Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tubularized Reconstructed Plate Urethroplasty - An Alternative Technique For Distal Hypospadias Repair
Tubularized Reconstructed Plate Urethroplasty - An Alternative Technique For Distal Hypospadias Repair
PII: S0090-4295(20)31263-2
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.urology.2020.10.007
Reference: URL 22580
Please cite this article as: Can Taneli , Halil Ibrahim Tanriverdi , Abdulkadir Genc , Aydin Sencan ,
Cuneyt Gunsar , Omer Yilmaz , TUBULARIZED RECONSTRUCTED PLATE URETHROPLASTY:
AN ALTERNATIVE TECHNIQUE FOR DISTAL HYPOSPADIAS REPAIR, Urology (2020), doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.urology.2020.10.007
This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the addition
of a cover page and metadata, and formatting for readability, but it is not yet the definitive version of
record. This version will undergo additional copyediting, typesetting and review before it is published
in its final form, but we are providing this version to give early visibility of the article. Please note that,
during the production process, errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal
disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Can Taneli1, Halil Ibrahim Tanriverdi2, Abdulkadir Genc2, Aydin Sencan2, Cuneyt Gunsar2,
Omer Yilmaz2
1
Manisa Celal Bayar University, Department of Pediatric Surgery, Division of Pediatric
Urology, Manisa-Turkey
2
Manisa Celal Bayar University, Department of Pediatric Surgery, Manisa-Turkey
Director, Division of Pediatric Urology, Department of Pediatric Surgery, Manisa Celal Bayar
E-mail: cantaneli@gmail.com
1
Ethical Standards: Informed consent was obtained pre-operatively from all our patients
Authors Contribution:
2
Abstract:
plate urethroplasty (TRPU) in distal hypospadias repair which allows the tubularization of
Methods: This study is a prospective single surgeon series. Between January 2019-March
2020, total of 158 patients underwent hypospadias repair, and 29 selected patients had
vertical incision is made starting from halfway up the glans. This incision creates a diamond
like defect which enables wedge removal of a segment of spongiosum tissue from the base
of urethral plate extending to the hypospadiac meatus. Vertical incision is closed horizontally.
The urethral plate is stretched and loosened from the base and re-secured into its bed using
quilting stitches. Reconstructed urethral plate ensures the required width to allow the
Results: Preoperative glans width was 13.4±0.9mm, urethral plate width was 6.1±0.9mm.
Mean postoperative follow-up period was 13.6 months. All patients had successful functional
outcome and cosmetically satisfying appearance. None of the patients required meatal
Conclusions: Native urethral plate itself is used as a natural flap to increase the surface
area of the urethral plate in this new perspective of urethroplasty method. We believe that
TRPU procedure provides an alternative approach for the formation of neourethra and it is a
successful and relatively simple procedure with low complication rates, good cosmetic results
3
Introduction
being currently used. Even the most commonly used correction techniques continue
infection etc. Successful outcomes depend mainly on the surgeon’s skills and
plate urethroplasty. The procedure simulates fossa navicularis and additionally solve
hypospadias surgery.
tubularizing the penile skin to the meatus.1-3 Tubularization of the urethral plate is the
incision in the urethral plate.4 The incision results in denuded surface for delayed
epithelization, but it may not add the desired width. The exact healing mechanism of
the incised plate is still open for discussion. To improve healing of the neourethra
after TIPU, the grafting of the dorsal incised area using the inner prepuce and dorsal
inlay graft urethroplasty (DIGU) has been described.5 DIGU is an attractive procedure
4
The aim of the present study is to introduce an alternative method, tubularized
We describe the steps of the TRPU technique on our initial series with successful
short-term outcome.
The TRPU method was performed in selected 29 patients between January 2019 and
March 2020 from a total of 158 patients that underwent hypospadias repair during
this inclusion period. The operation was performed consecutively to the patients that
met the inclusion criteria in a single center, by a single surgeon (CT), in a prospective
setting. The inclusion criteria for TRPU procedure is primary hypospadias repair with
shallow groove and flat glans where the relaxing midline incision is not ideal, but also
the groove is not narrow enough to require grafting. The indication for this technique
is well vascularized, thick, compliant, elastic plates, with urethral defect not longer
than 2-3 cm. Exclusion criteria are redo operations for hypospadias and preoperative
androgen stimulation. The major contraindication is fibrotic and scarred urethral plate.
