Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 136

JAN 2024 / VOL 114 NO 1

US $16 CAN $22 LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE THE MAGAZINE OF THE AMERICAN
SOCIETY OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS

DERU
A small firm draws out Ohio’s
Underground Railroad story

LOOM HOUSE
Inspiration meets calculation
on Bainbridge Island

REFLECTING MLK
Kofi Boone on the monument
to the civil rights icon

GROW BOTS
Experiments in generative AI
Oslo Fountain, Shown in Greystone

Portola Fountain, Shown in Greystone

Huntington Urn, Shown in Greystone

Bibendum Fountain, Shown in Alpine Stone

Series 3 Planter, Shown in Greystone


Beautify Your Outdoor Spaces

D'Este Estate Fountain, Shown in Alpine Stone

P LA NTE R S | FO UNTA I NS | DÉ COR

215-541-4330 | www.campaniainternational.com | projects@campaniainternational.com


We make cities
mmcite.com smart and beautiful
LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTURE
MAGAZINE
THE MAGAZINE OF THE AMERICAN
SOCIETY OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS

16

JANUARY 2024
8 INSIDE
10 LETTERS
12 LAND MATTERS
122 ADVERTISER INDEX
123 ADVERTISERS BY PRODUCT CATEGORY

TEN EYCK LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS, TOP; ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, BOTTOM
FOREGROUND
16 NOW Timothy A. Schuler, Editor
A taqueria by Ten Eyck Landscape Architects preserves
Austin’s vibe; new tools help better ID climate vulnerability;
a traffic circle temporarily ignites downtown Indianapolis;
forgotten brownfields are enlivened as a community space,
and more.

34 HOUSE CALL
Made to Mushroom by Timothy A. Schuler
The design team for an enchanting Bainbridge Island
renovation puzzled over how to meet a tricky sustainability
target until Anne James, ASLA, had a novel idea.

48 GOODS Kristen Mastroianni, Editor


Out and About 34
New design elements that add polish to public spaces.

4 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


58
DAVID JOSEPH PHOTOGRAPHY, TOP; SAHAR COSTON-HARDY, AFFILIATE ASLA, CENTER; ERIC ARNESON AT TOPOPHYLA. IMAGE GENERATED BY CHATGPT-4, BOTTOM

FEATURES
58 Star Tracks by Zach Mortice
A tiny budget, a stormwater target, and a significant historic
site on the route of the Underground Railroad were all that
Cleveland’s DERU Landscape Architecture needed to turn a
bioswale into a wellspring for storytelling.
92
THE BACK
92 An Elegy in Granite by Kofi Boone, FASLA
Photography by Sahar Coston-Hardy, Affiliate ASLA
A decade after its opening, changing perspectives
cast new light on the Martin Luther King Jr. Monument
on the National Mall.

104 BOOKS Mimi Zeiger, Editor


Flux and Change by Fadi Masoud
A review of The Comprehensive Plan: Sustainable,
Resilient, and Equitable Communities for the 21st Century,
by David Rouse, ASLA, and Rocky Piro.

132 BACKSTORY
132 Visual experiments by @pangeaexpress
explore AI’s ever-expanding boundaries.

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 5


LANDSCAPE PUBLISHER
Michael O’Brien, Honorary ASLA /
ASLA BOARD OF TRUSTEES
PRESIDENT

ARCHITECTURE
SuLin Kotowicz, FASLA
mobrien@asla.org
PRESIDENT-ELECT
DIRECTOR OF DEVELOPMENT AND Kona Gray, FASLA

MAGAZINE STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS


Daniel Martin, Honorary ASLA /
dmartin@asla.org
IMMEDIATE PAST PRESIDENT
Emily O’Mahoney, FASLA

THE MAGAZINE OF THE AMERICAN VICE PRESIDENTS


Monique Bassey, ASLA
ADVERTISING SALES
SOCIETY OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS 202-216-2325
Chris Della Vedova, ASLA
Joy Kuebler, FASLA
Ebru Ozer, FASLA
SALES MANAGER Jean Senechal Biggs, ASLA
Monica Barkley / barkley@asla.org April Westcott, FASLA
EDITOR
Jennifer Reut / jreut@asla.org CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SALES MANAGER Torey Carter-Conneen
Kathleen Thomas / kthomas@asla.org
ART DIRECTOR SECRETARY
Christopher McGee / cmcgee@asla.org Curtis Millay, ASLA
PRODUCTION
SENIOR PRODUCTION MANAGER TREASURER
SENIOR GRAPHIC DESIGNER Laura Iverson / liverson@asla.org Michael O’Brien, Honorary ASLA
Kristen Mastroianni / kmastroianni@asla.org
TRUSTEES
COMMUNICATIONS AND MARKETING
COPY CHIEF Benjamin Baker, ASLA
DIRECTOR Chad Bostick, ASLA
Lisa Schultz / lschultz@asla.org Manny Gonzalez / mgonzalez@asla.org Elizabeth Boults, ASLA
Jonathan Bronk, ASLA
PRODUCTION EDITOR Kenneth Brooks, FASLA
ON THE COVER SUBSCRIPTIONS
Leah Ghazarian / lghazarian@asla.org Katie Clark, FASLA
REPRESENTATIVE Matthew Copp, ASLA
An interpretive subscriptions@asla.org Jitka Dekojova, ASLA
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS Geoff Evans, ASLA
landscape for the Brian Barth; Jared Brey; Jessica Bridger; Alexander Fenech, ASLA
Cozad-Bates House BACK ISSUES
Sahar Coston-Hardy, Affiliate ASLA; Jay Gibbons, ASLA
in Cleveland by 888-999-ASLA (2752) Lara Guldenpfennig, ASLA
Lydia Lee; Jonathan Lerner; Jane Margolies; William Hall, ASLA
DERU Landscape Zach Mortice; Maci Nelson, Associate ASLA; Jonathan Hayes, ASLA
Architecture, page 58. Timothy A. Schuler; James R. Urban, FASLA; James Hencke, ASLA
Lisa Owens Viani; Mimi Zeiger Gail Henderson-King, ASLA
Todd Hill, ASLA
Allen Jones, ASLA
EDITORIAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE Landscape Architecture Magazine (ISSN 0023-8031) is Carl Kelemen, FASLA
David Toda, ASLA / Chair published monthly by the American Society of Landscape
Omprakash Khurjekar, ASLA
Monique Bassey, ASLA / Vice President, Randy Knowles, ASLA
Architects, 636 Eye Street NW, Washington, DC 20001- Chad Kucker, ASLA
Communications 3736. Periodical postage paid at Washington, D.C., and Chris Laster, ASLA
Diana Boric, Associate ASLA additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send address Justin Lemoine, ASLA
Nathaniel Byro, ASLA changes to Landscape Architecture Magazine, 636 Eye
Evan Mather, FASLA
Sara Hadavi, ASLA Christopher Moon, ASLA
Street NW, Washington, DC 20001-3736. Publications Elizabeth Moskalenko, ASLA
Jiali Liu, Associate ASLA Mail Agreement No. 41024518. Return undeliverable Amin Omidy, ASLA
Graciela Martin, Associate ASLA Canadian addresses to PO Box 503 RPO, West Beaver Holley Bloss Owings, ASLA
Daniel McElmurray, ASLA Creek, Richmond Hill, ON L4B 4R6. Copyright 2024
Michele Palmer, ASLA
Dennis R. Nola, FASLA Vaughn Eric Perez, ASLA
ASLA. Subscriptions: $79/year; international: $119/ Zachary Pierce, ASLA
Andrew Sargeant, ASLA year; digital: $68/year; single copies: $10. Matthew Rentsch, ASLA
Matthew Sickle, ASLA Brian Roth, ASLA
Bo Zhang, ASLA Landscape Architecture Magazine seeks to support a
Thomas Ryan, FASLA
Jan Saltiel-Rafel, ASLA
healthy planet through environmentally conscious pro- Barbara Santner, ASLA
EDITORIAL duction and distribution of the magazine. This magazine Todd Schoolcraft, ASLA
202-898-2444 is printed on certified paper using vegetable inks. You Tim Slazinik, ASLA
Dustin Smith, ASLA
can read more about the sustainability efforts of our
Nathan Socha, ASLA
publishing partners at bit.ly/lam-sustainability. Robert Tilson, FASLA
Patricia Trauth, ASLA
The magazine is also available in digital format through William Bryce Ward, ASLA
Alan Watkins, ASLA
bit.ly/lam-zinio or by calling 1-888-999-ASLA.
Andrew Wickham, ASLA
Gretchen Wilson, ASLA
Barbara Yaeger, ASLA
Dana Anne Yee, FASLA

LAF REPRESENTATIVES
Barbara Deutsch, FASLA
Roberto Rovira, ASLA

NATIONAL ASSOCIATE REPRESENTATIVE


Lauren Gray, Associate ASLA
AMBER N. FORD

NATIONAL STUDENT REPRESENTATIVE


Madeline Kirschner, Associate ASLA

PARLIAMENTARIAN
Susan Jacobson, FASLA

6 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


REST. RECHARGE. CONNECT.
F+S Seating + Charging Stations = Coordinated Combos for Life on the Go.

FLOAT BENCHES

Backed and backless 6-foot benches.


Durable powdercoated aluminum frames
with hardwood slats. Impressive design
flexibility. Freestanding or surface mount.

TENZA CHARGING STATIONS

Power for mobile devices and more in


stainless steel. Two sizes provide
convenient, comfortable charging for
seated and standing users. One or two
charging garages. Highly customizable.

www.forms-surfaces.com
LAM /
INSIDE

CONTRIBUTORS

AMBER N. FORD (“Star Tracks,” page 58)


is an artist and freelance photographer
based in Cleveland who holds a bachelor
of fine arts degree in photography from
the Cleveland Institute of Art. You can
follow her on Instagram @ambern.ford.
“Landscape can still be so beautiful
in the late fall/early winter when
planted with intention.”

FADI MASOUD (“Flux and Change,”


page 104) is an associate professor of
landscape architecture and urbanism at
the University of Toronto and the director
of the Centre for Landscape Research.
You can follow the Centre on Instagram
@clr.daniels.utoronto.
“Even a century apart, the need for holistic
and integrated solutions to urban issues
continues to be rooted in environmental
and social justice, solutions that are
seemingly obvious and correlative.”

GOT A STORY?
At LAM, we don’t know what we don’t know.
If you have a story, project, obsession, or
simply an area of interest you’d like to see

VALAURIAN WALLER, TOP; YASMIN AL-SAMARRAI, BOTTOM


covered, tell us! Send it to lam@asla.org.

For more information, visit LAM online


at landscapearchitecturemagazine.org/
contribute-to-lam.

Follow us on X and Instagram


@landarchmag and on Facebook
at www.facebook.com/
landscapearchitecturemagazine.

LAM is available in digital format through


landscapearchitecturemagazine.org/
subscribe or by calling 1-888-999-ASLA.

8 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


EXPERIENCE MODERN FIRE | MISO 36 CONCRETE FIREBOWL

888.823.8883 | sales@paloform.com | paloform.com


LAM /
LETTERS

TAKE US UP
I am a licensed landscape architect.
I worked hard for this distinction
and I am proud of my profession.
In this effort, I found the Frame-
Works recommendations [Putting
People at the Center: Reframing Land-
However, nobody knows what I do scape Architecture for Maximum Im-
or what I am capable of doing. Sob. pact, available at asla.org], while slight-
ly unsettling for this tree hugger, to
I could complain about that to my be very useful. In developing these
landscape architect friends and feel pitches, I found ways to incorporate
sorry for myself, or, as I have now my true loves of nature and ecology
decided, I can develop three or four with a focus on humans. So c’mon,
“elevator pitches” and use them at my fellow landscape architects, let’s
every opportunity. I’ll tell them to promote and celebrate ourselves to
everyone, sprinkle them around in the outside world.
social media posts and in the tagline
of my email address, make bumper SUSAN KENZLE, ASLA
stickers and T-shirts—the options AUSTIN, TEXAS
are endless.

CORRECTION
In “The Outsiders Are In” in
the November issue, a statistic
attributed to Lesley Bertolotti on
page 61 was incorrect. Instead
of “residential uses account for
60 percent of all the freshwater
consumed in Florida,” it should
have said “On average, we’re
finding that up to 60 percent of
a new single-family home’s wa-
WRITE US
ter use in Central Florida goes
toward landscape irrigation.” LAM welcomes letters from readers.
We regret the error. Letters may be edited and condensed.
Please email comments to LAMletters
@asla.org or send via U.S. mail to:

AMERICAN SOCIETY
OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS
636 EYE STREET NW
WASHINGTON, DC 20001–3736

10 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Blending Expert Craftsmanship with Innovative Technology.

We combine the design vision and production skills of hands-on craftspeople with the
very latest in manufacturing technology to create amazing, high-quality products –
products that would have previously been unimaginable and unachievable.
We call this unique approach “Modern Craft Manufacturing,” and it’s just one of the ways
we’re setting the standard for innovation and quality in the world of outdoor design.

Landscape Forms | A Modern Craft Manufacturer


LAM /
LAND MATTERS

DESIGN
INTELLIGENCE
T his month, I interviewed Eric Arneson, one-
half of Topophyla Landscape Design, but bet-
ter known on social media as @pangeaexpress,
Phillip Fernberg, ASLA, and Eric Gilbey, ASLA,
two members of the network, told me that while
the PPN is working on guidance frameworks, it
about a few images he posted that jolted me was worth reading up on the work of allied pro-
awake when I scrolled through them (see Back- fessionals at the American Planning Association,
story, page 132). He had made them with the gen- where Fernberg pointed me to Thomas Sanchez,
erative AI chatbot ChatGPT-4, the latest OpenAI a planner and professor at Virginia Tech. He also
release that can interpret nontext file types—in sent me “Dezeen’s Policy on AI,” probably the most
this case, a planting plan. After uploading a plan, transparent policy I read for using AI, particularly
the bot generated a rendering via the DALL-E en- for designers and media.
gine. It took a bit of tinkering to get right, which
is something Arneson does with great deliberate- Gilbey, who is a product marketing manager for
ness. Arneson likes to find the edges of what the landscape at Vectorworks, says his firm is actively
AI tools can do, and he is one of the designers working on AI integrations that they expect to
OpenAI approached for feedback over the past release in the future, and in general, industry
two years. He emphasized how important it was is more excited and less worried about the un-
to be included in the conversations that help knowns of AI. They also observed that designers
shape these technologies, rather than “getting just don’t seem as anxious about recent technology
left behind,” or worse, left out completely. when it comes from an industry that they perceive
as partners, rather than competitors, and perhaps
Arneson said he doesn’t see generative AI as a that’s a way forward.
practical tool (yet) but thinks landscape architects
should jump in and learn how to use it now. “It’s Fernberg says a recent AI-focused webinar hosted
probably going to be an integral part of the design by the Landscape Architecture Foundation attracted
profession, whether we like it or not, so it’s good hundreds, and that he could see an online series
to get familiar with it so you don’t get taken advan- that moved beyond speculative hand-wringing and
tage of or blindsided by what’s coming.” walked designers through the value proposition of
AI, and explained how it could make their firms
While our conversation ranged around the ethics easier to run.
and the necessity of using AI, he also stressed the
need for landscape architects to have a framework As Gilbey points out, the potential of AI for sav-
for its responsible use, something that did not ing time and automating tasks, such as nursery
yet exist. I decided to poke around and see where searches for specific seeds, can only help the
we might find or develop something for land- profession, which is very much dominated by
scape architects, so I got in touch with the Digital small firms. For them, Gilbey says, “AI can be a
Technology Professional Practice Network (PPN) sole practitioner’s best friend.”
hosted by ASLA.

