Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PDF Schistosomiasis Control in China The Successful Example of Jiangxi Province Zhongdao Wu Ebook Full Chapter
PDF Schistosomiasis Control in China The Successful Example of Jiangxi Province Zhongdao Wu Ebook Full Chapter
https://textbookfull.com/product/schistosomiasis-in-the-people-s-
republic-of-china-from-control-to-elimination-1st-edition-xiao-
nong-zhou/
https://textbookfull.com/product/lineage-and-community-in-
china-1100-1500-genealogical-innovation-in-jiangxi-the-
historical-anthropology-of-chinese-society-series-1st-edition-he/
https://textbookfull.com/product/mine-waste-management-in-china-
recent-development-di-wu/
https://textbookfull.com/product/environmental-management-in-
china-policies-and-institutions-jing-wu/
Photo catalytic Control Technologies of Flue Gas
Pollutants Jiang Wu
https://textbookfull.com/product/photo-catalytic-control-
technologies-of-flue-gas-pollutants-jiang-wu/
https://textbookfull.com/product/mobilizing-without-the-masses-
control-and-contention-in-china-diana-fu/
https://textbookfull.com/product/population-development-
challenges-in-china-family-planning-policy-and-provincial-
population-difference-pengkun-wu/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-legal-barriers-to-
technology-transfer-under-the-un-framework-convention-on-climate-
change-the-example-of-china-chen-zhou/
https://textbookfull.com/product/educational-journeys-struggles-
and-ethnic-identity-the-impact-of-state-schooling-on-muslim-hui-
in-rural-china-1st-edition-xinyi-wu-auth/
Parasitology Research Monographs 11
Zhongdao Wu
Yiwen Liu
Heinz Mehlhorn Editors
Schistosomiasis
Control in China
The Successful Example of
Jiangxi Province
Parasitology Research Monographs
Volume 11
Series Editor
Heinz Mehlhorn
Department of Parasitology
Heinrich Heine University
Düsseldorf
Germany
This book series “Parasitology Research Monographs” presents carefully refereed
volumes on selected parasitological topics. Parasites have an increasing impact on
animal and human health in the present times of globalization and global warming.
Parasites may be agents of diseases and- often at the same time- vectors of other
agents of disease such as viruses, bacteria, fungi, protozoa and/or worms. The
growth in knowledge of parasitic physiology, cell structure, biotechnological and
genetic approaches, ecology, therapeutic capabilities, vaccination, immunology,
diagnosis, transmission pathways and many other aspects of parasitology is increas-
ing dramatically, even in the face of the breakthroughs that have already been made.
Reflecting these most recent achievements and the importance of parasites as a
threat to human and animal health, the series’ broad scope concentrates on partic-
ularly hot topics that were recently covered by review articles in the journal
“Parasitology Research” or in other journals. These reviews offer compact but
intense insights into the ongoing research and into the methods and technologies
used to control parasites. The volumes in the series build on these topics, and the
volume editors are well-known experts in their respective fields. Each volume offers
10 to 20 comprehensive reviews covering all relevant aspects of the topic in focus.
Schistosomiasis Control
in China
The Successful Example of Jiangxi Province
Editors
Zhongdao Wu Yiwen Liu
Zhongshan School of Medicine Jiangxi Provincial Institute of Parasitic Diseases
Sun Yat-sen University Qingshanhu District, Nanchang
Guangzhou, China Jiangxi, China
Heinz Mehlhorn
Department of Parasitology
Heinrich Heine University
Düsseldorf, Germany
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Switzerland AG.
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Foreword
v
vi Foreword
hilly endemic areas are typical representatives of most endemic areas in China. Thus,
the prevention and control of schistosomiasis has a unique status and function in
China. In 1958, Chairman Mao Zedong wrote a famous poem “Seven Rhythms and
Say farewell to the Ghost of Diseases” about the establishment of China’s anti-
schistosomiasis “first red flag” in Yujiang County, Jiangxi Province. In 2004, in
Jinxian County (Jiangxi Province), the comprehensive strategy of controlling the
source of infection was successfully explored, and this has become the leading
strategy in the process of eliminating schistosomiasis in China. In 2018, China's
schistosomiasis control memorial hall was established in Yujiang as another plat-
form for external exchanges and worldwide cooperation in the work of schistoso-
miasis control. The prevention and control of schistosomiasis in Jiangxi Province
which has passed through the same stages of prevention and control methods as the
whole country proved its unique prevention and control characteristics.
