5/9/24, 6:11 PM In India, the idea of democracy differs from its practice | The Indian Express

Subscribe Sign In
JOURNALISM OF COURAGE

Home ePaper Cities India Explained Opinion Business Entertainment Sports Politics UPSC

UPSC Pack IPL Premium Stories Elections Express Shorts Mini Games 🎙️Podcast Health & We

News / Opinion / Columns / In India, the idea of democracy differs from its practice

In India, the idea of democracy differs from its practice

Our politics increasingly seems unmoored from certain human values
considered essential for democracy. Thus, another way of imagining a
democracy that is engaged with the human being is challenging.
Written by M H Ilias
Updated: May 9, 2024 11:20 IST

Follow Us

Gandhi did not favour the constitutionalisation of democracy which, according to him, has to be preserved in
society as an essential value.

According to Italian political philosopher Giorgio Agamben, democracy is both a

means of constituting the body politic and a technique of governing. As a technique
of governance, democracy has been a source of legitimacy for governments to
exercise power and control or govern the “population” since the French Revolution.
In societies, on the other hand, it is a natural sentiment, an essential value.
https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/india-democracy-election-9316842/ 1/5
5/9/24, 6:11 PM In India, the idea of democracy differs from its practice | The Indian Express

Freedom to dissent, demand justice, recognise differences and respect theSubscribe

rights ofSign In
JOURNALISM OF COURAGE
others are driving forces of democracy in the first sense. The “majoritarian
Home ePaper determines
consensus” Cities India the
Explained Opinion
character Businessof Entertainment
and content democracy inSports Politics UPSC
the second
EXPRESS EXPLAINED
sense. The history of India and Nepal's border issue X

In practice, democracy as a principle seldom overpowers the notion of democracy

as an administrative practice. It is no different in India. Questions about the state of
democracy come up only around crises of procedures like those related to elections
or institutions like Parliament. Few seriously examine what values should mark
democracy in a country like India where pluralism, diversity and tolerance are
necessary for society to survive.

The idea of democracy was introduced and nurtured during the national
movement. Despite its upper-caste and middle-class content, the values and
principles of democracy became entrenched in politics and thereby in the political
imagination of the people in subtle ways. Even those opposed to Gandhi, Ambedkar
and socialists converged on the notion and importance of tolerance and dissent.

Due to the structural inequalities of Indian society, B R Ambedkar considered

democracy a value that the Constitution must protect and guarantee. Gandhi did
not favour the constitutionalisation of democracy which, according to him, has to
be preserved in society as an essential value. He did not want to privilege and
legalise democracy as a part of constitutional morality over a traditional, social
morality. In his view, it was not a part of our natural sentiment. Rather, it was
artificially cultivated or externally imposed — which is in contrast to the “real”
democratic tradition in India that flourished through religious co-existence.

In the early years after Independence, the Indian state maintained some
commitment to justice and fundamental rights but tolerance of dissent remained
an incomplete project. The state’s position as “guardian of democracy” resulted in
many unpleasant episodes, including the proclamation of Emergency by Indira
Gandhi in 1975. What makes the present situation different from previous
experiences is that the clout of certain kinds of organisations is no longer seen as
abnormal. This happened during the Emergency as well – Sanjay Gandhi’s hold on
the government is well-known. But the current regime has legitimised the sway of
organisations like the RSS through popular means. The conditions of a working

https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/india-democracy-election-9316842/ 2/5
5/9/24, 6:11 PM In India, the idea of democracy differs from its practice | The Indian Express

democracy may be the same for seven decades, but the principles and values have
Subscribe Sign In
JOURNALISM OF COURAGE
the potential to be altered.
Home ePaper Cities India Explained Opinion Business Entertainment Sports Politics UPSC
Our politics increasingly seems unmoored from certain human values that are
EXPRESS EXPLAINED
The history of India and Nepal's border issue X
often considered essential for democracy. Thus, another way of imagining a
democracy that is engaged with the human being and a concern for everyday life
is challenging in our situation.

Alain Badiou describes democracy as the dominant “emblem” in a political society.

One can express displeasure over the functioning of political society, denounce the
structure or any aspects of it, or criticise political parties that are a part of it. You
will always be pardoned as long as you do it in the name of democracy. This
observation becomes more pertinent in the Indian context, especially when
everyone, including those who are against democracy, engages in discussions on
forms of democracy, when concern over the very content and values of democracy
struggle to capture popular imagination.

