Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alamsyah 2023 IOP Conf. Ser. Earth Environ. Sci. 1235 012004
Alamsyah 2023 IOP Conf. Ser. Earth Environ. Sci. 1235 012004
Farmers Using Static Mixer and Dry Washing - Achievement Analysis of One Cylinder
Diesel Engine Using Virgin Coconut Oil
Biodiesel
To cite this article: Rizal Alamsyah et al 2023 IOP Conf. Ser.: Earth Environ. Sci. 1235 012004 Burhan Yuliansyah, Triwidagdo and
Abuhasan
Rizal Alamsyah1, Maharani Dewi Solikhah1, Agus Kismanto1 and Susi Heryani2
1
Organization for Energy and Manufacture, National Research and Innovation
Agency (BRIN)
2
Center for Agro-based Industry, Ministry of Indutry-Indonesia
Email: rizalams@yahoo.com
1. Introduction
World oil prices continued to increase significantly, which has impacted the price of domestic fuel oil
(BBM) in Indonesia, which is still using the subsidy scheme. Such condition influences the
government's subsidy budget (Jazuli et al 2021). This situation happens not only for world crude oil
prices but also for the price of gas, which has an impact on the increase in the price of non-subsidized
Liquefied Petroleum Gas (Kuehl et al 2021).
To reduce the consumption of fossil fuels, the government strives to accelerate the implementation
of new and renewable energy (EBT) to achieve the target of 23% new renewable energy (EBT) in the
national energy mix in 2025 as mandated by the National Energy General Plan (Simanjuntak 2022). In
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution
of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.
Published under licence by IOP Publishing Ltd 1
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
developing renewable energy as well as bioenergy, various efforts have been conducted, including the
development of small-scale biofuel production (Raharjo et al 2022).
One of the important and widely used fossil fuels in Indonesia is diesel fuel, which is being
replaced by biodiesel. Biodiesel is a fuel substitute for diesel oil derived from vegetable oils such as
coconut oil and palm oil. Biodiesel can potentially replace diesel oil and can solve fuel oil (BBM)
problems in the future (Liew et al 2014). In line with that, coconut and palm oil as feedstocks are
considered adequate to support the development of biodiesel production in Indonesia without
disrupting the food sector (Rahman et al 2022, Guimaraes Pereira et al 2014).
Indonesia is one of the biggest coconut producers countries in the world. It has production of 14.50
billion kernels per year with an area of 3.88 million hectares of coconut trees and 98% of which are
community plantations. The number of coconut farmers involved in the business of coconut
cultivation in Indonesia is 6.155 million households (International Coconut Community 2017). Most
coconut production in Indonesia is produced by the plantation of people who are located in remote
areas (Alouw and Wulandari 2019). Coconut produced in this area is very difficult to distribute,
especially to outsiders areas or islands. Some of the coconuts produced in remote areas it is made into
copra. Coconut farmers are often faced with the unstable selling price of copra. Indonesia has a very
long coastal area where coconut trees grow abundantly and has the potential to be developed as an
alternative fuel for coco-biodiesel (biodiesel derived from coconut/copra). The use of coco-biodiesel
in remote areas is expected to help the government to create self-sufficient energy and to improve the
community's economy therefore for coconut farmers in remote areas, the presence of biodiesel will be
very helpful. In Indonesia, biodiesel is produced by large-scale factories for the use of diesel oil blends
and export (Tupa R. Silalahi et al 2020). For that reason, it is necessary to introduce small-scale
biodiesel processing with appropriate equipment so that it can be operated by coconut farmers in
plantation areas or remote areas (Jamaran 2008).
Coconut oil and palm oil are potential vegetable oils to be used as raw materials for biodiesel
because of their superior characteristics (Fukuda et al 2001). In terms of quality, biodiesel produced
from coconut oil and palm oil has a higher cetane number than biodiesel derived from vegetable oils.
Also compared to fossil fuels, the process of making biodiesel is easier. There are three
processes/steps for biodiesel processing, namely degumming, transesterification, washing, or
purification (Alamsyah et al 2010).
The stirring factor strongly influences biodiesel production. The problem with conventional mixing
is that the two phases of the material (vegetable oil and methanol) in the reaction are difficult to mix.
If the agitator blade is used, rotation is not high enough to give a maximum mixing effect, so it isn’t
easy to get a short reaction time due to a slow reaction rate (Koflo Corp 2006). In this study, crude
coconut oil was processed using a static mixer reactor. The static mixer reactor is used for
transesterification process, where coconut oil is converted into coco-biodiesel. The advantage of using
a static mixer is that the stirring mechanism is more effective, so that biodiesel will form faster. Static
mixers can be applied to mix fluids that have low viscosity, high viscosity, fibrous materials and for
blending processes (Thompson and He 2007, Paul et al 2003). The shear stress in the static mixer will
be higher because the shear stress result is quite large. The value of shear force will be increased
because the fluid (reactants) are splitted, twisted, turned, and recombined (Paul et al 2003).
