Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Improving Students Reading Comprehension Through SRA Reading Laboratory - EDITED
Improving Students Reading Comprehension Through SRA Reading Laboratory - EDITED
An Action Research
Presented to the Faculty of College of Teacher Education
University of Mindanao
Davao City
May, 2023
ii
Abstract
enrolled in the school with the school ID 304375 were enlisted as participants of the
qualitative questionnaires were conducted before and after the implementation of the
utilizing the SRA reading laboratory. Students also claimed that the intervention has
been beneficial to them. From this, relevant measures may be taken by teachers and
reading.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page i.
Abstract ii.
Table of Contents iii.
List of Tables vi.
Introduction 1
Context and Rationale 1
Innovation, Intervention, and Strategy 2
Action Research Question 4
Method 4
Participants, Other Sources of Data and Information 4
Data Gathering Procedure 5
Data Analysis Plan 5
Results and Discussion 6
Reflection 14
Recommendation 15
References 16
Appendices 18
Appendix A: Letter to Conduct the Study 18
Appendix B: Informed Consent 19
Appendix C: SRA Starting Level Guide 22
Appendix D: SRA Reading Levels 27
Appendix E: Grammarly Report 28
Documentation 29
iv
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
1 Pre-Test Scores Before the Implementation of SRA 6
2 Raw Scores During SRA Sessions 8
3 Average Scores of Students Per Color Level 10
4 Pre-Test Scores and Post Test Scores 12
1
help of SRA reading laboratory and teachers, students who will be chosen to
participate may have the chance to improve their reading comprehension skills and
prepare them as they go on to higher level of education.
enhance their reading levels (Mousavian & Siahpoosh, 2018). The SRA reading
laboratory emphasizes skill development, which increases learners' reading
comprehension by allowing them to try out various reading styles; the more they
practiced, the better they became at using those skills to understand the texts given
such as predicting meaning, using prior information/background knowledge, and
acquiring new vocabulary that will help them improve their reading skills
(Puripunyavanich, 2021). In addition, an intervention strategy for improving reading
comprehension ability helps to assist learners in activating background knowledge in
order to interact with the text with comprehension, which is why SRA is required to be
implemented in schools these days. Therefore, it has been suggested that reading
engagement is a prerequisite for building attention among students, which finally leads
to strong student performance in reading skills (Roomy & Alhawsawi, 2019).
Discussion of Results
In this section, the results and discussions have four tables that connect to the
study. Table 1 shows the pre-test scores before the implementation of SRA. Table 2
shows the raw scores during SRA sessions. Table 3 shows the average scores of
students per color level. Lastly, Table 4, shows the pre-test scores and the post-test
scores.
a. Baseline Data Observation
Table 1
Pre-Test Scores Before the Implementation of SRA
Student A 5
Student B 5
Student C 3
Student D 3
Student E 4
Student F 3
Student G 4
Student H 8
Student I 6
Student J 10
Student K 9
Student L 10
Student M 6
Student N 6
Student O 6
Student P 6
Student Q 6
Student R 11
Student S 11
Student T 12
7
As observed in the table, the majority of Grade 7 students who took the SRA
Reading Laboratory Pre-test got failing scores. Since the students got failing scores,
this indicates that most Grade 7 students need to use Power Builders to enhance their
reading comprehension skills. Only Student T, who scored twelve (12) on SRA
Reading Laboratory Pre-test, got a passing score. Therefore, even though the student
got or did not get a passing score, he/she still needs to use Power Builders material in
order to improve their reading comprehension skills.
Furthermore, students were asked to answer short-response and checklist
types of questions during the pre-test. The questions focused more on the learners’
reading habits as well as their familiarity with the SRA reading laboratory. This will also
serve as the introduction of the starting level guide for the SRA Reading Laboratory to
the students. Based on their responses, most of the students have not yet used SRA
Reading Laboratory before. In short, this is the first time for Grade 7 students to deal
with this SRA Reading Laboratory.
