Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Textbook The Swedish Presence in Afghanistan Security and Defence Transformation 1St Edition Arita Holmberg Ebook All Chapter PDF
Textbook The Swedish Presence in Afghanistan Security and Defence Transformation 1St Edition Arita Holmberg Ebook All Chapter PDF
https://textbookfull.com/product/security-and-defence-in-europe-
j-martin-ramirez/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-eus-common-security-and-
defence-policy-learning-communities-in-international-
organizations-1st-edition-giovanni-faleg-auth/
https://textbookfull.com/product/high-solids-alkyd-resins-first-
edition-holmberg/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-evolution-of-business-in-
the-cyber-age-digital-transformation-threats-and-security-1st-
edition-divya-gupta-chowdhry-editor/
European Union Security and Defence Policies Operations
and Transatlantic Challenges First Edition George
Voskopoulos (Editor)
https://textbookfull.com/product/european-union-security-and-
defence-policies-operations-and-transatlantic-challenges-first-
edition-george-voskopoulos-editor/
https://textbookfull.com/product/basic-swedish-a-grammar-and-
workbook-1st-edition-ian-hinchliffe/
https://textbookfull.com/product/border-management-in-
transformation-transnational-threats-and-security-policies-of-
european-states-1st-edition-johann-wagner/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-fighters-americans-in-
combat-in-afghanistan-and-iraq-first-edition-u-s-c-j-chivers/
https://textbookfull.com/product/haunting-modernity-and-the-
gothic-presence-in-british-modernist-literature-1st-edition-
daniel-darvay/
i
This book delivers on two analytical levels. First, it is a broad study of Sweden
as an international actor, an actor that at least for a brief period tried to play
a different international role than that to which it was accustomed. Second,
the book problematizes the role of international military missions as drivers
for change in the security and defence field. Several perspectives and levels
of analysis are covered, from the macro level of strategic discourse to the
micro level of the experiences of individual commanders. The book focuses
upon Sweden and its participation in the international military mission
in Afghanistan during 2002–12. It contributes to the growing literature
evaluating the mission in Afghanistan and explores the implications of the
security and defence practices that have dominated Western Europe for the
last decade.
The Routledge Series on Military Strategy and Operational Art analyzes and
assesses the synergistic interrelationship between joint and combined military
operations, national military strategy, grand strategy, and national political
objectives in peacetime, as well as during periods of armed conflict. In doing
so, the series highlights how various patterns of civil–military relations, as well
as styles of political and military leadership influence the outcome of armed
conflicts. In addition, the series highlights both the advantages and challenges
associated with the joint and combined use of military forces involved in
humanitarian relief, nation building, and peacekeeping operations, as well as
across the spectrum of conflict extending from limited conflicts fought for
limited political objectives to total war fought for unlimited objectives. Finally,
the series highlights the complexity and challenges associated with insurgency
and counter-insurgency operations, as well as conventional operations and
operations involving the possible use of weapons of mass destruction.
Edited by
Arita Holmberg and Jan Hallenberg
iv
Contents
1 Introduction 1
ARI TA H OL MBERG A N D JA N H A LLEN BERG
2 Conceptual framework 19
ARI TA H OL MBERG A N D JA N H A LLEN BERG
vi Contents
7 Leadership lessons: new challenges for smaller nations in
multinational, highly stressful missions 116
G E RRY L ARSSO N, A I DA A LV I N I U S, MA R I A F ORS B RANDE B O,
P E D E R H YLLEN G R EN, SO FI A N I LSSO N A ND AL ICIA OHL S S ON
10 Conclusions 182
ARI TA H OL MBERG A N D JA N H A LLEN BERG
Index 196
vii
List of figures
List of tables
Notes on contributors
x Notes on contributors
Sofia Nilsson (Ph.D., Karlstad University, Sweden) is a researcher at the
Department of Security, Strategy and Leadership at the Swedish Defence
University.
Erik Noreen (Ph.D., Uppsala University, Sweden) is Associate Professor at
the Department of Peace and Conflict Research at Uppsala University.
Alicia Ohlsson (M.A.) is a researcher in Psychology at the Department of
Security, Strategy and Leadership at the Swedish Defence University.
Inger Osterdahl (L.L.D., Uppsala University, Sweden) is Professor in Public
International Law at the Faculty of Law, Uppsala University.
Ake Sivertun (Ph.D., Umea University, Sweden) is Professor in Military
Technology at the Department of Military Studies at the Swedish Defence
University.
Ralph Sundberg (Ph.D., Uppsala University, Sweden) is Lecturer and a post-
doctoral researcher at the Department of Peace and Conflict Research,
Uppsala University.
1
1 Introduction
Arita Holmberg and Jan Hallenberg
• What influence has the Swedish engagement in Afghanistan had for each
chapter’s area of study during the past decade?
• What consequences can be identified for the chapter’s area of study and
the security and defence field as a whole?