A fairy tale says that a glimpse of a pot may announce a lurking leopard. In a
similar way, this book documents the challenges and strategies for completely
eliminating schistosomiasis in Jiangxi Province by learning from the past, by
evaluating the present situation of schistosomiasis, and by using all measurements
of schistosomiasis prevention and treatment and treated people. The success of the
measurements of schistosmiasis prevention and control in China is documented in
this book and is based on the constant accumulation of knowledge during the project.
Thus, there is good hope that the publication of this book will provide useful
references for the prevention and control of global tropical diseases and offer
practical experience for other schistosomiasis endemic countries to achieve the
UN's goal of sustainable development by 2030.
The flukes of the genus Schistosoma received their recent genus name describing the
unique lifelong partnership between males and females, whereby the male transports
lifelong the female inside a channel, which is formed by the upfolded lateral borders
of the males. For many centuries, these worms endangered millions of humans and
their animals in tropical and subtropical regions. Since humans in these regions
could not avoid contact with water, wherein the vector snails live—e.g., in lakes and
rivers—infection rates and numbers of human deaths had always been very high
endangering the survival of human populations in many regions of the world. With
the worldwide introduction of praziquantel (a drug marketed under different names)
starting around 1980, physicians had a “weapon” to cure slight infections. However,
drugs alone could not solve the problem. Therefore, industrialized countries like
Japan and China had started anti-schistosomiasis campaigns 15–20 years ago, which
now bear the fruits of the enormous efforts needed in many fields of science and
economy. Japan has actually declared full eradication of these worms and China is
on the brink of it. This book contains reports on the problems and solutions to help
China become free of schistosomiasis in the near future.
We are thankful for the assistance from Dr Xiaoying Wu who is a researcher at the
Third Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China.
ix
Contents
xi
Chapter 1
Schistosomes: Trematode Worms That
Endanger Still Today Millions of Humans
and Animals
Heinz Mehlhorn
Abstract The clinical symptoms (bloody urine and/or bloody feces) of the disease,
which today is called schistosomiasis, are due to infections with rather small and tiny
trematode worms of only 1–2 cm in length being known already since the times of
the Egyptian Ramses kings (1290–1157 BC). However, the descriptions of these
worms in the blood vessels of humans are not older than 160–170 years, and really
successful treatment started not earlier than 1974, when the chemical compound
praziquantel came onto the market.
Eradication programs are very difficult, since these worms infect not only humans
but also a broad spectrum of free-living vertebrate and evertebrate hosts, wherein the
parasites may hide themselves during eradication trials among humans and various
animals. This chapter reports details of the life cycle stages of these worms, which
have been targeted by different control measurements during the last few decades in
China, Japan, and several Asian countries.
The present genus name Schistosoma (¼ twisted body) was created in the year 1858
by the German zoologist David Friedrich Weinland to characterize a genus of
dioecious (digenean) flatworms, which in contrast to other species of this group
have developed male and female individuals. However, these worms do not occur as
single individuals in the blood vessels of their hosts, but always as pairs, whereby the
flattened male worm harbors lifelong the string-like female in a so-called canalis
gynaecophorus (Figs. 1.1 and 1.2). The present genus name Schistosoma has its
origin in the Greek terms schizein ¼ divide and soma ¼ body. The history of the
discovery of the adult worms leading to the so-called schistosomiasis of our days has
two sources:
H. Mehlhorn (*)
Department of Parasitology, Heinrich Heine University, Duesseldorf, Germany
e-mail: mehlhorn@uni-duesseldorf.de
Fig. 1.1 Life cycle of Schistosoma mansoni and typical eggs and intermediate hosts of
S. haematobium and S. japonicum (According to Piekarski 1987). A Final host: man; site of the
adult worms: mesenteric vessels. 1a Sexually mature pair of flukes of S. mansoni (Sambon 1907). b
Mature egg of S. mansoni (lateral spine). 2 Miracidium. B Intermediate hosts: aquatic snails
(Planorbidae, e.g., Planorbis boissyi, Australorbis glabratus). 3a Sporocyst of the first type (mother
1 Schistosomes: Trematode Worms That Endanger Still Today Millions of. . . 3
⁄
Fig. 1.1 (continued) sporocyst); 3b Sporocyst of the second order (daughter sporocyst). 4 Free
cercaria (forked-tail cercaria). I S. haematobium (Bilharz 1852): the egg containing a miracidium is
provided with a terminal spine. Shells of the intermediate hosts of the species: (a) Bulinus truncatus
(North Africa) and (b) Bulinus globosus (West Africa). II S. japonicum (Katsurada 1904): egg with
miracidium (shell has a very small lateral spine); shells of intermediate hosts of the snail genera (a)
Schistosomorpha, (b) Oncomelania, and (c) Katayama
4 H. Mehlhorn
Fig. 1.2 (a) Scanning electron micrograph of a couple of the species Schistosoma mansoni. The
male covers the string-like female inside a so-called canalis gynaecophorus. The surface of the
males of this species is—in contrast to that of males of S. japonicum—equipped with hook-bearing
bosses, which help to become fixed in peculiar regions of the host’s blood vessels. These bosses and
hooks are not present in several other species such as Schistosoma japonicum. (b) Light micrograph
of a stained couple of Schistosoma mansoni. Note the blood-filled, dense appearing intestine
– Adults that live united as couples in the blood vessels of their hosts (Figs. 1.1,
1.2, 1.3, 1.4)
– Females that excrete species-specific eggs (Fig. 1.5), which occur either in the
feces or in the urine, depending on the species.
