Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Screenshot 2024-04-02 at 12.31.21
Screenshot 2024-04-02 at 12.31.21
by
Ibtisam Haider
FA19-PHM-065/ATD
Maryan Yousaf
FA19-PHM-066/ATD
Muhammad Asghar Khanzada
FA19-PHM-067/ATD
Muhammad SAAD Kahlid
FA19-PHM-068/ATD
Muhammad Usman Khan
FA19-PHM-069/ATD
Pharm-D (Doctor of Pharmacy)
Thesis
in
Clinical Pharmacy
COMSATS University Islamabad
Abbottabad Campus - Pakistan
Department of Pharmacy
Spring, 2024
2
COMSATS University Islamabad - Abbottabad
Campus
Pharmacotherapy of Geriatrics
A Thesis Presented to
Abbottabad Campus
Pharmacotherapy of Geriatrics
An undergraduate thesis submitted to the Department of Pharmacy as partial
fulfilment of the requirement for the award of Degree of Pharm-D (Doctor of
Pharmacy)
Muhammad Asghar
FA19-PHM-081/ATD
Khanzada
Department of Pharmacy
COMSATS University Islamabad (CUI)
Abbottabad Campus
April 2024
2
Final Approval
Pharmacotherapy of Geriatrics
by
Ibtisam Haider
FA19-PHM-065/ATD
Maryam Yousaf
FA19-PHM-066/ATD
Muhammad Asghar Khanzada
FA19-PHM-067/ATD
Saad Kahlid
FA19-PHM-068/ATD
Muhammad Usman Khan
FA19-PHM-069/ATD
Supervisor: __________________________________________________________
Dr. Ashfaq Muhammad
Assistant Professor
Department of Pharmacy, CUI, Abbottabad Campus
HoD: ______________________________________________________________
Prof. Dr. Abdul Mannan
Department of Pharmacy, CUI, Abbottabad Campus
Declaration
___________________________
Ibtisam Haider
FA19-PHM-040/ATD
Signature of the student:
___________________________
Maryam Yousaf
FA19-PHM-074/ATD
Signature of the student:
____________________________
Muhammad Asghar Khanzada
FA19-PHM-081/ATD
Signature of the student:
____________________________
Saad Kahlid
FA19-PHM-082/ATD
Signature of the student:
____________________________
Muhammad Usman Khan
FA19-PHM-085/ATD
Signature of the student:
Certificate
Date: _________________
Supervisor
__________________________
_
Dr. Ashfaq Muhammad
Head of Department
_____________________________
Prof. Dr. Abdul Mannan
Department of Pharmacy
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Ibtisam Haider, FA19-PHM-065/ATD
Maryam Yousaf, FA19-PHM-
066/ATD
Muhammad Asghar Khanzada, FA19-PHM-
067/ATD
Saad Kahlid, FA19-PHM-
068/ATD
Muhammad Usman Khan, FA19-PHM-
069/ATD
ABSTRACT
Pharmacotherapy of Geriatrics
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction
2. Physiological Changes that occur with Aging
a. Changes in Central Nervous System
b. Changes in Muscular System
c. Changes in Urinary and Excretory System
d. Changes In Reproductive System
e. Changes in Respiratory System
f. Changes in Integumentary System
g. Changes in Cardiovascular System
h. Changes in Lymphatic System
i. Changes in Endocrine System
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
Alpha
Beta
g Microgram
l Microliter
m Micrometer
Chapter No
1.Introduction
Why Geriatrics?
As our lives lengthen and we enjoy better health, it's crucial to consider how we age,
foster innovations for sustained well-being, and shape a healthcare system ready for the
future. This emphasizes the pivotal role of geriatrics as a profession for all of us as we
journey through the aging process.
A Complex Challenge:
The increasing lifespan within our communities offers promising opportunities but
failing to address the specific healthcare needs of aging individuals’ risks undermining
this progress. This is where geriatrics, a healthcare specialty focusing on innovative
elder care, comes into play.
Geriatrics encompasses a diverse range of healthcare professionals, including doctors,
nurses, physician assistants, pharmacists, and social workers, all extensively trained in
addressing the unique health challenges of older adults. They understand the
complexities of aging and are skilled in collaborative care, essential given that many
seniors manage multiple chronic conditions and make care decisions alongside family
members or other stakeholders.
