Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HSC Economics Essay Scaffolds 2019 Covering Most Topics
HSC Economics Essay Scaffolds 2019 Covering Most Topics
For an economy other than Australia, discuss the strategies used to promote economic growth and
development
In recent decades, the Chinese government have adopted policies that involves capturing the
benets of globalisaon, primarily the increase in nancial ows through ODP and TNC's
populaon in higher educaon grew strongly from 1.4% in 1978 to over 20% in 2019 as a result of
the policy. However, access to educaon and schooling remains uneven with the 9-year compulsory
educaon policy unaecng around 20% of the populaon, these being mostly students living in
rural areas. Students born into auent families, usually living in SEZs such as Shanghai and Beijing,
have a much greater access to high-quality educaon than those from lower income families which is
highlighted in the literacy rates of Shanghai and Beijing in 2014 being 98.52% and 96.85%
respecvely whereas the literacy rate in Tibet in 2014, a rural area, was just 60.07%. This lack of
equal accessibility to educaon has also contributed to the widening of the distribuon of income
and wealth, with income levels in urban areas 150% higher than naonal average, four mes the
amount of rural areas.
Explain the implicaons of appreciaons and depreciaons in the value of the Australian Dollar for
the Australian economy
Australian dollar oated in 1983, has been subjected to uctuaons due to interacons of market
forces. These uctuaons have been accompanied by posive and negave eects on the Australian
economy
Body 2: Depreciaon disadvantage - Increased net primary income decit VALUATION EFFECT
Explain the causes and eects of recent trends in the exchange rate in the Australian economy
INTRO:
The exchange rate is the value of currency measured in the terms of another
Since 1983, Australia has had a oang exchange rate, where the value is measured by
supply and demand of AUD in the forex market, which establishes an equilibrium price
o This has meant the AUD has been exposed to volality from external
shocks
The value of the exchange rate can also be measured bilaterally (with one other) or
through the Trade Weighted Index
Appreciaon occurs when the value of the AUD increases in value relave to another
currency
Causes of uctuaons in the exchange rate are global and domesc economic
condions, interest rate dierenals and expectaons and speculaon
Exchange rate has a rippling eect on Australia's internaonal compeveness, trade,
growth, unemployment and inaon
AUD peaked at $1.10 USD in 2011 following the resources boom, but has steadily
declined since to $0.68 currently
5th most traded currency
P6: EFFECT - Increased purchasing power > Improved standards of living + control of inaonary
pressures
Appreciaon leads to increased purchasing power, increasing real incomes and
material standards of living
Cost-push inaon reduced
Imports are cheaper overseas and also hard for domesc rms to increase prices
2011, AUD peaked at $1.10 USD due to the mining boom. This helped contain
inaonary pressures through lower import prices
o Inaon remained below 3% despite strong growth at 4.2%
Discuss the eects of proteconist policies and free trade agreements on the Australian economy
Body 1: Taris
Taxes on imported goods imposed for the purpose of protecng domesc industries
o Makes domesc producers more compeve by arcially making
imports more expensive
o TARIFF GRAPH
o Taris raise the price of goods and services
o Expands domesc producon
Decline in taris from 1980 36% > 1.6% 2019
Retaliaon eect may lead to loss of export income
Inecient allocaon of resources as incomes transferred to inecient rms/industries
Body 2: Subsidies
Financial assistance to domesc producers, enabling them to reduce their selling price
and compete with ecient overseas rms
o SUBSIDY GRAPH
o Increases domesc producon/supply and employment
o Lowers price of goods
Direct cost on government budgets (therefore subsidies can be temporary)
o Economists prefer subsidies as more likely to be removed as it costs for
government
Reduced producvity growth
Automove industry
EU use of subsidies in agriculture industry, 30% of budget protecng agriculture
Body 3: Quotas
Refers to restricons on the amount or value of goods that may be imported
o QUOTA GRAPH
Higher cost-push inaon
Explain the trends and causes for Australia's current account situaon and explain
strategies/policy opons that are available to ensure it remains sustainable
Historically, Australia has had a persistent CAD for the last 44 years which occurs when net debit on
the current account exceeds the value of the net credits. These sustained CADs raise quesons about
Australia's external stability, investor condence and solvency of rms and the government. The
main cause of Australia's persistent CAD in recent decades has been due to the savings-investment
gap as well as cyclical factors such as the mining boom and China's rate of growth. However, recently
Australia has recorded a CAS for the rst me in 44 years, as a result of strong and growing
commodity prices. Policies to ensure Australia can maintain external stability in the medium term
include microeconomic policies of compulsory superannuaon to reduce the savings-investment gap,
taxaon reform and compeon policies to improve Australia's internaonal compeveness as well
as trade liberalisaon to widen the narrow export base of Australia.