Washing of crude biodiesel methods should be always continuously developed, due to the results of
the process which will largely determine the quality of biodiesel, energy consumption, and overall
production costs (Zhang et al 2003). One of the methods that can be applied is the dry method (dry
washing) which is useful to remove all soap and dirt from crude biodiesel without using water. There
are several ways to dry washing biodiesel for instance biodiesel purification by washing or cleaning
agent or absorbent technology is one of the solutions that can be offered (Faccini et al 2011). The
disadvantages of biodiesel dry washing system are the additional equipment to perform the dry
washing column (membrane) and the pump, and when using resin it needs to be washed. Applied dry-
washing biodiesel is highly recommended because it will save water and time. In addition, to shorter
2
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
time needed especially to get products ready, the sooner biodiesel produced the faster can be used
(Atadashi 2015).
The purpose of this study is to introduce a process and equipment prototype for processing coco-
biodiesel that can be operated on a small scale which is suitable for coconut farmers, especially in
remote areas. Meanwhile, the benefits expected from this study are to create a design of energy self-
sufficiency village through the utilization of local resource potential namely copra where these
materials are very abundant in coconut-producing main areas and generally located in isolated areas.
Hopefully, these villages can create new job opportunities, provide productive economic activities,
and increase the income of coconut farmers.
2.2. Methods
The experimental methods for making coco-biodiesel from CNO consisted of the following steps:
1) degumming, 2) transesterification, 3) settling, 4) washing of crude coco-biodiesel, 5) testing of
coco-biodiesel quality, including methyl ester content, free glycerol, total glycerol, viscosity, water
content, density, iodine number, acid number, and Free fatty acid or FFA, and 6) recovery of
methanol. The coco-biodiesel processing flow chart can be seen in Figure 1.
3
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
2.2.1. Degumming
The degumming process was conducted by adding phosphoric acid into CNO with a concentration of
2% (V/V), then the reactants were heated at a temperature of 80–90°C for two hours. After that, the
mixture was settled for 4 hours (Alamsyah 2020). The degumming process can be done with a
centrifuge and the treatment is the same with the addition of phosphoric acid and heating, followed by
centrifugation for 1-2 hours.
Since the free fatty acid value of CNO is around 5 - 6%, it must be reduced to below 5%. After the
degumming process, the FFA (Free fatty acid) value was tested. If the FFA content is less than 5%, the
oil can be processed directly. However, If the FFA content is higher than 5%, it will consume a lot of
catalyst and coco-biodiesel products that have high soap content. When FFA levels are high, the
esterification process must be carried out with an acid catalyst (Ramadhas et al 2005).
2.2.2. Transesterification
The synthesis of coco-biodiesel was conducted by transesterification of crude palm oil with methanol
using a static-mixer reactor (Figure 2). The molar ratio between CNO and methanol consists of 1: 10,
1: 6, and 1: 4. Each treatment was repeated three times, and the results were averaged. The purpose of
the variation of the molar ratio is to obtain optimum conditions for the use of methanol to produce
maximum coco-biodiesel yield and to obtain the shortest reaction time so that the transesterification
process can be operated out economically.
The amount of KOH used was 1% of the amount of crude coconut oil. The first stage in the
production of coco-biodiesel was by heating the coconut oil in a reactor at a specified temperature
(65°C) and at the same time methanol was mixed with KOH. When the desired temperature of crude
coconut oil is reached, a mixture of KOH with methanol is put into the reactor, then mixing was
started and the pump was turned on so that the mixture of reactants passes through the reactor and
static mixer at a speed of 1.25 m/s.
4
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
Sampling during the transesterification process was carried out at 2, 5, 10, 15, 30, 60, and 90
minutes. After 90 minutes, the product mixture flowed into a settling tank. The resulting product was
allowed to stand for 4 hours to form a glycerol layer at the bottom and a methyl ester layer at the top
(coco-biodiesel). Furthermore, the coco-biodiesel is washed or purified using dry/membrane washing.
1. Feed inlet
2. Condenser
3. Sprayer
4. Static mixer
5. Heater
6. Pump
7. outlet
2.2.3. Settling
After transesterification, the mixture of reactants has flowed into the settling tank. The product formed
was settled for 4 hours to form a glycerol layer on the bottom and a methyl ester layer (coco-biodiesel)
at the top. The two layers are formed due to the difference in specific weight. The glycerol layer
formed still contains methanol. Next, the two layers are separated by flowing glycerol at the bottom
and settled in a separate tank. Meanwhile, the coco biodiesel layer is flowed by a circulation pump to
the washing tank.
