Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Human Branding in Political Marketing
Human Branding in Political Marketing
Human Branding in Political Marketing
To cite this article: Richard Speed, Patrick Butler & Neil Collins (2015) Human Branding in Political
Marketing: Applying Contemporary Branding Thought to Political Parties and Their Leaders, Journal of
Political Marketing, 14:1-2, 129-151, DOI: 10.1080/15377857.2014.990833
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the
“Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis,
our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to
the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions
and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors,
and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content
should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources
of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims,
proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever or
howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising
out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms &
Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-
and-conditions
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
Journal of Political Marketing, 14:129–151, 2015
Copyright # Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
ISSN: 1537-7857 print=1537-7865 online
DOI: 10.1080/15377857.2014.990833
RICHARD SPEED
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
PATRICK BUTLER
Melbourne Business School, Carlton, Victoria, Australia
NEIL COLLINS
Graduate School of Public Policy, Nazarbayev University, Kazakhstan
129
130 R. Speed et al.
perform a central role in business, and brand and related concepts underpin
areas of research interest pertaining to customer value, market positioning,
consumer experience, and management performance. Research on brand
issues may be found in the principal theoretical journals in marketing, includ-
ing Journal of Marketing, Journal of Marketing Research, Marketing Science,
and Journal of Consumer Behaviour. In this essay, we attempt to contribute to
this research momentum by taking one of the most recent branches of brand
research—the study of the human brand—into the political marketing arena.
Among the conclusions of this exploration are that brand concepts are of
functional value to political management and that political marketing,
because of the distinctive role of the person in the party organization,
provides a particularly useful context for the study of the human brand.
Many recent research articles in political marketing assert the field’s
enhanced stature and contribution. It is regarded as an identifiable academic
subdiscipline (Butler, Collins, and Fellenz 2007); as drawing upon the expert-
ise of scholars in multiple fields including management, politics, economics,
sociology, and journalism (Butler and Harris 2009); as growing in scale and
support (Harris and Lock 2010); and as an established field of professional
practice (Plasser and Plasser 2002; Johnson 2009). As evidence of its growth
and impact, political marketing may point to its own dedicated journal, text-
books, handbooks and edited works, academic conferences, and specialist
interest groups in the academy.
Reports of progress are not intended to play down the difficulties and
controversies associated with development and establishment of the field,
however. Advancement has not been uncontroversial. Political marketing is
subject to criticism from two main directions: one concerns the ethics of
applying business concepts to democratic processes because of the
perceived negative effects on societal welfare (Butler and Harris 2009;
Henneberg 2004; Marland 2003; O’Shaughnessy 1990). The other, more
recent, mode of criticism arises within the field, from interested parties
concerned with continually improving the quality of research. Part of that
concern relates to the importance of utilizing newer and more sophisticated
marketing concepts in political marketing research. Henneberg and
Human Branding in Political Marketing 131
O’Shaughnessy (2009), for instance, note that ‘‘political marketing still shows
an adherence to concepts which are coming more and more under scrutiny
in mainstream marketing’’ (p. 8) and decry ‘‘its reliance on (arguably)
obsolete marketing concepts’’ (p. 8). Investigating an important issue in
contemporary marketing theory within the political marketing arena is an
attempt here to address such concerns.
Another concern in theory building is the lack of contingency thinking.
Transferring the nomenclature of marketing to politics is relatively simple:
Citing policies as products, citizens as buyers, and votes as price can contrib-
ute to a helpful initial framing of conditions. But other than briefly serving to
signal grounds for comparative analysis, that is an oversimplification of the
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
weights. For instance, Harrop (1990) talks of party image and policies; Farrell
and Wortmann (1987) speak of ‘‘party image, leader image, and manifesto
proposals or selected issues’’ as being the ‘‘product’’; and Worcester and
Mortimore (2005) propose a ‘‘political triangle’’ based on issues, party image,
and leader image.
In this paper, we follow this school of thinking about the political
‘‘product’’—or offer to the market—and draw on the framework proposed
as the basis for contextualizing political marketing described by Butler and
Collins (1994). In this approach, what characterizes the offer and differenti-
ates it from the common or commercial understanding of a product is that
it is a distinctly multi-component phenomenon that combines the ideology,
the person, and the party (see Figure 1). Each of these components of the
FIGURE 2 Illustrative Association set for Volkswagen Beetle (from John et al. 2006).
