Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ijmet 09 07 035
Ijmet 09 07 035
Dr. Seethalakshmi R
Assistant Professor, Department of Commerce
Cauvery College for Women-Tiruchirapplai, Tamil Nadu, India
Dr. Sowdamini T
Assistant Professor, GITAM Institute of Management
Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh, India
ABSTRACT
Purpose- The purpose of this paper is to do a study of lean management tools and
practices in health carethrough a systematic literature review. The effective tools of
lean management such as six sigma, Lean strategy and other methods which improve
the quality in health care are identified through the review of literature.
Design/methodology/approach-Content Analysis is used to analyses the literature
collected from 50 articles from a reputed journal from 2012-2017, literature body is
followed by the pattern of content analysis, and the subcategories were formed to do a
typical research.
Findings-The result of lean implementation in the health care service has created
a positive impact for many health care issues like reducing the waiting time,
addressing the professionals jobs satisfaction and it has paved a way for an improved
quality service in health care through lean principals and tools.
Paper type: Literature review
Key words: Content analysis, lean tools and techniques,Lean safety, lean six sigma,
Lean quality improvement, Literature review.
Cite this Article: Vinodhini A, Dr. Seethalakshmi R and Dr. Sowdamini T, Analyzing
the Role of Lean Management in Health Care: A Systematic Literature Review,
International Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Technology 9(7), 2018, pp.
303–312.
http://iaeme.com/Home/issue/IJMET?Volume=9&Issue=7
1. INTRODUCTION
Lean is a set of operating philosophies, which was first invented by Womack, Jones and Roos
to define the Toyota Production system. Later Lean manufacturing practices were adopted by
many manufacturing industries to improve their product quality with a low cost and with
more flexibility which also improved their competitiveness in the market, with a long term
approach to improve the efficiency and quality which was possible only by implementing lean
practices as it works on a systematic manner by identifying and eliminating waste through the
concept of continuous improvement. After a continued success in the manufacturing sector,
lean has also been adopted by the health care sector as patient care looking for hassle free,
world-class healthcare services from Indian hospitals and at the same time India is emerging
as a preferred destination for Medical Tourism, which is opening a new growth opportunity
for Indian health care organizations. Implementation of Lean in healthcare will enhance the
confidence of domestic as well as foreign customers in the hospitals, which can assure world-
class healthcare quality at competitive cost. In India implementation of lean in health care is
less compared to other countries in the world. Since the last few years' cost of health care is
continuously rising along with increasing complexity and sophistication in clinical processes.
Due to increased sophistication in healthcare operations, it requires a large number of people
with special skills, expensive diagnostic machines and complex processes to enhance quality
and safety issues which can be addressed through the implementation of lean management.
The waiting time is a major problem faced by the patients in condition of sickness which can
be addressed by Lean. There are lean tools to overcome the waiting time problem. Now days
the healthcare sector is working under increasing pressure to deploy resources more
efficiently to reduce costs and improve service quality. The principles of Lean Thinking have
been developed to tackle such problems. Lean Thinking in health care is not just about cost
reduction, nor about 'efficiency' improvements or staff cuts. It is about improving the safety
and quality of healthcare by applying a series of continuous incremental improvements in
processes, people and organizational culture. Interest in applying lean thinking to healthcare
processes has grown across the world. Many hospitals have begun to see how lean processes
can deliver better quality outcomes, increased patient’s satisfaction and improved working
conditions for staff while treating a number of patients with the same resources. In a global
context, countries like Sweden, Japan, Canada, America, and Russia implemented lean in
healthcare and are very successful in the overview of value stream mapping; while the lean
management is implemented only in very few health care services in India.
Successful Lean health care efforts result in the measurable improvements in patient
outcomes, such as improved quality, less harm due to preventable errors, better access, shorter
waiting times, and better service. Implementing Lean management in health care has gained
an advantage in global health care. The researcher has done a detailed study of lean in the
health care industry through a systematic literature review.
