Professional Documents
Culture Documents
How The Cultural Frameworks of Thailand and Laos Influence The Control and Management of Sex Trafficking
How The Cultural Frameworks of Thailand and Laos Influence The Control and Management of Sex Trafficking
By
Pat Ratanasirivliai
SOCI E-143
transfer, harboring or receipt of people through force, fraud, or deception (FFC) for the
Protocol (UNTOC or Palermo Convention) that was enacted in 2000 with more than 147
signatures, it is on the rise all over the world (Fitzgibbon, 2003). Asia and the Pacific is
the area with the highest number of human trafficking in the world with Thailand as one
of the major hubs of human trafficking in the region (Niamvanichkul, 2011). Human
provision, or obtaining of a person for labor or services, through the use of force, fraud,
the purpose of a commercial sex act in which a commercial sex act is induced by force,
fraud, or coercion, or in which the person induced to perform such act has not attained
U.S. law defines the term force as— (A) the use of a weapon; (B) the use of such
(C) inflicting physical harm sufficient to coerce or compel submission by the victim (10
USC § 920(g)(4)). Fraud is the intentional use of deceit, a trick or some dishonest
means to deprive another of his or her money, property or a legal right. The term
“coercion” means— (A) threats of serious harm to or physical restraint against any
person; (B) any scheme, plan, or pattern intended to cause a person to believe that
failure to perform an act would result in serious harm to or physical restraint against any
person; or (C) the abuse or threatened abuse of law or the legal process (18 USC §
1591(e)(2))
However, in the case of sex trafficking in Thailand and Laos, the situation of
force, fraud, and coercion is not as direct as defined by Human Rights First, a U.S.
based NGO working on sex trafficking. Most trafficked women in Thailand and Laos are
indirectly coerced into sex work by underlying expectations within the cultural
(Niamvanichkul, 2011; Molland, 2011). Despite the general public’s opinion and the
apply the UN definition of trafficking to these women in Thailand due to cultural reasons
and the nature of exploitation. This leads to difficulty in identifying and solving the
trafficking problems by case workers (Molland, 2). This paper argues that the
complexities of Thai and Lao culture act as a form of indirect coercion of both Thai and
Lao women in sex trafficking and that the definition of force, fraud, and coercion (FFC)
by the UN is highly debatable to this group of Thai and Lao sex workers
Introduction
more Lao people are looking for a better economic opportunity and many have at least
one time in their life crossed the border between Vietiane and Nong Kai through the
2017)
. It is quite easy for Thai and Lao people to cross the border to the other country
because of the special visa agreement as both are ASEAN country members. Even
without a passport, Lao and Thai people can also obtain a special permit at the border
between the government of the Kingdom of Thailand and the government of the Lao
ข ้ามแดนระหว่างรัฐบาลแห่งราชอาณาจักรไทยกับรัฐบาลแห่งสาธารณประชาธิปไตยประชาชนลาว,
1997). The border between Vientiane and Nong Kai is where sex trafficking happens. A
source, destination, and transit country for men, women, and children subjected to
forced labor and sex trafficking." In a recent PBS video, "Global Voices Day: My God
Died" (2024), it is estimated that Thailand's sex industry attracts approximately three to
five million frequent customers and is worth more than 6.4 billion dollars. In Thailand,
local women, men, and children are trafficked into other countries, especially wealthier
Asian countries such as Japan, Malaysia, and Singapore.The number of trafficked Thai
females in Japan alone is between 50,000 and 70,000 (Taylor, 2005). According to the
International Organization for Migration (2000), “Thai women were first trafficked to
Singapore and Malaysia, but the trafficking later expanded to Japan, Taiwan, Europe,
Many women and children from other countries are also trafficked into Thailand.
Many migrants from other countries are trafficked into Thailand to work as sex workers.
and Lao trafficked to work in brothels in northern provinces such as Chiang Mai and big
cities such as Bangkok and Pattaya. The estimated number of commercial sex workers
in Bangkok are 200,000( Niamvanichkul, 2011 ). Every year, between 200,000 and
450,000 people are trafficked in the Greater Mekong Subregion. The majority are young
women from Laos. Despite moving to Thailand voluntarily at first to seek better
employment opportunities, they are later coerced into prostitution both directly and
2023).
