Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 13

NeuroRehabilitation 18 (2003) 135–146 135

IOS Press

Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online:


Lessons learned, initial findings and future
directions
Robert L. Glueckauf∗ and Jeffrey S. Loomis
Center for Research on Telehealth and Healthcare Communications and Department of Clinical and Health
Psychology, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL, USA

Abstract. Family caregivers of older adults with progressive dementia (e.g., Alzheimer’s disease) are faced with a variety of
emotional and behavioral difficulties, such as dealing with persistent, repetitive questions, managing agitation and depression,
and monitoring hygiene and self-care activities. Although professional and governmental organizations have called for the
creation of community-based education and support programs, most dementia caregivers continue to receive little or no formal
instruction in responding effectively to these challenges. The current paper describes the development and implementation of
Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online, a Web- and telephone-based education and support network for caregivers of individuals
with progressive dementia. Lessons learned from the first two years of this state-supported initiative are discussed, followed
by the findings of a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation-funded strategic marketing initiative and an initial program evaluation
of AlzOnline’s Positive Caregiving classes. Finally, clinical implications and future directions for program development and
evaluation research are proposed.

1. Overview and rationale for online dementia or others, issuing frequent reminders, and monitoring
caregiver intervention hygiene and self-care activities. Unfortunately, such
intensive home care activities are performed at high
Approximately 5 million US citizens over 60 have cost to caregivers in terms of psychological, physical,
Alzheimer’s disease or a closely related form of pro- and financial resources. Caregivers of persons with de-
gressive dementia. The economic consequences of mentia typically experience reduced social activities,
these disorders are substantial, costing the nation $95 disrupted household routines and relationships, as well
billion a year in medical care, lost productivity, and as deterioration in mental and physical health [4,5].
care [1,2]. In an effort to address these substantial psychoso-
Despite the common belief that elders with Alzheim- cial, emotional, and physical health concerns, elder
er’s disease reside primarily in long-term care facili- care organizations across the United States have de-
ties, family members provide the vast majority of care veloped a wide range of respite, assisted living, adult
for these individuals in the home [3]. Caregiving re- day care, and support programs for persons with pro-
quirements for older adults with dementia typically in- gressive dementia and their caregivers. Our home state
clude managing potentially injurious behavior to self of Florida, a leader in aging and elder care, currently
funds 13 memory disorder clinics, four model day care
programs, and respite services. There are also four
∗ Address for correspondence: Robert L. Glueckauf, Ph.D., Center
Florida chapters of the national Alzheimer’s Associ-
for Research on Telehealth and Healthcare Communications, Depart- ation and over 25 independent Alzheimer’s organiza-
ment of Clinical and Health Psychology, University of Florida, P.O.
Box 100165, Gainesville, FL 32610-0165, USA. Tel.: +1 352 392 tions that provide support groups, day care, wanderer
4154 ext. 10; Fax: +1 352 392 2980; E-mail: rgluecka@hp.ufl.edu. identification programs, and basic information about

ISSN 1053-8135/03/$8.00  2003 – IOS Press. All rights reserved


136 R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online

dementia care. In addition, there are a large number this research group has shown significant improvement
of private long-term care facilities across Florida that on rates of diagnosed depression and emotional well
provide a broad spectrum of residential services [6]. being in cognitive-behavioral program participants as
Although these organizations have provided a wide compared to controls who showed little changed over
variety of adult day care and residential services for in- time [12].
dividuals with Alzheimer’s and their families, the gap
between caregiver needs and available services contin-
3. Florida recognizes need for online dementia
ues to grow, particularly in the areas of health promo-
caregiver education and support
tion, stress management, and lifestyle enhancement.
Most agencies that serve persons with Alzheimer’s dis- In June 2000, the State of Florida Department of
ease have only limited financial resources, small num- Elder Affairs (DOEA) recognized the need to provide
bers of professional staff, and cover broad geographi- Internet and toll-free telephone access to expert educa-
cal regions. By necessity, the majority of their services tional services for Florida’s caregivers of persons with
have focused on providing medical diagnostic exams, progressive dementia. They affirmed that Alzheimer’s
home care assistance, adult day care, and respite. As disease is Florida’s epidemic and that caregivers of
a consequence, expert consultation on stress manage- Florida’s 400,000 individuals with dementia required
ment, caregiving techniques, and lifestyle enhancement around-the-clock, specialized support and assistance.
for caregivers continues to be difficult to obtain, ex- Based on his earlier accomplishments in providing
pensive, and in certain portions of rural Florida and the telehealth services to rural individuals with neurolog-
nation, completely nonexistent [7,8]. ical disabilities and their families [13,14], the DOEA
awarded an annually renewable grant to the first author,
Robert Glueckauf, director of the University of Florida
2. Recent advances in telecommunications Center for Research on Telehealth and Healthcare Com-
technology and caregiver intervention munications (CRTHC), to develop a statewide, online
education and support network for caregivers of per-
Fortunately, two recent scientific advances have en- sons with progressive dementia.
hanced our prospects for meeting the specialized ed- Glueckauf and his staff, Jeff Loomis, Eric Ecklund-
ucational and support needs of caregivers of individ- Johnson, Pat Dages, and Hope Benefield, recognized
uals with progressive dementia. One major advance that the task was a challenging one. They were com-
is the development of telecommunication technologies missioned to build a website that was not only easy to
that facilitate long distance education and communi- navigate and accessible to a wide range of users (e.g.,
cation across multiple locations. The Internet holds caregivers with slow modems), but also were required
to establish the most efficacious methods for promot-
considerable promise as a vehicle for meeting the ed-
ing their web services across the State. In the remain-
ucational and support needs of dementia caregivers.
der of the paper, we first outline the overall mission of
Caregiver information about stress management, the
the dementia caregiver telehealth initiative followed by
latest research developments, and referrals to commu-
a description of the development and lessons learned
nity resources can be provided 24 hours a day seven
from Year 1 of Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online
days a week, simply by clicking a mouse [9] The sec- or AlzOnline. Second, we discuss the goals and opera-
ond major advance is the growing body of interven- tions of our Robert Wood Johnson Foundation-funded
tion approaches that have been developed to increase strategic marketing initiative and its outcomes. Third,
caregiver’s perceptions of self-efficacy, reduce depres- we describe the development and lessons learned from
sion, and to improve caregiver quality of life. Health AlzOnline Year 2. Special emphasis will be given to
professionals now have at their disposal a toolbox of the challenges we faced in developing and implement-
empirically-validated strategies that enhance caregiver ing our first and second generation websites, as well as
well-being, stress management skills, and reduce the how these lessons shaped our decisions in establishing
likelihood of caregiver burnout [10,11] For example, the overall direction of the web- and telephone-based
Dolores Gallagher-Thompson and associates have de- caregiver initiative. Last, we present the initial out-
veloped a multi-component cognitive-behavioral pro- comes of our Positive Caregiving classes, followed by a
gram for dementia caregivers that includes relaxation discussion of clinical implications and future directions
training, increasing pleasurable daily events, and as- for web- and telephone-based caregiver education and
sertiveness training. Across several outcome studies, research.
R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online 137