A Growing Field:
The field of geriatrics is expanding rapidly. Take, for instance, the career prospects for
geriatricians, physicians specializing in the care of older adults. The demand for
approximately 20,000 geriatricians currently outstrips the supply, with fewer than 7,300
certified geriatricians practicing nationwide. Looking ahead to 2030, projections
indicate a need for as many as 30,000 geriatricians. Meeting this demand requires
innovative strategies to expand the workforce, not only among physicians but also
among nurses, physician assistants, pharmacists, social workers, and others.
The field of geriatrics presents a wealth of opportunities for the future of healthcare. As
demand for expertise in this area continues to grow, the field remains dynamic,
fulfilling, and ripe with opportunities for those willing to seize them.
• Blood vessels supplying the kidneys can become hardened. This causes the kidneys
to filter blood more slowly. Renal blood flow is halved by 75 years.
Changes in the bladder:
• The bladder wall changes. The elastic tissue becomes stiffer and the bladder becomes
less stretchy. The bladder cannot hold as much urine as before.
• In a healthy aging person, kidney function declines very slowly. Illness, medicines,
and other conditions can significantly degrade kidney function.
COMMON PROBLEMS
Aging increases the risk of kidney and bladder problems such as:
• Bladder control issues, such as leakage or urinary incontinence (not being able to
hold your urine), or urinary retention (not being able to completely empty your
bladder)
• Signs of a urinary tract infection, including fever or chills, burning when urinating,
nausea and vomiting, extreme tiredness, or flank pain
• Birth Rate: The birth rate per 1000 population has decreased from 18.4 in 1970
to 11.8 in 2017.
• Mean Age of Mothers at First Childbirth: The mean age of mothers at first
childbirth has risen from 21.4 years in 1970 to 26.6 years in 2016.
• Proportion of Infants Born to Women over 35: The proportion of all infants born
to mothers over 35 years old has increased from 4.6% in 1970 to 14.9% in 2012.
These trends highlight a demographic shift towards delayed childbearing and a higher
proportion of births occurring to older mothers in the United States over the past few
decades. These data are sourced from a study published in the Journal of Clinical
Endocrinology and Metabolism and based on information from the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention's National Vital Statistics System.
Aging in men involves functional changes across the reproductive axis, impacting both
steroidogenic and gametogenic aspects. While it's widely accepted that serum
testosterone levels decline with age, this decline is further affected by the presence of
comorbidities. However, the long-term effects of testosterone supplementation on
health outcomes in older men, including its impact on prostate cancer risk and major
cardiovascular events, remain understudied.
The first section of this chapter reviews the pathophysiology and health consequences
of age-related testosterone decline, proposing a patient-centric approach to treatment
decisions. The second section discusses age-related changes in the testes' gametogenic
compartment.
Female fertility peaks in a woman's twenties and gradually declines until around age
35, after which it decreases more rapidly until menopause, which marks the end of
fertility. Menopause is characterized by the cessation of menstruation due to the
depletion of ovarian follicles and their hormone production. A woman is deemed
postmenopausal after not menstruating for a full year, typically occurring between ages
50 and 52 but varying individually.
Symptom severity varies among individuals, ranging from absent to severe. Factors like
smoking and poor health can influence the timing of menopause and fertility decline.
Postmenopause, lower estrogen levels can lead to various changes. Cardiovascular
disease becomes as prevalent in women as in men, possibly due to estrogen's
cholesterol-lowering effects. Without estrogen, many women experience high
cholesterol and related cardiovascular issues. Osteoporosis is another concern as bone
density decreases rapidly after menopause, increasing the risk of fractures.
Hormone therapy (HT), using synthetic estrogens and progestins, can alleviate
menopausal symptoms. A study by the Women’s Health Initiative in 2002 observed HT
outcomes over 8.5 years but was halted at 5.2 years due to a higher breast cancer risk
with estrogen-only HT. However, other studies over 50 years, including a 2012 study
with 1,000 menopausal women for 10 years, showed cardiovascular benefits with
estrogen and no increased cancer risk. Some researchers suggest the age group in the
2002 trial might have skewed results. The ongoing debate focuses on HT benefits and
risks. Current guidelines endorse HT for reducing hot flashes, ideally starting at
menopausal symptom onset, using the lowest effective dose for the shortest duration (5
years or less), and regular pelvic and breast exams for women on HT.
