Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Textbook Spirituality Sport and Doping More Than Just A Game Tracy J Trothen Ebook All Chapter PDF
Textbook Spirituality Sport and Doping More Than Just A Game Tracy J Trothen Ebook All Chapter PDF
Textbook Spirituality Sport and Doping More Than Just A Game Tracy J Trothen Ebook All Chapter PDF
https://textbookfull.com/product/religion-and-human-enhancement-
death-values-and-morality-1st-edition-tracy-j-trothen/
https://textbookfull.com/product/game-design-workshop-fourth-
edition-tracy-fullerton/
https://textbookfull.com/product/more-than-human-1st-edition-
jamie-lorimer/
https://textbookfull.com/product/more-than-a-phoenix-phoenix-
brothers-2-1st-edition-ashlyn-chase-chase/
Game Design Workshop A Playcentric Approach to Creating
Innovative Games 5th Edition Tracy Fullerton
https://textbookfull.com/product/game-design-workshop-a-
playcentric-approach-to-creating-innovative-games-5th-edition-
tracy-fullerton/
https://textbookfull.com/product/growling-for-more-grayslake-
more-than-mated-universe-30-1st-edition-alexa-riley/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-spell-of-the-sensuous-
perception-and-language-in-a-more-than-human-world-abram/
https://textbookfull.com/product/true-believer-hubert-humphrey-s-
quest-for-a-more-just-america-1st-edition-traub/
https://textbookfull.com/product/hiking-the-grand-canyon-a-
detailed-guide-to-more-than-100-trails-john-annerino/
SPRINGER BRIEFS IN RELIGIOUS STUDIES
BRIEFS IN RELIGION AND SPORT
Tracy J. Trothen
Spirituality,
Sport, and
Doping: More
than Just a
Game
SpringerBriefs in Religious Studies
Series editors
Eric Bain-Selbo, Western Kentucky University, Bowling Green, KY, USA
D. Gregory Sapp, Stetson University, DeLand, FL, USA
More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/13810
Tracy J. Trothen
Spirituality, Sport,
and Doping: More than
Just a Game
123
Tracy J. Trothen
School of Religion and School
of Rehabilitation Therapy
Queen’s University
Kingston, ON, Canada
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Switzerland AG
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Preface
I love sport. I invest a lot in it. Sport is spiritual for me. I usually hesitate or qualify
these statements. Especially as an ordained minister and professor of ethics and
theology, I want to be careful about how I describe the relationship between
spirituality and sport. In this short book, I make the case that sport is spiritual for
some athletes and fans.
I ask what difference sport’s spirituality makes to the use of science and tech-
nology in sport. Like so many sports fans, I am troubled by doping scandals and the
relentless pursuit of winning at any cost. What does it really mean to make sport
better? What does spirituality have to do with doping and other ways of improving
sports performances?
In my 2015 book on sport and enhancements, I introduce the question of what a
reframing of the sport enhancement ethics debate might look like if sport’s spiritual
dimension is taken seriously. In this book, I shift the discussion to the reciprocal
relationship between sport enhancement use and spirituality.
I write this as a United Church of Canada minister, a registered psychotherapist with
the College of Registered Psychotherapists of Ontario (CRPO) specializing in spiritual
health, and professor of ethics and Christian theology in religious studies and reha-
bilitation therapy. For much of my career, I have tried to keep these aspects of my
identity separate. Only recently have I begun to understand the wisdom of some of my
mentors in encouraging me to bring these aspects together more deliberately as
intertwined resources. A psychotherapeutic perspective added depth to my ethical
analysis. My commitment to spirituality and to the value of discovering the divine in
multiple areas of life helped shape this book. I hope that my musings help the reader to
reimagine sport enhancement ethics as we contemplate the meaning of sport.
I am a firm believer in the value of sport, in spite of the distortions that twist
sport into over-the-top violence or take the joy and fun out of it. But all aspects of
life, including religion and sport, are like that: They can get twisted and abusive,
emptied of goodness. This is why it is so very important to examine our value base
and desires deliberately and critically. While it is easy to go along for the ride, the
rapid expansion of sport enhancement options carries a tidal wave of values that
threaten to drown marginalized values, including spirituality. People can and do
v
vi Preface
experience spirituality in sport. If sport has a sacred dimension, we need to ask how
growing technological innovations affect not only sports performances but expe-
riences of sport as sacred. What difference does it might make to the enhancement
debate if sport’s spirituality is taken seriously?
Athletes have long used technology and science to improve their perfor-
mances including lightweight tennis racquets, biodynamic running shoes, training
regimes, caffeine, banned substances such as EPO and anabolic steroids. Now we are
on the verge of new possibilities, including gene editing, robots, stem cell therapies,
and moral bioenhancements. How might these innovations affect sport’s spiritual
dimension?
Before I begin, a few words of explanation are in order regarding my word choice.
I have chosen to use the term “doping” in the title of this book. “Doping” is the term we
know best, on a popular level, to describe sport enhancement use. I had to wrestle with
this choice because doping does not describe all enhancements and doping has a
pejorative meaning. Not all enhancements are banned, not all administered as a pill or
by injection, and not all are bad. “Enhancement” is a much more inclusive term but it is
fraught, too, with value problems; not every enhancement makes sport better. And
“enhancement” is not yet a term familiar to everyone. I decided to begin with the
familiar term—doping—complicate it, and shift to a complicated understanding
of “enhancement.” I also want to point out my decision to use the term “athlete.”