The chapters are structured broadly around the research questions in their
area of study. Policies, strategies, organization or practices are highlighted
to various degrees in the different chapters, depending on their focus and
level of analysis. There is no doubt that this research task is complex. The
development of the Swedish security and defence fields is multifaceted, with
many nuances and sources of change. However, the long Swedish involvement
3
Introduction 3
in Afghanistan appears to have been an important factor in several respects
and a thorough analysis is needed to assess the role of this engagement.
The results can contribute to theoretical development in relation both to
the literature that considers broader changes in the security and defence field
and to the research that focuses on the transformation of the Armed Forces
of the world, in particular small- and medium-sized European militaries. In
addition, several of the chapters illustrate how changing security policies
and the transformation of the field both nourish and challenge the evolution
of the Swedish self-image. The introduction and the concluding chapter, in
particular, address these larger questions pertaining to the Swedish national
image in connection to international security affairs.
In the following, the Swedish empirical landscape and previous research
in relation to the theme of this book is introduced. We also present the inter-
national setting in which the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF)
has operated: Afghanistan. The literature concerning other countries that
have participated in the military mission in Afghanistan is touched upon to
see whether there are any relevant comparisons that can be made between
their experiences and those that Sweden has had. Finally, the chapters are
introduced.
Empirical background
What can be said about the empirical starting point in the Swedish case?
We argue that expressions of Swedish identity can be found by focusing on
policies, strategies, organization and practices, and therefore provide the
reader with a starting point as to where these appeared in the shift from the
1990s to the 2000s. The aim is both to provide a departure for the analysis
in the subsequent empirical chapters and to present analytical aspects with
which to assess conclusions about possible changes due to international
engagement.
Explanations for Swedish participation in international operations since
the end of the Cold War are multiple, ranging from the defence of values to
the protection of the Swedish homeland beyond its borders to opportunities
for the military to train (Angstrom 2010, Holmberg 2013). Swedish politi-
cians have made enormous efforts to defend and explain the use of force,
both to a national (public) and an international (elite) audience. If Ringmar’s
(2007, pp. 90–1) checklist of requirements for explaining action through iden-
tity is applied, there are clear indications that international operations played
a significant role in the telling of the story of the new Swedish security policy
in a situation where security was seen as gained through cooperation rather
than isolation.
The Social Democrats may have had difficulties with telling this story con-
vincingly; their mindset was likely to have been particularly influenced by the
dominance of the neutrality policy as a result of years of social democratic
hegemony in Swedish politics during the Cold War. However, the decades
4
These sentences indicate that the Swedish Government at the time envisioned
a role for Sweden that was more proactive, on a larger scale and with the
option of the use of military force to a larger extent than traditionally had
been the case. It is difficult not to link these views directly to the Swedish
military mission in Afghanistan. During these years (from perhaps 2006
to 2012), several if not most of the countries participating with forces
in Afghanistan had a positive view of the chances for a transformation
of Afghan society as a result of a successful international mission in
Afghanistan. The Swedish Government clearly shared this optimism and
the document cited is an indication of this. At the time of writing in late
2015, with the clear majority of the foreign forces having left Afghanistan
at the end of 2014, this optimism no longer exists. Instead, the participating
5
Introduction 5
countries seem to concentrate on leaving the country in the best possible
condition, albeit far from the ideals imagined some 5 years earlier. In
assessing the role of international engagement for transformation in the
security and defence field, we have an opportunity to consider the state
of this change in the Swedish self-image. This discussion is pursued in the
concluding chapter.
Policies
Sweden has not been at war with another state for over 200 years. During
the twentieth century its ability to stay outside great power conflict was seen
as linked to its policy of neutrality, which became an important part of
the Swedish identity. The neutrality policy implied that a relatively strong
national defence capability was maintained, since Sweden did not join any
of the alliances that were established in Europe following the Second World
War (as a consequence, it is one of few countries in Europe that until the
end of the Cold War lacked major experience of defence integration in the
form of membership in alliances). With EU membership in the mid 1990s,
the neutrality and non-alignment policy became obsolete. Neutrality was
abandoned and non-alignment evolved into military non-alignment, a
policy that has gradually become less important: largely as a consequence
of Sweden’s membership in the EU and the development of the Common
European Security and Defence Policy (Eriksson 2006).
Sweden has also gradually enhanced its partnership with NATO (Edstrom
et al. (Eds) 2011, Wagnsson 2011). With the changed foreign and security
policy orientation, the strategies, organization and practices of the Swedish
Armed Forces (SAF) gradually changed. Starting with the 1992 Government
Bill, the SAF were reformed and resources reduced. In 1995, the Swedish
security policy was said to contain both a national and an international
dimension. Still, however, defence policy remained part of the national
domain. The defence policy decision in 1999 introduced a new main task for
the SAF: international operations. This development was due to a changed
threat perception and a widened view of security policy. During the following
years, the reform of Swedish security and defence policy was to accelerate
(Eriksson 2006).
