Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TMS3729 - 2024 Study Guide 10043322
TMS3729 - 2024 Study Guide 10043322
Sciences in FET
Only Study Guide for
TMS3729
university
of south africa
©2022 University of South Africa
Published by the
University of South Africa
Muckleneuk, Pretoria
TMS3729/OL/001-4/2023
10043322
Teaching Physical
Sciences in FET
Only Study Guide for
TMS3729
Department of Science and Technology
University of South Africa,
Pretoria
CONTENTS
Page
INTRODUCTIONv
Lesson 4: Assessment32
4.1 What is assessment? 32
4.2 Why assess? 32
4.3 Types of assessment 33
4.3.1 Baseline assessment 33
4.3.2 Diagnostic assessment 33
4.3.3 Formative assessment 33
4.3.4 Summative assessment 33
4.3.5 Systematic assessment 34
4.3.6 Alternative assessment 34
...........
iii TMS3729/1
CO N T EN T S
...........
iv
I nt r o d u c t i o n
INTRODUCTION
Please access the below Electronic Reserves (e-reserves) as additional study
material for this module. E-reserves can be downloaded from the Library
catalogue. More information is available at: http://libguides.unisa.ac.za/request/
request
...........
v TMS3729/1
INTRODUCTION
...........
vi
L E SS O N 1: T h e d is t i n c t i ve n at u r e o f p hy si c a l s c i e n ce s
1 LESSON 1
LEARNING OUTCOMES
At the end of this lesson unit, you should be able to answer the following criti-
cal questions:
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this unit is to give you guidance on how to work through the
outcomes of the Module. In this module, we endeavour to move away from
the traditional way of teaching Physical Science. We will concentrate on
understanding the basic concepts, which forms the foundation of the learning
of physical science.
There are many activities in this study guide. We advise you to buy an exercise
book and to do the activities.
Before you read any further, we need you think about what Physical Science
means to you.
...........
1 TMS3729/1
Ac tivit y 1.1
Write a short paragraph on your experiences as a learner in a Physical
Science class when you were at school. Write at least one good experience
and one bad experience.
...........
2
L E SS O N 1: T h e d is t i n c t i ve n at u r e o f p hy si c a l s c i e n ce s
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
...........
3 TMS3729/1
Ac tivit y 1. 2
Write a paragraph to describe what you think each of the scenarios
represent. Do not rush through the activity. Write as much as you can
about the situation in each scenario.
Third, even though scientific knowledge is, at least partially, based on and/or
derived from observations of the natural world (i.e., empirical), it nevertheless
involves human imagination and creativity. Science, contrary to common
belief, is not a totally lifeless, rational, and orderly activity. Science involves
the invention of explanations and this requires a great deal of creativity by
scientists. The “leap” from atomic spectral lines to Bohr’s model of the atom
with its elaborate orbits and energy levels is a case in point. This aspect of
science, coupled with its inferential nature, entails that scientific concepts, such
as atoms, black holes, and species, are functional theoretical models rather
than faithful copies of reality (Lederman, Lederman, & Antink 2013).
conduct their investigations, what they observe (and do not observe), and
how they make sense of, or interpret their observations. It is this (sometimes
collective) individuality or mind-set that accounts for the role of subjectivity
in the production of scientific knowledge. It is noteworthy that, contrary
to common belief, science never starts with neutral observations (Chalmers,
1982). Observations (and investigations) are always motivated and guided by
and acquire meaning in reference to questions or problems. These questions
or problems, in turn, are derived from within certain theoretical perspectives.
(Lederman, Lederman, & Antink 2013).
Sixth, it follows from the previous discussions that scientific knowledge is never
absolute or certain. This knowledge, including “facts,” theories, and laws, is
tentative and subject to change. Scientific claims change as new evidence,
made possible through advances in theory and technology, is brought to bear
on existing theories or laws, or as old evidence is reinterpreted in the light of
new theoretical advances or shifts in the directions of established research
programs. It should be emphasized that tentativeness in science does not
only arise from the fact that scientific knowledge is inferential, creative, and
socially and culturally embedded. There are also compelling logical arguments
that lend credence to the notion of tentativeness in science. Indeed, contrary
to common belief, scientific hypotheses, theories, and laws can never be
absolutely “proven.” This holds irrespective of the amount of empirical evidence
gathered in the support of one of these ideas or the other (Popper, 1963,
1988). For example, to be “proven,” a certain scientific law should account for
every single instance of the phenomenon it purports to describe at all times.
