Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 19

Annals of Internal Medicine䊛

In the Clinic®

Hyperthyroidism Screening

Diagnosis

T
hyrotoxicosis is a general term for excess
circulating and tissue thyroid hormone
levels, whereas hyperthyroidism specifi-
cally denotes disorders involving a hyperactive Treatment
thyroid gland (Graves disease, toxic multinodu-
lar goiter, toxic adenoma). Diagnosis and deter-
mination of the cause rely on clinical evaluation, Practice Improvement
laboratory tests, and imaging studies. Hyperthy-
roidism is treated with antithyroid drugs, radio-
active iodine ablation, or thyroidectomy. Other
types of thyrotoxicosis are monitored and
treated with ␤-blockers to control symptoms
given that most of these conditions resolve
spontaneously.

CME/MOC activity available at Annals.org.

Physician Writer doi:10.7326/AITC202004070


Michael T. McDermott, MD
From University of Colorado CME Objective: To review current evidence for screening, diagnosis, treatment, and practice
School of Medicine, Denver, improvement of hyperthyroidism.
Colorado (M.T.M.) Funding Source: American College of Physicians.
Disclosures: Dr. McDermott, ACP Contributing Author, has nothing to disclose. The form can
be viewed at www.acponline.org/authors/icmje/ConflictOfInterestForms.do?msNum=M19
-3638.

With the assistance of additional physician writers, the editors of Annals of Internal Medi-
cine develop In the Clinic using MKSAP and other resources of the American College of
Physicians. The patient information page was written by Monica Lizarraga from the Patient
and Interprofessional Partnership Initiative at the American College of Physicians.
In the Clinic does not necessarily represent official ACP clinical policy. For ACP clinical
guidelines, please go to https://www.acponline.org/clinical_information/guidelines/.
© 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Thyrotoxicosis is a clinical state range, and it is considered “sub-
1. Ross DS, Burch HB, Coo-
per DS, et al. 2016 Ameri- characterized by excess serum clinical” when the TSH level is low
can Thyroid Association and tissue concentrations of thy- or undetectable but levels of
guidelines for diagnosis
and management of hy- roxine (T4), triiodothyronine (T3), both T4 (free or total T4) and total
perthyroidism and other
causes of thyrotoxicosis. or both. The term hyperthyroid- T3 are within the reference range.
Thyroid. 2016;26:1343- ism refers specifically to thyrotox- Therefore, overt and subclinical
421. [PMID: 27521067]
2. Burch HB. Drug effects on icosis resulting from hyperactivity thyrotoxicosis are defined bio-
the thyroid. N Engl J Med. of the thyroid gland. Thyrotoxico- chemically without regard for
2019;381:749-61. [PMID:
31433922] sis is considered “overt” when clinical features. The prevalence
3. Barroso-Sousa R, Barry WT,
Garrido-Castro AC, et al. the serum thyroid-stimulating of thyrotoxicosis in the United
Incidence of endocrine hormone (TSH) level is low or States is estimated at 1.2%,
dysfunction following the
use of different immune undetectable and serum T4 (free with approximately 40% of cases
checkpoint inhibitor regi- or total T4) level, total T3 level, or being overt and 60% being
mens: a systematic review
and meta-analysis. JAMA both are above the reference subclinical (1).
Oncol. 2018;4:173-82.
[PMID: 28973656]
4. Brahmer JR, Lacchetti C,
Schneider BJ, et al; Na-
tional Comprehensive
Cancer Network. Manage-
Screening
ment of immune-related Who has elevated risk for should also be considered in pa-
adverse events in patients
treated with immune
thyrotoxicosis? tients with medical conditions
checkpoint inhibitor ther- Persons at increased risk for thy- that may be caused or aggra-
apy: American Society of
Clinical Oncology clinical rotoxicosis include those with vated by thyrotoxicosis (osteopo-
practice guideline. J Clin rosis, atrial fibrillation, supraven-
Oncol. 2018;36:1714-68.
goiters, type 1 diabetes, other
[PMID: 29442540] autoimmune diseases, and a fam- tricular tachycardia, or heart
5. Pariani N, Willis M, Muller
I, et al. Alemtuzumab- ily history of thyroid disease. failure). Screening is also recom-
induced thyroid dysfunc- Medications that increase risk mended in women older than
tion exhibits distinctive
clinical and immunologi- include amiodarone, 50 years (6) because of the
cal features. J Clin Endo-
crinol Metab. 2018;103:
interferon-␣, interleukin-2, lith- higher prevalence of thyroid dis-
3010-8. [PMID: ium, iodide, iodinated contrast ease in this group.
29878256]
6. U.S. Preventive Services agents, immune checkpoint in-
Task Force. Screening for hibitors, and alemtuzumab (2–5). What screening tests should be
thyroid disease: recom- used?
mendation statement.
Ann Intern Med. 2004; Should clinicians screen for Serum TSH measurement is the
140:125-7. [PMID: thyrotoxicosis?
14734336] best test for thyrotoxicosis. TSH is
7. Burch HB. Overview of the Screening in the general popula- undetectable or low in both overt
clinical manifestations of
thyrotoxicosis. In: Braver- tion is not cost-effective because and subclinical thyrotoxicosis be-
man LE, Cooper DS, eds.
Werner & Ingbar's The
of the low prevalence of thyrotox- cause of negative feedback by
Thyroid: A Fundamental icosis (6). However, case finding elevated or high normal T4
and Clinical Text, 11th
Edition. Wolters Kluwer;
is recommended in persons who and/or T3 levels on the pituitary
2020. are at high risk because of co- gland. TSH assays are standard-
8. Boelaert K, Torlinska B,
Holder RL, et al. Older morbid conditions, family history, ized, accurate, and widely
subjects with hyperthy-
roidism present with a
or medication use. Testing available.
paucity of symptoms and
signs: a large cross-
sectional study. J Clin
Endocrinol Metab. 2010;
95:2715-26. [PMID:
20392869] Screening... Screening for thyrotoxicosis in the general population is
9. Nordyke RA, Gilbert FI Jr,
Harada AS. Graves' dis-
not cost-effective. Experts recommend measuring serum TSH levels in
ease. Influence of age on persons with goiters, type 1 diabetes, other autoimmune diseases, os-
clinical findings. Arch teoporosis, atrial fibrillation, supraventricular tachycardia, heart failure,
Intern Med. 1988;148:
626-31. [PMID: 3341864] or a family history of thyroid disease; those taking amiodarone, immune
10. Trivalle C, Doucet J, checkpoint inhibitors, or alemtuzumab; and women older than 50
Chassagne P, et al. Dif-
ferences in the signs and
years.
symptoms of hyperthy-
roidism in older and
younger patients. J Am
Geriatr Soc. 1996;44: CLINICAL BOTTOM LINE
50-3. [PMID: 8537590]
11. Smith TJ, Hegedüs L.
Graves' disease. N Engl J
Med. 2016;375:1552-
65. [PMID: 27797318]

姝 2020 American College of Physicians ITC50 In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Diagnosis
What symptoms should include tachycardia and/or an
prompt clinicians to consider irregularly irregular heart rate; 12. Fatourechi V, Aniszewski
thyrotoxicosis or goiter; warm, moist skin; hand JP, Fatourechi GZ, et al.
Clinical features and
hyperthyroidism? tremor; and adrenergic eye signs outcome of subacute
(stare and lid lag) (Appendix thyroiditis in an inci-
Symptoms that suggest thyrotoxi- dence cohort: Olmsted
cosis include nervousness, in- Table 1) (7–9). Other features County, Minnesota,
study. J Clin Endocrinol
creased sweating, heat intoler- may indicate the specific cause. Metab. 2003;88:2100-5.

ance, palpitations, fatigue, Graves disease is characterized [PMID: 12727961]


13. Ide A, Amino N, Kang S,
weight loss, tachycardia, dys- by diffuse goiter, thyroid bruit, et al. Differentiation of
postpartum Graves'
pnea, weakness, leg edema, eye inflammatory/congestive eye thyrotoxicosis from post-

symptoms, emotional lability, signs (proptosis, periorbital partum destructive thyro-


toxicosis using antithyro-
and frequent defecation (7–9). edema, chemosis, extraocular tropin receptor
muscle dysfunction), pretibial antibodies and thyroid
Elderly patients tend to have blood flow. Thyroid.
milder, more subtle, and less typ- myxedema (usually on the shins), 2014;24:1027-31.
[PMID: 24400892]
ical symptoms that are often and thyroid acropachy (soft tis- 14. Bartalena L, Bogazzi F,

dominated by fatigue, depres- sue enlargement and clubbing of Chiovato L, et al. 2018
European Thyroid Associ-
sion, weight loss, and atrial fibril- the fingers) (1, 11). The diagnosis ation (ETA) guidelines for
the management of
lation (7–10); the term apathetic of toxic multinodular goiter or amiodarone-associated

thyrotoxicosis describes this toxic adenoma is supported by thyroid dysfunction. Eur