2.2.4. Washing
To wash crude coco-biodiesel in the washing reactor, crude coco-biodiesel was collected into the
feeder tank. This tank serves to accommodate crude biodiesel to be washed or purified. Crude coco-
biodiesel was flowed using rotary gear pumps into the membrane such that crude biodiesel will be
filtered out and flowed to the pipe covered by the membrane, while the impurities that do not pass the
filter will be trapped inside the membrane (Atadashi 2015). Refined biodiesel then will collect into an
outlet. Measurements of the flow rate of dry washing of biodiesel were done by collecting 1 litter of
refined biodiesel in one minute.
For washing biodiesel using water, 30 liters of water are heated at a temperature of 90 degrees
Celsius. Hot water then flowed into 10 kg of crude biodiesel repeatedly. Feeding of hot water is
stopped when the water that passed through biodiesel has a clear color and at the same time, the water
consumption for this washing method was calculated (Bateni 2017). Biodiesel was then dried at a
temperature of 100-110 degrees Celsius until the air bubbles disappear.
Measurement of the amount of energy required for dry washing was by measuring the power of a
1.5 hp electric motor to filter crude biodiesel into the membrane and to flow crude biodiesel from the
tank to the feeder tank using a kWh-meter. It was also calculated the energy released by operators
during the washing process takes place. The energy consumption for water washing was also
5
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
measured using a kWh-meter. The measurement was done for: the measurement of heat energy
released from the heater (1500 Watts) for heating water up to 90°C, the measurement of heat energy
released from the heater for drying biodiesel at a temperature of 110°C, and the measurement of
energy for drainage biodiesel and water for washing using electric pumps 250 watts. The energy
released from operators was also measured. According to Stout (1990), the energy released from
operators can be calculated by multiplying the number of operators worked with a calorific value of
human labor (0.94 MJ/person) divided by production capacity (kg/h).
Second, each layer still contains methanol. Washing is done several times until the washing water
is clear, at least 2 times. At the time of decantation, need to be careful in separating and removing the
undercoat. Tank washing is equipped with a heater and hot water inlet (80–90°C) as well as a
circulation pump. Need anticipation for vaporized methanol (condenser). After washing, it is
necessary to analyze the levels of glycerol and acid number.
2.2.5. Drying
Coco-biodiesel drying tank and glycerol purification were conducted with the same process or
equipment, because the mechanism was also the same, namely by evaporating the methanol that
remained in these two reactants and applying a vacuum pressure of 1 atm (360 cm Hg) which
previously preheated at a temperature of 100-110°C.
6
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
3.2. Settling
After transesterification, the reactant mixture was flowed into a settling tank and settled for 4 hours
until two layers were formed, namely the top layer (coco-biodiesel) and the bottom layer (glycerol)
which has a higher density than coco-biodiesel. The appearance of coco-biodiesel was different from
crude coconut oil. The coco-biodiesel has a light yellow color and has a lower viscosity than glycerol.
Meanwhile, glycerol was more viscous than coco-biodiesel. The glycerol layer formed still contains
methanol. Next, the two layers are separated by flowing glycerol at the bottom and stored in a separate
tank. Meanwhile, the coco-biodiesel layer flowed to the washing tank. The product of coco-biodiesel
and glycerol (a by-product of the transesterification process) can be seen in Figure 3.
Figure 3. Coco-biodiesel and glycerol produced from transesterification using a static mixer
As shown in Table 1, the production of coco-biodiesel using a static-mixer reactor with 98.30%
FAME was reached after 30 minutes. By reacting 30 kg of CNO and 8.2 kg of methanol produced
39.24 kg of coco-biodiesel and 5.33 kg of glycerol. The average weight of coco-biodiesel and glycerol
obtained after washing and drying were 28.8 kg and 3,81 kg respectively. The amount of coco-
biodiesel obtained was higher than 28.8 kg, it was because there was still some left in the static mixer
pipe, so the amount was slightly reduced. Glycerol still contained a small amount of methanol which is
carried from the transesterification process so it needs to be evaporated.
3.3. Washing
Table 2 below shows the results of the energy analysis for washing coco-biodiesel both by dry
washing (membrane) and washing using hot water. The energy used in dry washing consists of the
energy used by the pump to flow the crude coco-biodiesel to the membrane, to flow the coco-biodiesel
from the holding tank to the feeder tank, and the energy released from the operator during processing.
