Houston (1996) - Symbolic Sweatbaths of The Maya

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 21

Society for American Archaeology

Symbolic Sweatbaths of the Maya: Architectural Meaning in the Cross Group at Palenque,
Mexico
Author(s): Stephen D. Houston
Source: Latin American Antiquity, Vol. 7, No. 2 (Jun., 1996), pp. 132-151
Published by: Society for American Archaeology
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/971614 .
Accessed: 08/06/2014 20:41

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

Society for American Archaeology is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Latin
American Antiquity.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA:ARC:illl ECTURAL
MEANINGIN THE CROSSGROUPATPALENQUE,MEXICO

Stephen
D. Houston

Thefunction of elite Maya architecture should not always be interpretedliterally,for it may also reflect metaphorical and
semantic extensions best studied through iconography, hieroglyphic texts, ethnohistory, and ethnography. This holistic
approach is employed to help resolve puzzlingfeatures of the Cross Groupsanctuaries at Palenque, Mexico. The Cross Group
likely served as the setting for symbolic sweatbaths, probably involving effigies of supernaturals under the care of Kan
Balam, the Palenque ruler who commissioned these structures. This and other argumentssituate such informationwithin an
understandingof metaphor in Maya architecture.

A pesar de interpretaciones literales con respecto a la funcion y significado de la arquitecturamaya en contextos de e'lite,
este ensayo sugiere un enfoque distinto, dando e'nfasisa los datos iconogra'ficos,epigra'ficos,etnohistoricos, y etnogra'ficos
para elucidar patrones de meta'forasarquitectonicas. En particular, se refiere a unos rasgos enigma'ticosdel "Grupode la
Cruz" en la ciudad maya de Palenque, Chiapas, Me'xico.Tales rasgos demuestranuna explicacion puramente simbolica de
este conjunto, el cual funcionaba como el centro de los "banos de vapor" utilizados por ima'genesde los dioses dina'sticos
del sitio, a buen recaudo del gobernante Kan Balam, su guardian titular.Alfin, este ensayo subraya la importanciade sim-
bolismo y las meta'forasen la interpretacionde arquitecturaMaya.

A centralconcernto Mayanistsis the inte- bining a purely symbolic function with some, but
grationof archaeologyand epigraphy,a not all, of the formal propertiesand terminology
task made more pressing by recent of a sweatbath,can be understoodby surveyinga
advancesin the deciphermentof Maya script. wide variety of information, ranging from
Thispaperprovidesan exampleof suchintegra- iconography and hieroglyphs of the Classic
tionby focusingon the site of Palenque,Mexico, period to ethnographic data on the medicinal
thelocationof muchepigraphicresearchoverthe qualities of the Native Americansweatbath.
past two decades(e.g., Schele 1992), and on a This paper focuses first on a puzzle: why did
place withinthis ClassicMayacity the Cross the Maya apply hieroglyphic terms for "ovens"
Group, a cluster of buildings and platforms and "sweatbaths"to structuresthat scholarshave
renownedfor both its hieroglyphictexts and labeled "sanctuaries"?It then shows, through a
iconography andtheeleganceandcarefulpropor- close study of thematically linked features of
tion of its architecture.The Cross Group is sweatbaths in modern, colonial, and ancient
equallynoteworthyfor anotherreason:it further sources, that Mesoamericansweatbathspossess a
documentsa complex repertoireof symbolic polythetic "package"of attributes,some concep-
manipulations (some "conflated," others tual and some material. The sanctuaries at
metaphoric)that are broadlydiffusedin depic- Palenquehave enough of these featuresto under-
tions of Classic Maya architectureand in the line their close linkage with sweatbathsbut a suf-
buildingsthemselves(MillerandHouston1987). ficient number of formal differences to indicate
Close attentionto art and writingin the Cross their symbolic quality.There is no evidence that
Groupshows thatone such manipulation, com- such structureswere ever used to generateor con-

Stephen D. Houston * Departmentof Anthropology,BrighamYoung University,Provo, UT 84602

Latin American Antiquity,7(2), 1996, pp. 132-151 .


Copyright (C)by the Society for AmericanArchaeology

132

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Ilouston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 133

Figure 1. Map of Palenque, Chiapas, Mexico (after Robertson 1983:Map 3).

tain heat or steam. The paper concludes by as LakamHa' (BannerWater).This was probably
addressing the ways in which ancient Maya a more generallabel for the site core of Palenque,
invoked varied meanings and metaphorsin their although combined here with LakamWitsin an
architecture. example of poetic coupleting "thebannerwater
or lake, and the banner hill." A study of place
A Puzzle names in Maya inscriptions,in which terms for
The temples of the Cross Grouphave a geograph- lake, water,or hill figure importantly,leads to the
ically prominent location within the site of conclusion thatthe site core of Palenqueprobably
Palenque, appearingon the lower slope of a hill took its name from the Otolum River, which
that may have been called YemalK'uk' Lakam bisects the core and cascades by the North Group
Wits (Descending Quetzal-BannerHill), perhaps (Stuartand Houston 1994:31).
a referenceto the "Mirador"hill thatrises majes- What interests us here, though, is not the
tically behind the Cross platform (Figure 1).' As toponymy or place names of the Classic period
Stuart points out (Stuart and Houston but the internal layout of the Cross Group tem-
1994:3s31), the door jambs of Temple 18 at ples. Robertson writes that each contains an
Palenque suggest that this area was subsumed "innersanctuary,a small structureindependentof
toponymicallywithin anotherlocation, translated the outer core of the building" (Robertson

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
134 LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY [Vol. 7, No. 2, 1996

SanctuaryTablet Sanctuary

o 5m

Figure 2. Arrangement of sanctuary in the Temple of the Sun, Cross Group, Palenque (after Robertson 1991.Figures
73-75; and Schele and Freidel l990:Figure 6, 11).

1991:9); in her words, "therewas never anything The iconography of the sculpturalensembles
like [the Cross Group]before, and nothing like it in the Cross Group is quite complex (see
was ever designed again" (Robertson1991:10). I Robertson 1991 for full illustration). The west
propose that the layout of the temples occurs at entablatureof the Temple of the Cross shows a
other sites and that it can be understoodin far clear depiction of a caiman, with cross-bandsfor
broader terms. The sanctuaries are not entirely orbs, and a distinctive, oval medallion with three
unique in layout and meaning, since examples of dots that is often associated with this reptile,
analogous structuresoccur in the corpus of Maya almostcertainlytermedayin in the Classic period.
architecture. Taube (1989:9) makes an excellent case that the
To understandthis point we must look at the caimanrepresentsa "primordialbeast from which
sanctuaries themselves (Figure 2). They are the earth is both destroyed and fashioned," and
small, stuccoed structureswith shallow corbeled that it is "closely identiEledwith an aged god of
vaults. In all three cases The Temples of the creation and sustenance."Regrettably,the entab-
Cross, the Sun, and the Foliated Cross the inte- latures of the Temple of the Sun are less clear,
rior dimensions are approximatelythe same: 3 m although one appears to depict a seated ruler,
wide, slightly less than 2 m deep, and about 2 m probably the great ruler Kan Balam, as he has
from the raisedfloor to the springlineof the vault, come to be called, with kneeling attendantsto
with just under a meter to the capstone. The either side.2 Nothing at all remains of the front
Sanctuaryof the Foliated Cross is distinguished entablatureof the Temple of the Foliated Cross.
by having two holes in this capstoneover the cen- The iconographyof the sanctuariesis no less
ter of the sanctuaryvault (Robertsonl991:Figure complex, although hieroglyphic evidence does
149). Each sanctuarysits within a larger,corbeled provide labels for these structures.Figure 3 dis-
chamberthatcommunicatesthroughan axial pas- plays a comparisonbetween the probablenames
sageway to a front room; three doors lead from of the sanctuariesand iconographicelements on
each room to the exterior. theirexteriors(Schele and Freidel 1990:239-252;