Sometimes I substitute “sports participant” for “athlete” because many of us see
“athlete” as an exclusive, privileged term to describe only those who are highly skilled
at their sport. I can hesitate to claim that I am an athlete because sometimes I struggle
to see myself as good enough to warrant that title. But when I stand back and think
about it, we can all be athletes through dedicated participation in sport. We do not have
to be among the elite, but we do have to be committed and do our best.
I begin, in Chap. 1, with psychologist Kenneth I. Pargament’s research and finding
that people can perceive the sacred in many aspects of life. Pargament does not make
ontological claims about the sacred. Instead, his research is about the qualities that
facilitate perceptions of the sacred, and the everyday life implications of discovering the
sacred. I apply his finding to sport and show that it is very possible for people to
discover the sacred in sport. I propose that the discovery of the sacred in sport can
be expressed in the hope experienced in sport. Theological insights help us to consider
the significance of intentionality as a needed aspect of sport’s spirituality. Chapter 2
identifies several possible sport enhancements and distills five ethical issues regarding
the use of these enhancements. We are then positioned to consider possible implica-
tions of sport enhancement use for the sacred in Chap. 3 by revisiting hope in sport.
Beginning with a tragic Canadian sports story, in Chap. 4 I pose the reciprocal
question, asking what implications an awareness, valuing, and prioritizing of sport’s
spiritual dimension might have on the sport enhancement ethics debate. To explore this
reciprocal question, I go back to the five ethical issues identified in Chap. 2.
Intentionality, values, and critical self-reflexivity emerge as key concepts throughout
the book.
This book grew out of a longer volume (Winning the race? Religion, hope, and
reshaping the sport enhancement debate, 2015) that I wrote for the Sport and
Religion Series by Mercer University Press. Readers of Winning the Race? will see
some continuation of the themes from that book in this one. They will also notice
important new directions, especially the application of a psychological approach to
spirituality, from my perspective as a theological ethicist and psychotherapist. I am
grateful to the people who have encouraged me (sometimes mercilessly) to engage
both these aspects of my identity in my writing.
I am indebted to many people. Thanks go to the people at Springer for the
encouragement and assistance in the creation of this monograph. I am particularly
grateful to the editors of this series, Eric Bain-Selbo and Gregory Sapp, and to the
anonymous peer reviewer, for their thoughtful feedback. Without a six-month
sabbatical leave from Queen’s University, this book would not have been possible.
A few very good friends have generously read over drafts of these chapters. Others
have encouraged this project and suffered through several conversations about
enhancements, spirituality, and sport. Barb, Lynne, Lois, Calvin, Ian, Marie, and, of
course, Sophia and Gwen, I owe you many thanks. Your insights and suggestions
have been invaluable. As always, any mistakes remaining are mine alone.
Most important has been the support of my husband and best friend, Ron.
While I find the sacred in sport, I find it most in my faith and in my closest
relationships. This one is dedicated to you, Ron.
vii
Contents
ix
Chapter 1
Spirituality and Sport: Searching
for the Sacred
Abstract This chapter explores the meaning of spirituality, focusing on the research
of psychologist Kenneth I. Pargament. The sacred is characterized by the qualities of
transcendence, ultimacy, boundlessness, interconnectedness, and spiritual emotions.
When the sacred is discovered in sport, there are implications for one’s life. These
implications and sacred qualities are examined as they may occur in five locations
of hope in sport. This chapter demonstrates that multifaceted hope can be a mani-
festation of the sacred in sport by showing that sacred qualities and implications of
finding the sacred are experienced in the five locations of hope. In short, sport has a
spiritual dimension.
it can be a place where the sacred is discovered through the multifaceted presence
of hope. In this way, the concept of hope overlaps with the concept of spirituality.
Pastoral theologian Pamela R. McCarroll carried out an in-depth study of hope,
investigating fifty-two articles and thirty books published between 1976 and 2011 that
addressed the topic of hope. These sources came from several disciplines, including
theology, philosophy, psychology and health care (McCarroll 2014, p. 19). She found
that there was no consensus regarding the meaning of hope. Hope has been understood
as an internal dispositional quality and also as transcendent. Hope can be about the
pursuit of varied goals and outcomes—some specific and concrete, and others more
open-ended. McCarroll describes hope as being about relationship with self, others
(community), creation, and the transcendent. Interestingly, these domains of hope
mirror many understandings of the domains of spirituality, which is also a very
difficult concept to define.1 Based on careful analysis of these many understandings
of hope, McCarroll proposes the following broad definition of hope: “Hope is the
experience of the opening of horizons of meaning and participation in relationship
to time, other human and nonhuman beings, and/or the transcendent” (p. 48) In this
chapter, I am interested in hope as a manifestation of spirituality when spirituality is
understood as the search for the sacred (Pargament 2013a).