4. Mission statement (a) Dolores Gallagher-Thompson’s and Larry Thomp-


son’s previous caregiver intervention research [10,12,
The overall mission of Alzheimer’s Caregiver Sup- 15,16], and (b) Glueckauf and colleagues’ assertive-
port Online is to: (a) provide Internet- and telephone ness training studies [17,18]. The classes were bundled
based education and support for caregivers of indi- into three separate packages or modules of four to five
viduals with progressive dementia, (b) disseminate classes each. The three packages and their associated
empirically-based information about effective coping class offerings are displayed in Table 1.
and problem-solving skills for caregivers of individuals These web-based materials were collectively labeled
with progressive dementia, (c) serve as a clearinghouse “Positive Caregiving” classes to emphasize the bene-
for Internet-based caregiver support services, and (d) ficial aspects of the caregiving experience, as well as
provide a toll-free telephone line to ensure easy and to underscore the educational focus of the AlzOnline
rapid access to information and support about dementia website. Packages 1 and 2 (see Table 1) included one
caregiving issues. prerecorded class (i.e., Basics of Dementia), followed
In keeping with the priorities of the DOEA, we were by five, 30- to 45-minute live classes, consisting of di-
charged first and foremost with meeting the needs of
dactic presentations interspersed with group discussion
Floridian caregivers. However, DOEA leadership real-
and suggested outside activities. Packages 1 and 2 also
ized that Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online was a
were available live over a toll-free telephone line.
service delivery model that other states might choose to
The beta version of our first generation website was
emulate, and thus encouraged CRTHC staff to develop
services that would be useful to dementia caregivers completed at the end of Phase 1 and consisted of three
across the nation and the world. main areas. The first area contained our live, inter-
active, web-based Positive Caregiving classes. Care-
4.1. Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online: Year 1 givers were able to hear and see the facilitator (i.e., in-
structor) throughout the class, as well as to view simul-
The first year of the dementia caregiver telehealth taneously a slide show that emphasized the key points
initiative was divided into three separate phases: Phase of the presentation. In addition, they had the option
1 (product development), Phase 2 (initial evaluation of communicating with one another and the facilita-
of website) and Phase 3 (modification and follow-up tor using a chat box that was conveniently located at
evaluation). the bottom of the web page. To reduce the demand
for bandwidth from our dedicated AlzOnline server,
4.1.1. Phase 1 we employed an application service provider (ASP) to
The objectives of Phase 1 included: (a) the integra- deliver the secure, live classes, slide presentations and
tion of our web- and telephone-based education and chat room. 1
support program into the existing Florida network of The second area of the website was the library. This
dementia care services, (b) the development of our section provided caregivers with links to authoritative
Internet-based psychoeducational classes, (c) the iden- publications on dementia care, frequently asked ques-
tification of web-based caregiver information resources tions about Internet-based communication, and a pub-
and pertinent web links, and (d) initial construction of lic message board. The final area of the website con-
the website. During this six-month interval, AlzOnline tained links to helpful federal, state, and community
staff members made regular telephone and face-to-face resources. We made a concerted effort to include links
contacts with elder care organization personnel (e.g., to community elder care organizations across Florida.
service directors and coordinators of the Area Agencies These senior service organizations play a critical role
on Aging and their lead organizations) and caregiver in the lives of both caregivers and care recipients with
advocates across Florida. We also made several presen- progressive dementia, providing frontline services and
tations and conducted workshops at DOEA-sponsored support in activities of daily living, attendant care, and
events, such as their statewide caregiver forums, elder crisis management.
leadership institutes, and Alzheimer’s Disease Initia-
tive Advisory Committee meetings.
In developing the psychoeducational classes for the 1 An ASP is a company that provides videostreaming and other
website, the first author and his postdoctoral associate, applications to individuals, agencies and organizations using their
Eric Ecklund-Johnson, drew from two major sources: own computer equipment and manpower.
138 R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online

Table 1
AlzOnline Positive Caregiving classes: Generation 1
Package 1: Increasing Caregiver Awareness and Emotional Well-Being
Basics of Dementia: Memory, Emotions & Behavior
Relaxation Training
ABCs of Positive Thinking
Connection between Daily Events & Emotions
Increasing Positive Emotions
Package 2: Coping with Challenging Caregiving Situations
Basics of Dementia: Memory, Emotions & Behavior
Relaxation Training
ABCs of Positive Thinking
Assertive Responding in Caregiving Situations
Managing Challenging Caregiving Situations
Package 3: Setting Personal Caregiving Goals
Developing New Goals
Implementing New Goals
Review and Feedback on Goal Progress
Community Networks and Techniques for Maintaining Gains