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
-

136 LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY [Vol. 7, No. 2, 1996

are the following: (1) 9.12.18.5.16, the 2 Cib 14


Mol date that Lounsbury (1989:248) has dis-
cussed in its astrological implications, which
involved the "impressive gathering of . . . three
celestial figures";(2) 9.12.18.5.17, the dedication
A B C D
of the K'inich K'uk'Na, perhapsreferringto sub-
structuresor platforms in the Cross Group; (3) Figure 5. Building terms in Cross Group texts. (A) u
9.12.19.14.12, connected,possibly, with the sanc- pEbna-ilspelling from door jamb of sanctuary, Temple of
the Cross, A6b (after Schele and Mathews 1979:Plate
tuaries themselves, which we know from struc- 273). (B) u kun-ilspelling from the west jamb, the Temple
tural evidence to be slightly later than the of Cross, C1 (after Robertson 1991:Plate 33). (C) u wayb-
construction of the chambers that contain them; il spelling from the Temple of the Sun Tablet, 05 (after
Robertson 1991:Plate 95). (D) u chitin-il spelling from
and, finally, (4) a Period Ending of 9.13.0.0.0.3 Temple of the Cross Tablet, 06 (after Robertson
These dates range from A.D. 690 to 692. 1991:Plate 9).
The Period Ending, the completion of an
importantcalendricalcycle, is unambiguous.The SA) proposed that this combinationof signs rep-
event associated with the structureknown as the resented the name of a building, possibly an
K'inich K'uk' Na, probably relates to "dedica- expression for a general class of structure,much
tion," although the expression is not completely like the wayibbuildings identified by Houston
deciphered,nor is the house (the Na in this name) and Stuart (1989) that have been interpretedby
securely identified. More relevant in this context Freidel, Grube, and Schele (Freidel et al.
are the probable dedications of the sanctuaries 1993:188-190, 441) as possible lineage shrines.
andthe actions recordedin connection with the 2 A perusal of Yucatec sources points to an intrigu-
Cib 14 Mol date. The events mentioned on the ing gloss: pib, which the Spanish-Mayaportion
alfardasare situatedtextuallyin terms of the birth of the Motul dictionary describes as a "very hot
of the supernaturalconnected with that particular bath for women," particularlythose who have
temple(Figure 4). We have discussed previously
recentlygivenbirth(BarreraVasquezl980:651).
the names of the sanctuaries that follow the Tojudge from other sources, the general sense is
"house"events; at the end of the texts occur the that of a subterraneanoven used for steaming
name of the Palenque ruler Kan Balam and, in food and, apparently, people that is, it is a
twocertain cases, the names of his parentsand a sweatbath.4The na in pibna-il is patently the
referenceto the placement or "forming"of the wordfor house, and the final consonantis a com-
sanctuaryin the site core of Palenque (Stuart mon suffix attached to nouns inflected for pos-
1994). What comes between is quite intriguing. session. After the pibna comes a term that has
At G2 on the alfarda texts appears a group of been variously interpretedas "divine-thing"or
signsthat can only read u-pi-bi-na-li, transliter- "holiness,"but that all concur must read u k'u-il
atedas u-pibna-il. Stuart (1987:38-39) (Figure oru ch'u-il(Ringle 1988).

A b

B .D

"house event" Date Sanctuary name u k'aba

ahis name"

Figure
6. Comparisonof texts fromthe doorjamb and east alfardaof the Templeof the Cross.
(A) Excerptfromdoor

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 137

I believe prior interpretationsof this expres- were in conjunction" (Schele and Freidel
sion are incorrect.The glyphs indicate simply that 1990:Figures6-15), that is, "two gods, perhaps
the pibnabelonged to the God of Kan Balam- correspondingto stars or planets, were in con-
another possessed entity. The clearest evidence junction."This is not what the glyphs say. Rather,
for this comes from a comparisonof two texts, the they read pu-lu-yi u-chi-ti-ni-il, or pul-uy u
sanctuarydoor jamb and the east alfardaof the chitin-il.Stuart (personal communication 1991)
Temple of the Cross (Figure 6). Part of the door shows, from dictionarysources and phonetic sub-
jamb text probably records: i-OCH-naX5EB 5 stitutions at Dos Pilas and Piedras Negras, that
K'ANASV6 KAAN-na-?/u-K'ABA/u-pi-bi-na- pul signifies "burn."Less clear is the meaningof
1U1 ?ye-NAL"Gl"/u-HUN-*TANMAK-*WAY- chitin.From a substitutionin a parallelphrasein
la, i och-naS eb S k'anasi6 kaan?,u k'aba,u the Temple of the Sun (O5), which contains way-
pibna-il,I .9yenal,"Gl", u huntanbak*elwayal, bil (FigureSC) in place of chitin,it seems reason-
or, in loose paraphrase,"then,on the date 5 Eb 6 able to assume that chitinis a kind of structure
*Kayab, is entered the 6 Sky? building, which is (Figure SD). Again, the rich Yucatecsources pro-
the name of the sweatbathof the god G1, who is vide a cognate form: kitim or kitin (Silvarez
the guarded thing of bakelwayal[title used by 1984: 198; Beltran de Santa Rosa Maria
Palenquekings]."5The alfardacontains much the 1859:236), which BarreraVasquez lists as a syn-
same information,although phrasedin a slightly onym for pib, "subterraneanoven" (1980:651).
different way: OCH-na/6 KAAN-na-?/u-pi-bi- Accordingly, the 2 Cib 14 Mol event should be
na-li/u-K'U-lilK'INICH KAN BALAM/BAK- understoodas, "theoven or sweatbathof the Triad
WAY-la, och-na 6 kaan?, u pibna-il, u k'u-il is burning."That is, the PalenqueTriadprepared
k'inichkanbalambak*elwayal,or, in paraphrase the bath by creating the necessary heat. As we
"is entered the 6 Sky? building, the sweatbathof shall see, there may be a reason why the event
the god of Kan Balam, who holds the bakelwayal would take place before the probablededication
title."In otherwords, one text explicitly identifies of the sanctuaries;at the least, we know that this
the sweatbathas the propertyof G1, a god in the was a key event afterthe accession of Kan Balam
Palenque Triad, and the other states that this (Lounsbury1980). Finally, it is worthmentioning
sweatbathbelongs to thegod of Kan Balam. The that there is another expression attested for the
alternativephrasings show that Kan Balam pos- sanctuaryof the Templeof the Cross. On the front
sessed a special relationship with this god and panel, the sanctuary is given its proper name,
that k'u records "god" ratherthan "holiness" or which is then described as "the name of the ku-
some relatednotion. nu-il (or kun-il),"probably of GI (Figure SB;
What aboutthe 2 Cib 14 Mol event mentioned Freidel et al. 1993:466). This phrase has been
before? Lounsbury ( 1989) demonstrates its interpreted to mean "platform"(David Stuart,
unusual astronomical properties, yet the event personal communication 1989), a reasonable
should not be translatedloosely as "GII and GIII idea, but there is anotherpossibility. The Vienna

f;rj.A:2, 1
' - -

!&>!

%<
S
)

u pAbna-il God's name or epithet u hun tan bak(elJwayal


"hissweatbath" "hisprotectedthing"

jamb (after Schele and Mathews 1979:273). (B) Excerpt from east alfarda (after Schele and Mathews 1979:272).

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY
138 [Vol. 7, No. 2, 1996

and Motul dictionaries, also in Yucatec


Maya, 1938:136). Nonetheless, the bathis still an impor-
record that kun (also kuun)means an "oven in
tant feature in many Native American
which ink is made from smoke," communi-
presumably ties. In the GuatemalanHighlands, it goes
from carbon scraped off the walls by a
(Barrera numberof terms, of which Quiche tuj is perhaps
Vasquez 1980:352). Thus, there are two kinds of
the best-known (Edmonson 1965:127;
glyphic reference to the sanctuaries as places Orellana
1987:5800). Scholars, though, are more likely to
where intense heat is generated, and smoke
or refer to them as temazeal, from the Nahuatl
steam is produced, and another reference to term
a temazcalli, a "hose like an oven where people
similar location that may be distinct from the
bathe themselves" (Karttunen 1992:222) or
sanctuaries. a
"[l]ittle house like a stove, where they bathe and
This, then, is our puzzle: Why would the
sweat" (Campbell 1985:306). There is great, for-
Classic Maya apply such terminology to build-
malvarietyin modernor recentMaya
ings that are certain never to have been used sweatbaths,
as which may (1) be circular,square,or
ovens or sweatbaths,as these are rectangular
conventionally in plan; (2) supportroofs of wooden boards
identified?The wide doorways of the sanctuaries and
tiles, or plaster or mud domes (often covered
arenot appropriatefor this function, nor do by
the flimsythatch protection);or (3) contain walls
buildingsdisplay any sign of intenseheat or burn- of
stone,mud, wattle, or even living rock, as in
ing.The correctemphasis should be on the a
word cavitycarved into volcanic stone at San
"conventional." Evidently, the terminology Antonio
Palopo(Virkki 1962:75). In Chamula, Chiapas,
employedby the Maya was not a literal nomen-
Mexico,some caves are referredto as symbolic
clature of structuresbut one thatcarriedsymbolic
"steambaths" (Bricker 1973: 114; Taube
connotations,a hypothesis that receives support
fromethnographicand archaeological data. 1988:295-296).
The As Satterthwaite(1952:14) pointed out
ethnography deserves attentionfirst. Just as it is years
ago,the sweatbaths also share many
imprudent to place exaggeratedstress on cultural features.
Mostsweatbaths are low, small, and
continuities from the remote past, so is it an error tightly
sealed, with entrancesthatare quite narrow.A few
to
go to the opposite extreme.Broadly
distributed aresemisubterranean,the better to conserve
traitsin the Maya region are likely to be heat
of (AlcinaFranch et al. 1982:113-114; Virkki
ancientorigin, particularlywhen the possibility of
1962:75).Length averages about 2 m, width is
Spanish colonial influence can be reliably dis- about1.8 m, and height is about 1.3
counted. The sweatbath is one such package of m
(Satterthwaite 1952:15). Many have drains to
ancient features, a considerationof which helps remove water splashed over stones to produce
explain why the Maya used "sweatbath"and steam or over the body to invigorate the skin.
"oven" to describe structures associated with
Various flues, including "exit holes" throughthe
divine
birth. roof,
help regulateheat and steam. Low benches
The Ethnography of the Sweatbath provideseating, and enclosing the buildings
offers
privacy for undressingor consumption of
Today,the sweatbathis not used as widely as it
medicinaland restorative drinks (Cresson
oncewas. It is found exclusively in colder zones, 1938:
101; Giron Mendez 1985:95; Satterthwaite
despitethe abundantevidence of its prior exis-
1952:11-17). Finally, a common pattern,both in
tence
in the ratherhotterlowlands (Alcina Franch
the
Maya region and in Mexico, is for there to
et
al. 1982:102; cf. Blake and Blake
1988:41).6 have
been two distinct parts to the sweatbath:a
For
complex reasons having to do with changing
steamchamber, where the actual bathing takes
attitudestoward costumbre (indigenous tradi- place,
and a fire hearthor furnace, where stones
tions)
and views of sweatbathsas places of possi- are
heated and sprinkled with water to produce
ble
contagion, the medicinal functions of the steam
(Alcina Franchet al. 1982:110). In depic-
sweathouse have become increasingly restricted tions
of late Postclassic and early Colonial temaz-
and
its religious significance attenuated (Katz
cales
in Mexico, these structures may be
1990:2;Virkki 1962:81-84; Wauchope separatedfrom one another, although the more