It can logically be argued that one such future instance, of which we have no
knowledge whatsoever, may behave in a manner contrary to what the law
states. As such, the law can never acquire an absolutely “proven” status. This
equally holds in the case of hypotheses and theories (Lederman, Lederman,
& Antink 2013).
...........
6
L E SS O N 1: T h e d is t i n c t i ve n at u r e o f p hy si c a l s c i e n ce s
Finally, it is important to note that individuals often conflate NOS with science
processes (which is more consistent with scientific inquiry). Although these
aspects of science overlap and interact in important ways, it is nonetheless
important to distinguish the two. Scientific processes are activities related to
collecting and analysing data, and drawing conclusions (AAAS, 1990, 1993;
NRC, 1996). For example, observing and inferring are scientific processes. On
the other hand, NOS refers to the epistemological underpinnings of the activities
of science. As such, realizing that observations are necessarily theory-laden
and are constrained by our perceptual apparatus belongs within the realm of
NOS (Lederman, Lederman, & Antink 2013).
Ac tivit y 1. 3
What do you understand by the way of knowing?
Ac tivit y 1.4
What is the difference between observation and inference. Write two
paragraphs.
Illustrate the difference between observation and inference using an
example.
Ac tivit y 1. 5
Explain the difference between theory and laws
Illustrate the difference between the theory and laws using an example
...........
7 TMS3729/1
Ac tivit y 1.6
Explain what you understand by science as a human enterprise practiced
in the context culture. Your answer should be based on the African culture
supported by examples.
Ac tivit y 1.7
Explain the following aspects of the nature of Science and give examples
• Scientific knowledge is tentative.
• Scientific knowledge has basis in empirical evidence.
• There is a difference between data and evidence.
• Scientific laws and theories are separate kinds of scientific knowledge.
• Scientific knowledge is based upon observations and inferences.
• Scientific knowledge is heavily dependent upon theories.
• Scientific knowledge is created from human imagination and logical
reasoning.
• Scientific knowledge can be obtained by a variety of scientific methods.
• Scientific observations are inherently subjective based on interpretations.
• Science is a human endeavor influenced by society and culture.
Ac tivit y 1. 8
What makes Physical Science different from other subjects? (Nature of
Science)
How does this influence your preparation of the lessons?
Ac tivit y 1.9
What is your view of the nature of science in the South African teaching
context.
Ac tivit y 1.10
Looking at Physical Science as a subject. Do you think the subject Physical
Science can be Africanised. Write two paragraphs give examples.
on transmitting these values” (Metz & Gaie 2010). “However, it does not
follow that moral education is simply a matter of ensuring students mimic
the past, for three reasons. First, being concerned for the good of students
entails not utterly restricting their knowledge to that of a fairly circumscribed
culture, particularly in a globalised world in which even rural communities
have to engage with a wide array of foreign people, policies and institutions.
It is implausible to think a given culture at a particular moment is optimal,
or even adequate, for the welfare of all the people who participate in it.
So, the injunction to exhibit solidarity with others gives a moral educator
reason not to quash student doubt about the propriety of an existing way
of life. Second, in order to genuinely share a way of life, a moral educator
ought not to rely on threats and rote regurgitation. Truly sharing a way of
life means voluntarily participating in it, for part of what is valuable about
a loving or friendly relationship is the fact that people come together, and
stay together, of their own accord. Third, since becoming a person includes
caring about the quality of others’ lives, a moral educator needs to help
develop students’ capacity for sympathy and encourage them to engage in
mutual aid with themselves, their extended families and the broader society”
(Metz & Gaie 2010).
Ac tivit y 1.11
Write two paragraphs in which you explain how the Ubuntu principles can
be used in the teaching of physical science. Give examples.
When teaching Physical Sciences, you must contribute towards the holistic
development of your learners in the following ways (South Africa, Department
of Education 2003):
(1) Give learners the opportunity to apply scientific principles, so that their
understanding of the world in which they live will be evident.
