Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fex 2006.2
Fex 2006.2
Fex 2006.2
EXAMINATION REPORT
FINAL FELLOWSHIP EXAMINATION
SEPTEMBER 2006
GENERAL COMMENTS
In preparing for the examination candidates should be aware that the Objectives of Training guide the
range of content which may be assessed. It is important that candidates allow appropriate time and
resources for preparation for each section of the examination. As this is the Final Fellowship
examination, responses are expected to demonstrate a consultant level of prioritisation, judgement,
integration and decision making.
Description N % of exam
applied pharmacology 26 17
miscellaneous complications 12 8
paediatric anaesthesia 12 8
cardiac disease 11 7
applied anatomy 10 7
medicine 8 5
pain 7 5
regional anaesthesia 7 5
cardiac investigations 7 5
shock resuscitation 7 5
equipment 7 5
pregnancy obstetrics 6 4
monitoring 6 4
haematological disorder investigation 6 4
infection 5 3
statistics 5 3
rare diseases 5 3
renal disease & investigations 5 3
cardiac complications 5 3
liver disease 4 3
ophthalmic anaesthesia 4 3
applied physiology 4 3
acute trauma 4 3
anaesthetic plan 4 3
endocrine disease 4 3
acute trauma 4 3
equipment 4 3
C:\Documents and Settings\tansel.ANZCA\Local Settings\Temporary Internet Files\OLK387E\2006 2.doc
2
Description N % of exam
neuromuscular skeletal 4 3
anaphylaxis 3 2
monitoring 3 2
pre-operative clinical assessment 3 2
pulmonary investigations 3 2
critical care 3 2
DVT and PE 3 2
ENT anaesthesia 3 2
ophthalmic anaesthesia 3 2
orthopaedic anaesthesia 3 2
safety electrical 3 2
cardiac physiology 2 1
malignant hyperthermia 2 1
allergy atopy 2 1
applied physics 2 1
cardiac anaesthesia 2 1
elderly 2 1
neuropathy 2 1
neurosurgical anaesthesia 2 1
surgery 2 1
thoracic anaesthesia 2 1
urological anaesthesia 2 1
vascular anaesthesia 2 1
aspiration full stomach 1 1
difficult airway 1 1
liver disease 1 1
pulmonary disease 1 1
anaesthesia for ECT 1 1
colorectal anaesthesia 1 1
endoscopy imaging monitored care 1 1
ethics 1 1
laparoscopic surgery 1 1
obesity 1 1
postoperative care 1 1
The overall pass rate for this section of the examination was 42% Candidates are advised to apportion
their time equally amongst the short answer questions as all the questions are worth equal marks.
Candidates are reminded to read the question carefully and answer the question asked. The use of
abbreviations is discouraged as these can be open to different interpretations. Logical, organised
answers with legible handwriting will attract better marks.
Question SAQ subject Pass Rate
1 Equipment 81%
2 Anaesthesia Technique 55%
3 Applied Physiology 57%
4 Chronic Pain 66%
5 Perioperative Medicine 19%
6 Perioperative Medicine 45%
7 Obstetric Anaesthesia 28%
8 Neurosurgical Anaesthesia 45%
9 Pharmacological 686%
10 Anaesthetic Technique 46%
11 Pharmacology 47%
12 Pharmacology 56%
13 Anaesthetic Technique 70%
14 Medicine 36%
15 Pre-anaesthetic assessment 45%
3
Question 1: Discuss the risks and benefits associated with intermittent positive pressure
ventilation through proseal ® laryngeal mask airway for a patient undergoing
laparoscopic cholecystectomy.
Most candidates could list the main risks and benefits. A good answer required a
comprehensive list of risks and benefits specifically for a proseal mask in this
procedure. Most candidates realised the proseal provided a more effective seal with
IPPV but the pressure limits quoted varied from 20-50 cmH2O. Most also
acknowledged the presence of an oesophageal lumen but many did not mention passing
an orogastric tube to empty the stomach. Other common errors included describing the
Trendelenburg position for laparoscopic cholecystectomy rather than the reverse
Trendelenburg, which is usual. Many candidates suggested that the proseal is useful if
the patient is a known difficult intubation. This is considered inappropriate for an
elective case where a definitive airway could be established by other means. Many
candidates were not clear about the use of muscle relaxants. Many stated that muscle
relaxants would not be required with a proseal however it was unclear whether they
were suggesting the patient breathes spontaneously or have their ventilation suppressed
by other means. Overall this question was poorly answered considering it asked about
a common airway device in a common procedure.