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 139

(Cosminsky 1977:311; Lewis 1951:363). It is


importantto rememberthat these treatmentsare
F.t oN ".,1.t^ intended not only to heal the woman who has
given birth or is about to give birthbut also as a
means of protectingthe community.Both in the
Maya region and elsewhere in Mesoamerica,
{ pregnantwoman are widely regardedas danger-
ous entities, because their "directgaze can cause
F E babies and young plants to sicken and die" (Paul
1974:294). Similarly, the world poses many
threatsto pregnantwomen and their unbornchil-
dren eclipses especially are thought to cause
Figure 7. A sweatbath from the Codex Mendoza (after deformities (Cosminsky 1977:312). Along with
Berdan and Anawalt 1992:3:50). other ministrations,sweatbathingneutralizesper-
nicious influences by at once protectingand iso-
usual pattern is to have the fire hearth in an lating an individual in grave, bodily
adjoining structure,which conducts the steam to disequilibrium.They are placed apart for their
the bath chamber through a narrow aperture own good and for the good of the community.
(Krickeberg 1935:308-309; Satterthwaite The child's relationshipto the natal sweatbath
1952:Figures 2, 3, and 5). Colonial depictions does not cease with birth.According to Wagley:
also show clear evidence of exit flues that issue The afterbirth should be buried in the floor of the
smoke (Figure 7) (Berdan and Anawalt sweathouse, which is attachedto the family dwelling.
1992:3:50;Piho 1989:214). There is a belief that the afterbirthcontinues to be
part of the individual .... Each individual should
The Maya sweatbath does more than refresh therefore know where his afterbirth was buried.
the body. Ethnographicsources place a consistent Later, one may be sick and the soothsayer's divina-
emphasis on the curative and therapeuticproper- tions may indicate that the treatmentcalls for prayers
ties of the bath, particularlyas these relate to to be offered in front of the sweathouse in which one
notions of "hot"and "cold"and relative states of was "firstbathed"and in which the "afterbirth"lives.
Thus, when a birth occurs away from home on a
corporeal equilibrium (Foster and Anderson trading trip or at a coffee plantation the afterbirth
1978:59-60; Logan 1977; Neuenswander and should be cooked in a clay vessel until it is dry. In this
Souder 1977:98-103; Orellana 1987:35-42). The form, it may be carriedback to the village and buried
bathrestores"heat"and eliminates fevers, which, in the family sweathouse. "The sweathouse will be
along with other illnesses, can be "sweated out" happy again," said Diego Martin, "when the family
returnswith a new child and when there are fires in it
(de Fuentes y Guzman 1972, 3:91; Katz 1990:2;
again." Even after a person is adult, he should return
Orellana 1987:59). Often, sweatbaths are taken to this same sweat bath from time to time to burn a
by several people at a time, who may strike each candle and to pray.According to several of my infor-
other with maize leaves, corn husks, shrubs, or mants, most people forget to observe this ritual until
twigs to open the pores of the skin (Carrasco a crisis forces them to remember"[Wagley 1949:23;
for comparable data see Virkki 1962:79; Alcina
1946:738; Piho 1989:216; Virkki 1962:78).
Franchet al. 1982:126; Gir6n Mendez 1985:66].
The most intensive medicinal use of the bath
occurs before, during,and, especially, afterchild- Informationgatheredby Ichon (1973:151) and
birth, in treatmentspresided over by a midwife others shows that the coupling of the umbilicus
who is usually beyond child-bearing age and afterbirthwith a sense of "home"and "root-
(Cosminsky 1972:307;Wagley 1949:22). In some edness" is widespreadin Mesoamerica.More to
communities,birthstraditionallytake place in the the point, ethnographicdata on sweatbathsshow
sweathouse (Cosminsky 1972:180; Orellana a variety of features, especially an association
1987:58;Virkki1962:79), to be followed by baths with birthing and subsequent obstetrical treat-
at fixed intervals, when the woman's stomach is ments, as well as long-termconnections between
massaged and special foods are preparedfor her childrenand their natal sweatbath.

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
140
LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY [Vol. 7, No. 2, 1996

Figure8. A sweatbathfrom the CodexMagliabechiano(afterNuttall 1903:65).

Sweatbaths in the Colonial Period were the related progenetrix figures, Yoalticitl
andToci, the mother of the gods (Corona 1960;
Many of these features connections with Moedano1977:6-7; Miller and Taube 1993:160).
birthing,midwifery,and healing-can be attested In addition, the Magliabechiano describes the
indocumentaryand archaeologicalsources of the elaboraterituals necessary for entering the bath,
earlyColonial period (Lee 1979; Lee and Bryant includingthe burningof incense and the daubing
1988:12,Figure 7). The de Coto dictionary (ca. ofblack paint over the body in honor of the god
1650)of CakchiquelMaya, for example, refers to Tezcatlipoca(Nuttall 1903:65). Analogous ritu-
thesweatbathas a place where the sick are bathed als,including the venerationof the "spiritof the
byputting them in "ovens or baths,"noting also steambath" usually addressed as "mother"or
thecustom of regular sweatbathingby pregnant "grandmother" and possessing both positive and
women (de Coto 1983:61; see also Gage negativequalities are still performed through-
1958:221).Duran, Sahagun,Clavigero, and other outcentralMesoamerica(Hollenbach 1977; Katz
authorsall refer to the relevance of such baths to 1990:8;Moedano 1977:12-15).
birthing (Moedano 1977:11). The Codex The sweatbathwas often the setting of prac-
Magliabechianofurnishes an image of sweat ticesthathorrifiedor disgustedthe Spaniards.For
chamber with flue holes, water channel, and fire- instance,the Magliabechianoalso shows a sacri-
wood, apparently being tended by an elderly ficeto Tezcatlipocain which a body was thrown
woman,doubtless a curer or midwife (Figure 8). intoa building, to be cooked and steamed on
Abovethe doorway is the head of Tlazolteotl, the charcoal or heated rocks; whetherthis was a real
patronessof recently delivered women and of sweatbathor a simulation of one scarcely mat-
purificationand curing. Her mouth is smeared teredto the sacrificial victim. Regrettably,we
withthe filth of sins consumedby her duringcon- understand little of the ritualcontext of this cere-
fessions;unspun cotton-a key part of her cos- mony.A more widespread offense to the
tume-garlandsher head. According to Sahagun, Spaniardswas mixed bathing. Writing of late
thegoddesses with dominion over the sweatbaths ColonialGuatemala,Cortez y Larrazmentions a