(2) Stimulate their curiosity and interest in the natural and physical world in
which they live.
(3) Develop their insight into and respect for different scientific perspectives,
(4) and cultivate in them a sensitivity for the cultural beliefs, prejudices and
practices of society.
(5) Help them to develop the skills and values that will prepare them for
various situations in life.
...........
10
L E SS O N 1: T h e d is t i n c t i ve n at u r e o f p hy si c a l s c i e n ce s
Ac tivit y 1.12
Describe different ways of presenting knowledge and facilitating learning
of Physical Science in each of the above (1–5).
Discuss the role of the teacher in ensuring that (1–5 above) is achieved.
10 40 30 10
11 40 30 10
12 40 28 12
...........
11 TMS3729/1
...........
12
L E SS O N 1: T h e d is t i n c t i ve n at u r e o f p hy si c a l s c i e n ce s
Topic Content
Grade 10 Magnetism (magnetic field of permanent magnets, poles
of permanent magnets, attraction and repulsion, magnetic
field lines, earth’s magnetic field, compass), Electrostatics
(two kinds of charge, force exerted by charges on each other
(descriptive), attraction between charged and uncharged
objects (polarisation), charge conservation, charge
quantization ),Electric circuits (emf, potential difference (pd),
Electricity & current, measurement of voltage (pd) and current, resistance,
Magnetism resistors in parallel) 14 hours
Grade 11 Electrostatics (Coulomb’s Law, Electric field), Electro-
magnetism (Magnetic field associated with current-carrying
wires, Faraday’s Law), Electric circuits (Energy, Power) 20 hours
Grade 12 Electric circuits (internal resistance and series-
parallel networks), Electrodynamics (electrical machines
(generators, motors), alternating current) 12 hours
...........
13 TMS3729/1
Topic Content
Chemical Grade 10 Physical and chemical change (separation by physical means;
Change separation by chemical means; conservation of atoms
and mass; law of constant composition; conservation of
energy).Representing chemical change (balanced chemical
equations). Reactions in aqueous solution (ions in aqueous
solutions; ion interaction; electrolytes; conductivity;
precipitation; chemical reaction types) Stoichiometry (mole
concept). 24 hours
Grade 11 Stoichiometry (molar volume of gases; concentration; limiting
reagents; volume relationships in gaseous reactions) Energy
and chemical change (energy changes related to bond
energy; exothermic and endothermic reactions; activation
energy). Types of reactions (acid-base; redox reactions;
oxidation numbers 28 hours
Grade 12 Reaction rate (factors affecting rate; measuring rate;
mechanism of reaction and of catalysis). Chemical equilibrium
(factors affecting equilibrium; equilibrium constant;
application of equilibrium principles). Acids and bases
(reactions; titrations, pH, salt hydrolysis). Electrochemical
reactions (electrolytic and galvanic cells; relation of current
and potential to rate and equilibrium; standard electrode
potentials; oxidation and reduction half reaction and cell
reactions; oxidation numbers; application of redox reactions).
28 hours
...........
14
L E SS O N 2: Te a c h i n g a n d l e a r n i n g s t r ate g i e s i n p hy si c a l s c i e n ce
2 LESSON 2
science
LEARNING OUTCOMES
We will know that qualifying student teachers are competent when they can:
• Highlight and critically appraise the similarities and differences between the
various teaching methods, learning strategies, and teaching media appropriate
to the teaching of their subject in different contexts;
• Choose the most applicable method(s) for the teaching and learning of different
aspects of their subject in different contexts;
• Choose, adapt or design the most applicable teaching media for teaching different
aspects of their subject in different contexts; and
• Select and use appropriate technology for teaching different aspects of their
subject in different contexts.
2.1 INTRODUCTION
There is a lot of teaching strategies in use in the schools. Teachers often wonder
about the alternative teaching strategies that are more effective. The study
unit will look at a number of teaching and learning strategies in the science
classroom.
We hope that, after you have worked through this unit, you will have realised
that combining the best of the old ideas with fresh ideas about teaching and
learning will enable you to become a better quality Physical Science teacher.
Ac tivit y 2.1
In your view what is a teaching strategy and what is the learning strategy?