Thyroid J. 2018;7:55-66.
presentation. palpating multiple thyroid nod- [PMID: 29594056]
ules or a solitary nodule. Fever 15. Li D, Radulescu A, Shres-
tha RT, et al. Association
and thyroid tenderness suggest of biotin ingestion with
Some elements of the history performance of hormone
subacute thyroiditis (12). and nonhormone assays
may also suggest the specific in healthy adults. JAMA.
cause of thyrotoxicosis (Appen- What laboratory tests should 2017;318:1150-60.
[PMID: 28973622]
dix Table 1, available at Annals clinicians use to diagnose 16. Burch HB, Cooper DS.
.org). Eye pain or swelling, dou- Management of Graves
thyrotoxicosis or disease: a review. JAMA.
ble vision, or a skin disorder on hyperthyroidism? 2015;314:2544-54.
[PMID: 26670972]
the shins point to Graves dis- Serum TSH measurement is the 17. Cooper DS. Antithyroid
ease as the cause (1, 11). Recent best test for diagnosis of thyro- drugs. N Engl J Med.
2005;352:905-17.
pregnancy raises the possibility toxicosis. Levels are usually unde- [PMID: 15745981]
18. Burch HB, Cooper DS.
of postpartum thyroiditis. Ante- tectable in overt thyrotoxicosis Anniversary Review:
rior neck pain, malaise, fever, and low but often detectable in antithyroid drug therapy:
70 years later. Eur J
and sore throat are characteristic subclinical thyrotoxicosis. Either Endocrinol. 2018;179:
of subacute thyroiditis. Use of R261-R274. [PMID:
should prompt the clinician to 30320502]
amiodarone, lithium, interferon-␣, order a free T4 or total T4 (if free 19. Azizi F, Amouzegar A,
Tohidi M, et al. Increased
interleukin-2, potassium iodide, T4 is not available) test. If the free remission rates after
immune checkpoint inhibitors or total T4 level is normal, a total long-term methimazole
therapy in patients with
(especially ipilimumab and niv- T3 test should be ordered be- Graves' disease: results
of a randomized clinical
olumab) (3, 4), or alemtuzumab cause some patients have normal trial. Thyroid. 2019;29:
(5) or recent exposure to iodin- T4 levels but elevated T3 levels 1192-200. [PMID:
31310160]
ated radiocontrast agents in- (T3 toxicosis). Measurement of 20. Feldt-Rasmussen U,
crease the likelihood of drug- Schleusener H, Carayon
free T3 levels is not recom- P. Meta-analysis evalua-
induced or iodine-induced mended because of inaccuracy tion of the impact of
thyrotropin receptor
thyrotoxicosis (2). Surreptitious of the available assays. antibodies on long term
ingestion of thyroid hormone remission after medical
therapy of Graves' dis-
must also be considered. Once thyrotoxicosis is diag- ease. J Clin Endocrinol
nosed, the cause must be deter- Metab. 1994;78:98-102.
What physical examination mined. When the physical exami-
[PMID: 8288723]
21. Tun NN, Beckett G, Zam-
findings indicate possible nation strongly suggests Graves mitt NN, et al. Thyrotro-
pin receptor antibody
thyrotoxicosis or disease (diffuse goiter, thyroid levels at diagnosis and
after thionamide course
hyperthyroidism? bruit, thyroid orbitopathy [inflam- predict Graves' disease
Physical signs often identified matory/congestive eye signs], relapse. Thyroid. 2016;
26:1004-9. [PMID:
with thyrotoxicosis of any cause pretibial myxedema, thyroid 27266892]

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine In the Clinic ITC51 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Table 1. Laboratory and Other Studies for Thyrotoxicosis
Test Indication
TSH Suspected thyrotoxicosis
Free T4 Suppressed TSH
Total T3 Suppressed TSH; normal free T4 level
Thyroglobulin Suspected thyroiditis (subacute, postpartum, or silent)
Erythrocyte sedimentation rate Suspected subacute thyroiditis
TRAb Thyrotoxicosis differential diagnosis (positive in Graves
disease)
Euthyroid Graves orbitopathy
Assessment of remission during antithyroid drug therapy in
Graves disease
Assessment of neonatal risk in pregnant patients with Graves
disease
Thyroid peroxidase antibodies Confirmation of Hashimoto thyroiditis and autoimmune
thyroid disease in general (including Graves disease)
Assessment of risk for drug-induced thyroid dysfunction and
postpartum or silent thyroiditis
Thyroid hormone antibodies (anti-T4 and Investigation of incongruous thyroid hormone and TSH results
anti-T3 antibodies) (spuriously high free T4 and total T3) in patients with
Hashimoto thyroiditis
RAIU Confirmed biochemical thyrotoxicosis with negative TRAb
level or palpable thyroid nodules
Thyroid scan Confirmed biochemical thyrotoxicosis; normal or elevated
RAIU
Thyroid ultrasonography Presence of thyroid nodules; differentiation of type 1
(iodine-induced) and type 2 (thyroiditis)
amiodarone-induced thyrotoxicosis
Color Doppler ultrasonography Differentiation of type 1 and type 2 amiodarone-induced
thyrotoxicosis
Whole-body scan Suspected struma ovarii or functioning metastatic follicular
carcinoma
Human chorionic gonadotropin Confirmation of pregnancy, gestational thyrotoxicosis,
hyperemesis gravidarum, choriocarcinoma, molar
pregnancy, testicular tumor

RAIU = radioactive iodine uptake; TRAb = thyrotropin receptor antibody; TSH = thyroid-stimulating hormone.

acropachy), further testing is un- radioactive iodine uptake (RAIU) test


necessary (1, 11). However, if the and a thyroid scan should be
cause is unclear, additional test- ordered (1).
ing is needed because treatment
differs considerably for specific Hyperthyroidism (thyrotoxicosis
causes (Tables 1 and 2; also see with high or normal RAIU) usu-
the Box: Differential Diagnosis of ally results from 1 of 3 disor-
Thyrotoxicosis With the Use of RAIU ders: Graves disease, toxic
Test). Measurement of serum thyro- multinodular goiter, or toxic
tropin receptor antibodies (TRAbs) thyroid adenoma (Box: Differen-
is recommended if thyroid palpation tial Diagnosis of Thyrotoxicosis
does not identify thyroid nodules or With the Use of RAIU Test). The
significant tenderness (1, 11–13). If thyroid scan distinguishes
TRAb levels are positive, the diagno- among these 3 conditions (1).
sis is usually Graves disease and no Diffuse isotope uptake is seen
further tests are needed; TRAbs in Graves disease, patchy up-
have sensitivity of 96%–97% and take (multiple nodules) is seen
specificity of 99% for Graves disease with toxic multinodular goiter,
(11) but can be weakly positive in and uptake in a single nodule
subacute thyroiditis. If thyroid nod- with suppression of the remain-
ules are present or if TRAb levels are der of the thyroid gland is seen
negative or borderline positive, a with toxic adenoma.

姝 2020 American College of Physicians ITC52 In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Table 2. Differential Diagnosis of Thyrotoxicosis
Disease Characteristics Reference
Elevated free T4 level, suppressed TSH
Graves disease Positive TRAb level; increased/normal RAIU; 1, 11
homogeneous thyroid scan
Toxic multinodular goiter Increased/normal RAIU; heterogeneous thyroid scan 1
Toxic thyroid adenoma Increased/normal RAIU; single “hot” focus on thyroid 1
scan with suppression of remainder of thyroid
Subacute thyroiditis Low RAIU; no visible uptake on thyroid scan; increased 1, 12
erythrocyte sedimentation rate; high thyroglobulin
level; may be followed by hypothyroid phase
Postpartum or silent thyroiditis Low RAIU; no visible uptake on thyroid scan; high 1
thyroglobulin level; may be followed by hypothyroid
phase
Surreptitious/iatrogenic thyroid hormone ingestion Low RAIU and thyroglobulin level; may involve 1
L-thyroxine or liothyronine ingestion
Checkpoint inhibitor therapy History of checkpoint inhibitor use; RAIU may be high, 2–4
normal, or low
Alemtuzumab History of alemtuzumab use; RAIU usually high; 2, 5
homogeneous thyroid scan
Struma ovarii Low RAIU in neck; increased pelvic uptake on 1
whole-body scan
TSH-producing pituitary tumor Normal or high TSH level; increased/normal RAIU; 1
elevated ␣-subunit level; pituitary tumor present on
magnetic resonance imaging
Gestational thyrotoxicosis Increased human chorionic gonadotropin level; 1
negative TRAb level; nuclear medicine testing
contraindicated
Hyperemesis gravidarum Increased human chorionic gonadotropin level; 1
negative TRAb level; nuclear medicine testing
contraindicated
Choriocarcinoma, molar pregnancy, testicular tumor Increased human chorionic gonadotropin level; 1
negative TRAb level; increased/normal RAIU;
homogeneous thyroid scan
AIT Two distinct types of thyrotoxicosis: type 1 AIT 1
(iodine-induced) and type 2 AIT (thyroiditis); negative
TRAb level; low RAIU
Functional, widely metastatic follicular thyroid cancer Prior thyroidectomy in most patients; low RAIU in neck; 1
increased uptake in metastases on whole-body scan
McCune–Albright syndrome Negative TRAb level; increased/normal RAIU; –
homogeneous thyroid scan