Sport can inspire hope in at least five different ways, which will be discussed
later in this chapter: winning, anticipation, and losing; star athletes and “my team”;
perfect moments; embodied connections and possibilities of just communities; and
flow states which can be experienced by the athlete and by fans (Trothen 2015). I
suggest that these sources of hope in sport each can be manifestations of spirituality
as a search for the sacred (Pargament 2013a). In other words, I discuss how the
discovery of sacred may be manifest in each of these locations of hope.2
Some see claims of sport’s spirituality or religiosity as idolatrous (Higgs and Braswell
2004) or inaccurate (Chandler 1992, p. 57), while others see these claims as very
fitting (for example, Price 2006; Ellis 2014; Trothen 2015). Part of the reason for this
disagreement are differences in understandings of secular and religious. If the secular
and the religious are understood as mutually exclusive, and if spirituality is seen
as restricted to institutional religions, then sport and other pop-culture phenomena
cannot be spiritual.
1 For example, Fisher (2011) proposes four domains of spirituality: the personal domain, the com-
munal domain, the environmental domain (connecting with nature), and the transcendental domain
(“relating to some-thing or some-One beyond the human level”).
2 I write as a Canadian and often use sports examples from the Canadian context. Since most
publications on sport, religion, and spirituality are written by scholars in the United States and
the United Kingdom, examples from sports in these countries are more common. My hope is that
examples from countries such as Canada that appear less often in this discipline can generate a more
global sense of sport as it relates to religion and spirituality.
Why a Consideration of Sport as Sacred Is Worthwhile 3
The question of meaning need not be explicitly pursued, but can be lived or expe-
rienced. The implicit quality of spirituality inspired by pop culture, religions, or
both, resist hard-and-fast definitions, just as they open up a multiplicity of ways of
experiencing the sacred.
Part of the problem involved in pinning down what some experience as the com-
plex, powerful, and awe-inspiring qualities of sport is the difficulty of defining spir-
ituality and religion. Instead of starting with definitions of religion and spirituality,
it may be more prudent to start instead with understandings of religion and spiri-
tuality, since the term “understanding” implies a more provisional conception that
is responsive to shifting contexts and new insights. I am persuaded that empirical
studies combined with theoretical research may offer constructive and insightful
approaches to contemporary spirituality, so long as scientism is avoided.3
I have suggested elsewhere that “sport is a secular religion because sport functions
as a communal belief system and it is characterized by the spiritual quality of hope”
(2015, p. 80). I have been drawn to an understanding of sport as a secular religion in
part because this concept implicitly rejects a binary split between the secular and the
religious. I agree with theologians such as Jürgen Moltmann and Mayra Rivera who
see the sacred and the profane, and the religious and the secular, as intersecting and
overlapping. Likewise, I find it compelling because good arguments have been made
for the religious-like function and form, and sometimes content, of sport (for example,
see Bellah 1967; Novak 1967/1994; Albanese 1982; Mathisen 1992; Prebish 1993;
Price 2006; Bain-Selbo 2009; Ellis 2014; Trothen 2015; Bain-Selbo and Sapp 2016).
Notwithstanding the value of these arguments, including my own, that sport can
function similarly to an institutional religion, I am becoming more persuaded that
sport may be better understood in terms of spirituality rather than as a religion. No
matter how strenuously and persuasively counterarguments are made, the concept
3 Scientism assumes arguments or findings and their interpretations as objective fact, camouflaging
the influence of investigators’ values, assumptions, and perspectives. See, for example, an excellent
article by Parry (2005, p. 22). Scientific, evidence-based methods are built on the assumption that
every claim is provisional. Every finding and interpretation may be proven false or limited, otherwise
there would be no need for further inquiry.
4 1 Spirituality and Sport: Searching for the Sacred
4 Historian Nongbri (2013) provides a very readable of religion as a constructed category. Nongbri
points out that the concept of religion is projected onto many ancient cultures, noting that religion
has not been a universal concept. Looking back over the past 2000 years, Nongbri concludes that
the contemporary assumption that religion is about “inner disposition and concern for salvation”
(24) does not apply to antiquity. His analysis supports the notion that through much of antiquity
there was no distinction between the “religious” and the secular. Indeed, it was not until modernity
(the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries) that the category of religion as separate from the secular
emerged. In sum, Nongbri argues that the category of religion has been assumed to be natural and
universal, when it is, in reality, neither.
5 The more recent SBNR (spiritual but not religious) tendency (I stop short of calling it a movement
as this status is not clear) sometimes includes a social justice component, extending well beyond
the self and embracing a value system.
6 See, for example, Simon Robinson’s analysis of this historical backdrop (2007).
Why a Consideration of Sport as Sacred Is Worthwhile 5
7 It
is important to note that contextual factors including individual experiences, social norms and
customs, and cultural features influence what we see as sacred.
6 1 Spirituality and Sport: Searching for the Sacred
8 Bain-Selbo, in his study of southern US college football fans, found that while these fans often
used spiritual or religious terms to describe their football fan experiences, they did not often identify
these experiences directly as religious (Bain-Selbo 2008).
Spirituality as a Search for the Sacred 7
9 Because spiritual emotions such as awe, joy, and gratitude are interwoven throughout the other
four attributes, I do not always explicitly identify spiritual emotions as a distinct attribute.
8 1 Spirituality and Sport: Searching for the Sacred
10 Religious studies scholar Blazer (2012) found that most persuasive understandings of sport as
a religion rely on function (form-based), not substantive (content-based), approaches to religion.
In fact, content-based arguments tend to demonstrate a disjuncture between sport and religion.
Pargament’s substantive and functional approach to spirituality, from a psychological perspective,
provides an alternative lens through which to understand sport’s spiritual dimension.