4.1.2. Phases 2 and 3 not have access to the Internet, or if given the option,
The primary focus of Phases 2 and 3 was the evalua- would prefer to receive educational services over the
tion of website educational materials, caregiver classes, telephone rather than the Internet. Thus, it was essen-
message board, and web links. A selected group of tial to provide an alternative mode of service delivery
dementia caregivers (n = 11), senior service profes- for this subpopulation of caregivers. Furthermore, we
sionals (n = 8), and DOEA staff (n = 2) was asked to needed to have a back up for our web-based programs.
rate on a 5-point scale (with 1 = not at all and 5 = com- If AlzOnline.net experienced temporary transmission
pletely) the clarity, usefulness, and ease of navigation difficulties or if our server needed repair, toll-free tele-
of website reading materials, live caregiving classes, phone would ensure continuity of service during both
message board, and state and national web links. Over- unanticipated and planned down times.
all, reviewers indicated that the website’s written ma-
terials were clear (M = 4.0), understandable, useful 4.2. Lesson learned from AlzOnline Year 1
(M = 3.9), and easy to navigate (M = 4.4). They
also reported that the content of the Positive Caregiving We faced three major challenges in designing and
classes was easy to comprehend (M = 3.8) and helpful implementing the first generation of AlzOnline: (a)
in reducing caregiver distress (M = 4.0). However, design adaptation, (b) the transmission, privacy, and
several caregivers reported significant difficulties opti- size of on-line classes, and (c) the content development
mizing their computers for two-way chat and/or oral of Positive Caregiving classes
communication, as well as problems with audio clarity.
Specifically, they reported that class facilitators’ voices 4.2.1. Design adaptation
sounded somewhat “tinny,” and at times were difficult One of the initial tasks of the AlzOnline technical
to understand. Toward the end of Phase 3, we incor- staff was to identify an off-the-shelf video streaming
porated reviewers’ recommendations into the website application that was capable of delivering live interac-
(e.g., improving audio clarity) and the first generation tive classes to multiple caregivers across different sites
of AlzOnline.net was ready to be rolled out to the pub- and of supporting group interaction through use of a
lic. standard chat room. We were particularly interested in
Although the bulk of our efforts was devoted to the finding an off-the-shelf application that met two basic
development and evaluation of the website, an impor- requirements: (1) audio that was clear, continuous, and
tant goal for AlzOnline Year 1 was to establish a par- transmittable at a slow rate of connection to the Inter-
allel, toll-free telephone service. As discussed previ- net [e.g., 28.8 kilobytes per second (kbps)], and (2)
ously, the primary objective of the toll-free telephone video that was well-defined and fluid, particularly in
line was to provide easy and rapid access to dementia displaying presentation slides and the facilitator’s body
caregiver information and support. A sizeable minor- movements.
ity of the dementia caregiver population, particularly We quickly discovered that there were very few prod-
older spouses and those who lived in rural areas, did ucts on the market that could deliver our Positive Care-
R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online 139

giving classes with minimal downloading delays and 4.2.2. Transmission, privacy, and class size
that required a minimum level of skill for caregivers After deciding how to design the first generation of
to use (i.e., provided a turnkey solution). The only AlzOnline, we needed to determine how to best deliver
products available for purchase at the time were Real the content. Generally speaking, the process of trans-
Networks Producer and Real Presenter. They both of- mitting live classes over the Internet is a straightforward
fered live and prerecorded video and audio streaming, task. The most common users of interactive web-based
as well as the option of delivering presentation slides education are young adults with recent computer equip-
to caregivers. However, neither Real Networks Pro- ment, high technology comfort, and in many instances,
ducer nor Real Presenter supported text-based chat, a high-speed connectivity.
required feature of our interactive classes. We expected the opposite to be the case for a sizeable
In addition to the two Real applications, we exam- proportion of the dementia caregiver population. Many
ined solutions from other corporations that claimed caregivers continue to use older computer hardware and
they had a product that would meet our requirements. software, as well as slow 28.8 kbps modems. They also
Despite our request to purchase their videoconferenc- were likely to express a higher level of concern about
ing packages outright, these companies offered only to privacy and security on the web, and concomitantly, a
lease their products to us, and typically at high cost. lower level of comfort with computer technology than
In the final analysis, we signed a contract with an Ap- that of young adult web users.
plication Service Provider offering a solution that was When first delivering our Positive Caregiving classes,
both inexpensive and versatile. The product we leased we believed that we would be able to accommodate
provided microphone-based, two-way voice commu- the diverse telecommunication needs of our users. One
nication and text-based chat, as well as the option of of the claims of our first Application Service Provider
delivering simultaneous slide presentations. product was the capacity to adjust video streaming
Another important design issue we faced was to ob- transmission rates without compromising audio or
tain the services of a webmaster who could both think video quality. We were able to stream the instructor’s
“outside the box” in developing a site for users with live presentation, slides, and text-based chat at either
potentially limited Internet skills, and who could build slow (28.8 kbps) or at higher speeds (128 kbps). Con-
a website that conformed to the rules of the World Wide trary to our initial expectations, several caregivers, par-
Web Consortium and the SPRY Foundation on inter- ticularly those with slow modems, reported that the
operability. We hired an experienced webmaster who class instructor’s voice was tinny and at times, difficult
possessed both these skills, and decided to outsource to comprehend. This user group also felt that the ad-
the construction of the original website to Silverscape, vantages of viewing the instructor live on the Internet
Inc., a local web design company that worked with a were outweighed by the mediocre audio quality.
wide range of University of Florida departments and re- As a result of these concerns, we switched to a sec-
search centers, as well as local businesses. The advan- ond ASP model, which removed the live video por-
tages of this approach were twofold: First, the web de- tion of our streaming classes and replaced it with a
sign company would be able to generate a “first pass” of postage stamp-size picture of the instructor. This de-
the website in a relatively short time (i.e., three months) cision yielded significant benefits. Caregivers reported
and at a reasonable cost. Silverscape prided itself on a substantial increase the quality of audio transmission
its capacity to provide a quick turnaround to valued and in turn, heightened perceptions of the clarity and
customers, had a long history of designing health care quality of classes.
websites, and offered reasonably priced services. A Turning to the issue of privacy, both AlzOnline staff
second benefit of hiring a web design company was that and DOEA project officers felt very strongly that the
the webmaster would be able to devote the majority of privacy and confidentiality of caregiver class discus-
his time to modifying and fine tuning the features of sions was a top priority. This goal was accomplished
the website. The dementia caregiver community, es- through the use of a password requirement for class par-
pecially older spouses of persons with dementia, had ticipation, and an Internet certificate that created a se-
specific Internet usage requirements. For example, the cure link between the caregiver and the website. Thus,
font size of written materials and web banners needed only those caregivers who had been issued a unique user
to be large and easy to read, the amount of text shown identification and password were able to participate in
on each page had to be kept to a minimum, and buttons our Web-based Positive Caregiving classes.
and tab used to navigate within and between web pages Another challenge that the AlzOnline staff faced to-
needed to be salient and easy to operate. ward the end of the first year of the project was the
140 R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online