JENNIFER REUT
EDITOR

12 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Our NEW Monoslope Cantilevers
feature a modern and streamlined look with support columns
cleverly located to the rear for safety and unobstructed views!

1.800.609.6066
shadesystemsinc.com/monoslope
Founded by Grammy-Winning musician, Richard Cooke,
Freenotes Harmony Park is passionate about uniting
communities and cultures with handcrafted, expertly-tuned
sound sculptures. Designed to promote improvisation with
harmonious tones, each instrument allows anyone to explore
their creativity regardless of ability or experience.

T he Ori g inal Conc er t- Quali ty Outdoor M usi cal Inst ruments

VISIT OUR WEBSITE TO SEE AND HEAR


OUR COMPLETE LINE OF INSTRUMENTS

1-833-262-1569 · freenotesharmonypark.com · 544 Chestnut Street · Chattanooga, TN 37402


FOREGROUND
ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE

BAINBRIDGE ISLAND,
WASHINGTON

A residence is a breeding
ground for foraging, in
HOUSE CALL, page 34.

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 15


FOREGROUND /
NOW
EDITED BY TIMOTHY A. SCHULER

BELOW
Water plays an important
role in the outdoor spaces
at Austin’s Cosmic Saltillo,
which repurposes a pair
of historic Texaco depot
buildings (seen at bottom).

KEEPING IT IN THE LANDSCAPE FOR A NEW TAQUERIA,


TEN EYCK LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS A ustin, Texas, has been the country’s
fastest-growing metropolitan

WEIRD PRESERVES A SLICE OF AUSTIN’S HISTORY. area for 12 years running. The steady
BY TIMOTHY A. SCHULER growth, driven by a booming tech

ERIKA RICH, TOP; TEN EYCK LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS, BOTTOM


and venture capital sector, has utterly
changed the fabric of the city—and
not without consequences. According
to one news outlet’s analysis of city
data, at least 800 historic structures
have been demolished since 2000.
“I’ve seen, one by one, these beloved
places torn down,” says Christy Ten
Eyck, FASLA, the founding principal
of Austin’s Ten Eyck Landscape Ar-
chitects. “It makes these little jewels
that much more important and re-
warding to work on.”

16 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


The contemporary new anywhere playsystem by Landscape Structures®

e s s color
nd l ed
c e s and e re-inspir
n tu
u r a l influe g for a na nities
ct kin tu
t s a r chite ou’re loo lay oppor
hi ry ep
ment. Wit g, whethe d inclusiv
n n n
la y enviro play setti lenging, a .
l
e to any p t to your mic, cha materials
o rar y vib mplemen the dyna h mix of
p co ve -ric
s a contem e perfect ids will lo sensory
g h .K nd
o rm a brin , create t e modern design a
F es o r lar
ibiliti ing m angu /forma
poss r someth ’s clean, i.com
yle o o r ma la yls
st F tp
o v id ed by visit us a
pr re
o le arn mo
T

#playconnectsus ©2023 Landscape Structures Inc. All rights reserved.


FOREGROUND /NOW

Cosmic Saltillo is an anomaly in the East Austin. First used by Texaco as a


city’s contemporary real estate gold storage depot and later by artists and
rush. Designed by Ten Eyck and the musicians as a venue, the property is intimate, vine-shrouded seating areas
architecture firm Clayton Korte, the among the last vestiges of the former separate from the main courtyard.
roughly 18,000-square-foot restau- railyard that is now the Saltillo mixed- Anything that could be was salvaged,
rant space is the second outpost of use development. says Paul Oveisi, the cofounder of
TEN EYCK LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTS
Cosmic Coffee, whose stylishly ram- Cosmic Coffee, including the build-
shackle South Austin location opened The shells of the existing Texaco ings’ concrete slabs, which were jack-
in 2019. The new space, accessible buildings were painstakingly pre- hammered out and repurposed as
from Austin’s Red Line commuter rail served, right down to the graffiti, massive, asymmetrical pavers for the
and the Red Line Trail that follows it, along with three towering elm trees entry. “Christy fought tooth and nail
revives a pair of graffiti-covered, his- and a collection of crumbling brick to make sure that we preserved all that
torically significant metal buildings in walls, which Ten Eyck used to create old concrete,” he says.

18 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Each irregular piece of concrete the “funky, organic, creative part of ways been there, in part because
had to be placed by hand, says Billy Austin” set the tone for the entire the team has allowed the vegetation
ABOVE Spencer, the founder of Spencer project, he says. “It’s rare that you that previously enveloped the back
A limestone fountain in
Landscape Company, who person- have somebody that believes in this half of the site to resume its con-
the courtyard was built
out of salvaged oil pipe ally oversaw the creation of the entry idea,” he notes. “They could have quest. “We cut everything down
and a decommissioned and a custom fountain built out of saved money and built this in [a] because we had to, and [Christy]
gravel crusher. salvaged pipe and a gravel crusher. way where it would have taken a told me, ‘Paul, don’t worry, they’re
Spencer grew up in Marfa, Texas, fraction of the effort. But there was going to come back,” Oveisi says
OPPOSITE BOTTOM and worked with Ten Eyck Land- a lot of care taken to save this mate-of the existing vines. “And they in-
Old concrete slabs
were jackhammered
scape Architects on the landscape rial and reuse it.” deed came back. And I think that
for Marfa’s El Cosmico hotel (unre- adds to the [feeling that] this stuff
ERIKA RICH

out of the buildings and


stored on-site until lated to Cosmic Coffee). At Cosmic The result is the rare addition to has been around forever. Some of
they could be reused. Saltillo, the emphasis on preserving East Austin that feels as if it’s al- it has.”

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 19


FOREGROUND /NOW

NATIONAL VULNERABILITY PERCENTILE

WIDENING
THE LENS
ONLINE TOOLS FOR IDENTIFYING
CLIMATE VULNERABILITY
CONTINUE TO IMPROVE.
BY TIMOTHY A. SCHULER

T he first thing Catherine Seavitt Nordenson, FASLA, did


when she learned about the Climate Vulnerability Index
(CVI), developed by the Environmental Defense Fund and Texas
It is meant for policymakers but also as a tool for
environmental justice communities themselves,
says Grace Tee Lewis, an epidemiologist who led
A&M University, was to check to see if it accounted for race. The the work on the CVI for the Environmental De-
newly appointed chair of the landscape architecture program fense Fund. The map, which is open access and
at the University of Pennsylvania had followed the controversy also can be overlaid with other datasets, makes
surrounding the Biden administration’s Climate and Economic sometimes invisible vulnerabilities clearly legible.
Justice Screening Tool, which upon its release in November 2022 And it is accompanied by a working list of every
had been called out for omitting race. “There’s a kind of gloss- federal climate- and environmental justice-focused
ing over of the racist spatial planning that has been part of our program or grant opportunity for which communi-
country forever,” Seavitt Nordenson says of the White House’s ties might apply.
methodology.
“If you recognize, ‘I’ve got a lot of vulnerability
The CVI (accessible at climatevulnerabilityindex.org) does indeed because of lead,’ or ‘I’ve got a lot of transportation
include race and ethnicity among its 184 indicators, along with issues,’ then it lists out government funds that have
data on mental and physical health, maternal mortality, air pol- already been allocated for that, or potential sources
lution, incarceration rates, sea-level rise, and extreme weather of funding that could match up with that specific

U.S. CLIMATE VULNERABILITY INDEX; MAPBOX/OPENSTREETMAP


events—more than three times the number of factors included indicator,” Tee Lewis says.
in the White House’s screening tool. “They’re really taking a
broad sweep of what this could be,” Seavitt Nordenson says of the Seavitt Nordenson envisions both practitioners
CVI. The indicators are aggregated to create an overall vulner- and students of landscape architecture using the
ability score and percentile ranking for every census tract in the tool. “It’s really powerful to see what’s going on in
United States, which is visualized in an interactive map. (While [a particular] district and what the triggers are in
ABOVE Hawaiʻi and Alaska are included, U.S. territories such as Guam terms of climate,” she says. At the same time, she
The Climate and Puerto Rico are not.) is drawn to the lighter parts of the map, the areas
Vulnerability Index that, for one reason or another, may be less at risk.
provides a fine-grained
look at which U.S.
Researchers at the Environmental Defense Fund say the CVI “I was looking for the blank spaces on the map,” she
communities are most— is intended to guide federal investments in climate resilience says. “Where are we seeing less impact, and how
and least—vulnerable and adaptation, 40 percent of which are to go to marginalized can we learn from those spaces to rethink how we
to climate threats. communities as part of President Biden’s Justice40 Initiative. can reduce vulnerability?”

20 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


FOREGROUND /NOW

BELOW
Merritt Chase’s scheme
leaned more on design
than programming
to draw people into
a previously car-
dominated space.

HANGING
AROUND
TOWN
A TEMPORARY DESIGN
FOR A TRAFFIC CIRCLE
SPARKS DOWNTOWN
INDIANAPOLIS.
BY JARED BREY

T he best place in Indiana to see


cars speeding around in circles
is the Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
The second best might be the ring
of streets surrounding the 284-foot-
high Soldiers and Sailors Monument
in downtown Indianapolis. So it was
a big change of pace when, this past
summer, part of Monument Circle
was shut down to vehicles and filled
with synthetic turf parklets, potted
shade trees, umbrellas, ping-pong
tables, and a beer garden.

The project, SPARK on the Circle, was


the third in a series of interventions
on Monument Circle dating back to
2015, and by far the most intensive—a
six-month activation where previous
efforts had lasted about a week, says
Chris Merritt, ASLA, a principal at
Merritt Chase, which designed the
space. It was also a preview, down-
HADLEY FRUITS

town leaders hope, of how the neigh-


borhood could evolve as it moves on
from the COVID-19 pandemic.

22 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


LINE
The Power of a Line
We believe that for design to be truly great,
it must stand the test of time, be sustainably
crafted, and proudly American made.
L I N E : A timeless, minimalist expression
of space.
Designed by Shane Coen | Coen+Partners
Landscape Forms |
A Modern Craft Manufacturer
FOREGROUND /NOW

SPARK ON THE CIRCLE ILLUSTRATIVE SITE PLAN

WEST MARKET STREET RESTROOM TRAILERS

MOBILE BAR
EXISTING
STREET CLOSURE 21+ BEER GARDEN

WANDERING GROVE

PARKLET

LISTENING BOOTH

WAGON OF WONDERS

WELCOME TRAILER

LE
NT CIRC
UME
MON

ing to Taylor Schaffer, the president park, which drew on tactical urban-
and CEO of Downtown Indy, Inc. ist projects that Merritt Chase has
Though COVID-19 made the district experimented with in other cities,
emptier in many ways—as it did in brought in more than 45,000 visitors
most cities—for the past few years between July and October 2023, each
it’s also been the fastest-growing one staying for an average of 64 min-
residential neighborhood in the city. utes, according to Schaffer, whose
The addition of new housing marks group, like many other downtown
a welcome shift in the balance of resi- organizations, uses anonymized cell-
dents, workers, and visitors, Schaffer phone data to monitor visitation. It
“A big part of it was, how do we make says, and the next thing to do is unite was a thoroughly different type of
ABOVE
this a place where it’s not just the a string of distinct and disjointed traffic for downtown Indianapolis,

MERRITT CHASE, TOP; HADLEY FRUITS, BOTTOM


More than 45,000
people visited the programming and activation that’s downtown areas. Improving public she says. The city plans to bring it
park between July and bringing people here, but the physi- space is critical. back this spring.
October of last year. cal design of the space itself makes
it really attractive and desirable as a Merritt Chase designed the Monu- “It was always surprising to me,”
TOP RIGHT
place you want to be in?” Merritt says. ment Circle project with Big Car Col- Schaffer says, “without an event,
The project shut cars
out of one quadrant of
laborative, an Indianapolis art and without any distinct or time-specific
Monument Circle, which Downtown Indianapolis was “a design nonprofit, after working with programming, that you could walk
surrounds the Soldiers neighborhood in transition” long the city to develop a South Down- out there and just see people enjoying
and Sailors Monument. before the pandemic began, accord- town Connectivity Vision Plan. The the space.”

24 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Discover
What’s Possible
Exploration, awe, excitement, movement and fun
are only part of what’s possible with the Level X®
Collection of products. With play, anything is possible.

© BCI Burke Company 2023. All Rights Reserved. bciburke.com


FOREGROUND /NOW

POSTINDUSTRIAL
PASTORAL
ORGANIZED NEIGHBORS HELP
A NEGLECTED BROWNFIELD
IN THE CITY OF DENVER
STAY RURAL.
BY ZACH MORTICE

W hen the Globe Smelting and Refining Com-


pany set up shop north of Denver in the late
1880s, neighbors worked side by side in its found-
“They worked together, they knew how to
do that, and so they kept that vision going,”
says Cindy Chang, the executive director
TOP
Globeville’s landscape
before it was reimagined
as a community green
ries. One hundred years later, the company was the of Groundwork Denver, an environmental space.
subject of increasing criticism and action from those justice nonprofit that helped guide the
same neighbors because of environmental pollution. Globeville neighbors’ vision for the site. After BOTTOM
By the time the plants closed, the neighborhood of more than a decade of planning, the outcome Valerian’s design
Globeville was left with a Superfund site, the soil of that community organizing is the Platte maintains the rural
atmosphere of the
filled with arsenic and lead. But the communal Farm Open Space, a passive recreational
neighborhood, channeling
solidarity remained, though this time it would be landscape completed in 2020 that was meant it into a richly planted
harnessed to rehabilitate the five-and-a-half-acre for contemplative strolls in a rehabilitated native prairie.
brownfield site into a community green space. native prairie.