The underlying and largest cause of Australia's historic CAD has been the savings-investment gap.
This is due to Australia having large naonal endowment in natural resources with a relavely low
populaon (23 million) which does not have enough to fund domesc investment. Accordingly, 15%
of total investment in Australia is from foreign investment which are recorded as credits on the
Financial Account. This leads to greater Net Foreign Liabilies which currently stands at 60% of GDP.
Servicing of this debt with interest are recorded as debits on the current account, which have heavily
contributed to Australia's historically persistent CAD. Further, cyclical factors such as the mining
boom, have also contributed to the CAD as large sums of prot were registered as a debit on the NPY
to foreign companies such as BHP Billiton,
Historically, Australia's trade balance has also contributed to the CAD however only recently, it has
contributed to the CAS. Australia's Balance of Goods and Services (BOGS) has uctuated between
decit and surplus in the last 15 years due to Australia's narrow export base and the altering
demands and prices of commodies and natural resources. Paul Keng in the early 90s stated that
Australia is at risk of becoming a "Banana Republic" due to our narrow export base and heavily
reliance on commodies. However, recently due to external factors such as the collapse of the
Brumadinho Dam and subsequent ooding of the Vale Mine as well as the aack on Saudi Arabian oil
processing plant, leading to a reducon in oil supply, demand for Australia's exports have increased
as well as the price, which has largely contributed to Australia's most recent CAS, the rst me since
1975.
Policies
Compulsory superannuaon
o Currently 9.5% projected 12% by 2026
Fiscal consolidaon
o Reducon in govt. expenditure and increase in taxaon
Budget decit shrunk from 3.2% to a predicted surplus in
2019-20
o Reduces crowding out eect
Where domesc rms are forced to seek foreign
investment to expand
Tax reform (reducon in company tax)
o 2016-17 budget: 28.5% > 27.5% expected 25% by 2026
o Designed to help Australian rms IC as overseas company tax is 22%
o Exporng industries will expand producon, improving trade balance
and CAD
o Facilitate expansion of producve industries such as educaon and ETMs
which could move into emerging economies such as China
Would help diversify Australia's narrow export base and
improve BOGS > CAD
Trade liberalisaon
o Signing of bilateral trade agreements with US, Korea, China
o Tari-free market access for Australian exports
China-Australia FTA (2015) allowed Australia wheat
exporters to have tari-free access to Chinese markets and
also allowed Australian rms to build hotels in urbanising
China
Increased exports > Credit on CA> Improved BOGS >
Reduce CAD
o Also reduces the price of imports, forcing Australian rms to improve
dynamic/technical/allocave eciency
Analyse the causes of unemployment and its eects on the Australian economy
INTRO:
Unemployment occurs when people in the labour force are not employed for at least 1
paid hour of work a week
Full employment is one of the main economic objecves of Australia
Unemployment rate is calculated by:
Various types of unemployment are: cyclical, structural as well as friconal, hidden,
seasonal
Government uses micro and macro policies to decrease unemployment
Australia's current unemployment rate is 5.3%
There is a growing problem of underemployment, where individuals are not workinig
as much as they want
o Labour underulisaon rate is 14%
Explain the causes of inaon and its eects on the Australian economy
INTRO:
Inaon refers to the general rise in price levels of goods and services in the economy
over me
Inaon is measured by the Consumer Price Index, a weighted basket of goods and
services purchased by households
Strong economic growth reected by the increase in demand from AD to AD2 results in
an increase in prices levels from P1 to P2 and hence demand-pull inaon
Inaonary expectaons, when people believe inaon will occur in the future, their
acons will contribute to current inaon
o When they think it will increase in the future, they will spend now and
demand-pull inaon increases
o High inaon environment can result in a wage-spiral as workers
demand higher wages to maintain their purchasing power
P3: EFFECTS -
Consumers lose purchasing power and real wages
o People on xed wages most vulnerable as they are unable to demand
higher wages (eg. Pensioners)
Unemployment will increase (Phillips curve)
o Economic uncertainty for rms, hesitant to hire workers