Strategies
It could be argued that the main Swedish security and defence strategy at the
time of the Cold War was to pursue an independent policy and organize the
defence on a national basis. As indicated, the new situation following the fall
of the Berlin Wall and the broadened perception of security changed this
strategy. During the 1990s, the focus upon territorial defence was gradually
abolished – although a strategy of recapturing the territorial defence was
present on paper (Rydén 2003). Sweden started to seek security solutions
6
Petersson argues that, in the 20-year period following the end of the Cold
War, all the fundamental aspects constituting Swedish security and defence
were changed: the goals, the means and the methods (Petersson 2010, p. 148).
In the spring of 2015, the Swedish Government submitted a defence bill
to Parliament that radically contradicts this view. We return to this in the
concluding chapter.
Organization
During the Cold War, both the organization of the defence policy process
in Sweden and the Swedish Armed Forces (SAF) as an authority were quite
static, and the SAF independently developed doctrines and military thinking
(Zetterberg 1999, p. 57). Due to the changed policies and strategies, the
organization of the Swedish security and defence policy has become a more
dynamic process that is of concern to more actors. Internationalization and
Europeanization hit rather directly into the heart of the organization of the
SAF, and as the use of military means and the Armed Forces becomes more
political, so does their organization.
In many ways, the Swedish Armed Forces have – during the years fol-
lowing the end of the Cold War – evolved in ways that largely correspond
to Moskos’s (2000) postmodern Armed Forces (Petersson 2010, Holmberg
2015). Since the end of the Cold War, Sweden has gone through much
the same transformation with respect to its Armed Forces as many other
European small- and medium-sized countries. The focus has been on down-
sizing and reorientation away from a national defence towards an inter-
operable defence to be used in international operations. The economic
7
Introduction 7
constraints on the defence sector are also likely to be similar to those in
most other countries.
The number of military forces has, according to estimations made by
Petersson (2010, p. 155), decreased by approximately 72–93 per cent (there
are differences between the defence branches) from 1988 to 2009. As a conse-
quence of the neutrality policy and the substantial long-term investments in
modern technology, Swedish air force capabilities are, however, still relatively
large in comparison to similar states.
Practices
Internationalization and Europeanization have constituted prominent aspects
of the transformation of the security and defence fields in Sweden since the
end of the Cold War. In the context of this book, we consider practices in
relation to participation in international operations. Naturally, different parts
of the field have different forms of practices. Like several of the other Nordic
countries, Swedish identity has a self-perception of being a do-gooder in
international affairs – which implies that, politically, military force is not used
without hesitation. Concerning participation in international missions, the
Swedish position has traditionally been dual: both sceptical and activist (Andrén
1996, p. 214 concerning the United Nations (UN)). On the one hand, Swedish
politicians have been sceptical towards using the military instrument for security
policy purposes (Petersson 2002); on the other hand, they have supported the UN
and decided upon participation in many UN and NATO operations of various
kinds. The Swedish Governments have made a priority of participating in EU
operations, contributing to more or less every single EU mission undertaken.
Swedish rationalizations for the use of force are a complex affair, and many a
reason for international participation has been brought forward over the years.
It is, however, reasonable to conclude that mainly political considerations have
driven Swedish engagement (Petersson 2002, Angstrom 2010, Holmberg 2013).
The international tasks have, however, to be weighed against the defence of
the homeland. This is a balancing act that may in practice become difficult for
both politicians and the military to pursue (Edstrom & Gyllensporre 2014).
Angstrom has argued that the Swedish strategic culture, which is divided into
one national and one international part, has constituted an obstacle for trans-
formation due to experiences connected to international operations, particularly
at the organizational level (Angstrom 2010). One of the most interesting aspects
to analyze is whether or not this division of strategic culture in Sweden has been
overcome due to the influence of the international engagement in Afghanistan.
Introduction 9
With the Afghanistan mission much was changed in the reference points
of Swedish security policy and military, to the extent that the changes
may be hard to detect and consider. The realities of coalition warfare
are only one of the lessons of the Afghanistan war. Other lessons are the
Swedish inability to create functioning civil–military coordination (not
only in rhetoric), the sluggishness of the military adaptation process in
the face of changed circumstances in the operations area, in terms of
materiel, organization and mental [preparedness]. Last but not least, the
Afghanistan mission made visible the existence of a remarkably great
democratic deficit in the security policy area.
(Agrell 2013, p. 331. Translated from
Swedish by the authors.)
Introduction 11
to reinforce existing national developments (Eriksson et al. 2013, pp. 66–8,
Rasmussen 2014). In the case of Denmark, Rasmussen notes that adaptation
was ‘second-order’; that is, the Danish military adapted to changes in the
British military’s approach and the Danish civilian effort adapted to the UN’s
development in Afghanistan (Rasmussen 2014, p. 155).