Normal or low free T4 level, suppressed TSH


Subclinical thyrotoxicosis Normal free T4 level; RAIU may be high or normal 1, 43
Recent thyrotoxicosis After treatment for hyperthyroidism 1, 43
Normal pregnancy Increased human chorionic gonadotropin level; 1, 43
negative TRAb level; nuclear medicine testing
contraindicated
Central hypothyroidism TSH level may be low or normal; free T4 level may be 1, 43
low
Recovery from thyroiditis TSH level may be low, normal, or elevated 1, 12, 43
Nonthyroidal illness TSH level may be low, normal, or elevated 1
Corticosteroid therapy Suppressive effect on TSH 2
Dopamine therapy Suppressive effect on TSH 2
Mitotane therapy Suppressive effect on TSH; adrenal cancer treatment 2
Bexarotene therapy Suppressive effect on TSH; mycosis fungoides treatment 2

AIT = amiodarone-induced thyrotoxicosis; RAIU = radioactive iodine uptake; TRAb = thyrotropin receptor antibody; TSH =
thyroid-stimulating hormone.

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine In the Clinic ITC53 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


2 AIT is a form of amiodarone-
22. Kim YA, Cho SW, Choi
HS, et al. The second Differential Diagnosis of induced thyroiditis. Findings that
antithyroid drug treat-
ment is effective in re-
Thyrotoxicosis With the Use suggest type 1 AIT include thy-
lapsed Graves' disease of RAIU Test roid nodules on examination or
patients: a median 11-
year follow-up study. High or normal RAIU ultrasonogram, increased blood
Thyroid. 2017;27:491-6.
[PMID: 28001121]
(hyperthyroidism) flow on color Doppler, and low
23. Villagelin D, Romaldini • Graves disease but detectable RAIU. Findings
JH, Santos RB, et al.
Outcomes in relapsed
• Toxic multinodular goiter that indicate probable type 2 AIT
Graves' disease patients • Toxic thyroid adenoma
following radioiodine or • HCG-induced include normal findings on thy-
prolonged low dose of hyperthyroidism roid examination and ultrasono-
methimazole treatment. • TSH-producing pituitary tumor gram, decreased color Doppler
Thyroid. 2015;25:1282- • McCune–Albright syndrome
90. [PMID: 26414885] blood flow, absent or very low
24. Andersen SL, Olsen J, Low or undetectable RAIU (other
Laurberg P. Antithyroid RAIU, and elevated serum
types of thyrotoxicosis)
drug side effects in the
population and in preg-
interleukin-6 level (14).
nancy. J Clin Endocrinol
• Silent thyroiditis
Metab. 2016;101:1606- • Postpartum thyroiditis What alternative explanations
14. [PMID: 26815881] • Subacute (granulomatous)
25. Yang J, Li LF, Xu Q, et al. thyroiditis should clinicians consider in
Analysis of 90 cases of • Iodine-induced patients with possible
antithyroid drug-induced thyrotoxicosis
severe hepatotoxicity
• Amiodarone-induced
thyrotoxicosis?
over 13 years in China.
Thyroid. 2015;25:278- thyrotoxicosis Clinical features that resemble
83. [PMID: 25384184] • Iatrogenic thyrotoxicosis those of thyrotoxicosis can occur
26. Suzuki N, Noh JY, Hi- • Metastatic follicular thyroid
ruma M, et al. Analysis of cancer with infections, sepsis, anxiety, de-
antithyroid drug-induced
severe liver injury in
• Struma ovarii pression, chronic fatigue, atrial
18,558 newly diagnosed HCG = human chorionic fibrillation, and pheochromocy-
patients with Graves'
disease in Japan. Thy- gonadotropin; RAIU = radio- toma. Thyroid hormone testing
roid. 2019;29:1390-8. active iodine uptake; TSH = can usually distinguish these disor-
[PMID: 31573408]
thyroid-stimulating hormone.
27. Nakamura H, Miyauchi ders from thyrotoxicosis. However,
A, Miyawaki N, et al.
Analysis of 754 cases of serum TSH levels can be low and
antithyroid drug-induced
free T4 levels can be variable in
agranulocytosis over 30 Other tests that may be consid-
years in Japan. J Clin normal pregnancy, gestational
Endocrinol Metab. 2013; ered when TRAb levels are nega-
98:4776-83. [PMID: thyrotoxicosis, hyperemesis gravi-
24057289]
tive and radioisotope studies are
darum, nonthyroidal illness syn-
28. Yang J, Yao LP, Dong contraindicated or not desired
MJ, et al. Clinical charac- drome, or central hypothyroidism
teristics and outcomes of (for example, in women who are
propylthiouracil-induced pregnant or nursing, or due to (hypothalamic–pituitary disease)
antineutrophil cytoplas-
mic antibody-associated patient preference) (1) include and with use of some medications,
vasculitis in patients with
thyroid ultrasonography with or including glucocorticoids, dopa-
Graves' disease: a me-
dian 38-month retrospec- without color Doppler (1, 13); mine, bexarotene, mitotane, met-
tive cohort study from a
measurement of serum thyroid- formin, and heparin (1, 2).
single institution in
China. Thyroid. 2017;27:
1469-74. [PMID:
stimulating immunoglobulins, It is particularly important to note
29088997] serum thyroid peroxidase anti- the effects of high-dose biotin
29. Seo GH, Kim TH, Chung
JH. Antithyroid drugs
bodies, serum thyroglobulin, se- use on thyroid tests (2, 15). Biotin
and congenital malfor- rum human chorionic gonadotro- is a common supplement in over-
mations: a nationwide
Korean cohort study. Ann pin, erythrocyte sedimentation the-counter preparations for
Intern Med. 2018;168:
405-13. [PMID:
rate, or 24-hour urinary iodine treatment of hair loss and brittle
29357398] excretion; or (rarely) whole-body nails. At the high doses used in
30. Pearce EN. Management
of thyrotoxicosis: precon-
radioiodine scan (1). these products, biotin can inter-
ception, pregnancy, and
the postpartum period. Amiodarone-induced thyrotoxi- fere with multiple hormone as-
Endocr Pract. 2019;25:
62-8. [PMID: 30289300] cosis (AIT) can be particularly dif- says because it is a key reagent
31. Okamura K, Sato K, Fu- ficult to accurately diagnose and used in assays; consequently,
jikawa M, et al. Remis-
sion after potassium treat (14). Type 1 AIT is a form of excess biotin in the circulation
iodide therapy in pa- (and thus in the test tube) can
tients with Graves' hyper- iodine-induced thyrotoxicosis
thyroidism exhibiting caused by the high iodine con- alter assay performance and pro-
thionamide-associated
side effects. J Clin Endo- tent in amiodarone; it typically duce false results. For example,
crinol Metab. 2014;99: occurs in patients with underly- high-dose biotin can result in low
3995-4002. [PMID:
25144628] ing nodular thyroid disease. Type serum TSH levels, elevated free

姝 2020 American College of Physicians ITC54 In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


T4 and total T3 levels, and posi- When should clinicians
tive TRAb levels in a euthyroid consider consulting an
person, a profile that could be 32. Cappellani D, Papini P,
endocrinologist? Pingitore A, et al. Com-
mistaken for hyperthyroid Graves parison between total
Clinicians should consider consult- thyroidectomy and medi-
disease. Patients who are taking cal therapy for
high-dose biotin supplements ing an endocrinologist when the amiodarone-induced