...........
15 TMS3729/1
Ac tivit y 2. 2
What do you understand by the following statements:
...........
16
L E SS O N 2: Te a c h i n g a n d l e a r n i n g s t r ate g i e s i n p hy si c a l s c i e n ce
Ac tivit y 2. 3
Explain the difference between the traditional or verification lab and the
investigative or inquiry approach. Write two paragraphs supported by
relevant classroom examples.
Ac tivit y 2.4
What are the implications of the constructivist perspective for learning
in the science classroom? Write two pages. Provide examples to illustrate
your answer.
Discuss the role of the teacher and learners in a classroom when
constructivism is used as a strategy.
Ac tivit y 2. 5
What is the effects of using various teaching strategies in the science
classrooms?
Critically discuss the following statements:
“Through inquiry, students develop or construct an understanding of
a concept for themselves, with the teacher facilitating the classroom
activities and discussion”
“When science teachers use strategies that require students to be
both physically and mentally engaged, they facilitate the active
construction of meaning”
(Write a page and half, use classroom examples).
Ac tivit y 2.6
Think about the teaching and learning strategies that you can use in the
science classroom to the teach the following topics and discuss the merits
and demerits of each.
• Newton’s First Law of Motion
• Principle of conservation of momentum.
• Doppler effect
Write at least four teaching strategies and four learning strategies.
Students bring prior naïve knowledge into a physics class. “Some
researchers describe student knowledge that does not align well with
the scientific knowledge we are trying to teach as “misconceptions,”
“alternative conceptions,” or “naïve theories.” (Tuminaro, & Redish, 2007).
Ac tivit y 2.7
Critically discuss the following concepts:
• Misconceptions,
• Alternative conceptions, or
• Naïve theories
Think about the teaching strategies that you can use correct
“misconceptions,” “alternative conceptions,” or “naïve theories.”
Discuss any three teaching strategies that you need to use for successful
teaching of Physical Science are suggested. These strategies are informed
by constructivism and sociocultural perspectives.
They are as follows:
• Build new knowledge from prior knowledge.
• Provide opportunities to communicate about Physical Science.
• Create opportunities for reflective thought.
...........
18
L E SS O N 2: Te a c h i n g a n d l e a r n i n g s t r ate g i e s i n p hy si c a l s c i e n ce
Ac tivit y 2. 8
Discuss each of the strategies in a paragraph of about five points each.
Inquiry Based Science Teaching
Inquiry has served as a major theme in science education since the post
Sputnik science education reform that began in the late 1950s (DeBoer
1991 as quoted by Chiappetta & Adams, 2004). The term inquiry has
been used to form curriculum goals, design instructional strategies, and
assess learning. The term also describes what scientists do (Chiappetta
& Adams, 2004).
Inquiry has been used to promote activity-oriented learning that reflects
scientific investigation, specifically the observation, experimentation, and
reasoning used by scientists.
Most science educators would agree that at least five reasons exist for
utilizing inquiry-base science instruction in the classroom. Inquiry-based
science instruction should promote: (Chiappetta & Adams, 2004).
• Understanding of fundamental facts, concepts, principles, laws, and
theories;
• Development of skills that enhance the acquisition of knowledge and
understanding of natural phenomena;
• Cultivation of the disposition to find answers to questions and to
question the truthfulness of statements about the natural world;
• Formation of positive attitudes toward science; and Acquisition of
understanding about the nature of science.
Ac tivit y 2.9
Discuss each of the five reasons in a paragraph of about five points each.
...........
19 TMS3729/1
3 LESSON 3
3 Lesson planning
LEARNING OUTCOMES
We will know that qualifying student teachers are competent when they can:
• Use the criteria for good formulation of learning intentions correctly and
demonstrate competence in the formulation of such learning intentions;
• Apply appropriate learning strategies, teaching methods and teaching media in
their planning of teaching;
• Apply the subject content of the curriculum, relevant pedagogical knowledge and
contextual realities to plan and present lessons in their subject;
• Teach lessons and facilitate learning;
• Reflect on their teaching and improve, change or adapt their practice;
• Identify their remaining learning needs and work on how to acquire them while
taking full responsibility for their actions, decision making and use of resources.