TRPU surgery cannot be performed in cases with severe curvature and hypoplastic
urethra which are unable to preserve the urethral plate. TRPU technique could be
spongium tissue excision. It is unnecessary to use TRPU technique in wide and very
manually by compasses in all patients. Groove depth and surface area cannot be
plate groove and surface before and after excision of subepithelial tissue at the base
5
of the plate cannot be assessed. The operation technique was chosen based on the
recorded. Data are given as mean ± standard deviation and range. This study was
parental consent was obtained from all patients. The assessment of the
to the technique of the operation. Meatal size and necessity of dilatation was
functional outcome criteria as: straight urinary stream containing flare with a
stream. Cosmetically satisfying results are indicated as: conical shaped glans, slit-like
wide glanular meatus, ideal mucosal collar, aesthetically appearing skin covering and
Surgical Technique
After traction suture is placed through the tip of the glans, a vertical incision is made
beginning at the upper-half portion of the glans and extending distally to the apex.
traction sutures are placed at the edges of the incision (Fig. 1A). This incision creates
tissue, gaining adequate space for wide meatus (Fig.1B). Subsequently, longitudinal
wedge removal of a spongiosum tissue from the base of urethral plate extending to
the hypospadiac meatus (Fig. 1C). Thus, a wedge-shaped groove is carved out from
performed while pulling the tissue with fine-toothed forceps, cutting the tissue with iris
6
scissors and then extirpating by curette. As long as the depth of spongiosum excision
Sub-epithelial excision from the base of the native urethral plate thins and increases
the epithelialized surface area (additional video). The enlargement of the plate
resembles the stretchability of the graft by cleaning the fat tissue under the skin.
widens the diameter of the narrow plate (Fig. 1D). Thinned, stretched and finally
enlarged native urethral plate is re-secured into its bed using quilting stiches to
reduce the risk of mobilization (Fig. 1E). Urethral plate itself is used as a natural flap
tissue extending to the hypospadiac meatus creates a space for central embedding
of urethra. The cavity formed into the glans particularly simulates the fossa
navicularis. A U-shaped incision is done along the lateral margins of the urethral
plate. Reconstructed urethral plate ensures the required width to allow the
performed. Dartos tissue lays over the suture line as a second barrier for
waterproofing. Glans wings are brought together with interrupted 6/0 polyglactin
suture. Skin is closed with 7/0 PDS suture after circumcision. The operation stages of
the TRPU technique and postoperative results are illustrated in Figure 2. A silastic 8-
10 Fr catheter is used in all operated cases not only to maintain urinary diversion but
also to keep the reconstructed plate pushed back into its bed for 5-7 days. The
dressing is removed at the 2nd day. Outpatient clinic visits are scheduled at 1st week
and 1st, 3rd, 6th and 12th months for evaluation of postoperative outcome. All data
7
including age, meatus location, voiding pattern, and postoperative complications
such as meatal stenosis, fistula and cosmetic results were collected for all patients.
Results
The mean age of the patients at the time of surgery was 38.8±24.9 months (mean ±
standard deviation), and range was 6-120 months. Preoperative glans width was
13.4±0.9 mm (range 12-14 mm), urethral plate width was 6.1±0.9 mm (range 4-8
mm). External urethral meatus was located glanular in 2, coronal in 10, subcoronal in
complications. The mean postoperative follow-up period was 13.6 months (range 6-
visits one patient had a small fistula which was easily repaired 6 months later.
Another patient had anterior deflation of urine which was corrected spontaneously
within 3 months without any treatment. All patients had successful functional
outcomes. Straight urinary stream that contains flare with a translucent center were
observed in all cases at scheduled follow-up voiding controls. None of the patients
require meatal calibration since flare-like voiding pattern was achieved and confirmed
by voiding video records. All patients had cosmetically satisfying appearance with the
slit-like wide external meatus. Glans shape was conical compared to the preoperative
configuration. The total complication rate was 3.4%. The overall outcome of this
Comment
More than 300 procedures for hypospadias repair are available differing only in minor
details. High complication rates are a reported for hypospadias repair in the literature.
