RATING SHEET FOR PME EXAMINEES

Name:

Address:

Email Address: _

Age: Gender: Status:

Present Position:

Company:

Date of Registration: No. of Years of Experience: _

Date of TER Submission:

TITLE OF TECHNICAL ENGINEERING REPORT:

A. FIRST ORAL EXAMINATION/INTERVIEW RATING (25 %)

1.0 EXPERTISE (40%)

1.1 Number of years of relevant ME practice (30%)

1.1.1 in excess of 20 years: 27-30%
1.1.2 13-20 years: 23-26%
1.1.3 9-12 years: 19-22%
1.1.4 5-8 years: 15-18%

1.2 Exposure to various fields (30%)

1.2.1 More than 5 fields (25-30%)
1.2.2 3-5 fields (16-24%)
1.2.3 2 fields (8-15%)
1.2.4 1 field (0-7%)

1.3 Technical Demands of those fields in terms of difficulty,

size of project or equipment (40%)
1.3.1 Large and Complex (26-40%)
1.3.2 Moderately Complex (11-25%)
1.3.3 Small and simple projects and equipment (0-10%)

TOTAL
2.0 DESIGN (40%)

2.1 Competence in various Mechanical Engineering Field (40%)

2.1.1 Has shown 5 Design competencies (32-40%)
2.1.2 Has shown 3-4 Design competencies (16-31%)
2.1.3 Has shown 0-2 Design competencies (0-15%)

2.2 Accuracy in answering technical questions (40%)

2.2.1 Highly accurate (26-40%)
2.2.2 Accurate most of the time (15-25%)
2.2.3 Not accurate most of the time (0-14%)

2.3 Composure and confidence (10%)

2.3.1 Calm and confident (8-10%)
2.3.2 Moderately calm and confident (5-7%)
2.3.3 Nervous and apprehensive (0-4%)

2.4 Ability to communicate (10%)

2.4.1 Fluent, no grammatical errors (8-10%)
2.4.2 Fluent with 2 or more errors (5-7%)
2.4.3 Unable to express clearly (0-4%)

TOTAL

3.0 LEADERSHIP AND VALUES (Refer to C. Leadership and Values) (20%)

3.1 Demonstrate Independence in Decision Making (40%)

3.1.1 Always solves problem appropriately (30-40%)
3.1.2 Moderately independent (18-29%)
3.1.3 Always depends on others to make decisions (0-17%)

3.2 Demonstrate Leadership qualities (40%)

3.2.1 Has shown 5 Leadership qualities (30-40%)
3.2.2 Has shown 3-4 Leadership qualities (18-29%)
3.2.3 Only 2 Leadership qualities (0%-17%)

3.3 Adheres to Code of Conduct (0-20%)

TOTAL
B. TECHNICAL ENGINEERING REPORT RATING (50 %)

1.1 Compliance with instructions (10%)

1.1.1 Compliant with outline requirement (10%) _
1.1.2 Non-Compliant to required outline (0%)

1.2 Technical Content and Discussions (50%)

1.2.1 Complete and extensive (36-50%) _
1.2.2 Moderately complete (26-35%)
1.2.3 Lacked details (0-25%)

1.3 Organization and Presentation of the Engineering Report(10%)

1.3.1 Good, structured and methodical (8-10%)
1.3.2 Average (4-7%)
1.3.3 Poor, disorganized (0-3%)

1.4 Soundness of Conclusions and Recommendations (25%)

1.4.1 Good, conclusions follow logically
from technical content (20-25%)
1.4.2 Average, one or two conclusions are not
related to technical content and unclear
(5-19%)
1.4.3 Poor, all conclusions are unrelated to technical discussions (0-4%)

1.5 Grammar, spelling (5%)

1.5.1 Good, no error in grammar and spelling (5%)
1.5.2 Average, 1-5 errors (3-4%)
1.5.3 Poor, more than 5 errors (0-2%)

TOTAL

C. SECOND ORAL EXAMINATION RATING (25 %)

1.1 Punctuality at the appointed time (10%)

1.1.1 On time (10%)
1.1.2 Late for 1-10 minutes (5%)
1.1.3 Late for 11-15 minutes (0%)
1.1.4 Late for more than 15 minutes (failed the PME upgrading)

1.2 Grasp of the subject matter (40%)

1.2.1 Exhibits knowledge of subject matter (26-40%)
1.2.2 Moderate knowledge of subject matter (15-25%)
1.2.3 Do not have knowledge of subject matter (0-14%)
 1.3 Accuracy in answering technical questions (30%)
1.3.1 Highly accurate (21-30%)
1.3.2 Accurate most of the time (10-20%)
1.3.3 Not accurate most of the time (0-9%)

1.4 Composure and confidence (10%)

1.4.1 Calm and confident (8-10%)
1.4.2 Moderately calm and confident (5-7%)
1.4.3 Nervous and apprehensive (0-4%)

1.5 Ability to communicate (10%)

1.5.1 Fluent, no grammatical errors (8-10%)
1.5.2 Fluent with 2 or more errors (5-7%)
1.5.3 Unable to express clearly (0-4%)

TOTAL

SUMMARY OF RATINGS

1. First Oral Exam Total x 0.25

2. Engineering Report Total x 0.50

3. Second Oral Exam Total x 0.25

FINAL AVERAGE RATING

Name of Examinee:

Date of Online Oral Examination: ______________________________

Board of Mechanical Engineering