– Miracidium larvae that look like ciliates (¼ free-living protozoans) and hatch in
freshwater as soon as eggs have been entered therein and penetrate into species-
specific snails (Steinmann et al. 2006) (Fig. 1.6a, b)
– Bifurcated cercariae (Figs. 1.7 and 1.8) that leave the intermediate hosts (snails)
and are able to enter a broad spectrum of final hosts (mammals, humans), where
they grow up to adult females or males, which mate and live in species-specific
blood vessels (e.g., inside vessels of the intestinal wall or inside vessels of the
urogenital system (Table 1.2).
These different positions of the adult worms in the body of humans lead to the fact
that the worm eggs are either (mainly) excreted within the feces or in the urine of
their hosts. However, many of the numerous daily excreted eggs stick in the tissues
and induce therein life-threatening granulomas (Richter et al. 2016) (Figs. 1.9 and
1.10). In all cases, the bifurcated cercariae act as infectious stages, which after
leaving the intermediate hosts (¼ snails) swim to a broad spectrum of potential
vertebrate hosts, attach there, enter the skin while discharging the bifurcated tail
(Figs. 1.7 and 1.8), and finally enter the blood vessels of several organs.
1 Schistosomes: Trematode Worms That Endanger Still Today Millions of. . . 5
Fig. 1.3 Light micrograph of a stained couple of Schistosoma japonicum. The dark appearing
female has left, at places the canal is gynaecophorous of the male (Source: Prof. Dr. Wei, Wuxi,
China)
since human infections may easily occur due to contact with contaminated water
(by penetration of cercariae), more than 700 million humans live at the risk of being
infected by schistosomes, although there exist significant control methods and
excellently acting chemotherapeutics (Mehlhorn et al. 1982, 1983; Mehlhorn
2016; Agrawal 2012; Bian et al. 2015; Cao et al. 2016; Gao et al. 2015; Grys
2016; Liu et al. 2011; Othman and Soliman 2015; Shimada et al. 2010; van Dam
et al. 2015; Wang et al. 2012; Weerakoon et al. 2015; Wu 2016; Zheng et al. 2012;
Zhong et al. 2014; Zhou et al. 2016).
The Asian species Schistosoma japonicum, which was first described in the year
1847 by Fujii and was later confirmed by the German guest professor von Baelz
(1849–1913) in the year 1883, has now been documented in many Asian regions
(Agrawal 2012; Cao et al. 2016; Grys 2016; Wu 2016; Zhong et al. 2014). The living
adult worms appear yellow or yellowish-brownish. The males measure 1.2 cm by
0.5 mm, while females reach a size of 2 cm in length, but only 0.4 mm in width. The
females of this species are extremely fertile, since they produce up to 3000 eggs per
day, while the females of the African species S. mansoni excrete only about 300 eggs
per day and thus have a much lower fecundity (Becker and Mehlhorn 1980; Gönnert
1955; Gönnert and Andrews 1977; Mehlhorn et al. 1982, 1983; Gryseels et al. 2000).
1 Schistosomes: Trematode Worms That Endanger Still Today Millions of. . . 7
Fig. 1.4 Electron micrograph of a section through the surface of an adult Schistosoma worm
showing the electron-dense surface coat. The noncellular tegument and the protruding spine (hook)
are colored in gray
The disease symptoms due to infections with S. japonicum and the related species
S. mekongi and S. malayi appear as follows:
– Cercarial dermatitis at sites, where the cercariae have entered, occurs as skin
inflammations within a few days (Fig. 1.11).
– Initial relapsing fever (also called Katayama fever; see Fujii 1847; Ishii et al.
2003) starts after an incubation period of about 4–7 weeks accompanied by
swellings of liver and spleen as well as considerable abdominal pain.
– Bloody stools may occur about 30–40 days after infection.
– Chronic symptoms (diarrhea, obstipation, repeated inflammations, intestinal
polyps) are found 3–6 months after the infection.