8
it was published.4 However, some concerns about meatal stenosis and necessity for
regular urethral dilatations were reported.6 Nguyen et al7 suggested that meatal
too far distally. Others reported that, neourethral stenosis is linked to plate
characteristics.8-9 Seleim et al10 stated that 4 mm width is the border line of clinical
relevance that defines poor urethral plate. Abbas and Salle11 proposed an objective
simple formula, measuring the ratio of the urethral plate before and after incision,
(urethra plate ratio =urethral plate pre incision/urethral plate after incision) to help
deciding to graft or not to graft the plate. They thought that if the ratio is less than 0.5,
be vulnerable to stenosis.11
considering the optimal repair in hypospadias, the depth, width and characteristics of
the urethral plate should be assessed. Snodgrass12 reported that, the appearance of
the urethral plate varies according to the thickness of connective tissue between the
epithelial surface of the plate and underlying corpora cavernosa. TIPU repair varies
from a deep incision for a shallow groove to no incision for deep groove. 12 Since
most cases have a shallow or moderate groove, the incision of the plate should be
extended deep to corporal bodies. The major indications for grafting were flat glans
or inadequate urethral plate width. Grafting the incised plate decreased the incidence
of meatal stenosis but the procedure added graft-related problems. If the urethral
plate is inadequate, the surgeon could complete the repair with alternative or
9
embedded the neourethra with a small midline incision of the glans. Koff14 and
Barthold15 changed this approach and improved the embedding by making a larger
incision in attempt to reduce tissue pressure on the neourethra. In the original Barcat
technique and modifications, the entire urethral plate is mobilized and attached to a
meatal based skin flap obtained from adjacent shaft skin. Even after extensive
mobilization of urethral plate and substantial resection of glandular tissue during the
or sensitivity were observed.16 The TRPU technique is completely different from the
GRACE and Barcat modifications. TRPU technique is unique as it keeps the native
urethral plate intact in its original place and excises spongiosum tissue from the back
tissue creates a longitudinal deep groove extending to the hypospadiac meatus and
posterior resetting of the native urethral plate is done by using quilting stiches.
The DUG procedure is a reliable technique to widen the urethral plate. However,
DUG and TRPU have different approaches to widen the urethral plate. Unlike DUG
technique, with the TRPU technique the urethral plate is not only widened but also
We have been using glanular spongiosum excision successfully for more than a
(MAGPI) repair.18 We did not observe blood circulation, sensitivity and scar problems
in any patient operated with the modified MAGPI method. Later, in DIGU operations,
we started to place a preputial graft after spongiosum tissue excision. With the
experience gained from these operations, we realized that wedge excision of the
10
spongiosum tissue could be extended to the hypospadiac meatus by preserving the
integrity of urethral plate even in distal penile shaft hypospadias. This method
described in the present article is an intermediate solution between TIPU and DIGU
techniques. Native urethral plate itself is used as a natural flap to increase the
surface area of urethral plate in this new perspective of urethroplasty method. TRPU
particularly enlarged and grooved plates, ensures the required width for optimal
tubularization.
It is generally accepted that both the preputium and spongiosum tissue have a V-
shaped defect in the ventral part of the hypospadiac meatus.19 However, we also
believe that the spongiosum tissue is not completely missing. It is thicker in the dorsal
part of the urethral plate just like the dorsal collection of the hooded preputium. In our
opinion, the groove is shallow due to the spongiosum tissue collected in the dorsal
part of the urethral plate. Collection of dorsal spongiosum under the plate, allows the
midline relaxing incision in TIPU. Whereas the collection of spongiosum in the dorsal
part of the plate enables evacuating the spongiosum tissue under the epithelialized
surface in TRPU. Furthermore, the removal of the spongiosum creates a space for
TIPU and TRPU techniques in shallow groove hypospadias cases are illustrated in
figure 3.
