Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 178

Example 2 – Option 2:

Bent columns on capped piles

Abutment

Bent cap

Pile cap
Abutment Piles: 14"Ø concrete-filled steel pipe

Details on following slides

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 1
railing

8" slab deck

6.25' BT-63 girder


4" 8.25'

4.0' Top of column at mid-


height of bent cap

32.25' 24.0' 30.25'


20.0'
47.0'

Ground level
4.0' Top of piles at mid-
height of pile cap
14.75' 12.75'

Assumed point of pile fixity


(idealized cantilever pile)

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 2
Extend the pile to the mid-
depth of the pile cap

14" concrete-filled
steel pipe

13.0'
Bent cap

2.0'
30" Ø 6.5'
4.5'

4.5'
5.0' 8.5'
2.0'

13.0' 2.0'
Pile cap: 13' x 13' x 4'

4.0'

12.75'

Assumed point of pile fixity

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 3
Z X = 80.0'
Pinned bearing
X
Z=0

Z = -6.083' Z = -6.083'
Z = -6.25' Roller bearing Z = -6.25
Z = -8.25'
(X = 0, X = 160')

Abutment
Bent 24.0'

Extend the pile to the mid- Z = -32.25'


depth of the pile cap
14.75

Z = -47.0'

X = 73.5'

X = 86.5'
X = 75.5'

X = 84.5'
10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 4
Z

15.0'
13.0'
8.5'
4.0'
2.0'

Units: feet

Y=0
Y = -15.0
Y = -13.0

Y = -2.0

Y = 13.0
Y = 2.0
Y = -8.5

Y = -4.0

Y = 4.0

Y = 8.5
Views toward X = 0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 5
X = 80, Y = 0, Z = 0

Z
X
Y

Bridge Wizard cannot model the pile and pile cap.


These must be modeled (drawn) manually.
The pile cap is modeled as a 4.0' deep thick-plate
element (element boundaries and all plate nodes
are in one plane at the mid-depth of the plate).
The piles are frame sections that must be defined
before they can be used.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 6
Y = - 8.5'
Z
X
Y

next 2 slides

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 7
Z

View in +X direction
top of deck
Y Z=0

bent cap bent cap ( frame section )


column
pile Z = - 8.25'
nodes

overlapping nodes

column ( frame section )

pile cap ( thick-shell


element )
Z = - 32.25'

pile ( frame section )

Z = - 47.0'

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 8
top of column at mid-depth of bent cap at
Z X = 80.0', Y = - 8.5', Z = - 8.25'
X
mid-depth of pile cap in
Y a plane at Z = - 32.25'

tops of piles in a plane at


cap mid-depth Z = - 32.25'

column
pile
nodes

bottoms of all piles at depth Z = - 47.0' overlapping nodes

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 9
Open file CSI Bridge file
Example2-Two-Equal-Span-Option2.bdb
saved at the end of Option 1

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 10
Extrude view off

Extrude view on

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 11
For the rest of this example, the Bridge Wizard will not be used

Instead, the CSI command line tabs and sub-tabs in the


screen headings will be used. For example:

Command line tab

Sub-tabs

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 12
First, remove the fixity (all d.o.f.) at column
bases that was used in Option 1

Option 1 assumed column


bases were "fixed"

Note CSI bridge "fixed


boundary" symbol

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 13
Recall that in Option 1 the Bent was
named Bent_fixed_base

Bent_fixed_base

Fixed base support


( all 6 d.o.f. )

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 14
For Option 2 a new Bent named Bent_free_base will be created. The free
end of each column base will later be connected to the pile cap foundation.

Bent_free_base

Free base support


( all 6 d.o.f. )

See next slide

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 15
The built-in Base Support options provided by the
Bridge Bent Column Data form are only Pinned or
Fixed ( the default option is Fixed, as show ).
In order to have a Free column base support it is
necessary to define and attach a new user-defined
Foundation Spring that is free in all 6 d.o.f.
This Foundation Spring is a new Component. It
will be created in the following slides, and named
Column_base_spring.