One assessment of the Danish participation in both the Afghanistan mis-
sion and the war in Iraq concludes that particularly Copenhagen’s role in
the latter war meant that Denmark’s leaders had access to the White House
to an extent that is unusual for such a small NATO member (Henriksen &
Ringsmose 2012). In the case of Norway, Heier argues that the balancing
between national and international operations had become more and more
difficult to handle during the period of the Afghanistan mission (Heier 2014,
pp. 232–5). New tasks gave the military more of an expertise function, the
new role brought a new sense of individual responsibility and a new iden-
tity as warfighters was born (and shared among the segment of the military
organization that has this experience) (Heier 2014, pp. 227–30). This observa-
tion has similarities with the Canadian experience.
Finally, a note on the German experience is required. Hilpert views this
operational experience as the last step in transforming German strategic cul-
ture regarding the use of force, making it acceptable for the country to par-
ticipate in combat operations (Hilpert 2014, p. 186). In the beginning of the
2000s, the discourse was similar to the one present a decade earlier, focus-
ing on peacekeeping in the Balkans. However, with the introduction of the
Counterinsurgency (COIN) doctrine, the understanding of warfare and the
soldier’s role started to change slowly. Operational equipment needs were dealt
with, but procurement patterns adapted slowly. Hilpert argues that change
was undertaken only after external influence, which some agents acted upon
(Hilpert 2014, pp. 187–8). Since the Afghanistan operation and its develop-
ment constitutes the external factor, this can also be seen as a bottom-up
process.
Introduction 13
A final aspect should be mentioned in our attempt to achieve a brief clari-
fication of the vital ingredients of a very complex conflict situation. This is
that, ever since their inception in 1994, the Taliban in Afghanistan has been
supported (with varying intensity, but seemingly without end) by the ISI: the
Inter-Services Intelligence Agency of Pakistan (See Rashid 2008, particularly
pp. 84–96 and 110–24, Roy-Chaudhury 2011).
During the second half of the 1990s, Afghanistan was gradually pulled
into what was to become an internationalized conflict: the struggle between
the United States and the self-proclaimed guardian of Islamic virtue, Al
Qaeda, led by the Saudi exile Osama bin Laden. When the Sudanese authori-
ties, responding to pressure from Washington, decided to expel Osama bin
Laden from the country in 1996, bin Laden and his allies were given sanctu-
ary by Mullah Omar, the leader of the Taliban in Afghanistan. During five
years of existence and build-up in Afghanistan, Al Qaeda created what are
reported by some to have been more than 120 training camps in Afghanistan
(see ‘Strategic Geography’, Dodge & Redman (Eds) 2011). On 11 September
2001, Al Qaeda was ready to strike at the United States.
It was in direct response to the Al Qaeda attacks against the United States
in September 2001 that first US and then other international forces entered
Afghanistan, starting with some US special operations forces in October
2001. A large international conference on the future of Afghanistan was held
in December 2001. Starting in 2002, military forces from many members of
the UN – including Sweden – started to arrive in Afghanistan. Their mission
was to stabilize and rebuild a country ravaged by many years of war. What
started as a US- and to some extent a UN-led mission gradually evolved into
a NATO mission in 2003. The creation of ISAF – the International Security
Assistance Force – was to serve as the nucleus of the international mission in
Afghanistan for many years.
ISAF has gone through many different phases. The complexity and devel-
opment of the mission itself is thus an additional dimension of the case that
makes it stand out somewhat in comparison to other international missions
conducted by the international community since the end of the Cold War (the
Iraq War being the most similar example, although in that case the interna-
tional community was less united). The initial phase of the ISAF operation
in Afghanistan was characterized by the challenges of trying to meet the mis-
sion’s state-building aims, which largely required capabilities that NATO did
not have at its disposal. An awareness of the need for coordination with other
actors in the international community emerged; in 2006, the comprehensive
approach was adopted and intense coordination efforts followed (Yost 2014,
pp. 138–9).
By 2006–10, the operation encountered growing resistance, which led to a
focus upon counterinsurgency. From 2011–14, a period of withdrawal, down-
sizing and training took place, with the aim of transferring responsibility for
Afghanistan’s security to its national forces in 2014. Subsequently, a training,
advice and assistance mission called ‘Resolute Support’ has been approved
14
Over the decade, the American military footprint increased from approxi-
mately 1,000 Special Forces troops in 2001 to nearly 100,000 mostly con-
ventional troops and several thousand civilians from various agencies by
mid-2011. This increased level of effort and broadened strategic focus
in itself represented a monumental adaptation that dramatically affected
the conduct of units in the field.