Spirituality as a Search for the Sacred 9
derive meaning from what is perceived as sacred (Pomerleau et al. 2016, p. 45).
Fourth, sacred objects or experiences are prioritized and become “organizing forces”
in their lives (2013a, pp. 261–262).11 Fifth, “people protect and preserve the sacred
(Pargament et al. 2017, p. 734). And sixth, “people react strongly to loss or violation
of the sacred” (Pargament et al. 2017, p. 734).
I consider how these implications may manifest when one discovers the sacred in
sport. When the locations of hope in sport are examined, the core sacred attributes of
transcendence, ultimacy, boundlessness, interconnectedness, and spiritual emotions
emerge as aspects of hope in sport. In sum, I theorize that Pargament’s research can
help us to appreciate more fully the significance and meaning of sport in the lives of
many followers.
The gold-medal game of the men’s 2010 Olympic hockey game became the most
watched event (of any kind, not only sport) in Canadian history, with 16.6 million
Canadians, almost half of the country’s population, watching the entire game and
26.5 million—about 80% of Canada’s population at the time—watching at least
part of the game (NHL.com 2010). The question of why sport is so important to so
many people has been investigated mainly through psychological, sociological, and
historical lenses. The reasons why people are motivated to follow sport as spectators
or fans are multiple, but most research points to the excitement of competition;
stress relief; connecting with others (for example, social issues of belonging and
identity); aesthetics; and escapism.12 Theologian Robert Ellis, in his 2012 empirical
study of 468 sports spectators and athletes, had similar findings regarding motives
behind both spectating and playing sports: fitness and health (primarily for athletes);
stress relief; social motives; enjoyment of competition and simple enjoyment.13 What
has been ignored in many of these studies, with a very notable exception being
Ellis’s, is the possibility that these motives for watching or participating in sports
may have additional layers that point to a greater driving force. Although competition,
stress relief, social connection, enjoyment, and fitness are persuasive and important
motivators, they do not fully explain the pervasive, powerful attraction of sport. I
agree with Ellis who suggests that spirituality may be the underlying reason why so
many people are drawn to sports.
There are few social scientific research studies that investigate the possible rele-
vance of spirituality or religion to the question of why people follow sport. The two
most notable of such studies suggest that there is indeed a spiritual motivation for
11 This fourth implication is included in all relevant sources in which Pargament is an author, except
14 Pargament explains that there has been a tendency within psychological research to diminish or
deny spirituality as a motivation in and of itself. Instead, motivations for subscribing to a religion
tend to be explained away in “psychological, social, or physiological” terms (2013b, p. 271). Part of
the reason for this overlooking of spirituality as irreducible, Pargament offers, is that psychologists
as a group in the United States are much less theistic than the general population of the country. It
may well be that attempts to understand sports fans’ and athletes’ motivations have been affected
by the same myopia.
15 Elsewhere I have considered the spiritual quality of hope and posit that there are four locations
of hope in sport and that these locations of hope attract both fans and athletes (Trothen 2015,
The Game Is On!—Why Are Sports Such a Big Deal? 11
sions of the discovery of the sacred in sport. To do this, I ask whether Pargament’s
core sacred qualities—transcendence, ultimacy, boundlessness, interconnectedness,
and spiritual emotions—may be present in some people’s perception of sport, and
if the six implications of the discovery of the sacred may be experienced by sports
fans and athletes.
Winning, Losing and Anticipation: We hope to win. We wait with bated breath for
record-breaking performances and personal bests. Even when the odds are stacked
against us, we hope our team will win. In 1992, immediately following the Toronto
Blue Jays’ first World Series win, it is estimated that half a million fans flooded
Yonge Street, from Lake Ontario all the way north to Highway 401. In 2015, when
the Blue Jays won the American League East pennant for the first time since 1993,
fans rejoiced. As one fan tweeted, “22 years. 3559 games. You’re damn right it’s
time to celebrate!”
Part of the fans’ jubilation is the identification that many experience with their
teams. Winning can bring a special sort of hope–validating our loyalties and even
validating ourselves. This psychological dynamic of identification with a team or
individual athlete is called “basking in reflected glory” (BIRG), and is even more
pronounced if the win occurs following a challenge to the individual fan’s self-esteem
(Cialdini et al. 1976). A big win can make it seem as if anything is possible and that
one is on top of the world. If sport is perceived through a sacred lens, the experience
of winning can go even further, imbued with qualities of transcendence, ultimacy,
boundlessness, interconnectedness, and spiritual emotions. The win may take on a
sense of ineffability and hold deeper meaning than meets the eye for the perceiver:
it is not uncommon for a devout fan to feel a lasting sense of vindication or that
they are truly on top of the world because their NHL team won the coveted Stanley
Cup. Also, Pargament’s observation that “perceptions of the sacred appear to act
like an emotional generator,” stimulating feelings of awe, elevation, love, hope, and
gratitude, fits well with the emotions that are generated at sports events particularly at
championship-level competitions in the wake of a win or outstanding performance.
Winning is important and stokes hope and jubilation. Winning, however, is not
required for hope. Fans persist in hoping for a win even in the face of years of losses.
I continue in defiance of much reason to hope that the Toronto Maple Leafs will win
the Stanley Cup, even though they have not won it since 1967. And Chicago Cubs
fans kept rooting for their team despite not winning the World Series from 1908 until
2016, when they finally broke the infamous curse of the Billy Goat!