The writer is professor, School of Gandhian Thought and Development

Studies, Mahatma Gandhi University, Kerala

© The Indian Express Pvt Ltd

First uploaded on: 09-05-2024 at 08:00 IST

TAGS: Democracy

TOP CATEGORIES

Explained News Political Pulse Latest Opinion Mumbai News

Delhi News Pune News Bangalore News Bollywood News

Health News India News Sports News Lifestyle News

Latest News Cricket Tech Reviews Gadgets

Mobile & Tabs Food & Wine Elections 2024 Fitness

TRENDING NEWS

https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/india-democracy-election-9316842/ 3/5
5/9/24, 6:11 PM In India, the idea of democracy differs from its practice | The Indian Express
Latest News Health And Wellness Education News Buy All-Access Plan
Subscribe Sign In
JOURNALISM OF COURAGE
Entertainment News Trending News Political News Business News
Home ePaper Cities India Explained Opinion Business Entertainment Sports Politics UPSC
Why Subscribe Indian
EXPRESS EXPLAINED
Buy Digital Premium Subscribe To The Indian Lok Sabha Election
Express The history of India and Nepal's border issue Express Schedule X
IPL 2024 Board Exam Results WBCHSE WB HS Result 2024

LATEST STORIES

Karnataka HC Grants Bail
To Pocso Accused After
He Agrees To Marry
Victim
Would Rather Quit Politics
Than Leave BJP Again:
Arvinder Singh Lovely
IMD Warns Of Rain, Kerala +2 Result 2024 Live
Thunderstorms Until May Updates: DHSE Kerala
12, Rapid Drop In Plus Two Result Today At
Temperatures In West 3 PM, Check At
Bengal Keralaresults.Nic.In

Can Gut Bacteria Chew Up
Your Bad Cholesterol?
Sonakshi Sinha On
‘Gruesome Act Of
Violence’ Against Manisha
Koirala’s Character In
Heeramandi, Fareedan’s
Reaction To It: ‘Loved How
Bad She Is’
Pakistan On Edge On First Vijay Deverakonda’s
Anniversary Of May 9 Birthday Gift To Fans:
Mayhem Led By Imran Actor To Star In Dil Raju’s
Khan Supporters Pan-India Rural Actioner
SVC 59, See Blood-Soaked
Poster

Biden Administration Will Karnataka SSLC Result Indian-American Express Subscription

Propose Tougher Asylum
Standards For Some
Migrants At The Border
2024 Declared At
Karresults.Nic.In, 73.40%
Pass; 78 Schools Score 0
Philanthropist Ramesh Offer For UPSC Aspirants:
Bhutada Donates USD 1 Get Access To Full
Million To Hindu American Package Including
Foundation Monthly UPSC Essentials
Magazine

Lok Sabha Election 2024
Live Updates: Rahul
Gandhi, Amit Shah To
Campaign In Telangana
8-Year-Old Girl Rescued
From Kidnapper Within 24
Hours: Delhi Police
Mentally Unstable Man
Kills 2 In Aligarh, Lynched
By Villagers
Kerala Govt Issues Alert
After Rise In West Nile
Fever Cases: Know The
Causes And Symptoms Of
The Disease

FOLLOW US

DOWNLOAD APPS

The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates
news sources for their journalistic standards.
EXPRESS GROUP

The Indian Express ieTamil.com

The Financial Express ieBangla.com

https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/india-democracy-election-9316842/ 4/5
5/9/24, 6:11 PM In India, the idea of democracy differs from its practice | The Indian Express

Loksatta ieMalayalam.com
Subscribe Sign In
JOURNALISM OF COURAGE
Jansatta ieGujarati.com

Home
inUth ePaper Cities India Explained Opinion Business Entertainment Sports Politics UPSC
The ExpressGroup
EXPRESS EXPLAINED
MyInsuranceClub Newsletters
The history of India and Nepal's border issue X
26/11 Stories of Strength Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Awards

Online Classes for Kids Light House Journalism

Compare Term Insurance

QUICK LINKS

T&C Privacy Policy

Advertise with Us Brand Solutions

Contact Us Subscribe

Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses) This website follows the DNPA’s code of conduct

CSR

Copyright © 2024 The Indian Express [P] Ltd. All Rights Reserved

https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/india-democracy-election-9316842/ 5/5