Bent_free_base

Z Column_base_spring
Y ( free in all 6 d.o.f. )
X

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 16
Components command line tab, Item ► Foundation Springs sub-tab

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 17
Create a new Foundation Spring

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 18
Define and name Column_base_spring

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 19
Create a new Bent ( cap and columns ) and name it Column_free_base

4.0' Z = -8.25'

Column length: 24.0'


5.0' ( mid-depth of bent cap to
mid-depth of pile cap )
22.0'

4.0' Z = -32.25'

free end of column ( represented


pile cap and piles will by Column_base_spring )
be added later

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 20
Components command line tab, Item ► Bents sub-tab

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 21
Create a new Bent to be named Bent_free_base
( note that Bent_fixed_base already exists )

Symbol for fixed reaction at base


of column for Bent_fixed_base

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 22
The new Bent_free_base has been
created, but has not yet been assigned
to the bridge model ( to replace the
currently assigned Bent_free_base )

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 23
Replace Bent_fixed_base with Bent_free_base in the Bridge Model

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 24
10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 25
Update model to complete replacing Bent_fixed_base with Bent_free_base

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 26
Revising the reaction condition at the base of the bent columns is complete.

No base reaction symbol is


shown at a reaction point that
is free ( Bent_free_base )

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 27
Add a new Frame Section for the 14"-diam concrete-filled steel pipe piles

Review existing Material Properties

Reinforcing steel

Structural steel ( default )

4 ksi concrete ( will be


used in piles )

The materials needed for the piles have already available ( no new materials are required )

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 28
Create a Frame Section for the concrete-filled pipe pile
( reference: CSIBridge-EI-multiplier.ppt )

CSI Bridge has no built-in Frame Sections of this type.

concrete core Concrete:


fc' = 4 ksi
tw = 3/8" doutside = 14" Ec = 3708 ksi
Note that the steel properties
are not entered ( they are
steel pipe
needed to compute the SMF )

The program uses the following method to create a Frame Section like this one:

1. Start with a concrete section whose outside diameter is that of the pipe doutside.
doutside = 14.0 in

2. Enter a Stiffness Multiplication Factor SMF = 2.297 to increase the EI of the


concrete section to that of the filled-pipe section

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 29
10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 30
Assuming current units:
kips, ft, F

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 31
Complete creating Conc_filled_pipe_pile

Conc_filled_pipe_pile is a fictitious 14"-diam concrete pile section whose stiffness has been
increased by a SMF = 2.297 so that it will act as a concrete-filled steel pipe pile section.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 32
Add a new thick plate Area Section for the 4'-thick pile cap

Use Advanced tab

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 33
Complete Pile_cap_plate definition

Verify units:
Kip, ft, F

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 34
Bridge is now ready for adding pile/cap foundation

Redefined bent:
Bent_free_base

Z
X

New component definitions added: Bent_free_base 24.0'


Pile cap thick-plate elements:
Pile_cap_plate
Z = -32.25'
Concrete-filled steel pipe piles:
Conc_filled_pipe_pile "Free" bent column base defined by:
Column_base_spring (free in 6 d.o.f.)

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 35
Add the pile cap and piles to each column in the Bridge Model

Z
Bent cap: 4.0' x 4.0' x 27.0'
( already in Bridge Model )

Y
X
Bent column: 30"-diam x 24.0'
( already in Bridge Model )

Pile cap: 13.0' x 13.0' x 4.0' thick plate element

Piles: 14"Ø concrete-filled steel pipe pile

The bent cap, bent columns and the piles have been defined as Frame Sections.
The pile cap finite elements have been defined as a thick plate Area Sections.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 36
Z

8.25'
Y
X

Draw this pile/cap foundation first,


and then copy to other side

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 37
Z View in +Y direction Z View in +X direction
( section thru Y = - 8.5 ) ( section thru X = 80 )