– Liver granuloma, liver swellings, and fibrosis follow as well as lung and brain
symptoms and may become extremely severe (Hams et al. 2013; Grimes et al.
2015; Chuah et al. 2014; Gryseels et al. 2000).
Recognizing the potentially huge death rates due to schistosomiasis, many Asian
countries have long since started intense activities to eliminate these parasites. After
initiating such intense control measurements in the year 1978, Japan succeeded
finally in the year 1996 to eliminate these parasites practically in all regions (Tanaka
and Tsuji 1997). As Zhongdao Wu reported in 2016, China also started very early
8 H. Mehlhorn
Fig. 1.5 Light micrographs of the eggs of four important Schistosoma species (from left
S. mansoni, S. japonicum, S. intercalatum, and S. haematobium)
such intense activities to reach the goal to eliminate this risk of deadly infections in
those 12 provinces, where many human cases permanently occurred. Although
considerable reduction rates have been reached and today only people in five main
regions remain endangered, huge efforts are still needed to eliminate this parasite
1 Schistosomes: Trematode Worms That Endanger Still Today Millions of. . . 9
Fig. 1.6 (a, b) Scanning electron micrographs of a Schistosoma miracidium larva with the full set
of cilia (left) and after removal in order to show the borders of the surface cells (right). AP Apical
papilla, C Cilia, PL Plate cells of the tegument
10 H. Mehlhorn
from the Chinese map (Gray et al. 2014; Li et al. 2014; Xu et al. 2015; Zou and Ruan
2015; Zhong et al. 2014). Since schistosomes are still common in some countries
surrounding China and in faraway countries like those in Africa, where Chinese
workers stay for longer periods, reimport of these worms is constantly possible,
especially in the present times of intense globalization. Thus, a constant monitoring
is needed to avoid an increase of imported schistosomiasis cases and thus to block
new infections in clean regions. Bird schistosomes (Table 1.3) may induce inflam-
mations in human skin, leading to severe itching (Fig. 1.11).
Since the 1980s, praziquantel (Fig. 1.12) has been shown to be active against all
Schistosoma species by disturbing the energy metabolism of the worms (Gönnert
1955; Gönnert and Andrews 1977; Liu et al. 2011; Becker and Mehlhorn 1980;
1 Schistosomes: Trematode Worms That Endanger Still Today Millions of. . . 11
Table 1.2 Important Schistosoma species in vertebrate animals—some may occur in humans or at
least may enter as cercariae the human skin
Size ♀ Intermediate host:
Species mm snails Final hosts
Schistosoma bovis 12–32 Bulinus spp. Cattle, sheep, camels, rodents, mon-
keys, humans
S. curassoni 15–25 Bulinus spp. Ruminants
S. indicum 10–25 Indoplanorbis spp. Ruminants, camels
S. spindale 10–16 Indoplanorbis spp. Ruminants
S. nasale 10–12 Indoplanorbis spp. Ruminants
Orientobilharzia 8–10 Lymnaea spp. Ruminants, horses, camels
turkestania
Heterobilharzia 10–18 Lymnaea spp. Racoons, lynx, roe deer, dog, opossum
americana
12 H. Mehlhorn
Fig. 1.9 Light micrograph of a section through liver tissues showing a shrunk egg (due to
preparation) of Schistosoma mansoni
Mehlhorn et al. 1981, 1983; Mehlhorn 2016; Wu 2016; Zhong et al. 2014. Recent
tests in China have proven that the combination of praziquantel (PZQ) and
artemether will help to close the gap in treatment, if praziquantel alone should
reduce activity.
Incubation period
S. japonicum 2–3 weeks
S. mansoni 2–3 weeks
S. intercalatum 4–7 weeks
S. haematobium 2–20 months
1 Schistosomes: Trematode Worms That Endanger Still Today Millions of. . . 13
Fig. 1.10 Macrophoto of the bladder wall of a person being infected with Schistosoma
haematobium. Eggs passing the bladder wall lead to bleedings finally seen in the urine
Prepatent period
S. japonicum 4–5 weeks
S. mansoni 4–7 weeks
S. intercalatum 6–8 weeks
S. haematobium 8–12 weeks
Patent period
All human Schistosoma species: 5–20 years
Schistosoma genome
– Nuclear genome size: 270 Mb
– Chromosomes: 8 pairs (¼ 7 pairs autosomes, 1 pair sex chromosomes)
– Male ZZ
– Female ZW (¼ heterogametic)
– Gene copies: ~14,000
– Repetitive content: 40–60%
– Mitochondrial genome: 14,500 nucleotides
14 H. Mehlhorn
Fig. 1.11 Skin reactions of this type occur after penetration of cercariae
Zhong F, Liu C, Zhang X (2014) Guideline adherence for the treatment of advanced schistosomiasis
japonica in Hubei, China. Parasitol Res 113:4535–4541
Zhou XN, Li SZ, Utzinger J, Bergquist R (eds) (2016) Schistosomiasis in the People’s Republic of
China: from control to elimination. Elsevier, Oxford
Zou L, Ruan S (2015) Schistosomiasis transmission and control in China. Acta Trop 143:51–57
Chapter 2
The History and Experiences
of Schistosomiasis Control in China
Zhongdao Wu
Abstract This chapter looks at the history of the spreading of a very important life-
threatening disease, which in former times was named bilharziasis, but now it is
called schistosomiasis referring to the Greek terms schistos ¼ divided and
soma ¼ body, which describes the fact that the male worm covers the female
lifelong.