should stop 2–3 days before hav- diagnosis of thyrotoxicosis is uncer- thyrotoxicosis. J Clin
Endocrinol Metab. 2020;
ing hormone measurements and tain or the cause is unclear, such as 105. [PMID: 31545358]
33. Uy HL, Reasner CA,
can resume taking them after- when TRAb levels are negative and Samuels MH. Pattern of
recovery of the hypotha-
ward if desired (2, 15). RAIU is low or undetectable. lamic–pituitary–thyroid
axis following radioactive
iodine therapy in pa-
tients with Graves' dis-
Diagnosis... Thyrotoxicosis is diagnosed on the basis of the history, ease. Am J Med. 1995;
99:173-9. [PMID:
physical examination, and characteristic laboratory findings (low serum 7625422]
TSH level with elevated levels of free T4 and/or total T3). Clinicians 34. Träisk F, Tallstedt L,
should identify the cause from clinical features along with TRAb testing, Abraham-Nordling M,
et al; Thyroid Study
RAIU testing, and thyroid scan, when indicated. In some situations, de- Group of TT 96. Thyroid-
termining the cause may require additional tests. associated ophthalmopa-
thy after treatment for
Graves' hyperthyroidism
with antithyroid drugs or
CLINICAL BOTTOM LINE iodine-131. J Clin Endo-
crinol Metab. 2009;94:
3700-7. [PMID:
19723755]
35. Acharya SH, Avenell A,
Philip S, et al. Radioio-
Treatment dine therapy (RAI) for
Graves' disease (GD) and
the effect on ophthal-
What nonpharmacologic serum thyroid hormone levels mopathy: a systematic
therapies should clinicians relatively quickly in patients with review. Clin Endocrinol
(Oxf). 2008;69:943-50.
recommend? Graves disease, toxic multinodu- [PMID: 18429949]
36. Sosa JA, Bowman HM,
Patients with uncontrolled thyro- lar goiter, or toxic thyroid ade- Tielsch JM, et al. The
toxicosis should avoid strenuous noma (1, 16 –18); they are usually importance of surgeon
experience for clinical
physical exertion; reduce or elim- not effective in other types of thy- and economic outcomes
rotoxicosis (1). Methimazole is from thyroidectomy. Ann
inate caffeine intake; quit smok- Surg. 1998;228:320-30.
ing (1); avoid exogenous sources more potent than PTU (1, 16 –18), [PMID: 9742915]
37. Lillevang-Johansen M,
of iodine (kelp, iodine supple- requires less frequent dosing Abrahamsen B, Jør-
(once or twice daily), and is pre- gensen HL, et al. Excess
ments, iodinated contrast mortality in treated and
agents); and avoid biotin supple- ferred because of the higher risk untreated hyperthyroid-
ism is related to cumula-
ments, which can interfere with for liver toxicity with PTU (1). The tive periods of low serum

hormone assay accuracy (2, 15). starting dose of methimazole de- TSH. J Clin Endocrinol
Metab. 2017;102:
pends on the initial free T4 level. 2301-9. [PMID:
How should clinicians choose When free T4 levels are 1.0 –1.5 28368540]
38. Lillevang-Johansen M,
and prescribe drug therapy? times the upper limit of normal Abrahamsen B, Jør-
gensen HL, et al. Dura-
Medications that are available to (ULN), the recommended start- tion of hyperthyroidism
and lack of sufficient
treat thyrotoxicosis are shown in ing methimazole dose is 5–10 mg treatment are associated
Table 3. ␤-Adrenergic blockers once daily; when free T4 levels with increased cardiovas-
cular risk. Thyroid. 2019;
are appropriate for symptomatic are 1.5–2.0 times the ULN, the 29:332-40. [PMID:
patients with thyrotoxicosis of 30648498]
starting dose is 10 –20 mg once 39. Okosieme OE, Taylor PN,
any cause (1, 16) regardless of daily; and when free T4 levels are Evans C, et al. Primary
therapy of Graves' dis-
the primary therapy chosen for 2.0 –3.0 times the ULN or higher, ease and cardiovascular
the condition. the starting dose is 30 – 40 mg morbidity and mortality:
a linked-record cohort
once daily or in divided twice- study. Lancet Diabetes
Methimazole and propylthioura- daily doses (1, 18).
Endocrinol. 2019;7:278-
87. [PMID: 30827829]
cil (PTU) are the 2 antithyroid 40. Hieu TT, Russell AW,
drugs (ATDs) available in the The recommended duration of Cuneo R, et al. Cancer
risk after medical expo-
United States; carbimazole is methimazole therapy for Graves sure to radioactive iodine
in benign thyroid dis-
used in parts of Europe, Africa, disease is 12–18 months, after eases: a meta-analysis.
and Asia. ATDs inhibit thyroid which it can be tapered or dis- Endocr Relat Cancer.
2012;19:645-55. [PMID:
hormone synthesis and reduce continued if the patient is 22851687]

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine In the Clinic ITC55 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Table 3. Drug Treatments for Thyrotoxicosis
Agent Mechanism of Action Dosage Benefits Adverse Effects Notes
Propranolol ␤-Blocker 60–80 mg every 4 h Blocks T4-to-T3 conversion Possible aggravation In thyroid storm, consider
(high doses) of heart failure, invasive monitoring in
asthma patients with heart
failure
Atenolol ␤-Blocker 50–100 mg every Once-daily dosing Possible aggravation Uncomplicated
12–24 h possible of heart failure thyrotoxicosis only
Metoprolol ␤-Blocker 50–100 mg every Once-daily dosing Possible aggravation Uncomplicated
12–24 h possible of heart failure thyrotoxicosis only
Esmolol ␤-Blocker 250–500 mcg/kg Rapidly titratable Intensive monitoring Thyroid storm only;
intravenous required consider invasive
loading dose, monitoring in patients
then continuous with heart failure
infusion of
50–100 mcg/kg
per min
Methimazole ATD: inhibits thyroid Free T4 level 1.0–1.5 – Agranulocytosis Delayed effect seen due to
hormone synthesis times ULN: Start (0.2%–0.4%), preformed thyroid
5–10 mg once cholestatic hormone release;
daily jaundice (<0.2%), thyroid storm dose
Free T4 level 1.5–2.0 birth defects (e.g., higher (20 mg every 4 h;
times ULN: Start aplasia cutis, PTU preferred)
10–20 mg once choanal atresia) if Manufacturer recommends
daily used in first performing liver function
Free T4 level 2.0–3.0 trimester of tests in the event of
times ULN or pregnancy (more anorexia, pruritus, or
higher: Start common than right upper quadrant
30–40 mg once with PTU) abdominal pain and
daily or in divided stopping therapy for
doses twice daily aminotransferase
elevations >3 times ULN
Agranulocytosis occurred
in 0.2%–0.4% of patients
receiving ATDs in 3
studies involving
>22 000 patients
PTU ATD: inhibits thyroid 50–150 mg 3 times Blocks T4-to-T3 conversion Agranulocytosis Delayed effect seen due to
hormone synthesis and daily (0.2%–0.4%), preformed thyroid
T4-to-T3 conversion hepatitis (<0.2%), hormone release;
vasculitis, birth thyroid storm dose
defects if used in higher (load 600–1000
first trimester of mg, then 200–250 mg
pregnancy (less every 4 h; PTU preferred
common than over methimazole)
with methimazole) Agranulocytosis occurred
in 0.2%–0.4% of patients
receiving ATDs in 3
studies involving
>22 000 patients
I-131 Destroys iodine-avid 10–30 mCi Reduction in thyroid Transient Contraindicated in
thyroid tissue hormone values in exacerbation of pregnancy; avoid with
2–3 mo thyrotoxicosis moderate to severe
possible; Graves orbitopathy
worsening of
Graves
orbitopathy
Iopanoic acid Blocks T4-to-T3 conversion 500–1000 mg orally Potent blocker of T4-to-T3 Precludes use of Do not use before ATD;
once daily conversion I-131 until iodine rapid preoperative
cleared preparation
For thyroid storm, do not
start until 1 h after
starting ATDs
Not available in the United
States
Saturated solution of Blocks thyroid hormone 5 drops 4 times Ease of administration Iodine allergy (true Do not use before ATD;
potassium iodide release daily iodine allergy is preoperative
(SSKI, Lugol rare); precludes preparation for
solution) use of I-131 until thyroidectomy and
iodine cleared treatment of thyroid
storm
NSAIDs Anti-inflammatory effects – Fewer adverse effects than Gastrointestinal Subacute thyroiditis only; can
steroids irritation use naproxen, ibuprofen,
or other NSAID
Hydrocortisone Blocks T4-to-T3 conversion, 300 mg intravenous Treats coexisting adrenal Hyperglycemia For thyroid storm, 300 mg
anti-inflammatory effects loading followed insufficiency and intravenous loading
by 100 mg 3 vasomotor instability followed by 100 mg
times daily every 8 h
Prednisone Anti-inflammatory effects 40–60 mg/d Rapid relief of pain in Cushing syndrome Subacute thyroiditis and
subacute thyroiditis type 2 amiodarone-
induced thyrotoxicosis
only

Continued on following page

姝 2020 American College of Physicians ITC56 In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Table 3—Continued
Agent Mechanism of Action Dosage Benefits Adverse Effects Notes
Lithium Blocks thyroid hormone 300 mg 4 times Adjunctive therapy Neurologic, renal, Must monitor levels
release daily gastrointestinal, For thyroid storm, adjust
cardiac dose to maintain
therapeutic range;
questionable benefit
beyond potassium
iodide
Cholestyramine Binds thyroid hormone in 1–2 g twice daily Adjunctive therapy Gastrointestinal –
the intestines
Plasmapheresis Removes T4/T3 from Once or twice Adjunctive therapy – Thyroid storm or before
circulation surgery or I-131 if
toxicity to ATD

ATD = antithyroid drug; I-131 = radioactive iodine; NSAID = nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug; PTU = propylthiouracil; ULN =
upper limit of normal.