X Z=0 Y Z=0

Z = - 8.25 Z = - 8.25

Z = - 32.25 Z = - 32.25

Z = - 47.0 Z = - 47.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 38
Components, nodes and grid lines.
Z=0
The terms Nodes and Joints mean the
Z = - 8.25
Z same thing, and are used interchangeably.
X
Y

Z = - 32.25

Z = - 47.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 39
Nodes ( "joints" ) and grid lines

Z = - 8.25 nodes required to for pile cap area


Z nodes required to draw piles
X nodes at ends of column
Y nodes that will be inserted when pile
cap is assembled from plate elements

Z = - 32.25

Z = - 47.0

The grid lines will be used to draw


thick plate elements that make up
the pile cap, and the nine piles.
Nodes will be added by the program
as these components are drawn.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 40
Z = - 8.25'

Z = - 32.25'

In order to draw piles and pile cap


grid lines will be required at:
X = 73.5 , 75.5 , 80.0 , 84.5 , 86.5
Y = -2.0 , -4.0 , -8.5 , -13.0 , -15.0
Z = - 47.0'
Z = -8.25 , -32.25 , - 47.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 41
View joints ( "nodes" ) created by CSI Bridge

Check to turn on Joint Labels

Uncheck to show Joints


This block will remain unchecked so that Joints
are visible in the balance of this Exercise

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 42
Typical joint and label

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 43
Use Rubberband Zoom to isolate and expand any selected region in view window

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 44
Start

Drag Rubberband Zoom cursor to


capture region to be zoomed-in on

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 45
Region enclosed with Rubberband Zoom expanded to full view window

Repeat Rubberband Zoom


to zoom in further

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 46
Return to full-size view

Restored full view

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 47
Turn off Joint Labels, but leave Joints showing

Uncheck

Remember – these joints are


automatically created by CSI Bridge
anytime model is Updated

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 48
View default grid lines created by CSI Bridge

Can be in any heading ( Home show here )

Right-click anywhere in
drawing window

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 49
Even though CSI Bridge inserted many joints ( "nodes" ) no grid lines
were drawn through any nodes except the origin at X, Y, Z = 0, 0, 0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 50
1. Delete the grid lines for X = 0, Y = 0 and Z = 0
2. Enter grid lines listed on Slide 38 ( be certain units are Kip, ft, F )

Double left-click on
each cell
Enter

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 51
10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 52
Only the grid lines listed in the Define
Grid System Data table are shown

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 53
Use Rubberband Zoom to get a closer view

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 54
Note that joints ( "nodes" ) are not
automatically created at the grid
intersections.
Joints are only created when members
are drawn ( either in Bridge Wizard or
manually ).
Additional joints will be added as the
cap elements and the piles are drawn.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 55
View of XZ plane ( in +Y direction )

Y X

If the XZ view is chosen, then the user can


"step through" the XZ planes at
Y = -2.0 , -4.0 , -8.5 , -13.0 , and -15.0

These are the planes that have been created


by drawing the grid lines.

There must be grid lines at these Y locations


for the "step through" to be possible

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 56
Switch to a 2D view in the XZ plane in the +Y direction

View of XZ plane

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 57
View of XZ plane at Y = -15

Use arrows to "step up" or "step down" through Y planes

X = 86.5
X = 73.5

X = 160
X = 80
X=0

Grid lines
Z = -8.25

Z = -32.25

Z = -47.0

Cursor location
X = 73.5
X = 84.5

"X-Z Plane @ Y=-15"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 58
View of XZ plane at Y = -13

No structure components visible because


they have not been drawn yet
"X-Z Plane @ Y=-13"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 59
View of XZ plane at Y = -8.5

Bent column and nodes visible

"X-Z Plane @ Y=-8.5"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 60
Switch view from XZ plane to XY plane

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 61
View of XY planes at Z = -8.25, -32.25, -47.0

