REGNIER, A. Congenital Orbital Cysts of Neural Tissue in Two Dogs

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Veterinary Ophthalmology (2008) 11, 2, 91–98

Blackwell Publishing Inc

Congenital orbital cysts of neural tissue in two dogs


Alain Regnier,* Isabelle Raymond-Letron* and Robert L. Peiffer†
*Department of Clinical Sciences, National Veterinary School, 23 chemin des Capelles, B.P. 87614, 31076 Toulouse Cedex 3, France; †Merck Research
Laboratories, Merck & Co. WP45-226, PO Box 4, West Point, PA 19486, USA

Address communications to: Abstract


Alain Regnier A 3-month-old English Cocker Spaniel and a 6-month-old miniature poodle
Tel.: +33 561 193832
presented with clinical signs related to an abnormal right eye since birth. In both dogs,
Fax: +33 561 193203 the right globe could not be identified and was replaced by a fluctuant intraorbital mass
e-mail: a.regnier@envt.fr covered by a vascularized mucous membrane. Ultrasonography demonstrated that both
Presented as an abstract at the masses were cystic structures markedly larger in size than the normal contralateral
Annual Meeting of the globes. In both cases, surgical excision revealed a multilobular cyst filling the whole
European College of Veterinary orbital cavity. Histopathologic examination and immunostaining for glial fibrillary acid
Ophthalmologists and European
protein and S100 protein supported a diagnosis of neural cysts associated with ocular
Society of Veterinary
Ophthalmology, Porto, dysplasia. The definitive diagnosis was congenital cystic eye and microphthalmos with
June 2005. cyst for the Cocker Spaniel and miniature poodle, respectively. Karyotype was normal in
both dogs. Congenital cystic eye and microphthalmos with cyst result from defects in
early embryonic life that arise following formation of the optic vesicle and prior to
closure of the optic fissure. To the authors’ knowledge neither has been reported in the
canine species. They should be considered in the differential diagnosis of orbital cysts in
dogs.
Key Words: colobomatous cyst, cyst, cystic eye, dog, microphthalmos, orbit

INT RO DUC T IO N C A S E R E P O RT S

Orbital cystic lesions of children encompass a broad range of Case 1


conditions which vary in etiology, presentation, and patho- A 3-month-old, male, English Cocker Spaniel presented for
logic appearance.1,2 They can be divided into four major examination with an abnormal right eye, which had slowly
groups: (i) cysts of the surface epithelium, such as dermoid enlarged since the eyelids opened. The other puppies in the
cysts; (ii) teratomatous cysts; (iii) neural cysts; and (iv) litter were described as normal but were not available for
secondary cysts from adjacent structures, such as mucocele examination. The dam was primiparturient and had not
and dentigerous cysts.1,3 Neural cysts include those associated received any medical treatment nor had she had access to
with developmental abnormalities of the globe and those chemicals prior to or during pregnancy. The sire had been
associated with brain and meningeal tissue.1 Those related used before and had not produced offspring with congenital
to abnormal ocular development are further divided into defects. The puppy was alert, and the only abnormalities
congenital cystic eye and microphthalmos with cyst.1,4 The seen were those limited to the right eye. Ophthalmic exami-
latter represents a subset in the spectrum of ocular colobomas nation revealed that on the right side the palpebral fissure
and is also termed colobomatous cyst.1,4 These two ocular length was normal, but the interpalpebral space was narrow
abnormalities are evident at birth in most cases, and they are and associated with bulging of both eyelids (Fig. 1). Palpa-
considered sufficiently uncommon in pediatric ophthalmology tion of the eyelids and periorbital region did not elicit pain,
that individual case reports are usually published in the and did not exhibit any thrill or pulsation. Eyelid retraction
literature.5–12 In a recent paper on congenital cystic eye in was limited to 4–5 mm by a pink, vascular mucous mem-
children, the authors only cited 14 cases, including their two brane that extended from the palpebral conjunctiva of the
cases, reported in the medical literature since 1964.3 This upper eyelid to that of the lower eyelid and covered an
report describes two cases of congenital orbital cysts in the intraorbital mass. There was no visible globe, and palpation
dog resembling neural cysts associated with ocular maldevelop- through the upper eyelid revealed a soft intraorbital mass.
ment in children. Schirmer tear test value was 7 mm/min. The left eye was normal.