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 141

sweatbath "in which promiscuously and at all


hours entermen, women, boys, and girls" (Cortez
y Larraz1958:158). Similarexpressions of disap-
proval appear in the writings of Diego Duran,
who, in describingthe Aztec, notes that "mingled
and naked as they are, therecannotfail to be great
affronts and offense to our lord" (Duran
1971:271-272; see Nuttall 1903:65 for similar
remarks).He also comments that a woman would
accompanya man so as to fan him, and that "with
that fanning they blew away illness, strengthened
the flesh, and gave healthand strengthto the sick"
(Duran 1971:270-271; Piho 1989:216). Other
references to sexual misbehavior in sweatbaths A
occur among the Mixtec (Parsons 1936:Note 40),
and the Mam of Guatemala,where until recently
sweatbathsserved as discrete locations for illicit
sex (Wagley 1949:35). This association is still to
be found in Santiago Atitlan, where the Tzutuhil
Maximonfigure is thought to live in an under-
ground sweatbath with a harem of highly
amorous women (Tarnand Prechtel 1981; Taube
1988: 288). We can summarize,then, by saying
that curing for the ill and pregnant, as well as
other activities, possibly of a sexual nature,were
integralto the early Colonial use of the sweatbath.
Hints of Precolumbianbeliefs include linkages to
B
particulargods and goddesses but especially to a
progenetrix associated with purification, curing,
and birth. Figure 9. Precolumbiansweatbathsfrom Mexico. (A)
Mixtec sweatbath (after Nuttall 1975:Plate 81). (B)
Sweatbath from the Codex Borgia (after Seler
The Precolumbian Sweatbath 1963:3:13).
We now come full circle, and closer to Palenque,
by returningto the Precolumbianperiod. This is conical structure, probably a domed oven.
not an appropriateplace to review all of the Variousevents take place within such structures,
archaeological and artistic evidence from this including the assassinationof the half-brotherof
time, a task handledcapablyby Satterthwaiteand 88 Deer (Figure9A; Jansen 1982:389-390). The
by Alcina Franch and his colleagues (Alcina Codex Borgia (Figure 9B) shows one certain
Franchet al. 1982; Satterthwaite1952; Taladoire sweatbath(theremay be some others),containing
1981). But we can review a few pieces of infor- a recliningfigure, and a streamof waterflows out
mation, beginning with actual depictions of the side (Seler 1963:3, 12-13).
Prehispanic sweatbaths. Of these, some of the Although rare, other imagery reveals some of
clearest examples appear in the Mixtec codices the more durableaspects of sweatbathsymbolism
(Figure 9A), in a form suggesting the physical in Mesoamerica (AtTeola 1936). For example,
separation of furnace and sweat chamber (e.g., Furst has emphasized the relationship between
Caso 1960:11, 13; Nuttall 1975:16, 81). The sweatbathsand the aged progenetrix 91 Eagle in
sweatbathhas a doorway facing the viewer, and the obverse of the Vienna Codex, a preconquest
the heaped and smoking rocks occur in a separate screenfold manuscript (Furst 1978:159, 172,

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
142 LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY lVol. 7, No. 2, 1996

Figure 10. Map showing location of well-attested Precolumbian sweatbaths in the Maya region.

Figure 87). K. A. Taube(personalcommunication connected with sweatbathing in the Codex


1993) has compiled persuasive evidence that Magliabechiano;see above) and at the same time
newborns, depicted consistently on their backs, vlewlng ms maKeupm a mlrror. lne lntenaea
* * 1 - 1 * * 11 * s s

sometimes wrappedin swaddling clothes or with location is doubtless a supematural sweatbath,


umbilici intact, occur frequentlyin sweatbaths,as since two of the gods have stripped,and one is
in the South Ballcourt at E1Tajin.There are also being fanned by a woman, much like the custom
a very few images of sweatbathsof Late Classic described by Duran (1971). Moreover, the god
date. One comes from a well-known cylindrical Chac is seated within what is clearly a hill, a set
vessel showing a set of four God Ns with their of stacked"hill signs of the sort much like those
consorts (Coe 1978:Plate 11). It takes little imag- on the sanctuary in the Temple of the Sun
ination to see in this iconography an episode of (Robertson l991:Figure 91). I have alluded
debaucheryand lascivious pleasure.Females fon- before to the linkage of caves and sweatbaths,a
dle males, enema pots abound, there is musical logical connection given the subterraneanlayout
accompaniment,and, but for thin loincloths, two of many of them, and to the association of licen-
of the God Ns are naked.A god to the right seems tious activity with sweatbaths.
to be daubinghimself with black paint (a pigment Such scenes are extremely rare. The actual

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 143

Table 1. Metric Dimensions of Steam and Firebox ChamberInteriorsin EasternMesoamerica.

Steam Chamber Firebox Chamber


Classic period
Ceren, Str.9a 2.60 x 2.60 x .80 in diam.
PiedrasNegras, Str. N-1 4.80 x 3.25 x 2.00 1.15 x .85 x >.86
PiedrasNegras, Str. S-19b x2.8 x2.5 x x.90

PiedrasNegras, Str.J-17 4.00 x 2.90 x 2.3 x x 1. 10

PiedrasNegras, Str. 0-4 4.50 x 2.80 x 2.6 x x 1.00

PiedrasNegras, Str. S-2 4.50 x 3.00 x 2.5 x x 1.10

PiedrasNegras, Str. S4h 4.50 x 3.20 x 2.6 x x 1.10

PiedrasNegras, Str. R-13 4.60 x 2.50 x 2.70 x x.90

PiedrasNegras, Str. P-7 3.30 x 2.20 x 2.70 .95 x .35 x >.70


SQuirigua,Str. 2c .75 ft x 2.30 x .75
SQuirigua,Str. 3d .SSx3.04.x 1.00
San AntonioC 3.00 x 10.00 x 1.60
Tikal, near Str. 5E-23.28r 2.00 x 2.00 x
TerminalClassic/EarlyPostclassic periods
Agua Tibiag 2.25 x 4.5 x
Chichen Itza, Str. 3ClSh 5.00 x 2.75 x >2.00 l.SOx l.SOx>l.OO

Chichen Itza, Str. 3E3h 5.50 x 3.00 x 1.97 .44 x .88 x .55
E1Paraiso(circular) 5.50 in diam. x >2.00 .80 in diam. x ca. .60

Late Postclassic period


Los Cimientos-Chustumr 1.40 x 6.30 x ca. 1.00 x 1.00 x

Nte: The first figure representsmetic width, the second represents"depth"or length to the back of chamberfrom the entrance;
the thirdrecordsapproximatedistancefrom the floor to the highest point in chamber.Many measurementsfrom PiedrasNegras
are rough approximations.
a McKee (l990:Figure 2).
b Satterthwaite(1952:79, Figures 31-36).
c Morley (1935:135-136, Figure 30).
d Morley ( 1935:141-142, Figure 38a; Satterthwaite1952:25), providesdimensionsfor the chamberin Str.3 but disputesMorley's
. . .
ldentlficatlon.
cAgrinier(1966:29-30).
r Ichon (1977:203-205, Figure 3).

gAlcina Franchet al. ( 1982:Figures1-3).


h Ruppert(1935:Figure349, 1952:56, 82-83, Figures 50-51).

i Kidderand Shook (l959:Figure 3).

archaeologicalevidence of Precolumbiansweat- black, thus resembling a kun; Ruppert


baths is far stronger(Agrinier 1966). Many may 1935:Figure349, 1952:56, 82-83, Figures 50 and
have been provisional, perishable affairs of the 51), Agua Tibia (Alcina Franchet al. 1982), and
sort found in Central Mexico (Katz 1990; John Los Cimientos-Chustum(Ichon 1977). Of these,
Monaghan,personalcommunication1993). More the sweatbathfrom Ceren, dating to about A.D.
formal sweatbathswith solid masonry construc- 600, is exceptionalfor the preservationof its plas-
tion have been found at several sites in the Maya ter dome (about2 meters high) and thatchedroof
region (Figure 10): a Formative example at screen. Regardless of their date, virtually all
Dzibilchaltun (Andrews and Andrews 1980:30), sweatbathsand fire boxes have roughly the same
and other,alleged bathsat Tikal (Ichon 1977:201) dimensions (Table 1). Size varied slightly, pre-
and Uaxactun (Smith 1950: 20, 30), as well as sumablyaccordingto the numberof bathersto be
secure examples from Ceren (McKee 1990; accommodated,the ability of the masonryto con-
Sheets 1992), Piedras Negras (Satterthwaite serve heat, and probablythe intensityof the fire.
1952), El Paraiso (Kidder and Shook 1959), Of all Late Classic sweatbathsthe best docu-
ChichenItza (note that Structure3E3 was painted mented by far are those excavated by Cresson,

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
144 LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY [Vol. 7, No. 2, 1996

Figure 11. View of sweatbath, Piedras Negras Structure P 7 1st-A (after Satterthwaite 1952:Figure 47).