With the portrayal of media in the west, many people believe that young women
from poor countries might be tricked or coerced into sex work without their consent and
they are not able to escape from the situation because they are in a position with much
lower power dynamic or that their employers take their passport or means of escape
(Meyer et al, 2019) . Some might be bound to work off their debt as employers pay for
2011). If they are sold by their family, it must be the case that their father is addicted to
drugs or they are in abject poverty and have no choice but to sell some of their children
in hope for their better life (Molland, 54). Some of the described situations are mostly
true for certain groups such as the Burmese people who got trafficked to Thailand. 75%
of the Burmese women who worked in the sex industry described the nature of their
trafficking that involves a strong indication of force, fraud, and coercion (Meyer et al,
2019).
However, the situation in Thailand and Laos are a lot different than what the
media portray or the general public believe. Usually, the process of recruitment starts
when someone who left the village to work in a big city in Thailand came back to the
village to visit her parents and relatives. She came back wearing modern, beautiful
clothes with beautiful hair and makeup. She appeared happy and successful and
boasted about how she made “the right decision” to leave a small rural village for a big
city. Now she has a comfortable job that does not involve any form of agrarian hard
labor and makes a lot of money that can be used to afford a better lifestyle for her
parents by building a new house or buying a new motorcycle, electrical appliances, and
smartphones. Her story drew a lot of attention from other younger female villagers who
viewed her as a role model and also aspired to leave a small village for a big,
glamorous city life. The “successful” returner, nonetheless, did not disclose the nature of
her employment in the big city but would be happy to help other girls in the village who
aspired for a better life to come join her in Thailand. Travel arrangements were made
and these Lao women from a small village made their entry into Thailand. Upon arrival
at a restaurant or any designated premise, they found out that the glamorous job that
made a lot of money was to sell sex. They, at first, refused to do it. However, the
manager or “mamasan” did not force or coerce them and suggested that if they did not
want to sell sex, they could sell drinks, do the dishes, or other jobs in the restaurant,
which they obliged. After one or two months of doing menial labor in the restaurant, they
started to realize that the women who sold sex made a lot more than them and could
afford beautiful clothes, makeup, and nice things, so now they wanted to sell sex too.
They also realized that the job was not that bad and even pleasant because some of the
This is a common scenario of how sex trafficking is done through the Thai Lao
border and a prevalent gateway on how Thai and Lao women enter into the sex industry
in the first place (Molland, 2011). This scenario confuses many people, especially the
or coercion (FFC) are not clearly met here. It is true that they crossed the border under
the ruse that a job will be provided for them. However, upon arrival, after finding out
about the nature of the job, they were not forced to engage if they did not want to. One
might argue that this is not the case of trafficking because they could leave if they
wanted to. There was no known debt bondage here or if there had been debt incurred, it
could have been paid off by their salary or other jobs that were not sexual in nature.
The argument to determine that this is a sex trafficking case includes one that
takes into consideration the state of mind of the women when they worked on the
premise. They might fear retribution or violence if they refused to engage in sex work.
There are also other subtle or cultural elements in the scenario that could be indirectly
linked to coercion such as the fear of returning home as a failure, economic pressure,
and peer pressure. Can these elements be included as a form of coercion? That it
One key element in human trafficking is the trafficker. A lot of scholarship and
media paint the picture of traffickers as gang members from the organized crime
enterprises in the region (Niamvanichkul, 2011; Meyer et al, 2019 ). However, in this
scenario, the trafficker is usually a woman who used to be trafficked in the same
scenario and might still be working as a sex worker in the same bar or restaurant. Once
she gets older or she is economically incentivized by the restaurant’s manager, she will
try to recruit newcomers from the same village when she goes back to visit her
hometown (Molland, 121). The girls she recruits usually are those she might know
personally or have family ties with her. Therefore, in a way, she is both being trafficked
and trafficking other women. She is being exploited and exploiting others at the same
time. This makes the legal process extremely difficult when it comes to prosecution
because she is also a victim of sex trafficking which is deeply rooted in Thai Lao culture.