In terms of the answers of the students, the kinds of texts that Student T prefer
to read most are “short stories, comics, and Wattpad.” This means that Student T had
already developed his desire for reading. For the things that they like to do in their
spare time, Student C answered, “sleeping and playing out with my friends,” while
Student L answered, “playing computer games, and answering my homework.” As
illustrated in their responses, none of them have included reading as part of their daily
routines. This could explain why they perform poorly in reading comprehension tests
as they have not established a habit of reading.
The results presented above are in line with the study of Devera (2022), which
shows that less than 15% of Filipino students, or around three out of every twenty
learners, have difficulty reading simple texts. Filipino students are likely to experience
difficulties because the majority of them fail to meet the basic requirements in reading,
writing, and arithmetic caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. As stated by Tan (2021),
most Filipino students who struggle with reading comprehension come from families
with limited resources where the home and educational environments do not support
growth mindsets. Students could view their educational needs as a hardship because
they must prioritize working to support their families financially.
8
Presented in the table above are the learners’ scores in the 10-item reading
comprehension test for every Power Builder they read. Students were required to read
and answer at least three (3) Power Builders from each color level. If they reach the
passing score of seven (7) and above in each Power Builder, they are eligible for
9
promotion to the next color level. If not, then they must read and answer up to five (5)
Power Builders from their current color level before advancing to the next. This
condition was established to ensure that struggling readers are given more opportunity
to develop their reading skills before proceeding with more difficult reading materials.
Based on the data illustrated, it can be observed that students were more likely
to achieve a passing score by the time they reached the third level. For instance,
Student L failed in all his reading comprehension tests on his starting level. However,
by the time he reached his third color level, he was able to pass three reading
comprehension tests. Students B, D, K, M, and O had the same case. Additionally, the
number of students who obtained a passing average score is significantly greater on
the third level (9 students) than that on the first level (7 students). It should be noted
that the complexity of the reading materials increases as students move along the
color levels. Hence, to see students improving in their reading comprehension
performance despite dealing with increasingly difficult texts only goes to show that
exposure to reading materials of high complexity is advantageous to one’s
development of reading skills – provided, however, that there are adequate
opportunities to practice one’s reading comprehension skills.
Furthermore, the results demonstrate that learners who have read and
answered five (5) Power Builders are generally more likely to obtain a greater test
score average on their third level. For instance, Learner D went from having an
average score of 4.2 in his starting color level to having an average of 5.8 upon
completing his third color level. This phenomenon is likewise observed in Student A,
B, F, G, H, L, M, and O. From this, it can be inferred that students who are exposed to
more reading materials tend to become better readers.
The findings above are supported by the study of Habib and Hussein (2018),
which illustrated that learners who read stories of high complexity performed better in
reading comprehension tests than their peers who read stories of low complexity. The
researchers further postulated that this could be due to the fact that reading materials
of greater complexity generally require readers to undergo more intensive and
demanding cognitive and linguistic processes. Hence, this leads to greater gains in
developing one’s reading comprehension skills. Aside from the quality of the texts,
Tang and Li (2019) also suggest that the quantity of the reading materials also play a
significant role in improving learners’ reading comprehension abilities. In their study, it
was revealed that students who engaged in extensive reading had significantly higher
10
scores on measures of reading comprehension than those who read fewer materials.
This is because extensive reading offers a multitude of cognitive benefits to readers,
such as increased vocabulary knowledge, enhanced reading fluency, and expansion
of background knowledge.
Table 3
Average Scores of Students Per Color Level
Student Q 8 6.6 7
Based on the average test scores of students in each level, it can be deduced
that most learners showed gradual improvement in terms of their performance in
reading comprehension tests. There was a significant increase in their test score
averages during the implementation of the SRA Reading Laboratory, as observed in
Student B, Student M, and Student O. Meanwhile, Students A, C, E, and Q have mean
scores which are not linear as shown in the data presented above. Although, some of
their scores fall lower than their previous mean scores, they were still promoted to the
next power builder that corresponds to another color level to introduce them to a
variety of reading materials. Also, it was observed that the students’ motivation in
reading depends on the level of their interest about what they read. The sessions were
during their dismissal and some of them rushed to go home and did not take the
assessment seriously. Vocabulary is as well one of the factors affecting the
consistency of their mean scores. Some power builders contain Americanized
terminologies that are difficult for the readers to understand; hence, the inconsistent
performance. It is also seen that scores mostly differ from each color level students
were put in, indicating that the higher the level a learner achieves, the better they
become in comprehending what they read. For instance, the average score of students
who finished at the color level Yellow was between 4 and 5.8. Meanwhile, the average
score of students who finished at the color level Green was between 5.8 and 8.6.