Step through Z = -8.25 , -32.25, -47.0


Bent cap beam and nodes

Y=0

"X-Y Plane @ Z=-47" "X-Y Plane @ Z=-32.25" "X-Y Plane @ Z=-8.25"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 62
Modeling the Pile Cap

The 13.0' x 13.0' x 4.0' pile cap will be modeled as an assembly of plate finite elements.
Finite elements connect to each other, and to other components in the structure, at joints
at the corners of each finite element.
In CSI Bridge, a plate finite element is a subset of shell finite elements. A rectangular
plate element has a joint at each of its four corners. Six degrees of freedom are active at
each joint (i.e., six forces – three linear and three rotational - can act at each joint ). The
element local coordinate system ( 1-2-3 ) is the frame of reference for the six degrees of
freedom at the joints. The joints are located on the mid-depth plane in the plate:

R2

3 R3 U2 R1 Similar at each joint

2 1 U3 U1

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 63
For a horizontal element ( on that lies in the structure X-Y plane ) the plate element 1-2-3
local coordinates are oriented as shown:

R2

3 R3 U2 R1

2 1 U3 U1

Y X

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 64
The pile cap must be subdivided into enough
elements so that there is a joint at each location
where "something happens":
Pile cap corners
Bent column
Pile-to-cap connections
Bent column-to-pile-to-cap connection

Element

Pile cap corner


Joint
Pile-to-cap connection Column-to-pile-to-cap connection

Pile Pile

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 65
Thick-plate finite elements ( defined earlier as Pile_cap_plate sections ) will be used
to model the 13.0' x 13.0' x 4.0' pile cap. The pile cap will be subdivided as shown,
which will results in joints at the following points:
Each of the four corners
Each place where a pile connects to the pile cap
The place where the bent column connects to the pile cap

Bent column

Z = - 32.25

Pile cap corner

Pile

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 66
The sixteen elements will be drawn in the order shown. The program will insert joints
as each element is drawn. Note that additional joints along the boundaries ( ) will
be created in addition to the joints needed to connect the bent column and the piles
to the pile cap.

Z = - 32.25

Z
Note – the Number (e.g., 1 ) shown in each
element is manually added to show drawing
Y sequence. The program assigns its own
X element number as each is drawn.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 67
Draw pile cap in XY plane at Z = -32.25

Use Home tab Rubberband Zoom to enlarge figure

nodes at column bases

grid lines

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 68
Enlarged view of XY plane grid lines at Z = -32.25

Joint at column base

grid lines

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 69
Go to Advanced tab, which opens Draw options

X = 73.5

X = 86.5
Y = -2.0

Grid lines at Z = -32.35

Y = -15.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 70
Select Rectangular Area tab and select Area Section

Draw rectangular area

Select Area Section


Pile_cap_plate that
was defined earlier

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 71
Select first diagonal corner of Pile_cap_plate to begin plate-element drawing sequence

Put cursor pointer on Grid


Point and left-click mouse

This box will show as


long as plate drawing
mode is active

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 72
Use Grid Points to draw the first of 16 plate Area elements

Dotted line appears as cursor is


Line added to show
moved until Grid Point is reached
element just drawn

1 1

Left-click mouse – this will


Move (not drag) cursor show joints at the corners of
pointer to Grid Point plate element 1 just drawn

Note – the Number (e.g., 1 ) shown in each element is


manually added to show drawing sequence. The program
assigns its own element number as each is drawn.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 73
Position cursor to draw element 2

Line added to show element just drawn

1 Move (not drag) the


cursor to this Grid Point
and left-click mouse

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 74
Draw the second of 16 plate Area elements

Lines added to show previously-drawn element

Dotted line appears as cursor is moved until Grid Point is reached

1 2 1 2

Left-click mouse – this will


Move (not drag) cursor
show joints at the corners of
pointer to Grid Point
plate element 2 just drawn