(Russel 2014, p. 55)
Outline
Following this introduction, the conceptual framework of the book is
developed in Chapter 2. Starting at the political–strategic level, Jan Angstrom
and Erik Noreen aim in Chapter 3 to study the imprints that the Afghanistan
intervention has made on Swedish strategy, drawing attention to the strains
between the national and the international in Swedish strategic culture. In
Chapter 4, Inger Osterdahl reflects on the developments in international
15
Introduction 15
law and how the Swedish Government related to these in its reasoning
regarding the Swedish use of force. Turning to the events in the field, in
Chapter 5, Magnus Johnsson analyzes organizational innovations at the
tactical level that have taken place in Afghanistan during the 10 years of
the Swedish mission that this book covers. In Chapter 6, Ake Sivertun, in
an empirical essay of slightly different character than our other chapters,
addresses military–technological aspects of the mission, experiences related
to these and their possible imprints at different levels. Gerry Larsson and
his colleagues draw ‘leadership lessons’ in Chapter 7, highlighting individual
experiences with implications for organizational development. Chapter 8
by Robert Egnell looks at how gender mainstreaming and issues relating
to UN resolution 1325 became a focal point of the mission and fed into
organizational change in the SAF. In Chapter 9, Ralph Sundberg studies
the veteran policy that the Swedish Government developed and conducted
during the years of the Afghanistan mission, reflecting on changes in views
of the profession. Finally, in Chapter 10 the editors draw conclusions from
the empirical chapters and compare and contrast these findings with what we
know from previous research about the role of international operations in
transformation processes. This chapter also further addresses the changing
identity of Sweden, highlighting both prospects and constraints for its future
sustainability.
Notes
1 A good account of the ethnic groups in Afghanistan can be found in Dodge &
Redman (Eds) (2011). Compare Barfield 2010, pp. 24–31.
2 Indeed, one estimate is that there are currently more than 7 million Pashtun in
Afghanistan and 14 million in neighbouring Pakistan (Encyclopaedia Britannica
2013).
References
Agrell, W. (2013) Ett krig har och nu: Sveriges vag till vapnad konflikt i Afghanistan
[A war here and now: Sweden’s road to armed conflict in Afghanistan]. Stockholm:
Atlantis.
Andrén, N. (1996) Maktbalans och alliansfrihet: Svensk utrikespolitik under 1900–talet
[Balance of power and non-alignment: Swedish foreign policy during the twentieth
century]. Stockholm: Norsteds juridik.
Angstrom, J. (2010) ‘Forsvarsmaktens internationella insatser: I den svenska sakerheten
eller identitetens tjanst?’ [International missions: In the service of Swedish security
or identity?] in Engelbrekt, K. & J. Angstrom (Eds) Svensk sakerhetspolitik i Europa
och varlden [Swedish security policy in Europe and the world]. Stockholm: Norstedts
Juridik, pp. 169–202.
Angstrom, J. & J.W. Honig (2012) ‘Regaining strategy: Small powers, strategic culture,
and escalation in Afghanistan’ The Journal of Strategic Studies Vol. 35, No. 5,
pp. 663–87.
16
Introduction 17
Kirchner, E.J. & J. Sperling (Eds) (2007) Global security governance: Competing
perceptions of security in the twenty-first century 1st Edition. London: Routledge.
Kirkey, C. & N. Ostroy (2010) ‘Why is Canada in Afghanistan? Explaining Canada’s
military commitment’ Special Issue: Canada’s Commitment to Afghanistan, American
Journal of Canadian Studies, Vol. 40, No. 2, pp. 200–13.
Larsen, H.B.L. (2013) ‘NATO in Afghanistan: Democratization warfare, national
narratives and budgetary austerity’. Cambridge, MA: Belfer Center for Science and
International Affairs, Harvard University.
Lieven, A. (2011) Pakistan: A hard country London/New York: Allen Lane.
Maley, W. (2006) Rescuing Afghanistan. London: Hurst & Co.
Marten, K. (2010) ‘From Kabul to Kandahar: The Canadian forces and change,’
Special Issue: Canada’s Commitment to Afghanistan, American Journal of Canadian
Studies, Vol. 40, No. 2, pp. 214–36.
Moskos, C.C. (2000) ‘Toward a postmodern military: The United States as a
paradigm’, in Moskos, C., C.J. Allen Williams & D.R. Segal (Eds) The postmodern
military: Armed Forces after the Cold War. New York: Oxford University Press,
pp. 14–31.
Osterdahl, I. (2010) ‘The use of force: Sweden, the Jus ad Bellum and the European
Security and Defence Policy,’ Nordic Journal of International Law Vol. 79, pp.
141–88.
Petersson, M. (2002) ‘Break glass only in case of war…’ IFS Info Vol. 5, No. 2,
pp. 4–21.
Petersson, M. (2010) ‘Forsvarstransformeringen efter det kalla krigets slut:
klassificering, forklaring, karakteristik’ [‘Defence transformation after the end of
the Cold War: Classification, explanation and characteristics’] in Engelbrekt, K.
& J. Angstrom (Eds) Svensk sakerhetspolitik i Europa och varlden [Swedish security
policy in Europe and the World]. Stockholm: Norstedts Juridik, pp.147–67.
Rashid, A. (2001) Taliban. New Haven, CN/London: Yale Nota Bene, Yale University
Press.