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists


92 r e g n i e r , r ay m o n d - l e t r o n a n d p e i f f e r

Figure 1. External photograph (a) and horizontal


B-scan image (b) of congenital cystic eye in an
English Cocker Spaniel. A narrow vertical
palpebral fissure and bulging of eyelids were
observed on right side (a). No definite intraocular
structures could be identified on the ultrasound
image (b) except for a round echogenic structure
(arrowhead), and an echogenic clump of tissue at
the posterior pole of the hollow structure (arrow).

Figure 2. Photomicrographs of the cyst wall of a


congenital cystic eye in an English Cocker Spaniel.
On this portion of the irregularly shaped
formaldehyde-fixed specimen (a), the neuroglial
tissue (arrows) is surrounded by a variably thick
layer of connective tissue externally (arrowheads).
Adipose tissue (*) is present external to the outer
wall, and a malformed lens (L) lies within the
cavity. H&E, ×10. Section illustrating that various
degrees of differentiation exist in the
neuroepithelial lining (b). H&E, ×200. This area
(c) shows the immature inverted retina with
ganglion cells externally located (arrow) and a
unique internal granular cell layer. H&E, ×200.
A multilayered rosette formation is present in this
area of immature inverted retina (d). H&E, ×200.

On B-scan images (10-MHz transducer), the intraorbital The anteroposterior length of the cystic cavity was 20.4 mm
mass appeared as an anechoic and irregularly shaped struc- compared to a length of 14.8 mm for the fellow eye. A develop-
ture when scanned in a vertical plane. Patterns of echogenicity mental anomaly of the globe was suspected but a definite
within the cystic cavity resembled curvilinear septations. The diagnosis was not made. As slow enlargement of the mass was
horizontal scan plane disclosed a round echogenic lesion reported by the owner, surgical excision was recommended
with an anechoic central area, located near the center of the and performed using the lateral enucleation technique.
anechoic cavity, and compatible with an ectopic lens (Fig. 1). Intraoperatively, a multilobular, thin-walled, cystic mass was

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 11, 91–98


o r b i ta l n e u r a l c y s t s i n d o g s 93

found to fill the entire right orbit. The mass was extensively
adherent to the medial orbital wall and during the final
phase of the dissection it ruptured, releasing a clear, yellow,
serous fluid. The third eyelid was identified and removed.
No evidence of communication between the cystic mass and
the frontal sinus or cranial cavity was noted. Gross examination
of the specimen disclosed a ruptured cystic mass characterized
by a smooth but irregular outer surface due to fibrous con-
strictions, and covered by scant orbital fat and extraocular muscle.
All excised tissue was fixed in buffered 10% formalin, rou-
tinely processed for histologic examination, and stained with
H&E. Tissue sections were also submitted for immuno-
histochemical assessment for glial fibrillary acid protein (GFAP
M0761) and S100 protein (Polyclonal rabbit anticow S100
protein, Z0311). The antibodies were from a single commercial
source (Dakocytomation, Trappes, France), and reactivity was
assessed with appropriate positive and negative controls.
Microscopically, the cystic structure was surrounded by
islands of epithelial tissue including scattered lobules of
atrophic lacrimal tissue. The outer layer of the cyst wall con-
sisted of a thin layer of more or less compact, vascularized
connective tissue, resembling sclera, to which adipose tissue
and some extraocular muscles were attached (Fig. 2). This layer
was penetrated at its posterior pole by an optic nerve-like
structure. The inner surface of the cyst wall was lined with a thin
basophilic layer of poorly differentiated neuroepithelial tissue,
in which areas of inverted immature retina with a single granular
layer and occasional foci of photoreceptor differentiation
and rosette formation were seen (Fig. 2). This inner layer
demonstrated GFAP and S100 positive immunohistochemical
staining which attested its neural origin (Fig. 3). The cyst
contained a rudimentary lens covered by a single cuboidal
Figure 3. Areas of the cyst wall lining of a congenital cystic eye in an
layer of epithelial cells surrounded by a thin and regular basal English Cocker Spaniel immunostained for GFAP (a) and S100 protein
lamina to which remnants of the tunica vasculosa lentis were (b) The strong brown reactivity of the immature retina with anti-GFAP
attached (Fig. 2). Retinal pigment epithelium, cornea and antibodies is seen in this area of rosette formation (a). The primitive
uveal tissue could not be identified. Serial 5-μm sections of photoreceptors are stained brown with immunolabeling for S100
the specimen failed to disclose the presence of an associated protein (b). Anti-GFAP and anti-S100 immunoperoxidase,
microphthalmic eye. The pathologic diagnosis for this dog was diaminobenzidine chromogen, hematoxylin counterstain; ×200.