Menopause
By around the mid-sixth decade, women universally
undergo menopause, marked by a reduction in
ovulation frequency and eventual cessation of
reproductive ovarian function within approximately
15 years. During this transition, ovarian follicles
function less efficiently, leading to lower oestradiol
levels and higher follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH)
concentrations, while luteinizing hormone (LH)
remains unchanged. Although oestrogen
concentrations decrease, small amounts of the
weaker oestrogen, oestrone, are still produced.
These hormonal changes are associated with
increased cardiovascular risk, rapid bone loss,
vasomotor symptoms, psychological effects, and
atrophy of oestrogen-responsive tissues.
Andropause
As men age, there is a gradual decline in
testosterone levels, known as andropause. This
decline is more significant for free testosterone due
to increased sex hormone-binding globulin levels.
The age-related reduction in testosterone is mainly
due to decreased production rates, affecting the
hypothalamic–pituitary–testicular axis.
• Altered sleep pattern: Physiological changes as we get older are also reflected
by changes to our sleep patterns. Sleep is a continuous, dynamic
neurophysiological process involving the complex interaction of many different
networks within the brain.
These pathophysiological changes interact with each other and with environmental
factors to drive the aging process and increase the risk of age-related diseases, such as
cardiovascular disease, neurodegenerative diseases, cancer, and metabolic disorders.
Similarly, postural changes, stiffness, and reduced mobility, commonly associated with
aging, can mask symptoms indicative of Parkinson's disease, such as rigidity and
bradykinesia. Consequently, these symptoms may go unnoticed or undiagnosed.
Changes in body composition:
The human body comprises fat, lean tissue (muscles and organs), bones, and water.
Beyond the age of 40, there is a discernible shift in body composition, characterized by
a decline in lean tissue. Vital organs such as the liver, kidneys, and others also
experience cellular loss during this phase. This reduction in muscle mass is closely
linked with increased vulnerability to weakness, disability, and morbidity.
Height diminution is a consequence of age-related alterations in bone, muscle, and joint
structure. On average, individuals tend to lose approximately 1 cm in height every
decade after reaching 40 years of age, with the rate of loss accelerating notably after 70.
Adopting a nutritious diet, maintaining physical activity, and proactively addressing
bone density loss are effective strategies for mitigating these changes.
Shifts in total body weight exhibit gender-specific patterns, with men typically
experiencing weight gain until around the age of 55, followed by a gradual decline later
in life. This phenomenon may be attributed to a decline in testosterone levels, the
primary male sex hormone. Conversely, women typically observe weight gain until
approximately 67–69 years of age before entering a phase of weight loss. Research also
indicates that older individuals may harbor nearly one-third more fat compared to their
younger selves, with adipose tissue preferentially accumulating around the body's core
and internal organs.
Pain:
Pain is common in older people. However, as people age, they complain less of pain.
The reason may be a decrease in the body's sensitivity to pain or a more stoical attitude
toward pain. Pain is often not correctly recognized and treated in people with dementia,
and use of a scale such as the Abbey pain scale may help to recognize when a person is
in pain.
Polypharmacy: The prescription and use of multiple drugs to deal with concomitant
multiple diseases is known as polypharmacy.
Polypharmacy and Adverse Drug Events:
Given the practical difficulties of studying older and frail people in randomised clinical
trials, alternate mechanisms for determining risk to benefit ratios need to be considered.
Cost effectiveness models have been used to balance clinical trial efficacy data with
adverse effect data from observational and case control studies.
DOSE To Prescribe: Traditionally, it has been proposed that the dosage of many drugs
should be reduced in older people to compensate for the age related changes in
pharmacokinetics.