The methods you ultimately use will be those that suit your personality, interests
and abilities. It is important to feel comfortable with the methods you use. The
methods used successfully by one teacher may be totally impractical for another.
Your lessons should be planned thoroughly and in detail, even if you later find
that you have to deviate from your initial plan. For instance, all apparatus and
diagrams should be prepared before the learners arrive at your class.
During each lesson you have to bear in mind what prior knowledge the learners
have. You should not lose sight of your goal, or your planning as to how to
achieve it. You can measure your success after the lesson, by the extent to
which you could awaken your learners interest and encourage them to do
meaningful activities. You must ensure that you stick to the point and avoid
lengthy digressions. Some learners (fortunately the minority) make a point
of disrupting the lesson in a peaceful fashion by asking irrelevant questions.
Tactfully avoid these questions. I invite such learners to come and discuss the
question with me during break or after school. (As expected, they usually do
not turn up.)
The average learner is more comfortable with concrete, rather than abstract
ideas, because most people think in terms of things or objects. Abstract laws and
principles should, however, continuously be linked to real apparatus, findings
and procedures by making use of models or diagrams. Models and diagrams
should never be overloaded with information. They then become confusing
and difficult to understand. They should be designed in such a manner that
they demonstrate/ explain the issue at hand clearly.
Ac tivit y 3.1
Explain what is meant by the following: Write two paragraphs each.
a. Observation
b. Trial and error
c. Verifying deductions
Ac tivit y 3. 2
As you probably remember from your own school career, a practical lesson
can be a winning recipe for chaos.
Write down your fears about practical lessons.
In my experience of practical lessons, learners think it is a period in which
to play or, in the case of Chemistry, add chemicals together in an unbridled
fashion in the hope of creating a bomb.
Make absolutely sure that your learners have the necessary prior knowledge
to complete the practical successfully. This will ensure that they are positive
about the following practicals.
It should be evident that you should be even better prepared for such a
lesson than for a theoretical lesson. Your chances to succeed are good if
you keep to the following guidelines:
• Divide the learners into groups. There should not be more than four
learners to a group.
• You can use any of the three scientific methods of investigation
mentioned in
• Just make sure to decide beforehand what you aim to achieve with
the practical (what your goal is) and work purposefully.
• Make sure that your learners are thoroughly prepared as to what is
expected of them during the practical.
• Include self-assessment and group assessment in your assessment.
...........
22
L E SS O N 3: L e ss o n p l a n n i n g
Ac tivit y 3. 3
The first practical lesson you want to do with your grade 10 learners is a
demonstration of Ohm s law.
You may, for instance, explain the flow of electrons by asking learners who
have dental fillings to let a piece of foil touch a filling and then explain what
they have experienced.
Evaluate and compare the two methods (practical and demonstration lessons)
with regard to their effectiveness, the maintenance of discipline, success in
reaching the original goal, assessment, learner involvement, stimulating learners
to solve problems, etc.
I am sure you will agree that learners may easily lose interest during this type of
lesson. The main reason for this is, of course, that not everyone can necessarily
see well when the demonstration is done. You can try the following tips if you
experience similar problems:
• Ensure that your apparatus is large enough, so that everyone can see.
• Do the experiment before the learners arrive, so that you can be sure that
it works.
• Let some of your learners be laboratory assistants who can help you (see
later on in this lesson unit).
• Call smaller groups of learners to the demonstration bench and demonstrate
the experiment to each group in turn.
• Walk through the class, demonstrating to learners at their seats.
• Use the overhead projector. Chemistry experiments where a change of
colour occurs, for example acid-base titrations, can be demonstrated very
well in this manner. Magnetic fields can also be demonstrated effectively
using iron filings and a magnet.
• Hold the learner’s attention by asking stimulating questions during the
demonstration. You may even repeat the demonstration if you wish to
emphasise a certain aspect.
• Engage the learners who are less involved by giving them small tasks.
• Most learners will then feel important and will instantly want to become
involved.
• Never lose sight of the purpose of the demonstration.
• Make sure that you have achieved your objective by the end of the period.
• Test the learners understanding by giving them a written assignment
(assessment) to complete about the demonstration.
