Professional Documents
Culture Documents
284-Article Text-306-2-10-20210802
284-Article Text-306-2-10-20210802
¹ 2
UDK 632.15:66.092.9
DOI: 10.33070/etars.2.2021.07
A system for preventing formation and environ- regarding changes in volumes, forms of accumula-
mentally safe removal of persistent organic pollu- tion and storage of POPs was carried out in 2020.
tants (POPs) is an actual problem for Ukraine. The As at March 31, 2006 21,615 tons of unusable
Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pol- or prohibited plant protection chemicals (PPC)
lutants requires establishment of that system, and were accumulated in Ukraine, 2,019 tons of them
in 2007, Ukraine develops the National Plan for its are pesticides classified as POPs, among which ma-
implementation. When developing the Plan, all jority is DDT — 1,744 tons and hexachlorocyclo-
POPs specified in the Convention were thoroughly hexane — 273 tons [1].
inventoried, and in order to correct actions of the In recent years, inventory of unusable and pro-
National Implementation Plan, an expert assessment hibited pesticides has been taken at the regional
level. Each regional State Ad-
Table 1. Storage status of prohibited and unusable pesticides by ministration Office annually
January 01, 2019 makes an Environmental Pass-
port of the region, which con-
Pesticides, Condition of storehouses tains data on volume of accumu-
stored Number of lation and storage status of un-
Region Satis- Unsatis-
in SH, storehouses Good
factory factory usable and prohibited PPC.
tons
Please see the Summary on stor-
Vinnitsa Region 2964.0 116 1 26 89
age of prohibited and unsuitable
Kherson Region
1921.804 – – – 0 pesticides by January 01, 2019
(01.2017)
in Table 1.
Sumy Regiont 563.529 64 – 38 26
As of beginning of 2019, 8 re-
Odesa Region 532.818 66 0 11 55 gions completely disposed of ac-
Zhytomyr Region 392.186 137 11 36 94 cumulated unusable PPC, but in
Kyiv Region 298.355 22 – 3 19 many cases, storehouses and sur-
rounding sites were not cleaned
Cherkasy Region 282.371 13 3 4 6
of pesticide residues. Detailed in-
Chernigiv Region 277.900 52 0 1 51 ventory of waste and areas
Khmeltitskiy around storehouses contaminated
253.518 11 – 9 2
Region with pesticides should be one of
Zaporizhzhya
Region
252.714 49 3 8 38 the main tasks of the updated Na-
tional Implementation Plan.
Mykolaiv Region 166.87 6 – 3 3
It is also necessary to make
Poltava Region 160.44 21 18 3 significant adjustments to
Rivne Region 46.815 13 12 1 planned actions of the National
Lugansk Region 36.5 4 2 1 1 Plan according to current state
of accumulation of polychlorin-
Donetsk Region 25.660 – – – 0
ated biphenyls (PCBs) in
Ternopil Region 17.814 7 – 1 6 Ukraine. In 2003, according to
Volyn Region 0 0 0 0 0 specially developed forms of sta-
Dniepropetrovsk tistical reporting, a nationwide
0 0 0 0 0
Region inventory of electrical equip-
Transcarpathian ment, containing PCB, was
0 0 0 0 0
Region
completed [2]. According to ob-
Ivano-Frankivsk
Region
0 0 0 0 0 tained inventory results, the Na-
Kropyvnytskiy tional Registry of PCBs was de-
0 0 0 0 0 veloped, and actions for envi-
Region
L’viv Region 0 0 0 0 0 ronmentally sound disposal of
Kharkiv Region 0 0 0 0 0
PCBs were planned in the 1st
edition of the National Imple-
Chernivtsi Region 0 0 0 0 0
mentation Plan.
82 ISSN 2413-7723. Åíåðãîòåõíîëî㳿 òà ðåñóðñîçáåðåæåííÿ. 2021. ¹ 2
Table 2. Number of equipment with concentrated PCBs in the regions in 2003 and 2018
Total number of concentrated PCBs in 2003 In accordance with requirements of the Stock-
was estimated to be 4,240 tons. Similar to the case holm Convention on POPs, inventory should be
of pesticides, there have been significant changes covered all objects where the PCB pollution ex-
in situation with PCBs in the time ahead. ceeds 50 ppm. Therefore, in 2017, a research for
Clarification of the data of the National Register possible PCB contamination of transformers filled
on concentrated PCBs was conducted in period of with mineral oil was started. In 2017–2018, 5,000
2017–2018 within framework of the EF/UNIDO screening tests of mineral oil samples were ana-
Project “Environmentally sound management and lyzed. An updated National Implementation Plan
final removal of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs)” should provide a wider investigation.