China is a civilization of more than 5000 years, both ancient and modern country. It
is located in Asia and its territory lies between latitudes 18 and 54 N, and longi-
tudes 73 and 135 E. The landscapes vary significantly across its vast width. In the
east, along the shores of the Yellow Sea and the East China Sea, there are extensive
and densely populated alluvial plains, while on the edges of the Inner Mongolian
plateau in the north, broad grasslands predominate. Southern China is dominated by
hills and low mountain ranges, while the central-east hosts the deltas of China’s two
major rivers, the Yellow River and the Yangtze River. Other major rivers include the
Pearl River, Mekong, Brahmaputra, and Amur. China’s climate is mainly dominated
by dry seasons and wet monsoons, which lead to pronounced temperature differ-
ences between winter and summer. In the winter, northern winds coming from high-
latitude areas are cold and dry; in summer, southern winds from coastal areas at
lower latitudes are warm and moist. The climate in China differs from region to
region because of the country’s highly complex topography.
Z. Wu (*)
Department of Parasitology, Zhongshan School of Medicine, Guangzhou, People’s Republic of
China
e-mail: wuzhd@mail.sysu.edu.cn
Schistosomiasis was endemic in China and its history can be traced back to
2000 years ago. In the 1970s, the eggs of Schistosoma japonicum from the
mummy of the western Han dynasty tombs in Hubei Jiangling and Hunan were
discovered (in liver, gut). This finding confirms the epidemic history of schistoso-
miasis in China for at least 2100 years. Although the Chinese traditional medicine
carried out a certain amount of research and exploration of schistosomiasis, due to
the limitations of science and technology at that time, there was a lack of systematic
research on the etiology, pathogenesis, and treatment of the disease. Only symptoms
of the disease have left some records in the books of traditional Chinese medicine. It
was not earlier than 1905, when Logan, a physician at Changde Guangde Hospital,
discovered Japanese schistosomiasis eggs in an 18-year-old farmer’s stool samples
and reported the case in a professional magazine (Chinese Medical Journal of
English, 1905, 19: 243–245). Later, foreign and Chinese medical pioneers did
some investigations on schistosomiasis and gradually mastered the basic situation
of schistosomiasis epidemic.
The data show that the schistosomiasis endemic areas are situated along the
Yangtze River and in the southern regions including Jiangsu, Zhejiang, Anhui,
Jiangxi, Hunan, Hubei, Shanghai, Sichuan, Yunnan, Fujian, Guangdong, and
12 Guangxi provinces (autonomous regions and municipalities directly under the
central government), whose endemic areas were north to Baoying County of Jiangsu
province (north latitude 33 150 ), south to Yulin City of Guangxi (north latitude 22
50 ), east to Shanghai Nanhui (east longitude 121 510 ), and west to Yunlong County
of Yunnan province (east Longitude 99 500 ). The lowest elevation of the regions
was zero (Shanghai), nd highest was up to 3000 m (Yunnan province). From
Yichang of Hubei province to the lower sites of the Yangtze River in the Shanghai
regions, the endemic areas were closely connected, while the other endemic areas
were scattered or completely isolated. The prevalence of schistosomiasis seriously
jeopardized the general health of the local population and destroyed many villages in
the endemic areas. Therefore, Chairman Mao described in a poem “Thousands of
village people left the house, ten thousand ghosts are singing.” This is exactly the
true portrayal of schistosomiasis in old China.
After the founding of People’s Republic of China, the government has profoundly
realized the dangers of schistosomiasis. In the summer of 1955, Chairman Mao
presided and the Central Committee proposed that the central government has to set
up a leading group for the prevention and treatment of schistosomiasis and called for
“the elimination of schistosomiasis.” This was the starting point of the schistosomiasis
control in China (Thirteen-Five National Schistosomiasis Control Program).