Never lose sight of the five different strategies we discussed in the previous
lesson unit.
• issue-based learning
• investigation-based learning
• problem-based learning
• problem solving
• active learning
The principles of Physical Sciences are at times very abstract. For this reason,
especially, they should be reinforced in problem-solving lessons. This is the
only manner in which most learners eventually master the work. The old
adage unknown, unloved is really true. If the learner is actively busy with the
so-called difficult concepts, he/ she will in time gain the self-confidence to
tackle the more difficult problems.
Learners can be used very effectively as laboratory assistants and they are
usually very enthusiastic. At the same time, they learn skills in the laboratory
that they would otherwise not have learnt
Ac tivit y 3.4
I hope I have convinced you of the value of learner laboratory assistants.
Well- trained assistants can make your task a lot easier.
...........
25 TMS3729/1
You decide to make use of learner assistants. Plan and discuss the entire
process from recruiting learners as assistants, until they are fully trained.
You may use the following guidelines:
• How will you go about recruiting learner assistants?
• What criteria will you use when selecting learner assistants?
• Which skills will you teach them?
• What will a learner assistant s duty sheet look like?
• Are you going to reward the learner assistants?
• How will you exercise control over the learner assistants?
• What possibilities of promotion do you intend building into your
system?
The tasks given to a learner assistant will differ from grade to grade. Learners
may, however, not work with chemicals without close supervision. It is therefore
important to make sure that they do not have access to your supplies store if
you cannot be present.
Never underestimate learner’s creativity. They can also help with the planning of
unconventional experiments to explain certain principles, like finding different
methods to demonstrate static electricity.
Tasks given to learner assistants at the school where I work, include the
following:
• helping during stocktaking
• preparing practical’s
• preparing solutions for Chemistry
• creating workstations and setting out apparatus
• assisting during practical’s, for instance replenishing chemicals when
necessary
• clearing up and putting away apparatus directly after practical’s
• distributing apparatus to classrooms
• keeping a supplies register
• keeping the stores neat
• labelling supplies
• repairing apparatus if possible
• keeping the issuing register (a register of all apparatus that is issued
and received back)
Learner assistants could, for example, stay an hour after school (voluntarily) on
a rotation basis, in order to do the necessary work. Some of the more senior
learners can train juniors each year. The learners can be rewarded with a
badge or colours/honorary colours at merit ceremonies.
You will be surprised at the number of scientific principles you can explain
using cheap alternatives.
In the meantime, I suggest that you collect your own alternative equipment
to do practical’s. John Scott wrote an excellent book, Everyday science: real-
life activities, in which he describes numerous alternative experiments which
should fascinate you and your learners.
Newton s Second Law: Place a marble and a soccer ball on a table. Fillip each
away with your finger. The smaller mass of the marble causes it to move much
faster than the soccer ball.
Newton s Third Law: Make your own private jet! Inflate a balloon and drop
it. The air escaping from the balloon (action) makes the balloon propel in the
opposite direction (reaction).
...........
28
L E SS O N 3: L e ss o n p l a n n i n g
Acceleration: Build different inclines with a piece of wood and bricks. Let a
toy car go down them. The steeper the incline, the greater the final velocity.
Using the same incline, a heavier toy car will not go down as fast as a light one.
Air pressure: Fill a glass with water and put a piece of paper on top of the
glass. Turn over the glass–the water does not flow out!
Surface tension: Carefully fill a glass with water. The water rises above the rim
of the glass–a beautiful example of surface tension.
...........
29 TMS3729/1
Never forget to market Physical Sciences. Your learners are your clients. Accept
the challenge.
The challenge is yours to motivate those learners who have little or no courage
to take that leap.
Ac tivit y 3. 5
Teaching can never be boring. You have hardly conquered one challenge
or the next crops up!
Choose two of the above-mentioned activities and plan in detail how you
would use each to get your learners to be venturesome?
Encouraging learners to be more daring/venturesome is an ongoing
activity which will never be completed. There will always be learners who
need guidance in this regard.
...........
30
L E SS O N 3: L e ss o n p l a n n i n g
You will not have time during the first year of your teaching career to pay
attention to all of the activities discussed here
(Or the many others you can think of). Tackle the one or two you wish
to concentrate on whole-heartedly. Remember: enthusiasm breeds
enthusiasm. If you are daring, your learners will follow!)