by surveying enterprises (see Table 2). Since partic- Another persistent organic pollutant — hexa-
ipation in the survey was freely, results obtained do chlorobenzene — plays an important role in origin
not reflect the state of the issue for whole country. of environmental risks for Ukraine. Reportedly,
Many enterprises, which showed PCBs in 2003, 11,352.5 tons of hexachlorobenzene waste were
did not confirm presence of equipment with PCBs stored at the Kalush Chemical and Metallurgical
in 2018, or even they were closed down. There are Plant in 2001. According to the Environmental
also enterprises that were not covered by inventory Passport of the Ivano-Frankivsk Region,
in 2003, but showed a significant number of capac- 29,431 tons of waste, containing hexachloroben-
itors in 2017. zene and soils from sites around a landfill, were
Clarification of this data with a direct check of taken for disposal during 2010–2013. However,
enterprises, on which previously equipment with recultivation of landfill was not completed.
PCBs was discovered, should be one of the direc- Within updating the National Implementation
tions in the updated National Action Implementa- Plan, it is necessary to examine of areas surrounded
tion Plan. landfill in order to assess extent of pollution with
ISSN 2413-7723. Åíåðãîòåõíîëî㳿 òà ðåñóðñîçáåðåæåííÿ. 2021. ¹ 2 83
hexachlorobenzene and to define measures on re- sistent organic pollutants by reducing or eliminat-
moval of residual contamination. ing their releases into environment. NIP of every
To define measures regarding development of country has to have part concerning to monitoring
POP treatment infrastructure, it is important to of SC chemicals based on global and regional mon-
know not only total scale of accumulation of cer- itoring activities and plans. Key aspect of this
tain types of POPs, but also amount and forms of monitoring programs is to evaluate effectiveness of
waste generation during decommissioning of equip- the SC measures in this case on the territory of
ment, cleaning storehouses, and recultivation of every country.
landfills, etc. A risk of irreversible changes in terrestrial and
In addition to creation of an infrastructure for aquatic ecosystems requires a coordinated monitor-
disposal of accumulated POPs, the National Imple- ing effort based on broad international coopera-
mentation Plan should be aimed at preventing or tion. It means that every monitoring system is
reducing the so-called “unintentional production” long-term process with the basic focus on determi-
of POPs. nation of trends in time and space.
The Stockholm Convention on POPs requires It has been recognized that an important step in
the Parties: establishment of effective control measures is the
— develop an action plan for identification, de- inventory of current POP concentrations in various
termination of properties and resolution of issues environmental compartments, and assessment of
related to chemical emissions, in appendix C: hex- their time trends. Determination of POP concen-
achlorobenzene (HCB); hexachlorobutadiene; pen- trations in the atmosphere, wet and dry deposition,
tachlorobenzene ((PeCBz); polychlorinated bi- surface water, sediment, soil, and vegetation are
phenyls (PCBs) polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins desirable under various geographic and climatic
and dibenzofurans (PCDD/PCDF) and polychlo- conditions. Such information improves our under-
rinated naphthalenes; standing of the pathways and potential effects of
— contribute to application of existing, neces- chemical substances, and defines specific parame-
sary and practical measures that could promptly ters for exposure assessment. At the same time,
ensure elimination of the source, or a real and sub- new data sets valuable for validation of regional
stantial reduction in emissions. and global models of atmospheric transport and en-
Emissions assessment is carried out according to vironmental fate are generated. A number of sites
generally accepted method by multiplication pro- where POPs are continuously monitored over ex-
duction volumes of a particular product by emis- tended time periods in several environmental com-
sion factor [3]. Emission factor is established based partments is, however, very limited.
on specific features of the technological process, The Stockholm Convention Global Monitoring
requirement for raw materials, and configuration Plan (GMP) [6] evaluates whether the POPs (and
of equipment. This coefficient also shows how ap- their levels observed in the environment) were re-
plication of “best available techniques will reduce duced or eliminated as requested in Articles 3 and
emissions into environment of certain POPs”. 5 of the Convention which means that information
As of 2018, on the base of statistics [4, 5] re- on environmental levels of the chemicals listed in
garding volumes of activity and with use of spread- the Annexes to the Convention should enable de-
sheets proposed by UNEP for POP emission the tection of trends over time. Therefore, focus is
following PCDD/PCDF, PCB, HCB and PCB re- upon monitoring of background levels of POPs at
leases were calculated (please see Table 3). locations not influenced by local sources.