Rashid, A. (2008) Descent into chaos: The United States and the failure of nation
building in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Central Asia. New York: Viking.
Rasmussen, M.L V. (2014) ‘The military metier: Second order adaptation and the
Danish experience in task force Helmand’ in Farrell, T., F. Osinga & J.A. Russell
(Eds) Military adaptation in Afghanistan. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Ringmar, E. (2007) Identity, interest and action A cultural explanation of Sweden’s
intervention in the Thirty Years War. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Roosberg, H. & A. Weibull (2014) ‘Forsvarsmakten efter ISAF: Lardomar och
paverkan pa militarstrategisk niva’ [The Swedish Armed Forces after ISAF: Lessons
learned and consequences at the military strategic level] FOI report, FOI-R-
3914-SE, August 2014.
Roy-Chaudhury, R. (2011) ‘Pakistan’ in (Eds) Dodge, T. & N. Redman Afghanistan:
2015 and beyond. London: International Institute for Strategic Studies/Routledge,
pp. 167–85.
Rubin, B. (2002) The fragmentation of Afghanistan: State formation and collapse in the
international system 2nd edition. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Russel, J.A. (2014) ‘Into the great Wadi: The United States and the war in Afghanistan’
in Farrell, T., F. Osinga & J.A. Russell (Eds) Military adaptation in Afghanistan.
Stanford: Stanford University Press, pp. 51–82.
18
Mr. Densch sat in the corner of Mrs. Densch’s Louis XIV boudoir.
He sat all hunched up on a little gilt pinkbacked chair with his
potbelly resting on his knees. In his green sagging face the pudgy
nose and the folds that led from the flanges of the nostrils to the
corners of the wide mouth made two triangles. He had a pile of
telegrams in his hand, on top a decoded message on a blue slip that
read: Deficit Hamburg branch approximately $500,000; signed
Heintz. Everywhere he looked about the little room crowded with
fluffy glittery objects he saw the purple letters of approximately
jiggling in the air. Then he noticed that the maid, a pale mulatto in a
ruffled cap, had come into the room and was staring at him. His eye
lit on a large flat cardboard box she held in her hand.
“What’s that?”
“Somethin for the misses sir.”
“Bring it here.... Hickson’s ... and what does she want to be buying
more dresses for will you tell me that.... Hickson’s.... Open it up. If it
looks expensive I’ll send it back.”
The maid gingerly pulled off a layer of tissuepaper, uncovering a
peach and peagreen evening dress.
Mr. Densch got to his feet spluttering, “She must think the war’s
still on.... Tell em we will not receive it. Tell em there’s no such party
livin here.”
The maid picked up the box with a toss of the head and went out
with her nose in the air. Mr. Densch sat down in the little chair and
began looking over the telegrams again.
“Ann-ee, Ann-ee,” came a shrill voice from the inner room; this
was followed by a head in a lace cap shaped like a libertycap and a
big body in a shapeless ruffled negligée. “Why J. D. what are you
doing here at this time of the morning? I’m waiting for my
hairdresser.”
“It’s very important.... I just had a cable from Heintz. Serena my
dear, Blackhead and Densch is in a very bad way on both sides of
the water.”
“Yes ma’am,” came the maid’s voice from behind him.
He gave his shoulders a shrug and walked to the window. He felt
tired and sick and heavy with flesh. An errand boy on a bicycle
passed along the street; he was laughing and his cheeks were pink.
Densch saw himself, felt himself for a second hot and slender
running bareheaded down Pine Street years ago catching the girls’
ankles in the corner of his eye. He turned back into the room. The
maid had gone.
“Serena,” he began, “cant you understand the seriousness...? It’s
this slump. And on top of it all the bean market has gone to hell. It’s
ruin I tell you....”
“Well my dear I dont see what you expect me to do about it.”
“Economize ... economize. Look where the price of rubber’s gone
to.... That dress from Hickson’s....”
“Well you wouldnt have me going to the Blackhead’s party looking
like a country schoolteacher, would you?”
Mr. Densch groaned and shook his head. “O you wont
understand; probably there wont be any party.... Look Serena there’s
no nonsense about this.... I want you to have a trunk packed so that
we can sail any day.... I need a rest. I’m thinking of going to
Marienbad for the cure.... It’ll do you good too.”
Her eye suddenly caught his. All the little wrinkles on her face
deepened; the skin under her eyes was like the skin of a shrunken
toy balloon. He went over to her and put his hand on her shoulder
and was puckering his lips to kiss her when suddenly she flared up.
“I wont have you meddling between me and my dressmakers.... I
wont have it ... I wont have it....”
“Oh have it your own way.” He left the room with his head
hunched between his thick sloping shoulders.
“Ann-ee!”
“Yes ma’am.” The maid came back into the room.
Mrs. Densch had sunk down in the middle of a little spindlelegged
sofa. Her face was green. “Annie please get me that bottle of sweet
spirits of ammonia and a little water.... And Annie you can call up
Hickson’s and tell them that that dress was sent back through a
mistake of ... of the butler’s and please to send it right back as I’ve
got to wear it tonight.”