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 75
Position cursor to draw element 3

1 2 Move (not drag) the


cursor to this Grid
Point and left-click
mouse

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 76
Draw the third of 16 plate Area elements

Dotted lines added to show


previously-drawn elements
Dotted line appears as cursor is moved until Grid Point is reached

2 3 1 2 3
1

Left-click mouse – this will


show joints at the corners of
Move (not drag) cursor plate element 3 just drawn
pointer to Grid Point

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 77
Position cursor to draw element 4

Move (not drag) the cursor to this


Grid Point and left-click mouse
Grid point

1 2 3

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 78
Draw the fourth of 16 plate Area elements

Dotted lines added to show


previously-drawn elements
Dotted line appears as cursor is moved until Grid Point is reached

1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4
Grid point

Left-click mouse – this will


Move (not drag) cursor
show joints at the corners of
pointer to Grid Point
plate element 4 just drawn

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 79
First row of elements is now drawn

Dotted lines added to show elements

First row of four elements that


will make up the pile cap plate. 1 2 3 4
Note that joints have been
inserted at the corners of each
element at the grid points.

Outline of pile cap


Repeat for three more rows
of four elements each

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 80
Draw second row of 4 elements ( elements 5 – 8 of 16 )

Start
Left-click Left-click

Left-click Left-click End

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 81
First and second rows of elements are now drawn

Dotted lines added to show elements

1 2 3 4
Second row of four
elements that make up the
pile cap plate. Again joints 5 6 7 8
have been inserted at the
corners of each element at
the grid points.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 82
Draw third row of 4 elements ( elements 9 – 12 of 16 )

Start
Left-click Left-click

Left-click Left-click End

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 83
First, second, and third rows of elements are now drawn

Dotted lines added to show elements

1 2 3 4

5 6 7 8

Third row of four elements


9 10 11 12
that make up the pile cap
plate.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 84
Draw fourth row of 4 elements ( elements 13 – 16 of 16 )

End
Start Left-click Left-click
Left-click

Left-click Left-click

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 85
Drawing of Area elements that make up pile cap is complete

Dotted lines added to show elements

1 2 3 4

5 6 7 8

9 10 11 12

Fourth row of four elements that


13 14 15 16
make up the pile cap plate.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 86
Click arrow symbol to exit drawing mode Go to Home and turn on Extrude View

Grayed area shows elements just drawn

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 87
Turn off Extrude View and turn on Area Labels

Area Label numbers assigned by the program

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 88
Perspective View – Area Labels and Grid Lines turned off

In Display Options
uncheck Area Labels

Z = - 32.25
Right click View Panel, select Edit
Grid Data to turn off grid lines

Z = - 32.25

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 89
Turn on Area Labels and Local Axes

Y
X

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 90
Turn on Extrude View

Labels are not shown


in Extrude View

In Display Options
check Extrude View

4.0'

Z = - 32.25

Z = - 32.25

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 91
Use Set 3D View to switch to XZ View

XZ view

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 92
XZ plane Extrude View ( Perspective toggled off )

Perspective toggle

Base of column at
mid-depth of pile cap
Z = -32.25

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 93
Draw the three piles at Y = -13.0

Z = - 32.25

Z = - 47.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 94
Switch to XZ View and step to plane at Y = -13

Here, do not use More to set view

Three piles will be draw


using these grid lines

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 95
Use Rubberband Zoom to expand the area where the piles will be drawn

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 96
Mid-depth of pile cap
Z = -32.25

Three piles will be draw using


these three grid lines

Tips of piles
Z = -47.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 97
Go to Advanced tab, which opens Draw options
Select Frame/Cable/Tendon

Select from list

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 98
Draw pile at X = 75.5

Move pointer to grid point at


X = 75.5, Y = -13.0, Z = -47.0

Left click to begin drawing

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 99
Move pointer to grid point at
X = 75.5, Y = -13.0, Z = -32.25