While dose reduction may mitigate adverse drug reactions, its impact on efficacy in
elderly patients remains uncertain. Indeed, there is a debate regarding the potential
necessity for higher medication doses in certain contexts; for instance, age-related
immunosuppression may warrant higher doses of broad-spectrum antibiotics in some
cases.
Reviewing appropriateness of prescription:
Geriatricians and pharmacists have developed two primary sets of criteria for
medication management: explicit and implicit criteria. Explicit criteria typically focus
on either drugs or specific diseases and are formulated through expert consensus to
compile lists of medications that are either contraindicated or should be approached
with caution in elderly patients or those with particular medical conditions. On the
other hand, implicit criteria rely predominantly on clinical judgment to evaluate each
prescribed medication in a tailored manner, considering factors such as indication,
efficacy, dosage, adverse effects, and cost.
Both sets of criteria offer unique advantages and face distinct limitations, reflective of
their intended purposes, applicability across different countries or elderly populations,
frequency of updates, metrics used to gauge appropriateness, provision or absence of
information regarding failure to prescribe drugs indicated for treating or preventing
specific diseases, and inclusion or exclusion of the most vulnerable elderly individuals
with multiple chronic conditions.
General Principles: Pharmacokinetics refers to how a drug behaves within the body,
including its absorption through the gut, initial metabolism in the gut and liver, binding
to proteins, distribution throughout the body, and elimination via kidneys, liver, or other
pathways. Aging brings about several changes that could potentially impact these
variables (see Table 1).
Drug Absorption: Although age-related changes such as reduced gastric acid, altered
gastric emptying rates, and shifts in liver and gut blood flow could theoretically affect
absorption, the actual impact on drug absorption across the gut is minor and often
clinically insignificant. While some studies suggest a slower rate of drug absorption in
the elderly, overall, age does not significantly alter the bioavailability of drugs that do
not undergo substantial first-pass elimination.
First-Pass Elimination: After absorption, drugs enter the portal circulation and
undergo first-pass metabolism in the liver before entering systemic circulation. Water-
soluble drugs, which are generally not extensively metabolized by the liver, are less
affected by first-pass metabolism. However, for lipophilic drugs, a substantial portion
of the dose may undergo extraction in the liver during first pass, greatly affecting
bioavailability. Even slight changes in hepatic function can significantly alter
bioavailability, as seen with certain widely used drugs like nitrates, beta-blockers, and
calcium channel blockers.
Protein Binding and Distribution: Age-related changes in body composition, such as
decreased plasma albumin, can impact protein binding of drugs. This alteration means
that the free fraction of drugs bound to albumin increases with age, leading to greater
pharmacological activity upon acute administration. However, the raised free fraction
also results in increased clearance, maintaining a new steady-state. While total plasma
drug concentrations may decrease, free drug plasma concentrations remain constant due
to hepatic or renal clearance of free drugs.
Changes in drug distribution also occur with age. For instance, a decrease in body water
affects the distribution of water-soluble drugs, resulting in relatively higher plasma
concentrations per unit dose in older individuals. Conversely, lipid-soluble drugs
exhibit more extensive distribution, leading to lower plasma concentrations. The
increased distribution volume primarily impacts the drug's half-life and duration of
action, which can be crucial, especially with drugs like hypnotics that may cause a
lingering 'hangover' effect in the elderly.
Renal Clearance: It has been long understood that renal clearance of drugs typically
decreases with age, leading to the common practice of reducing doses for renally
excreted medications like digoxin in elderly patients. Parameters such as glomerular
filtration rate, renal plasma flow, and various measures of tubular function have been
observed to decline with age. However, recent studies have highlighted significant
variability in the age-related decline in renal function among individuals. While many
older patients experience a notable decrease in glomerular filtration rate, some maintain
relatively normal renal function. This inter-individual variability underscores the
importance of individualized drug therapy rather than rigid adherence to standard
guidelines.
Hepatic Clearance: Numerous studies have demonstrated impaired clearance of drugs
eliminated by the liver in elderly populations, increasing the risk of type A adverse
events. Hepatic clearance (CLH) of a drug is influenced by factors such as hepatic
blood flow, extraction ratio, and liver size. Age-related changes in these factors have
been reported, including a decrease in liver blood flow and size. While early studies
suggested a decline in critical drug-metabolizing enzymes with age, recent data indicate
minimal changes in humans and non-human primates. However, in frail or hospitalized
elderly individuals, certain enzyme activities may be significantly reduced, leading to a
higher risk of adverse drug reactions.