3. METHODOLOGY
Qualitative Study Content Analysis Conceptual Content Analysis
Inductive Method
practitioners
Charles R et.al, (2015) American Journal of Business To examine how
initiatives mediate the effect
of medical error sources to
enhance three hospital
outcomes
Deepak et.al, (2016) Implementing Six Sigma
combined with lean can help
the hospital to deliver world-
class quality care and
simultaneously bring down the co st
Sub Field 2 : Lean Tools and Practices
Pernilla Lindskog et.al, (2015) The study expands upon
lean tools and innovations enabling
job resources
Horaciosorianomeier et.al, (2011) International Journal of Lean Six Impact of layout configuration
Sigma in a hospital on implementation
of lean management
Bryanmaltosh et.al, (2014) International Journal of Health Care Implementation of practices
Quality Assurance imported from manufacturing into
health care as a solution to rise in
health spending and disappointing
patient staffing indicators
Pauline Hwang et.al, (2014) International Journal of Health Care Health care providers are
Quality Assurance implementing lean practices
to achieve results to present
a model that identifies and
defines lean implementation
key success factors in health
care organization
Oscar Roemeling et.al, (2017) International Journal of Operation The role that employees
and Production Management initiate lean improvement
project play in health care
Mialjungblom (2014) International Journal of Quality and To research the practices of
Service Science ethics in Swedish health care
Maltloubhussain Malik (2016) Journal of Health Organization and To manage health care waste in
Management public and private hospitals
Tapanijorma et.al, (2016) Leadership in health services To evaluate lean thinking used in
health care in the environment of
finish health care
Yashdaultani et.al, (2016) Implementing lean in different
departments of health care
organization with various lean tools
Sarellavy et.al, To overcome the unfavorable
conditions of the hospital staffs and
patients in construction of
health care organizations
Gabriela Souza Assis et.al, (2016) Business process management Focuses on complex and
difficulties in health care, to
analyses the study of promotion in
BPM lean in health care
Gustaf Kastberg et.al, (2017) Qualitative research in accounting The study is to expand our
and management understanding of process
oriented of HC organization in
the shape of Lean management &to
investigation what measures a
taken to reframe the HC
organization.
Beata Kollberg et.al, (2014) International journal of productivity To discuss how a performance
and performance management measure system called
4. FINDINGS
Content analysis is an effective tool for conducting a literature review in a transparent way.
The research focuses on many problems faced in health care in improving the quality and the
efficiency, the researcher found the following results of lean six sigma which is implemented
in many countries like UK, USA, India and Singapore to solve the major health service issues
like medical errors. In order to improve the service quality the 5s method is adopted to solve
the problem. The 5S are Sorting, Simplifying, Safety, Standard and Sustainability which leads
to quality delivery of service to the patients in health care. Lean tools are implemented for the
benefit of three dimensional successful outcomes such as for the Patient, Professionals and
Health system improvement. It reduces patient waiting time and medical errors through 5S
approach. With regards to professionals, lean drives a quality working environment through
the factors of job control, job clarity, decision making and time spend with the patients to
avoid staff overtime. For the improvement in the outcome of the health system, lean adopted a
strategy in physical layout design, NGH layout modeling which gives a complete design
model for the physical layout which is desirable in health care. The main issues addressed by
lean management in health care is waste reduction, waste elimination and to reduce the
waiting time of the patients which leads to the quality health care by Just In Time, Value
Stream Mapping for an enhanced quality service in health care. Clinical risk is avoided by
lean management in health care by the methods of lean quality care, reduce risk, and reduce
cost method patient safety method. Lean implementation in Indian hospitals is very less in
number; the researcher has collected 50peer reviewed journal articles in which only 5article
address the issues of lean health care in Indian context. Hence the researcher focuses on
“study on the impact of lean implementation in Indian health care”.
5. CONCLUSIONS
This paper contributes to the identification of the research gap between lean in global
healthcare and lean in Indian health care system. The key factors enabling a successful lean
management in health care are brought forward through content analysis .The Findings of this
paper leads to understand the concept of lean management in health care.
