Tenant work

Review of CD of “SAMA” L.17 / L.18

Second revision- Detail drawing

Dec 24th/25th,26th 2022

Background of rev iew

Compliance with Requirement of submission

Basically some pints improved from previous submission however few points
found not comply with our comments on previous submission:
• Not following Technical Tenant guide line .
• Not providing all detail drawing requested by our comments.

2
Architectural Drawing

Following Comments applicable on both level 17th and 18th

PS: General Note drawing from Architect to Contractor not part of this review.
A-1:Furniture Lay out :

1.pressurization louvers Obstructed

by Wall , refer to tenant guide line
(and below site picture) – this
comment was given also in
previous revision.

2.Interface with base build wall

( door frame ) to be provided.

4
A-1.1:Furniture Lay out:

• Fire Hose cabinet Obstructed by

Sliding panels , please refer to
Tenant guide line and site
condition as this area highlighted
as restricted area to obstruct -
this comment was given also in
previous revision.

5
A-1.2:Furniture Lay out:

• Provide vertical section for

sliding panel showing track
mechanism to confirm track
for such panels will not
obstruct MEP Rooms door to
open outward ( confirm doors
height, also clarify on
requested section ceiling
height on this area) obstruct -
this comment was given also in
previous revision.

6
A-2:Reflected Ceiling Layout :

We noted that many Area’s ( as

example highlighted by Red mark on
This drawing) Exceed the limitation
set by Tenant Guide line which will
result with clash with MEP service
on site, please consider Tenant guide
line limitation of ceiling height - this
comment was given also in previous
revision.

7
A-2.1:Reflected Ceiling Layout :

Ceiling Plan not identify Location of

access panel for Facade light
controllers , and MEP Items, valves,
grills,,,etc.

Photo Taken from Tenant guide line Item: I.2.3.7

8
A-3:Floor Finish Layout :
Floor Finished Interface detail wit
h base build work missing
( Drawing no. ID-012/ ID-016)
Please consider actual location for
Threshold so Floor finish will be
extended to terminate with
Threshold.

9
A-4:Typical wall Detail:

• Slab deflection need to be

consider in upper detail of
tenant Dry wall
( Recommendation only)

Screenshot from wall Detail drawing

Our recommendation to use deflection Track

10
A-4.1:Typical wall Detail:

• Its not clear where one side gypsum

wall to be used, however of this
intended to use at core wall side , its
not necessary gypsum board to reach to
slab as there is a lot of penetration ,
refer to our recommendation detail for
your reference – as example gypsum
board stop above ceiling with 100mm Screenshot from wall Detail drawing
( Recommendation only)

Our recommendation 11
 A-4.2:Typical wall Detail:
• Please use actual façade detail ( please
request façade mullion as built) to make
proper detail,also note that each façade has
different inclination please consider , we
attach here our recommendation for your
reference

Actual site condition ,

please study this gypsum
For Reference detail Screenshot from wall Detail drawing
wall fire rated or not, if yes,
then consideration to
close area under
aluminum cover

12
A-5:/ Typical ceiling Det ails :

1.This ceiling height will clash with

current MEP service, please
reconfirm Tenant guide line for
limitation on ceiling height .

2. Please consider slab deflection

For upper detail of gypsum wall.

3.Please study smoke Extraction

with SAMA office to decide wall
above ceiling .

Above comment still same from last

revision

13
A-3:St air Case Detail:
For Opened Stairway between L.17 and 18 we noted that:

1.Stair protected by from 3side, but one side open , basically

stair connected to floor need to be isolated to prevent two
floors being connected during fire.
2.Fire consultant should verify this condition.

Concept to isolate stair for SAMA

understanding

Stair open to L.18 without any barrier

to prevent smoke going from L.17 to
L.18 14
A-3.1:St air Case Detail:
For Opened Stairway between L.17 and 18 we noted that:
2.SAMA drawing not utilizing Embedded plate to connect Main frame of stair , please refer to below and next drawing for as built condition of
such embedded plates.

As built location for Embedded Sama Drawing 15

A-3.2:St air Case Detail:
For Opened Stairway between L.17 and 18 we noted that:
2.SAMA drawing not utilizing Embedded plate to connect Main frame of stair , please refer to
below and next drawing for as built condition of such embedded plates.

As built location for Embedded

16
Electrical Drawing

Following Comments applicable on both level 17th and 18th

E-1:Fire Alarm Layout:

1. Rev.1 drawing updated for device

change from conventional Smoke
detector to Addressable, however
wiring loop still showing
conventional system “ End Loop”

18
E-2:Low Current Layout:

this cable tray to be shifted as this

location very congested and no
enough space to install this cable
tray. Refer to Tenant guide line and
as built condition for this area.

19
E-3:Panel board :

* As example in Drawing RKL-EL-

AD-17-016 SAMA drawing not
following as built condition , Rating
feeder in SMDB not following as
built power.

Screen shot from our as built

Screen shot from SAMA Drawing

20
Mechanical Drawing

Following Comments applicable on both level 17th and 18th

M-1:HVAC Duct work Layout 17t h Floor Mast er Plan Rev.1

Base building ventilation exhaust duct with inlet (smoke exhaust duct with inlet in case of fire)
needs to be taken into consideration which most likely would clash with the proposed ducting
route. (common)

As built condition SAMA R.1 Drawing , lot of

duct work in as built
condition not showing

22
M-1:HVAC Duct work Layout 17t h Floor Mast er Plan Rev.1

Base building ventilation exhaust duct with

inlet (smoke exhaust duct with inlet in
case of fire) needs to be taken into
consideration which most likely would
clash with the proposed ducting route.
(common)

Site picture 23
M-2:HVAC Duct work Layout 17t h Floor Mast er Plan Rev.1

It is observed that (some branch) ducts are not controlled with VAVs. It is recommended that all
duct branch ducts have VAVs with connection to associated AHU control,for sufficient thermal
control and fan speed control.

As built condition showing

tenant office requirement

24
M-3:HVAC Duct work Layout 17t h Floor Mast er Plan Rev.1

It is recommended to have supply diffusers at perimeter side in order to maintain comfortable

thermal environment which would create less radiation from the glazing (or from blind).

As built condition showing

tenant office requirement

25
M-4:HVAC Duct work Layout 17t h Floor Mast er Plan Rev.1

Base building ventilation exhaust duct with inlet (smoke exhaust duct with inlet in case of fire)
needs to be taken for the positioning of interior wall.(common)

As built condition SAMA R.1 Drawing , smoke

inlet not considered .

26