Human Branding in Political Marketing 135
Following this logic, the tripartite political offer can be interpreted as a brand
(Smith and French 2009; French and Smith 2010; Needham 2006), with
136 R. Speed et al.
that promises more parental choice will draw associations from the right.
Foreign policies that emphasize human rights issues are associated with
internationalism, whereas policies that emphasize trade opportunities are
more nationalist in association. These associations exist for each of these
policies regardless of the candidate or party advocating them (Bale 2006).
Parties also have associations arising from their origins, past positions,
and past actions (White and de Chernatony 2002; Evans 2008). In Figure 2,
the British Conservative Party is seen as traditional in outlook, a supporter
of business committed to lower taxes and representative of the upper and
middle classes.
The individuals involved in political parties also carry associations
(Harris and Lock 2001; Needham 2005; Scammell 2007; Haddock 2003;
Finlayson 2002). For instance, a local candidate may have a past history in
FIGURE 3 Possible association set for British Conservative Party (adapted from French and
Smith 2010).
Human Branding in Political Marketing 137
the community that carries an association. But at the top level in the party, as
political leaders make decisions they acquire associations. Margaret Thatcher
was associated with war in the Falklands; Tony Blair with war in Iraq.
Winston Churchill’s decisions over the Tonypandy riots in 1910 created
negative associations that affected his standing in Wales for the rest of his life.
The political offer, then, can be reinterpreted in these three terms. Each
element of the offer—policy, party, and person—can be the subject of mar-
keting communication designed to either reinforce or change voters’ percep-
tions and so can form part of the brand’s positioning. Also, to the extent to
which voters have knowledge about the policies, party, or people that form
the brand stored in memory, these elements form part of the brand heritage.
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
Seen through the brand lens, the political offer highlights three possible
sources of associations about the political brand: the ideology or policy,
the organization or party, and the leader. In competition, political decision
makers have attempted to shift the political contest in their favor by changing
each and all of these three elements. The amendment and abandonment of
contentious and unsuccessful policy positions is a constant aspect of the
political process.
To emphasize the central role of the person, the position of the political
leaders as a brands is convoluted further by the fact that they rarely have an
identifiable existence as brands independent of their status as party leaders.
To illustrate this, we explore human brands and the unusual characteristics of
political leaders in branding in terms in the next section.
Personal Any Universal— How individuals Organizations Criticism—(Hearn Not developed Considerable
Individual employers, can use tools buy the 2008; Shepherd ‘‘how-to’’
friends, and techniques personal brand 2005; Lair et al. literature (e.g.,
acquaintances of marketing 2005) Peters 1999;
and brand Andrusia and
management to Haskins 2000)
advance their
careers
Celebrity Well-known Consumers How the Organizations Drivers of Considerable Considerable
identities familiarity and acquire consumer celebrity literature in
associations of celebrity brand attachment endorsement media and
well-known equity through (Thomson 2006) literature (e.g., cultural studies
139
individuals contracts Silvera and
influence Austad 2004)
consumer
behavior
Businessperson CEOs Stockmarkets, How the Organizations Not developed No application to Distinction
employers familiarity and with celebrity marketing between
associations of CEOs gain reputation and
business leaders benefits and celebrity
affect their accept risks (Rindova et al.
organization 2006); impact of
CEO celebrity
on
remuneration
and
(Continued )
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
TABLE 1 Continued
performance
(Wade et al.
2006);
premiums paid
in takeovers
(Hayward and
Hambrick 1997)
Politician Leaders= Voters How the People (leaders Not developed Change of leader Communication
candidates familiarity and and to reposition strategies to
140
associations of a candidates) are parties (Neale reposition party
political leader= part of the et al. 2008) leaders
candidate affect political offer (Scammell 2007)
electoral made by a Public relations
prospects of party strategies to
political parties position female
politicians
(Motion 2000)
Impact of leader
reputation on
political parties
(Davies and
Mian 2007)
Human Branding in Political Marketing 141
There are two main situations where a human brand can be linked to a
branded organization: by contract or by office. In these cases the human
brand is a competitive resource that may be used to represent the organiza-
tion to the public. In the case of a celebrity endorser or advertising spokes-
person, the connection between the person and the brand is by contract. An
alternative link is through office bearing. In this case, the human brand is a
competitive resource of the organization, but they are also a company officer
and have decision rights within the organization. In a commercial context,
such a human brand would be a celebrity business person, a recognized
individual who leads a known organization (Treadway et al. 2009; Graffin
et al. 2008; Hayward et al. 2004; Rindova, Pollack, and Hayward 2006)
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
While human branding theory is in its infancy, there are nonetheless a number
of observations that can be made about the factors influencing the strength of
a human brand, and these factors can be examined in the context of politics.