VALERIAN, TOP; SCOTT DRESSEL-MARTIN, BOTTOM

26 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


TAKING IDEAS
FROM IMAGINATION
TO THE SITE.

TOP-GRADE WOOD • METALS • RECYCLED PLASTICS 1.800.937.0203 site-craft.com


CUSTOMIZED TO YOUR IMAGINATION
FOREGROUND /NOW

PLATTE FARM
OPEN SPACE
1 NORTH POLLINATOR 1
GARDEN & ENTRY
2 EXISTING FEATURE
COTTONWOOD
3 CONCRETE TRAIL
4 DETENTION POND FOREBAY
5 DETENTION POND
6 DETENTION OVERLOOK 2

7 CRUSHER FINES TRAIL


8 BOULDER RETAINING WALL
9 POST AND DOWEL FENCE 3
10 SOUTH POLLINATOR
GARDEN & ENTRY
9

For years, the site was a dumping ground. “It was around two beloved cottonwood trees, keeping
a very popular area to joyride stolen cars,” says Jan them intact. It was “a special way of honoring
Ediger, a neighbor and member of the Platte Farm [the community’s] vision,” Chang says.
steering committee, which led the rehabilitation.
Environmental degradation took a steep toll on The project took 14 years to realize, during
Globeville, now a predominantly Hispanic/Latinx which Ediger and her neighbors enlisted
neighborhood, as the EPA found that, because of the the support of city council members
pollution, local children had elevated levels of lead and worked through easements with
in their bodies. “Everybody just wanted to make it the local power utility that owns
right,” says Stacey Stickler, an associate principal at power lines in the area. Though
Valerian, the landscape architecture firm that was it’s been a long journey, Ediger
hired to create a master plan for the site in 2017. says she can hardly believe her
luck or her neighbors’ com-
Certain elements on the site had to be altered mitment. She bikes the open
9
(contaminated soil was removed and replaced with space’s trail, and some-
a topsoil cap), but neighbors wanted many parts of times when she goes for
the landscape to remain, such as its quasi-rural at- a walk, she brings her
mosphere. Though it’s located in the city of Denver, cat. “It came to pass,”
the site is isolated due to interstate highways, rail she says, “and I can
lines, and industrial properties that seem to shut the hardly believe how
4
rest of the city away. “There’s still a barn there. It was beautiful it is.”
very important to keep that rural feel,” Stickler says.

SCOTT DRESSEL-MARTIN, TOP LEFT; VALERIAN, RIGHT


Ediger wanted Valerian’s intervention to be as 5
6
8
“simple and as natural as possible,” she says. The
planting plan relies heavily on forbs. A headliner N

is Indian blanket (Gaillardia pulchella), deployed


across the entire site and chosen for its ability to
7 TOP LEFT
attract pollinators and its phytoremediation ca- 3
The centerpiece of the
pabilities. A permeable Grasscrete forebay, filled
Platte Farm Open Space
with water-loving grasses such as Nebraska sedge, is an overlook with
channels stormwater into a basin and forms a seating that frames views
picturesque overlook. Valerian designed the basin 10 of the valley and city.

28 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Unilock presents award-winning EcoTerra technology,
unleashing a new, greener era in hardscaping.

UP TO 15% EFFLORESCENCE CEMENT-FREE COLOR STAYS


REDUCTION IN CO2 FREE FACE-MIX TRUE LONGER

Connect with a Unilock Territory Manager


to learn more about this and other exclusive
Unilock products.
FOREGROUND /NOW

A PLACE FOR
EVERY PERSON
A NEW HOUSING DEVELOPMENT
IN ARKANSAS IS DESIGNED
FOR NEURODIVERSITY
AND COMMUNITY.
BY MACI NELSON, ASSOCIATE ASLA

T he ability to decide how to get from one place


to another is a choice that many people take
for granted. But for many neurodivergent indi-
Strategy + Design (OSD). Betts McCombs and
Ashton McCombs III created SLS in 2016 in re-
sponse to the limited options for housing, mean-
viduals, these small yet meaningful travels from ingful work, and socialization for their daughter
school or to work are a resource for a sense of self- Anna, a young adult on the autism spectrum. The
actualization, dignity, and independence, experts master plan envisions connections between the
say. At South Cato Springs, a 230-acre Ozarkian neurodiverse and broader communities, achieved
mixed-use, mixed-income development designed in part through pedestrian-friendliness and nodes
to serve neurodivergent individuals in Fayette- for social gathering throughout the site. The
ville, Arkansas, an emphasis on nature-immersed staff at SLS says they believe this project is the
mobility that promotes nonvehicular travel as start of a cultural shift that embraces living with
the norm could help the development become a differences of neurodiverse people rather than OFFICE OF STRATEGY + DESIGN
ABOVE model of inclusivity for the region. separating them.
Part of the
development’s plan are
The development, which broke ground in June “This is not a neurodivergent-only place. It is
microneighborhoods
that include spaces 2023, is being led by SLS Community, a Fayette- not exclusionary,” says Ashton McCombs IV, the
for urban farming ville nonprofit connecting neurodivergent adults executive director of SLS Community and Anna’s
and recreation. to resources, and the New York-based Office of older brother. Simon David, ASLA, the principal

30 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


FOREGROUND /NOW

SOUTH CATO SPRINGS SITE PLAN

of OSD, says he also is designing toward inclu- to this region that have been previously inacces- ABOVE
sion. “When we divide up and segregate from sible for many neurodiverse families. The master plan for
South Cato Springs
each other, it is such a huge loss for all of us,”
weaves nature and
he says. The development also plans to increase the em- active transportation
ployment of neurodivergent adults with vocational throughout the
OSD pulled inspiration from the surrounding training in urban agriculture and hospitality. The community.
forest environment, aiming to honor the way master plan calls for specialized housing near
natural systems bring us together. The walk- centrally located shops and an integrated urban
able spaces respond to the existing site’s sloping farm. This farm is referred to as the agrihood and
topography and will incorporate woodland plant- is designed as a part of a gathering space rather
ing. Canopied walkways and trails that link to the than a separate working space.
adjacent Kessler Mountain Regional Park and the OFFICE OF STRATEGY + DESIGN
Razorback Regional Greenway will create a com- “We believe that everybody has something that
fortable, shaded space for all. To support success they can do that would provide them with the
and independent living for neurodiverse adults, huge benefit of having a productive day,” Betts
the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences McCombs says. “Every human has something
plans to house a research and care facility on the to give, a skill to develop, to help them feel like a
site. The facility will provide a variety of services useful participant in society.”

32 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


WaggaWagga
Discover Our Newest Innovation with a High Play Value Inside!

Berliner Seilfabrik Play Equipment Corporation


96 Brookfield Oaks Drive, Suite 140, Greenville, SC 29607 | T +1 864 627 1092 | info@berliner-playequipment.com
FOREGROUND /
HOUSE CALL
LOOM HOUSE AGRICULTURAL STRATEGIES

MADE TO
MUSHROOM
A CREATIVE CROP HELPED ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTURE HIT A TRICKY SUSTAINABILITY TARGET.
BY TIMOTHY A. SCHULER

A nne James, ASLA, pored over the wild berries, hazelnuts, raised beds Challenge, one of the most stringent

ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE


site plan one more time. In front for vegetables—but it wasn’t enough. building sustainability standards cur-
of her were concept sketches she had rently in practice. The existing house,
ABOVE made for a roughly half-acre residen- The project, known as Loom House, composed of two structures perched
The Living Building tial property on Bainbridge Island was a collaboration with the Miller on the edge of a bluff and joined by a
Challenge’s food
production requirement
across Puget Sound from Seattle. Hull Partnership, Biohabitats, and wooden deck, had been built in 1968,
helped inspire the The wedge-shaped site, in James’s other specialized consultants, and and designed by the noted Pacific
project’s adventurous reimagining, was already brim- the team was working to meet the Northwest modernist Hal Moldstad.
plant palette. ming with food-producing plants— lofty standards of the Living Building In 2016, Karen Hust and Todd Vogel

34 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Boundless Outdoor Connections.
Introducing modular Ogden Tables that optimize the arcs, curves
and linear shapes of Ogden seating while inviting users to really
lean into their leisure time, take study sessions outdoors, or catch
up with friends over lattes.

Ogden – a truly personalized and harmonious design experience.

800.716.5506 | www.maglin.com
FOREGROUND /HOUSE CALL

purchased the house, attracted to the of its own water, produce all of its the possibility of introducing a type
property by its proximity to Vogel’s own energy, and avoid materials con- of edible organism she’d never de-
sister and her family, who live just taining any one of nearly 20 harm- signed with before: mushrooms.
down the street, as well as the rugged ful chemical classes cataloged on the
beauty of Bainbridge Island. program’s Red List. One of the more “That was a great stroke of brilliance
unusual requirements of the chal- from Anne,” says Chris Hellstern, an
Hust and Vogel decided to pursue lenge is that projects must enhance architect at Miller Hull and the firm’s
Living Building certification after access to healthy, locally grown food Living Building Challenge services
a meeting with the design team at by devoting a part of the total project director.
which Miller Hull presented every area to agricultural production. In the
sustainability rating system on the case of the Loom House, the project’s James—who, prior to opening her
books. “We didn’t know much about floor-to-area ratio of 0.15 meant that office, Anne James Landscape Ar-

ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE


the Living Building Challenge, but the design team needed to include chitecture, spent a decade working
when we learned about it, we just more than 7,000 square feet of food alongside the acclaimed landscape
felt very inspired,” Hust recalls. “We production on-site. architect Richard Haag—proposed
ABOVE
wanted to do the hard thing.” creating a mycological foraging
Raised beds for herbs
and vegetables were
The house’s densely forested site forest of fungi native to the Pacific
possible only where To be certified under the Living Build- didn’t leave the design team many Northwest. The idea emerged or-
there was enough ing Challenge, a project must, among options. But after several days of con- ganically, she says, from memories
sunlight. many other imperatives, supply all templation, an idea struck James— of hiking in and around western

36 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Paver-Grate ®

IRONSMITH’s Paver-Grate ® allows you to design over –instead of around— tree areas for
optimized planting, tree health and pedestrian comfort. An excellent choice for urban areas.
Paver-Grate® tree grates can be specified in standard or custom sizes with or without
opening’s. Trim rings and integrated tree grates available in multiple styles.

For more information about all IRONSMITH products visit us online at,
www.ironsmith.biz or call, 760-776-5077.
FOREGROUND /HOUSE CALL

MYCOLOGICAL
FORAGING FOREST

Washington. “I’ve worked a lot with ing Building Challenge’s


this plant pathologist named Dr. urban agricultural require-
Olaf Ribeiro, and walking through ment. Fortunately, it was also an
ABOVE the forest with him on projects, I idea embraced by the clients. “It was
Inoculated stumps learned a lot about mushrooms,” she really exciting,” Hust says. “I mean, it does, and James describes her ap-
and other fungi-growing
says. “So it was just by observation, who wouldn’t love to be able to grow proach at Loom House as one of
media are arranged
as part of a foraging really, and internalizing that observa- mushrooms and harvest them from careful editing, preserving a series

ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE


forest. tion [that the idea was born].” their own backyard?” of mature fir trees and charismatic
rhododendrons while enhancing
INSET Combined with the other planned For landscape architecture, the Liv- the garden’s ecological value by
Upturned logs will agricultural components, includ- ing Building Challenge is as much replacing a majority of ornamen-
eventually be colonized
by shiitake and blue
ing a berry bramble that would be about what a team doesn’t do— tal species with native plants. As
oyster mushrooms, as open and accessible to neighbors, the greenfield development is ineligible, with the mycological garden, James
stumps might be in an mycological foraging forest was for example, as is the use of many drew inspiration from the island’s
unmanaged forest. the last piece in satisfying the Liv- fertilizers and pesticides—as what ecology. “The thing to think about is,

38 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


THE DOUGLAS BENCH
POWDER COATED OR STAINLESS STEEL
YELLOW BALAU WOOD SEAT | SURFACE MOUNT

SHIPPING NATIONWIDE
MADE IN THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST

BIKE RACKS, BIKE LOCKERS, BOLLARDS, GET INSPIRED AT: HUNTCO.COM


RECEPTACLES, BENCHES, TABLES AND CHAIRS.
CUSTOM BUILDS AND BIKE ROOM LAYOUTS. INSTAGRAM TWITTER
S I T E F U R N I S H I NG S
@Huntco @HuntcoSupply
START YOUR PROJECT: 1-800-547-5909
FOREGROUND /HOUSE CALL

ABOVE what is the landscape around you?”


The incorporation of she says. “What can grow without
mushrooms required
supplemental water in the condi-
specialized drawings
and planting schedules. tions that you have?”