The key step of the technique is to stretch the urethral plate by evacuating
spongiosum and removing the subepithelial tissue from the back of the plate to
expand the natural urethral plate. This maneuver also re-grooves the urethral plate,
11
for re-epithelialization. In addition, spongiosum tissue removal creates a hinging
effect, facilitates glanular closure, embeds the neourethra further into the glans and
Snodgrass and Bush20 stated that, the urethral meatus normally completely enclosed
by the glans which makes urine stream narrow and straight. Hypospadias repair
should restore natural anatomy creating a straight compact urinary stream. The new
TRPU technique imitates fossa navicularis in the normal anatomy of the urethra and
repair. The TRPU procedure eases the embedding of the urethra further into the
glans, thus a slit-like wide meatus and straight urinary stream containing flare with a
translucent center is obtained (Fig. 4). The TRPU technique is applicable for all distal
hypospadias but has significant value in patients with shallow groove and relatively
narrow plate which are majority of the hypospadias cases. This new technique can
except one small fistula which was easily repaired later. In addition, anterior deflation
postoperative sixth month. We believe that anterior deflation of urine may occur due
Although it is commonly stated that meatal stenosis or stricture may not become
apparent until toilet training, none of our toilet-trained patients needed urethral
calibration at the follow-up period. In this series, the TRPU method was applied to
patients in a wide age range of 6-120 months. It has shown that this new method can
12
It has been well noted that boys with hypospadias show abnormal (subclinical) flow
patterns before and after surgery.21 However, until long term follow-up studies clarify
The limitations of this study were short term follow-up and absence of a comparison
of the surgical technique has not been applied in a randomized setting but by
In conclusion, the new TRPU provides an alternative tool to the formation of urethra
in distal hypospadias. Native urethral plate itself is used as a natural flap to increase
the surface area of urethral plate in this new perspective of urethroplasty. We believe
that the TRPU is a relatively simple procedure with a low rate of complications, good
References
1.Thiersh C. On the origin and operative treatment of epispadias. Arch Heilk. 1869;
10: 20.
13
5. Kolon TF, Gonzales ET. The dorsal inlay graft for hypospadias repair. J Urol.
2000;63:1941-1943.
410x.1999.00207.x.
https://doi.org/10.1097/ 01.ju.0000110426.32005.91.
8. Holland AJ, Smith GH. Effect of depth and width of the urethral plate on
9. Sarhan O, Saad M, Helmy T, et al. Effect of suturing technique and urethral plate
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.juro.2009.04.034.
grafting the preservable narrow plates with consideration of native plate width at
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpurol.2019.05.002
11. Abbas TO, Pippi Salle JL. When to graft the incised plate during TIP repair? A
suggested algorithm that may help in the decision-making process. Front Pediatr
14
12. Snodgrass WT. Tubularized incised plate hypospadias repair; indications,
4295(99)00144-2.
13. Barcat J. Les hypospadias. III. Les uretroplasties, les resultates – les
14. Koff SA, Brinkman J, Ulrich J et al. Extensive mobilization of the urethral plate
and urethra for repair of hypospadias: the modified Barcat technique. J Urol.
1994;151:466-469.doi: 10.1016/s0022-5347(17)34992-3.
15. Barthold JS, Teer TL, Rodman JF. Modified Barcat balanic groove technique for
doi:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2011.12.013.
17. Stock JA, Hanna MK. Distal urethroplasty and glanuloplasty procedure: results of
2004;38:122-124. https://doi.org/10.1080/00365590310020042.
19. Baskin LS Ebbers MB. Hypospadias: anatomy, etiology, and technique Journal
15
21. Wolffenbuttel KP, Wondergem N, Hoefnagels JJ, et al. Abnormal urine flow in
boys with distal hypospadias before and after correction. J Urol. 2006;176(4 Pt
2):1733-1737. doi:10.1016/S0022-5347(06)00614-8.
doi:10.1111/j.1442-2042.2011.02839.x.
16
Figure Legends
Figure 1. The TRPU technique. A, A vertical incision is made beginning at the upper-half of
the glans and extending distally to the apex. B, Glanular spongiosum tissue is excised with
iris scissors in order to deepen the groove of the urethral plate C, Cleaning the tissue under
the epithelialized surface of the plate widens the native urethral plate. D, Vertical incision and
secured into the glans using quilting stitches. F, U-shaped incision is done along the lateral
Figure 2: A, Spongiosum tissue excision. B, Expanded plate is re-secured into the glans. C,
Figure 4: A, Narrow glanular neourethra without fossa navicularis causes a string type
urinary stream. B, TRPU procedure provides a wide meatus and straight urinary stream that
Video Legend
Video showing sub-epithelial excision from the base of the native urethral plate thins and
increases the epithelialized surface area. The resulting enlargement of the plate resembles
the stretching ability of the graft after extirpating the fat tissue under the skin.
17
Figure 1
18
Figure 2
19
Figure 3
20
Figure 4
21