neural cyst associated with clinical anophthalmia, an abnormal


ocular development in the spectrum of the congenital cystic eye.
B-scan ultrasonography demonstrated a septated cystic
Case 2 lesion in the right orbit, markedly larger in size (maximum
A female miniature poodle rehomed from a humane shelter axial length: 29.1 mm) than the normal left eye (axial length:
and aged approximately 6 months was presented for exami- 17.2 mm). On vertical and horizontal views, the pattern of
nation of the right eye. Information concerning the dam, sire, echogenicity within the mass appeared as curvilinear septa-
other puppies in litter and the history of the problem was not tions manifesting as abnormal echogenic material in conti-
available. The right palpebral fissure appeared wider than nuity with its wall, and protruding into its lumen (Fig. 5).
that of the fellow eye with a pink mass distending the eyelids. Surgical excision of the intraorbital mass was performed
There was no blepharospasm and only a slight epiphora. similar to the previous case; intraoperatively, a cystic lesion
Closer inspection revealed a highly vascular, slightly dark was found to fill the whole orbit, extending to the orbital
pigmented mucous membrane protruding through the right apex. Although adherent to the orbital wall, the mass was
palpebral fissure (Fig. 4), and adherent to a soft intraorbital dissected in toto. Macroscopically, the cystic lesion resembled
mass. No visible cornea and limbus could be identified but that of the previous case, with thin and transparent walls
the nictitating membrane and lacrimal puncta were present. that allowed visualization of the clear yellow fluid filling the
Schirmer tear test value was 15 mm/min. Examination of the cavity. Extraocular muscle tissue was present. When cut in
left eye was unremarkable. half along the sagittal plane, the formaldehyde-fixed cyst

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 11, 91–98


94 r e g n i e r , r ay m o n d - l e t r o n a n d p e i f f e r

Figure 4. External photograph of microphthalmos with cyst in a


miniature poodle showing the vascularized and pigmented wall of the
orbital mass that protrudes through the right palpebral fissure.

appeared multilocular with one large cystic cavity and


several smaller ones. At the approximate center of the cavity,
a small (about 4.0 × 5.2 mm in size), nodular pigmented
mass was connected to the superior and inferior aspects of
the cyst wall by trabeculated strands of white tissue (Fig. 6).
The specimen was processed for histologic and immuno-
histochemical evaluations as described for case 1.
Microscopically, the outer surface of the cyst wall was
composed of dense connective tissue with attached adipose
tissue, muscle, and nerve fibers. The inner surface consisted
of a layer of poorly differentiated neuroepithelial tissue
including areas of immature retina identified by the presence
of small round basophilic nuclei. This layer of neuroepithe-
lium was positive for GFAP and S100 protein. In some areas
the neuroepithelial tissue interdigitated with the overlying
connective tissue layer and in others it formed small projec-
tions into the cyst lumen. On serial sectioning, it was found
that the connective tissue layer of the neural cyst became
continuous with the thicker wall, resembling sclera, of a
small cystic, pigmented mass that was in fact the pigmented Figure 5. Vertical (a) and horizontal (b) plane ultrasonograms
nodular mass macroscopically observed (Fig. 6). The struc- (10 MHz transducer) of microphthalmos with cyst in the right orbit of
tural differentiation seen in this pigmented mass was con- a miniature poodle. The multilobular cystic lesion fills the entire orbital
sidered typical for that of a severely microphthalmic eye. cavity (a). The hyperechoic excrescences of the cyst wall represent the
Internally, the sclera was lined by a layer of pigmented uveal cyst septations protruding into the lumen of the cavity (b).
tissue with areas of choroidal differentiation (Fig. 6). A
segment of normal appearing anterior uveal tissue, including
iris, ciliary body and ciliary processes, was also identified, globe with the cavity of the neural cyst (Fig. 6). The anterior
but the structures of the iridocorneal angle were absent. The part of the microphthalmic globe, in place of the normal
choroid-like tissue was lined by neuroepithelial tissue in an cornea, consisted of a dense thick vascularized collagenous
arrangement which resembled developmentally immature stroma, in continuity with the scleral-like layer, and with an
detached retina (Fig. 6). This immature retina contained irregular multilayered nonkeratinized epithelium with a
areas with dysplastic rosettes. A small, round and dysplastic pigmented basal cell layer. This area of epithelium was
lens was adherent to the ciliary processes. At the posterior circumferentially in continuity with a nonkeratinized bi-
pole of the microphthalmic globe, the presence of a colo- layered cuboïdal epithelium containing numerous goblet cells.
bomatous cleft allowed continuity of the central cavity of the Based on the apposition of a globe with severe microphthalmia