RIGHT Besides the agricultural requirement,


After inoculation, the toughest target to hit, James says,
some logs were was the water-use-reduction require-
assembled into loosely
ment. The Living Building Challenge
stacked structures
called ricks. prohibits the use of any potable water
for irrigation and requires that 100
percent of stormwater be treated on-
site. Existing buildings must also
reduce indoor water use by 30 per-
cent. Although the Cascadia region
is a famously wet place, the particu-
lar pattern in which precipitation
falls in Seattle and the surrounding
area created challenges for landscape residential projects, storing enough a good part of the way to the water
maintenance, James says. “People water for the irrigation demand often use target. But even with new native
don’t understand that in Seattle we isn’t feasible. “What you have to do is plantings and a 10,000-gallon cis-

ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE


have a lot of rain, but we don’t have just reduce your use as much as you tern under the former driveway, the
hardly any rain from, like, the first can,” she says. cost of meeting the requirement was
of July through the end of Septem- out of reach. “We could have provid-
ber. We’re talking about a Mediter- Replacing the property’s lawn and or- ed the water for the project, includ-
ranean climate: dry, dry, dry,” she namental plants—including a large ing the irrigation, but the cost of the
says. What that typically means is and enigmatic wisteria vine that was system that we would have needed to
that cisterns are oversized to make transformed into a chandelier for the build was perceived as nonsustain-
it through the dry season. But on dining room—propelled the team able because it was so expensive,”

40 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Architectural Paving Stones

WWW.NITTERHOUSEMASONRY.COM
FOREGROUND /HOUSE CALL

“WHO WOULDN’T LOVE


TO BE ABLE TO GROW
MUSHROOMS AND
HARVEST THEM
FROM THEIR
OWN BACKYARD?”
—KAREN HUST

ABOVE James says. resource)—James assembled a list material: dozens of fresh alder logs
King stropharia “We were try- of six “regionally appropriate” ed- (for inoculation), hundreds of packets
was among the ing to be a model ible mushroom varieties: shiitake, of mushroom plug spawn (the inocu-
first mushroom for small houses, renovated houses, lion’s mane, king stropharia, blue lant), and several pounds of beeswax
varieties to appear and it just seemed like a disconnect.” oyster, pearl oyster, and phoenix oys- (for sealing the plugs). As part of
following the project’s
completion.
The project ultimately received an ex- ter. These were chosen because they her drawing set, James developed
emption in the water category, based aligned with Bainbridge Island’s cli- a mycological inoculation schedule,
on an annual reduction in water use mate and also matched up with the which detailed the names, quantities,
of approximately 60,000 gallons, hardwood species available. Differ- inoculation types, and timing of the
or more than 50 percent compared ent tree species are better suited to various mushroom varieties. Some
to baseline. certain fungi, James explains, and fungi could be cultivated year-round;
the varieties selected reflected the others only in the spring or fall.
If large-scale water storage can be types of wood she could acquire
cost prohibitive for the average “fresh” from local arborists: alder To build the garden, workers from
homeowner, the creation of a my- and big-leaf maple. “You have to Ohashi Landscape Services stacked
cological garden is quite the oppo- have fresh logs so that they’re not the alder logs into a series of three-
site. “It’s pretty cheap,” James says. contaminated with other mycelium,” foot-high, Jenga-like towers called
“It’s not something a normal person James notes. “Types of wood avail- “ricks,” then inoculated them with
couldn’t do.” able would vary in different areas of mushroom spawn. They drilled
the country, and fungal selections holes 5/16 of an inch in diameter up

ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE


After some initial research and con- would likely reflect that.” and down the length of the logs, into
sultation with staff at Fungi Perfecti which they inserted the plug spawn
—an Olympia, Washington-based James’s unusual take on a food forest (small, myceliated wooden dowels).
mycological supply company found- —which, in addition to mushrooms, After the plugs were inserted, the
ed by the mushroom evangelist Paul included wild onions and edible workers melted the beeswax over
Stamets (whose book Mycelium ferns—did come with a steep learn- a small camp stove and used the
Running: How Mushrooms Can Help ing curve, however, as well as a hefty wax to seal the holes. For the same
Save the World was also a helpful amount of unconventional landscape reason “fresh” logs are necessary, the

42 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


PROVEN
ADAPTABLE

FIZZY MIZZY ®
A sweetspire that literally stands out in the
Itea virginica ‘SMNIVMM’ PP#33,549; CBRAF
landscape! Abundant upright flower spikes bloom
Native species | Fragrant | Compact in early summer, bridging the gap between the
SUMMER USDA 5-9
seasons. This adaptable, compact shrub can
be sited full sun to full shade, expanding its
2-3’ tall + wide
landscape applications. SCAN TO LEARN MORE

For wholesale plant inquiries please contact us at


SpringMeadowNursery.com or 800-633-8859
FOREGROUND /HOUSE CALL

RIGHT ricks’ base logs are not inoculated,


When it was completed, forming a barrier that prevents the
the Loom House became rest of the structure from being in-
the first residential
fected by other soil-based mycelium.
renovation to achieve
Living Building In addition to the ricks, myceliated down, when in fact they were brought that exists in symbiosis with the ele-
certification. alder chips—nested between two in and inoculated with mushroom ments at play on the site—“the water
uninoculated layers—were spread mycorrhizae,” James says. and the sun and the wind and things
BELOW over a 32-square-foot area of the forest that grow naturally here. It feels like
Other strategies to floor, and several more alder stumps Building the mushroom garden was a our house is helping to root us into
meet the requirements
included reusing site
were inoculated and stood upright in novel experience for the entire design this place in a really honest way, and
materials such as the garden. “The thought was that it team. “These landscape guys, they Anne has been really instrumental
concrete. would look like old trees that got cut had never done this either, so I was in helping weave the house into the

BEN SCHAULAND, TOP RIGHT; ANNE JAMES LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, BOTTOM LEFT
trying to give them all the information landscape.” Hust and Vogel have
that I could,” she says. She made a even had the pleasure of seeing the
point to be on-site during the inocu- first few mushrooms emerge from
lation process, partially to ensure it the forest floor, though it will be a
went smoothly but also to observe the while yet before the ricks produce
process firsthand. “It was new to all of enough fungi for a harvest. (It can
us,” she says. take anywhere from six months to
five years for the fungi to fruit, de-
Completed in 2019, the house un- pending on the growing medium
derwent the requisite performance and the local conditions.) “We defi-
monitoring for one year. In 2021, nitely have seen a few,” Hust says,
the Loom House received certifica- “but they’re just getting going.”
tion under version 4.0 of the Living
Building Challenge—only the fourth TIMOTHY A. SCHULER’S WRITING ON THE BUILT
house, and the first renovation, to do ENVIRONMENT HAS APPEARED IN PLACES
JOURNAL, METROPOLIS, BLOOMBERG CITYLAB,
so. Hust, one of the owners, com- AND LAM, WHERE HE HAS BEEN A CONTRIBUT-
pares the house to a living organism ING EDITOR SINCE 2015.

44 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Rough&Ready
Products: Rough&Ready Hug a Tubs & Shrubtubs Square
Hug a Tubs
Project: Tower City Center, Downtown Cleveland (OH) Landscape Architect: MKSK

Product Range: Rough&Ready, beam size: 2.8” x 5.9”


Wood options: FSC®-certified hardwood or Accoya
TWIN option: All Black (recyclate)
Accessories: Back- and armrests, USB Power Charger

Solid Wing Bench NEW TWIN Green Circular Skirt Benches NEW Love Tub Plaza Shade & Heavy-Heavy Benches TWIN

Cloudy Grey (recyclate) CorTen Lava Grey (recyclate)

STREETLIFE AMERICA Philadelphia, PA I usa@streetlife.com I www.streetlife.com I t. 215 247 0148 I FSC® License number: C105477
University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR
Size & Color: 5” x 12”, A80010

A UNIQUE, PEDESTRIAN-FRIENDLY
PAVING ALTERNATIVE

HANOVER® ASPHALT BLOCK


Produced with Post-Industrial Recycled Content, Asphalt
Block is a unique paving alternative Available in several
shapes and sizes and a variety of colors and textures, A80018 A80026 A80055
20.1% 24.4% 87%
Asphalt Block is extremely durable, soft under foot and
spark resistant.

www.hanoverpavers.com
FOREGROUND /
GOODS EDITED BY KRISTEN MASTROIANNI

OUT AND
ABOUT
PUBLIC FURNISHINGS
WITH SWAGGER.

520VS SERIES
This new and versatile seat-
ing surface from DuMor features
laser-cut bent steel straps. The method
allows for a uniform gap between each
strap, creating a clean and continuous look. HARTMAN BENZON MEDIA

The series will also include standard benches,


tables, seat islands, and wall-mount benches.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, VISIT WWW.DUMOR.COM.

48 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


THE HILL
The Hill litter bin touts character
and functionality. Available in more
than 200 color choices, the container
is made of hot-dip galvanized and
powder-coated steel and elevates any
public space. Vestre offers a lifetime
guarantee against rust, and the Hill
can be equipped with a smart sensor
system that sends alerts when it’s
time to empty the bin.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, VISIT
WWW.VESTRE.COM.

SUBMIT
DO YOU HAVE A NEW PRODUCT
THAT YOU WOULD LIKE
TO SEE IN GOODS?
SUBMIT YOUR MATERIALS TO
LAMGOODS@ASLA.ORG.

Indicates products that have an


Environmental Product Declaration
(EPD) available.

CYRCA M30-P1/K4
SECURITY BOLLARD
Cyrca is the latest addition to
the growing security bollard
EINAR ASLAKSEN, TOP; COURTESY FORMS+SURFACES, BOTTOM

collection by Forms+Surfaces.
Its crash-tested core suits Cyrca
for areas that face a moderate
threat of heavy or fast-moving traf-
fic. Cyrca is available in illuminated and
nonilluminated variations, and offers a choice
of cap designs, providing versatile options. The
stainless steel elements are available powder-coated
or in a satin finish with Ceramiloc, which offers
enhanced protection from weather and graffiti.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, VISIT
WWW.FORMS-SURFACES.COM.

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 49


FOREGROUND /GOODS

SEDI CONNECT
This solar-power-equipped station is per-
fect for busy public spaces where lighting
and mobile device charging are desired.
The wraparound seating unit is built with
sustainable materials, and the enclosed
frame provides shelter from both sun and
rain. Two USB charging outlets and two
Qi charging pads are included; additional
outlets may be added.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, VISIT
WWW.ARCHASOL.COM.

COURTESY ARCHASOL

50 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


PLAYFUL
GATHERINGS

Pennant Park at Daybreak


South Jordan, UT
Collaboration: Loci, Big T Recreation

Earthscape is your single source for designing and building custom wood play
structures. We collaborate with you to bring the impossible to life and create info@earthscapeplay.com | 1.877.269.2972

unforgettable playscapes. earthscapeplay.com


FOREGROUND /GOODS

OGDEN MODULAR SERIES


Flexibility is the key to this modu-
lar seating and surface collection,
which can adapt to site require-
ments and offers backed and back-
less varieties of curved, circular, or
straight benches. The seating can
be optimized by adding modular
COURTESY MAGLIN

tables with wall-mount, pedestal,


square, and cantilever bases.
FOR MORE INFORMATION, VISIT
WWW.MAGLIN.COM.

52 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


BRICK IS
COLORFUL
Lemon Avenue streetscape, English Edge clay pavers, installed by Preferred Pavers and Concrete. Photography: Ray Gamma.

When life gives you lemons, celebrate them


with a beautiful streetscape
L emon Avenue in Sarasota is a nod lemon, a pineapple at Pineapple
to the region’s citrus industry Avenue and an ornate compass rose at
and it’s also a vibrant retail district in a State Street. All with our English Edge
resort city. pavers in four fired-in colors that will
Thanks to forward-thinking city never fade: Buff, Full Range, Dark
planners and landscape architect firm Accent and Rose.
David W. Johnston Associates, Lemon
Avenue is now a more walkable, Learn more at:
bikeable, driveable thoroughfare with PineHallBrick.com/LAM
an aesthetic sense of place.
The award-winning clay paver
hardscape includes the namesake
World’s largest supplier of clay pavers.
FOREGROUND /GOODS

DOGGIE DEMAND
These motion-activated fountains
provide fresh water as dogs approach.
The sensors are placed at a dog’s
height for easy access to hydration
and play, but the fountains can also
be operated by a button. They feature
durable powder-coated commercial
steel in six color options.
FOR MORE INFORMATION,VISIT
WWW.COOLDOGWATERFOUNTAINS.COM.

COURTESY COOL DOG WATER FOUNTAINS

54 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


permaloc Hardscape Restraints
®

S U S TA I N A B L E E D G I N G S O L U T I O N S

The ground moves - your hardscape shouldn’t.


Permaloc is the industry leader in aluminum hardscape restraints for brick, pavers,
porcelain, travertine, and asphalt. Our edging is designed to hit just above the center of the hardscape.
No matter the size of your hardscape, we have the edging option you need.

GOOD BETTER BEST


StructurEdge™ BrickBlock™ AsphaltEdge™

Residential / Commercial / Commercial


Light Commercial High-End Residential Heavy-Duty Applications
Readily forms curves, radii Two base options, each Designed for asphalt over
and angles, allowing wide allowing one part to be aggregate, asphalt
installation flexibility. used for both straight overlay, and asphalt over
and curvilinear concrete,
applications.

800.399.9600 | www.permaloc.com
awaken the personality
of your space

To discover more, visit www.moveart.swiss

move art
together with

TM
FEATURES

CLEVELAND

A smattering of
seedheads at
AMBER N. FORD

the Cozad-Bates
House is part of
the interpretive
scheme, page 58.

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 57


WESTERN RESERVE HISTORICAL SOCIETY, LEFT

58 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


CLEVELAND’S
DERU LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTURE
SEES BIG STORIES
IN SMALL SPACES.
BY ZACH MORTICE

PHOTOGRAPHY BY AMBER N. FORD

nside the Cozad-Bates House, a hand-


some, red brick Italianate building on the
east side of Cleveland that’s the last pre-
Civil War house in the University Circle
neighborhood, is a small exhibit that tells
the history of Ohio and Cleveland’s role in LEFT
the Underground Railroad. A map of Ohio At the Cozad-Bates
House, a quote from
created in the late 19th century by the Ohio
Harriet Tubman is
State University history professor Wilbur Siebert placed to rise above
traces the clandestine network, with thin arteries the stormwaters.
arrayed south to north, reaching across almost
all its counties. Seven of these trails converge in OPPOSITE
Cleveland before crossing Lake Erie into Canada. A 19th-century map
of the Underground
It gives every impression of the loose town-to-
Railroad in Ohio.
town network of sympathetic families that would
open their homes to people escaping enslavement
that the railroad was—long on hope, short on
actual infrastructure.

According to the exhibit, 275 people fleeing slav-


ery passed through Cleveland over eight months
in 1854. Siebert’s 1898 book, The Underground
Railroad from Slavery to Freedom, asserts that

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 59


TOP LEFT
The Cozad-Bates House

DERU LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, TOP LEFT AND BOTTOM


landscape before
DERU’s design.
FUNCTIONAL BOTTOM LEFT
DIAGRAM The small site was
PEDESTRIAN crisscrossed with foot
DESIRE LINE traffic and needed
responsive circulation.
SITE BOUNDARY
OPPOSITE
A plaza with interpretive
N
signage attracts visitors
from the sidewalk.

60 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Cleveland was one of the Underground Railroad’s Few enslaved people could write, and even if
most important hubs and that the route from they could, “Most of us don’t write down on
Kentucky to Ohio was likely the most traveled. paper, ‘I just broke a federal law today,’” says
“Ohio may lay claim to eight terminal stations, Kathryn Puckett, the board president of Restore
all comparatively important,” he wrote. Cleveland Hope, an advocacy organization that
led the restoration of the Cozad-Bates House to
The position of Ohio between slave-holding Ken- commemorate Cleveland’s role in the Under-
tucky and freedom in Canada, where slavery had ground Railroad. “There are very few places that
been illegal since 1834, made the Cozad-Bates can document that a fugitive was actually there.”
House an ideal location for the Underground
Railroad, though there are scant direct accounts When Puckett’s attention turned to the plot of
of people who made their way through Cleveland. lawn that surrounded the house in 2018, she

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 61


62 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024
LEFT
The team at DERU
Landscape Architecture
in their Cleveland office.
From left are founder
Jayme Schwartzberg,
ASLA; Erin Laffay, ASLA;
Anna Enderle, Associate
ASLA, who is now with
SmithGroup; and Maci
Nelson, Associate ASLA.

began to wonder how a landscape could tell this


story. Puckett says she wanted a space that could
communicate “the intelligence and courage it
took to be a freedom-seeker and [an Underground
Railroad] conductor.”