thorny question of optimal class size. Previous re- Our initial thinking about how to order our Positive
search on Internet-based psychoeducational interven- Caregiving classes was to follow the sequence of topics
tions showed that participants place a high priority on used in previous intervention conducted by our consul-
opportunities to interact with class members and to ex- tants, Dolores Gallagher-Thompson and Larry Thomp-
change health care tips and suggestions [9]. However, son [16,21] and by Glueckauf and associates [17,18],
our AlzOnline teaching core was limited to three staff with each of seven classes building on the knowledge
members. We were concerned that if caregiver demand base and skills acquired in the preceding one. How-
for educational services were high, our ability to pro- ever, our Dept. of Elder Affairs project supervisors
vide multiple, small group classes over the week would were opposed to this idea, emphasizing that caregivers
be compromised. We simply did not have the resources should have maximum flexibility in the selection and
to offer more than 12 to 15 live interactive classes per order of specific online classes.
week. The outgrowth of this discussion was a creative com-
Ironically, the class size issue turned out to be moot. promise. We divided our original class curriculum into
Only a small proportion of caregivers (i.e., approxi- three separate packages of four to five classes. Care-
mately 1% or 25 of 2000 visitors who log onto our givers had the option of enrolling in either Package 1 or
website each month) have chosen to participate in our 2, and were able to take the first three classes of each of
series of live seven, one-hour classes (see Table 1). The these packages in any order they wished. The knowl-
most highly utilized services on our website have been edge and skills acquired in the last two classes, how-
the Message Board, Library, and Helpful Links, those ever, were hierarchical in nature, and thus needed to be
options that require only a limited investment of time taken in the prescribed sequence (see classes 4 and 5 of
to obtain a considerable amount of information. Thus, Packages 1 and 2 in Table 1). Note that Package 3, Per-
in the final analysis, we decided to maximize the in- sonal Caregiving Goals, was offered to caregivers after
teraction and learning opportunities of individual class they completed either of the first two packages, and was
participants, limiting the number of participants in each delivered only over the telephone. Because of the need
class to a maximum of eight. to conduct a detailed analysis of caregiver’ cognitions,
emotions, and behaviors during goal-related situations,
4.2.3. Content development of online caregiving we felt that the telephone was the medium of choice.
classes
In addition to the web transmission and class size
considerations, the AlzOnline staff were faced with the 4.3. Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online: Year 2
thorny issue of how to best sequence the web- and
telephone-based caregiving classes. As behavioral sci- After successfully competing the construction, beta
entists we wanted to ensure the integrity and robustness testing, and implementation of the first generation web-
of the educational intervention and, at the same time, site, the AlzOnline staff confronted a new set of un-
tailor the curriculum to the specific learning require- certainties and challenges at the outset of Year 2 of the
ments of the audience and to the unique features of the project. One set of uncertainties and challenges was
transmission medium (e.g., Internet or telephone). We common to all new Internet enterprises. We needed to
also were concerned about how to increase the like- develop a reliable and sufficiently large user base to en-
lihood that caregivers would take the entire series of sure the further development and sustainability of our
classes.2 web-and telephone based caregiver initiative. In addi-
tion to this issue, we also received constructive feed-
2 Seven classes or topics have formed the core of previous care-
back from the first cohort of graduates (n = 9) from
giver intervention studies: (1) basics of dementia, (2) relaxation
our Positive Caregiving classes about certain aspects
training, (3) ABCs of positive thinking, (4) connection between daily of our website, particularly difficulties in navigating
events and emotions, (5) increasing positive emotions, (6) assertive the website, inadequate button sizes, and the crowded
responding in caregiving situations, and (7) managing challenging appearance of certain web pages.
caregiving situations. These topics were also the thrust of AlzOnline
Packages 1 and 2. Note that a third component or package, Person-
alized Goal Setting, was added to the AlzOnline curriculum. The
rationale for this decision is located in the earlier work of Glueck- goal setting reported greater improvement in psychosocial function-
auf and his associates. Webb and Glueckauf [22] found that partic- ing at the 3 month follow-up than controls who received standard
ipants who received psychoeducational treatment plus personalized psychoeducation alone.
R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online 141