At present, for many origins of pollution there But national monitoring has to be focused on
are no well-based emissions factor into different the most relevant POPs sources in the country,
environments. Therefore, one of the tasks of the contaminated sites, potential transboundary
updated National Implementation Plan should be transport. Design of this national monitoring pro-
also to determine emission factors for both existing gram, development of the national network and
equipment configuration and for options for its long-term realization is very complicated and ex-
possible modernization. pensive process. There is a basic difference between
Objective of the Stockholm Convention is to development of the long-term monitoring program
protect human health and environment from per- and shorter pilot phase or study projects.
84 ISSN 2413-7723. Åíåðãîòåõíîëî㳿 òà ðåñóðñîçáåðåæåííÿ. 2021. ¹ 2
A lot of activities including long term measure- ated pesticides mainly in water, soil and human
ments was discussed in the NIP from 2007. There samples.
is a summary of programmes which were focused In this time a relatively sufficient number of
on the long-term measurements of organochlorin- laboratories, which were able to determine the
ISSN 2413-7723. Åíåðãîòåõíîëî㳿 òà ðåñóðñîçáåðåæåííÿ. 2021. ¹ 2 85
OCPs existed. Now is only fully supports the con- atively small amounts of accumulation its own op-
siderations of the Stockholm Convention on POPs timal technology and acceptable means of its im-
— the L. Medved Institute of Ecological Hygiene plementation are determined.
and Toxicology, Kyiv city) that has been accred- The most significant in volume is group of solid
ited for the right of carrying out of measurements waste, with a relatively low content of POPs. This
of PCDDs/PCDFs content (in emitted sub- group includes almost all prohibited and unusable
stances, fish, waste products, and soils). plant protection chemicals (PPC).
According to the data rendered by the State hy- Inventories of the late 90’s showed that among
drometeorological service two OCPs belonging to stored chemicals were: 1) the granules and powders
the POPs group are being monitored regularly. — about 50 %, 2) liquid preparations, suspensions,
These are DDT (including p,p’-DDE, p,p’-DDT, emulsions — 35 %, and 3) pastes — 15 %.
and p,p’-DDD) and HCB in the waters and DDT Over 20 years of storage, because of mixing and
only (including p,p’-DDE, p,p’-DDT, and p,p’- repackaging, all mixtures have acquired a solid
DDD) in the soils at the territory of Ukraine. state with an unknown variable chlorine content.
One of the goals of the National implementation Overall majority of solid DDT mixtures consists of
plan upgrade development is to prepare and estab- 50–70 % of mineral inert matrix. That is, if POPs
lish a modern extensive network for monitoring of share in total number of unusable pesticides is
POPs presence in environment which should be a ~ 10 %, amount of chlorine in total volume of unus-
control tool to assess an effectiveness and adequacy able pesticides is estimated at approximately 2–3 %.
of measures developed in frames of the National To destroy active ingredient of such substances,
Implementation Plan of POPs. But key element effective measures are needed for desorption and
will be sufficient financial support for develop- transfer it to the gas phase. As practical experience
ment of really long-term monitoring network. proved, rotary kilns perform this most effectively.
The next step in establishment of an environ- Today in Ukraine there are small technological
mentally sound management system for POPs is complexes (with capacity of 500–800 kg/hour)
accepting the outcomes of inventory on volumes of built based on a rotary kiln with a gas cleaning
POPs accumulation and monitoring their releases system; they are designed for 2–3 % chlorine in
into environments, and development of ecologi- loading. Such installations can also be used for
cally effective and economically optimal infra- treating soils with a high content of pesticides from
structure for POPs disposal. According to forms of land near abandoned pesticide storehouses. Sites of
accumulation, POP-containing wastes with similar soil with high contamination of HCB are also at
physicochemical properties should be divided into the Kalush’s landfill of HCB waste.
separate groups, and optimal treatment technology Use of plasma destructive technique may be ac-
should be determined for each group. ceptable for concentrated organochlorine toxic sub-
If some country has powerful (with a capacity stances, in particular, synthetic oils based on PCB
of several tons per hour) installations built on uni- [7]. Composition of synthetic oils usually includes
versal rotary kilns, then question of technology se- 2–3 chlorinated organic compounds that during
lection for any type of wastes is not so acute. Mod- thermal destruction in chemically inert plasma
ern technological complex based on a rotary kiln with an addition of water vapor allow getting sim-
with a multi-stage gas cleaning system is universal ple products: CO2, H2O, and HCl. In addition,
tool that provide high environmental and economic simple products formed after destruction reduce in-
efficiency in destruction a wide range of waste. vestment and operational costs of gaseous products
Content of chlorine in the loading (mixture of cleaning system compared to other technologies
waste) in such installations is allowed up to 10 %. based on using of rotary kiln. However, plasma
However, capital costs for establishment of such technology has its own disadvantages. To ensure a
complexes are very high. There are no private com- high resource of continuous operation of arc plas-
panies in Ukraine that could be able to invest in matron or stable discharge in radio frequency plas-
development of such installations at existing level matron, argon is used, which significantly reduces
of risks in hazardous waste disposal activities, and the economic effect of a simple system for gas
state programs do not include their construction in cleaning. Usually, the installations with a capacity
the near future. The more realistic strategy is when of up to 150 kWt are used for destruction of POPs
for each group of POP-containing waste with rel- and ODS. Thus, two installations with a produc-
86 ISSN 2413-7723. Åíåðãîòåõíîëî㳿 òà ðåñóðñîçáåðåæåííÿ. 2021. ¹ 2
tivity of 70 kg/hour could be able to process all — releases of POPs into the environment (air,
concentrated PCBs, which were accumulated in water, soil) due to imperfect production processes.