For more than 50 years, with the high attention and leadership of the CPC Central
Committee and the State Council, with the close cooperation of relevant depart-
ments, schistosomiasis control measurements made remarkable achievements. First,
the endemic areas were gradually staged. Starting 1995, among 12 epidemic prov-
inces (autonomous regions and municipalities), schistosomiasis was controlled in
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
of Cortés, that he had come of his own free-will, and at the intimation
of the gods, to stay awhile with his guests. He told them to calm the
people with this assurance, and to disperse the gathering.
FOOTNOTES
[490] They had now been four days in Mexico, without going farther than the
palace, says Bernal Diaz. A page named Orteguilla, who had already acquired a
smattering of Aztec, was sent with the interpreters to ask this favor. Hist. Verdad.,
69.
[491] Soldiers who had been in Rome and Constantinople declared that never had
they seen so large and orderly a market, with so large an attendance. Bernal Diaz
indicates the site of the plaza to have been where the church of Santiago de
Tlatelulco was erected, and this still remains under the same name, over a mile
north-west-by-north of the central plaza of Mexico. Hist. Verdad., 70-1. The old
maps of Mexico already spoken of give the same site, and Alaman’s investigations
point out correctly the street which led and leads to it, although he has failed to
notice the above authorities, which give the very site. Disert., ii. 282-5.
[492] It has been generally accepted that the temple in the centre of the city was
visited, but Bernal Diaz, who is the only narrator of this excursion, states distinctly,
in several places, that the pyramid ascended was situated in the Tlatelulco
market-place, ‘adonde está aora señor Santiago, que se dize el Tlatelulco.’ Hist.
Verdad., 70-1. The description of the temple court and interior is somewhat
confused, and evidently combines points which belong to the central temple.
[494] Bernal Diaz, Hist. Verdad., 70-1. Sigüenza y Góngora, the well-known
Mexican scholar of the seventeenth century, follows Bernal Diaz. Anotaciones
Crit., MS., 1-2.
[496] He refers to this promise in the second letter to the king, saying, ‘porque
certifiqué á V. A. que lo habria preso ó muerto ó súbdito.’ Cortés, Cartas, 52.
[497] ‘En la verdad era así é lo tinien acordado,’ affirms Tapia, Rel., in Icazbalceta,
Col. Doc., ii. 579. ‘Estas nueuas, falsas, o verdaderas,’ is the non-committing
phrase of Gomara. Hist. Mex., 123. Ixtlilxochitl takes firmer ground. ‘According to
an original letter in my possession, signed by the three heads of New Spain, and
written to his Majesty the emperor, our master, they exculpate Motecuhzoma and
the Mexicans of this and other charges, declaring them inventions of the
Tlascaltecs and of some Spaniards who feared that they would never see the hour
when they might leave the city and place in security the riches they had obtained.’
Hist. Chich., 296. Clavigero adopts the view that Cortés called for such testimony
from certain chiefs among his allies, whose dislike of the Mexicans would be sure
to prompt it. ‘Per giustificar vieppiù il suo attentato, e muovere i suoi Spagnuoli ad
eseguirlo, fece chiamar parecchie persone principali de’ suoi alleati (la cui
informazione dovrebbe sempre essergli sospettosa).’ Storia Mess., iii. 90-1.
Vetancurt has a story that, a drought prevailing at the time, the Spaniards induced
the heavens by means of masses and prayers to send rain. This made the priests
and idols jealous, and the emperor was prevailed on to rid himself of the
Spaniards. The Tlascaltecs learned of the plot and reported it. Teatro, pt. iii. 130.
[498] According to Bernal Diaz the members of this council suggested not only the
seizure but the reasons for it. Cortés responded that he had not been oblivious of
the danger, but saw not how the seizure could be effected. The captains proposed
to beguile the prince to their quarter and detain him. If Cortés hesitated they were
willing to undertake the task. The old soldier is evidently misled, as he was in the
scuttling affair, to assume too much credit for himself and his fellow-soldiers.
Cortés had no doubt adopted his common tactics, so frequently admitted by
Bernal Diaz himself, of inspiring his comrades to suggest what he had resolved
on. This is proved by the promise made to the emperor in his first letter, four
months before, to capture Montezuma.
[499] Bernal Diaz, Hist. Verdad., 73, followed by a number of other writers, states
that the letter was received at Mexico the morning after this meeting, but it has
been shown that he must be wrong. He mentions as one of the statements in the
letter that the Totonacs were in revolt, and it is probable that Cortés may have said
so to show the soldiers that retreat was cut off, and that seizure was the only
recourse.