3.14 SUMMARY
This lesson unit dealt mostly with lesson planning.
The type of lessons were discussed in detail. The role of the laboratory assistant
or learner assistants was also discussed, as was the handling of laboratory
equipment/supplies. Suggestions were made on how to supplement shortages
of laboratory equipment.
...........
31 TMS3729/1
4 LESSON 4
4 Assessment
LEARNING OUTCOMES
We will know that qualifying student teachers are competent when they can:
• Apply assessment principles to design assessments;
• Use learning intentions and assessment criteria to design assessments; instruments
that can be used to assess learners effectively and objectively;
• Apply the requirements for assessment in the curriculum to design appropriate
assessments for the school environment;
• Apply the requirements for assessment in the curriculum to design assessments
at appropriate cognitive levels;
• Make assessment decisions from scenarios/case studies/practical examples.
• Give useful/meaningful feedback on formative assessments to improve learning;
• Record assessments in accordance with curriculum requirements using scenarios/
case studies/practical examples; and
• Reflect on assessments and improve/change/adapt where needed.
Assessment provides the learner with information about his/her own progress.
Assessment helps indicate whether the learning outcomes have been achieved
through teaching. If the assessment indicates that too little progress was made,
teaching and learning should be adjusted accordingly.
Diagnostic assessment will also help you to adjust the learning programme if
necessary, or to plan other supportive strategies.
Nowadays all schools have to provide for learners with impairments, whether
it be a physical, hearing, visual or any other impairment. These learners
cannot always be assessed in the same manner as their classmates. Alternative
assessment, depending on the learner s impairment, will be necessary.
It is extremely important that assessment must be reliable. You cannot use only
one assessment method, because you will then not get a complete picture of
the learner. Therefore, it is essential that the evaluation of learner’s progress
should be based on more than one assessment method. This is the principle
of continuous assessment.
In order to decide what type of activity will best meet the assessment needs,
ask yourself the following questions:
We know from experience that learners are much more critical about themselves
than we are. This method may be a lot more effective than one might imagine.
Just as critical as learners are about themselves, they are about each other’s
work. In this manner they encourage each other to produce a better quality
of work.
In group assessment the process, as well as the final product are assessed. You
can naturally also evaluate social skills, time management, the management
of resources, and group dynamics.
...........
35 TMS3729/1
This type of assessment is often reserved for tasks where learners have
to communicate with each other or work together towards a common goal. A
suitable measuring instrument should be chosen for this type of assessment.
The disadvantage is that it may be time-consuming.
This type of assessment is also used to see if learners can apply that which
they have learnt in theory, in practice. Can the learners do an experiment in
practice, using their theoretical knowledge?
• rating scales
• checklists
• rubrics
...........
36
L E SS O N 4 : A ss e ssm e nt
Explaining the rating scale is very important, as it gives the learner an idea of
what he/she has achieved, as well as of the instances in which, and the reasons
why he/she has not achieved the learning outcomes.
These rating scales were used in the traditional marking methods, but without
the explanatory details. It was difficult to form an idea of the learner s strong
and weak points in terms of the outcomes that he/she was supposed to achieve.
4.8.2 Checklists
Checklists consist of discrete statements that describe the expected performance
in a specific task. If a learner meets a specific criterion (statement) on the
checklist, it is ticked off.
All the criteria that are ticked off give an indication of the learner s performance.
Similarly, the statements that have not been ticked off give the learner an
indication of his/her weak points and what he/she still has to attend to.
4.8.3 Rubrics
A rubric is a specific set of criteria which indicates the expected outcomes to
both the teacher and the learner.
These criteria should be clear guidelines describing both abilities and values.
A rubric is a combination of a rating scale and a description of standards.
...........
37 TMS3729/1
As facilitator, you may initially be sceptical about rubrics, because you might
feel that they are subjective. They may however be a very good aid if applied
correctly. The opposite is also true–if used incorrectly, they may be disastrous.
It is essential that you as teacher must know exactly what is required for each
criterion included in the rubric.