S
eeping in red twilight out of the Gulf
Stream fog, throbbing brassthroat that
howls through the stiff-fingered streets,
prying open glazed eyes of skyscrapers,
splashing red lead on the girdered thighs of
the five bridges, teasing caterwauling
tugboats into heat under the toppling
smoketrees of the harbor.
Spring puckering our mouths, spring
giving us gooseflesh grows gigantic out of
the droning of sirens, crashes with
enormous scaring din through the halted
traffic, between attentive frozen tiptoe
blocks.
r. Densch with the collar of his woolly ulster up round his ears
M and a big English cap pulled down far over his eyes, walked
nervously back and forth on the damp boat deck of the
Volendam. He looked out through a drizzly rain at the gray wharf
houses and the waterfront buildings etched against a sky of
inconceivable bitterness. A ruined man, a ruined man, he kept
whispering to himself. At last the ship’s whistle boomed out for the
third time. Mr. Densch, his fingers in his ears, stood screened by a
lifeboat watching the rift of dirty water between the ship’s side and
the wharf widen, widen. The deck trembled under his feet as the
screws bit into the current. Gray like a photograph the buildings of
Manhattan began sliding by. Below decks the band was playing O
Titin-e Titin-e. Red ferryboats, carferries, tugs, sandscows,
lumberschooners, tramp steamers drifted between him and the
steaming towering city that gathered itself into a pyramid and began
to sink mistily into the browngreen water of the bay.
Mr. Densch went below to his stateroom. Mrs. Densch in a cloche
hat hung with a yellow veil was crying quietly with her head on a
basket of fruit. “Dont Serena,” he said huskily. “Dont.... We like
Marienbad.... We need a rest. Our position isnt so hopeless. I’ll go
and send Blackhead a radio.... After all it’s his stubbornness and
rashness that brought the firm to ... to this. That man thinks he’s a
king on earth.... This’ll ... this’ll get under his skin. If curses can kill I’ll
be a dead man tomorrow.” To his surprise he found the gray drawn
lines of his face cracking into a smile. Mrs. Densch lifted her head
and opened her mouth to speak to him, but the tears got the better of
her. He looked at himself in the glass, squared his shoulders and
adjusted his cap. “Well Serena,” he said with a trace of jauntiness in
his voice, “this is the end of my business career.... I’ll go send that
radio.”
Mother’s face swoops down and kisses him; his hands clutch her
dress, and she has gone leaving him in the dark, leaving a frail
lingering fragrance in the dark that makes him cry. Little Martin lies
tossing within the iron bars of his crib. Outside dark, and beyond
walls and outside again the horrible great dark of grownup people,
rumbling, jiggling, creeping in chunks through the windows, putting
fingers through the crack in the door. From outside above the roar of
wheels comes a strangling wail clutching his throat. Pyramids of dark
piled above him fall crumpling on top of him. He yells, gagging
between yells. Nounou walks towards the crib along a saving
gangplank of light “Dont you be scared ... that aint nothin.” Her black
face grins at him, her black hand straightens the covers. “Just a fire
engine passin.... You wouldn’t be sceered of a fire engine.”
Ellen leaned back in the taxi and closed her eyes for a second.
Not even the bath and the halfhour’s nap had washed out the
fagging memory of the office, the smell of it, the chirruping of
typewriters, the endlessly repeated phrases, faces, typewritten
sheets. She felt very tired; she must have rings under her eyes. The
taxi had stopped. There was a red light in the traffic tower ahead.
Fifth Avenue was jammed to the curbs with taxis, limousines,
motorbusses. She was late; she had left her watch at home. The
minutes hung about her neck leaden as hours. She sat up on the
edge of the seat, her fists so tightly clenched that she could feel
through her gloves her sharp nails digging into the palms of her
hands. At last the taxi jerked forward, there was a gust of exhausts
and whir of motors, the clot of traffic began moving up Murray Hill. At
a corner she caught sight of a clock. Quarter of eight. The traffic
stopped again, the brakes of the taxi shrieked, she was thrown
forward on the seat. She leaned back with her eyes closed, the
blood throbbing in her temples. All her nerves were sharp steel
jangled wires cutting into her. “What does it matter?” she kept asking
herself. “He’ll wait. I’m in no hurry to see him. Let’s see, how many
blocks?... Less than twenty, eighteen.” It must have been to keep
from going crazy people invented numbers. The multiplication table
better than Coué as a cure for jangled nerves. Probably that’s what
old Peter Stuyvesant thought, or whoever laid the city out in
numbers. She was smiling to herself. The taxi had started moving
again.
George Baldwin was walking back and forth in the lobby of the
hotel, taking short puffs of a cigarette. Now and then he glanced at
the clock. His whole body was screwed up taut like a high
violinstring. He was hungry and full up with things he wanted to say;
he hated waiting for people. When she walked in, cool and silky and
smiling, he wanted to go up to her and hit her in the face.