Mason, and Satterthwaiteat the Classic Maya city excavationscorrespondat all to the "enemaollas"
of Piedras Negras (Figure 11) (Mason 1935; in Classic iconography,includingthe "sweatbath"
Satterthwaite 1936:62-63). Most appear to be vase (Coe and Furst 1977; de Smet 1985).
Late Classic in date (Satterthwaite 1936:73), Palenque itself also has Late Classic sweat-
althoughSatterthwaite(1952:56) detected several baths. During his excavations of the Palace,
phases of constructionand a high degree of vari- Alberto Ruz discovered features that may well
ability that might refleet a "considerable"time have been sweatbaths "narrowsectioned rooms
range. Wagley's (1949) informationmay provide . . . along the southernside of the Tower Court"
an explanationfor both the monumentalconstruc- (Robertson 1985:79-80), of which one had two
tion and relatively large numberof sweatbathsat holes for the passage of steam from a subter-
the site. The Mam of Santiago Chimaltenango ranean firebox to the sweat chamber (Ruz
possess natal sweatbaths,which are the locations 1952:56, Figure 3, Plate 13). Unfortunately,pre-
of theirfirst bathand "warming"of theirblood, as sent documentationof these features is limited.
well as the places where the afterbirth was More recently, archaeologists with the Mexican
interred.Conceivably, this accounts for the pat- governmenthave excavated a sweatbathwell to
tern at Late Classic Piedras Negras. The sweat- the north of the Cross Group, but details are not
bathsmay correspondto each of the laterrulersof yet forthcoming.
the site or possibly to the immediatemembersof
their family, who would returnperiodicallyto the The Sanctuaries as Symbolic Sweatbaths
sweatbathsfor rites of purificationat moments of We can now returnto the problem posed at the
life crisis-certainly the number of such baths beginning of this paper: Why did the ancient
roughlymatchesthe numberof Late Classic rulers Maya of Palenque attachthe terms "steambath"
at the site. Moreover,the outer rooms defined by or "oven"to the sanctuariesof the Cross Group?
the enclosing structuremay have been used for I propose that the sanctuary"sweatbaths"cannot
dressing or dining and other festivities, perhaps be understoodliterally as such. Rather,the pibna
like those depicted on the "sweatbath"vase (Coe in the Cross Group were symbolic versions of
1978:Plate 11). It would be useful to determine buildingscommon in Mesoamerica,past and pre-
whether the vessels recovered in Satterthwaite's sent.A comparisonwith known sweatbathsdating

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 145

from the Preclassicto the Late Postclassic periods processions meld syncretistically with Catholic
(Table 1) shows a number of similarities; for practices (e.g., Hill 1992:92-93). This custom
example, the dimensions of the sanctuariesfall perhaps enjoyed considerable time depth, since
within the range of variationfor sweat chambers. the effigies mentioned in the Temple of the
Yet the differencesare far greaterand more strik- Inscriptionsmay have been occasionally taken to
ing. The Cross Grouppibna are a little smaller the Cross Group for ritual purification. Third,
thanmost and with doorwaysabouttwice as wide similar effigies have been recovered from royal
and high as the norm (cf. Satterthwaite1952:15), burials at Tikal, Guatemala(e.g., Coe 1967:57).
suggesting that the conservationof heat was not More broadly,the "heat"being generatedin the
an importantconsideration.Moreover,there is a Palenque"sweatbaths"was of an entirely figura-
complete absence of evidence for fire or fire- tive sort.7Nonetheless, the complex iconography
boxes, or for the conduct of waterfor bathingand of the Cross Groupis by no meansfully explained
the generationof steam. These features stand in by this interpretation,although it does provide a
utter contrast to all other ethnographic and useful frameworkfor analysis.
archaeologicalexamples. Nor, contrary to statements by Robertson
In reviewing the events mentioned before, (1991:10), are such structuresunique. Andrews
there is still the enigma of the 2 Cib 14 Mol date, (1989:Figures121, 1141, 1145)documents"sanc-
which precedes the "forming"of the sanctuaries tuary"layouts in temples, some in triadicpattern,
by a period of over a year.There are two possible at the Tabasquenosite of Comalcalco. Of later
explanations:that this was an earlier sweatbath date thanthe examples from Palenque,these tem-
being "heated,"or that this event referredto the ples most likely derive from the innovations in
initial stoking of the oven that generated the the Cross Group; it is probably no coincidence
"heat." The astronomical symbolism of this that an apparentPalenqueEmblem Glyph was in
action is as yet unclear,althoughit may relate to local use at Comalcalco (Andrews 1989:Figure
the extraordinarystarloreuncovered recently by 115a). Similarly,a reference to the building of a
Freidel and Schele (Freidel et al. 1993:59-122). pibna, "sweatbath," occurs on Tortuguero
Finally, the symbolic sweatbathsdo not, strictly Monument6, a T-shapedslab just under 2 m in
speaking, belong to the ruler Kan Balam but to height (Riese 1980). Not surprisingly,the local
each of his respective "gods." The discussion dynasty also employed the Palenque Emblem
above of paralleltexts in the Temple of the Cross Glyph. Sites with close dynasticties (as cadet lin-
makes this particularlyclear. eages?) to Palenquemay have been more inclined
Wagley's (1949) ethnographicdatahave some- to use these architecturalforms and the glyphic
thing to tell us here. The sanctuarieswould appear expressions for them.
to represent the "natal" sweatbaths of the Along with Lothrop (cited in Satterthwaite
PalenqueTriad,to which they repairfor moments 1952:5, 24-25), although for very different rea-
of purification.The continual emphasis on refer- sons, Taube and I also identify some of the
ences to supernaturalbirth lend weight to this Postclassic shrineson the east coast of Yucatanas
suggestion. The role of Kan Balam was to refur- symbolic sweatbaths. The best example is the
bish and maintainthe sweatbaths,which, on occa- temple of San Miguel on Cozumel Island,a place
sion, presumably contained portable images of known to be closely linked to Ix Chel, the aged
the gods. The existence of such images, to be goddess of birth,creation,anddestruction(Figure
moved from one location to another,is more than 12; Roys et al. 1940:5; Freidel and Sabloff
a speculative idea. In the first place, the dressing 1984:45). The temple has an internal chamber
or adornmentof such effigies is mentionedin the measuring 1.5 x 2.14 x 1.83 m relatively close
immense tablets of the Templeof the Inscriptions to the measurementsof the Palenque sanctuar-
at Palenque (Lounsbury1991:81S817). Second, ies and, even more important, contains the
the transportationin ritual circuits of effigies- carved image on a frontal column of an aged
usually of "saints" is well-attestedin traditional woman in the birthingposition, her belly corru-
Maya communities, although, of course, such gated with the stretchmarksof manypregnancies,

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
.

LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY
146 lVol. 7, No. 2, 1996

stairways clearly not the best location for


ballplay, since the ball would carom uncontrol-
lably off the jagged angles of steps. lwhe
conflated
imagery vibrates with related or consecutive
events, of ballgames, human sacrifice, or the rit-
ual display of captives, regardless of
whether
ballplayingactuallytook place on stairways.
Other evidence underlines the complexity of
meaningin Maya architecture.Metaphorsabound
in Classic buildings. The Maya observed
concep-
tual similarities between stairways and the
suc-
cession of kings (Houston 1994) and linked

A
b .^ structuresto hills and doorwaysin stone buildings
to the entrances of caves (Schele and

havebeen noted by Africanists,particularly


Freidel
1990:7() 73)*Some of these generalpatternsalso
Blier,
whoreportson vernaculararchitectureamong
the
Batammaliba in Benin and Togo (Blier
',
1987:3S37). Blier shows that buildings embody
symbolswith "the ability . . . to carry multiple
, l, ,
meaningssimultaneously"(Blier 1987: 218), and
W
,

,/
* * .
I that,throughmetaphor,Batammalibaarchitecture
.

notonly exists in the present,to be used and


O 5m acti-
I . vatedby ritual, but recalls acts of creation
. . . I
and
"thehighly abstract and remote realm of
B the
larger cosmos" (Blier 1987:57, 175). Buildings
Figure12. Oblique view and plan of a
possible symbolic
sweatbathat San Miguel, Cozumel, Yucatan
may evoke like things and convey differentlevels
(after ofmeaning;the configurationof the human
Lothrop1924:Figure 166).
body
canform a templatefor understandingthe house,
levelsof a building may correspondto levels of
herhands grasping breasts, perhaps in allusion
to the
cosmos, the act of constructionreplicatespri-
theonset of lactation (Lothrop
1924:Figures 165 mordial creation. The building itself becomes a
and166; this is the same figure Holmes
described means of establishingand reinforcingorder,espe-
as"an ape-visaged figure" [1895:65]).
Similar cially
when its shape and function couple events
statues
"of tall women" may have been seen at Isla
andbeings of the distantpast with actions carried
Mujeres by Bernal Diaz del Castillo (see Freidel
outin the present. Some of these
andSabloff 1984:45). Again, the aim was not to multiple
metaphors may have been known to all; elite
build
a literal sweatbath, as Lothrop supposed,
but architecturesimply preserved evidence of them
todeviseone that operated symbolically.
better
than the perishable constructionsof non-
elite
membersof society. But perhapsthe esoter-
Discussion
ica
of architecturalmetaphor resulted equally
The
Cross Group buildings at Palenque sweat-
froma need to maintain a sense of mystery or
baths
that function symbolically-raise
intriguing epistemologicalprivilege, in which, as Griaule
questions about Maya architecture. Elsewhere,
sawfor the Dogon in Mali, deeper knowledge
Millerand I have described "conflationary" pat-
remained the preserve of a "tight-knitgroup of
terns
in depictions of Maya buildings (Miller
and eldersand priests" (Blier 1987:219; Griaule
Houston 1987). Sculptors combined or "con-
1965),
ratherlike the "languageof zuyua"distin-
flated"
ballgame imagery with depictions of stair-
guishingnoble from non-noble in Late
ways;on occasion, the imagery itself occurs
on Postclassic
Yucatan(Roys 1967).8