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 11, 91–98


o r b i ta l n e u r a l c y s t s i n d o g s 95

Figure 6. Gross photograph (a) of the parasagittal section of a


formaldehyde-fixed microphthalmos with cyst in a miniature poodle
and microscopic sections (b–d) of the microphthalmic eye. Notice the
relationship between the microphthalmic eye (arrows) and the orbital
cyst (a). The communicating cleft between the microphthalmic eye and
the cavity of the orbital cyst is indicated by the bent arrow (b). H&E,
×10. Close-up view of the choroid and partially detached immature
retina (c). H&E, ×100. Ciliary body with muscle fibers and long and fine
ciliary processes (d). H&E, ×100.

to a neural cyst and apparent continuity of globe and cyst


D I S C U S S IO N
cavities, the diagnosis of microphthalmos with cyst was
established. Neural cysts associated with ocular dysplasia in children are
To complement the pathological diagnoses, a chromo- thought to result from failures of embryologic events that
some analysis of both dogs was carried out from cultures of take place early in ocular development.1,3 In vertebrates the
peripheral blood lymphocytes, as currently performed in the first morphological sign of eye development is the bilateral
cytogenetics laboratory of our institution.13 No altered evagination of diencephalon that marks the appearance of
chromosomes were identified, so the karyotype was inter- the optic sulci,14,15 identified on day 13 of gestation in the
preted as normal for each case. dog.16 Continued evagination of the optic sulci leads to the