Left click to complete line


Right click to "lift pencil"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 100


Draw pile at X = 80.0

Move pointer to grid point at


X = 80.0, Y = -13.0, Z = -47.0

Left click to begin drawing

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 101


Move pointer to grid point at
X = 80.0, Y = -13.0, Z = -32.25

Left click to complete line


Right click to "lift pencil"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 102


Draw pile at X = 84.5

Move pointer to grid point at


X = 84.5, Y = -13.0, Z = -47.0

Left click to begin drawing

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 103


Move pointer to grid point at
X = 84.5, Y = -13.0, Z = -32.25

Left click to complete line


Right click to "lift pencil"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 104


The three piles at Y = -13.0 are complete

Exit drawing mode

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 105


At Home tab Refresh Window to see the piles and nodes just drawn

What's missing?

There are no boundary


restraints at the column bases
(as shown, columns are free in
all d.o.f.)

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 106


Apply a fixed boundary restraint at the base of the column at X = 75.5

Pile

Right click on joint Flashing red circle

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 107


Double left click

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 108


10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 109
Restraint symbol
added at node

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 110


Repeat for these nodes ( one at a time )
See next page

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 111


Double left click

Right click joint

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 112


Piles with boundary restraints completed at Y = -13.0 are complete

Refresh drawing

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 113


Rubberband Zoom this area

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 114


Piles, nodes and boundary restraints at Y = -13.0

Nodes at outer corners


of corner plate elements

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 115


Open and select Extrude View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 116


10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 117
Base of column and tops of
piles at mid-depth of pile cap
Z = -32.25

Tips of piles
Z = -47.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 118


Draw the three piles each at Y = -8.5 and Y = -4.0

Z = - 32.25

Z = - 47.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 119


Option 1: In XZ View manually draw piles at Y = -8.5 and Y = -4.0

Y = -8.5
Step to Y = -8.5 and draw three
piles and add boundary restraints
as previously shown

Y = -4.0
Step to Y = -4.0 and repeat

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 120


Option 2: Replicate the three piles and boundary restraints at Y = -13.0
to Y = -8.5 and Y = -4.0. This can be done in

1. Two steps: Replicate three piles at Y = -13.0 to Y = -8.5 in one step,


and then replicate the same piles at Y = -13.0 to Y = -4.0
in a separate step

2. One step: Replicate three piles at Y = -13.0 to both Y = -8.5 and


Y = -4.0 in a single step.

The one-step replication is possible if spacings between the three lines of piles are the same.
Here, the spacings between Y = -13 and Y = -8.5 and between Y = -85. and Y = -4.0 are
ΔY = +4.5 . Note that ΔY is positive because the " ΔY steps" will be from Y = -13.0 to
Y = -8.5 and then from Y = -8.5 to Y = -4.0.

The one-step replication will be use here.

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 121


Show only the footing/pile area

Rubberband Zoom this area

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 122


Select: Three piles, six nodes (at ends of piles), and three boundary restraints

Do not include the


plate edge nodes
for replication

Use the following four steps


to make this selection

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 123


Selection Step 1

Hold left
button down
Node at top of pile
Drag mouse to include the pile,
plus the joints at the top and Plate corner node
bottom of the pile.
Note that the plate corner node Drag mouse from left to right
cannot be avoided. It will be
deselected in Step 4.
Selected area

Node at bottom of pile


Let left
button up

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 124


Selection Step 2 Selection Step 3

Hold left
Hold left
button down
button down
Node at top
of pile
Node at top of pile

Drag mouse
Drag mouse

Node at bottom
Selected area Selected area
of pile
Node at bottom of pile

Let left
Let left button up
button up

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 125


Selection Step 4

Objects to be replicated

Left-click to deselect
the plate corner joint

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 126


Replicate 3-pile selection ΔY = +4.5 twice in one step

ΔY = +4.5

ΔY = +4.5

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 127


Replicate completed – view in Home tab, Rubberband Zoom

Two rows of
piles added
Rubberband Zoom

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 128


Perspective Extrude View of selected area

Open and select Extrude View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 129