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 147

My contention is that the Cross Group sweat- reviewers. These colleagues have helped me sharpen the
paper, although perhaps not always to their satisfaction;this
baths need to be understoodwithin a framework
remains very much an essay structuredin my own idiosyn-
of metaphor and ritual praxis. They are like cratic way. Karl Taube was especially helpful with ideas and
sweatbathsbut do not generate perceptible heat; sources and with providing stimulating insights into the
they exist in relationto the distantpast, when the iconographyof birthin Mesoamerica;as always, David Stuart
gods were born near or in their natal sweatbaths, assistedby sharinghis unmatchedknowledgeof Mayanscript.
Patient audiences at the University of Arizona and Brigham
yet were patentlyconstructedby the Late Classic
Young University listened to a preliminaryversion of this
Maya. ln some respects,to describethem as sym- paper, and their comments contributed to its revision.
bolic or metaphoric sweatbaths (being at once Financialsupportand otherassistancecame from the Peabody
like, and unlike, the real structures) skirts the Museum and Departmentof Anthropology,Yale University,
essential identity between things in a metaphoric and from a grant bestowed on David Stuart and me by the
relationship.Ritual ensures that actual and sym- National Endowment for the Humanities, Collaborative
ResearchProgram;the views presentedhere do not necessar-
bolic sweatbaths discharge similar functions, ily represent the opinions of this munificent organization.
although with very different participants both Linda Schele invited me to present the first formulationof
structures may purify and restore equilibrium. these ideas at a symposium in honor of Merle Greene
Likewise, buildings in Classic Maya cities may Robertsonand Floyd Lounsbury.To Floyd I owe a great deal
both imitate mythological structures,such as a for both his example and many kindnesses. This paper (and
two apples!) goes to him and to my other teacher in Mayan
primeval"houseof water,"and, at the same time, script,Michael D. Coe.
be those structures,a nonpareil, mythic original
being duplicated in many separate locations References Cited
(Schele 1994). In this, Maya buildings resemble Agrinier,P.
the Aztec Templo Mayor,at once a pyramidcon- 1966 La casa de banos de vapor de San Antonio. Boletfn
del InstitutoNacional de Antropologia 25:29-32.
taining many different stages of construction, Alcina Franch,J., A. Ciudad Ruiz, and J. Iglesias Ponce de
commissioned by distinct Aztec rulers, and at Leon
least two mythological locations (Matos 1982 El "temazcal"en Mesoamerica:evolucion, forma y
funcion. Revista Espafiola de AntropologfaAmericana
Moctezuma 1987:199). 10:93-132.
But such issues will not be resolved here.What Alvarez, C.
we can address is a point raised a century and a 1984 Diccionario etnolinguistico del idioma maya
yucateco colonial. Universidad Nacional Autonoma de
half ago by John Lloyd Stephens: "Thereis rea- Mexico, Mexico, D.F.
son to believe . . . thatthe enclosed innerchamber Andrews,G. F.
was an adoratorio,or oratory,or altar.What the 1989 Comalcalco, Tabasco, Mexico: Maya Art and
Architecture.Labyrinthos,Culver City, California.
rites and ceremonies of worship may have been, Andrews, E. W., IV, and E. W. Andrews,V
no one can undertaketo say" (Stephens 1841:2, 1980 Excavations at Dzibilchaltun, Yucatan, Mexico.
347). Here we have undertakenStephen'scharge, Publication 48. Middle American Research Institute,
Tulane University, New Orleans.
and arguedthatthe sanctuariesin the Cross Group Arreola,J. M.
exist in both tangible and symbolic dimensions, 1936 El temazcal o bano mexicano de vapor. Ethnos
as places linked to divine birth and purification 1:28-33.
ArzapaloMarin,R. (translator)
within the architecturalsetting of a sweatbath. 1987 El ritual de los Bacabes. Fuentes parael Estudio de
That such subtleties are now within reach points la Cultura Maya 5. Instituto de Investigaciones
to the contributionMaya epigraphycan make to Filologic as, Centro de Estudios Maya, Universidad
Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, Mexico, D.F.
archaeology and to the necessity of recognizing BarreraVasquez,A. (editor)
the richness of semantic play in Classic Maya 1980 Diccionario Maya Cordemex, Maya-Espafiol,
architecture. Espafiol-Maya.Ediciones Cordemex, Merida.
Beltrande Santa Rosa Maria,P.
1859 Grama'ticay semidiccionario de la lengua maya:
Acknowledgments.This paper is for my teachers,Michael D.
arte del idioma maya reducido a sucintas reglas y
Coe and Floyd G. Lounsbury.I acknowledge with gratitude semilexicon yucateca. Espinosa, Merida.
the advice of John Clark, Michael Coe, Beth Conklin, Paula Berdan,F. F., and P. R. Anawalt
Covington, Pat Culbert, Don Forsyth, John Hawkins, Kevin 1992 The Codex Mendoza. S vols. University of
Johnston, Mark King, Mary Miller, John Monaghan, John California Press, Berkeley.
Pohl, Linda Schele, Payson Sheets, and three anonymous Berlin, H.

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
148
LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY [Vol. 7, No. 2, 1996

1963 The Palenque Triad. Journal de la Socie'te'des Maria. Biblioteca de Autores Espanoles. Ediciones
Ame'ricanistes52:91-99. Atlas, Madrid.
Blake, S., and M. Blake de Smet, P. A. G. M.
1988 A Regional Study of Household Features in 1985 Ritual Enemas and SnuJ5fsin the Americas.
Modern Maya Communities. In Ethnoarchaeology America Studies 33. Centre for Latin American
Among the Highland Maya of Chiapas Mexico, edited Research and Documentation,Dordrecht,Holland.
by T. A. Lee, Jr., and B. Hayden, pp. 39v3. PapersNo. Duran,D.
56. New World Archaeological Foundation, Brigham 1971 Book of the Gods and Rites and the Ancient
Young University, Provo, Utah. Calendar. Translatedby F. Horcasitas and D. Heyden.
Blier, S. P. University of OklahomaPress, Norman.
1987 The Anatomy of Architecture: Ontology and Edmonson,M. S.
Metaphor in Batammaliba Architectural Expression. 1965 Quiche'-English Dictionary. Publication 30.
CambridgeUniversity Press, Cambridge. Middle American Research Institute,Tulane University,
Bricker,V. R. New Orleans.
1973 Ritual Humor in Highland Chiapas. University of Foster,G. M., and B. G. Anderson
Texas Press, Austin. 1978 Medical Anthropology.John Wiley and Sons, New
Campbell,R. J. York.
1985 A Morphological Dictionary of Classic Nahuatl: A Freidel, D. A., and J. A. Sabloff
Morpheme Index to the Vocabulario en lengua mexi- 1984 Cozumel: Late Maya Settlement Patterns.
cana y castellana of Fray Alonso de Molina. Hispanic Academic Press, New York.
Seminary of Medieval Studies, Madison, Wisconsin. Freidel,D., L. Schele, and J. Parker
Carrasco,P. 1993 Maya Cosmos: Three Thousand Years on the
1946 El temazcal. In Me'xicoprehispa'nico,edited by J. Shaman'sPath. William Morrow,New York.
A. Viro, pp. 737-741. Furst,J. L.
Caso, A. 1978 Codex VindobonensisMexicanus 1:A Commentary.
1960 Interpretation of the Codex Bodley 2858. Publication4. Institutefor MesoamericanStudies, State
Translated by R. Morales, revised by J. Paddock. University of New York,Albany.
Sociedad Mexicana de Antropologia, Mexico, D.F. Gage,T.
Coe, M. D. 1958 In ThomasGage's Travelsin the New World,edited
1978 Lords of the Underworld:Masterpieces of Classic by J. E. S. Thompson. University of Oklahoma Press,
Maya Ceramics. Princeton University Art Museum, Norman.
Princeton, New Jersey. GironMendez, I. de J.
Coe, M. D., and P. T. Furst 1985 El temazeal: un estudio arqueologico y su trascen-
1977 Ritual Enemas. Natural History 86(3):88-91. dencia contemporanea. Licenciaturathesis, Escuela de
Coe, W. R. Historia, Universidad de San Carlos de Guatemala,
1967 Tikal: A Handbook of the Ancient Maya Ruins. GuatemalaCity.
University of Pennsylvania Museum, Philadelphia. Griaule,M.
Corona,H. 1965 Conversations with Ogotemmelli:An Introduction
1960 Deidades de la medicina y de los banos. Boletin del to Dogon Religious Ideas. Oxford University Press,
Centro de Investigaciones Antropolo'gicasde Me'xico Oxford.
8.6-8. Hill,R. M. II
Cortezy Larraz,P. 1992 Colonial Cakshiquels: Highland Maya Adaptation
1958 Descripcion geografico-moral de la Diocesis de to Spanish Rule, 1600-1700. Harcourt Brace
Goathemala,tomo II. Sociedad de Geografiae Historia, Jovanovich, Fort Worth,Texas.
GuatemalaCity. Hollenbach,E.
Cosminsky,S. 1977 El origen del sol y de la luna: cuatro versiones en
1972 Decision Making and Medical Care in a el trique de Copala. Tlalocan 7:123-170.
Cuatemalan Indian Community. Ph.D. dissertation, Holmes,W. H.
Brandeis University, Waltham, MA. University 1895 Archaeological Studies Among the Ancient Cities
Microfilms, Ann Arbor. of Mexico, pt. 1. Anthropological Series 1. Field
1977 El papel de la comadrona en Mesoamerica. Museum of NaturalHistory, Chicago.
Ame'ricaIndigena 37(2):305-335. Houston, S. D.
Cresson,F. M. 1994 Classic Maya Depictions of the Built Environment.
1938 Maya and Mexican Sweat Houses. American Paper presented at the October 9, 1994, Pre-Columbian
Anthropologist40:88-104. Symposium "Function and Meaning in Classic Maya
deCoto, T. Architecture,"DumbartonOaks, Washington,D.C.
1983 Thesaurus verborum.In Vocabulariode la lengua Houston, S. D., and D. S. Stuart
Cakshiquel v[el] Cuatemalteca, nuevamente hecho y 1989 The Way Glyph: Evidence for '4Co-essences"
recopilado con summo estudio, travajo y erudicion, Among the Classic Maya. Research Reports on Ancient
edited by R. Acuna. UniversidadNacional Autonoma de Maya Writing 30. Center for Maya Research,
Mexico, Mexico, D.F. Washington,D.C.
deFuentes y Guzman,F. A. Ichon, A.
1972 In Obras historicas de don Francisco Antonio de 1973 La religion de los Totonacasde la Sierra, Me'xico.
Fuentes y Cuzma'n:Recordacion Florida (1690-1699), Instituto Nacional Indigenista, Mexico, D.F.
edicion y estudio preliminar de C. Saenz de Santa 1977 A Late Postclassic Sweathouse in the Highlands of