“How do you make that journey?” she asks. “How


do you decide from the familiarity of the Ken-
tucky plantation to walk toward freedom; freedom
you’ve been told about but you haven’t read about.
You don’t have a map. [You] don’t know who will
help [you] or who will turn [you] in. How do you
feed yourself along the way? The plants were
sustenance to get from here to there. [You] don’t
even know where there is. They were walking
among the plants and hiding among the plants
and living among the plants.”

Interpreting this for the grounds of the Cozad-


DAVID JOSEPH PHOTOGRAPY

Bates House became the brief of DERU Landscape


Architecture, which was founded in 2014 by Jayme
Schwartzberg, ASLA, and now includes Erin Laf-
fay, ASLA, and Maci Nelson, Associate ASLA. After
the house served a long spell as a boarding house

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 63


PLAN
1 PLAZA WITH HERRINGBONE
PATTERN POINTING NORTH

8
2 OUTLINE OF CONSTELLATION
AND AFRICAN PAVING
PATTERN INSIDE THE
“DRINKING GOURD”
COZAD-BATES
HOUSE 3 FREEDOM-SEEKER PATH

4 BIORETENTION

5 ACCESSIBLE PATH TO
7 INTERPRETIVE CENTER

6 RESTING PLACE

6
7 NORTH STAR INLAY

8 PICNIC TABLE

9 EVENT LAWN

2
10 TONI MORRISON BENCH

5 11 HISTORICAL MARKER

EAST 115TH STREET

3
1

DERU LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE

10
11 N

MAYFIELD ROAD
“HOW DO YOU MAKE
THAT JOURNEY?
HOW DO YOU DECIDE
TO WALK TOWARD
FREEDOM?”
—KATHRYN PUCKETT

and then sat vacant for about 20 years, DERU doing green infrastructure,” Schwartzberg says.
was hired by University Circle Inc., a community “They’re engineers, and they care about dollars
development nonprofit that has owned the house to gallons, and they don’t particularly care about
since 2006, to design an experience of “physical how you get there.” But DERU’s richer vision to
empathy” into the land, Schwartzberg says. focus attention on how people traveled through
the landscape and what they encountered along
The project began humbly, with a grant from the the way was able to hitch a ride on the sewer dis-
Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District for a bit trict funding. The majority of the project’s total
more than $200,000 to install a stormwater bio- budget of $300,000 was fulfilled by the grant,
swale on the property. The initial plan seemed bare which was satisfied by placing a richly planted,
bones and a bit clumsy: a squiggly permeable-paver crescent-shaped bioswale in the northwest corner
path to the house bordered by a loosely triangular of the house’s lot.
rain garden depression. Schwartzberg called it a
“hole in the ground and some plaques.” University The new design concept is organized around the
Circle brought DERU in “to develop what that was constellations of the Big Dipper, Little Dipper,
really going to be,” she says. and North Star, represented by brass stars affixed
to pavers and stones, some already showing the
Schwartzberg had worked with the sewer district teal patina of weathering. Stepping down into
before on green infrastructure demonstration the bioswale, there’s a quote by Harriet Tubman
gardens, prompted by a stringent Environmen- on pavers of alternating height: “There was one
tal Protection Agency consent decree that re- of two things I had a right to, liberty or death; if
quired the city to capture and treat more than I could not have one, I would have the other.” As
98 percent of water heading into its combined stormwater levels rise, the last phrase above the
sewer system. “They were kind of pushed into water line will be “liberty or death.”

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 65


DERU LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, TOP

66 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


And that’s not the only way this landscape will The plantings in the bioswale are largely medici-
change with the weather and seasons. As the nal and edible, documented for their utilitarian
bioswale grows in, it will get shaggy, denser, and uses during the 19th century, including by Indige-
the meticulously sited navigational star arrays nous people. There are persimmons, serviceberry,
and Tubman’s defiant words will get less visible. and currants to satiate hunger. There’s Echinacea
That’s part of the plan. to fortify the immune system before setting out
on a life-threatening journey, antiseptic yarrow
“We thought a lot about how, when you’re a to clean cuts and scrapes, and rose hips to ease
freedom-seeker, you’re not taking the main road,” joint pain, all labeled with wispy white line draw-
ABOVE Schwartzberg says. “You’re taking the backroads, ings by Schwartzberg’s mother, Ilynn Guldman.
A sketch of DERU’s untrodden paths. We wanted [to get] people off The labels also explain their medicinal uses. On
bioswale design for the the walkways and to dig through plants. You have the Underground Railroad, “the only things that
Cozad-Bates House.
to push your way through a little bit.” were constant were the stars and sometimes the
OPPOSITE plants,” says Matt Provolt, the associate director
The plantings in DERU’s landscape evokes this experience with of planning and design at University Circle Inc.
the bioswale are a soggy, sunken trough that might faintly call
dense and messy, to mind trekking through a marsh or crossing a Beyond the bioswale, DERU’s landscape is a se-
an interpretation of river. To deal with the more intensive than usual ries of interlocking, arcing paths and small plazas.
what former slaves
bioswale foot traffic, DERU selected hardy plant- Herringbone pavers highlight arrows pointing
seeking freedom might
have encountered as ings and used sandy soil that’s less subject to north, and the cup of the Big Dipper, detailed in a
they crept through compaction and also aids drainage for the water kente cloth pattern, comprises Joan Evelyn South-
marshland and that is collected from the roof of the house and gate Walk, named after the legendary founder of
across rivers. piped into the swale. Restore Cleveland Hope, Joan Southgate, who

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 67


PLANT LIST
TREES

Amelanchier × grandiflora ‘Autumn Brilliance’


(Autumn Brilliance serviceberry)

Nyssa sylvatica ‘Zydeco Twist’


(Zydeco Twist black gum)

Diospyros virginiana ‘Golden Delight’


(Golden Delight persimmon)

SHRUBS

Cephalanthus occidentalis ‘SMCOSS’


(Sugar Shack buttonbush)
Cornus sericea ‘Farrow’
(Arctic Fire red osier dogwood)
Lonicera caerulea var. kamtschatica
‘Cinderella’ (Cinderella honeyberry)
Lonicera caerulea ‘Borealis’
(Borealis honeyberry)
Rosa palustris
(Swamp rose)

PERENNIALS

Allium cernuum
(Nodding onion)
Symphyotrichum cordifolium ‘Avondale’
(Avondale blue wood aster)
Dennstaedtia punctilobula
(Eastern hay-scented fern)
Echinacea purpurea ‘Magnus’
(Magnus purple coneflower)
Echinops ritro ‘Veitch’s Blue’
(Veitch’s Blue globe thistle)
Eryngium × zabelii ‘Big Blue’
(Big Blue sea holly)
Iris sibirica ‘Blue Moon’
(Blue Moon Siberian iris)
Achillea millefolium ‘Apfelblüte’
(Appleblossom yarrow)

GRASSES

Bouteloua gracilis
(Blue grama) DERU LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
Carex vulpinoidea
(Fox sedge)
Carex pensylvanica
(Pennsylvania sedge)
N
Panicum virgatum ‘Heavy Metal’
(Heavy Metal switchgrass)

68 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


ABOVE walked from Ripley, Ohio, to St. Catharines, On- hood defined by the Cleveland Clinic and Case
The medicinal and tario, along one route of the Underground Rail- Western Reserve University. The owner, Justus
edible plants in road while in her 70s. From the black, gray, and Cozad, was an engineer for the railroad, and his
the bioswale are
highlighted with
earthy ochered red-brick pavers here, an axial, work often took him across the Midwest, but he
illustrations by narrow line of pavers leads toward the North Star, lived at the house on and off for the next several
Schwartzberg’s on the handle of the Little Dipper. Separated by decades, expanding it with an Italianate addition
mother, Ilynn Guldman. the bioswale, another small plaza is bordered by in 1872. It was listed on the National Register of
sandstone reclaimed from the site and arranged Historic Places in 1974 and proclaimed a Cleve-
in terraced stair seating that matches the sand- land landmark in 2006.
stone foundations of the house—room enough
for a small outdoor classroom. One of the historical quotes, attributed to Jus-
tus Cozad, on the ground next to a picnic table
The Cozad-Bates House was completed in 1853 in near the rear of the house, reads: “I myself have
what was then East Cleveland Township, a rural worked many a day in the field with runaway
farming area, but which is now a busy neighbor- slaves and always sat at the table to eat with

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 69


“ WE WANTED [TO GET] PEOPLE
OFF THE WALKWAYS AND TO
DIG THROUGH PLANTS.”
—JAYME SCHWARTZBERG, ASLA

them.” Despite this sentiment, there’s no defini- pulled from the archives of the Western Re-
tive proof that the Cozad-Bates House was a stop serve Historical Society and Restore Cleveland
on the Underground Railroad, though some Hope. Many of the materials came from personal
members of the Cozad family (like Justus’s uncle, diaries and journals of the Cozads’ neighbors.
father, and grandfather) were documented aiding “We’re pretty dense in here,” says Elise Yablonsky,
escaped slaves. University Circle’s vice president of community
development. The landscape offers “literal and
Navigating by the stars, trusting strangers with figurative breathing room to connect with the
your life, foraging for food and medicine, stalking emotional and first-person sides of the story,”
through wild country: Visitors to the Cozad-Bates she says.
OPPOSITE House will experience small pieces of all of this.
DERU’s Erin Laffay When Schwartzberg talks about the landscape “You’re surrounded by parking garages and hospi-
and her son at that she and the team at DERU (which at the tals, so to save that plot of land and put your back
the Cozad-Bates
House.
time included Laffay and Anna Enderle, Associate to Mayfield Road, and just be in that moment—
ASLA) designed, there’s the sense that she recog- you can be transported in time even without go-
nizes that this project does something that she’s ing through those doors,” says Angie Lowrie, the
MACI NELSON, ASSOCIATE ASLA, OPPOSITE

likely never done before and that many designers director of the Cleveland History Center, a part of
never get to do. “You could tell the story in a way the Western Reserve Historical Society and a key
that helps people put themselves in this,” she says. partner providing historical research for DERU
“[It’s] so visceral.” and University Circle Inc.

This story is told in a small interpretive center During her research, Schwartzberg visited the
on the first floor of the house by photos, maps, National Underground Railroad Freedom Center
historical illustrations, and especially documents, in Cincinnati, and saw what she didn’t want. After

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 71


a tired exhale, she whispers, “It’s boring. It’s a lot enslaved to grow and process, a nod toward the eco-
of text. You’re only getting secondhand, thirdhand nomics of slave labor. On the signage is written in-
stories about people after they’ve died. It’s a sur- terpretive text developed by researchers that doesn’t
prisingly hard story to tell.” hedge: “There was always someone in pursuit—
someone claiming ownership or someone seek-
But some landscape exposition at the house was ing a reward for capture. There were sounds of
unavoidable. For this, the team turned to the graph- dogs and horses, and shouts in the night. Failing
ic designers at Agnes Studio, who designed two meant brutal punishment. It meant continuing a
double-sided displays with gold lettering and star life of endless hard labor in which they were not
patterns at their base. They selected a deep indigo considered human.” And of the conductors: “They
hue to reference the cash crop that Black people were chose to break the law. But many more did not.”

72 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


RIGHT
Interpretive signage
designed by Agnes
Studio is deep indigo,
the color of a cash crop
that enslaved people
produced.

OPPOSITE
A bench at the Cozad-
Bates House was
established by the
Toni Morrison Society
as part of its Bench
by the Road Project.

Schwartzberg says that roses signify the (poten- track and field star, whose four Olympic gold
tial) joyful resolution of the freedom-seeker’s medals earned in 1936 in Berlin rebuked the
journey; they reside with “a little river of irises” Nazi myth of white supremacy. Each of Owens’s
that flows through the bottom of the bioswale. gold medals came with an oak tree seedling, and
“It’s easy to make flowers pretty,” she says, but they made their way to Ohio when he returned.
“we wanted things that weren’t just friendly, pretty The last confirmed living tree from this group
plants, because it can’t just be a success story. was planted at a local high school where Owens
There are too many people who never escaped.” trained. In 2017, it was cloned and propagated at
As such, a gnarled Zydeco Twist black gum sap- Cleveland’s Holden Arboretum.
ling at the southern edge ends the landscape
with a grim totem. “We felt like it was a good That clone is now planted at the center of the
tree to represent what slavery does to humanity,” Olympic Oak Plaza. Four concrete markers,
Schwartzberg says. sloped and rounded rectangles given a shape
that’s a hybrid between an oak leaf and a tendril
Not far from the Cozad-Bates House, DERU is of Olympic flame, are placed along a narrow
helping to tell another nuanced story of persever- reddish-brown running track, 200 meters long—
ance and victory at Rockefeller Park, again with the length of one of Owens’s gold-medal-winning
University Circle as the client. Working with the races. The mile markers remind visitors that
Cleveland artist Angelica Pozo, DERU’s design Owens’s legacy was based on “traversing space
for Jesse Owens Olympic Oak Plaza celebrates and distance,” says Pozo, and her tile mosaics
the legacy of Jesse Owens, the Cleveland-native installed last summer are lined in glass tile the

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 73


RECONCILING CIVIL RIGHTS
INEQUALITIES MEANS
“MAKING SIGNIFICANT MARKS
IN THE LANDSCAPE.”
—JAYME SCHWARTZBERG, ASLA

color of flame along their narrow edges, while Reconciling civil rights inequalities means “making
their broad faces are covered in green ceramic significant marks in the landscape,” she says. As one
tile. One face of each marker will have written of the most racially segregated cities in the country,
accounts of Owens’s life before, during, and after “Cleveland has more to reconcile with than most.”
the 1936 Olympics, narrating his triumphs as
well as his disappointments, including when he The Cozad-Bates House landscape is grounded in
was denied the traditional White House visit by sensory experiences of plants and space that are pow-
President Franklin Roosevelt. On the opposite erfully elemental and intensely individual. “When
side will be drawings on ceramic tile that Pozo you put a berry in your mouth, and experience that
sketched from photos of Owens. sharp, sweet taste, that’s so evocative, that’s such
a strong sense-memory,” Schwartzberg says. “We
DERU’s design surrounds the thin and wispy oak wanted people to experience that moment.”
tree with St. John’s wort ground cover. Schwartz-
berg wanted the planting contributions to be “un- ZACH MORTICE IS A CHICAGO-BASED DESIGN JOURNALIST WHO
derstated because [Pozo’s] art is very colorful and FOCUSES ON ARCHITECTURE AND LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE.
strong and vibrant,” she says. In front of the tree
will be a concrete podium with a bench on each Project Credits
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT DERU LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE,
side, each the length of his medal-winning long CLEVELAND. CLIENT UNIVERSITY CIRCLE INC., CLEVELAND. GREEN
jump, all covered in Olympic-medal-colored glass INFRASTRUCTURE NORTHEAST OHIO REGIONAL SEWER DISTRICT,
tile: gold on the tallest (center) podium, silver CLEVELAND. COMMUNITY PARTNER RESTORE CLEVELAND HOPE,
and bronze on the others. Like the Cozad-Bates CLEVELAND. INTERPRETIVE PARTNER WESTERN RESERVE HIS-
TORICAL SOCIETY, CLEVELAND. GRAPHIC DESIGN AGNES STUDIO,
House landscape, it’s an act of remembrance. CLEVELAND. STORMWATER ENGINEERING NEFF & ASSOCIATES,
Schwartzberg says she wanted the tree to be front CLEVELAND. CONTRACTOR R. J. PLATTEN CONTRACTING COMPANY,
and center “so it doesn’t get lost again.” NORTH ROYALTON, OHIO.