“George do you realize that it’s only because numbers are so cold
and emotionless that we’re not all crazy?” she said giving him a little
pat on the arm.
“Fortyfive minutes waiting is enough to drive anybody crazy, that’s
all I know.”
“I must explain it. It’s a system. I thought it all up coming up in the
taxi.... You go in and order anything you like. I’m going to the ladies’
room a minute.... And please have me a Martini. I’m dead tonight,
just dead.”
“You poor little thing, of course I will.... And dont be long please.”
His knees were weak under him, he felt like melting ice as he
went into the gilt ponderously ornamented diningroom. Good lord
Baldwin you’re acting like a hobbledehoy of seventeen ... after all
these years too. Never get anywhere that way.... “Well Joseph what
are you going to give us to eat tonight? I’m hungry.... But first you
can get Fred to make the best Martini cocktail he ever made in his
life.”
“Tres bien monsieur,” said the longnosed Roumanian waiter and
handed him the menu with a flourish.
Ellen stayed a long time looking in the mirror, dabbing a little
superfluous powder off her face, trying to make up her mind. She
kept winding up a hypothetical dollself and setting it in various
positions. Tiny gestures ensued, acted out on various model stages.
Suddenly she turned away from the mirror with a shrug of her
toowhite shoulders and hurried to the diningroom.
“Oh George I’m starved, simply starved.”
“So am I” he said in a crackling voice. “And Elaine I’ve got news
for you,” he went on hurriedly as if he were afraid she’d interrupt him.
“Cecily has consented to a divorce. We’re going to rush it through
quietly in Paris this summer. Now what I want to know is, will you...?”
She leaned over and patted his hand that grasped the edge of the
table. “George lets eat our dinner first.... We’ve got to be sensible.
God knows we’ve messed things up enough in the past both of us....
Let’s drink to the crime wave.” The smooth infinitesimal foam of the
cocktail was soothing in her tongue and throat, glowed gradually
warmly through her. She looked at him laughing with sparkling eyes.
He drank his at a gulp.
“By gad Elaine,” he said flaming up helplessly, “you’re the most
wonderful thing in the world.”
Through dinner she felt a gradual icy coldness stealing through
her like novocaine. She had made up her mind. It seemed as if she
had set the photograph of herself in her own place, forever frozen
into a single gesture. An invisible silk band of bitterness was
tightening round her throat, strangling. Beyond the plates, the ivory
pink lamp, the broken pieces of bread, his face above the blank
shirtfront jerked and nodded; the flush grew on his cheeks; his nose
caught the light now on one side, now on the other, his taut lips
moved eloquently over his yellow teeth. Ellen felt herself sitting with
her ankles crossed, rigid as a porcelain figure under her clothes,
everything about her seemed to be growing hard and enameled, the
air bluestreaked with cigarettesmoke, was turning to glass. His
wooden face of a marionette waggled senselessly in front of her. She
shuddered and hunched up her shoulders.
“What’s the matter, Elaine?” he burst out. She lied:
“Nothing George.... Somebody walked over my grave I guess.”
“Couldnt I get you a wrap or something?”
She shook her head.
“Well what about it?” he said as they got up from the table.
“What?” she asked smiling. “After Paris?”
“I guess I can stand it if you can George,” she said quietly.
He was waiting for her, standing at the open door of a taxi. She
saw him poised spry against the darkness in a tan felt hat and a light
tan overcoat, smiling like some celebrity in the rotogravure section of
a Sunday paper. Mechanically she squeezed the hand that helped
her into the cab.
“Elaine,” he said shakily, “life’s going to mean something to me
now.... God if you knew how empty life had been for so many years.
I’ve been like a tin mechanical toy, all hollow inside.”
“Let’s not talk about mechanical toys,” she said in a strangled
voice.
“No let’s talk about our happiness,” he shouted.
Inexorably his lips closed on to hers. Beyond the shaking glass
window of the taxi, like someone drowning, she saw out of a corner
of an eye whirling faces, streetlights, zooming nickleglinting wheels.
The old man in the checked cap sits on the brownstone stoop with
his face in his hands. With the glare of Broadway in their backs there
is a continual flickering of people past him towards the theaters down
the street. The old man is sobbing through his fingers in a sour reek
of gin. Once in a while he raises his head and shouts hoarsely, “I
cant, dont you see I cant?” The voice is inhuman like the splitting of
a plank. Footsteps quicken. Middleaged people look the other way.
Two girls giggle shrilly as they look at him. Streeturchins nudging
each other peer in and out through the dark crowd. “Bum Hootch.”
“He’ll get his when the cop on the block comes by.” “Prohibition
liquor.” The old man lifts his wet face out of his hands, staring out of
sightless bloodyrimmed eyes. People back off, step on the feet of the
people behind them. Like splintering wood the voice comes out of
him. “Don’t you see I cant...? I cant ... I cant.”