asymptomatic, the serum TSH these disorders. Nonetheless,


level is normal, and TRAb levels long-term low-dose methimazole 41. Ryödi E, Metso S, Jaati-
nen P, et al. Cancer inci-
are negative (1, 18). Remission is reasonable for patients who dence and mortality in
occurs in approximately 50% of patients treated either
choose this option (1). Before with RAI or thyroidec-
patients; however, longer treat- I-131 or thyroidectomy, methima- tomy for hyperthyroid-
ism. J Clin Endocrinol
ment periods of up to 5 years zole is often prescribed to con- Metab. 2015;100:
3710-7. [PMID:
may significantly improve the re- trol hyperthyroidism and reduce 26262435]
mission rate (19). In patients who risk for posttreatment thyroid 42. Kitahara CM, Berrington
de Gonzalez A, Bouville
were initially TRAb-positive, a storm (1). Methimazole therapy A, et al. Association of
radioactive iodine treat-
negative TRAb level at the end of should be stopped 7 days before ment with cancer mortal-
treatment strongly predicts re- ity in patients with hyper-
I-131 administration or just be- thyroidism. JAMA Intern
mission, whereas a persistently fore thyroidectomy (1). Med. 2019. [PMID:
31260066]
positive TRAb level predicts re- 43. Biondi B, Cooper DS.
lapse once methimazole therapy ATDs are not effective in low- Subclinical hyperthyroid-
ism. N Engl J Med.
is discontinued (1, 20, 21). Simi- RAIU thyrotoxicosis and should 2018;378:2411-9.
[PMID: 29924956]
larly, persistently suppressed se- not be used in these conditions. 44. Carlé A, Andersen SL,
rum TSH levels with use of me- Furthermore, low-RAIU thyrotoxic Boelaert K, et al. Man-
agement of endocrine
thimazole predict relapse if use disorders tend to be self-limiting disease: subclinical thy-
rotoxicosis: prevalence,
of the drug is stopped (1, 20, 21). and, depending on the cause, causes and choice of
therapy. Eur J Endocri-
When methimazole therapy can- usually respond symptomatically nol. 2017;176:R325-
not be stopped because of per- to ␤-blockers, nonsteroidal anti- R337. [PMID:
28274949]
sistently positive TRAb levels or inflammatory drugs, or glucocor- 45. Selmer C, Olesen JB,
Hansen ML, et al. Sub-
suppressed TSH or if Graves dis- ticoid therapy (1). One exception clinical and overt thyroid
dysfunction and risk of
ease recurs after discontinuation is type 1 AIT, which may respond all-cause mortality and
of therapy, radioactive iodine to an ATD (1, 14). cardiovascular events: a
large population study. J
(I-131) ablation or thyroidectomy Clin Endocrinol Metab.
Minor adverse effects of ATDs 2014;99:2372-82.
is usually recommended. Alterna- [PMID: 24654753]
include rashes and liver enzyme 46. Collet TH, Gussekloo J,
tively, methimazole can be given Bauer DC, et al; Thyroid
elevations (cholestatic markers
at low doses (≤10 mg/d) as long- Studies Collaboration.
[alkaline phosphatase and biliru- Subclinical hyperthyroid-
term therapy in patients who pre- ism and the risk of coro-
bin] with methimazole and hepa- nary heart disease and
fer this (1, 22, 23). mortality. Arch Intern
tocellular enzymes [aspartate Med. 2012;172:799-
aminotransferase and alanine 809. [PMID: 22529182]
ATDs effectively reduce thyroid 47. Sawin CT, Geller A, Wolf
hormone levels in patients with aminotransferase] with PTU) (1, PA, et al. Low serum
thyrotropin concentra-
toxic multinodular goiters or 16 –18, 24). Of note, mild to mod- tions as a risk factor for
atrial fibrillation in older
toxic thyroid adenomas, but they erate liver enzyme elevations persons. N Engl J Med.
do not promote remission in may be present at baseline due 1994;331:1249-52.
[PMID: 7935681]
these conditions (hyperthyroid- to thyrotoxicosis itself and often 48. Gammage MD, Parle JV,
Holder RL, et al. Associa-
ism recurs after ATD therapy dis- resolve after initiation of ATD tion between serum free
thyroxine concentration
continuation). Therefore, I-131 therapy (1); however, it is recom- and atrial fibrillation.
therapy or thyroidectomy is the mended that ATD therapy should Arch Intern Med. 2007;
167:928-34. [PMID:
preferred primary treatment for not be started when hepatic en- 17502534]

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine In the Clinic ITC57 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


zyme levels exceed 3 times the (with or without perchlorate if
49. Bauer DC, Ettinger B,
Nevitt MC, et al; Study of ULN and should be discontinued available), and type 2 AIT (thy-
Osteoporotic Fractures if hepatic enzyme levels increase roiditis) is best treated with oral
Research Group. Risk for
fracture in women with to these levels during treatment glucocorticoid therapy. Methima-
low serum levels of
thyroid-stimulating hor- (1). Because PTU can cause se- zole and glucocorticoids are
mone. Ann Intern Med. vere hepatocellular necrosis with sometimes used together when
2001;134:561-8. [PMID:
12803168] liver failure (25, 26), in 2009 the the distinction between types 1
50. Burch HB, Wartofsky L.
Life-threatening thyrotox-
U.S. Food and Drug Administra- and 2 is not definitive (14). Some
icosis. Thyroid storm. tion advised clinicians to use me- patients are resistant to even
Endocrinol Metab Clin
North Am. 1993;22:263- thimazole instead of PTU except high doses of these medications;
77. [PMID: 8325286] in cases of methimazole allergy thyroidectomy is an effective op-
51. Isozaki O, Satoh T, Wakino
S, et al. Treatment and and in pregnant women during tion in these patients (32).
management of thyroid
the first trimester (1, 16 –18).
storm: analysis of the When should clinicians
nationwide surveys: the Agranulocytosis, a potentially
taskforce committee of the
life-threatening disorder, devel- consider I-131 ablation as
Japan Thyroid Association
and Japan Endocrine ops in 0.2%– 0.4% of patients tak- primary therapy?
Society for the establish-
ment of diagnostic criteria ing either ATD (1, 27), most often I-131 ablation is another primary
and nationwide surveys for
within the first few months; it oc- therapy option for Graves dis-
thyroid storm. Clin Endo-
crinol (Oxf). 2016;84: curs more commonly with high ease. It has a long record of effi-
912-8. [PMID: 26387649]
52. Angell TE, Lechner MG, doses (≥40 mg/d) of methima- cacy and safety (1, 16) and is also
Nguyen CT, et al. Clinical zole but is not related to PTU a good choice for secondary
features and hospital
outcomes in thyroid dose (1). Agranulocytosis often therapy in patients with Graves
storm: a retrospective
resolves after discontinuation of disease who do not have remis-
cohort study. J Clin Endo-
crinol Metab. 2015;100: therapy but may persist and re- sion with primary ATD treatment
451-9. [PMID: 25343237]
53. Galindo RJ, Hurtado CR, quire bone marrow–specific ther- (1, 16).
Pasquel FJ, et al. Na- apies if it is not recognized and
tional trends in inci- Patients with Graves disease
dence, mortality, and use of the medication is not
clinical outcomes of should be given an I-131 dose
patients hospitalized for
promptly stopped. PTU may also
that is sufficient to cause hypo-
thyrotoxicosis with and occasionally cause an antineutro-
without thyroid storm in thyroidism (1, 16)— usually about
the United States, 2004 – phil cytoplasmic antibody–posi-
2013. Thyroid. 2019;29: 10 –15 mCi as a fixed dose or a
tive vasculitis (28). When given to
36-43. [PMID: calculated dose based on gland
30382003] pregnant women in the first tri-
54. Chiappa V, Anderson size and RAIU (1, 16). Approxi-
MA, Barrett CD, et al. mester, methimazole has been
mately 90% of patients with
Case 24-2019: a 39-year- associated with aplasia cutis, cho-
old woman with palpita- Graves disease respond well and
tions, abdominal pain, anal atresia, and other birth de-
and vomiting. N Engl J become hypothyroid within 3– 6
fects; similar birth defects have
Med. 2019;381:567-77. months of I-131 administration;
[PMID: 31390504] been reported with PTU but are
55. Bahn RS, Burch HB, both free T4 and TSH should be
Cooper DS, et al; Ameri- less common (1, 24, 29, 30).
can Thyroid Association. Therefore, it is recommended monitored routinely during that
Hyperthyroidism and
that pregnant women with time so that hypothyroidism can
other causes of thyrotoxi-
cosis: management Graves disease be treated with be promptly recognized and
guidelines of the Ameri- treated (1, 33). For patients who
can Thyroid Association PTU during the first trimester and
and American Associa-
then switched to methimazole in do not respond to the initial I-131
tion of Clinical Endocri-
nologists. Endocr Pract. the second and third trimesters dose, retreatment can be consid-
2011;17:456-520.
(1, 30). ered 3– 6 months later. Sialadeni-
[PMID: 21700562]
56. Kahaly GJ, Bartalena L, tis is an occasional adverse effect
Hegedüs L, et al. 2018 from I-131 uptake by the salivary
European Thyroid Associ-
Cold (nonradioactive) iodine
ation guideline for the (oral potassium iodide) has been glands.
management of Graves'
hyperthyroidism. Eur reported to be effective long-
Thyroid J. 2018;7:167- term therapy for patients with Pregnancy is an absolute contra-
86. [PMID: 30283735]
Graves disease who do not toler- indication for I-131 ablation (1,
57. Brito JP, Castaneda-
Guarderas A, Gionfriddo
ate an ATD but decline or have 30) because this radioisotope
MR, et al. Development
and pilot testing of an contraindications to I-131 or thy- can destroy the developing fetal
encounter tool for shared
roidectomy (31). thyroid gland. Therefore, women
decision making about
the treatment of Graves' of childbearing potential should
disease. Thyroid. 2015; Type 1 AIT (iodine-induced) is always have a documented nega-
25:1191-8. [PMID:
26413979] usually treated with methimazole tive pregnancy test result imme-

