Frontier Crimes Regulation - A Past That Never Ends

8/1/23, 10:49 PM Frontier Crimes Regulation: a past that never ends - DAWN.
COM
TODAY'S PAPER | AUGUST 01, 2023
Frontier Crimes Regulation: a past that never ends

Zuha Siddiqui | Published May 15, 2018
Da Sanga Azadi Da — "What freedom is this?" — is the Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement

(PTM) anthem heard at their gatherings and jalsas.
PTM’s figurehead, Manzoor Pashteen, asked that question in Karachi — the world's largest Pashtun
city by population — on Sunday, May 13, as the PTM headed over to Pakistan’s main metropolis.
Karachi, after all, is where a young Pashtun from Waziristan, Naqeebullah Masood, was killed in an
extrajudicial encounter by the police on suspicion of terrorism on January 13, which provided
impetus for PTM’s rallies and demands for fair treatment from the state.
But if we are to trace the origins of some of the grievances of the Pashtuns of Pakistan's tribal areas,
we will have to go all the way back to 1893 — to the year when the Durand Line was set in stone as a
border separating British India from Afghanistan.
The creation of this border-province begins the story of the continued maltreatment of the Pashtuns
inhabiting these areas.
Characterised by the Raj as ill-defined and turbulent, these regions compromised the defence of the
borders of British India. They did not border a recognised foreign power; rather, they separated the
Raj’s dominion from the 'wild', 'lawless, 'unsettled' and 'warlike' tribes living in the hills that
stretched into Afghan lands.
https://www.dawn.com/news/print/1407020 1/17
8/1/23, 10:49 PM Frontier Crimes Regulation: a past that never ends - DAWN.COM
A map of Fata.
Eventually, these borderlands were assimilated into the Pakistani state post-1947 and incorporated
into what we now know as the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (Fata). For the residents of this
region, however, not much has changed in over a century in terms of infrastructure and development.
The curfews, coercion and oppression that the PTM protests against today trace their roots to laws
created by the Raj.
The basic aim of the Raj was to ensure that order prevailed along British India’s periphery and that a
'safe and permanent frontier' was established along its borders.
In 1898, the London Times ran a report on these policies of the Raj:
"Now that we had established our authority and supremacy over the district in which warlike
operations [the Afridis revolted after the Durand line was proclaimed — a revolt which the British
successfully quashed] had been taking place, it seemed an opportune moment to define what were
the objects which we should wish to promote, what should be our frontier policy in India.
"[Lord George Hamilton] had always held that the presence and the advance of Russia in Central
Asia was a factor connected with our frontier policy which we could not ignore.
"We must protect our subjects [referring to subjects in Punjab and Sindh] and must ensure that the
tribes under our influence [are] not interfered with."
And while the rest of British India was a crude reproduction of the metropole — introducing a
centralised state that had ostensibly modern forms of governance, a bureaucracy, defined territory
and a monopoly over violence — colonial rule in borderlands was markedly different.
As opposed to pursuing a project of modernisation, the goal was to ensure that the frontier’s ‘unruly’
tribesmen did not integrate with the rest of the territories of the Raj.
Galvanising the Raj’s impulse towards the institutionalisation of difference and excluding the frontier
and its inhabitants from the colonial state were the Frontier Crimes Regulations (FCR), established
as law over Bajaur, Mohmand, Khyber, Orakzai, Kurram, Waziristan — the borders of NWFP — in
1901.
These regulations transformed tribesmen into imperial vassals, denied them access to colonial courts
and Raj governance and yet, expected them to act in accordance with the interests and concerns of
the overarching imperial state.
Subsequently, under the guise of respecting the independence of the tribes, the Raj’s road and railway
construction was limited to the areas of British Baluchistan — and not the border region — and
irrigation projects were limited to the provinces of Sindh and Punjab.
At the same time, service in tribal militias — which served on colonial outposts and checkpoints along
the frontier region’s border with Afghanistan — transformed Pashtuns into wage labourers, tying
them further into the colonial economic system at minimal cost, and consequently, to the colonial
state.
Colin Metcalfe Enriquez’s The Pathan Borderland — published in 1921 — describes this as a
"marvelous method":
"Not the least wonderful of the many marvelous methods employed in keeping our fickle and
excitable neighbours [North of the Durand Line] in order is the use made of the Pathans themselves
to protect our marches."
According to Enriquez’s chronicle, the number of troops — militias, border military police and levies
— along the border numbered 10,440 in July, and all but 1,150 were Pashtun.
The FCR recognised and codified the existence of the jirga, or Council of Elders. But while the jirga's
punishments and decisions were based on tribal customs, the FCR allowed and empowered the
British Deputy-Commissioner to make both civil, and criminal, references to Councils of Elders.
In addition, where the Deputy-Commissioner believed that a civil dispute was likely to lead to a
blood-feud or a breach of peace — especially in cases where a frontier tribesman was party to the