We highlight two distinguishing features of human brands in politics that may
be developed on the basis of the three-component representation of the polit-
ical offer outlined earlier. We concentrate on the relationship between the
person and the other two elements. First, the relationship between the person
and the ideology or policy is critical. That is, the alignment of the political lea-
der and the promise to the voter must be clear and credible; the fundamental
question of authenticity underpins this. Second, the relationship between the
person and the party is critical. For any leader, the ability to command a party
to actually deliver policy and to be perceived as such, is essential. This is
about the authority of the person in the political organization. Thus, we
explore the brand authenticity and brand authority of the political figure.
Figure 4 outlines the nature of the relationships.
the actual personality of the person who is the human brand. This is consist-
ent with the use of ‘‘brand persona’’ to represent the image communicated
when dealing with abstract brands. It is also consistent with the distinction
that is made in corporate branding between image and identity. In analyzing
political marketing, a brand persona is a useful concept to employ. All the
deliberate positioning effort applied to party and candidate is attempting
to create a particular brand image in the eyes of the targeted voters. The posi-
tioning process will seek to highlight attributes that are particularly valued by
these target voters and to moderate any attributes that are seen as negatives.
As the preferences of target voters change, so must the brand persona, even
if the underlying party or personal characteristics cannot be changed as
quickly.
In building any brand, managers rarely have complete freedom to pro-
mote attributes and position the brand as they wish. For any brand, the
brand’s history and heritage constrains their options, and some consistency
with past positioning is required. For human brands, while the concept of
the persona recognizes that there is scope for the presentation of an image
that is not necessarily a complete representation of the individual’s actual
character, the persona presented must be one that the individual concerned
can support and reinforce in their day-to-day actions. The extent of scrutiny
on both the political and personal lives of political leaders is sufficient to
highlight areas where the persona presented does not ring true.
We term this fit between persona and underlying personality
‘‘authenticity.’’ Note that we are not suggesting that the brand persona has
to be a warts-and-all presentation of the individual concerned. A good brand
persona is a presentation of a persona that the individual concerned is able to
Human Branding in Political Marketing 143
of memory, history, and attitudes toward the Vietnam War to raise doubt
about the authenticity of his war service record in Vietnam effectively
destroyed one of Kerry’s biggest single assets in the electoral contest with
George W. Bush (Robinson 2006).
The requirement to adjust position does not just arise over time with
changing public perceptions. It also arises directly from the political process.
Generating authenticity is a challenge in a number of electoral systems,
where there is a distinction between election by activists and by the general
population. The challenges of serial elections where activists and general
voters both have a role in electoral outcomes have been investigated exten-
sively in political science (e.g., May 1973; Robertson 1976; Kitschelt 1989). In
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
this paper we focus purely on the authenticity challenges posed and leave on
one side the more general challenges investigated in such research.
The U.S. system of primaries to choose candidates followed by a general
election has long been considered problematic for candidates since they
must first win the support of the majority of their own party and then win
the support of the general electorate. This two-stage process means that in
the first contest they are seeking to win the approval of the median primary
voter and in the second the median general election voter. These two targets
have distinctly different preferences, and positions taken to secure the party
nomination may well have to be moderated to secure the support of
non-party voters. Researchers in political economy have investigated the
conditions under which electoral institutions influence election outcome:
‘‘During primary election campaigns, extremism is better than moderation
because primary voters are located near the ends of the ideological spectrum.
Only after primary nominations are settled is moderation towards the center
a reasonable strategy’’ (Burden 2001: 99)
The problem is similar, but less formal, in leadership contests in parlia-
mentary parties. Generally the electorate for leadership contests are party
members or party parliamentarians, who have considerably more partisan
preferences than the general electorate. Successful leadership candidates
often find that positions taken to secure the leadership have to be dismantled
to contest general elections. Presenting a persona that is appealing to the
median voter among party activists and then seeking to present a persona
that appeals to the median voter among the general electorate, requires a
repositioning and has the potential for inconsistencies that undermine the
perception of authenticity. This is not a problem that human brands outside
politics encounter with such regularity.
