Professional Documents
Culture Documents
G20 1 3 Discussion Outline
G20 1 3 Discussion Outline
The legislative and regulatory elements of the I.B. The legal and regulatory requirements that
corporate governance framework can usefully be aEect corporate governance practices should
complemented by soft law elements such as be consistent with the rule of law, transparent
corporate governance codes which are often and enforceable.
based on a “comply or explain” principle in order Corporate governance codes may oEer a
to allow for flexibility and to address specificities complementary mechanism to support the
of individual companies. development and evolution of companies’ best
practices, provided that their status is duly
Soft law - could be considered as “a defined.
convenient description for a variety of non-
binding normatively worded instruments Consultation
used in contemporary international If new laws and regulations are needed, such as
to deal with clear cases of market imperfections,
they should be designed in a way that makes it that the delegated authority is applied fairly,
possible to implement and enforce them in an consistently, and in accordance with the law.
eGicient and even-handed manner covering all
parties. Consultation by government and other I.D. Stock market regulation should support
regulatory authorities with corporations, their eEective corporate governance.
representative organisations, shareholders, and
stakeholders, is an eGective way of doing this. Most of the large stock exchanges are now profit
maximising and themselves publicly traded joint
Cost-Benefit stock companies that operate in competition with
Mechanisms should also be established for other profit maximising stock exchanges and
parties to protect their rights. In order to avoid trading venues.
over-regulation, unenforceable rules, and
unintended consequences that may impede or Regardless of the particular structure of the stock
distort business dynamics, policy measures market, policy makers and regulators should
should be designed with a view to their overall assess the proper role of stock exchanges and
costs and benefits. trading venues in terms of standard setting,
supervision and enforcement of corporate
Enforcement governance rules.
Public authorities should have eGective
enforcement and sanctioning powers to deter I.E. Supervisory, regulatory and enforcement
dishonest behaviour and provide for sound authorities should have the authority,
corporate governance practices. In addition, autonomy, integrity, resources and capacity to
enforcement can also be pursued through private fulfil their duties in a professional and
action. objective manner.
Moreover, their rulings should be timely,
I.C. The division of responsibilities among transparent and fully explained.
diEerent authorities and self-regulatory bodies
should be clearly articulated and designed to Supervisory, regulatory and enforcement
serve the public interest. responsibilities should be vested with bodies that
are operationally independent and accountable
Corporate governance requirements and in the exercise of their functions and
practices are typically influenced by an array of responsibilities, have adequate powers, proper
legal domains, resources, and the capacity to perform their
functions and exercise their powers.
Corporate governance practices of individual
companies are also often influenced by human To guard against conflicts of interest (including
rights and environmental laws, and increasingly the potential for political or business interference
laws related to digital security, data privacy and in supervisory and enforcement processes),
personal data protection. operational independence may be reinforced
by autonomy over budgetary and human
Under these circumstances, there is a risk that resource management decisions.
the variety of legal influences may cause
unintentional overlaps and even conflicts, which Such autonomy should be coupled with high
may frustrate the ability to pursue key corporate ethical standards and accountability
governance objectives. mechanisms, including timely, transparent and
fully explained decisions that are open to public
It is important that policy makers are aware of this and judicial scrutiny.
risk and take measures to ensure a coherent and
stable institutional and regulatory framework. I.F. Digital technologies can enhance the
supervision and implementation of corporate
Delegation governance requirements, but supervisory and
When regulatory responsibilities or oversight are regulatory authorities should give due
delegated to non-public bodies, notably stock attention to the management of associated
exchanges, it is desirable to explicitly assess why, risks.
and under what circumstances, such delegation
is desirable. In addition, the public authority When artificial intelligence and algorithmic
should maintain eGective safeguards to ensure decision-making are used in supervisory
processes, it is critical to maintain a human
element in place to mitigate against risks of Investors’ confidence that the capital they
incorporating existing biases in algorithmic provide will be protected from misuse or
models and the risks from an over- reliance on misappropriation by corporate managers, board
models and digital technologies. members or controlling shareholders is an
important factor in the development and proper
I.G. Cross-border co-operation should be functioning of capital markets.
enhanced, including through bilateral and
multilateral arrangements for exchange of In providing protection to investors, a distinction
information. can usefully be made between ex ante and ex
post shareholder rights.
I.H. Clear regulatory frameworks should Ex ante rights are, for example, pre-
ensure the eEective oversight of publicly emptive rights and qualified majorities for
traded companies within company groups. certain decisions.
The prevalence of company groups in many Ex post rights allow the seeking of redress
jurisdictions has therefore heightened the need once rights have been violated.
for regulators to ensure that the corporate
governance framework provides means to One of the ways in which shareholders can
eGectively monitor them. enforce their rights is to be able to initiate legal
and administrative proceedings against
Jurisdictions are encouraged to develop a management and board members.
practical definition and criteria for the oversight of
company groups focusing on aspects such as the The confidence of minority investors is enhanced
controlling relationship of group companies and when the legal system provides mechanisms for
their parent, companies’ domicile, and minority shareholders to bring lawsuits when they
appropriateness of inclusion in consolidated have reasonable grounds to believe that their
financial reporting, among other aspects. rights have been violated.
III. Institutional investors, stock markets, and III.B. Votes should be cast by custodians or
other intermediaries nominees in line with the directions of the
beneficial owner of the shares.
The corporate governance framework should
provide sound incentives throughout the Custodian institutions holding securities as
investment chain and provide for stock nominees for customers should not be permitted
markets to function in a way that contributes to to cast the votes on those securities unless they
good corporate governance. have received specific instructions to do so.
The Principles recommend that institutional III.C. Institutional investors acting in a fiduciary
investors disclose their policies for corporate capacity should disclose how they manage
governance with respect to their investments. material conflicts of interest that may aEect
the exercise of key ownership rights regarding
their investments.
assess their corporate investments by comparing
When such conflicts arise from material business market-related information with the company’s
relationships, for example through an agreement information about its prospects and
to manage the portfolio company’s funds, they performance.
should be identified and disclosed.