Switch to XZ View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 130


XZ Extrude View ( Perspective turned off )

Perspective toggle

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 131


Switch to YZ View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 132


YZ Extrude View ( Perspective turned off )

Perspective toggle

Z
View toward X = 0
Y

Pile rows added by Replicate

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 133


Finish drawing the foundations
Z Z

Y Y

5.0 17.0 5.0 ΔY = +17.0

Just completed

Replicate

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 134


In Home tab:
Turn off Extrude View , select 3-d View , and Rubberband Zoom to get area shown

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 135


Drag mouse from left to right to select pile cap and piles

Be sure to include the


plate node at the far
corner of the pile cap.
Start selection

End selection

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 136


Selected objects to Replicate

Selected objects: Pile cap


(16 finite elements) and
nine fixed-base piles

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 137


Replicate selected objects

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 138


Replicated objects – note that grid
lines are not replicated or expanded

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 139


In Home tab, return to Perspective View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 140


Switch to Perspective Extrude View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 141


Switch to YZ Extrude View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 142


YZ Extrude View

Perspective toggle

Z Grid lines

Grid lines

Perspective on Perspective off

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 143


The grid lines can now be either deleted or hidden

Delete grid lines ….. a bad idea …. DON'T DO IT

Right click
anywhere in view
panel Delete all

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 144


Hide the grid lines

Right click
anywhere in view
panel

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 145


The grid lines are still there, but are hidden.
They can be unhidden by the same procedure ( as will be done in Option 3 of this Exercise )

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 146


Foundation drawing completed and the grid has been hidden

Perspective toggle
But….is the foundation part
of the Bridge Model?

Perspective on Perspective off

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 147


In Home tab, Restore Full View ( Perspective ) and turn off Extrude View

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 148


In Bridge tab, Update the Bridge Model to include the foundations

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 149


After the Bridge Model has been updated, switch to the Analysis tab
and run an analysis for the DEAD loads

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 150


Analysis complete: Note that the model is Locked.
In order to make any changes in the model it must be Unlocked,
which will erase the results of the analysis

The model has deflected, but the


deflection is a little hard to see

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 151


In the Home tab, open the Deformed Shape box

The deformed shape has been drawn using a


very small default Auto Scaling factor

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 152


Choose a Scale Factor that shows a reasonable deformed shape

The magnitude of the scale factor has no physical


significance … it is just a relative number

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 153


Extrude View off
Extrude View on

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 154


Displacements U1 , U2 , U3 measured in structure X-Y-Z coordinates

Z (U3)
Y (U2)
X (U1)

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 155


Deflected profile

XZ plane

Z (U3)
Deflection reference line
X (U1)

Deflection at bent due to elastic shortening


of the bent columns and the piles

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 156


Selected vertical deflections

Move cursor to joint


Z (U3)

X (U1)

U3 = -0.0593 in
U3 = -0.2957 in

Set units to inches

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 157


Longitudinal ( M3 ) moment diagram – Entire Bridge

Structure ("global")
coordinate system
Z

Y 2
X 4913 ft-k
1

Member coordinate system for 3107 ft-k


member laid out from X = 0 to
X at the end of the bridge

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 158


Compare DEAD load moment diagrams for two column base options

Option 1 Option 2
Bent columns fixed at bases Bent columns on pile foundations
( column extended to mid-depth
of pile cap )

4949 ft-k 4913 ft-k

2997 ft-k 3107 ft-k

Why are they different?