When compiling a rubric, you must ask yourself the following questions (quoted
from the NCS, South Africa, Department of Education 2003):
• Which outcomes are being targeted?
• Which Assessment Standards are targeted by the task?
• What kind of evidence should be collected?
• Which are the different parts of the performance that will be assessed?
• Which different assessment instruments best suit each part of the task (such
as the process and the product)?
• What knowledge should be evident?
• What skills should be applied, or actions taken?
• What opportunities for expressing person opinions, values or attitudes arise
in the task and which of these should be assessed and how?
• Should one rubric target all the Learning Outcomes and Assessment
• Standards of the task or does the task need several rubrics?
• How many rubrics are, in fact needed for the task?
It is of critical importance that you as teacher should discuss the rubric or rubrics
with the learners before they tackle the required task. The rubric makes it clear
what learning and performance will be required. Ultimately, it is a powerful
instrument for self-assessment.
EXAMPLES OF RUBRICS
RUBRIC: PRESSURE VS VOLUME
1. GROUP WORK
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Works individually only.
...........
38
L E SS O N 4 : A ss e ssm e nt
Does practical work and assists others without reading up or asking for written
or verbal instructions; in other words, well prepared. Knows exactly what to do.
2 NOTES
1 Poor.
2 Incomplete and disorganised.
3 Complete and systematic.
4 Excellent; easy to understand; covers whole memo.
3. ACTIONS (skills)
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Identifies and chooses suitable items for specific instruction.
2 Sets up apparatus according to written instructions.
3 Uses all apparatus without additional verbal instructions.
4 Follows written instructions and does all experiments in a methodical and
organised manner, taking safety precautions into consideration.
4. OBSERVATION
1 Uses apparatus correctly.
2 Takes correct pressure and volume readings.
3 Takes correct unit readings.
4 Can correct mistakes if readings seem to be wrong.
5. RECORDING (results)
1 Writes readings down. (table)
2 Writes readings in a table.
3 Adds headings to table.
4 Indicates units.
6. INTERPRETATION
1 Draws only one graph.
2 Draws both graphs.
3 Indicates units on both axes (both graphs).
4 Uses scale correctly (both graphs).
7. CONCLUSION
1 pv k
2 p 1/V
3 Notes that T is constant.
4 Indicates that it is a closed system.
2. NOTES
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Poor.
2 Incomplete and disorganised.
3 Complete and systematic.
4 Excellent; easy to understand; covers whole memo.
3. ACTIONS/METHOD
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Identifies and chooses suitable items for specific practical instruction.
2 Sets up apparatus according to written instructions for practical work.
3 Can use all apparatus without additional verbal instructions.
4 Follows written instructions and does all experiments in a methodical and
organised manner, taking safety precautions into consideration.
4. OBSERVATION
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Builds circuit.
2 Changes potential difference with rheostat.
3 Takes ammeter and voltmeter readings.
4 Uses units for ammeter and volt-meter readings.
5. RECORDING
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Writes down readings.
2 Writes readings in a table
3 Adds headings to table.
4 Indicates units.
6. INTERPRETATION
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Draws labelled axes for a graph.
2 Uses a scale for the graph.
3 Plots points on graph and draws best possible straight line.
4 Determines gradient of graph.
7. CONCLUSION
0 Does not make any attempt.
1 Mentions that V is directly proportional to I.
2 Mentions that R is constant.
...........
40
L E SS O N 4 : A ss e ssm e nt
5 Meritorious 60–79
4 Satisfactory 50–59
3 Adequate 40–49
2 Partial 30–39
1 Inadequate 0–29
The degree of difficulty of any paper must be determined using certain criteria.
This ensures that the paper is in fact set according to a certain standard.
...........
41 TMS3729/1
4.12 SUMMARY
In this lesson unit we have attempted to explain what is meant by assessment,
why it is necessary, and what types of assessment there are.
We have guided you in choosing the correct assessment method. You were
shown different methods to keep records and the value of each of these
methods was discussed.
When you have worked through this study guide and made it your own, you
can call yourself a TEACHER!! Congratulations with this milestone you have
reached in your life. It is an unbelievably fulfilling career.
Carry the following quotation from Christa McAuliffe with you: I touch the
future, I teach.
...........
42