Finally, the average score of students who finished at the color level Blue was between
7.7 and 9.
The findings above are consistent with the study of Wu and Huang (2019),
which evinced that students who completed higher color levels in the SRA reading
laboratory had higher reading comprehension scores than their peers who completed
lower color levels. This could be due to the fact that students who attained higher color
levels were exposed to reading materials of greater complexity, thereby giving them
an opportunity to practice more advanced reading strategies to comprehend the text.
Therefore, achieving higher color levels in the reading laboratory is associated with
higher average test scores.
12
Student A 5 5
Student B 5 6
Student C 3 4
Student D 3 5
Student E 4 4
Student F 3 5
Student G 4 6
Student H 8 10
Student I 6 9
Student J 10 10
Student K 9 10
Student L 10 9
Student M 6 5
Student N 6 8
Student O 6 7
Student P 6 10
Student Q 6 8
Student R 11 13
Student S 11 10
Student T 12 12
Shown in the above-presented table are the scores after utilizing the Science
Research Associates laboratory. This study administered the same questionnaire for
both pre-test and post-test to find out how the learners’ reading comprehension has
improved through the aid of the SRA laboratory.
13
From the data illustrated, it is evident that most of the scores are higher than
what is tallied in their pre-test data; thus, indicating the efficacy of the implementation.
One example is Student F who scored three (3) on his pre-test and scored five (5)
during the post-test with the aid of the abovementioned laboratory.
Furthermore, it has been realized that the use of the SRA laboratory helped the
students improve their reading comprehension as stated in the above-presented data.
Although most students still failed to reach the passing score of 12, they nevertheless
demonstrated significant improvement from their pre-test performance. In fact,
eighteen (18) out of twenty (20) participants had greater scores on their post test than
the pre-test. There was also an increase in the students’ overall post test average (7.8)
compared to their pre-test average (6.7). Moreover, eight (8) students have scored 10
and above in the post-test, which is considerably greater than the number of students
who scored the same in the pre-test, with only five (5) out of 20. Indeed, most of the
scores are high and only a few got low scores due to having difficulties in
understanding the reading materials and other factors to be discussed. Therefore, this
implies that SRA laboratory is effective in improving students’ performance in reading
comprehension test.
When asked about the benefits they gained after using the SRA, one student
wrote: “I learned so many [things] like animals’ unusual ability.” Moreover, another
student asserted that engaging with the SRA laboratory has helped her answer her
homework better since “I can understand more and read well.” From their responses,
it can be deduced that the intervention has been successful in letting students realize
how advantageous reading is for them. If this persists, learners may become
interested in reading well enough that they decide to develop a habit of reading.
Upon asking the participants about the difficulties and their suggestions on the
process of using the laboratory, one student suggested: “… that they can make the
story shorter so we can understand and read well” indicating that the length of the
material affects the students’ willingness to read and comprehend. The shorter it is,
the more it becomes interesting to the readers. Another student suggested that their
experience would have been better had the laboratory provided easier texts to read:
“[I hope that they] make the story easier to read”. Taking into consideration the context
of the stories used in the laboratory, we can surmise that the Westernized setting of
the stories made it harder for students to relate and thereby comprehend the text. This
14
further suggests that it will be easier for them to understand the material if they are
familiar with what they read.