Bunkhun is a psychological bond between someone who, out of sheer kindness and
sincerity, renders another person the needed helps and favors, and the latter's
remembering of the goodness done and his ever-readiness to reciprocate the kindness
(Jittichanon, 2018; Komin, 242). In the scenario where the women get trafficked from
Laos to engage in sex work in Thailand, they might not comprehend the fact that they
get trafficked because in their view, someone who is from the same village as them help
secure employment in a bigger city for them, pay for their transportation, and give them
a gift such as a new dress or makeup. They feel indebted to this person and do not view
the traffickers as “bad people’ but rather saviors that rescue them out of poverty. When
The concept of sex, virginity, relationship, and marriage in Thai and Lao cultural
when the cultural practice has to be taken into account when determining if the said
In Thai, there is no word for sex in the same sentiment as in English. The term is
“dai-sia” when a man and a woman have sexual intercourse. The literal translation of
the term “dai-sia” is gain-lose which means a man gains and a woman loses (Royal
Thai Dictionary, 2011). The implication is that it does not matter if sex is consensual, a
man always gains something from a woman like her virginity or her worth while a
woman loses her virginity or her worth to a man. Another synonym for dai-sia is “sia-tuo”
which is literally translated to “lose body,” meaning a woman loses her body as in her
virginity, worth or sense of self to a man (Royal Thai Dictionary, 2011). Thus, in this
cultural context, any form of sexual relations such as kissing, touching, or even holding
hands in public are construed as sexual transgression which has a deep moral
man is caught having premarital sex with a woman in a rural village of Thailand or Laos,
he is expected to either marry her to regain her social status or paying a fine to the
woman’s family. This kind of case happens a lot in Thailand where a man is caught
having premarital sex with an underage woman. The woman’s family threatens to press
negotiation process as well because the rape charge also does affect the woman’s
reputation in a negative way. So in a way, a man could “pay” his way off the sexual
transgression he committed against her. The reason for this is because a woman’s
sexual reputation affects her ability to be married and the amount of the bride price her
family will receive on her wedding day (Mitchell, Chartisathian, and Sachdev, Web).
Contrary to the western culture where the bride/s family is expected to pay for the
wedding and dowry, Thai and Lao women are expected to be paid a “bride price” or “sin
sod,” which will be displayed in the form of gold bars, cash, and a diamond ring. The
amount varies and goes from $3,000 to $300,000 depending on various factors
including the woman’s purity, look, education, and social status. A beauty queen or
female celebrity is expected to be paid a very high bride price in Thai society (Mitchell,
family as a form of
repayment for
(Molland, 86). In
“kha nam nom,” which means the price of the mother’s milk in Thai (Royal Thai
Dictionary, 2011). Therefore, if a groom finds out about her premarital relationship with
any other man, her purity will be seen as tarnished and the amount of the bride price will
drop subsequently. This is especially true in the rural areas of Thailand and Laos where
most women do not have high education and have a poor family background. Since any
sexual transgression toward an unmarried woman reduces the value of her future bride
price, a woman’s family believes that they are eligible to get financially compensated for
many young Lao women to sell their virginity (Molland 2011). This practice has since
become popular and increased the rate of trafficking of minors for sexual exploitation.
According to the UN Parlemo protocol, any person under 18 is not able to consent to
sex (Protocol). Therefore, all the virginity sales are a form of sex trafficking as the age
when women start their debut in the sex industry could be as young as 15 years old
(Molland 2011). This is due to the popular belief that young women are more likely to be
virgins. The price of the virginity sales goes from $300 (10,000 baht) to $1,400 (50,000
baht) based on the woman’s look and complexion color (Yongcharoenchai, 2016). The
reasoning behind this practice is that they view losing their virginity to their boyfriends
as a losing strategy because there is no guarantee that they will be married to them in
the future (Molland, 2011). Thus, many young girls believe it is better to sell their
In a Thai and Lao culture, the role of parents and children are intertwined with the
belief in Theravada Buddhism. Parents give life to their children and in return, children
repay their payments when they grow up. However, how men and women pay back to
their parents are different. Men can be ordained as Buddhist monks and assign all the
merits they get to their parents (Molland, 2011). However, women cannot become
monks and fulfill the same duty. This is because in Buddhism, Buddha placed women
they can become enlightened (Paudel & Dong, 2017). This is the reason why there are
no female Buddhist monks in Theravada Buddhism. Hence, the only way women give
back to their parents is through care during parent’s old age and financial means
(Molland, 2011). Women are expected to financially support their family. The financial
pressure is high especially in the rural areas in the era of globalization where jobs can
only be found in big cities. With little to no education, a lot of women resort to sex work
Premarital sex is a taboo in Thai and Lao culture. Having a boyfriend is seen as
generated from sex work can be sent back to the sex worker’s family to support their
better lifestyle and education for their younger male siblings (Molland, 2011; Molland,
87). The merits generated from taking care of the family wipe away the stigma
associated with prostitution as they perform their duties of taking care of parents
(Molland, 84).This is also a reason why many Thai and Lao women enter into the sex
industry after breaking up with their boyfriend (Molland, 88). Since they are no longer
virgins and lose social status in society as women, they are still valuable in the
economic sense from commodification of their bodies and still can be “dutiful daughters
(Statham, 2019).”