74 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


LEFT
Brass stars outline
the constellations
that freedom-seekers
used to navigate
northward.

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 75


The ASLA Fund and Founders Club
thanks our members for their
continued support.
Their contributions to the ASLA Fund and the Founders Club support the ASLA Climate Action
Plan, Career Discovery, MineCraft Camps and Dream Big with Design, Women of Color
Licensure Advancement Program, sending students to the conference, and more!

Jack Ahern Groundsmith Collective Daniel Martin Isobel Ritch


Anova Michael Grove Eugenia Martin Richard Roark
Araiys Design LA PC Deb Guenther Kaki Martin Sean Rotar
ArborStakes Lara Guldenpfennig Brice Maryman Christopher Sass
ASLA CO/WY Paula H. Horrigan Anonymous Donor Lauren Schmitt
Jeffrey Aten Leah Hales Emily McCoy Stephen Schrader
Ben Baker Laurie Hall Karen McCoy Jean Senechal Biggs
Ball State University Christopher Hardy Todd McCurdy Bruce Sharky
Beverly Bass Allyce Hargrove Jeffrey McLane Juanita Shearer-Swink
Monique Bassey David Hays Erin McMahon Adrian Smith
Kenn & Mary Bates Ron Henderson Judy Mehlman Chuck Smith
Terry Berkbuegler Gail Henderson-King Robert Melnick SMITHGROUP
Haley & Shannon Blakeman Heritage landscapes Philip Meyer St. Louis Chapter of ASLA
Kerry Blind Megan Hester MIKO Susan Stainback
Bliss Landscape Architecture Gary Hilderbrand Elizabeth Miller Frederick Steiner
Pamela Blough Todd Hill Wendy Miller Kate Stickley
Bockholt, Inc. Alison Hirsch Kristie Milliman Biff Sturgess
BrightView Landscape Development Christina Hite MKSK Jack Sullivan
Kenneth Brooks Michael Holmes Devon Moody SUNY ESF
Gary Brown Scott Howard Thomas Mroz Surface678
Pamela Burton & Company Stephanie Hsia Tom Mroz Rodney Swink
CA Sierra Chapter Hydro Dramatics Ramon Murray Sylvatica Studio
Cal Poly Pomona ID Sculpture David Myers The Boston Architectural College
Matthew Carlile Iowa State University - Nina Claire Napawan The University of Pennsylvania
Torey Carter-Conneen Landscape Architecture Thomas Neiman Michael Thomasgard
Taewook Cha Susan Jacobson, FASLA Galen Newman Jennifer Toole
Circle V Landscape Architecture Steven Jensen Jennifer Nitzky Marq and Rachel Truscott
CLARB L KAMIN-LYNDGAARD Northeastern University, School UF Landscape Architecture
Colorado State University Susan Kenzle of Architecture UMASS Amherst - LARP Department
Orlando Comas Gary Kesler Michael O’Brien University of Arizona School of
Confluence, Inc. Steven Kikuchi OJB Landscape Architecture Landscape Architcture
Matthew Copp Madeline Kirschner OLIN Vectorworks, Inc.
Jennifer Cross SuLin Kotowicz Emily O’Mahoney Virginia Burt Designs, Inc.
Amy Cupples Chad Kucker Nancy Owens Washington University in St. Louis
Curtis + Rogers Design Studio Joy Kuebler Holley Owings Kristina Werenko
Damon Farber Landscape Architects Joel Kurokawa Ebru Ozer Carol Whipple
Tamas Deak Marieke Lacasse Robert Page Kevin White White
Chris Della Vedova LANDAU Design+Technology Michele Palmer Todd Wichman
Margaret Deming Maria Landoni Pamela Self Landscape Architecture Andrew Wickham
Design Workshop Foundation Landscape Forms Paul Miller Design, Inc. Ron Wigginton
Dickson Design Studio, Inc. LandscapeDE, LLC Penn State University Gretchen Wilson
Jim Donovan Lucy Lawliss Permaloc Corporation Woman’s Club of
DuMor, Inc Charlene LeBleu Douglas Pettay Washington University
dwg. Vanessa Lee PGAdesign Gary Worthley
Nord Eriksson Lee and Associates, Inc. Karen Phillips Jon Wreschinsky
Samantha Fajardo Liggett Design Group Victoria Phillipy Darsa Wright
Sandra Fischer Robert Loftis Pland Collaborative Bo Yang
Barbara Fles David Lorberbaum Philip Pregill Kongjian Yu
Flex MSE Jeanne Lukenda Nancy Prince Cindy Zerger
George Gentile David Lycke Marion Purvis
Green Roofs Olympia WA Petra Mager Resilience Studio As of 11/9/2023.
Greenways Incorporated Maglin Site Furniture Vaughn Rinner

The ASLA Fund is the 501(c)(3) charitable foundation of the American Society of Landscape Architects,
supported by the tax-deductible ASLA members contributions and other individuals and organizations, and
committed to the careful stewardship and artful design of our cultural and natural environment. To donate, visit aslafund.org.
ASLA is celebrating 125 years of
excellence, advocacy, and progress
in landscape architecture. We are
grateful for partners that support
our ongoing efforts to meet our
mission of healthy, beautiful, and
resilient places for all.
PHOTOGRAPHY
Lisa Hu Chen

78 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


DAVID RUBIN Land

On the occasion of the American Society of Landscape Architects’


125th anniversary, we offer our heartfelt thanks for the Society’s
contributions to advancing the art and science of our profession.
As a studio committed to empathy-driven design, Land Collective
extends our sincere appreciation for the ASLA’s advocacy on behalf
of this most important discipline — one that positively informs the
breadth of constituency, from intimate spaces to global systems.

Collective (215) 383-0540 | land-collective.com

125 YEARS OF ASLA LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 79


Grateful for every shared
moment since 1962.

Congratulations to ASLA for 125 years! We look back fondly over our shared memories
throughout these many years. Victor Stanley remains committed to our role as a corporate
member in the landscape architecture community. We appreciate the improvements you
make to the world we all share and are so thankful to be a part of it all.

V ICTOR STA N L EY.COM

80 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


ASLA_LAM_CnvrtFullPg_AnivsryAdJan24.indd 1 11/27/2023 3:10:58 PM

125 YEARS OF ASLA LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 81


82 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 125 YEARS OF ASLA
CONTRACT | H OSPITA LIT Y | SITE | RESIDENTIAL

Congratulations ASL A
on 125 years of leadership,
education, and advocacy.

F O R M O R E I N F O R M AT I O N O N O U R P L A N T E R S ,
C O N TA C T U S AT 8 0 0 . 2 8 9 . 8 3 2 5 O R C O U N T R YC A S U A LT E A K . C O M .

LAM_Ad 125th Anniversary.indd 2 11/30/2023 10:22:15 PM

125 YEARS OF ASLA LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 83


Congratulations to ASLA for an incredible 125 year legacy
of leadership, advocacy, and stewardship in advancing and
elevating the profession of landscape architecture.

Photo: John Durant Civita Park, San Diego, CA

Positive Change by Design Since 1983

LAM ASLA 2023 Half Page Ad 11.28.23.indd 1 11/28/2023 9:17:47 AM

CONGRATULATIONS

125 YEARS

125 YEARS OF ASLA LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 85


Freshkills Park
Staten Island, NY

NYC Parks congratulates


ASLA on its 125th anniversary
Mark Focht PLA, FASLA Adrian Smith PLA, FASLA
Nancy Prince PLA, FASLA Whitney Talcott PLA, FASLA

86 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 125 YEARS OF ASLA


CONGRATULATIONS
American Society of
Landscape Architects
on 125 years of excellence!
We Shape Public Spaces

Congratulations to the American Society


of Landscape Architects for 125 years of
support and advocacy for the profession!

www.REALMcollaborative.com
@realm_collaborative

125 YEARS OF ASLA LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 87


C o ng r a t s
ASLA
CELEBRATING 125 YEARS OF
ADVANCING THE FIELD OF
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE

From your friends at


See our projects at:

Making Magic Out of Water Since 1959

Save the date


for the L.A.R.E.
APRIL April 1-17, 2024
EXAM Register by March 25

AUGUST July 29-August 14, 2024


EXAM Register by July 22

DECEMBER December 2-18, 2024


EXAM Register by November 25

Council of
Landscape Architectural
Registration Boards

Congratulating our friends at ASLA


LEARN MORE
on 125 years of excellence! & REGISTER

88 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 125 YEARS OF ASLA


CONGRATULATIONS ASLA ON YOUR

125 TH YEAR ANNIVERSARY

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
Photo: Christopher Gannon/Iowa State University

CONGRATS,
ASLA!
Join us and ASLA leaders
on Feb 20 at 3 pm ET for:

ASLA at 125: Exploring the


Future of Landscape
Architecture

Register at olmsted.org!

Save the date for other 2024


Conversations with Olmsted webinars!
May 21 | August 20 | Nov 19

125 YEARS OF ASLA LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 89


90 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024
SHORELINE
CHANGE
THE BACK
OVER TIME
1850
1938
1985 Two-thirds of land has been lost since
1994 Tangier was first mapped in 1850,
primarily on once-inhabited Uppards
2007
2013
2020
2023

Repeated breakthrough of Mailboat Harbor is first dredged


seawater into Toms Gut in 1922, then again through
the west in 1967

Mile-long rock barrier


built in 1989 slows
western erosion

Littoral drift of southern


sand spit caused by
northwestern wave action

2023 HALS CHALLENGE WINNER:


Working Landscapes
As interest in labor movements and the cultural
role of work has increased over the past several
years, the Historic American Landscapes Survey is
right on trend with its 14th annual challenge. Titled
THE HISTORIC AMERICAN LANDSCAPES SURVEY, NATIONAL PARK
SERVICE, WILLIAM A. PACKWOOD AND LINCOLN L. LEWIS, 2023

Working Landscapes, the challenge asked for new


documentation of historic landscapes that concerned
agriculture, flood control, industry, or other interpre-
tations of the theme. Three winners were announced
in October, with first place awarded to Tangier Island
Watermen Working Landscape (shown here) in
Tangier, Virginia, by Lincoln L. Lewis and William A.
Packwood of the University of Virginia. The drawings
and historical reports will be archived at the Library
of Congress, where they will be freely available online
(www.loc.gov/pictures/collection/hh).

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 91


AN ELEGY
IN GRANITE

THE ALLEGORICAL ASSEMBLAGES OF THE


MARTIN LUTHER KING JR. MONUMENT.
BY KOFI BOONE, FASLA

PHOTOGRAPHY BY SAHAR COSTON-HARDY, AFFILIATE ASLA

92 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


I
’ve been to the Martin Luther
King Jr. Memorial in Washing-
ton, D.C., many times: day and
night, individually and in groups.
I’ve sat and watched groups as
they moved through the Mountain
of Despair sculpture, touched the
walls of quotes, and took selfies in
front of the Stone of Hope. I have
many friends and family who love the
memorial. The site works as a linear
narrative experience, and it does, in
scale, material, and level of detail, mir-
ror other memorials that share the
National Mall. Based upon how you
remember King, or how you want to
remember King, the memorial can
inspire or frustrate you. The King Me-
morial symbolizes the challenges that
come from the decision to either be a
part of a whole symbolic landscape
fabric or to be apart from it. Should a
memorial to a civil rights leader blend
in with memorials to people that in
some cases represent the opposite of
their interests and values?

The Martin Luther King Jr. Memorial


opened in 2011 and almost immedi-
ately sparked controversies including
site selection and the transformation

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 93


94 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024
of the original design into its final form. The me- This was intended to leverage the
morial’s development was rife with the challenges popularity of Martin Luther King
of reconciling competing visions of how to honor Jr.’s “I Have a Dream” speech, de-
the contributions of one of the most famous lead- livered on the steps of the Lincoln
ers of the modern civil rights movement. Now, Memorial in 1963. However, NCPC’s
more than a decade later, and in the midst of a recommendation was countered by
disciplinary rethinking of memorialization, the the U.S. Commission of Fine Arts,
King Memorial may offer insights to those facing an independent federal agency that
the challenge of interpreting contested memories advises on issues of design. Presum-
through public landscapes. ably the commission was concerned
with the potential scale of the King
The site, on the northwest corner of the Tidal Memorial and its visual impact on
Basin, was not the site originally proposed. The the experience of the Lincoln Me-
federal government’s planning entity for the D.C. morial. Instead, the Commission of
region, the National Capital Planning Commis- Fine Arts recommended the Tidal
sion (NCPC), proposed a location near Constitu- Basin site. Home to hundreds of
tion Gardens and closer to the Lincoln Memorial. cherry blossoms (which bloom in

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 95


“THIS IS OUR HOPE. THIS IS THE FAITH THAT I GO
BACK TO THE SOUTH WITH. WITH THIS FAITH,
WE WILL BE ABLE TO HEW OUT OF THE
MOUNTAIN OF DESPAIR A STONE OF HOPE.”
—MARTIN LUTHER KING JR.

early spring, near the date of King’s site] is the back of the bus again.” However, the
assassination), the Tidal Basin site site was eventually accepted.
could borrow the broader reflective
quality of the basin. It also had an The memorial visualizes key factors we associ-
implied connection to the National ate with Martin Luther King Jr. but also makes
Mall based on a line of sight between vague references to others. What is well-known
the Lincoln and Jefferson Memorials. and reflected most prominently in the aesthetic
But siting a memorial to a civil rights of the memorial is King’s legacy as one of Amer-
leader between someone who owned ica’s greatest mobilizers through public oratory.
enslaved African people (Jefferson) King’s excellence in deploying the Black theologi-
and someone who primarily signed cal tradition of allegory and metaphor as a means
the Emancipation Proclamation to of clarifying social injustice informed ROMA
destabilize the Confederacy (Lincoln) Design Group, the competition-winning team
was problematic. Arrington Dixon, that produced the original memorial design. The
an NCPC member at the time, said, team, which eventually included the Black-led
“There are too many things here that architectural firm McKissack and McKissack, de-
make me feel that [the Tidal Basin rived two of its most important conceptual design

96 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


cues from King’s “I Have a Dream”
speech: his metaphor describing the
legacy of America’s Jim Crow policies
as “the mountain of despair” and the
promise of a commitment to civil
rights as “a stone of hope.” The two
sculptures are carved from granite
and form the most massive and vis-
ible elements of the memorial. The
Mountain of Despair is split with an
opening that visually connects the
Lincoln Memorial to the Tidal Basin
and the Jefferson Memorial beyond
and to the procession through this
memorial site. The Stone of Hope,
from which a towering and scowling
figure of King emerges, sits slightly
off-center from the opening in the
Mountain of Despair. The position-
ing implies that the stone was moved
with effort from the mountain.