Anent the abovementioned statements, localization plays a vital role in teaching
reading comprehension to students. This is supported by the study of Ismail,
Mohaideen, and Rashid (2020), which states it is common for students at this stage to
have difficulties in reading texts. One of the factors affecting it is the text selection;
hence, localization of reading materials is important to ease the reading and
understanding process. More so, the study of Taylor (2020) about the Impact of Texts
on Reading Comprehension, supports the idea that interest plays an important role in
reading comprehension and individuals display more persistence, engagement, and
positive affect toward tasks that they are interested in.
Reflection
Throughout the conduct of our study, we, as researchers, have our cents of
realizations. In our first session using the SRA Laboratory, it was evident that not all
participants were into reading; in that situation, we incorporated extrinsic rewards to
help boost their drive to read. However, due to this particular motivation, we realized
that most students only read the material not because it is pleasurable for them but
because of the reward they get after they read. With this, it is best to rely on something
other than giving rewards to learners so as to ensure that learners are reading the
texts because they are intrinsically motivated to do so and not for the sake of obtaining
a prize. Further, as we conducted this study, we realized that teaching reading to a
large number of struggling learners is challenging. You cannot effectively monitor them
individually, and you cannot get to know their strategies in reading – the role of the
teacher will be put to a limit considering the quantity of learners that must be dealt
with. As researchers, we supposed that it is better to teach reading one-on-one to
have a practical guided reading session that best benefits the learner. Moreover, even
though the SRA Laboratory has its facilitative role, it is undeniable that the teacher’s
guidance is still irreplaceable. In connection with this, the participants of this study had
difficulty understanding specific vocabulary that hampers their comprehension of the
text given; this made them ask for help from us researchers. Indeed, even though how
immersive learning materials may get, the teacher’s role toward a learner definitely
brings an impact that none can copy nor replace. To conclude, considering our first
interaction with the students, it was made apparent to us that most of the students
15
were having unpleasurable relationship with reading, but as this reading intervention
come to an end, most of the participants showed evident progress that made the SRA
Laboratory beneficial for the needed improvement in the reading comprehension skills
of these learners.
Recommendation
References
Devera, B. (2022). Lockdown’s Impact: Unicef Cites Poor Reading Skills Among PH
Kids. Inquirer.Net. https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1576573/lockdowns-impact-
unicef-cites-poor-reading-skills-among-ph-kids
Habib, R., & Hussein, S. (2018). The effects of reading comprehension and listening
to stories of different complexity on young EFL learners’ reading
comprehension and vocabulary learning. Journal of Education and Practice,
9(30), 80-91.
Ismail, H. H., Mohaideen, H., & Rashid, R. A. (2020). The Use of Local Literary Texts
as Reading Materials in English Language Classrooms: An Analysis of
Teachers' Perspectives. The Authors and IJLTER.ORG.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/348371643_The_Use_of_Local_Lite
rary_Texts_as_Reading_Materials_in_English_Language_Classrooms_An_A
nalysis_of_Teachers'_Perspectives
Mousavian, S., & Siahpoosh, H. (2018). The effects of vocabulary pre-teaching and
pre-questioning on intermediate Iranian EFL learners’ reading comprehension
ability. International Journal of Applied Linguistics and English Literature, 7(2),
58. https://doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijalel.v.7n.2p.58
Roomy, M. A., & Alhawsawi, S. (2019). Understanding reading strategies of EFL Saudi
students. English Language Teaching, 12(6), 33.
https://doi.org/10.5539/elt.v12n6p33
Tang, H., & Li, J. (2019). Effects of extensive reading on reading comprehension in
second language learning: A meta-analysis. Reading and Writing, 32(2), 319-
341. doi: 10.1007/s11145-018-9892-2
17
Appendix A
Letter to Conduct the Study
19
Appendix B
Informed Consent
20
21
22
Appendix C
SRA Starting Level Guide
23
24
25
26
27
Appendix D
SRA Reading Levels
28
Appendix E
Grammarly Report
29
DOCUMENTATION
Day 2. Considering the participants color placement, they began their reading
session based on their respective color levels.
Day 3. A participant from color level orange was promoted to the next level which is
the color level yellow.
30
Day 4. Participants from color level orange reached their last color level, the color
level green.