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houstonl SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA 149

Guatemala.AmericanAntiquity42:203-209. Mythological Portion of the Hieroglyphic Text of the


Jansen,M. E. R. G. Temple of the Cross at Palenque. In Third Palenque
1982 Huisti Tacu:estudio interpretativode un libro mix- Round Table, 1978, pt. 2, edited by M. G. Robertson,
teco antiguo, Codex Vindobonensis Mexicanus 1. pp. 99-115. University of Texas Press, Austin.
Incidentele Publicaties 24. Centro de Estudios y 1989 A Palenque King and the Planet Jupiter.In World
Documentacion Latinoamericanos,Amsterdam. Archaeastronomy,edited by A. F. Aveni, pp. 246-259.
Karttunen,F. CambridgeUniversity Press, Cambridge.
1992 An Analytical Dictionary of Nahuatl. University of 1991 Distinguished Lecture: Recent Work in the
OklahomaPress, Norman. Deciphermentof Palenque's Hieroglyphic Inscriptions.
Katz, E. AmericanAnthropologist93:809-825.
1990 El temazcal: entre religion y medicina. Paper pre- Mason, J. A.
sented at the III Coloquio de Historia de las Religiones 1935 Mexican and Mayan Sweat-Baths. Museum
en Mesoamerica y Areas Afines, November 28-30, Bulletin 6(2):65, 67-69.
Instituto de Inve stigac iones Antropologicas , Matos Moctezuma,E.
Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico, Mexico, 1987 Symbolism of the Templo Mayor. In The Aztec
D.F. TemploMayor: A Symposiumat Dumbarton Oaks, 8th
Kelley, D. and 9th October 1983, edited by E. H. Boone, pp.
1965 The Birth of the Gods at Palenque. Estudios de 185-209. DumbartonOaks, Washington,D.C.
CulturaMaya 1:183-198. McKee, B. R.
Kidder,A., and E. Shook 1990 Excavationsat Structure9. In 1990 Investigationsat
1959 A Unique Ancient Maya Sweathouse, Guatemala. the Cere'nSite, El Salvador:A PreliminaryReport,edited
In AmerikanistischeMiszellen: Festband Franz Termer by P. D. Sheets and B. R. McKee, pp. 90-107.
in Freundschaftund Verehrunggewidmet von Freunden, Department of AnFropology,Universityof Colorado,Boulder.
Kollegen un Schulern zur Vollendung des 65. Miller, M. E., and S. D. Houston
Lebensjahres, pp. 70-74. Mitteilungen aus dem 1987 The Classic Maya Ballgame and its Architectural
Museum fur Volkerkunde in Hamburg No. 25. Setting: A Study of Relations Between Text and Image.
Kommissionsverlag Ludwig Appel, Hamburg. RES 14:46-65.
Krickeberg,W. Miller, M., and K. Taube
1935 Beitrage zur Frage der alten kulturgeschichtlichen 1993 The Gods and Symbols of Ancient Mexico and the
Beziehungen zwischen Nord- und SUdamerika. Maya: An Illustrated Dictionary of Mesoamerican
Zeitschriftfur Ethnologie 46:287-373. Religion. Thames and Hudson, London.
Lee, T. A., Jr. MoedanoN., G.
1979 Coapa, Chiapas:A Sixteenth-CenturyCoxoh Maya 1977 El temazcal y su deidad protectoraen la tradicion
Village on the Camino Real. In Maya Archaeology and oral. Boletin del Departmento de Investigacion de las
Ethnohistory,edited by N. Hammondand G. Willey, pp. TradicionesPopulares 4:5-32.
298-222. University of Texas Press, Austin. Morley, S. G.
Lee, T. A., Jr., and D. D. Bryant 1935 Guide to the Ruins of Quirigua. Publication
1988 The Colonial Coxoh Maya. In Ethnoarchaeology Supplement 16. Carnegie Institution,Washington,D.C.
Among the Highland Maya of Chiapas, Mexico, edited Neuenswander,H. L., and S. D. Souder
by T. A. Lee, Jr., and B. Hayden, pp. 5-20. Papers No. 1977 El sindrome caliente-frio, humedo-seco entre los
56. New World Archaeological Foundation, Brigham Quiches de Joyabaj: dos modelos cognitivos. In
Young University, Provo, Utah. Estudios cognitivos del sur de Me'soamerica,edited by
Lewis, O. H. L. Neuenswander and D. E. Arnold, pp. 9>121.
1951 Life in a Mexican Village: Tepoztlan Restudied. Publication 3 of Museo de Antropologia. Instituto
University of Illinois Press, Urbana. Linguistico de Verano,Dallas.
Logan, M. H. Nuttall, Z. (editor)
1977 AnthropologicalResearch on the Hot-Cold Theory 1903 The Book of the Life of the Ancient Mexicans,
of Disease: Some Methodological Suggestions. Medical Containing An Account of Their Rites and
Anthropology 1(4):87-112. Superstitions,pt. I. University of California, Berkeley.
Lopez Austin, A. 1975 The Codex Nuttall: A Picture Manuscript from
1988 The Human Body and Ideology: Concepts of the Ancient Mexico, introduction by A. G. Miller. Dover
Ancient Nahuas. 2 vols. Translatedby T. and B. Ortiz de Publications, New York.
Montellano. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City. Orellana,S. L.
Lothrop,S. K. 1987 Indian Medicine in Highland Guatemala: The Pre-
1924 Tulum:An Archaeological Study of the East Coast Hispanic and Colonial Periods. University of New
of Yucatan. Publication 335. Carnegie Institution, Mexico Press, Albuquerque.
Washington,D.C. Parsons,E. C.
Lounsbury,F. G. 1936 Mitla: Town of the Souls, and Other Zapoteco-
1976 A Rationale for the Initial Date of the Temple of Speaking Pueblos of Oaxaca, Mexico. University of
the Cross at Palenque. In The Art, Iconography, and Chicago Press, Chicago.
Dynastic History of Palenque, pt. III. Proceedingsof the Paul, L.
Segunda Mesa Redonda de Palenque, edited by M. G. 1974 The Mastery of Work and the Mystery of Sex in a
Robertson, pp. 211-234. Robert Louis Stevenson Guatemalan Village. In Woman,Culture, and Society,
School, Pebble Beach, Callifornia. edited by M. Z. Rosaldo and L. Lamphere,pp. 281-299.
1980 Some Problems in the Interpretation of the StanfordUniversity Press, Stanford,California.

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
LATINAMERICANANTIQUITY [Vol. 7, No. 2, 1996
150

Piho, V. Austin, transcribed and edited by P. Wanyerka.