The memorial’s landscape plan is


based on the symmetrical layout of the
site plan. The diagonal line of sight
connecting the memorial to the Lin-
coln Memorial and the Jefferson Me-
morial features a tapered broad plaza,
paved in granite, which narrows to
the Mountain of Despair. A retain-
ing wall filled with layered plantings

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 97


rises as you move to the threshold, There appear to be traces in the final landscape
the cut through the mountain. After that are reminiscent of the allegory of rolling
proceeding through the narrow pas- streams. Arching granite retaining walls that
sage, the space opens to reveal the extend from the ground to seat-wall height
Stone of Hope and the expansive view on the north and south sides of the memorial
of the Tidal Basin beyond. An arched frame the memorial’s relationship to the Tidal
perpendicular space is revealed at this Basin edge. Two undulating islands between
point with two densely planted islands the basin edge and the wall form a variety of
framed by curved seat walls. Masses seating arrangements either facing the curv-
of grasses, shrubs, and flowering trees ing wall or located along narrower walkways
amplify the basic structure of the over-shaded by flowering trees. Oehme, van Sweden
all monument. The entire memorial and Associates Inc., the landscape architect
space is accessible, with no ramps, of record, did extensive work with the soil to
rails, or steps. support the growth of more than 180 newly
planted Yoshino cherry trees. The new plant-
While King’s contributions have ing adds to the memorial’s powerful visual
been well-documented, what is less and contextual connection to the Tidal Basin’s
celebrated is that the modern civil historic cherry trees.
rights movement included the work
of thousands of people—it was not The dark polished surfaces and sinuous forms
the work of one man. An original of the wall mimic waterways. The thick and
feature of the design concept was layered plantings on the memorial’s northern
the creation of garden seating areas side emulate rolling surfaces, perhaps rolling
to commemorate activists who were waters or hills that form the watersheds that
killed in the struggle for civil rights feed streams. The plantings’ mounded forms
freedom. These gardens were to be offer stark contrast to the straight walls leading
connected by water that would have to the Mountain of Despair. This experiential
collected and poured over a wall of interpretation of the design is strictly conjecture
quotes by King, visualizing a refer- on my part, and the lack of actual interpretation
ence to justice rolling down “like a for visitors is disappointing. ↘
mighty stream.”

98 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 99
100 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024
“WE WILL NOT BE SATISFIED UNTIL
JUSTICE ROLLS DOWN LIKE WATERS,
AND RIGHTEOUSNESS LIKE
A MIGHTY STREAM.”
—MARTIN LUTHER KING JR.

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 101


“WE SHALL OVERCOME
BECAUSE THE ARC OF
THE MORAL UNIVERSE
IS LONG, BUT IT BENDS
TOWARD JUSTICE.”
—MARTIN LUTHER KING JR.

→ The final elements of the memorial for the National Mall and Monument Lab recently
are a selection of King’s quotes pre- held an ideas competition with invited propos-
sented on the Stone of Hope as well als that speculate on the potential future of the
as two arching granite retaining walls. Tidal Basin. One theme that was pursued in all
The shape of the walls responds to the proposals was the impacts of climate change
another allegory used by King in his and the inevitable sinking of the National Mall.
“Remaining Awake Through a Great The National Mall, as we know it today, was built
Revolution” speech: “We shall over- on a floodplain and is slowly being reclaimed
come because the arc of the moral through settling, erosion, and flooding as ecologi-
universe is long, but it bends toward cal systems add dynamics to a currently statically
justice.” The wall includes selected designed landscape.
quotes from King’s speeches and is
illuminated at night. There are small Another recent effort was the Beyond Granite pilot
seating nooks facing the quotes in- project sponsored by the Trust for the National
tegrated into the retaining walls to Mall with support from the NCPC in 2022. This
enable groups to sit and reflect on effort invited artists to implement short-term
the words. Over multiple visits to monuments that challenged the typical narratives,
the site, I’ve observed that people domaterials, aesthetics, and visitor interactions we
pause and read the quotes. However, experience on the National Mall today. In a sense,
the quotes included in the memorial this initiative presents the possibilities of integrat-
are decidedly less critical than King’s
ing layers of cultural dynamics and change in a
most famous speeches, with only a setting that has been intentionally designed to be
few references to his “Three Evils of perceived as intransigent. For the King Memorial,
Society” speech from 1967. facing near-term climate-related risks, and lack-
ing explicit connections to the modern civil rights
Two recent efforts call into question movement, there may be opportunities to adapt
not only the future of this memorial and engage a broader range of public memory.
but our attitude about the nature
of the National Mall landscape as a KOFI BOONE, FASLA, IS THE JOSEPH D. MOORE DISTINGUISHED
PROFESSOR OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE AND ENVIRONMEN-
permanent setting for holding our TAL PLANNING AND A UNIVERSITY FACULTY SCHOLAR AT NORTH
national public memory. The Trust CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY.

102 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 103
THE BACK /
BOOKS EDITED BY MIMI ZEIGER

FLUX AND
CHANGE

THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:


SUSTAINABLE, RESILIENT,
AND EQUITABLE COMMUNITIES
FOR THE 21ST CENTURY
BY DAVID ROUSE AND ROCKY PIRO; LONDON AND NEW YORK:
ROUTLEDGE, 2022; 288 PAGES, $42.95.
REVIEWED BY FADI MASOUD

C omprehensive planning practice’s foundations and the


legal underpinnings of the planning profession are in-
separably linked to landscape architecture in North America.
munities for the 21st Century underscores this contemporary
relevancy, and the authors David Rouse, ASLA, and Rocky Piro
remind us of the significance of comprehensive planning in
At the turn of the last century, the social and environmental addressing today’s urban challenges.
fallouts brought on by the rapid expansion of cities across the
industrialized world necessitated the invention of legal and Straightforward, even clinical, The Comprehensive Plan reads like
spatial mechanisms to design and plan this unprecedented a resource manual for practitioners, bureaucrats, and academics.
urban growth. Frederick Law Olmsted Sr. and Jr., Charles Eliot, Broken into three large sections, its 17 chapters center issues of
John Nolen, and others took on the challenge of large-scale socioeconomic equity and climate change (including adaptation,
metropolitan park and parkway planning, suburban expansion, resilience, and mitigation) as cross-sectoral parameters for com-
and the complex foundations of urban governance. prehensive planning. “Sustainability, resilience, and equity—the
overarching themes of this book—are distinct but interrelated
In 1912, the American Society of Landscape Architects identi- concepts,” write Rouse and Piro. The authors push further on
fied 28 ongoing large-scale comprehensive plans in “A Brief these interdependencies as critically generative of schematic vi-
Survey of Recent City Planning Reports in the United States,” sions that are focused on “systems thinking,” something that has
which cemented the significance of landscape architects as long been relevant to the work of landscape architects. Unlike
the “comprehensive planners” of that era. More than a century rigid and static conceptions of urban form, a comprehensive plan
later, a drive toward holistic approaches to planning reasserts rooted in “systems” is aligned with how landscape architects prac-
the agency of landscape architects to take on that charge. The tice if their work is to be successfully integrated with dynamic,
Comprehensive Plan: Sustainable, Resilient, and Equitable Com- and often indeterminate, natural systems.

104 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


WHEN LESS IS
MORE
architectural refinement and craftsmanship matter

Product: Regular Joe 9” x 20” Heel Proof Trench Grates


Material: Raw Cast Ductile Iron
Design: Field Operations
Project: Domino Park
Location: New York, NY

decorative grates, site furnishings and custom castings


IRONAGEGRATES.COM
info@ironagegrates.com | 877-418-3568
THE BACK /BOOKS

RIGHT
Locations of 21st-century
comprehensive plans.
North America’s vast
and heterogeneous
geography offers
opportunities and
challenges.

Landscape architects played ings address themes that include “Natural


critical roles in shaping plan- Systems,” “Built Environment Systems: Mo-
ning in the early part of the 20th bility and Infrastructure,” “Social Systems,”
century, and they should now. For exam- and “Regional Connections.” Each presents a
ple, Frederick Law Olmsted Jr.’s influence on land use zoning list of carefully selected case studies; examples of best practices,
was undeniable. He was part of an advisory committee appointed tables, charts, and summaries; and guides on policy directions
by Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover in 1921 that drafted and applications.
A Zoning Primer, and he was the only member listed under the
professional designation of landscape architect. The document The authors put forward a multifaceted yet concise survey
defined the role of zoning in cities, its benefits, and how it should while focusing on the conditions, concerns, and opportunities
be applied. When advocating for a role for landscape architects that make up the substance of a contemporary comprehensive
in an era of a possible Green New Deal, Billy Fleming, in a 2019 plan. In line with their appeal to blend systems thinking into
essay for Places Journal, reminds us that in the early 20th century, the progression of 21st-century comprehensive planning,
urbanists and designers “entered public service, fighting for they assert that each of the chapters “incorporate a systems
housing justice, land conservation, and environmental resource approach as an alternative to the 20th-century practice of orga-
management at all levels of government.” nizing the comprehensive.” For example, the chapter “Natural
Systems” posits that “the built and natural environments are
Olmsted Jr. understood the value of ecological land use comple- not separate and discrete” but instead are interconnected with
mentation, promoting the synergistic interaction between “intersecting subsystems.” They press on the need to design
natural features, green space, and land use zoning. In his and plan the built environment by aligning it with the condi-
view, planning and its tools should not result in a centralized tions and capacities of its underlying environment. “Natural
“end-state vision” but a continually evolving process. In reports features such as slopes, soils, watersheds, and vegetation
written between 1905 and 1915, he urged professionals and continue to exist, even if altered or degraded by urban devel-
policymakers to understand the city plan not as a rigid set of opment,” they write. “Healthy, functioning natural systems
DAVID ROUSE, ASLA, AND ROCKY PIRO
instructions to be followed by successive generations but as integrated with the built environment are essential to support
an “organic, flexible document capable of responding to new healthy, sustainable communities.”
conditions and evolving over time.”
The book is filled with planning definitions, descriptions, and
The Comprehensive Plan echoes this premise in the second sec- language, and noticeably evident are the American Planning
tion, “The Substance of the Plan,” which makes up the bulk of Association (APA) national standards for guiding the creation
the book and is the longest and most detailed. The chapter head- and implementation of comprehensive plans. While this lends

106 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


THE BACK /BOOKS

PROFESSIONAL STANDARDIZATION
OF DEFINITIONS CAN FLATTEN DIVERSE
SOCIAL, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND
PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHIES.

the book an accessible, clear, and universal tone, it also renders Zoning Enabling Act (SZEA) and in 1928 with the Standard
the text rather monotonous. For example, when the definition City Planning Enabling Act (SCPEA). The SCPEA called for
of low-density residential zoning or open space provisions is zoning codes to conform to a larger, and more holistic, com-
invoked, a more replicable model is envisioned by the authors. prehensive plan. Yet the landmark 1926 Village of Euclid v.
Such universal planning language makes it difficult to de- Ambler Realty Co. Supreme Court case and the passing of the
scribe, for example, how open space for housing varies in the SZEA effectively enshrined land use separation and zoning,
arid Southwest versus the temperate Northeast, or an equity- not comprehensive planning, as the first act of planning. This
deserving community versus a wealthier established one. Even allowed states to enact laws permitting cities to establish a zon-
though the book cites comprehensive plans from across the ing commission before devising long-range comprehensive
United States, its aspirational national reach makes it difficult plans. The lag between the legislations resulted in planning
to emphasize the varying particularities of local geographies, commissions resorting to zoning as the primary device for
voices, and places across this vast and heterogeneous continent. drawing up plans. Thus zoning, not comprehensive planning,
Professional standardization of descriptions and definitions of- became the immediate legislative spatial blueprint for the
ten lends itself to the flattening of diverse social, environmental, development of cities.
and physical geographies.
Climate change has rendered visible the shortcomings of such
Governments often produce rigorous studies, reports, and overly deterministic and static plans, zoning codes, and devel-
plans with limited pathways to implementation. This is often opment models. Contemporary urban adaptation and resilient
due to a lack of robust and broad partnerships, community design strategies favor scenario-driven design schemes that
engagement, and investments. To that end, “While contem- account for multiple possible futures and a range of uncertain-
porary plans have more robust implementation sections, they ties. For example, the design and allocation of open space buf-
often consist of lists of unprioritized actions,” note the authors. fers should accommodate a range of inundation levels while
“Effective plans are comprehensive and visionary in their scope allowing multiple programmatic activities to take place at the
and reach, as well as strategic, focused, and adaptable in their same time. Such spatial and programmatic flexibility is often
approach to implementation.” at odds with the overly deterministic, reductive, and restrictive
nature of land use zoning codes.
A glaring omission in the book is a critical discussion on the
legislative power of land use zoning codes in shaping the ur- Rouse and Piro explore how comprehensive planning should
ban fabric. In many ways, zoning is a much more formidable accommodate scenario planning to “generate and evaluate
force toward implementation than comprehensive planning. possible futures to frame choices and inform community
The legal mechanisms that continue to underpin planning decision-making...given the uncertainty of future change
today were established in 1926 through the Standard State over the long-range time horizon of the plan, which suggests

108 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Determine the Value of Trees with
The Guide for Plant Appraisal.
The Guide for Plant Appraisal, 10th
Edition, Revised is the most informative
and comprehensive alignment of current
knowledge of the approaches, processes, and
methods of plant valuation.