姝 2020 American College of Physicians ITC58 In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


diately before receiving I-131 16). Experts recommend treating
(1, 30). Other contraindications highly symptomatic patients or
to I-131 therapy include lactation, those with free T4 levels that ex-
diagnosed or suspected thyroid ceed the ULN by more than
cancer, and the presence of 2-fold with methimazole,
significant Graves orbitopathy ␤-blockers, or both for up to a
(GO) (1). month before I-131 therapy (1,
16). Methimazole therapy should
Worsening of preexisting GO is a then be discontinued 7 days be-
well-recognized complication of fore I-131 administration because
I-131 treatment (34, 35). Other it can reduce the effectiveness of
risk factors for GO progression I-131 therapy (1).
include smoking, high serum
TRAb levels, and untreated hy- When should clinicians
perthyroidism (1). Patients with consider thyroidectomy as
inactive or mild GO but no risk primary therapy?
factors for progression can re- Thyroidectomy can be consid-
ceive I-131 with minimal concern ered as primary therapy for any
for worsening of GO. However, patient with hyperthyroidism (1),
patients who have mild GO with in patients with Graves disease
risk factors or have moderate to who do not achieve remission
severe GO should receive oral with primary ATD therapy, in pa-
glucocorticoid coverage if I-131 tients who have moderate to se-
is their chosen therapy (1). The vere GO, and in refractory cases
recommended prednisone dose of AIT (32). Thyroidectomy is also
is 0.4 – 0.5 mg/kg of body weight recommended for hyperthyroid
per day for 1 month starting 1–3 patients who have thyroid nod-
days after I-131 administration, ules that could be cancerous, for
with tapering over the ensuing 2 patients who decline or cannot
months (1). In addition, smoking tolerate other forms of therapy,
cessation should be strongly en- and for pregnant women during
couraged in all patients. the second trimester if hyperthy-
roidism cannot be controlled
I-131 is 1 of the 2 preferred pri- with an ATD.
mary therapy options for toxic
multinodular goiters and toxic Clinicians should prescribe me-
thyroid adenomas (1). Hypothy- thimazole for at least a month to
roidism is the main adverse ef- achieve euthyroidism before sur-
fect, occurring in 50%–75% of gery (1). Patients with Graves dis-
treated patients. The I-131 doses ease, but not those with toxic
required in these patients are multinodular goiters or toxic ade-
approximately 20 –30 mCi. Be- nomas, should also receive oral
cause GO does not occur in potassium iodide during the
these conditions, glucocorticoid week before surgery to further
coverage is not necessary. I-131 reduce thyroid hormone levels
therapy is not effective in low- and to reduce thyroid vascularity
RAIU thyrotoxicosis and should (1). Other options for reducing
not be used (1). thyroid hormone levels in pa-
tients who are unable to tolerate
Serum T4 and T3 levels often in- ATDs include lithium, bile acid
crease transiently in the first 1–2 sequestrants, iopanoic acid, and
weeks after I-131 administration plasmapheresis.
(1). This can exacerbate thyro-
toxic symptoms and has been Outcomes are best when a high-
reported to precipitate thyroid volume thyroid surgeon does the
storm in persons with severe pre- procedure (36). Most patients are
treatment hyperthyroidism (1, rendered hypothyroid by surgery

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine In the Clinic ITC59 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


and should start replacement ery 6 –12 months, with a goal of 6 – 8 weeks later (1). Once the
L-thyroxine doses (1.6 mcg/kg maintaining the serum TSH level pituitary gland recovers from
per day) before discharge from (and free T4 level if measured) chronic suppression, serum TSH
the hospital (1). Thyroidectomy within the reference range (1). levels again become reliable and
is not indicated for low-RAIU thy- are the best test for monitoring
rotoxicosis other than for pa- When an ATD is prescribed, clini- replacement therapy. TSH levels
tients with refractory AIT (32). cians should consider ordering a should thereafter be maintained
baseline complete blood count within the reference range. After
Radiofrequency ablation of soli- (CBC) and liver panel because thyroidectomy for hyperthyroid-
tary or multiple toxic thyroid abnormalities of these tests can ism, a full replacement dose of
nodules can be effective when result from the presence of thyro- L-thyroxine (1.6 mcg/kg daily)
done by experienced operators toxicosis at baseline or may de- should be started at or before
for patients who prefer to avoid velop later as an adverse drug hospital discharge (1). Serum
or have contraindications to effect. Patients should be advised TSH should be measured 6 – 8
I-131 therapy or thyroidectomy to notify their provider if they de- weeks later and the L-thyroxine
(1). velop symptoms of agranulocyto- dose should be adjusted at 6- to
How should clinicians monitor sis (fever, sore throat) or symp- 8-week intervals until the TSH
patients who are being treated toms suggestive of liver injury level is within the reference
for hyperthyroidism? (jaundice, dark urine, pruritus, range; it can then be monitored
After starting ATD treatment, abdominal pain, nausea, vomit- annually.
thyroid tests (measurement of ing) or vasculitis (fatigue, arthral-
What are long-term
TSH, free T4, and total T3 [if T3 gias) (1, 16 –18). A CBC, liver
panel, and/or erythrocyte sedi- considerations for the primary
was initially elevated]) should be
done every month for 3 months mentation rate should then be treatment options for
(Appendix Table 2, available at ordered, as appropriate, and use hyperthyroidism?
Annals.org). Once thyrotoxic of the ATD should be discontin- Increased cardiovascular morbid-
symptoms have resolved and ued if these severe adverse ef- ity and mortality have been re-
thyroid test results are within fects are identified (1). However, ported in patients with treated
the reference range, ␤-blocker routine monitoring of the CBC hyperthyroidism; however, this
use can be stopped and the and liver enzyme levels is not rec- seems to be due to the overall
ATD dose can usually be re- ommended in the absence of duration of insufficiently treated
duced by 30%–50%. Thyroid suspected ATD toxicity. hyperthyroidism rather than the
testing should then be done treatment method (37–39). Can-
every 3– 6 months. In patients Patients who receive I-131 should cer risk has been another area of
with Graves disease, if the se- have a repeated clinical assess- interest. Two previous studies
rum TSH level is normal and the ment and thyroid tests 2–3 did not find a significant increase
serum TRAb level becomes months later (1, 16). Of note, se- in any type of cancer after I-131
negative after 12–18 months, rum TSH levels may remain sup- therapy (40, 41). Subsequently, a
ATD therapy can be tapered or pressed for up to 6 weeks after study of 18 805 patients reported
stopped to determine whether chronically elevated T4 and T3 small but statistically significant
remission has occurred (1, 16). levels decrease into or below the associations between prior I-131
A normal serum TSH level dur- normal range (33). Therefore, it is therapy and mortality from all
ing treatment and a negative important to measure free T4 solid tumors combined, includ-
TRAb level at 12–18 months along with TSH levels in the first ing female breast cancer (42).
predict a high likelihood of re- 2–3 months after I-131 therapy;
mission, whereas a persistently during this time, hypothyroidism What is subclinical
low TSH level and a positive is often characterized by low se- thyrotoxicosis, and what are
TRAb level indicate that remis- rum free T4 levels with persis- the indications for treatment?
sion has not occurred (1, 16, tently low or normal TSH levels Subclinical thyrotoxicosis is a
20, 21). Because remission does (1, 33). Accordingly, thyroid hor- term used for mild thyrotoxicosis
not occur with toxic multinodu- mone replacement therapy that manifests primarily as low
lar goiters and toxic thyroid ad- should be started when the free serum TSH levels and serum free
enomas, if long-term methima- T4 level becomes low, even if T4 and total T3 levels that are still
zole therapy is chosen, regular TSH is not elevated; measure- within the reference ranges (1,
monitoring of TSH with or with- ment of serum free T4 and TSH 43, 44). Most patients are asymp-
out free T4 should be done ev- levels should then be repeated tomatic, but some have mild