dispute — he was at the liberty to refer the case to a jirga of his own nomination.
In other words, supreme power lay in the hands of the Deputy-Commissioner: he could question the
jirga's decisions, veto or pass criminal sentences and bar hostile tribes from entering British India.
And because of the Raj’s stifling military presence in the tribal borderlands — with four 'movable
columns' in Peshawar, Kohat, Bannu and Dera Ismail Khan, along with multiple corps of military
police, levies and militia across the region, from Waziristan right up to Chitral — these tribes, more
often than not, had no option but to accept the terms laid upon them.
For example, a 1919 Nottingham Evening Post report states that the "Mahsuds accepted all our
[referring to the Raj] terms, which include an unopposed march through their territory and the
continuance there of our troops until all fines have been paid."
In addition, Article 11, Section (1) of the FCR stated , "The Deputy Commissioner may or if the
Commissioner so directs, shall, by order in writing, refer the question to the decision of a Council of
Elders (jirga), and require the Council to come a finding on the question after such inquiry as may be
necessary and after hearing the accused person. The members of the Council of Elders (jirga) shall, in
each case, be nominated and appointed by the Deputy Commissioner. [emphasis added]"
More importantly, with Article 36, the FCR granted the British government the authority to "remove
persons" — with "remove" ostensibly referring to a colonial form of deportation: one that forced
inhabitants of the frontier region to "reside beyond the limits to which this regulation [the FCR]
extends."
In 1937, the Evening Telegraph and Post in Dundee, Scotland reported about "Tribal Hostages
Handed Over". It detailed that over a hundred men were "handed over as hostages" to the
Government of India by the jirga of the Tori Khel tribe in Mirali, Khaisora Valley, Waziristan.
This "handing over" of men was part of the conditions laid down upon the Tori Khel tribesmen by
Major-General D. E. Robertson, Commander of the Waziristan district, "to ensure peace."
In addition, the FCR lacked basic civil protections, allowed collective punishment of individual
crimes and placed extraordinary discretionary powers in the hands of the officers of the Raj.
A 1914 report in London’s The Times titled "Indian Frontier Tribe Chastised" described the
"punishment" of the entire Bunerwal tribe as a consequence of a raid carried out by a few tribesmen:
"The column set out to execute reprisals on the Bunerwal tribesmen who recently raided British
territory has, after a tiring night march, taken the villages and captured a number of prisoners."
When Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the new state kept the architecture of tribal governance
in place, thus keeping tribesmen of the frontier outside the realm of citizenship and leaving them in a
state of perpetual dislocation.
It wasn’t until 1997 that regions governed by the FCR were granted representation in the national
legislature. Party-based elections – after much debate and deliberation – were introduced to the
region in 2013.
The recently passed Fata reforms bill proposes abolishing the FCR altogether (there were substantial
amendments to the FCR in 2011 ), bringing the region into the fold of the province of Khyber
Pakhtunkhwa, as well as expanding the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court and the Peshawar High
Court to the region.
While the bill has been approved and signed by the President, its terms haven’t been made law as
yet due to political reasons.
There has also been talk of granting Fata a share in the NFC award — this proposition has allegedly
been opposed by other provinces.
But the military checkposts across Fata remain standing. They are physical reminders of over a
century of high handedness.
And the people of Fata remain confined to the margins of the state, excluded from the national body
politic and defined by an era of colonial governance with limited rights and restricted access to
judicial systems.
Latest Stories
Indian railway security official shoots dead senior
officer, 3 Muslim passengers in ‘hate crime’
Elections to be held on 2023 census: PM Shehbaz
NA passes bill proposing up to 3 years in jail for Punjab authorities give approval for screening of
disclosing identities of intelligence officials, others ‘Barbie’ in province
‘War not an option’: PM Shehbaz says ready to talk to Met office forecasts more monsoon rains in upper parts
‘neighbour’ on serious matters of Pakistan from tomorrow
Indus Echoes, Pakistan’s ‘first Sindhi language feature film in 26 years’, nears completion
Punjab to decide fate of Barbie today
Euphoria star Angus Cloud dead at 25
Most Popular
01
At least 44 killed, over 100 injured in ‘suicide’ blast at JUI-F convention in KP’s Bajaur
02
With CPEC entering 2nd phase, some nations making efforts to bypass Pakistan in this process of
connectivity: PM
03
Cartoon: 31 July, 2023
04
Muslim woman assaulted in India
05
PM Shehbaz opposes Ishaq Dar as interim prime minister
06
Dawar warns militancy may engulf country if not curbed
07
Joining China’s Belt and Road was an ‘atrocious’ decision: Italy minister
Bajaur bombing
08
09
India’s future path
Must Read
The new data protection law is a farce aimed at violating citizens’ privacy
Shumaila Shahani
Progressive developments in data protection can only be made through inclusive policy-making processes that seek
input from privacy experts, tech companies, and, most importantly, citizens.
It seems as if the idea of putting a loyal politician in charge of the