4.3.1. Strategic marketing initiative utilization of AlzOnline services increased over 300%.
First, it was essential to develop a variety of mecha- As shown in Fig. 1, the number of new users each
nisms for informing our constituencies, dementia care- month grew from 1,067 to 3,240 and the total num-
givers and elder care professionals across Florida, about ber of pages visited in a 30-day period increased from
our services and for attracting them to visit our web- 3,867 to 24,805.
site. Fortunately, at the beginning of Year 2, we re-
ceived a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Founda- 4.3.2. Web design issues
tion (RWJF) that afforded us the opportunity to develop As noted above, we received feedback at the begin-
and implement a strategic marketing initiative. ning of Year 2 from the first cohort of graduates from
The specific objectives of the RWJF grant were to: our Positive Caregiving classes. Although we already
(a) identify target caregiver, community support net- had revised our first generation website (i.e., the web-
work and professional audiences who may use, or refer site developed during the first year of the project) based
others to use AlzOnline’s services, (b) identify influen- on reviews from expert caregivers and professional con-
tial “opinion leaders” in Florida government, consumer sultants, several class participants, particularly those
organizations, and senior services agencies who may who were new to the Internet, still found the website
serve as AlzOnline champions, (c) determine promo- somewhat difficult to navigate and awkward to use. For
tional opportunities for AlzOnline among target care- example, they felt that certain portions of the website
giver, community support network and professional (e.g., the Resource section) were difficult to access, and
constituencies, and (d) identify best practices and cross- that the size of some of the website buttons were too
promotional opportunities among Internet sites that small to locate and depress.
currently serve caregivers of individuals with progres- As a consequence of our first cohort’s feedback, we
sive dementia and related chronic medical conditions. decided to create a new generation of AlzOnline, “Alz-
Shortly after obtaining the RWJF grant, we hired the Online Generation 2.” The layout of the website was
Wilson Agency located in Jacksonville, Florida to serve changed to create a more spacious look, with less text
as our marketing consultants. Following their advice, and larger open spaces. We also increased the size of
we convened a small working group conference consist- buttons to help caregivers navigate across various sec-
ing of statewide leaders from DOEA, the state’s Area tions of the website. In addition to these design modifi-
Agencies on Aging, Florida chapters of the Alzheimer’s cations, we combined several caregiver resources (e.g.,
Association, senior service organizations, and demen- library, message board, and links) under a single Re-
tia caregivers. The working group unanimously agreed source Center domain.
that the best way to inform caregivers about AlzOnline Our decision to create AlzOnline Generation 2 not
was to encourage grassroots senior service organiza- only led to beneficial design changes, but also provided
tions (i.e., those agencies who influence and support the opportunity to expand our scope of specialized ed-
dementia caregivers) to refer their clients to our web- ucation services. We had wanted for some time to de-
site. This “Influence the Influencer” strategy was based velop a mechanism for offering important topical in-
on the premise that there was a smaller, secondary tar- formation to caregivers and elder care providers that
get group of individuals that, as a consequence of their would be available any time of the day without delay
professional credibility, coupled with their routine con- or the need for password identification. The upshot
tact with caregivers in local markets, could positively was an innovative and exciting service known as the
influence the behavior of our primary target audience “Expert Forum.”
(i.e., dementia caregivers). Other key strategies pro- Through both selected list-serve and broad-based fax
posed in the Wilson’s marketing plan were: (a) creating notifications, AlzOnline staff invited caregivers and el-
a public awareness media campaign that specifically der care professionals across Florida and the nation to
focused on print, radio, and television outlets, (b) po- participate in a free, one-hour telephone conference fo-
sitioning www.AlzOnline.net supervisory staff as ex- cusing on the latest developments in dementia research,
perts in telecommunications and in dementia caregiver strategies for increasing caregiver quality of life, and
education, and (c) promoting speaking engagements practical caregiving considerations. The format of the
in statewide caregiver conferences, seminars, seniors Expert Forum conferences consisted of a 20-minute
expos and local senior service organizations. didactic presentation with accompanying PowerPoint
The outcomes of our marketing initiative were im- slides, followed by a 20- to 30-minute question and an-
pressive. From October 2001 to October 2002, overall swer period. We digitally recorded each telephone fo-
142 R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online

30000

25000

20000

15000

10000

5000

0
1

2
02

02

2
1

02
2

02
2
02
1

2
2
-0

-0
l-0
-0

r-0
-0
-0

-0
-0
n-

n-

p-
g-
b-
ov

ov
ec

ar
ct

ct
ay

Ju
Ap
Ja

Ju

Se
Au
Fe
O

O
M
N

N
D

M
Distinct users/30 period Average Request/Month

Fig. 1. Number of new users and the total number of pages visited in a 30-day period from October 2001 to October 2002.

rum and then made it accessible to users in the “Expert As a consequence of these concerns, we recently
Forum Archives” section of our website (see Table 2 decided to make a gradual transition from live Internet
for a representative list of Expert Forum presentation delivery to the use of prerecorded, Web-based Positive
topics). Thus, the development of generation 2 of Alz- Caregiving classes, followed one week later by live toll-
Online led to unanticipated secondary benefits. The free telephone follow-up discussion groups. We expect
new Expert Forum section of the website gave care- that the benefits of this option should be substantial.
givers and professionals instant access to highly infor- Caregivers will be able to take pre-recorded Web-based
mative audiovisual presentations in the convenience of classes whenever they wish, anytime of the day or night.
their homes any time during the day or night.
Furthermore, they will have the opportunity to review
portions of a class or an entire class, in preparation
4.4. Lessons learned from AlzOnline year 2
for their follow-up 800-line discussion group. We also
Year 2 was a productive year for Alzheimer’s Care- felt that this change in protocol played to the strengths
giver Support Online. As discussed previously, signif- of the two transmission modalities: (1) the Internet
icant strides were made in increasing overall utiliza- would be used for what it does best, video streaming
tion rates and in improving the ease of navigation of presentations one-way to the user, and (2) the telephone
the website. Nonetheless, we continued to face three would be deployed for what it does best, facilitating
significant challenges, particularly difficulties in web- interactive group discussions among participants and
based delivery of Positive Caregiving classes, problems the class facilitator.
with the design of the home page, and limitations in the
establishment of caregiver community.
4.4.2. Problems with design of AlzOnline’s home page
4.4.1. Difficulties in delivery of Web-based classes A second major challenge was located in the design
First, despite multiple efforts during Year 2 to sim- of our home page. In follow-up surveys administered at
plify instruction in computer optimization and on-
the end of Year 2, caregivers indicated that they wanted
line class interaction procedures, telecommunications
direct links on the home page to key sections of the
staff continued to expend considerable effort and time
website, such as the Message Board and the Expert
resolving technical difficulties associated with live,
web-based classroom interactions (e.g., unanticipated Forum. In AlzOnline Generation 2 (see Section 4.3.2
changes in computer software settings, problems with above), these services were accessible by clicking the
the use of computer firewalls and of different versions Resource Center and Caregiver Support links on the
of Web browsers, as well as general equipment failure), home page, but no formal notification was provided
and caregivers’ confusion about the use of chat and to guide the user to these options. Thus, we decided
two-way audio. These difficulties were not only trou- to change the basic layout of the home page to high-
blesome for staff, but also unfortunately led to caregiver light those services that were most highly utilized by
frustration. caregivers.
R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online 143