Few candidates scored very high marks and the better answers had a logical layout with
some good anatomical diagrams. Legible handwriting is always appreciated. Many
candidates’ description of the block were inaccurate and incorrect. The optimum
insertion site was often too low and too wide. Better candidates indicated the depth
they would expect to strike the lateral process. Loss of resistance is an imprecise sign
and better candidates noted this and then indicated a depth of advancement beyond the
lateral process. The technique and anatomy is well described on the NYSORA.com
website. Some confused the interpleural block with the paravertebral block. Some
wasted time writing on thoracic epidurals and thoractomoy. Pneumothorax was
mentioned by most but is relatively rare. Many did not identify block failure as a
problem.
Question 3: Describe the cardiovascular changes which occur during clamping and
unclamping of the supra-renal aorta during repair of an abdominal aortic
aneurysm in a patient with normal ventricular function and outline your strategies
to maintain critical organ perfusion during these times.
Many candidates gave a good account of the cardiovascular changes which occur with
cross clamping of the supra-renal aorta. Unfortunately, a large number of answers were
incomplete in the other areas of the question ie. description of the cardiovascular
changes which occur with aortic unclamping and description of strategies for
maintaining critical organ perfusion during clamping and during unclamping. Such
incomplete answers generally scored poorly. Pharmacological and non-pharmacological
therapies which may have efficacy in protecting organ function but which do not
influence perfusion were not relevant.
Few answers were of a high standard despite phantom limb pain being a common
postoperative problem. There was confusion between phantom limb pain, phantom
sensations and stump pain. Some candidates did not appreciate this was a type of
4
neuropathic pain and therefore did not select the correct treatment. Some candidates
confused phantom limb pain with CRPS.
Question 5: Describe and justify an appropriate strategy for the use of low molecular weight
heparin in a patient undergoing knee replacement surgery with an epidural block.
The pass rate for this question was poor. Since there is little in the way of data on the
subject of neuraxial anaesthesia and anticoagulation, knowledge of the expert
consensus view is vital to the safe management of this technique in this common
setting. Candidates should not use unexplained or uninterpretable abbreviations.
Writing must be legible. Answers with an identifiable structure are easier to follow and
will aid candidates in providing more comprehensive answers. Elements of strategy
were rarely directly linked to justifications as the question asked.
Good answers reflected an awareness of the issues raised by the ASRA consensus
statement relating to this topic. These included:
• How strategy may be altered if a patient has used or is likely to be given other drugs
that affect haemostasis intra and post operatively
• Nomination of a drug, dosage, timing in relation to epidural insertion, dosage
interval
• Nomination of the type and concentration of epidural solution used to enhance the
early detection of epidural haematoma
• Strategy for catheter removal
• The critical place of staff education in post procedural monitoring (frequency and
duration and nature), specifically with the aim of early detection of signs associated
with epidural haematoma
• How the management plan might be altered if epidural insertion is traumatic
• The place of monitoring anti-Xa levels
Question 6: List and explain the typical electrolyte abnormalities of chronic renal failure.
This question required factual knowledge all too often missing in candidates responses.
• in many responses the only correct electrolyte abnormality correctly identified was
hyperkalaemia
• explanations were even more deficient
• confusion regarding serum sodium was widespread
• confusion regarding serum calcium and the role of parathyroid hormone was
widespread
• no marks were awarded for descriptions of blood chemistry abnormalities other than
electrolytes
Many answers gave a list of options with little clinical interface, some made a choice
from the options and fewer justified their choice.
Some answers did not mention this significant after effect of a dural puncture at all, or
gave scant emphasis to this debilitating problem. Much time was spent in detailed
issues with regard to the safe use of an intrathecal catheter, but few gave any insight
into the practical issues of such management in private practice (with no onsite medical
staff) or a busy hospital setting which may preclude this as an ongoing alternative.
Emphasis on explanation to the patient and ongoing communication and review was
laudable. A detailed description of the performance of an epidural blood patch was not
required.
Question 8: Describe the principles of cerebral protection in a patient with an isolated closed
head injury.
Most candidates did not provide a systematic approach towards maintaining adequate
cerebral oxygenation. They tended to provide a discussion just around cerebral
perfusion pressure. Several candidates gave an account of anaesthesia for head injured
patients which was not required. Surgical approach to reduce intracranial pressure was
mentioned by very few candidates.
Question 9: Nitrous oxide should not be used routinely as a component of general anaesthesia.
Discuss.
Most candidates were able to supply a list of good and bad features of Nitrous Oxide
and this formed a suitable introduction to the question. Better answers commented on
the critical importance of the agent’s features, and discussed the importance of newer
evidence as to nausea, immune suppression, and outcome to give a balance as to which
features should be regarded as most important to continue to use N20 in general
anaesthesia.