1989 E1uso del temazcal en la Altiplanicie Mexicana. In Cleveland State University, Cleveland.
Homenaje a Roman Pina Cha'n, coordinated by R. Seler, E.
Garcia Moll and A. Garcia Cook, pp. 213-228. 1963 Codices Borgia. 3 vols. Fondo de Cultura
Coleccion Cientifica 187. Instituto Nacional de Economica, Mexico, D.F.
Antropologia e Historia, Mexico, D.F. Sheets, P.
Riese, B. 1992 The Ceren Site: A Prehistoric Village Buried by
1980 Die Inschriften von Tortuguero,Tabasco. Material Volcanic Ash in Central America. Harcourt Brace
der Hamburger Maya Inschriften Dokumentation 5. Jovanovich, Fort Worth,Texas.
Universitat Hamburg,Hamburg. Smith,A. L.
Ringle, W. M. 1950 Uaxactun, Guatemala: F,xcavations of 1931-37.
1988 Of Mice and Monkeys: The Valueand Meaning of Publication588. CarnegieInstitution,Washington,D.C.
T1016, the God C Hieroglyph. Research Reports on Stephens,J. L.
Ancient Maya Writing 18. Center for Maya Research, 1841 Incidents of Travel in Central America, Chiapas,
Washington,D.C. and Yucatan.2 vols. Harperand Brothers,New York.
Robertson,M. G. Stuart,D.
1983 The Sculpture of Palenque: 1. The Temple of the 1987 Ten Phonetic Syllables. Research Reports on
Inscriptions. Princeton University Press, Princeton, Ancient Maya Writing 14. Center for Maya Research,
New Jersey. Washington,D.C.
1985 The Sculptureof Palenque: 111.The Late Buildings 1994 "The Fire Enters His House": Maya Hieroglyphic
of the Palace. Princeton University Press, Princeton, Records of Building Dedications and Related
New Jersey. Ceremonies. Paper presented at the October 9, 1994
1991 The Sculpture of Palenque: 114 The Cross Croup, Pre-ColumbianSymposium "Functionand Meaning in
the North Group, the Olvidado, and Other Pieces. Classic Maya Architecture." Dumbarton Oaks,
Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. Washington,D.C.
Roys, R. L. Stuart,D., and S. Houston
1965 Ritual of the Bacabs: A Book of Maya Incantations. 1994 Classic Maya Place Names. Studies in Pre-
University of Oklahoma Press, Norman. Columbian Art and Archaeology No. 33. Dumbarton
1967 The Book of Chilam Balam of Chumayel. Oaks, Washington,D.C.
University of OklahomaPress, Norman. Taladoire,E.
Roys, R. L., F. V. Scholes, and E. B. Adams 1981 Les Terrains de Jeu de Ball (Me'so-ame'riqueet
1940 Report and Census of the Indians of Cozumel, Sud-Ouest des Etats Unis). Etudes Mesoamericaines,
1570. Publication 523, Contribution 30. Carnegie Series II, no. 4. Mission Archeologique et Ethnologique
Institution,Washington,D.C. Francaiseau Mexique, Mexico.
Ruppert,K. Tarn,N., and M. Prechtel
1935 The Caracol at Chiche'n Itza', Yucatan, Me'xico. 1981 "Eating the Fruit": Sexual Metaphor and
Publication454. Carnegie Institution,Washington,D.C. Inititiation in Santiago Atitlan. Paper presented at the
1952 Chiche'n Itza: Architectural Notes and Plans. XVII Mesa Redonda, Sociedad Mexicana de
Publication595. CarnegieInstitution,Washington,D.C. Antropologia, San Cristobalde las Casas, June 21-27.
Ruz Lhuillier,A. Taube,K. A.
1952 Exploraciones en Palenque, 1951. Anales del 1988 The Ancient Yucatec New Year Festival: The
InstitutoNacional de a4ntropologEa e Historia 5:47-66. Liminal Period in Maya Ritua1 and Cosmology.
Satterthwaite,L. Unpublished Ph. D. dissertation, Department of
1936 An Unusual Type of Building in the Maya Old Anthropology, Yale University, New Haven,
Empire. Maya Research 3(1):62-73. Connecticut.
1952 Piedras Negras Archaeology: Architecture; Pt. v 1989 Itzam Cab Ain: Caimans, Cosmology, and
Sweathouses. University Museum, Philadelphia. Calendrics in Postclassic Yucata'n.Research Reportson
Schele, L. Ancient Maya Writing 26. Center for Maya Research,
1992 A New Look at the Dynastic History of Palenque. Washington,D.C.
In Supplement to the Handbook of Middle American Virkki,N.
Indians: 5. Epigraphy, edited by V. R. Bricker, pp. 1962 Comentariossobre el bano de vapor entre los indi-
82-109. University of Texas Press, Austin. genas de Guatemala.Guatemala Indfgena 2(2):71-85.
1994 The Iconography of ArchitecturalFacades during Wagley,C.
the Late and Terminal Classic Period. Paper presented 1949 The Social and Religious Life of a Guatemalan
at the October 9, 1994, Pre-Columbian Symposium Village. Memoir No. 71. American Anthropological
"Functionand Meaning in Classic Maya Architecture," Association, Menasha, WI.
DumbartonOaks, Washington,D.C. Wauchope,R.
Schele, L., and D. Freidel 1938 Modern Maya Houses: A Study of Their
1990 A Forest of Kings: The Untold Story of the Ancient Archaeological Significance. Publication 502. Carnegie
Maya. William Morrow,New York. Institution,Washington,D.C.
Schele, L., and P. Mathews
1979 The Bodega of Palenque, Chiapas, Mexico. Notes
DumbartonOaks, Washington,D.C.
1993 The Proceed ings of The Maya Hieroglyphic 1. Lakam may be glossed as either"big" or "banner"(Stuart
Workshop,March 13-14, 1993, University of Texas at and Houston 1994:30). As David Stuart(personalcommuni-

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Houston] SYMBOLICSWEATBATHSOF THE MAYA
151

cation 1992) points out to me, "banner"accords better with ing 13 jars of cenote wateron a flat, presumablyheated stone.
iconographic evidence, in which soft objects held by lords The text is importantfor two reasons: (1) the color-codingof
(and at least one lady) closely resemble elements of the "circles" (seating areas?) and kinds of steam suggest some-
LAKAM logograph. thing of the recondite,ritualizednatureof this bathing;and (2)
2. Robertson reconstructsthe head as that of a supernatural the existence of such an incantationin the northernLowlands
confirms the use of sweatbathsin areas beyond their present
being, yet a photographby Maudslay demonstratesthat the
head was completely gone by 1889, leaving its identity up to distribution.Regrettably,the two translationsof this passage
in the Ritual of the Bacabs vary considerably,although the
conjecture(Robertson 1991:Plate81).
general meaningremainsclear.
3 I leave out a possible, intermediatedate of 9.12.18.5.19 for
the reason that it is unlikely to exist an ordinalconstruction, 7. There is a possibility thatthe notions of "hot"and "cold"as
appliedto humansmay have extended to partsof the ceremo-
occurringwith a transitiveverb referringto the summoningof
nial landscapeat Palenque;presumably,certainlocations gen-
gods, has been, in my view, mistakenly identified as a so-
called "distance number,"which specifies the time elapsed erated "heat,"others exercised a "cold"influence on states of
between two dates (cf. Schele and Mathews 1993:124). bodily equilibrium.Implicit here is a rejection, seconded by
Lopez Austin (1988) in his study of centralMexican belief, of
4. Schele and Freidel are mindful of this reading (1990:470, Foster's notions regarding the Spanish origins of humoral
Figure 6:14) but preferto emphasize the meaningof "sanctu- pathology in indigenous medicine (cf. Foster and Anderson
ary"or "undergroundbuilding,"a term thoughtto evoke "the 1978:59). Foster's historicalperspectivewas a useful correc-
tombs of Pacal and other kings in pyramids" (Schele and tive to prior,naive ideas, but, in my opinion, has been taken
Freidel 1990:239). too far, as was also trueof his studyof nagualism(cf. Houston
5. Some of these readings,especially och na, come from work and Stuart1989).
by Stuart (1994). Note, too, that several signs are undeci- 8. Alternatively,only a few structuresmay have meritedsuch
phered, such as the superfix on the "sky" glyph; readings metaphoricplay.A glimmerof this occurs in Colonial Yucatec
markedwith an asteriskare reconstructiblefrom parallelver- sources, such as the ChilamBalam of Chumayel,in which the
sions in other inscriptions.The Cholan spelling of the month most importantstructure,the Cathedralin Merida, Yucatan,
name has been modified to accord with epigraphic usage, was describedin termsof couplets:"his greatchurch,his royal
which favors Yucatecanforms. house, his mountainoushouse, his darkhouse, for the service
6. Taubepoints out to me that the Ritual of the Bacabs, writ- of God the Father,God the Son, God the Holy Ghost"(Roys
ten in YucatecMaya, provides the most complete indigenous 1967:43, with my emendationsof the translation).
descriptionof sweatbathingand its medicinalproperties(Roys
1965:6s61, 106-107; Arzapalo Marin 1987:398v00). Text
XL, folia 18>182, records the generationof steam by pour- Received February22, 1994; accepted January 13, 1995.

This content downloaded from 188.37.82.74 on Sun, 8 Jun 2014 20:41:56 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

You might also like