interim govt is gaining traction
Editorial: Bill on violent extremism is well equipped to cut down any party which crosses so-
called ‘red lines’
MLC: Cricket breaks new ground as America’s South Asian diaspora

gets a taste of T20 extravaganza
Brashna Kasi
Showing up at the IMF’s doorsteps has been a feature of several South

Asian countries
Opinion
Growing distrust
Arifa Noor
A loyal politician is apparently in demand — not just a politician.
Updated 01 Aug, 2023
A begging bowl to fight poverty
Jawed Naqvi
01 Aug, 2023
Killer tobacco
Navaira Ali Bangash
01 Aug, 2023
Justice or revenge?
Rashad Bukhari
Updated 31 Jul, 2023
UN’s new agenda for peace
Maleeha Lodhi
Editorial
01 Aug, 2023
Climate adaptation
FOR Pakistan, searing heatwaves, severe squalls, hunger and displacement make
climate change a hot topic. The...
Updated 01 Aug, 2023
Gutting democracy
Even the PTI’s rivals have had the foresight to realise that this proposed law is an
equal threat to their parties.
01 Aug, 2023
GB road safety
WHILE road safety in Pakistan is overall poor, the situation is particularly acute on
the high-altitude ...
31 Jul, 2023
Bajaur bombing
The Taliban regime next door is also proving to be a problem.
Updated 31 Jul, 2023
Auto slump
Analysts agree that it is likely that industry sales will remain suppressed over the next couple of years.
31 Jul, 2023
Foo fighters
“THE truth is out there.” The ominous tagline of the hit science fiction drama The X-
Files has taken on a new...

Frontier Crimes Regulation - A Past That Never Ends

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Frontier Crimes Regulation - A Past That Never Ends

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

8/1/23, 10:49 PM Frontier Crimes Regulation: a past that never ends - DAWN.

TODAY'S PAPER | AUGUST 01, 2023

Frontier Crimes Regulation: a past that never ends

Da Sanga Azadi Da — "What freedom is this?" — is the Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement

Elections to be held on 2023 census: PM Shehbaz

Punjab to decide fate of Barbie today

Euphoria star Angus Cloud dead at 25

Cartoon: 31 July, 2023

Muslim woman assaulted in India

PM Shehbaz opposes Ishaq Dar as interim prime minister

Dawar warns militancy may engulf country if not curbed

India’s future path

It seems as if the idea of putting a loyal politician in charge of the

MLC: Cricket breaks new ground as America’s South Asian diaspora

Showing up at the IMF’s doorsteps has been a feature of several South

Updated 01 Aug, 2023

A begging bowl to fight poverty

Navaira Ali Bangash

Updated 31 Jul, 2023

UN’s new agenda for peace

Updated 01 Aug, 2023

Updated 31 Jul, 2023

You might also like