姝 2020 American College of Physicians ITC60 In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


or borderline positive (Graves treated hyperthyroidism com-
Treatment of Thyroid Storm disease), the RAIU is typically bined with a precipitating event,
Decrease thyroid hormone within the reference range but such as thyroidectomy, nonthy-
synthesis inappropriately normal for a low roid surgery, infection, trauma,
• Propylthiouracil (oral, rectal, TSH level, and thyroid scan find- or recent I-131 therapy. Fever
nasogastric tube): 600 –1200 ings are consistent with the un- (temperature >102 °F) is a cardi-
mg/d (divided doses) derlying cause (1). nal manifestation. Supraventricu-
• Methimazole (oral, rectal,
nasogastric tube, lar tachycardia, atrial fibrillation,
intravenous): 60 –120 mg/d
Treatment may be considered for heart failure, and ischemic heart
(divided doses) subclinical hyperthyroidism symptoms develop frequently,
Inhibit thyroid hormone release (Graves disease, toxic multinodu- and nausea, vomiting, diarrhea,
• Sodium iodide (intravenous): lar goiter, toxic thyroid adenoma) and abdominal pain are also
1 g over 24 hours but is usually not necessary for common features. Central ner-
• Potassium iodide (oral): 5 other types of subclinical thyro-
drops 4 times a day (SSKI) vous system manifestations in-
toxicosis (1). Experts disagree clude hyperkinesis, psychosis,
Reduce the heart rate
about whether subclinical hyper- and coma. Serum free T4 and
• Esmolol (intravenous): 500
mg over 1 minute, then
thyroidism requires treatment total T3 levels are often highly
50 –100 mg/kg per minute because many patients have no elevated, and the TSH level is
• Metoprolol (intravenous): or only mild symptoms and the usually undetectable.
5–10 mg every 2– 4 hours long-term course is variable (1,
• Propranolol (oral): 60 – 80
mg every 4 hours 43, 44); serum TSH levels some- Although serum TSH levels are
• Diltiazem (intravenous): 0.25 times return to normal within low and free T4 and/or total T3
mg/kg over 2 minutes, then 6 –12 months without treatment. levels are elevated in this condi-
infusion of 10 mg/min However, older patients with sub- tion, the hormone levels do not
• Diltiazem (oral): 60 –90 mg
every 6 – 8 hours clinical hyperthyroidism are at reliably distinguish patients with
Support the circulation increased risk for atrial fibrilla- thyroid storm from those with
• Glucocorticoids in stress tion, heart failure, osteoporotic uncomplicated thyrotoxicosis.
doses fractures, and early death (45– Therefore, clinical judgment by
• Fluids, oxygen, cooling 49). Therefore, current guidelines an experienced clinician is the
Perform plasmapheresis (can be recommend treating patients key to diagnosis. Validated scor-
used in patients who have with serum TSH levels less than ing systems are available to help
experienced previous
significant toxicity to
0.1 mU/L, those who are defi- clinicians determine when this
antithyroid drugs) nitely symptomatic, and those diagnosis is likely (50, 51)
Treat precipitating cause older than 65 years (1, 3, 43). De- (Appendix Table 3, available at
bate continues about the optimal Annals.org), but a scoring tool
management of asymptomatic should not override clinical
younger patients with TSH levels judgment.
symptoms consistent with thyro- that are low but at least 0.1 mU/L;
toxicosis. Care must be taken to in this situation, clinical judgment The immediate goals of therapy
ensure that this diagnosis is cor- and shared decision making are (50 –54) for thyroid storm are 1)
rect because similar thyroid hor- paramount (1, 43). Low-dose me- decrease thyroid hormone syn-
mone profiles may be seen in thimazole, 5–10 mg/d (or lower), thesis with an ATD (methimazole
other conditions, such as normal is the most common treatment or PTU [both can be given orally,
pregnancy, gestational thyrotoxi- for subclinical hyperthyroidism by nasogastric tube, or rectally,
cosis, hyperemesis gravidarum, (1), but I-131 ablation and thy- and methimazole can be given
nonthyroidal illness syndrome, roidectomy are still options. intravenously; PTU is typically
and central hypothyroidism (hy- used because it also decreases
pothalamic–pituitary disease), How is thyroid storm T4-to-T3 conversion]); 2) inhibit
and with use of certain medica- recognized and treated? thyroid hormone secretion with
tions, especially glucocorticoids, Thyroid storm, also called thyro- oral potassium iodide or intrave-
dopamine, bexarotene, mitotane, toxic crisis or decompensated nous sodium iodide; 3) reduce
metformin, and heparin (2). thyrotoxicosis, is a life- the heart rate with a ␤-blocker
When subclinical thyrotoxicosis is threatening emergency charac- (esmolol, metoprolol, proprano-
due to hyperthyroidism (Graves terized by exaggerated manifes- lol) and/or a calcium-channel
disease, toxic multinodular goi- tations of thyrotoxicosis (50 –54). blocker; 4) support the circula-
ter, toxic thyroid adenoma), It usually occurs in patients with tion with stress doses of intrave-
TRAb levels are usually positive unrecognized or inadequately nous glucocorticoids, intrave-

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine In the Clinic ITC61 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


nous fluids, oxygen, and cooling ATD-related agranulocytosis, se- tions occur, when significant GO
(for severe hyperthermia); and 5) vere liver toxicity, or severe vasc- is present, if the patient is preg-
identify and treat the precipitat- ulitis. nant, and when thyroid storm is
ing condition (see the Box: Treat- present or suspected. Clinicians
ment of Thyroid Storm). Plas- When should clinicians
should consider consulting an
mapheresis can be used to consider consulting an ophthalmologist when the pa-
rapidly reduce serum thyroid hor- endocrinologist or tient has double vision; impaired
mone levels in patients who have ophthalmologist? visual acuity, visual fields, or color
previously had significant toxicity Clinicians should consider con- vision; significant eye discomfort;
with an ATD. When thyroid storm sulting an endocrinologist for proptosis greater than 22 mm
was first described, the acute help developing an optimal man- (with an exophthalmometer, if
mortality rate was nearly 100%
agement plan, when unexpected available); or extraocular muscle
(50). The prognosis today is signif-
events or treatment complica- dysfunction.
icantly better when the condition
is promptly diagnosed and ag-
gressive therapy is instituted; mor-
Treatment... Thyrotoxicosis with positive TRAb levels or high or normal
tality rates in recent reports have
RAIU (Graves disease, toxic multinodular goiter, toxic thyroid adenoma)
been less than 10% (52–54). usually requires treatment with an ATD, I-131 ablation, or thyroidec-
When should patients be tomy. Clinicians should inform patients about the benefits and risks of
each possible therapy, after which shared decision making is appropri-
hospitalized? ate. Thyrotoxicosis with negative TRAb levels and low RAIU usually re-
Thyrotoxic patients should be solves within 3 months (except for AIT) and is best treated with
hospitalized if thyroid storm is ␤-blockers to control symptoms until the underlying disorder resolves.
confirmed or suspected. Hospi-
talization should also be consid-
ered for patients who develop CLINICAL BOTTOM LINE

Practice Improvement
What measures do PQRI consists of 318 quality mea-
stakeholders use to evaluate sures; however, none specifically
the quality of care for patients applies to persons with hyperthy-
with thyrotoxicosis? roidism.
Federal legislation passed in What do professional
2006 required the Centers for organizations recommend
Medicare & Medicaid Services
regarding care of patients with
(CMS) to create a physician re-
porting system for quality mea- thyrotoxicosis?
sures regarding covered ser- Professional associations (1, 55,
vices furnished to Medicare 56) have published evidence-
beneficiaries. CMS named this based guidelines for manage-
program the Physician Quality ment of thyrotoxicosis. A shared
Reporting Initiative (PQRI). Eligi- decision-making tool has been
ble professionals who meet the developed to assist patients and
criteria for satisfactory submis- providers when choosing an indi-
sion of data for services can earn vidualized treatment plan for
incentive payments. The 2012 Graves disease (57).

姝 2020 American College of Physicians ITC62 In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


In the Clinic Patient Information

https://medlineplus.gov/hyperthyroidism.html

Tool Kit Patient information and handouts on hyperthyroidism


from the National Institutes of Health's MedlinePlus.

www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/endocrine-dis-
eases/hyperthyroidism
Resources for patients on hyperthyroidism from the Na-
tional Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney
Hyperthyroidism Diseases.

www.thyroid.org/hyperthyroidism

www.thyroid.org/hipertiroidismo
Frequently asked questions on hyperthyroidism in Eng-
lish and Spanish from the American Thyroid Associa-
tion.

IntheClinic
Information for Health Professionals

www.aafp.org/afp/2016/0301/p363.html
Recommendations for diagnosis and treatment of
hyperthyroidism from the American Academy of Family
Physicians.

https://annals.org/aim/fullarticle/2208599/screening
-thyroid-dysfunction-u-s-preventive-services-task
-force-recommendation
2015 recommendation statement on screening for thyroid
dysfunction from the U.S. Preventive Services Task
Force.

www.liebertpub.com/doi/full/10.1089/thy.2016.0229
2016 guidelines for diagnosis and management of hyper-
thyroidism and other causes of thyrotoxicosis from the
American Thyroid Association.

www.karger.com/article/fulltext/490384
2018 guidelines for the management of Graves hyperthy-
roidism from the European Thyroid Association.

www.karger.com/Article/Fulltext/486957
2018 guidelines for the management of amiodarone-
associated thyroid dysfunction from the European Thy-
roid Association.