Losing can be crushing. Philosopher and theologian Michael Novak went so far
as to say that losing in sport can feel like a “death” (1967/1994, p. 153). While there
pp. 115–132). I now suggest that one of the locations of hope that I have identified is better understood
as two separate locations.
12 1 Spirituality and Sport: Searching for the Sacred
has been critique of this description as too extreme (Feezell 2013, p. 70), others have
supported Novak’s contention, arguing that sport is much more than just a game
for followers (Ellis 2012, p. 183). If sport was just a game, fans should be able to
disengage from an unsatisfying or disappointing sports event. Studies show, however,
that fans do not see themselves simply as passive observers: “supporters believe they
can influence what happens” in a competition (Ellis 2014, p. 259).16 Real people,
real dreams, and real struggle are involved; authentic meaning and happiness are not
restricted to dramatic existential moments but seem to be generated through more
temporary and simple “meaningful activities” such as sport for many people (Feezell
2013, p. 193). And if sport is perceived through a sacred lens, wins and losses take
on even greater meaning and significance. As Halifax cartoonist and Toronto Maple
Leaf fan Michael de Adder tweeted on April 26, 2018, “After the Empire Strikes
Back ends, the feeling I had that the Empire was winning and all hope was lost, is
the exact same feeling I have when the Boston Bruins win [and the Toronto Maple
Leafs lost in game seven of the 2018 Conference Quarterfinals].”
Pargament and his colleagues have found that one of the implications that the
discovery of the sacred has for human functioning is a strong reaction to the loss or
violation of the sacred (Pargament et al. 2017, p. 734). When people are not able
to protect and preserve what is sacred to them, through everyday spiritual coping
methods such as the continuation of rituals (eating nachos on game night, wearing the
lucky shirt), sticking to the conviction that they will win next time, or commiserating
with other fans or teammates, a spiritual struggle ensues. In this struggle, one’s beliefs
are either changed or discarded (Pargament 2013b, p. 277). Spiritual struggles are
“typically marked by isolation from God, self, and/or others and involve topics and/or
questioning that are not perceived as socially acceptable” (Faigin et al. 2014, p. 211).
The general expectation is that upset over a big loss, or the news that an athlete has
cheated is passing. For those fans who become depressed or otherwise stuck, social
norms suggest that there is something defective about these individuals. But it may
be that their sense of spiritual meaning has been damaged and they are struggling to
make sense of something that has been sacred to them. The loss is not just a loss;
it represents something more. There are, however, few safe places for people to be
taken seriously and to get help in processing these struggles. Sport is supposedly
“just a game.” We have failed to understand that for some people sport is spiritual,
regardless of whether it is explicitly named as spiritual.
Fans of teams that have lost numerous championships may find it even more
meaningful when they eventually do win; the years of persistence can inculcate
an increased sense of loyalty and community through mutual commiseration. This
shared narrative can open horizons of meaning, which McCarroll proposes form the
basis of hope. A long struggle can make victory sweeter.
Anticipation of the next season, game or moment is an important component of
hope. Winning is very important and it is not all that matters: athletes and fans in
Ellis’s study also reported a “good quality game as important, a strong performance
16 Ellis proposes that sports spectators are more than spectators and have vicarious relationships
with the players, noting that spectators expressed a strong sense of identification with the team.
It’s About Hope 13
from one’s team, a good effort” (Ellis 2014, p. 256). As Pargament asserts, “people
derive more support, strength, and satisfaction from those parts of their lives that
they hold sacred” (Pargament 2013a, p. 261). A loss will not usually compromise the
sacredness of sport; the sport usually will remain a prioritized and organizing force
with game-time being sacrosanct.
Star Athletes and “My Team”: Identification, including BIRG, with a team and
their fan group makes one part of a community; one belongs. Research studies and
anecdotal evidence show that people can find the “support, strength, and satisfaction”
that Pargament outlines as one of the implications of discovering the sacred, by being
part of a sports community (Price 2003, p. 16; McCutcheon et al. 2004, p. 82; Ellis
2012, p. 179).
Fans buy shirts with their favorite team’s logo or player’s number. Posters of
individual athletes and teams adorn walls. Time and money are spent on attending
games and competitions, as per Pargament’s first implication of the discovery of the
sacred: “people invest their resources, including time and money, in these sacred
things.”
Star athletes are regarded by some fans as more than role models; they are seen
as moral exemplars, even though there is no reason to expect exemplary or even
good moral behavior from someone known for the athletic skill alone. Sport does
not necessarily instill good character or virtue; athletes are not better people simply
because they perform their sport well or even superbly. But even when confronted
with incontrovertible proof that an athlete or a sport is not all that he/she/it is per-
ceived to be, the believer will usually find ways to hold fast to their convictions. The
conservation of the sacred is a strong motivating force. People want to hold onto
whatever is sacred to them and will go to some lengths to do so.
There are many spiritual pathways to help conserve or deepen one’s relationship
with the sacred. For people who subscribe to institutional religions, these pathways
may include attending worship services; participating in ritual practices; meditating
or praying; and gathering with others in the faith community. For people who find
the sacred in sport, spiritual pathways may include attending sporting events and
engaging in rituals such as singing the national anthem before a NHL game; making
pilgrimages to sacred sites such as the Hockey Hall of Fame in Toronto; wearing
emblematic clothing such as four-time gold medalist Hayley Wickenheiser’s hockey
number, 22; and gathering with fan communities.