[501] The neglect of this less speedy plan does indicate that the rumors of danger
were credited to a great extent at least.
[502] Hist. Verdad., 74. Cortés in his quiet way writes to the king that, after
passing six days in the great city, and finding that for various reasons ‘it suited the
royal interest and our safety to have this lord in my power, and not wholly at liberty,
lest he change in the proposal and desire manifested to serve Y. H.... I resolved to
seize and place him in the quarter where I was.’ Cartas, 88-9.
[503] ‘Mandó que su gente dos á dos ó cuatro á cuatro se fuesen tras él ... é con
él entramos hasta treinta españoles é los demas quedaban á la puerta de la casa,
é en un patio della,’ says Tapia, who appears to have been one of those who
entered. Rel., in Icazbalceta, Col. Doc., ii. 579.
[504] ‘Cõ armas secretas,’ says Gomara, Hist. Mex., 123, and probably they did
bear extra weapons beneath their cloaks.
[505] ‘Y otras hijas de señores á algunos de mi compañía.’ Cortés, Cartas, 89. But
the customary mark of favor was to give them from his harem. See Native Races,
ii.
[506] ‘Per non dar disgusto al Re, e per avere occasione di farla Cristiana,’ is
Clavigero’s excuse for the acceptance. Storia Mess., iii. 93. Brasseur de
Bourbourg, and some other writers, assume that Cortés declined; but the original
authorities all say or intimate that he accepted. Even Cortés himself writes in his
letter to the emperor, ‘despues ... de haberme él dado algunas joyas de oro y una
hija suya,’ etc. Cartas, 89. ‘Le persuadió,’ says Ixtlilxochitl, Hist. Chich., 290.
Gomara is even more explicit, and Herrera says that Montezuma insisted, ‘porque
queria tener nietos de hombre tan valeroso.’ dec. ii. lib. viii. cap. ii. The affair is
perhaps less important in itself than as index to the character of Cortés, who could
accept so intimate an offer with one hand while he prepared a blow with the other.
It might also be made to indicate that Montezuma could have had no base designs
against him when he made the uncalled-for offer of intrusting a daughter (if such
she was) to his keeping. Still the imperial character would not have suffered had it
been shown that this was but an artifice to lull his intended victim into a false
security.
[507] Some authors, like Herrera and Torquemada, say that he denied all
knowledge of the occurrence, calling it an invention of enemies.
[508] Ixtlilxochitl, Hist. Chich., 297. ‘Q̄ tenia la figura de Vitzilopuchtli,’ Gomara,
123; and so says Bernal Diaz. Tapia states that Montezuma told Cortés to send
two Spaniards with the messengers; but he doubtless declined to risk two lives on
such a trip. Rel., in Icazbalceta, Col. Doc., ii. 583-4.
[509] ‘Ingrato rey!’ exclaims Gallo, in commenting upon this surrender of a devoted
officer. Hombres Ilust. Mex., i. 318.
[510] Bernal Diaz makes Cortés accuse the emperor of perfidy, and of having
instigated the Cholula massacre. Hist. Verdad., 74. But this he would hardly do,
since his purpose was clearly to persuade, not to arouse anger.
[511] ‘No querria començar guerra, ni destruir aquesta Ciudad ... que si alboroto, ò
vozes daua, que luego sereis muerto de aquestos mis Capitanes, que no los
traigo para otro efeto,’ is Bernal Diaz’ blunt version. Hist. Verdad., 74.
[512] ‘Auia tenido platica de su idolo Huichilobos ... que convenia para su salud, y
guardar su vida, estar con nosotros.’ Id., 75.
[513] ‘Estuuieron mas de media hora en estas platicas.’ Id., 74. Tapia and others
say four hours, which is unlikely.
[514] ‘Porque mas vale que desta vez asseguremos nuestras vidas, ò las
perdamos.’ Bernal Diaz, Hist. Verdad., 75.
[515] ‘Era, ó muy falto de ánimo, ó pusilánime, ó muy prudente.’ Oviedo, iii. 289.
‘En él se cumplió lo que de él se decia, que todo hombre cruel es cobarde,
aunque á la verdad, era ya llegada la voluntad de Dios.’ Ixtlilxochitl, Rel., 411.