Table 2
Representative Expert Forum conferences
Sleeping, Aging, and Dementia (11/21/02)
Traveling and Dementia (10/24/02)
Overview on Dementia (10/10/02)
Alzheimer’s Drugs – What Are They And Do They Work? (9/20/02)
The Initial Visit to the Doctor for a Dementia Work-up: What to Expect (8/22/02)
Use of Anti-psychotic Drugs in Dementia (8/8/02)
Non-Medication Management of Agitated Behavior (7/11/02)
Driving and Dementia (6/28/02)
Wandering in Dementia: Helping the Lost Become Found (5/20/02)
Medicare and Medicare Rights (4/26/02)
Caregiver Issues on Dementia: After the Diagnosis (2/15/02)
Alzheimer’s Behavioral Management & Caregiving Issues (1/17/02)

4.4.3. Limitations in development of caregiver givers have completed the seven-session program; 11
community are ongoing; 8 dropped out after the initial screen-
The third area of concern was located in our aspira- ing interview. The primary reasons for dropout were
tion to develop a virtual community among dementia high involvement with caregiving obligations, compet-
caregivers. When we originally constructed AlzOn- ing work demands, and attendance at other support
line, we conjectured that the best way to build care- groups. Partially confirming these qualitative accounts,
giver community was through the use of the Message dropouts were more likely to have been employed out-
Board. Although the traffic on this user option has been side the home than completers (p = 0.01). Note that
consistently high, individual Message Board postings this was the only pretreatment factor that differentiated
have tended to elicit one or two caregiver responses between dropouts and completers.
apart from those initiated by AlzOnline staff. In effect, Caregivers who completed the study were on average
the Message Board inadvertently had evolved into an 64.4 years old (SD = 8.74). Eighteen participants
‘Ask the Professional’ service, rather than a vehicle for were female and 3 were males; 19 were non-Hispanic
establishing community among dementia caregivers. Whites and 2 were African Americans; 13 were spouses
As a consequence, we decided to add a chat room, and 8 were either daughters or daughters-in law of the
“AlzChat,” to facilitate real time interactions among care recipient. Their average length of caregiving and
peers and to facilitate peer socialization. We anticipate time spent with care recipient per week was 3.11 years
that AlzChat will provide opportunities to obtain useful (SD = 1.44) and 135.48 (SD = 54.1), respectively.
caregiving tips and information, enhance perceptions Three dependent measures were used to assess the
of social support, and in the long term, build caregiver effects of the Positive Caregiving classes: Steffen et
community. al.’s Caregiving Self-Efficacy scale (CSES) [23], Parke
et al.’s Stress-related Growth [24], and Lawton et al.’s
4.5. Initial program evaluation Caregiver Appraisal Inventory (CAI) [25]. The CSES
is a 30-item questionnaire containing three10-item sub-
The primary purpose of our initial program evalu-
scales that assess caregivers’ perceived self-efficacy in:
ation was to assess the effects of AlzOnline’s web-
(a) caring for their respite needs, (b) managing dis-
and telephone-based Positive Caregiving classes on the
ruptive and challenging behaviors of the care recipi-
psychosocial functioning of caregiver participants, par-
ent, and (c) responding to their own cognitions about
ticularly their perceptions of self-efficacy, emotional
caregiving demands. Respondents are asked to rate
growth, and burden from the caregiving experience.
their level of confidence (0% = cannot do at all, 50%
To date, we have enrolled 40 caregivers in our series
moderately certain can do, 100% = certain can do) in
of 7 Positive Caregiving classes. 3 Twenty-one care-
performing a variety of caregiving and self-care activ-
ities if they gave their best efforts. The Stress-related
3 Prior to taking interactive web-based classes, each caregiver Growth Scale is a 15-item questionnaire that measures
needed to optimize their computers using our Application Service caregivers’ appraisals of the benefits of the caregiv-
Provider’s set-up program. This set-up program checked the care- ing experience (e.g., increasing compassion for others,
giver’s computer to ensure that it was properly configured for chat
and for two-way audio transmissions. AlzOnline technical staff as-
self-confidence, and perseverance). Respondents are
sisted caregivers in performing the optimization procedure over the asked to rate the extent to which caregiving has led to
telephone. a variety of positive experiences on a 0 to 2 scale with
144 R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online