Reducon in real savings and investment
o Less domesc pool of funding
Reduces likelihood of deaon
o Deaon gives consumers incenve to purchase later, contribung to
decreased consumpon and AD
Moderate inaon encourages consumers to spend now, increasing growth and
employment
Assess the impact of recent changes in the global economy on Australia's external stability
Intro:
Floang of Australia dollar in 1983 Keng government
Increasing integraon within the global economy has disrupted Australia's external
stability
Aus is exposed to changes in the internaonal business cycle
o GFC, where nancial and trade shocks transmied into Aus > lower
growth
Denion
o Sustained CAD
o Ensuring servicing costs of the NFL are met
o Stability of exchange rate
o Brazilian iron ore mines have stopped producon amid the threat of dam
collapses
Discuss the connuing role of microeconomic reform in achieving Australia's economic objecves
Objecves:
Economic growth, unemployment, inaon (price stability), DOYW, environmental sustainability
Sustainable economic growth, full employment, price stability, DOYW
Scaold
o Limitaons of micro reform:
Polical constraints
Time lag: 4-5 years
Temporary structural unemployment > automobile
P2: Labour market reforms - Improved producvity of labour, controls inaon, worsens DOYW
Shi from strongly regulated and centralised labour market to decentralised labour
market
o Increased exibility and producvity in the labour market
Enabling employees to enterprise bargain and obtain individual contracts with the
prospect of greater wage or rewards
o Discouraging use of awards
o Employees under awards fell by 5% whereas enterprise agreements
increased by 5%
Decentralised wages have linked wages to producvity
o Higher producvity allows workers to bargain for higher wages
o Ecient industries aract high skilled workers due to higher wage,
increasing allocave eciency
o Provides an incenve for individuals to improve their educaon and skills
Increased wage exibility as employers are able to alter wages in response to external
shocks in the economy, limits cost push inaon
Creates wage dispersion, spling the gap between the high skilled and low skilled
workers
o Gini coecient increase from 0.3 to 0.33 from 1996-97 to 2012-13
P5: Limitaons
Long term implementaon me lag
o 4-5 years
o Passing of legislaon
Polical constraints
Short term
o Loss of economic output
o Structural unemployment (car industry)
200,000 jobs, direct and indirect lost in the short term
Loss of $29 billion economic output
Assess how labour market policies can be used to achieve Australia's economic objecves
Labour market policies are a microeconomic policy that targets the supply side of the Australian
economy and aims for an ecient allocaon of the labour resource to achieve Australia's economic
objecves of: strong and sustainable economic growth (3-4%), maintaining price stability (RBA 2-3%
target band), achieving full employment and an equitable distribuon of income. Historically, prior to
the 1990s, Australia has had a centralised and underulised labour market however reforms in the
past two decades such as decentralisaon has improved producvity of human capital and has
allowed for the achievement of Australia's economic objecves.
There are three main elements of labour market policies: rstly, the trade o between equity and
eciency. The government wants to promote and reward eciency within the labour market
through higher wage outcomes but also must manage equity to ensure the gap between rich and
poor is not hurng the Australian economy. Secondly, labour force parcipaon, which aims at
increasing producve capacity and aggregate supply ulmately achieving economic growth. Finally,
educaon, training and employment programs addressing both economic growth and long-term
structural and friconal unemployment.
The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) administers Australia's industrial relaons system which aims to
address equity. The system provides a safety net for lower income employees through industry
awards, which set out the minimum wage (currently $18.93 an hour) as well as the ten minimum
employment standards which includes maximum hours of work and requests for exible working
arrangements. This safety net aims to 'catch' individuals below the standards of awards by providing
them with basic employment standards and a minimum wage which allows for the achievement of a
more equitable distribuon of income. This is highlighted in the sustained increase of the Gini
coecient from 0.29 in the 1980s to 0.33 currently.