Relationships and marriage are transactional in nature. Thai and Lao women
understand and are taught that as wives, their duties are to take care of the husband,
children, and household. This means they are to give love, affection, physical touch and
sex to their husbands as their duties. In return, their husbands are obligated to support
them and their families through financial means (Statham, 2019). A good example of
retirement or divorce in a
aunts, uncles, cousins, or grandparents (Streckfuss, Web). The trend of a Thai woman
being married to an older western caucasian man has become popular and is the
ultimate goal of many Thai and Lao women as they can enjoy stability from the
western’s man retirement or pension funds until he is deceased. Many businesses such
as online dating agencies have been established in Thailand to cater the needs of these
women to match with older western caucasian men. This also includes a language
The property law in Thailand also favors Thai nationals economically. Ironically,
this inadvertently encourages Thai girls to enter into sexually exploitative relationships
in exchange for financial security. According to Thai property regulations, foreigners are
generally restricted from directly owning land, and may require a Thai partner for certain
under the Thai wife's name (Statham, 2019). This law also helps facilitate the financial
Since the goal of many Thai and Lao women is to land a financial arrangement
restaurant, bar, night club, or entertainment complexes where western male tourists
frequent is the best way to get a chance to meet them and possibly form a relationship
(Statham, 2019). Many older western caucasian men met their spouses from a bar
scene where their wives used to work as bar girls. One particular Thai woman named
Lon from the rural northern part of Thailand was a good example for this case. In the
book “My name Lon. You like me? (Sharron, 2005) ,” she entered into the sex industry
or in other words got trafficked when she was 14 and worked as a bar girl due to the
financial pressure put on her by her mother and brother. She later met her Swedish
husband in a bar where she worked and relocated to Sweden. “My impoverished culture
and my mother were the impetus for the sale of my dignity, but my actions saved my
Suppression of Prostitution Act, 1996). Police rarely enforce the law and only choose to
do so in the case where the premises where sex workers work refuse to pay bribes
(Villar, 2019). According to the Royal Thai Government’s Country Report on Anti-Human
Trafficking Efforts (2021), many times, when sex trafficking cases are investigated in
Thailand, there is always more than one police officer involved in the trafficking process.
In one case, five police officers were found to be complicit. Thai police use the
anti-human trafficking law as a reason to raid the entertainment complexes for their own
benefit and choose to prosecute the premises that do not pay bribes to them (Villar,
2019). Sex workers, especially migrant sex workers, are extremely vulnerable because
there is no law to protect them (Meyer et al, 2019). They are usually exploited by
employers and paid less Than Thai sex workers because the employers know of this
fact. In the case where sex workers report abuse to police, they are likely going to get
the country, so law does not protect or give any rights to foreign sex workers in
Thailand. Even a form of STI protection such as a condom if found can be used against
1990s a senior Thai general justified having Burmese prostitutes in Ranong by uttering:
“In my opinion it is disgraceful to let Burmese men frequent Thai prostitutes. Therefore, I
have been flexible in allowing Burmese prostitutes to work here” (Nation 1993).