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 159


Vertical reactions at tips of piles

If necessary, use Display Options


to turn off viewing Restraints

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 160


Rubberband Zoom to
isolate this footing

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 161


Isolated view of pile footing reactions in –Y region

Bent column
Right-click on joint

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 162


In XZ plane view reactions at each Y position

Use arrows to select Y = - 4.0


( note that Y position is not shown
anywhere on the screen – nasty )

Rubberband Zoom

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 163


Vertical reactions at Y = - 13.0 ft

X = 84.5
X = 75.5

X = 80.0
Y = - 13.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 164


Vertical reactions at Y = - 8.5 ft

X = 75.5

X = 80.0

X = 84.5
Y = - 8.5

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 165


Vertical reactions at Y = - 4.0 ft

X = 75.5

X = 80.0

X = 84.5
Y = - 4.0

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 166


Total upward vertical reaction per pile footing

52.47 + 55.05 + 52.39 = 159.9

55.09 + 65.87 + 55.01 = 176.0 495.8 kips

52.47 + 55.05 + 52.39 = 159.9

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 167


Axial force at base of bent column

present view ( whatever it may be )

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 168


Display member axial force for Frame Members

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 169


Rubberband Zoom to improve resolution

Select Y = - 8.5 ft

Note: Y position not shown!!

Bent column appears when Y = - 8.5'

Rubberband zoom

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 170


Axial force near base of bent column ( approximately at top of pile cap )

Bent column appears when Y = - 8.5'

Axial compression near base of bent


column = - 372.0 (4 sig. figures)

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 171


Alternate view – XZ View ( Rubberband Zoom )

Select Y = - 8.5 ft in XZ view

Note: Y position not shown!!

Bent column appears when Y = - 8.5'

Axial compression near base of bent


column = - 372.0 (4 sig. figures)

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 172


Show member axial force diagrams

If necessary, use Display Options


to turn off viewing Restraints

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 173


Compression forces in piles and in bent column where it connects to
the plate element at the mid-depth of the pile cap

Put cursor
on joint

Rubberband Zoom R = 52.47


(earlier slides)

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 174


Use Advanced ► Assign ► More to clear display of currently-shown results

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 175


Pile and cap weights

13.0' x 13.0'
concrete pile cap Weight of concrete pile cap ( disregard 2.0' steel pipe
4.0' length extensions into pile cap ):
13.0' x 13.0' x 4.0' x 0.15 k/ft3 = 101.4 kips

Weight per pile:

12.75' Core diameter = 13.25" / 12 in/ft = 1.102 ft


 1.1042 2
Core area per foot = ft / ft  0.9575 ft 2 / ft
4
Core weight = 0.9575 ft2/f x 0.15 k/ft3 = 0.1436 k/ft
concrete filled 14"-diam  ( 14.02  13.252 ) in2
steel piles ( 9 total ) Pipe area per foot =  0.1115 ft 2 / ft
4 ( 144 in2 / ft 2 ) / ft

steel pipe Pipe weight = 0.1115 ft2/f x 0.495 k/ft3 = 0.0552 k/ft
concrete core
Pile weight per foot = ( 0.1436 + 0.0552 ) k/ft = 0.1988 k/ft

tw = 3/8" Weight per pile = 0.1988 k/ft x 12.75 ft = 2.535 k/pile

Total pile weight = 2.535 k/pile x 9 piles = 22.8 kips

doutside = 14"

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 176


Check pile footing vertical equilibrium

Column force near top of pile cap = 372.0 kips


(why not use 373.1 kips – Slide 176 ??)

Pile cap weight = 101.4 kips


496.2 kips downward

Total pile weight = 22.8 kips

Close enough !!

Total reaction = 495.8 kips upward ( Slide 176 )

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 177


Save your CSI Bridge .bdb file in two versions:

Save as: Example2-Two-Equal-Span-Option2.bdb


This is the option just completed in which the two columns bases frame into
the pile cap in a pile-cap/piles foundation

Save as: Example2-Two-Equal-Span-Option3.bdb


This will be the starting point for the next option in which the columns bases
are connected to the pile caps by Joint Constraints

10/19/2011 Example2-Two-Equal-Spans-Option2-Final.ppt 178

You might also like