These pathways can fail when one is confronted by what Pargament calls a dis-
orienting issue. For those who perceive the sacred in sport, spiritual disorientation
could be generated by a disruption to hope: a momentous loss, a career-ending injury,
the inability to break records continually, or the revelation that an admired athlete
has used banned substances to stay in the game, break more records, or win. People
react strongly to violations of what is perceived to be sacred.
If sport is sacred to someone and if an athlete who they strongly admire is revealed
to be cheating or otherwise disrespecting the ideals of the game, Pargament and his
colleagues have identified methods that people use to cope with these violations.
Coping methods that conserve the sacred include trying one’s usual spiritual pathways
again, “spiritual meaning-making, seeking spiritual support and connection, and
14 1 Spirituality and Sport: Searching for the Sacred
17 Pastoral theologians have written about embedded and deliberative theologies. See, for example,
Stone and Duke (1996) and Doehring (2015). When a faith conviction is not deliberately examined
and reevaluated in relation to lived experiences, including those of suffering, loss and systemic
injustice, the faith claim may cease to make sense and not hold up in times of extreme stress.
It’s About Hope 15
By giving up his spot, Junio in all probability improved the chances of the Canadian
team winning. Morrison achieved a silver medal in the event. Whether or not athletes
act as moral role models or even exemplars, fans admire their star athletes for their
more-ness, seeing them as symbols of hope and promise because of their exceptional
athletic accomplishments.
Unity and Diversity: At its best, sport does not allow one to forget or devalue
one’s body, emotions, intellect, or spirit. At its worst, sport can promote unnecessary
violence, and athletes can be regarded as mere machines. Mainstream western cul-
ture tends to be either body-denying or body-obsessed. The ethic of winning at any
cost encourages an instrumental approach to the athlete as a body that has utility in
its potential to win. The value of the athlete is reduced to their capacity to compart-
mentalize, utilize, and optimize measurable abilities that can produce a win. On the
other hand, a sports ethic that centers on becoming the best that one can be holds the
potential for the promotion of embodied integrity fostering intrapersonal integration
and growth that may even transcend one’s perceived limits.
Sport also has the potential to celebrate and unite a confluence of people from
diverse racial, ethnic and socio-economic backgrounds. Top-notch athletes with
physical disabilities challenge assumptions about the meaning and limitations of
disability. Hayley Wickenheiser and other women’s Olympic hockey players chal-
lenged gender stereotypes.18 An example of a sports event that helped to unify a very
divided country is the 1995 Rugby World Cup, which was hosted in South Africa
soon after the end of apartheid. Through Nelson Mandela’s inspired leadership, the
country came together, black and white, to support and celebrate their rugby team in
winning the 1995 World Cup. On a less dramatic level, sports events that have been
previously restricted to certain countries or regions are being introduced across the
globe. For example, Toronto Maple Leaf games are broadcasted by Punjabi televi-
sion stations and commentators. Learning more about others through sport creates
more opportunities to develop relationships (Markovits and Albertson 2012).
Sport can be both liberating and oppressive, with athletes, teams, and sports lead-
ers overcoming or reinforcing barriers on the basis of sex, gender, disability, race,
ethnicity, age, and sexual orientation. Theologian Jürgen Moltmann sees the promise
of Olympia, in the expression of protest against barriers, divisiveness, and oppres-
sion: “Olympia will be ‘a symbol of hope’ if its character as protest, as alternative,
and as the prelude to freedom is stressed, in its contrast to burdened everyday life
in the economic, political, and social world. This is a primal human longing” (Molt-
mann 1989, p. 107). When sport is the locus of inclusion, it is a source of “support,
strength, … satisfaction”, and justice, stimulating feelings of awe, elevation, love,
hope, and gratitude.
Sport can be a unifying force, increasing intrapersonal and interpersonal connec-
tion, connection with nature, and connection with the transcendent (Pargament 2007,
pp. 112–113). The development of these relationships contributes to an awareness
of the interdependence of all life and of the possibilities endemic to this interdepen-
18 Some studies suggest that diversity can be promoted effectively in recreational sport, combating
dence. Connectedness is a spiritual attribute (Lomax et al. 2011) that can sustain
hope as the “opening of horizons of meaning and participation” (McCarroll 2014,
p. 48).
Perfect Moments: Perfect athletic moments are liminal: they stand at the thresh-
old of this world and beyond. The “imperfect performer” bridges the gap between the
seemingly possible and impossible. These moments include Dick Fosbury’s remark-
able jump, Nadia Comaneci’s perfect ten in the 1976 Olympic gymnastics, Paul
Henderson’s stunning goal in 1972 Canada-Russia series, and the list goes on. These
inspiring moments of athletic perfection generate feelings of awe, akin to Parga-
ment’s second implication of discovering the sacred.
These perfect sports moments are shared moments that draw a wide community
together through a known narrative. Because international or national level sports
competitions bring together such a large and broad community of people, perfect
moments become part of a shared story that allow many of us to connect with others
outside of our more intimate familial, collegial, and social communities. In Canada,
if you were alive in 1972, it is not uncommon to be drawn into conversations about
where you were when Paul Henderson scored the winning goal in the Summit Series.