Ageing and Drug Metabolism: There has been debate regarding the impact of ageing
on drug metabolizing enzymes' activities. While some studies suggested impaired
enzyme induction in response to stimuli in the elderly, recent research has challenged
this notion. Studies using an isolated peripheral blood monocyte model failed to
demonstrate impaired enzyme induction or decreased sensitivity to inducing stimuli
with age. Further research is needed to fully understand the relationship between ageing
and drug metabolism induction.
Ageing, Injury, and Drug Reactions: Elderly patients undergoing surgery or trauma
are particularly susceptible to adverse drug reactions, possibly due to reduced enzyme
activity. Studies have shown a marked decrease in plasma aspirin esterase activity
following hip fracture or hip replacement surgery. This decline in enzyme activity could
have significant clinical implications by affecting drug metabolism pathways.
Pharmacodynamic Variations in Geriatric Patients:
Pharmacodynamic variations in geriatrics refer to how elderly patients respond to drugs
due to age-related physiological changes, crucial for safe pharmacotherapy. Firstly,
aging alters receptor sensitivity, affecting drug-receptor interactions. For example, beta-
adrenergic receptor density in the heart and opioid receptor sensitivity in the CNS
change with age. Secondly, elderly patients may show altered responses to medications,
experiencing increased sensitivity to certain drugs like benzodiazepines and opioids,
heightening the risk of adverse reactions such as sedation and falls. Thirdly, age-related
organ dysfunction, like decreased renal and hepatic clearance, impacts drug metabolism
and elimination, necessitating dosage adjustments to prevent toxicity, especially for
renally excreted drugs like digoxin and lithium. Moreover, aging can disrupt
homeostatic mechanisms, increasing susceptibility to orthostatic hypotension and
electrolyte imbalances, affecting drug responses, notably with antihypertensives and
diuretics. Additionally, polypharmacy in older adults raises the risk of drug interactions,
which can result in additive, synergistic, or antagonistic effects, particularly concerning
medications with narrow therapeutic indices like warfarin and digoxin. Lastly,
neurological changes in aging, such as alterations in neurotransmitter levels and
neuronal function, affect drug responses in the CNS, influencing the efficacy and
tolerability of psychiatric and neurological medications. Understanding these variations
is critical for optimizing pharmacotherapy in older adults.
ADRs in geriatrics
Medications arguably stand out as the foremost technological advancement in
healthcare, particularly in safeguarding the geriatric population against illness,
disability, and premature death. With advancing age, alterations in drug metabolism and
pharmacological responses carry substantial clinical ramifications, accentuating the
likelihood of medication-related complications amidst heightened medication usage.
The correlation between escalating medication utilization, notably prescription drugs,
and the elderly demographic is firmly established. Predominantly, adverse drug
reactions (ADRs) leading to hospital admission or occurring during hospitalization
manifest as type A reactions, comprising approximately 80% of cases. Although less
prevalent among the elderly, type B ADRs can provoke severe toxicity in certain
instances. Research has underscored the intrinsic link between advancing age and
heightened ADR incidence, attributable to the intertwined influence of age and
polypharmacy compounded by age-induced changes in pharmacodynamics and
pharmacokinetics across specific medical conditions.
Implications and Strategies
In some scenarios, the combined administration of drugs may precipitate synergistic
toxicity, surpassing the cumulative risk of toxicity associated with each agent used
independently. Regrettably, prevailing international policy responses, particularly in
regions like India grappling with burgeoning elderly populations and chronic ailments,
have not accorded due emphasis to strategies aimed at enhancing ADR detection and
management. There exists a pressing need for comprehensive epidemiological
investigations encompassing substantial cohorts of elderly medication users to furnish
insights into the frequency and economic impact of ADRs. Such insights are pivotal in
fostering judicious therapeutic decision-making among individual clinicians and
formulating more efficacious social policies geared towards optimizing healthcare
outcomes.