Ukraine, in four years. 2. Optimal comprehensive solution to the prob-
Another option for concentrated PCBs is export lem of decontamination of POPs-waste in Ukraine
abroad for processing in available large incinera- is use of rotary kilns for waste with low concentra-
tors. It is important, that in case of POP waste tion of POPs and use of plasma reactors for highly
removal the disposal cost increases in 2–2.5 times. concentrated POPs.
Previous experience of other countries demon- 3. To reduce the emission of POPs into envi-
strates that replacement of mineral oils in trans- ronment because of their unintentional formation,
formers may lead to their contamination with it is necessary to develop a system of monitoring
PCB. Share of transformers with contamination up of POPs and to promote an implementation of the
to 50 ppm could reach 20 %. In aim to detect such “best available methods”, taking into account the
contamination, transformers in Ukraine have been monitoring results.
started to inspect. Previous screening tests of min-
eral oils for possible contamination with PCBs References
proved that such pollution is not high (up to
200 ppm) and possible volumes of contaminated 1. National Implementation Plan for the Stockholm
mineral oils may reach 24,000 tons. At such level Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants. —
of contamination, use of these oils as fuel in spe- http://www.pops.int/Implementation/NationalImp-
cialized rotary kilns, in particular in pesticides’ lementationPlans/NIPTransmission/tabid/253/
Ukraine/last_UNEP-POPS-NIP-Ukraine-1.English.pdf
processing, may be quite acceptable on environ-
2. Ryzhenko N. O., Bondar O. I., Chetverykov V.V.,
mental and economic indicators. However, in order Fedorenko Y.O. Polychlorinated biphenyls: Hazardous
to resolve finally the issue of possibility of burning properties and environmentally sound management in
oils contaminated with POPs, it is necessary to an- Ukraine. Regulatory Mechanisms in Biosystems. 2020,
alyze possibility of synthesis of dioxins/furans. 11 (1), pp. 37–44.
Ukraine is developing its own technologies for 3. Toolkit for Identification and Quantification of
thermal destruction of concentrated toxic organo- Releases of Dioxins, Furans and Other Unintentional
chlorine waste. The most promising among them are: POPs, UNEP, 2012. — http://toolkit.pops.int/Pub-
— technology for treatment of organochlorine lish/Downloads/UNEP-POPS-TOOLKIT-2012-En.pdf
4. Statistical Yearbook. Environment of Ukraine
waste in the melt of alkaline metal salts;
2018, State Statistics Service of Ukraine, Kyiv, 2019. —
— technology of steam-plasma gasification of http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/druk/publicat/kat_u/
hazardous waste. 2019/zb/11/Zb_dovk_2018.pdf
Unfortunately, to date, these technologies have 5. Output industrial products by type in 2018. State
not been sufficiently tested so that they can be rec- Statistics Service of Ukraine, Kyiv, 2019. — http://
ommended for wide implementation. www.ukrstat.gov.ua/druk/publicat/kat_u/2019/zb
/11/zb_yearbook_2018_e.pdf
Conclusions 6. Guidance on the global monitoring plan for per-
sistent organic pollutants, UNEP, 2015. — http://
1. There are large-scale environmental risks in chm.pops.int/Portals/0/download.aspx?d=UNEP-
Ukraine now caused by the following factors: POPS-COP.7-INF-39.English.pdf
— large volumes of use of POPs in electrical 7. Chetverykov, V., Koval, S., Rossoha, A., &
equipment; Bondar, O. (2018). Vyznachennja shljahiv ekologichno
obgruntovanogo vydalennja PHD v Ukrajini.
— large volumes of POPs-containing waste
[Guidelines on environmentally sound management and
(pesticides, hexachlorobenzene) stored in inappro- final disposal of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs)].
priate conditions; Kherson, Ukraine : OLDI-PPUS, 2018. 68 p. (Ukr.)