Question 10: Discuss in detail the technique of rapid sequence induction with cricoid pressure in
a child. Include the reasons for your choice of relaxant.
Discussion of rapid sequence induction and cricoid pressure was generally well
handled. However, candidates who did not mention the specific issues relevant to
children did not pass the question. Justification of choice of muscle relaxant was
adequate in most answers.
Question 11: Critically evaluate the use of Beta blockers in the perioperative period to prevent
myocardial infarction.
A number of candidates failed to identify which patient groups should receive this
treatment. Many failed to assess the evidence for the use of these drugs despite the
question requiring candidates to critically evaluate their use.
Ketamine is a very popular drug at the moment and a high standard of answer was
expected and generally most answers were of adequate standard.
A good answer required the candidate to apply part one knowledge to the current
clinical climate. Candidates must remember to read the question and legible hand
writing is useful.
Question 13: List the risks associated with the placement of a central venous catheter? Discuss
the ways in which these risks may be modified.
6
This question was generally well answered. Candidates had a good understanding
of the common risks (and the appropriate risk mitigation strategies) associated with the
placement of central lines. Good candidates recognised the risk of needlestick injury to
the operator and the risk of anaphylaxis with antibiotic or Chlorhexidine impregnated
lines.
Question 14: Critically evaluate the role of recombinant factor VIIa in blood loss requiring
massive transfusion in the trauma patient.
In general this question was poorly answered, despite many candidates knowing a lot of
information on the topic of Recombinant Factor 7a. The information was not organised
into a form that answered the question. The question as written asked for a critical
evaluation of the role of RF7a in major blood loss associated with trauma which should
involve a weighing of Pro’s and Con’s on the topic and a summary opinion on the role
of the drug.
Many candidates presented details that did not specifically answer the question as set,
such as: a description of RF7a, with detailed facts on the origin and makeup of the drug
or a full description of the coagulation pathway.
A listing of the Pro argument – points that could be discussed include : (but did not
necessarily have to completely include) were:
• A good theoretical basis for it’s usage
• Encouraging results from Case Reports
• It is quick and easy to use, with no storage problems.
• It may avoid many of the problems of continuing transfusion, such as
hypothermia, acid/base disturbance, volume overload etc.
• It does not carry a risk of infectious diseases transmission
• It may be of use in Jehovah Witness patients
1. A Listing of Con Arguments
• No evidence for it’s use
• Possibly a publication bias, as there is a tendency not to report bad outcomes.
• Off Licence product - problems of consent, paediatric use? etc
• Cost
• Availability.
• Agreement on usage between interested parties such as Haematology,
Anaesthesia.
• Side Effects?
• No real agreed protocol for it’s use
2. An Appreciation of the Practical Issues Involved, such as:
Question 15: Discuss the usefulness of the ASA grading as a measure of perioperative risk.
Although there was a good overall pass rate, there was a wide range of performance in this section of
the examination. Examiners attempt to set a task for candidates that can be completed in the given time
frame. Candidates who performed poorly in this section did not have a systematic approach to a
focused history and examination or frequently missed vital information because they did not listen to
the patient’s answers to their questions. This is an important section of the examination as it is the only
opportunity examiners get to see candidates interact with patients.
• Interviewing skills i.e. obtaining relevant and accurate information, listening to the patient and
responding to their non-verbal cues
• Professionalism i.e. shows respect, compassion to patient and is sensitive to patient comfort,
modesty
ANAESTHESIA VIVAS
The aim of this section of the examination is to assess the candidates’ ability to:
Some scenarios may contain co-morbidities or diseases that some candidates have not had experience
with e.g. cystic fibrosis but which is reasonably considered part of the curriculum i.e. chronic
respiratory disease (module 5). It is expected that a consultant anaesthetist will have a systematic way
of thinking about this content which achieves the desired safe anaesthesia practice.
She has no other significant medical history and no allergies. She weighs 15 kg.
She has been receiving vincristine and doxorubicin prior to her planned nephrectomy.
How would you assess the potential side effects of this chemotherapy?
8
2. You are requested to anaesthetize a woman who is 32 weeks pregnant with a suspect acute
appendicitis. She is febrile 38.2C, tachycardic, tachypnea and looks unwell. The surgeon
plans to perform a laparoscopic appendenctomy.
What are the anaesthetic implications of the physiologic changes of pregnancy in this
lady?
3. 63 year old male presents with headache, sweating, chest pain, palpatations. BP 220/120 and
pulse of 65. Past history of hypertension controlled on enalapril, myocardial infarction 3 yrs
ago. Smokes 20 cigarettes/day. A left adrenal phaeochromocytoma is confirmed by 24 hour
urine catecholamine levels and MRI. The patient is scheduled for laparoscopic adrenalectomy
in 2 weeks.