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 11, 91–98


96 r e g n i e r , r ay m o n d - l e t r o n a n d p e i f f e r

formation of the optic vesicles that come into proximity with Congenital cystic eye usually presents as a soft mass filling
the surface ectoderm, giving rise to a focal thickening of the the orbit and distending the upper or lower eyelid,1,3 as in
surface ectoderm, the lens placodes, identified by gestational the English Cocker Spaniel of the present study (case 1).
days 15–17 in the dog.16 Interaction of the optic vesicle with Microphthalmos with cyst varies in its presentation, and may
the lens placode leads to their coordinated invagination appear as a cyst associated with an obvious microphthalmic
resulting in the formation of the primitive lens vesicle and a eye, or as a large cyst associated with a small eye that is not
double-layered optic cup that will give rise to the photo- clinically detectable.1,3,9 This clinical manifestation was present
receptor and pigment epithelial layers of the retina.14,15 Normally, in the miniature poodle of this study (case 2). Congenital
the lens vesicle and optic cup are distinct by gestational day orbital cysts of neural tissue usually occur unilaterally,1,3 but
19 in the dog.16 When, for unknown reasons the optic vesicle cases of bilateral congenital cystic eye11 or microphthalmos
does not invaginate, the development of the globe is arrested with cysts6,20,21 have been reported. Congenital cystic eye
and the cavity of the optic vesicle persists. The ectodermal associated with contralateral microphthalmos with cyst has
and neural elements do not differentiate, and the orbit thus also been observed in one child.9 Orbital neural cysts can occur
contains, instead of an eye, a congenital cystic eye lined by in isolation or with associated malformations including eyelid
neuroglial tissue with no evidence of normal ocular struc- abnormalities, such as eyelid coloboma10 contralateral hyper-
ture.3,17,18 In children, the arrest in transformation of the plastic primary vitreous,10 and nonocular abnormalities, such as
optic vesicle into optic cup most commonly occurs before facial clefting and malformation of the nostril,9,11 which are
the end of the 7 mm stage of the embryonic development.8 If more frequent when there is bilateral involvement. No such
the insult occurs shortly after this stage, partial invagination abnormalities were observed in the dogs of this study.
of the optic vesicle may result in rudimentary cornea,3 or Differential diagnoses of orbital cysts in the dog, include
lens and immature retina with rosette formation.8 cystic structures of the orbit and periorbital region arising
Under normal circumstances, the process of optic vesicle from the orbital lacrimal gland, gland of the nictitating
invagination progresses from inferior to superior and leads membrane, zygomatic salivary gland, or lacrimal system.22,23
to the formation of a groove that runs along the inferior side Inflammatory cysts, such as abscess or parasitic cyst can also
of the optic cup and stalk.15 This slit-like channel is termed be considered,23,24 although parasitic cysts are rarely encoun-
the optic, embryonic, choroid or fetal fissure.14,15 From the tered in the orbit.24 All these ocular lesions are usually dif-
8-mm stage of gestation in humans9 and after gestational day ferentiated by the presence of a globe and their external
25 in the dog,16 the two lips of the optic fissure and stalk will appearance which includes periorbital swelling, exophthal-
fuse so that the optic cup will be complete and optic stalk mos and/or protrusion of the nictitating membrane.22–24
will become a tube.14,15 Improper fusion of the edges of the Orbital ultrasonography was useful in the two present cases,
fissure may occur anywhere along the length of the cleft, and because it demonstrated for each of them the presence of a
produces a defect in the neuroectodermal tissues manifested large multilobulated cystic structure filling the entire orbital
as a typical coloboma, or rarely as microphthalmos with cavity. In children, ultrasonography,11,12,25 computed tomography
cyst.5 This latter congenital malformation is defined as a scan3,11,12,20 and magnetic resonance imaging3,11,12,21 have been
neuroectoderm-lined mass that protrudes through a colo- used to demonstrate the cystic appearance of the orbital mass,
boma in the wall of a microphthalmic eye.1 The probable and help differentiate the two types of neural cysts. Diagnostic
mechanism of formation of microphthalmos with cyst is imaging studies can show a uni- or multilocular cyst without
overgrowth of the inner neuroectodermal layer at the mar- clearly defined structures in patients with congenital cystic
gin of the persistent optic fissure, resulting in development eye,3,11,12 while they can reveal a small globe in apposition to
of a cyst originally continuous with the space between the a cystic cavity and sometimes apparent continuity of vitreous
two layers of the optic cup.5,9 If the wall of the cyst separating cavity and cyst contents in cases of microphthalmos with
the vitreous cavity from the future subretinal space is absent, cyst.20,21,25 In our case of microphthalmos with cyst, ultra-
the cyst communicates directly with the vitreous cavity.9 sonography failed to detect the microphthalmic eye, probably
Congenital cystic orbital lesions associated with ocular because it was too small. Fine needle aspiration of the
maldevelopment seem uncommon in domestic animals, even cystic structure and cytologic examination of the aspirate is
though they probably occur more frequently than the two not currently recommended to confirm the diagnosis of
cases of this report suggest. In addition to these cases, anecdotal orbital neural cysts in children. In the dog, it might help in
reports of congenital cystic eye in a foal,17 and in a rabbit,19 can differentiating congenital orbital cysts from inflammatory
be found in the current literature. To the authors’ knowledge, cysts.
the unique combination of clinical findings and histopatho- Definitive diagnosis is supported by pathologic examina-
logical lesions seen in the two patients of this study has not tion of the orbital mass after its complete surgical excision.
been previously reported in the canine species. These ocular Congenital cystic eye is histopathologically similar to the
malformations were probably congenital as they were appar- cystic portion of microphthalmos with cyst, but the main
ent in the first few months of life, and they fulfilled many of differentiating feature between the two malformations is
the clinical and histological criteria of orbital cysts of neural evidence of an associated microphthalmic eye detected with
tissue associated with ocular maldevelopment in children.1,3–9 serial sectioning of the specimen in case of microphthalmos

