, which can contribute to an unwelcoming environment
for workers and a decrease in job satisfaction. (Robbins and Judge, 2013)

In addition, managing diversity can be difficult since it demands organisations to adopt

policies and practises that are welcoming to all employees, regardless of where they come
from. This may require making adjustments to the procedures for recruitment and hiring,
as well as the training programmes and the culture of the workplace. Creating and putting

8
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
these policies and practises into effect can take a large amount of time and need a
substantial amount of resources.

4.3 Strategies for Promoting Diversity and Inclusion

There are many obstacles that come along with managing diversity, but there are also
many different techniques that organisations may use to encourage diversity and
inclusion. Developing a culture that welcomes people of many backgrounds and identities
is one of the most effective techniques. This entails cultivating an environment in which
respect and gratitude are shown to all staff members, irrespective of their individual
histories. Organisations can accomplish this goal through giving training on diversity,
fostering open communication, and celebrating difference through the organisation of
cultural events and activities.

Developing policies and practises that are inclusive of all employees is yet another
technique that can be utilised to promote diversity and inclusion in the workplace. This
can involve creating flexible work arrangements, offering accommodations for
employees with disabilities, and ensuring that recruitment and hiring practises are free
from bias. In addition, this can involve ensuring that recruitment and hiring practises are
free from discrimination.

In addition, organisations can foster diversity by making a concerted effort to find and
hire people from a wide range of backgrounds. This can entail reaching out to
communities of different backgrounds, forming partnerships with organisations that are
focused on diversity, and making an attempt to attract candidates from a broad pool.

Overall, it is essential for businesses to hold themselves accountable for the promotion of
inclusiveness and diversity in the workplace. This can include establishing diversity
goals, determining how well those goals are being met, and holding leaders and managers
accountable for developing and sustaining an inclusive culture in the workplace.

9
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
5 Conclusion

In conclusion, diversity in the workplace can offer various benefits, some of which
include improved innovation, higher job satisfaction, and increased organisational
effectiveness. Managing diversity, on the other hand, can provide a number of issues,
including the need to address cultural differences and unconscious bias. To actively seek
out different candidates and hold themselves accountable for promoting diversity and
inclusion, organisations can create a culture of inclusivity as a step towards achieving
their goal of encouraging diversity and inclusion. In addition, organisations can design
policies and practises that are inclusive of all employees. It is possible for companies to
develop a more welcoming and varied working environment for their staff members if
they take these steps.

10
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es
Bibliography

Andersen, Heather, and Patrick Kennedy. 2018. The Accessibility Advantage: Why
Businesses Should Care About Inclusive Design. Accenture.

Akafo, V., & Agyekum Boateng, P. (2015). Impact of reward and recognition on job
satisfaction and motivation - core. European Journal of Business and Management
https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/234626762.pdf

Cox, T. (1993). Cultural diversity in organizations: Theory, research, and practice.

Berrett-Koehler Publishers.

Culture Plus Consulting. 2018. “How does employee well-being link to diversity and
inclusion?” https://cultureplusconsulting.com/2018/08/17/ how-does-employee-well-
being-link-to-diversity-and-inclusion/

Hauret, L., & Williams, D. R. (2020). Workplace diversity and job satisfaction.
Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, 39(4), 336-352.

Harrison, D. A., Price, K. H., & Bell, M. P. (1998). Beyond relational demography:
Time and the effects of surface- and deep-level diversity on work group cohesion.
Academy of Management Journal, 41(1), 96-107.

International Labour Organization. (2022). Transforming enterprises through diversity

and inclusion. https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_dialogue/---
Jackson, S. E., & Ruderman, M. (1995). Diversity in work teams: Research paradigms
for a changing workplace. American Psychological Association.

Jehn, K. A., Northcraft, G. B., & Neale, M. A. (1999). Why differences make a
difference: A field study of diversity, conflict, and performance in workgroups.
Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(4), 741-763.
https://web.mit.edu/cortiz/www/Diversity/PDFs/Jehn%20et%20al%201999.pdf

Lorenzo, Rocío, Nicole Voigt, Karin Schetelig, Annika Zawadzki, Isabelle Welpe and
Prisca Brosi. 2017. “The Mix that Matters. Innovation Through Diversity.” Boston
Consulting Group. www.bcg.com/publications/2017/ people-organization-leadership-
talent-innovation-through-diversity-mix-that-matters

McKinsey & Company (2020). “Understanding organizational barriers to a more

inclusive workplace.” www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/people-and-
organizational-performance/ our-insights/understanding-organizational-barriers-to-a-
more-inclusive-workplace.

Reynolds, Alison, and David Lewis. 2017. “Teams Solve Problems Faster When
They’re More Cognitively Diverse.” Harvard Business Review.

Robbins, S. P., Judge, T. A., & Vohra, N. (2013). Organizational behavior. Pearson
Higher Education.
http://www.mim.ac.mw/books/Organizational%20Behavior%20(15e).pdf

11
Blanca García Fuente
uo277840@uniovi.es

Williams, K. Y., & O'Reilly, C. A. (1998). Demography and diversity in organizations:

A review of 40 years of research. Research in Organizational Behavior, 20, 77-140.

12