How to minimize the ADRS in geriatrics
Strategies to Mitigate Adverse Drug Reactions (ADRs) in Older Adults
Role of Prescribers
1. Comprehensive Patient Examination:
Conduct thorough assessments, considering both symptoms and underlying conditions,
to discern adverse drug reactions from disease progression.
2. Complete Medication Record
Maintain comprehensive records of all medications, including non-pharmacological
agents, to mitigate drug interactions and polypharmacy risks.
3. Benefit-Risk Assessment:
Evaluate medication prescriptions based on individual patient benefits and risks to
minimize unnecessary medication use and associated adverse events.
4. Dose Adjustment:
Adjust drug dosages for renal impairment in elderly patients to mitigate adverse
reactions, considering age-related declines in renal function.
5. Avoidance of Inappropriate Medications:
Utilize tools like the Beers criteria and STOPP criteria to prevent unnecessary
medication use and reduce adverse drug reactions, while also addressing underuse of
essential medications.
6. Initiate Treatment with Low Doses:
Begin drug therapy at lower doses and gradually titrate based on patient response to
minimize adverse effects, particularly in the context of altered pharmacodynamic
responses in the elderly.
7. Optimized Drug Frequency and Timing:
Consider chronotherapy and optimal dosing schedules to align drug administration with
biological rhythms and reduce the incidence of adverse drug reactions.
8. Management of Drug Interactions:
Vigilantly assess for potential drug-drug, drug-disease, and drug-food interactions,
selecting alternative medications to minimize adverse outcomes associated with
polypharmacy.
9. Economic Considerations:
Recommend cost-effective medication options to enhance treatment adherence and
reduce the economic burden on elderly patients.
10. Patient Education:
Educate patients and caregivers about medication effects, potential adverse reactions,
adherence strategies, and the importance of timely communication with healthcare
providers.
Role of Patients/Caregivers
1. Understanding Medications:
Ensure comprehension of medication effects, administration timing, and dietary
restrictions to facilitate proactive communication with healthcare providers.
2. Improving Adherence:
Employ strategies such as pill organizers, alarms, and reminders to enhance medication
adherence and reduce errors in administration.
3. Monitoring Over-the-Counter (OTC) Medications:
Maintain awareness of all medications, including OTC, herbal, and supplemental
remedies, to prevent potential interactions and adverse effects.
4. Regular Medication Record Updates:
Regularly update medication lists and provide them during healthcare visits to
streamline treatment and eliminate unnecessary medications.
Polypharmacy
Understanding the Impact of Polypharmacy in Aging Populations
Global Aging Trends and Polypharmacy: The demographic shift towards an aging
population poses significant healthcare challenges globally. With increasing age,
individuals are more prone to chronic diseases, necessitating the use of multiple
medications, a phenomenon known as polypharmacy. This trend is particularly
pronounced in low- and middle-income countries, where rapid rates of aging are
observed.
Risks Associated with Polypharmacy: Polypharmacy amplifies the risk of adverse
drug reactions (ADRs) in older adults due to age-related metabolic changes and
reduced drug clearance. Additionally, the likelihood of drug-drug interactions escalates
with the use of multiple medications, contributing to further complications such as hip
fractures and prescribing cascades.
Pharmacist Involvement
• Explore pharmacist-led interventions, although evidence is limited, to potentially
enhance concordance and reduce adverse outcomes.
• Engage community pharmacists in spotting adverse drug reactions, interactions, and
concordance issues.
Minimizing Prescribers
• Encourage communication between primary and secondary care to minimize
unintentional discrepancies in medication.
• Reduce the number of prescribers involved in a patient's care to mitigate the
incidence of adverse drug reactions.
Education
• Utilize educational outreach visits to modify prescribing behavior among healthcare
professionals.
• Consider the impact of practice size on the effectiveness of educational
interventions.
Electronic Prescribing
• Implement electronic prescribing systems to reduce errors and enhance
communication between healthcare providers.
• Provide necessary support to patients to facilitate the adoption of electronic
prescribing.
Audit and Feedback
• Develop prescribing quality indicators tailored to older patients to provide immediate
feedback and facilitate continuous improvement.