This does not mean that there are not other perfect moments in sport that are etched
on one’s heart and mind. However, these perfect moments may not be as recog-
nized and known. For example, your first goal in a new soccer league, or your first
completed marathon. These, too, can be perfect moments filled with the same sense
of transcendence, fulfillment, and boundlessness that was experienced by fans who
witnessed Michael Phelps’ stunning achievement of eight gold medals at the 2008
Olympics.
I use the term perfect instead of excellent, deliberately. Theologian Michael R.
Shafer draws attention to the question of whether it is the sport act or the way it is
done (that is, through effort and/or giftedness) that informs a judgement of perfection
(2016, p. 194). What counts as perfection is difficult if not impossible to pin down. I
use the term perfect to try to capture those sports moments that elicit strong feelings
of riveted awe and amazement, leaving one with bated breath, and even a sense of
suspended time, or boundlessness. In other words, I choose the term perfect to connote
the sports moments that generate strong spiritual emotions including awe, elevation,
hope, and gratitude. These moments are in both continuation and contrast with the
stark ability of sport to exhibit human mistakes, failures, and glory, often within very
brief time passage. These perfect moments must occur within the muddiness and
sometimes ineptitude of raw human effort and amazing human abilities if they are
to generate the awe of which I write.
Is the quest for perfect moments too egocentric to generate an authentic sense
of transcendence? Joseph Price, professor of religion, notes that “[e]ven when the
pursuit of a perfect performance in sport becomes corrupted or distorted—when it
moves toward selfish goals rather than the joy and disclosive possibilities of play
itself—it still manifests a fundamental human desire for fulfillment” (Price 2000,
p. 211). This desire for fulfillment is part of the search for the sacred: the human
desire for something more—for transcendence. Even when motives are more self-
It’s About Hope 17
centered than outwardly oriented, the search for the sacred may well provide the
underlying propulsion.
The biblical Greek understanding of perfection has to do with wholeness, becom-
ing complete (Bain-Selbo and Sapp 2016, p. 144, note 6),19 or, I would suggest,
becoming more fully human. Instead of perceiving strivings for perfection as attempts
to supersede appropriate human limits, or even to become god-like, the quest for per-
fection is perhaps better understood as the quest to be more fully human, embracing
the part of ourselves that is hard-wired for spirituality, including the desire for feel-
ings of awe, elevation, love, hope, and gratitude that follow the discovery of that
which is sacred to us.
What it means to be more fully human is not clear. Athletes can go overboard in the
pursuit of so-called perfection in sport; this best of impulses can become manifested
destructively. Excessive self-violence, for example, is a risk. An overwhelming desire
to be the best can lead to dangerous weight loss or high risk-taking in already extreme
sports such as snow-boarding.
The quest for perfection and the best possible athletic performance is an organiz-
ing principle for many sport fans and athletes. A focus on watching one’s team or
improving our performance and hoping for the ultimate sports moment is a priority
that most are unwilling to give up unless faced with an overwhelming reason. Fit-
tingly, Pargament’s fourth implication of discovering the sacred is that the sacred is
prioritized as an organizing force in one’s life (see, for example, Ellis 2012, p. 179).
Perfect moments generate awe and can offer hope that the almost unimaginable,
the never before achieved, is indeed possible. These moments have the sacred quality
of boundlessness for the believer; they generate a sense of timelessness and “space-
lessness” (Pargament et al. 2017, p. 724). In this way, fans and athletes experience
“more support, strength, and satisfaction” from sport than from parts of their lives
that are not sacred to them. Perfect moments are about hope in that they can open
up horizons of meaning. The witnessing of moments in which human limitations are
transcended suggest the possibility that we can be or do, or participate in, more than
we had thought. This opening of possibilities is part of hope.
Flow: A “flow state,” as coined by psychologist Mihalyi Csikszenthmihalyi, is
characterized partially by total absorption in the experience, the sense that all life
is connected, a strong sense of self and the loss of individual ego. As an athlete in
flow, one is aware of working very hard but also not working at all—some describe
it as being on automatic pilot. Exceptionally strong athletic performances can be
driven by a flow experience. Although conditions for flow have been identified,
flow experiences cannot be induced (Elkington 2010; Jackson and Csikszentmihalyi
1999).
Most studies focus on flow states and the athlete, but the sports fan seems to
experience similar states (Bain-Selbo 2008, p. 9).20 Fans’ euphoria has been variously
19 See Chap. 3 of this title (pp. 51–70) for an in-depth exploration of the perspectives of several
religions on perfection, and the relationship between sport, religion, and perfection.
20 Bain-Selbo argues that “the experience of the religious adherent and the experience of the Southern
college football fan are essentially the same flow experiences; they are simply labeled differently.”
18 1 Spirituality and Sport: Searching for the Sacred
21 Very briefly, these eight elements are: clarity of goals and immediate feedback; a high level of
concentration; a close match between one’s perceived skills and the challenge; a feeling of control;
effortlessness; an altered perception of time; the melting together of action and consciousness; and
the experience of the autotelic quality of the sport. For more explanation and analysis please see
Flow in Sports: The Keys to Optimal Experiences and Performance (Jackson and Csikszentmihalyi
1999). For a fan to experience flow, they would need to identify strongly with the athlete(s); for
example, the fan must be fully convinced that the athlete’s abilities make the athletic challenge
possible but not easily possible.