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 11, 91–98


o r b i ta l n e u r a l c y s t s i n d o g s 97

with cyst.3,11,26 Microscopically, the cyst wall of our two cases R E FE R E N C E S


consisted of an outer layer of fibrous connective tissue lined
1. Shields JA, Shields CL. Orbital cysts of childhood-classification,
by neuroepithelial tissue which stained positively for markers
clinical features, and management. Survey of Ophthalmology 2004;
of the primitive retina (i.e. GFAP and S100 protein), as 49: 281–299.
previously reported in children with neural cysts associated 2. Kaufman LM, Villablanca JP, Mafee MF. Diagnostic imaging of
with ocular maldevelopment.1,3,9,11,12 In the English Cocker cyst lesions in the child’s orbit. Radiologic Clinics of North America
Spaniel (case 1) a dysplastic lens was present but serial 1998; 36: 1149–1163.
sections failed to disclose the presence of an associated 3. Hayashi N, Repka MX, Ueno H et al. Congenital cystic eye: report
microphthalmic eye, hence the diagnosis of congenital cystic of two cases and review of the literature. Survey of Ophthalmology
1999; 44: 173–179.
eye. It is generally assumed that the lack of surface ectodermal
4. Apple DJ, Rabb MF. Developmental anomalies. In: Ocular Pathology,
elements is a common feature of congenital cystic eye,1,17 Clinical Applications and Self-Assessment, 5th edn. Mosby, St Louis,
but as stated before, partial invagination of the optic cup may 1998; 14 –58.
result in the presence of ectodermal elements and retinal 5. Briggs RM, Chase RA, Dellaporta A. Unilateral congenital orbital
differentiation.3 Analysis of the human cystic eyes currently cyst with microphthalmos. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery 1968;
published shows that malformed cornea or incompletely 41: 376–380.
developed lens have been identified in three of them.7,8,11 6. Arstikaitis M. A case report of bilateral microphthalmos with cysts.
Archives of Ophthalmology 1969; 82: 480–482.
Presence of lens material and rosettes in our dog is consistent
7. Helveston EM, Malone E, Lashmet MH. Congenital cystic eye.
with an embryonic effect that probably occurred after gesta- Archives of Ophthalmology 1970; 84: 622–624.
tional day 19. An optic nerve-like structure was also identi- 8. Baghdassarian SA, Tabbara KF, Matta CS. Congenital cystic eye.
fied in this cystic eye, as previously reported in the human American Journal of Ophthalmology 1973; 76: 269–275.
literature.8 In the miniature poodle (case 2), the malformed 9. Waring GO III, Rodrigues MM. Clinicopathologic correlation of
eye associated with the cyst had many features in common microphthalmos with cyst. American Journal of Ophthalmology 1976;
with cases previously described in children.6,9,20,21 The 82: 714–721.
10. Pasquale LR, Romayananda N, Kubacki J et al. Congenital cystic eye
microphthalmic eye of this dog demonstrated a spectrum of
with multiple ocular and intracranial anomalies. Archives of Ophthal-
anterior segment abnormalities, dysplastic lens, immature mology 1991; 109: 985–987.
retina, and a choroidal and scleral coloboma through which 11. Goldberg SH, Farber MG, Bullock JD et al. Bilateral congenital
the vitreous cavity communicated directly with the cyst ocular cysts. Ophthalmic Paediatrics and Genetics 1991; 12: 31–38.
cavity. Extraocular muscles were observed in both dogs of 12. Mansour AM, Li HK. Congenital cystic eye. Ophthalmic Plastic and
this study, which agrees with the fact that these ocular struc- Reconstructive Surgery 1996; 12: 104 –107.
tures form independently and seem not to require normal 13. Ducos A, Berland HM, Pinton A et al. Nine new cases of reciprocal