• Utilize quantitative, qualitative, and evidence-based indicators to assess prescribing
quality and identify areas for improvement.
sebaceous glands, resulting in dryness and itchiness of the skin, especially in older
women after menopause.
Criteria used in Geriatric Pharmacotherapy:
Beer’s Criteria:
The Beers Criteria for Potentially Inappropriate Medications (PIMs) used in older
adults serves as a reference list for healthcare providers when prescribing medications
for individuals aged 65 and above. It is a tool used to ensure safe medication practices,
aligning with the principle of "do no harm." Updated by the American Geriatrics
Society every three years. [1]
The Beers Criteria, also known as the Beers list, was initially conceived in 1991 by the
late Dr. Mark Beers, a renowned geriatrician. It identifies medications that may cause
adverse drug events in older adults due to their pharmacological properties and the
physiological changes associated with aging. In 2011, the AGS started an update of the
criteria, comprising a team of experts and funding the development of the AGS 2012
Beers Criteria using an enhanced, evidence-based methodology.
Objectives: The aim of the AGS Beers Criteria is threefold: (1) to minimize older
adults' exposure to potentially inappropriate medications (PIMs) by enhancing
medication selection; (2) to provide education for both clinicians and patients; and (3)
to function as a tool for assessing the quality of care, cost-effectiveness, and medication
utilization trends in the older adult population.[2]
Major Divisions: The Beers Criteria comprises five sections delineating:
1. Medications unsuitable for individuals over 65 years old and not in hospice or
palliative care.
2. Medications to be avoided for individuals with specific health conditions.
3. Medications to be avoided due to potential drug interactions with other
medications.
4. Medications to avoid because their adverse effects outweigh the benefits.
5. Medications to be cautiously administered at reduced doses or avoided
altogether due to their impact on kidney function (renal impairment).
Methodology:
Study Design:
A cross-sectional observational study was conducted during September 2023 to March
2024 on 256 elderly patients with 65 years of age and above. Data was collected from
various hospitals of Haripur, Abbottabad and Mansehra region which were as under:
▪ District head quarter hospital (DHQ) Haripur, K.P.K Pakistan.
▪ Abbottabad medical complex (AMC) and Ayub teaching hospital Abbottabad,
K.P.K Pakistan.
▪ King Abdullah Teaching Hospital Mansehra K.P.K Pakistan.
Inclusion criteria
1. Patients who are 65 years of age or older are enrolled in this study.
2. Patients who were hospitalized between September 2023 to March 2024 are
included in this report.
Exclusion criteria
1. Patients who died during collection of data.
Sample size and data collection:
Data was collected by reviewing the case profile of 256 elderly patients who were
hospitalized or discharged during the study period. Data obtained from the patient
medical records consisted mainly of the following information.
▪ Personal information
▪ Patient's identification & demographics information
▪ Presenting main complaints
▪ Past medical history
▪ Family history
▪ Personal history
▪ Medication history
▪ Laboratory data
▪ Diagnosis/impression
▪ Medication before admission
▪ Medication in hospital
▪ Assessment of Drug/drug interactions
▪ Assessment of drug/food interaction
▪ Drug related problems and recommendation.
Identification of PIMs
All the medications for PIMs were assessed by all the project group students using the
Beer's Criteria 2023.
The medications in the record listed in the Beer's Criteria were PIMs according to the
major divisions of the criteria, which include the following:
Category A: Potentially inappropriate medications used in older adults.
Category B: Potentially inappropriate medications used in older adults due to drug
disease or drug-syndrome interactions that may exacerbate the disease or syndrome.
Category C: Potentially inappropriate medications; Drugs to be used with caution in
older adults.
Category D: Potentially inappropriate medications; Clinically important drug-drug
interactions that should be avoided in older adults.
Category E: Potentially inappropriate medications, that should be avoided or have their
dosage reduced with varying levels of kidney function in older adults.
3.6 Statistical analysis
The data collected were entered in Microsoft Office Excel 365 and analyzed using
Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) statistical software (version 20, IBM,
SPSS). The methods used to analyze the data include an analysis of descriptive
statistical variables such as frequency and percentages whereas chi-squire test was used
for statistical analysis of categorical variables.