What are the management goals for this patient before they come to theatre?
4. A 35 year old female with metastatic breast cancer is admitted with a pathological femur
fracture and is booked for a femoral nail. She is significantly short of breath. Her last course
of chemo was 4 months ago, and she is currently on various ‘alternative therapies’ under the
guidance of her naturopath.
5. A 57 year old man presented to the emergency department with 4 hour onset of severe back
pain, leg weakness and faecal incontinence.
6. You are called to the Emergency Department to assist the medical staff there who are
struggling to analgese a 54 year old male involved in a pedestrian accident leaving him with a
compound fracture of his left tibia and fibula. He has been given 45mg intravenous morphine
and as you approach the ED he is still screaming in pain.
7. A 55 year old man presents to the Emergency Department following a 1 metre fall from a
ladder whilst painting his house.
He has a fractured right radius which the ED staff would like reduced under an intravenous
regional anaesthetic technique. He was diagnosed with Ankylosing Spondylitis at the age of
35.
His current medications include prednisone 10mg, methotrexate and diclofenac. A lateral spine
x-ray was taken because of the pain.
A surgeon calls and advises that he has a patient on the ward who has just been transferred
from a local nursing home. He feels she needs urgent laparotomy. He tells you she’s not in
good shape and he’s worried she may have dead gut. He has a theatre organized for a half hour
from now.
9. You are the retrieval anaesthetist at a factory where a 30 yr old man is trapped by his partially
severed and obviously fractured Right forearm under heavy machinery. He is screaming in
pain and continues to bleed freely from his arm wound. His head is just under the machine
giving you no access to his airway other than to deliver oxygen via nasal cannula. Amputation
may be the only option to free him.
10. A 2 year-old presents for bilateral ueteric reimplantation, she weighs 14 kg and is otherwise
well. Her parents are very anxious about pain post operatively.
The parents ask what the options are for post-operative pain management for this child
for this procedure. Explain their risks and benefits.
11. You are telephoned and asked to urgently attend the emergency department to assist with the
management of a 25 year old woman who has been brought in following a high speed motor
vehicle accident. She is confused and hypotensive. Her husband, who has suffered minor
injuries in the crash, has informed staff that his wife is 28 weeks pregnant with their first child.
On arrival in the resuscitation room how will you conduct you initial assessment?
12. A 47 year old female is booked on your next morning list for resection of liver tumour. The
biopsy reveals carcinoid tumour.
13. A 65 yr old lady requires surgery for revision hip arthroplasty. She has longstanding atrial
11
fibrillation and a history of transient ischaemic attacks prior to being put on
warfarin therapy. Currently she is on warfarin 3 mg daily. You are consulted one week prior to
the planned surgery.
What further details of her history are relevant to planning your anaesthetic?
14. A 52 year old female presents for coiling of a left anterior communicating artery aneurysm.
She is a smoker with a known history of hypertension and ischaemic heart disease.
BP 180/110
HR 100
ECG: ST elevation, T wave inversion, QT prolongation.
15. A 26 year old male presents for laparotomy and bowel resection for Crohn’s disease. The
patient takes prednisone 20 mg and oxycontin 120 mgs daily. He has no other co-morbidities.
The patient requests an epidural for post-operative analgesia.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of an epidural for post-operative analgesia
in this patient ?
16. You are the anaesthetist working on a retrieval team in a major metropolitan hospital. You take
a call from a GP in a remote town 60 min away by helicopter.
She requests retrieval of an 18 year old male who has been trapped in a house fire. The patient
is estimated to have 50% burns, including airway and facial burns. The GP states that the
patient has stridor.
17. A 77 year old from a nursing home presents with an acute abdomen; the surgeon are concerned
she has a perforated viscus and want to perform a laparotomy.
18. You are the consultant anaesthetist on call . The hospital anaesthesia registrar is an Emergency
Medicine Trainee with 7 months anaesthesia experience. He rings you for advice regarding
the induction of anaesthesia for the following case. An intoxicated 18 year old male has had
his right leg run over after a push bike accident. He has sustained compound fractures to both
tibia and fibula with significant soft tissue loss. There are no other injuries. He is
cardiovascularly stable. He has no apparent head injury and his cervical spine has been cleared.
He refuses any regional techniques. His initial orthopaedic surgery will take 2 hours.
What advice do you give the registrar regarding the induction of anaesthesia?
M.A. JOSEPH
CHAIRMAN
FINAL EXAMINATION