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine In the Clinic ITC63 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW In the Clinic
Annals of Internal Medicine
ABOUT HYPERTHYROIDISM
What Is Hyperthyroidism?
The thyroid gland is a small gland in the front of
your neck. It makes hormones that control how
the body uses energy. Hyperthyroidism devel-
ops when the thyroid gland makes more thyroid
hormone than your body needs. There can be
several causes, including:
• Graves disease (an autoimmune disorder, and
the most common cause)
• Multiple nodules, or lumps, on the thyroid;
this is known as toxic nodular goiter
• A single, toxic lump on the thyroid; this is
called toxic adenoma
• Thyroiditis, which is an inflammation of the
thyroid gland that causes stored hormones to
leak into the body
What Are Common Symptoms?
iodine (an RAIU, or radioactive iodine uptake
• Weight loss test) and a thyroid scan to identify what is
• Nervousness or anxiety causing your hyperthyroidism.
• Feeling too hot and/or excessive sweating • Your doctor may want to obtain an ultrasound
• Shortness of breath of your thyroid and additional blood testing if
• Rapid heartbeat the cause is unclear or if you are pregnant or
• Trembling hands breastfeeding.
• Frequent bowel movements
• Tiredness How Is It Treated?
• Changes in mood Treatment depends on the cause and severity of
• Eye irritation or discomfort the hyperthyroidism as well as your age, physi-
Sometimes, people with hyperthyroidism have no cal condition, and preferences.
symptoms. Elderly persons may have milder • Beta-blockers can help control your
symptoms that include tiredness, depression, symptoms, including rapid heartbeat, tremors,
weight loss, and rapid heartbeat. anxiety, and heat intolerance. Symptoms

Patient Information
Sometimes, people have sudden onset of severe usually get better very soon after these
symptoms like high fever, irregular heartbeat, medicines are started.
shortness of breath, chest pain, or stomach pain. • Medications called antithyroid drugs may be
Patients with severe symptoms should go to the used to reduce the amount of hormone your
hospital right away. thyroid gland makes.
• Radiation to destroy the thyroid, called radioactive
Am I at Risk? iodine ablation, is a permanent treatment.
Hyperthyroidism is more common in women than • The thyroid may be removed surgically.
in men, especially in those older than 50 years. Talk to your doctor about the benefits and risks of
You may also be at higher risk if you have any of these options and your personal preference.
the following: Until your hyperthyroidism is under control, you
• A goiter (swelling of the thyroid gland in the should avoid strenuous physical activity; reduce
front of your neck) or eliminate caffeine; stop smoking; avoid prod-
• Certain medical conditions, such as type 1 ucts containing iodine, like kelp, iodine supple-
diabetes or other autoimmune disorders ments, and iodinated contrast agents; and avoid
• A family history of thyroid disorder biotin supplements.
• Use of certain medications
Questions for My Doctor
How Is It Diagnosed? • Do I need to take medicine to treat my
• Your doctor will ask about your symptoms and hyperthyroidism?
medical history and examine you. The physical • How long will I have to take the medicine?
examination will include feeling your neck, • Will I need surgery?
where the thyroid gland is. • Are there risks or side effects from the
• You will have blood tests to measure your treatment?
thyroid hormone levels. • How often should I have follow-up visits and
• Your doctor may order a test that measures blood testing?
the ability of the thyroid gland to collect • Will I need to see any other doctors?

For More Information


American Thyroid Association
www.thyroid.org/hyperthyroidism
Medline Plus
https://medlineplus.gov/hyperthyroidism.html

姝 2020 American College of Physicians In the Clinic Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Appendix Table 1. History and Physical Examination in Overt Thyrotoxicosis*
Symptom or Finding Frequency
History
Symptoms of general thyrotoxicosis
Weight loss 61%–85%
Heat intolerance 55%–89%
Tremulousness 54%
Palpitations 51%–89%
Nervousness/anxiety 41%–99%
Emotional lability 30%–60%
Increased stool frequency 22%–33%
Neck fullness 22%
Eye symptoms 11%–54%
Dyspnea 10%–75%
Weight gain 2%–12%
Fatigue 69%–88%
Excessive sweating 45%–91%
Increased appetite 42%–65%
Symptoms specific for Graves disease
Eye swelling NR, variable
Eye redness NR, variable
Eye pain NR, variable
Rash on shins NR, variable
Symptoms specific for subacute thyroiditis
Neck pain NR, variable
Sore throat NR, variable
Fever NR, variable

Physical examination
Findings of general thyrotoxicosis
Palpable goiter 69%–100%
Hand tremor 42%–97%
Adrenergic eye signs (stare, lid lag) 34%–71%
Moist skin 34%
Tachycardia 80%–100%
Atrial fibrillation 3%–10%
Findings specific for Graves disease
Diffuse goiter NR, variable
Bruit over goiter NR, variable
Infiltrative orbitopathy (proptosis, periorbital edema) NR, variable
Pretibial myxedema NR, variable
Thyroid acropachy NR, variable
Findings specific for toxic multinodular goiter
Palpable thyroid nodules NR, variable
Findings specific for toxic thyroid adenoma
Palpable thyroid nodule NR, variable
Findings specific for subacute thyroiditis
Fever NR, variable
Thyroid tenderness NR, variable

NR = not reported.
* Data compiled and adapted from references 7 to 9.

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Appendix Table 2. Elements of Follow-up for Thyrotoxicosis
Issue Method of Evaluation Frequency Notes
History
Response to therapy Ask patient Every visit –
Drug adherence and adverse Ask patient Every visit Patients taking antithyroid drugs
effects

Physical examination
Response to therapy Weigh patient Every visit –
Response to therapy Determine cardiac rate and Every visit Maintain heart rate <90
rhythm beats/min; obtain
electrocardiogram if heart
rate is irregular to exclude
atrial fibrillation
Expect decrease in flow murmur
with treatment
Response to therapy Careful thyroid palpation Every visit Expect decrease in goiter size
with successful Graves
disease treatment
Evaluation of eye signs, including – Every visit –
those specific to Graves disease
Other signs specific to Graves Inspect extremities for Every visit Patients with Graves disease
disease myxedema and thyroid and orbitopathy may also
acropachy develop pretibial myxedema
and thyroid acropachy

Laboratory testing
Response to therapy Obtain free T4 and second- Every visit until stable on T4 improves more rapidly than
or third-generation TSH antithyroid drug regimen TSH
Prolonged TSH suppression
possible after treatment of
moderate to severe
thyrotoxicosis
Response to therapy Measure TSH and TRAb After 12–18 mo of antithyroid To determine whether remission
levels drug therapy of Graves disease has
occurred
Drug adverse effects Liver function tests, CBC Immediately if agranulocytosis Routine measurement not
(fever, sore throat) or liver proven to be cost-effective
toxicity suspected; Methimazole manufacturer
erythrocyte sedimentation recommends performing liver
rate if vasculitis suspected function tests in the event of
during propylthiouracil anorexia, pruritus, jaundice,
treatment or right upper quadrant
Routine monitoring not abdominal pain and stopping
recommended therapy for aminotransferase
elevations >3 times the upper
limit of normal
Change in thyroid examination Ultrasonography When needed for new nodule –
or unexpected scan defect
(cold)

Drug therapy
Response to therapy; drug Adjust dose or change As needed –
adverse effects therapy as needed

Patient education
Course of disease and Discuss expected course and Each visit –
management potential adverse effects of
treatment

CBC = complete blood count; TRAb = thyrotropin receptor antibody; TSH = thyroid-stimulating hormone.

姝 2020 American College of Physicians Annals of Internal Medicine 7 April 2020

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020


Appendix Table 3. Thyroid Storm Scoring System*
Feature Score
Fever
99–99.9 °F 5
100–100.9 °F 10
101–101.9 °F 15
102–102.9 °F 20
103–103.9 °F 25
≥104 °F 30

Central nervous system symptoms


Absent 0
Mild agitation 10
Moderate 20
Severe 30

Cardiac findings
Pulse
99–109 beats/min 5
110–119 beats/min 10
120–129 beats/min 15
130–139 beats/min 20
≥140 beats/min 25
Atrial fibrillation 10
Congestive heart failure
Absent 0
Mild (edema) 5
Moderate (rales) 10
Severe (pulmonary edema) 15

Gastrointestinal symptoms
Absent 0
Nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, pain 10
Jaundice 20

Precipitant history
Absent 0
Present 10

Score
<25 Thyroid storm unlikely
25–44 Suggestive of thyroid storm
≥45 Thyroid storm likely

* From reference 50.

7 April 2020 Annals of Internal Medicine 姝 2020 American College of Physicians

Downloaded from https://annals.org by Jose Jose Alvarez Payares on 04/06/2020

You might also like