Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Instructional Courses On Medical Thermography - A Historical Perspective
Instructional Courses On Medical Thermography - A Historical Perspective
SUMMARY
This document is a review of the courses organised under the name of EAT. The survey aims to develop a solid structure
and schedule, which remain unchanged and are independent of the tutors or the venue of the course. Some of the previous
courses have been organised solely by the EAT, most, however, were certified by the EAT in cooperation with other insti-
tutions/organizations (University of Glamorgan, University of São Paulo, QIRT, Bucharest University, Polytechnic In-
stitute of Leiria, Porto University and Technical University of Madrid).
The duration and the topics that had been covered in the different courses varies depending on where they were taught.
Even the courses at the University of Glamorgan showed over the years changed content, not only to reflect the progress of
science, but also to adapt certain persons, who ended or started their cooperation with the group.
Based on previous course materials, we developed the structure of a 1 -day course by combining 4 hours theory with a
2-hours practical session, which will take place at the EAT2018 Congress in London, Teddington.
KEY WORDS: instructional course, medical thermography, EAT
Introduction
Courses for thermal imaging were offered very early in the imager. Instruction in the use of infrared cameras was pro-
history of clinical thermography. In the period between vided by manufacturers. Proceedings of symposia in New
1970 and 1985, liquid crystal paint, and later, crystals en- York 1964 [4] and Leiden 1969 [5] were published and the
closed in foils was the preferred technique of thermal im- first textbooks on thermography appeared in the Nether-
aging and the main indication was breast cancer. Instruc- lands [6], Japan [7] and North America [8].
tion on proper use and evaluation was given by manufac-
Although Thermology Associations were founded in the
turers, who received very quickly (purchased) assistance
nineteen seventies around the world, no printed informa-
from technicians and experienced medical doctors. An at-
tion is available whether those societies offered educational
las on liquid crystal thermography was edited in 1976 in
courses for recording, evaluation and interpretation of
Germany [1] Acta thermographica, the first journal dedi-
thermal images.
cated exclusively to thermography, published a supplement
on liquid crystal thermography in1981 [2]. Announcements Only the German Society of Regulation-Thermography
of liquid crystal thermography courses given M. Gautherie promoted their special technique through an education sys-
can be found in the first volume (1985) of the journal tem consisting of several levels, from beginners to experts
Thermodiagnostik (later renamed to ThermoMed) [3]. and complemented by refresher courses. [3].
The American Academy of Thermology started in 2000 to
The use of infrared camera was restricted to specialised certify technicians and physicians after they have com-
hospital departments due to the high costs of a thermal pleted a certification course and an examination [9].
98
Review
2..To demonstrate the application of standard technique The course followed and extended the paper "The Tech-
to assess physiological and pathological conditions nique of Infra Red Imaging in Medicine" by Ring and
Ammer, first published in Thermology international [13]
3. To understand and apply image processing and analysis and re-published in the book "Infrared Imaging, A case-
techniques book in clinical medicine" edited by F Ring, A. Jung and J.
Zuber for IOP Publishing in 2015.
Lectures were presented by Francis Ring, Richard Harding,
Bryan Jones and Kurt Ammer and covered the topics: Prin- Between November 2001 and July 2007 seven other courses
ciples of infrared imaging; technological developments, en- were given at the University of Glamorgan. All of them
vironmental conditions for quantifiable imaging, thermal were announced in Thermology international [14-20] and
99
Thermology international 27/3 (2017)
Table 2
Topics and duration of lectures in the Glamorgan courses
the website of Medical Imaging Research Unit of the Uni- Practical session
versity of Glamorgan. The topics and attendance of 3 In the practical sessions the attendants learned to record a
courses were described in short articles, published in thermal image of a distinct anatomical region, and to ana-
Thermology international [21-23]. The 5th Course assem- lyse the recorded images by defined regions of interest
bled teachers and students from 8 different nationalities using the CHTHERM software. The idea behind these
(Austria, Canada, Germany, Norway, Portugal, Romania, exercise was to teach the students
Slovenia, United Kingdom, USA)(figure 1). Interesting to
note that 40 students attended the 5th-7th courses, a mean 1. that thermal imaging is a method for temperature
of 10 participants per course. The origin of the partici- measurement as infrared thermography images the distri-
pants was varied, 17 were from the United Kingdom, 5 bution of surface temperature and does not provide much
from Portugal, 4 from Canada , 3 from Norway, 3 from the anatomical details.
United States of America, 3 from Hungary, 2 from Slovenia, 2. that the reproducibility and repeatability of temperature
1 from Malaysia, 1 from Pakistan and 1 from Romania. readings is dependent on image recording and on the posi-
Similar to the 35 participants in the courses 1 to 4, most of tion and shape of regions of interest
the attendants had their professional background in medical
physics, some were physicians, nurses or physiotherapists. Tasks of the practical sessions
Theory lectures
Each course was structured in theoretical lectures and 3rd course
practical sessions. A list of topics, the lecturer, the fre- 3 students defined twice rectangular, ellipsoid and hour-
quency of the topic presented and the duration of the lec- glass shaped regions of interest (ROI) over the anterior
ture is shown in table 2. The estimated total time of theory knee and compared the mean temperatures readings be-
lectures was 987 minutes equal to 16 hours and 15 minutes. tween different shaped and same shaped regions. The best
The lecture time for “Producing a thermographic report” repeatabilty of temperature readings was obtained from
was increased from originally 15 to 40 minutes and ex- the hour-glass shaped ROI [24].