[516] Bernal Diaz intimates clearly enough that no demonstration was made till
after his arrival. Hist. Verdad., 75. And so does Cortés. ‘Llorando lo tomaron en
ella [the litter] con mucho silencio, y así nos fuimos hasta el aposento donde
estaba, sin haber alboroto en la ciudad, aunque se comenzó á mover. Pero sabido
por el dicho Muteczuma, envió a mandar que no lo hubiese; y así, hubo toda
quietud.’ Cartas, 90. Ixtlilxochitl, however, allows Montezuma to stay long enough
in his palace, after ordering the litter, to enable the lords and nobles to come and
offer their services. A delay like this, which the Spaniards certainly never could
have permitted, might have given time for the tumultuous gathering which he
describes. Hist. Chich., 297. Prescott, in following this version, makes the emperor
so far overstep his usual dignity as to ‘call out’ to the people to disperse. ‘Tambien
detuvieron consigo á Itcuauhtzin, gobernador del Tlatilulco,’ says Sahagun, while
the leading nobles ‘cuando fue preso Mocthecuzoma le desampararon y se
escondieron.’ Hist. Conq., 25.
The seizure has, like the equally prominent episodes of the massacre at
Cholula, and the scuttling of the fleet, aroused no little comment in justification or
condemnation. ‘Now that I am old,’ says Bernal Diaz, ‘I stop to consider the heroic
deeds then performed, and I do say that our achievements were not effected by
ourselves, but were all brought about by God; for what men have existed in the
world who, less than 450 soldiers in number, dared to enter into so strong a city as
Mexico, larger than Venice, and so remote from Castile, to seize so great a lord?’
Hist. Verdad., 76. ‘Never Greek or Roman, nor of other nation, since kings exist,
performed a like deed, only Fernando Cortés, to seize Motecçuma, a king most
powerful, in his own house, in a place most strong, amid an infinity of people,
while possessing but 450 companions.’ Gomara, Hist. Mex., 124. Commenting on
this, Torquemada adds that ‘it was indeed a deed for daring never seen, and must
be attributed to God rather than to human heart.’ i. 458. Solis of course fails not to
extol the genius and daring of his hero, whose deed ‘appears rather in the light of
a fable’ than in consonance with simple history. Hist. Mex., i. 448. ‘A deed which
makes one tremble even to conceive, and much more to carry out. But God had
so determined it.’ Ixtlilxochitl, Hist. Chich., 296. ‘History contains nothing parallel to
this event, either with respect to the temerity of the attempt, or the success of the
execution,’ etc. Robertson’s Hist. Am., ii. 60. ‘An expedient, which none but the
most daring spirit, in the most desperate extremity, would have conceived.’
Prescott’s Mex., ii. 159. ‘An unparalleled transaction. There is nothing like it, I
believe, in the annals of the world.’ Helps’ Cortés, ii. 351. Clavigero is less carried
away by the incident, for he sees therein the hand of God. Nevertheless, he
sympathizes with Montezuma. Storia Mess., iii. 95, etc. Pizarro y Orellana finds
the deed eclipsed by the similar achievement, with a smaller force, under his
namesake Pizarro. Varones Ilvstres, 89-90. And later Mexican writers, like
Bustamante, see, naturally enough, nothing but what is detestable in the incident,
for according to the native records which form their gospel, Montezuma was
guiltless of any base intents. Unfortunately for them, these very records paint him
a blood-thirsty despot who punishes the slightest offence against himself, even
when merely suspected, with the most atrocious cruelty; one who is continually
seeking his aggrandizement at the expense of inoffensive, peace-loving tribes,
who oppresses not only conquered peoples, but his own subjects, with
extortionate taxes and levies to satisfy his inordinate appetite for pomp and for
new conquests. These records also admit that he had repeatedly sent sorcerers, if
not armies, to entrap and destroy the Spaniards. He who looked calmly on
hecatombs of his own subjects, slaughtered before his very eyes, would not
hesitate to condemn strangers for plotting against the throne which was dearer to
him than life itself. The Spaniards may have anticipated events considerably, but
there is no doubt that numerous personages, from Cuitlahuatzin downward, were
bitterly opposed to their enforced guests, and they would sooner or later have
realized the rumors which the allies began to circulate. Placed as he was, Cortés’
duty to himself, to the men intrusted to him, to his king, and to the cause of
religion, as then regarded, required him to give heed to such rumors, and, after
weighing their probability, to take the precautionary measure of seizing the
monarch, since retreat not only appeared fraught with disaster and dishonor, but
would be regarded as a neglect of opportunity and of duty. With Cortés, naught but
the first steps in assuming the conquest, and in usurping certain credit and means,
can be regarded as crimes, and the former of these was forced upon him by
circumstances of his age and surroundings. Every project, then, conceived by him
for the advancement of his great undertaking must redound to his genius as
soldier and leader. Of course, among these projects appear many which did not
advance the great object, and which must be condemned. But where do we find
greatness wholly free from stain?
CHAPTER XVIII.
DOUBLY REFINED DEALINGS.
1519-1520.