0 = not at all and 2 = a great deal. The Caregiver in the State of Florida. More than 33,000 older Florid-
Appraisal Inventory is a 19-item questionnaire used to ians of Hispanic-Latino descent currently have a diag-
assess caregivers’ perceptions of the demands and re- nosis of Alzheimer’s disease or a closely related condi-
wards of their role and role-related activities. The CAI tion [27]. Although professional and governmental or-
contains three subscales that were factor analytically ganizations have called for the development of demen-
derived: (a) subjective caregiving burden, (b) positive tia care programs tailored to the language and cultural
aspects of caregiving, and (c) burden. Participants are preferences of Hispanic caregivers, the current gap be-
asked to rate their appraisals of the consequences of tween the availability of such services and consumer
their caregiving duties on a five-point scale with 0 = demand continues to grow.
never true and 4 = nearly always true. In an effort to meet the educational and support
Mixed support was obtained for the effectiveness of needs of this important caregiver population, AlzOn-
AlzOnline Positive Caregiving classes. On the posi- line is in the process of translating all its web- and
tive side, participants reported significant pre- to post- telephone-based services into Spanish, including the
class increases on all three CSES subscales, and con- Message Board, Positive Caregiving classes, Library,
comitant decreases in subjective caregiving burden (all Helpful Links, and Expert Forum. We also plan to hire
ps < 0.05). Substantial improvements were noted in a Spanish-speaking counselor to facilitate telephone-
their perceptions of self-efficacy in performing routine based caregiver classes, respond to Message Board and
caregiving duties and managing challenging care recip- email inquiries, and to promote the website to the His-
ient behaviors, as well as their appraisals of the emo- panic community in Central and Southern Florida.
tional caregiver burden from the pre- to the posttesting A second future direction lies in the reconfiguration
phase. In contrast, caregivers report little or no change of AlzOnline’s Positive Caregiving classes. We plan
on the positive dimensions of the caregiving experience to digitally record the series of seven classes and make
(i.e., stress related growth and positive caregiving ap- them available on demand to caregiver participants.
praisals), as well as their perceptions of burden in pro- Caregivers will be encouraged to view each of the seven
viding caregiving assistance. Further replication of the prerecorded classes first, followed one week later by a
current study is required to determine whether the pos- live telephone follow-up discussion group. We antici-
itive dimensions of the caregiving role are substantially pate that this change in protocol will simplify signifi-
less sensitive to the effects of cognitive-behavioral in- cantly Internet-based class instruction, and enhance the
terventions, such as AlzOnline, than negative appraisals quality of interaction among caregivers and the class fa-
and attributions of self-efficacy in caregiving activities. cilitator. Furthermore, it builds on the strengths of each
Furthermore, caution should be exercised in interpret- transmission mode. The Internet is highly effective in
ing the findings of the current investigation. Both small delivering audiovisual instruction one-way (e.g., video
sample size and the absence of a control condition sub- streaming prerecorded classes from the telehealth cen-
stantially limit the internal validity of the results. ter to the caregiver’s home), but awkward to employ for
two-way oral communication. The opposite is the case
for telephone. Standard toll-free telephone is easy and
5. Future directions and clinical implications convenient to employ for two-way oral communication
(e.g., semi-structured discussion among caregiver par-
Two future directions are proposed to enhance the ticipants and the class facilitator), but not well suited
impact and accessibility of Alzheimer’s Caregiver Sup- for delivering didactic instruction.
port Online services. First, despite the burgeoning Finally, the clinical implications of AlzOnline’s Web
growth of Hispanic-Latino dementia caregivers in the and telephone education and support network are likely
United States over the past decade, there are currently to be substantial. AlzOnline has the potential of serving
only a limited number of education and support ser- as a prototype for other state elder care agencies and
vices that are tailored to the specific needs of these indi- provider networks to follow. The number of adults
viduals. This is especially the case for Hispanic-Latino who regularly use the Internet to obtain health care
family caregivers who are primarily Spanish speaking information continues to rise. According to a recent
and have not assimilated into the North American cul- Harris Poll approximately 110 million adults go online
ture [26]. an average three times a month to obtain information
There are few places in the country where the dearth on health-related topics [28]. A sizeable proportion of
of dementia support services is felt more acutely than these health seekers are garnering information about
R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online 145