Australia's progressive tax system aims at improving equity within Australia. The concept of
progressive is 'the more you earn, the more tax you pay' which aempts to close the gap between
the rich and poor. In 2013-14 the Australian government raised $176 billion in personal income
taxaon revenue, equivalent to approximately 11.5% of Australia's GDP which can be spent on social
security or infrastructure in low socio-economic areas. The eecveness of the progressive tax
system in Australia is evident as there are approximately 13 million taxpayers in Australia allowing
the government to combat income inequality eecvely. It also highlights the trade o between
eciency and equity.
Transfer payments issued by the government addresses equity by providing cash payments to
individuals who require assistance. Transfer payments aim to assist the unemployed who are seeking
work by providing them with monetary assistance temporarily unl they nd employment. A large
poron of government expenditure on social security and transfer payments has been a feature of
Australia's spending over the past decade. The 2018-19 Budget projected $10 billion would be spent
on transfer payments to the unemployed, equivalent to around 6% of Australia's total expenditure
portraying the government's focus on addressing income inequality.
The decentralisaon of the labour market involves market forces operang freely with minimal
government intervenon in determining wage outcomes. This has led to a more ecient allocaon
of resources as labour is moved to sectors of the economy that have the capacity to pay. Thus
producvity is increased as enterprise bargaining and individual contracts incenvises employees to
be more producve and gain high skills, educaon and training. It also ences individuals out of the
labour force to join based on the potenal to gain higher wages. This ulmately allows the objecve
of economic growth to be achieved.
Greater wage exibility through enterprise bargaining has also limited cost-push inaon as rm's
are more equipped to adjust to uctuaons in the economy which can be done by changing wage or
working hours. However, the decentralisaon of the labour market leads to increased income
inequality or wage dispersion as wage outcomes may be determined by the employees bargaining
power and not based on the employees producvity or skill. It also presents the issue of low wage
growth (Smulus 1) as wage growth is dependant on employee bargaining power. This highlights how
the decentralisaon of the labour market has both costs and benets in that it achieves economic
growth and controls inaon but increases inequality of income.
In the 2011-12 budget, the government injected $731 million introducing the Naonal Paid Parental
Scheme with the aim of increasing parcipaon rates to increase economic growth. The scheme
provided childcare subsidies of 18 weeks leave paid at the minimum wage to encourage parents to
join back into the labour force. This also incenvises casual and part-me working parents
(underemployed) to seek full me employment as child care is made more aordable, contribung
to an increased producve capacity and ulmately increased economic growth.
Another policy addressing economic growth is the changes to the tax free threshold in the 2012-13
budget aiming to increase parcipaon. The Gillard Government increased the tax free threshold
from $6000 to $18200, a signicant increase, encing individuals out of the labour force to join as
there is a potenal to earn more without geng taxed. These policies has assisted in the steady rise
of parcipaon rate over the past decade, currently at 65.5% (Smulus 2) and thus addressing the
economic objecve of economic growth through increasing aggregate supply and the producve
capacity of the economy.
Recent educaon programs can be seen in 2012, where the government injected $22.4 billion into
the Gonski scheme which provides funding for all schools across Australia aiming at improving
infrastructure and resources. It also addressed low socio-economic schools by providing them with
extra funding to improve their overall educaon standards. The purpose of the Gonski scheme is to
equip the youth with a quality educaon to improve producvity of human capital in the future
which addresses the economic objecves of long term unemployment and economic growth.
Also, in the 2016-17 Budget the government injected $840 million into the Youth Paths Program. The
program aims to improve the employability of young Australians thus lowering total unemployment.
The program involves an employability skill training, internship and apprenceship placement and
direct subsidies up to $10,000 for rm's that employee young Australians on the program. Its
eecveness is highlighted by its assistance of employing 120,000 young Australians. The program
aims to lower long term social welfare dependency as well as addressing future structural
unemployment as there are constant changes to demands and skills required for employment in the
economy.
The injecon of $5 billion saw the creaon of JobAcve in 2015 by the Rudd Government a job
matching service to make the labour market more ecient. The JobAcve scheme aims to minimise
friconal unemployment and assist individuals to secure employment. The program consists of 66
employment agencies who have clear incenves to ensure successful employment to job seekers is
ecient and eecve as possible. JobAcve has assisted in the achievement of the current 5.1%
unemployment rate (Smulus 3) or the achievement of full employment, just above Australia's Non-
Accelerang Inaon Rate (NAIRU) through lowering friconal and structural unemployment within
the economy.
