Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ethics Reviewer
Ethics Reviewer
*According to St. Thomas Aquinas, the fundamental Freedom is a Gift – ability to act significantly, gift given
difference between animal ethics and human ethics is to us by God.
that animals behave instinctively while human
Freedom is Complementary to Reason – freedom and
behavior is rational.
reason as necessary faculties for consciously making
Instinctive behavior – hard-wired, inborn, sense of things (Aristotle)
characteristic response to specific environmental
Freedom is Absolute – “absolutely free” (Jean-Paul
stimuli; an example is the altruistic behavior of social
Satre)
animals
Freedom demands Responsibility – Satre’s idea was
Rational behavior – decision-making process where
that freedom is the capacity to choose, that even not
the person acts in ways that best achieve his or her
choosing is a choice; responsibility follows freedom
needs in accordance with his or her set preferences,
priorities, and principles. *Responsibility as a moral quality serves as a
voluntary check and balance of one’s freedom.”
*Thus, only human beings can be ethical because only
humans have the capacity for free moral judgment. How Culture Shapes Human Behavior
− Judgment at this level is solely focused on the 1. Reason alone cannot be a motive to the will,
self but rather is the “slave of the passions”
a. Stage 1: Punishment-Obedience Orientation 2. Moral distinctions are not derived from
- “pre-moral” stage where decisions reason.
and actions are determined by 3. Moral distinctions are derived from the
moral sentiments: feelings of approval
(esteem, praise) and disapproval (blame) felt What is the Role of Feelings in Decision-Making?
by spectators who contemplate a character
*Our moral compasses are also powerfully influenced
trait or action.
by feelings.
4. While some virtues and vices are natural,
others (including justice are artificial. *Reasoning in moral decisions is preceded by an initial
intuition or gutfeel
According to his “Theory of the Mind”, humans have
what he called passions (which he used to describe Alfred Jules Ayer described two elements in moral
emotions or feelings). judgment:
a. Direct – caused directly by the sensation of a. Emotive – expressing positive feelings towards
pain or pleasure Ex. hope, fear a particular act. Ex. “Kindness is good” meant
b. Indirect – cased by the sensation of pain or you feel positive about acts of kindness
pleasure derived from some other idea or b. Prescriptive – an instruction or prescription of
impression. Ex. love, ambition and humility a particular behavior. Ex. “Be kind t o others”
this act encouraged others to follow
Scheler and the Philosophy of Feelings
Why feelings can be obstacles to making right
Max Ferdinand Scheler
decisions?
− German ethical philosopher, “emotion is the
1. Its non-deliberate nature
most important aspect in human existence”
2. Its partial nature
− asserted that emotions/feelings are inherent, 3. It is capricious
objective, and it exists even if you have not
experience it before (a priori) Deliberate – act was intentional, planned, with
− claimed that feelings are independent of the conscious effort.
mind; that it corresponds to the Divine Nondeliberate – contrary term that denotes
feelings are not chaotic. spontaneous actions
− feelings are the “PUREST SPERE” of human
consciousness *Emotions are no different from mindless automatic
reflex.
Four Strata of Feelings:
Aaron Been Zeev summarized the nondeliberate
1. Sensual Feelings – bodily pleasures or pain nature of feelings as follows:
2. Vital Feelings – life functions, health &
sickness 1. Responsibility entails free choice; if we are not
3. Psychic Feelings – about aesthetics, justice, free to behave in a certain manner, then we
and knowledge are not responsible for this behavior.
4. Spiritual Feelings – deal with the Divine 2. Free choice entails an intellectual deliberation
in which alternative are considered and the
*Spiritual feelings alone are INTENTIONAL, directed to best one is chosen.
a particular special object or a higher being, the 3. Since intellectual deliberation is absent from
Divine” emotions, we cannot be responsible for our
Difference Between Responses Based on Reason and emotions.
on Feelings The Partial Nature of Feelings
Dr. James Rachels – asserted that in moral reasoning, “the law of concern”, emotions are quiet when it is of
you could not rely on your feelings no matter how no personal concern, interested only in the immediate
powerful these feeling may be. situation, no rational explanations
An argument is reasonable if: Two aspects in the partial nature of emotions:
a. The facts are correct. 1. Decisions based on feelings focus only on a
b. The moral principles are correctly applied narrow area
c. Each individual’s well-being is treated equally 2. It reflects personal and self0interest
important. perspectives
*Emotions influence our attention Dr. Rachels – “at the very least is the effort to guide
one’s action based on the most logical choice (reason)
The Capricious Nature of Feelings
while giving equal importance to the interests of each
*Emotions rises for arbitrary reasons. person affected by your decisions (impartiality)
How Emotions Help in Making the Right Decisions The 7-step Moral Reasoning Model
*Emotions are the foundation of all our cognitive and 1. Gather the facts
behavioral processes; and emotional responses often 2. Identify the stakeholders
guide a person in making beneficial choices without 3. Articulate the dilemma
any conscious reasoning 4. List the alternatives
5. Compare the alternative with the principles
Three ways that feelings, especially negative feelings, 6. Weigh the consequences
help in making decisions: 7. Make a decision
1. It signals the need to adjust behavior LESSON 3
2. It can help us learn from our mistakes
3. Emotional responses can be reshaped as time Moral Courage – courage to put your moral principles
pass by into action even though you may be in doubts, are
afraid, or face adverse consequence.
Counterfactual thinking – psychological concept
about human tendency to create possible or Mark Johnson – it is important to have “an ability to
alternative scenarios other than what had actually imaginatively discern various possibilities fo action
happened. within a given situation to envision the potential help
and harm that are likely to result from a given action
Mindfulness – give active and open attention to called MORAL IMAGINATION
personal thoughts and feelings show that, with some
effort, emotional reactions can be brought in accord Moral Imagination – ability in particular
with your beliefs and goals. circumstances to discover and evaluate possibilities
not merely determined by that circumstance or
LESSON 2 limited by its operative mental mode or merely
Why should human beings be moral? framed by a set of rules or rule-governed concerns.
Immanuel Kant – reason alone is the basis for Self-mastery – product of the “will” that is achieved
morality, and once the person understood this basic by actually putting rational, moral choice into action
requirement for morality, he or she would see that
acting morally is the same an acting rationally.