tended by 15 extra minutes for discussion. This change be-
came necessary because in most health systems inter- 4th course
pretation of findings is a privilege of medical doctors. 5 students investigated the repeatability of ROI definition
Other health professionals are allowed to conduct a thermo- at the ankle joint, the forefoot and the soles and compared
graphic medical investigation on request by a medical doc- the forefoot temperatures recorded in a perpendicular view
tor. Thermographic findings must be presented in an ob- and an 45° angled view. The highest reliabilty coefficent
jective way and no conclusions must be made on an was obtained for the right ankle joint, the lowest for the left
underlying disease or further test procedures must not be ankle joint. Forefoot temperature differed by 0.9 to 1.1°C
proposed. between perpendicular and angled view [24].
100
Review
101
Thermology international 27/3 (2017)
102
Review
10. EAT-Instructional Course on Medical Thermography in Vi- Medicine. Akademickie Centrum Graficzno-Marketigowe Lodart
enna, 4th June 1993.Thermologie Österreich 1993, 3(1) 5-38 S.A, Lodz, 2003, p. 13-18
11. Programme of the III International course about thermo- 25. Ammer K, Ring EF Repeatability of the standard view both
graphy and pain. Acta Fisiátrica 1999, 6(2) 84. dorsal hands. Results from a training course on medical infrared
imaging. Thermology International. 2004; 14(3):100-103
12. Announcement of the 1st Course on Thermal Imaging in
Medicine, at the University of Glamorgan.Thermology interna- 26. Ammer K, Ring EF. Influence of the field of view on temper-
tional 2001, 11(2) 109 ature readings from thermal images. Thermology international
2005, 15(3): 99-103
13. Ring EFJ, Ammer K. The Technique of Infra Red Imaging in
Medicine. Thermology international 2000, 10(1) 7-14 27. Ammer K. Repeatability of temperature measurements at the
forehead in thermal images from the standard view "face" Thermo-
14. Announcement of the 2nd Course on Thermal Imaging in logy international 2006, 16(4): 138-142
Medicine at the University of Glamorgan. Thermology interna-
tional 2001, 11(3) 153 28.Announcement of the Short Course on Medical Thermo-
graphy in Bucharest. Thermology international 2008, 18(3) 113-
15. Announcement of the 3rd Instructional Course on Thermal 114, 117
Imaging in Medicine at the University of Glamorgan.Thermo-
logy international 2002, 12(1) 34, 38 29.Announcement of the 1st Practical Course in Medical Thermo-
graphy in Portugal, Polytechnic Institut of Leiria, Portugal.
16.. Announcement of the 4th Instructional Course on Thermal Thermology international 2011, 21(2) 75-76
Imaging in Medicine at the University of Glamorgan. Thermo-
logy international 2003, 13(1) 45 30.Programme and Abstracts of the Auburn-Glamorgan Work-
shop. Thermology international 2007, 17(2) 59, 62-65
17.Announcement of the 5th Short Course on InfraRed Thermal
Imaging in Medicine at the University of Glamorgan. Thermo- 31. Announcement of the Short Course on Medical Thermo-
logy international 2004, 14(1) 43 graphy, QIRT Conference 2008,in Krakow, Poland. Thermo-
logy international 2008, 18(1) 33
18. Announcement of the 6th Course on Thermal Imaging in
Medicine, Theory and Practice at the University of Glamorgan. 32. Announcement of the 1-Day Pre-Conference Course in
Thermology international 2005, 15(1) 39, 42 Porto, Portugal. Thermology international 2012, 22(2) 78
19. Announcement of the 7th Course on Thermal Imaging in 33. Announcement of the 1-Day Pre-Conference Course
Medicine, Theory and Practice at the University of Glamorgan. Madrid, Spain. Thermology international 2015, 25(1) 36-37
Thermology international 2006, 16(1) 38, 16(2) 74-75 34. CM/GEN APPENDIX B Issue 4: Specific Requirements
20.. Announcement of the 8th Residential Course on Theory and For Qualification And PCN Certification of Condition Moni-
Practice of InfraRed Thermal Imaging in Medicine at the Univer- toring And Diagnostic Personnel For Infrared Thermography.
sity of Glamorgan. Thermology international 2007, 17(2) 84 The British Institute of Non-Destructive Testing, CM IRT Issue 4.
1st April 2016. pp.1 -19
21.4th Instructional Course on Thermal Imaging in Medicine.
Thermology international 2003, 13(2)
22. 5th Course on Medical Thermal Imaging.Thermology inter- Address for Correspondence
national 2004, 14(3) 114 Prof Kurt Ammer MD, PhD
23. Ring EF. 8th Course on the Theory and Practice of Infra Red European Association of Thermology
Thermal Imaging in Medicine. Thermology International 2007, 1170 Vienna; Austria
17(3) 118-119 Email: kammer1950@aol.com
24.Ammer K Need for Standardisation of Measurements in
Thermal Imaging In: Wiecek B (ed) Thermography and Lasers in (received 18.05.2017, revision accepted 01.08.2017)
103