In Laos, prostitution is illegal as well. Police also rarely enforce the law. However,
the difference is that sex work is more discreet in that restaurants, bars, or nightclubs do
not allow sex workers and customers to engage sex acts on the premises. Customers
pay the places to take the women out to a nearby motel where the sex acts happen
(Molland, 91). However, in Thailand, a lot of venues also provide rooms for customers
Conclusion
Sex trafficking in Thailand and Laos has remained a problem due to cultural
environment of indirect coercion for girls and minors to be sex trafficked and exploited.
The cultural beliefs that require women to take care of and provide for their parents and
incomes despite their lack of formal education. This, in turn, causes many of them to
look for employment in big cities that expose them to being trafficked (Molland, 2011).
Even though many women find out later that the high paying jobs are all sex jobs, they
still choose to participate in sex work because of the economic benefits reaped from this
kind of work in comparison to other menial labor they can do (Molland, 95). Admitting
their failure to secure a good job after moving to a big city might also be another factor
that prevents them from returning home after finding out about the nature of the sex
work. Also, providing sex work in restaurants, bars, nightclubs, and entertainment
complexes gives them opportunities to meet with potential western partners who can
accept their sexual history and provide them with financial means to take care of
themselves and their family members including their children from previous relationship
Despite their willingness to participate in sex work later, the onset of the
trafficking usually involves recruiting them under some form of pretense indicating non
sex work jobs in a big city. Once girls or minors arrive there, they learn about the
difference in pay between sex jobs and non sex jobs. They might refuse to do sex work
at first but finally give in after acclimating themselves in the bar scene while watching
other sex workers entertain or spend time with customers (Molland, 2). This can also be
peer pressure that indirectly coerces these young women to start doing sex work. At this
point they are alone in a big city and not with their family or friends from the old village.
They might fear the consequences of refusing to do sex work because they have a
personal relationship with a trafficker or hold the concept of “bunkhun.” This leads to
more complications for case workers to determine if the cases they work on are sex
trafficking or prostitution since the coercion is indirect and caused by cultural, economic,
and social factors and not because of force, fraud, or (direct) coercion.
Bibliography
Primary Source
“Lifting the veil on virgin brides for sale”. Bangkok Post. Accessed May 6, 2024.
“Marriage: a matter of wife and debt?”. Bangkok Post. Accessed May 6, 2024.
“Sex in grey areas: sting operations horrify Thai sex workers by Kornkritch
“Tied in a knot: the Thai wives who go abroad”. Bangkok Post. Accessed May 6,
2024.
Secondary Sources
Books
Persons in Africa." African Security Review, vol. 12, no. 1, 2003, pp. 81-89.
Hattaway, Paul, ed. (2004), "Isan", Peoples of the Buddhist World, William Carey
Library, p. 103.
Komin, Suntaree. Psychology of the Thai People: Values and Behavioral
1990.
Molland, Sverre. The Perfect Business? Anti-Trafficking and the Sex Trade Along
Sharron, Derek. My Name Lon, You Like Me?: A True Story. 1st ed., Bangkok
Journal Articles
Meyer, Sarah R. et al. "Gender Differences in Violence and Other Human Rights
and Commodification of Virginity along the Mekong." The Asia Pacific Journal of
An Ethical Analysis." Open Access Library Journal, vol. 4, no. 4, Apr. 2017.
Women Who Partner Western Men." Population, Space and Place, vol. 27, no. 5,
Villar, Leo Bernardo. "Unacceptable Forms of Work in the Thai Sex and
Entertainment Industry." Anti-trafficking review, vol. 12, no. 4, 2019, pp. 108-126.
Law
Beach, Regina G. "The Lotus Project: Tackling Laos' Sex Trafficking Problem."
https://www.reginagbeach.com/blog/2018/4/13/the-lotus-project-tackling-laos-sex
-trafficking-problem
2024.
ระหว่างรัฐบาลแห่งราชอาณาจักรไทยกับรัฐบาลแห่งสาธารณประชาธิปไตยประชาชนลาว.
empowerment for Isaan women?. The Isaan Record. August 25, 2020.
United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) Lao. "Fourth Population and Housing
https://lao.unfpa.org/sites/default/files/pub-pdf/PHC-ENG-FNAL-WEB_0.pdf
United States. Congress. Trafficking Victims Protection Act of 2000. Public Law
https://www.state.gov/reports/2023-trafficking-in-persons-report/thailand.
https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/laos-population/.