Meanwhile, for the method of washing coco-biodiesel with hot water, the energy used consists of
energy to heat water, to heat coco-biodiesel, to flow coco-biodiesel (pumps), and for operators. From
Table 2, it can be seen that the energy used in dry washing was much smaller than the energy used in
water washing. Based on this table, the energy consumption for the dry washing method can be
reduced from 1361.81 kJ/kg to 315.49 kJ/kg and the energy ratio between energy for dry washing and
energy for water washing was 0.23. It was also exhibited that the use of dry washing methods energy
released by the operator was reduced from 92.72 kJ/kg to 24.21 kJ/kg.
7
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
Table 2. Comparison of energy used for washing crude coco-biodiesel (dry washing and hot water)
Types of washing Energy (kJ/kg)
Dry-washing
- Pump (membrane) 288
- Pump (holding tank) 3.28
- Operator 24.21
Total 315.49
Water washing
- Heater (heating water) 968
- Heater (heating biodiesel) 268
- Pump 13.09
- Operator 92.72
Total 1361.81
8
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
independent energy village will support environmental harmony, it will not hurt the environment, and
it will not be exploitative.
To realize energy self-sufficiency or an energy-independent village, one of the ways is to use a
green investment scheme (Cakranegara and Sidjabat 2021). Green investment program funds are
supported by several world and national institutions as well as national and international banks. Green
Investment is an investment scheme environmentally friendly and whose main condition is that the
business is carried out must be safe and do not destruct the environment. Green Investment Concept
directed the establishment of agricultural products businesses and community plantations, including
coconut plantations to be processed or increased its added value. The green investment must have a
real impact on the local community. Many remote areas of Indonesia still have conditions like this, so
it is necessary to empower coconut natural resources for local economic activities.
4. Conclusion
The use of a static mixer can increase the effectiveness of the transesterification process of coconut
natural oil (CNO) into coco-biodiesel. The use of a static mixer has a significant effect in reducing the
reaction time of the transesterification process in the biodiesel production process. To achieve a fatty
acid methyl ester (FAME) content of 96.5% as required in the SNI Biodiesel Standard (SNI 04-7182-
2006), the static mixer reactor only takes 15 minutes at a temperature of 65°C at a flow rate of 1.25
m/s. The optimum conditions for the transesterification process can be achieved with a molar ratio of
1: 6 (TG: methanol) which can provide minimal use of methanol. The use of a static-mixer reactor also
produces biodiesel quality characteristics that meet the requirements of SNI Biodiesel (SNI 04-7182-
2006).
The washing capacity of crude coco-biodiesel using a dry washing reactor (membrane) was higher
than washing using hot water, namely 0.67 litter/minute. The reactor was able to reduce the amount of
washing energy to 1046.32 kJ / kg which was 23.2% smaller than the energy for washing water. By
using the dry method, it was able to eliminate the use of 30 liters of water for washing 10 kg of crude
biodiesel.
References
[1] Jazuli M R, Steenmans I and Mulugetta Y 2021 Navigating policy dilemmas in fuel-subsidy
reductions: learning from Indonesia’s experiences Sustainability: Science, Practice and
Policy 17 391–403
[2] Kuehl J, Maulidia, M K, Bajaj and Boelts S 2021 Liquefied Petroleum Gas Subsidy Reform in
Indonesia: Lessons learned from international experience, International Institute for
Sustainable Development May 2021 p 3-7.
[3] Simanjuntak U 2022 In 2022, Indonesia Needs to Strive in Pursuing Energy Transition
Ecosystem Readiness Institute For Essential Reforms (IESR), January 2022
[4] Raharjo J, Rahmat B, Hasudungan J and Adam K B 2022 Breakthrough in Achieving Energy
Mix Target in Indonesia Paper presented at 2022 5th International Conference on Energy
Conservation and Efficiency, ICECE, 16-17 March 2022 1-10
[5] Liew W H, Hassim M H and Ng D K S 2014 Review of evolution, technology and sustainability
assessments of biofuel production Journal of Cleaner Production 71 11–29
[6] Rahman T, Arkeman Y, Setyaningsih D and Saparita R 2017 Indonesian CPO availability
analysis to support food and energy security: a system dynamic approach Paper presented at
ICBB Conference, June, 2017
[7] Guimaraes Pereira R, Tulcan O E P, Fellows C E, Silva I M D, Filho D M D E S, Lameira V D
J and Quelhas O L G 2014 Energy generation using coconut biodiesel and coconut oil in a
stationary engine International Journal of Oil, Gas and Coal Technology 7 450
[8] International Coconut Community 2017 Coconut Statistical Year Book Jakarta: International
Coconut Community
[9] Alouw J C and Wulandari S 2019 Present status and outlook of coconut development in
9
50th International Coconut Technical Conference IOP Publishing
IOP Conf. Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1235 (2023) 012004 doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1235/1/012004
10