and other celebrities may have links with organizations such as teams, movie
projects, or endorsed products, but these links can be changed. Players can
swap teams, new movie projects can be undertaken, new endorsement deals
can be signed. The human brand takes their personal brand equity with them
into the new situation. Even if human brand equity was built in a particular
organization, that link can be broken. With this degree of portability and
independence from organizations, it is possible to consider such human
brands as appropriate for use in co-branding models. For instance, a cos-
metics company might use an actress to brand a line of perfumes or a sport-
ing goods company use a sports star to brand a line of equipment. Such
arrangements are consistent with co-branding and can be modelled and
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
organizational actor will not just be promising but will also have some
responsibility for delivery. The ability of a leader to deliver on policy
depends on their ability to create a controlling coalition within their own
party. This process will vary depending on the political system or the party
structures. In the U.S., the need to form a coalition on a national issue is
frequently about marshalling enough legislators in Congress to pass a bill.
In countries with stronger party discipline the need to form a coalition is
not to marshal a vote on a bill but to get the bill drafted in a form that is
acceptable.
The consumer’s perception of a party leader’s ability to deliver is part of
the political brand. If perceptions of ability to deliver are low, then the con-
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
REFERENCES
Evans, S. (2008). Consigning its past to history? David Cameron and the Conservative
Party. Parliamentary Affairs, 61(2), 291–314.
Farrell, D. M., and M. Wortmann. (1987). Party strategies in the electoral market:
Political marketing in West Germany, Britain, and Ireland. European Journal
of Poltical Research, 15, 297–318.
Finlayson, A. (2002). Elements of the Blairite image of leadership. Parliamentary
affairs: A journal of representative politics, 55(3), 586–599.
French, A., and G. Smith. (2010). Measuring political brand equity: A consumer
oriented approach. European Journal of Marketing, 44(3=4), 460–477.
Goffee, R., and G. Jones. (2005). The paradox of great leadership. Harvard Business
Review, (December), 85–94.
Graffin, S. D., J. B. Wade, J. F. Porac, and R. C. McNamee. (2008). The impact of
CEO status diffusion on the economic outcomes of other senior managers.
Organization Science, 19, 457–474.
Graham, S. (2001). Build your own life brand: A powerful strategy to maximize your
potential and enhance your value for ultimate achievement. Fort Detroit, MI:
Free Press.
Grunert, K. G. (1996). Automatic and strategic processes in advertising effects.
Journal of Marketing, 60(4), 88–101.
Haddock, G. (2003). Making a party leader less of a party member: The impact of
ambivalence on assimilation and contrast effects in political party attitudes.
Political Psychology, 24(4), 769–780.
Harris, P., and A. Lock. (2001). Establishing the Charles Kennedy brand: A strategy
for an election the result of which is a foregone conclusion. Journal of
Marketing Management, 17(9–10), 943–956.
Harris, P., and A. Lock. (2010). Mind the gap: The rise of political marketing and a
perspective on its future agenda. European Journal of Marketing, 44(3–4),
297–307.
Harrop, M. (1990). Political marketing. Parliamentary Affairs, 43(3), 277–291.
Hayward, M. L. A., and D. C. Hambrick. (1997). Explaining the premiums paid for
large acquisition Evidence of CEO hubris. Administrative Science Quarterly,
42, 103–127.
Hayward, M. L. A., V. P. Rindova, and T. G. Pollock. (2004). Believing one’s own
press: The causes and consequences of CEO celebrity. Strategic Management
Journal, 25, 637–655.
Human Branding in Political Marketing 149
Hearn, A. (2008). Meat, mask, burden: Probing the contours of the branded self,
Journal of Consumer Culture, 8, 197.
Henneberg, S. C. (2002). Understanding political marketing. In N. O’Shaughnessy
and S. C. Henneberg (Eds.), The idea of political marketing. Westport, CT:
Praeger.
Henneberg, S. C. (2004). The views of an advocatus dei: Political marketing and its
critics. Journal of Public Affairs, 4(3), 225–243.
Henneberg, S. C., and N. J. O’Shaughnessy. (2009). Political relationship marketing:
Some macro=micro thoughts. Journal of Marketing Management, 25(1–2),
5–29.
John, D. R., B. Loken, K. Kim, and A. Basu Monga. (2006). Brand concept maps: A
methodology for identifying brand association networks. Journal of Marketing
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 11:13 24 April 2015
AUTHOR NOTES