It’s About Hope 19
but to experience strong emotions as part of a fan wave. These emotions could be
characterized as spiritual—but not necessarily—if sport is spiritual for that person.
If a person sanctifies sport, psychologically, then it is possible for emotions that
one experiences in response to sport as a source of the sacred, to be spiritual, as
understood by Pargament and his research colleagues. For an experienced emotion
to be spiritual, from Pargament’s psychological perspective, the emotion must have
spiritual qualities (e.g. transcendence, ultimacy, boundlessness, and possibly inter-
connectedness). If sport is not spiritual for the individual (i.e. an aspect of life in
which one has discovered the sacred), then the emotions experienced by that indi-
vidual are likely not spiritual if we accept that spiritual emotions are experienced
primarily—and possibly only—in the context of an object or experience that we have
sanctified. It may be that there are more than these four types of fan experiences.
My primary interest is that we recognize that not all emotions experienced by fans
in response to a sports event indicate a flow or spiritual state.
Fueled by strong emotions, sporting event crowds can be violent. Some have
theorized that the violence of sports fans has roots in “personal and political identities
involving economic and ethnic issues,” (O’Gorman 2010, p. 233)22 but other research
refutes this (Wann 1995).23 Studies have found likewise that although crowds can
engage in passive “automatic thinking,” they can also function proactively (Percy
and Taylor 1997, p. 38). So, why choose violence? I suspect that all four types of
emotional wave experiences can manifest in violent, destructive behavior. Regarding
the two types that are related to spirituality, it is important to consider Pargament’s
suggestion that in addition to awe, elevation, love, hope, and gratitude, there may
be “darker” emotions associated with the sacred (Pargament et al. 2017, p. 735).
Some fans who find the sacred in sport may benefit from greater awareness and
understanding of what lies behind their strong emotions at sports events.
Flow can generate hope through the sacred qualities of interconnectedness and
spiritual emotions. Intentional and communal reflection on the meanings of such
awe-inspiring moments for both athletes and fans, however, is necessary if these
experiences are to be expressed in consonant actions. This is where the theological
insight that the process of sanctification must include intentionality and discipline is
especially prudent and instructive. Long established religions know well the value and
necessity of spiritual disciplines in relation to experiences of the sacred. The sacred
is discovered through the process of sanctification—the imbuing of that aspect of
life with sacred qualities. The psychological understanding of sanctification rests on
description rather than proscription. A theological perspective of sanctification takes
the concept of the spiritual a step further. Not only is active participation required to
experience the sacred (God’s justification through grace), but so too is an intentional
and disciplined response to the sacred.
22 O’Gorman addresses fan violence and sums up the explanation for this provided by Franklin Foer
in How Football Explains the World (2004. London: Arrow Books, p. 13).
23 Wann studied the motivations of 272 sports fans and found no “relationship between level of
Sport as Spiritual
References
24 If people discover the sacred in sport, this has implications for therapeutic care. Instead of ignoring
sports talk, spiritual care providers need to listen more attentively, assuming sport may be about
hope as a manifestation of the sacred.
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
lähestyäkään ketään kaunista tyttöä koettamatta siepata suukkosta
tältä huolimatta mustasukkaisesta ihailijasta ja levottomista
vanhemmista, mutta nyt saivat kylän kaunottaret katsella turhaan
häneen tunteellisin ja puhuvin silmin. Hän tervehti vain heitä
ohimennessään ystävällisesti kiinnittämättä heihin sen enempää
huomiota, ja hänen silmissään oli niin omituinen ilme kuin hän
alituisesti olisi katsellut jotakin näkymätöntä.
»Jánko, miksi et puhu etkä juo? Juo nyt ja ilmoita meille tuon
onnellisen tytön nimi, joka saa jakaa Kisfalun rahat Andráksen
kanssa ja saa vielä parhaimman miehen kaupan päälliseksi».
»Mahdotonta!»
»Jánko, valehtelet!»
»Huhtikuun ensimmäinen päivä oli jo aikoja sitten».
»Keményn Andrásko»?
»Meidän Andrásko»?
»Muudanko meistä»?
»Milloin se tapahtui»?
»Miten se tapahtui?»
»Oikein, Jánko»!
»Eläköön Jánko»!
Jánko nostettiin suurelle tyhjälle laatikolle seisomaan. Hän oli
täydellisesti tietoinen omasta merkityksestään ja uutisiensa
ihmeellisyydestä. Hän näki tuosta korkeudesta kaikki nuo häneen
päin kääntyneet kiihkeät kasvot. Kuivattuaan suunsa hihallaan
valmistautui hän puhumaan mielenkiintoisesti ja lumoavasti. Mutta
juuri kun hän oli aloittamaisillaan, näki hän päitten yli isä
Ambrosiuksen tulevan häntä kohti, ja hän ajatteli, ettei hänen
asentonsa laatikon kannella ollut kyllin arvokas, ja otaksui, että pappi
kertoo kreiville, miten hänen luotettu palvelijansa levittää juoruja
kylään, jolloin kreivi ehkä suuttuu. Senvuoksi laskeutui Jánko
varovaisuuden vuoksi maahan silloin kun isä Ambrosius tunkeutui
joukon läpi.
HÄÄT.
Kun hän eilen oli lukenut nämä sanat, olivat ne tuntuneet hänestä
enkelien lausumilta silloin kun paratiisin portit aukenevat.