specific treatments for family members with chronic [8] R.L. Glueckauf, T.U. Ketterson, J.S. Loomis, P. Dages and H.
illnesses and their caregivers. Benefield, Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online: Overview
and initial outcomes, Invited presentation at the 15th annual
However, before AlzOnline and other newly devel- conference of the American Association of Spinal Cord Injury
oped Internet-based alternative health care delivery ap- Psychologists and Social Workers, Las Vegas, NV, September
proaches are widely adopted, further research is needed 2002.
to assess their efficacy, cost-effectiveness and gener- [9] H.J. Liss, R.L. Glueckauf and E.P. Ecklund-Johnson, Research
on telehealth and chronic medical conditions: Critical review,
alizability across different caregiver populations. To key issues, and future directions, Rehab. Psych. 47 (2002),
this end, Glueckauf and colleagues have recently sub- 8–30.
mitted a NIMH grant proposal to assess the efficacy [10] D. Gallagher-Thompson, S. Lovett, J. Rose, C. McKibbin,
and cost effectiveness of an integrative Internet- and D. Coon, A. Futterman and L.W. Thompson, Impact of psy-
choeducational interventions on distressed family caregivers,
telephone-based prevention program (i.e., Online Pre- J Clin Geropsychol 6 (2000), 91–110.
vention of Depression and Anxiety) on the emotional, [11] J. Kennet, L. Burgio and R. Schulz, Intervention for in-home
interpersonal, and physical functioning of dementia caregivers: A review of research 1990 to present, in: Hand-
caregivers. Quota sampling procedures will be used to book on dementia caregiving: Evidence-based interventions
for family caregivers, R. Schulz, ed., Springer Publishing
create a pool of 140 non-Black Hispanic, 140 African- Company, New York, 2000, pp. 61–125.
American, and 140 non-Hispanic White caregivers of [12] D. Gallagher-Thompson and A.M. Steffen, Comparative ef-
adults with progressive dementia located primarily in fects of cognitive-behavioral and brief psychodynamic psy-
South and North Florida. Data will be collected pre- chotherapies for depressed family caregivers, J Consult Clin
Psychol 62(3) (1994), 543–549.
and one-week posttreatment, as well as at the three- [13] R.L. Glueckauf, S. Fritz, E.P. Ecklund-Johnson, H.J. Liss, P.
and six-month post-intervention follow-up. Dages and P. Carney, Home-based videocounseling for rural
teenagers with epilepsy: Phase I findings, Rehabil Psychol 47
(2002), 49–72.
[14] R.L. Glueckauf, B. Hufford, J. Whitton, J. Baxter, P. Schnei-
Acknowledgements der, J. Kain and S. Vogelgesang, Telehealth: Emerging tech-
nology in rehabilitation and health care, in: Medical aspects
This paper was supported by grants from the State of disability: A handbook for the rehabilitation professional,
of Florida Department of Elder Affairs and the Robert 2nd. ed., Springer Publishing Company, M.G. Eisenberg, R.L.
Glueckauf and H.H. Zaretsky, eds, NY, 1999, pp. 625–639.
Wood Johnson Foundation. We also gratefully ac- [15] D. Thompson and H.M. DeVries, Coping with frustration
knowledge the assistance of Pat Dages, Tim Ketterson, classes: Development and preliminary outcomes with women
and Eric Sanabria. who care for relatives with dementia, Gerontologist 34 (1994),
548–552.
[16] D. Gallagher-Thompson, C. Ossinalde and L.W. Thompson,
Coping with caregiving: A class for family caregivers, VA
References Palo Alto Healthcare System, Palo Alto, CA, 1996.
[17] R.L. Glueckauf, J. Horley, M.F. Poushinsky and R. Vogel,
[1] White House Conference on Aging, Putting aging on hold, Assertiveness training for disabled individuals in wheelchairs:
US Government Printing Office, Washington, DC, 1995. Preliminary findings, Int J Rehab Res 7 (1984), 59–61.
[2] National Institutes of Health, Progress report on Alzheimer’s [18] R.L. Glueckauf and A.L. Quittner, Assertiveness training for
disease (NIH Publication No. 99–4664), US Department of disabled adults in wheelchairs: Self-report, role-play, and ac-
Health and Human Services, Washington, DC, 1999. tivity pattern outcomes, J Consult Clin Psychol 60 (1992),
[3] National Alliance for Caregiving, Family caregiving in the 419–425.
US.: Findings from a national survey, National Alliance for [19] R.L. Glueckauf, D.W. Nickelson, J.D. Whitton and J.S.
Caregiving and American Association of Retired Persons, Loomis, Telehealth and healthcare psychology: Current de-
Washington, DC, 1997. velopments in telecommunications, regulatory practices, and
[4] R. Schulz, ed., Handbook on dementia caregiving: Evidence- research, in: Handbook of clinical health psychology: Mod-
based interventions for family caregivers, Springer Publishing els and perspectives in health psychology Vol. 3, T. Boll, J.
Company, New York, 2000. Baum, R. Frank, ed., American Psychological Association,
[5] R. Schulz, A.T. O’Brien, J. Bookwala and K. Fleissner, Psy- Washington, DC, in press.
chiatric and physical morbidity effects of dementia caregiving: [20] D. Gallagher-Thompson, S. Lovett, J. Rose, C. McKibbin, D.
Prevalence, correlates, and causes, Gerontologist 35 (1995), Coon, Futterman and L.W. Thompson, Impact of psychoed-
771–791. ucation interventions on distressed family caregivers, J Clin
[6] Florida Department of Elder Affairs, 2002–2003 Consumer Geropsychol (2000), 91–110.
Resource Guide, State of Florida Department of Elder Affairs, [21] D. Gallagher-Thompson, J. Rose, M. Florsheim, F. Gantz, P.
Tallahassee, FL, 2002. Jacome, S. Del-Maestro, L. Peters, D. Arguello, C. Johnson,
[7] R.L. Glueckauf, Alzheimer’s caregiver support online: Sup- R.S. Moorehead, T.M. Polich, M. Chesney and L.W. Thomp-
porting caregivers throughout Florida, Invited address at the son, Controlling your frustration: A class for caregivers, De-
Florida Alzheimer’s Summit 2002, Florida House of Repre- partment of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Palo Alto, CA,
sentatives, Tallahassee, FL, March 2002. 1992.
146 R.L. Glueckauf and J.S. Loomis / Alzheimer’s Caregiver Support Online

[22] P.M. Webb and R.L. Glueckauf, The effects of direct involve- [26] L.D. Burgio, N. Solano, S.E. Fisher, A. Stevens and
ment in goal setting on rehabilitation outcome for persons with D. Gallagher-Thompson, Skill-building: Psychoeducational
traumatic brain injury, Rehab Psychol 39 (1994), 179–188. strategies, in: Innovative interventions to reduce dementia
[23] A.M. Steffen, C. McKibbin, A.M. Zeiss, D. Gallagher- caregiver distress, D.W. Coon, D. Gallagher-Thompson and
Thompson and A. Bandura, The revised scale for caregiving L.W. Thompson, eds, New York, Springer Publishing Com-
self-efficacy: Reliability and validity studies, J Gerontology: pany, NY, 2003, pp. 119–138.
Psych Sciences 57 (2002), 74–86. [27] Florida Department of Elder Affairs, Florida County Profiles
[24] C.L. Parke, L.H. Cohen and R.L. Murch, Assessment and 2003. Retrieved from http://elderaffairs.state.fl.us/doea/eng-
prediction of stress-related growth, J Personality 64 (1996), lish/Stats/CoProfile 2003, PDF.
71–105. [28] H. Taylor, Cyberchondriacs update, The Harris Poll #21,
[25] M.P. Lawton, M. Kleban, M. Moss, M. Rovine and A. Glicks- Retrieved from http://www.harrisinteractive.com/harris poll/
man, Measuring caregiving appraisal, J Gerontology: Psych index.asp?PID=299, Accessed May 1, 2002.
Sciences 44 (1989), 61–71.

You might also like