translocation in the domestic pig (Sus scrofa domestica L.). Journal of
development of the globe.21
Heredity 1998; 89: 136 –142.
While one case of congenital cystic eye with coincidental 14. Chow RL, Lang RA. Early eye development in vertebrates. Annual
maternal varicella infection has been reported in a child,27 Review of Cell Developmental Biology 2001; 17: 255–296.
the etiology of orbital cysts of neural tissue in children is 15. Cook CS. Ocular embryology and congenital malformations. In:
usually unknown. Neither hereditary tendencies nor obvious Veterinary Ophthalmology, 3rd edn. (ed. Gelatt KN) Lippincott
abnormalities during pregnancy have been described.1,3 The Williams & Wilkins, Philadelphia, 1999; 3–30.
etiology in our cases remained undetermined. Prenatal insult 16. Aguirre GD, Rubin LF, Bistner SI. Development of the canine eye.
American Journal of Veterinary Research 1972; 33: 2399–2414.
due to drugs, particularly anthelmintics, or to other environ-
17. Wilcock BP. The eye and ear. In: Pathology of Domestic Animals, Vol. 1,
mental factors was not identified for the English Cocker 3rd edn. (eds Jubb KVF, Kennedy PC, Palmer N). Academic Press,
Spaniel with the congenital cystic eye, and no such informa- Orlando, 1985; 340–406.
tion was available for the miniature poodle with micro- 18. Peiffer RL, Wilcock BP, Dubielzig RR et al. Fundamentals of
phthalmos with cyst. No chromosomal abnormality has been veterinary ophthalmic pathology. In: Veterinary Ophthalmology, 3rd
noted in affected children,3,6,10–12 and similarly the results of edn. (ed. Gelatt KN) Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Philadelphia,
karyotype analysis were normal for the two dogs of the present 1999; 355– 425.
19. Martin CL. Orbit and globe. In: Ophthalmic Diseases in Veterinary
report.
Medicine. Manson Publishing/ The Veterinary Press, London, 2005;
In conclusion, the congenital cystic eye and micro- 113–144.
phthalmos with cyst exhibited by these two dogs represent 20. Foxman S, Cameron JD. The clinical implications of bilateral
abnormalities in early embryonic development of the eye. microphthalmos with cyst. American Journal of Ophthalmology 1984;
These ocular malformations have clinical features in common 97: 632–638.
and their differentiation requires diagnostic imaging and 21. Wright DC, Yuh WTC, Thompson HS et al. Bilateral micro-
histopathologic studies. phthalmos with orbital cysts: MR findings. Journal of Computer Assisted
Tomography 1987; 11: 727–729.
22. Martin CL, Kaswan RL, Doran CC. Cystic lesions of the periorbital
A CKN O WLEDGMENT region. Compendium in Continuing Education for the Practicing Veterinarian
1987; 9: 1022–1029.
We wish to thank Hélène Berland and Anne Calgaro for 23. Ramsey DT, Fox DB. Surgery of the orbit. Veterinary Clinics of the
performing the karyotype analyses. North America: Small Animal Practice 1997; 27: 1215–1264.

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 11, 91–98


98 r e g n i e r , r ay m o n d - l e t r o n a n d p e i f f e r

24. Komnenou A, Eberhard ML, Kaldrymidou E et al. Subconjunctival 26. Dollfus MA, Marx P, Langlois J et al. Congenital cystic eyeball.
filariasis due to Onchocerca sp. in dogs: report of 23 cases in American Journal of Ophthalmology 1968; 66: 504–509.
Greece. Veterinary Ophthalmology 2002; 5: 119–126. 27. Werry H, Ries P. Congenital cystic eye. Klinische Monatsblätter für
25. Fischer YL. Microphthalmos with ocular communicating orbital Augenheilkunde 1978; 172: 888–894.
cyst-ultrasonic diagnosis. Ophthalmology 1968; 85: 1208–1211.

© 2008 American College of Veterinary Ophthalmologists, Veterinary Ophthalmology, 11, 91–98

You might also like