REFERENCES
[1] S.Alireza, (2017) "Quantitative analysis of Six Sigma, Lean and Lean Six Sigma research
publications in last two decades", International Journal of Quality &Reliability
Management, Vol. 34Issue: 5, pp.598-625,
[2] A. Zhang, W. Luo, Y. Shi, Song Ting Chia, ZhiHao Xavier Sim, (2016) "Lean and Six
Sigma in logistics: a pilot survey study in Singapore", International Journal of Operations
& Production Management, Vol. 36 Issue: 11, pp.1625-1643,
[3] S. Ashok Sarkar, A. Ranjan Mukhopadhyay, S. Kumar Ghosh, (2013) "Root cause
analysis, Lean Six Sigma and test of hypothesis", The TQM Journal, Vol. 25 Issue: 2,
pp.170-185,
[4] Charles R. Gowen III, Kathleen L. McFadden, S.Settaluri, (2012) "Contrasting continuous
quality improvement, Six Sigma, and lean management for enhanced outcomes in US
hospitals", American Journal of Business, Vol. 27 Issue: 2, pp.133-153,
[5] H. Soriano‐Meier, Paul L. Forrester, S. Markose, J. Arturo Garza‐ Reyes, (2011) "The role
of the physical layout in the implementation of lean management initiatives", International
Journal of Lean Six Sigma, Vol. 2 Issue: 3, pp.254-269,
[6] B. McIntosh, B. Sheppy, I. Cohen, (2014) "Illusion or delusion – Lean management in the
health sector", International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance, Vol. 27 Issue: 6,
pp.482-492,
[7] P. Hwang, D. Hwang, P. Hong, (2014) "Lean practices for quality results: a case
illustration", International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance, Vol. 27 Issue: 8,
pp.729-741,
[8] O. Roemeling, M. Land, K.Ahaus, (2017) "Does lean cure variability in health care?",
[9] International Journal of Operations & Production Management, Vol. 37 Issue: 9, pp.1229-
1245,
[10] M.Ljungblom, (2014) "Ethics and Lean Management – a paradox?", International Journal
of Quality and Service Sciences, Vol. 6 Issue: 2/3, pp.191-202,
[11] M. Hussain, M. Malik, (2016) "Prioritizing lean management practices in public and
private hospitals", Journal of Health Organization and Management, Vol. 30 Issue: 3,
pp.457-474,
[12] T.Jorma, H.Tiirinki, R.Bloigu, L.Turkki, (2016) "LEAN thinking in Finnish Healthcare",
Leadership in Health Services, Vol. 29 Issue: 1, pp.9-36,
[13] G.SouzaAssis Ferreira, U.Rezende Silva, A.Lucirton Costa, S.InêsDallavallede
DallavallePádua, (2018) "The promotion of BPM and lean in the health sector: main
results",Business Process Management Journal, Vol. 24 Issue: 2, pp.400-424,
[14] G. Kastberg, S.Siverbo, (2017) "Lean and process-orienting health care – linking and
disentangling activities", Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management, Vol. 14
Issue: 4, pp.390-406,
[15] B.Kollberg, Jens J. Dahlgaard, P.Brehmer, (2006) "Measuring lean initiatives in health
care services: issues and findings", International Journal of Productivity and Performance
Management, Vol. 56 Issue: 1, pp.7-24,
[16] H.Ishijima, EliudiEliakimu, S.Takahashi, N.Miyamoto, (2014) "Factors influencing
national rollout of quality improvement approaches to public hospitals in Tanzania",
Clinical Governance: An International Journal, Vol. 19 Issue: 2, pp.137-152,
[34] C.Guimarães, José Crespo de Carvalho, (2013) "Strategic outsourcing: a lean tool of
healthcare supply chain management", Strategic Outsourcing: An International Journal,
Vol. 6 Issue: 2, pp.138-166,
[35] F.Barnabè, Maria Cleofe Giorgino, Jacopo Guercini, Caterina Bianciardi, Vincenzo
Mezzatesta, (2017) "Engaging professionals with serious games: the Lean Healthcare Lab
at Siena University Hospital", Development and Learning in Organizations: An
International Journal, Vol. 31 Issue: 3, pp.7-10,
[36] D.Adebanjo, T.Laosirihongthong & P.Samaranayake (2016)Prioritizing lean supply chain
management initiatives in healthcare service operations: a fuzzy AHP approach,
Production Planning & Control, 27:12, 953-966,
[37] M.Hussain, M.Malik, Hamda S. Al Neyadi, (2016) "AHP framework to assist lean
deployment in Abu Dhabi public healthcare delivery system", Business Process
Management Journal,Vol. 22 Issue: 3, pp.546-565,
[38] G.Tortorella, FlávioSansonFogliatto, Michel Anzanello, Giuliano
[39] Almeida Marodin, Mayara Garcia & Rafael Reis Esteves (2017) Making the value flow:
applicationof value stream mapping in a Brazilian public healthcare organisation, Total
Quality Management &Business Excellence, 28:13-14, 1544-1558
[40] C.Guimarães, J.Carvalho, A.Maia, (2013) "Vendor managed inventory (VMI): evidences
from lean deployment in healthcare", Strategic Outsourcing: An International Journal,
Vol. 6 Issue: 1, pp.8-24.