In essence, labour market policies that address equity, parcipaon and educaon make a signicant
contribuon in achieving Australia's economic objecves. Equity labour market policies such as The
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and Australia's tax and transfer payment system has successfully allowed
the Australian government to decrease income inequality. Policies targeng labour force
parcipaon rate such as the decentralisaon of the labour market, Naonal Paid Parental Scheme
and changes to the tax free threshold has allowed for the increase in producve capacity and
aggregate supply ulmately contribung to economic growth. Addionally, labour market policies
focused on educaon, training and employment programs addresses long-term structural and
friconal unemployment and aims to improve the producvity of the labour force thus the economic
objecves of full employment and economic growth is achieved.
INTRO:
Supply side, EAOR
Historically, centralisaon labour market
INTRO 2:
3 Elements of labour market policies
o Trade o between equity and eciency
Government wants to reward eciency through higher
wages but also sought to maintain equity
o LFP
Increasing producve capacity and AS > LT Eco growth
P5: Naonal Paid Parental Scheme (LFP) > Economic growth + U/e
2011-12 budget $731 million to provide childcare subsidies of 18 weeks leave paid at
minimum wage
Encourages people to join back or push for full me work
Analyse the eecveness of the Australian governments use of scal policy in achieving its
economic objecves
INTRO 1
Trend: Historically, the Australian governments use of scal policy has been eecve in achieving
most of its economic objecves. However, in recent years, its eecveness has been quite limited.
Role: Sustained economic growth through stabilising uctuaons in the business cycle, reallocate
resources and redistribute income
Through these roles, scal policy achieves the economic objecves of sustained growth (3-4%), price
stability (2-3%) , full employment and external balance
INTRO 2
Fiscal policy involves the use of the governments budget to inuence the economy
through taxaon and expenditure decisions
Involves a structural component comprised of discreonary government taxaon and
expenditure decisions and cyclical, non-discreonary decisions
By altering levels of AD, government can inuence growth, u/e and inaon
Expansionary and scal eects
Current scal stance is contraconary due to governments eorts to 'cut the budget'
and scal consolidaon, however the non-discreonary cyclical factors result in an
overall slightly expansionary stance
Mulplier eect
o Government expenditure can be respent in the economy
Inial government spending on building materials for a
road project is re-spent in the local economy by the
building rm
Currently, Australia's use of contraconary scal policy has worked against the
expansionary monetary policy thereby liming its eecveness to achieve economic
growth
P2: Unemployment
Cyclical unemployment
o Labour is a derived demand > increase in AD/growth
The government's use of expansionary scal policy during the GFC led to
unemployment only increasing by 2% compared to US increasing by 5%
Recent contraconary scal policy and lack of growth has led to 5.2% unemployment
Analyse the eecveness of the Australian governments use of monetary policy in achieving its
economic objecves
INTRO:
Monetary policy inuences the cost and availability of money and credit in the
economy
Conducted by the RBA through its manipulaon of the cash rate in Domesc Market
Operaons
Primary aim: to maintain price stability (2-3% inaonary target) since 1993
Other aims: maintain full employment and sustainable economic growth
o The rate of interest is the cost of spending now rather than later
o Directly inuence an economy's AD (consumpon)
o By changing the cash rate, the RBA can directly aect the spending
decisions done by households and business's
Lower interest rates bring forward spending on consumer
durables whereas higher interest rates deter spending
Body 4: Unemployment
Cyclical unemployment
o Labour is a derived demand
Body 5: GFC
Cash rate dropped from 7.25% to 3% in under a year due to the poor global economic
condions
Expansionary monetary policy proved to be extremely eecve
o Unemployment only increasing by 2% compared to US 5%.
o Australia avoided recession with 1.3% growth
o Inaon within 2-3% target
Body 6: Limitaons
In recent years, monetary policy has seemed to be relavely ineecve in the medium
term, especially as expansionary monetary policy has been used contradictorily to
contraconary scal policy
o Unemployment remains high 5.2% and inaon below target at 1.6%
In the recovery period of the mining boom 2010-12, interest rates were increased to
contain inaon however this hurt non-mining sectors due to the 2 speed nature of
Australia's economy