Included in this edition are detailed


discussions of newly streamlined core concepts
and terminology, a review of the organization
and context of appraisal reports, and an
updated emphasis on appraiser awareness
of the environmental and ecological benefits
plants provide. Also new to this edition are
appendices and a glossary. (Revised October
2020, softcover, 170 pp)

Scan the QR code below for more on how to


purchase the print or digital edition.

isa-arbor.com/store
THE BACK /BOOKS

WHILE ARDUOUS TO CONCEIVE


AND IMPLEMENT, IT
IS ESSENTIAL THAT
WE FOREGROUND
HOLISTIC AND
COMPREHENSIVE
APPROACHES TO
URBAN PLANNING.

that communities should er varies, the scope of their


prepare for and adapt to application must expand or
a range of possible future contract to meet the new and
outcomes.” A section titled different conditions which
“Accounting for Uncertainty” are constantly coming within
RIGHT presents this critical approach the field of their operation. In a
Nonlinear systems to dynamic, nonlinear scenario changing world, it is impossible
essential for the design planning as a prerequisite for that it should be otherwise.”
of landscapes are
climate adaptation and resilience
equally critical when
applied to planning. planning and design. Here, the au- Rouse and Piro attempt to exhaus-
thors discuss a “Cone of Uncertainty” tively and thoroughly uncover the pa-
that plots time against short-, medium-, and rameters and interdependencies needed to
long-term decisions, tactics, strategies, and visions comprehensively “plan” sustainable, resilient, and
that are interrupted by unforeseen “drivers of change.” equitable communities. Although the book relies on case stud-
ies to highlight local specificities, an approach rooted in the
Scenario planning and accounting for some degree of uncer- environmental and social particularities of a place is crucial.
tainty are consistent with how Olmsted Jr. saw comprehensive While it might seem arduous to conceive, and even harder to
planning, much like he did landscape architecture, as a “dy- implement, large-scale visions in the 21st century, it is essential
namic and continuous process.” He was interested in tactical and that we foreground holistic and comprehensive approaches to
strategic approaches to shaping the city in relation to its social, urban planning. Designers and educators must advocate for
environmental, and governance contexts. His approach was also a role for landscape architects in outlining climate adaptation
in line with critiques of modern-era top-down comprehensive and resilience planning frameworks through enduring legisla-
planning. “The nature of the city was flux and change,” writes tive structures. This agency is only possible if we expand and
the anthropologist and political scientist James Scott in his 1999 strengthen our direct engagement and collaboration with the
book, Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the planning profession and the public agencies of communities at
DAVID ROUSE, ASLA, AND ROCKY PIRO
Human Condition Have Failed. “The best a planner can hope the forefront of the climate crisis. This book serves as a timely
for is to modestly enhance rather than impede the development reminder, reaffirming our capacity and urging us to advance
of urban complexity,” he continues. The ability to plan compre- the discourse on comprehensive planning.
hensively while proactively anticipating flexibility in writing up
zoning ordinances is consistent with what Supreme Court Justice FADI MASOUD IS AN ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR OF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
George Sutherland wrote in the majority opinion for Euclid v. AND URBANISM AND DIRECTOR OF THE CENTRE FOR LANDSCAPE RESEARCH AT
THE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO.
Ambler: “[W]hile the meaning of constitutional guaranties nev-

110 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Defining the
profession of
sustainable
landscape
development.
Used by landscape architects and
others to align land development
and management with innovative
sustainable design. Demonstrate
your expertise and become a
SITES Accredited Professional.

Learn more at sustainablesites.org

SITES-certified Phipps’ Center for Sustainable


Landscapes, Pittsburgh, PA
THE BACK /BOOKS

BOOKS
OF INTEREST

LESSONS IN RESILIENCE FROM


OLD TREES, NEW PARKS, AND
FUTURE INFRASTRUCTURES.

OLMSTED TREES HOW INFRASTRUCTURE WORKS:


BY STANLEY GREENBERG; MUNICH: INSIDE THE SYSTEMS THAT
HIRMER PUBLISHERS, 2022; 160 SHAPE OUR WORLD
PAGES, $40.
BY DEB CHACHRA; NEW YORK:
RIVERHEAD BOOKS, 2023;
320 PAGES, $29.
The photographer Stanley Greenberg
takes pictures of old trees. Specifi-
cally, the magnificent elms, beech- MERGING CITY AND NATURE: A materials scientist and engineer
es, and maples planted more than 30 COMMITMENTS TO COMBAT digs into the complex technologi-
a century ago in parks designed by CLIMATE CHANGE cal services that make up the built
Frederick Law Olmsted. For Olmsted BY BATLLEIROIG; BARCELONA: ACTAR environment—roads, electricity,
Trees, he traveled across the country PUBLISHERS, 2023; 358 PAGES, $44.95. reservoirs—and finds that these ev-
to take what he calls “portraits” of eryday systems are as much social
their wrinkled, gnarled, and weath- The Spanish firm Batlleiroig works as they are technological. They are
ered trunks. He captures the play of across urbanism, landscape architec- shared utilities, after all. While How
time on civic landscapes: in Chero- ture, and architecture, traversing and Infrastructure Works isn’t explicit in
kee Park in Louisville, Kentucky, a combining disciplines on each project. addressing landscape architecture,
sycamore fused with a brick wall; Its new book is part monograph and Deb Chachra’s chapter “Infrastruc-
lovers’ carvings tattoo a beech in Cad- part battle cry in the face of climate ture and Climate Instability” outlines
walader Park in Trenton, New Jersey. emergency. Each of the 30 case studies case studies where climatic condi-
The black-and-white images evoke addresses a different approach, includ- tions such as rising sea levels, storm
empathy for these stoic beings. As ing “Biodiversity,” “Green Life Cycle,” surges, and hotter temperatures are
the journalist Kevin Baker writes in “Recycling,” and “Self-Sufficiency.” undermining existing systems. These
one of the three essays in the book, These are prefaced by a trio of conver- are places where the collective tools
“[T]hrough Greenberg’s lens we react sations with experts and academics, in- of landscape architecture could steer
to them almost as though they were cluding landscape architecture faculty visions away from the postapocalyptic
human, or animals.” Clara Olóriz Sanjuán (Architectural and toward resilience.
Association School of Architecture)
and Joan Batlle (Universitat Politècnica
de Catalunya), whose dialogue situ-
ates landscape as a mediator between
people and nature.

112 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


The Cultural Landscape Foundation ®
presents

Claude Cormier
Oral History

View an excerpt and learn more


about the forthcoming Pioneers
Oral History featuring the late
Canadian designer of Sugar Beach,
Love Park, The Ring, and other
landscape architecture icons.

Learn More:
tclf.org/cormier-oral-history
Photo @ Will Lew, courtesy CCxA.

Julie Bargmann Oral History


More than two dozen video segments cover
the life, career, and design philosophy of
this enigmatic practitioner and inaugural
Oberlander Prize laureate.

tclf.org/bargmann-oral-history

Sponsors

Julie Bargmann The Hubbard Michael Van Valkenburgh


Educational Foundation Associates

Photo by Barrett Doherty.


Thank You to our Corporate Members
for their contributions to the success of ASLA and the
landscape architecture profession.

GOLD MEMBERS

Carlsbad Manufacturing Corporation Old Town Fiberglass, Inc. Vectorworks, Inc.


David Harber, Ltd. Renson VESTRE
Graber Manufacturing, Inc. Skyland USA, LLC Walpole Outdoors, LLC
Green Theory Design Sure-Loc Edging, Inc.
Kafka Granite, LLC Unilock

SILVER MEMBERS

Archatrak ForeverLawn Puget Sound Sika Corporation


ASL Stone GreenBlue Urban America, Inc. South Coast Wholesale
Basalite Building Products - Epic Plastics IZone Imaging The Chandler Company
Botton+ Gardiner LiveRoof Global, LLC US Composting Council
Everde Growers Lombardo Landscaping & Water Features, Inc. Vortex Aquatic Structures International
Fine Concrete Rain Bird Corporation Watertronics
Focus Industries, Inc. Rochester Concrete Products

STANDARD MEMBERS
American Meadows, Inc. Meyer Landscape Architecture, LLC Spruce & Gander, Inc.
Bay Area Concretes, Inc. Montana Fire Pits Stone Curators
Buell Recreation Naturcycle SYNLawn
Circle Redmont Newstone Group Tabbystone
CMM Custom Homes Ore Designs, Inc. The Lighthouse Group
CORE Landscape Ramo Group, Inc. The Organic Recycler
Dal-Tile Corporation RGS Landscape and Arbor Care The PlayWell Group. Inc.
GraniteScape USA, Inc. Rock & Rose Landscapes The Prestwick Companies
Hoffman Nursery, Inc. Rock Pros USA Third Degree Recreaton
Holcim Inc SCI Lighting Solutions Turf Etc. LLC DBA Synlawn
Huatan Landscaping, LLC Sealturf Grass!365 Vak Pak, Inc.
Intermarket Insurance Agency SED Landscape Architects Ltd. Wade Architectural Systems
ISiMAR Shanghai Xian Dai Architectural Decoration West Coast Turf
Junction Landscape & Construction & Landscape Design Research Institute WholeTrees Structures
LumberCon LLC Shenzhen Water Planning & Design Zoom Recreation, Inc.
MDT Mueller Design, Inc. Institute

*Members as of 11/10/23
PLATINUM MEMBERS
FF PARTITION WALL SYSTEMS
www.formandfiber.com | tel. 888-314-8852 | sales@formandfiber.com

116 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


Problem Solved...
“Thanks again for all of your help - this felt like
a huge success for us due to your help with the
design and expediting the production.”
Angie Hulsebus, PLA
Director of Landscape Architecture
Denver Area Operation

In June 2020, the City of Superior, CO approved a


bridge extending Marshall Road and connecting its
northern neighborhoods to downtown. The design
and planters needed to reflect the area’s beauty.
The deadline to construct and ship the planters
was tight. There was a worldwide pandemic.

Call or visit us today at 714–979–4212 TheChandlerCompany.com


© The Chandler Company, Inc. Made in the USA

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 117


Catch the Sunshine!

Greenhouses |Custom Enclosures


Equipment | Supplies

www.GothicArchGreenhouses.com 1-800-531-GROW (4769)

CREATING FOG WORLDWIDE SINCE 1978

Atomizing Systems

201.447.1222 | www.coldfog.com | info@coldfog.com

118 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


M AILBOXES C OMMERCIAL
& R ESIDENTIAL

Visit us online at mailboxes.com Salsbury Industries


18300 Central Ave, Carson, CA 90746-4008

Landscape Architects
Trim: 8” x 4.5’”

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 119


Sticking Up for Picking Up

Our Best Selling


Waste Station
#1003-L

#1402

SMART Litter Pick Up Bags

#1404

SMART Liner Trash Bags

Contact Us Today! 800.364.7681 DOGIPOT.COM

Show your support for landscape architects


Join the ASLA Founders Club!
The ASLA Fund and the Founders Club members are continuing the commitment through the recurring giving program that
allows the ASLA Fund to continue our mission of investing in global, social, and environmental change through the art
and science of landscape architecture.

Your ongoing contribution to the Founders Club supports the ASLA Climate Action Plan, MineCraft and Dream Big with
Design, Women of Color Licensure Advancement Program, sending students to the conference, and more!

ASLA Fund | Bringing awareness to the profession.


Join the Founders Club with any of the following gifts and receive special member benefits:

$18.99 monthly $189.99 quarterly $1899 annually

For more information or to join, visit aslafund.org.


The ASLA Fund is the 501(c)(3) charitable foundation of the American Society of Landscape Architects, supported by the tax-deductible ASLA members contributions
and other individuals and organizations, and committed to the careful stewardship and artful design of our cultural and natural environment.

Half page ad Founders Club.indd 1 7/20/2023 10:34:32 AM

120 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


π Most
Dependable
LANDSCAPING
ESSENTIALS Fountains,
Inc.™

ORDER BY 6 PM FOR
SAME DAY SHIPPING
and
so
GLOVES much
more!

Most Dependable Fountains, Inc.™


901-867-0039
TRASH CANS BURLAP ROLLS GAS CANS www.mostdependable.com

COMPLETE CATALOG 1-800-295-5510 uline.com

9/1/2023 2:14:32 PM

PROFESSIONAL
PRACTICE
NETWORKS

ASLA offers 20 Professional Practice Networks


(PPNs) – national platforms for networking and
exchanging information on specific topics.

Find your interest area and join for free!

www.asla.org/PPN.aspx

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 121


THE BACK /ADVERTISER INDEX
ADVERTISER WEBSITE PHONE PAGE #
ADVERTISING SALES APE Studio c/o Richter Spielgeräte apeoriginal.com 212-213-6694 56
636 Eye Street NW Archatrak, Inc. archatrak.com 406-551-7482 107
Washington, DC 20001-3736 ASLA Corporate Membership advertise.asla.org/CM 202-216-2326 114-115
202-216-2363 ASLA EXPO Promotion advertise.asla.org/expo 202-216-2326 130-131
202-478-2190 Fax
ASLA Fund aslafund.org 202-216-2366 76
sales@asla.org
Atomizing Systems, Inc. coldfog.com 888-265-3364 118
SENIOR PRODUCTION Axis Lighting axislighting.com 514-948-6272 119
MANAGER BCI Burke Co. Inc. bciburke.com 920-921-9220 25, 128
Laura L. Iverson Berliner berliner-playequipment.com 864-627-1092 33, 125
202-216-2341 Campania International, Inc. campaniainternational.com 215-541-4627 C2-1, 124
liverson@asla.org
Cell-Tek Geosynthetics, LLC celltekdirect.com 410-721-4844 128
Columbia Cascade Company timberform.com 800-547-1940 125, 127, 129, C4
DeepStream Designs deepstreamdesigns.com 305-857-0466 117
Dogipot, a PlayCore company dogipot.com 800-364-7681 120
Doty & Sons Concrete Products dotyconcrete.com 800-233-3907 126
DuMor, Inc. dumor.com 800-598-4018 31, 128
Earthscape earthscapeplay.com 877-269-2972 51, 126
Ernst Conservation Seeds ernstseed.com 800-873-3321 124
Form and Fiber formandfiber.com 888-314-8852 116, 127
Forms+Surfaces forms-surfaces.com 800-451-0410 7, 124
Freenotes Harmony Park freenotesharmonypark.com 833-262-1569 14
Gothic Arch Greenhouses gothicarchgreenhouses.com 251-471-5238 118
Green Theory Design Inc. greentheorydesign.com 604-475-7002 124
Gyms For Dogs - Natural Dog Park Products gymsfordogs.com 800-931-1462 127
Hanover Architectural Products, Inc. hanoverpavers.com 717-637-0500 47
Huntco Supply, LLC huntco.com 503-224-8700 39
Iron Age Designs ironagegates.com 206-276-0925 105, 126
Ironsmith, Inc. ironsmith.biz 800-338-4766 37, 129
Landscape Forms landscapeforms.com 800-430-6205 11, 23
Landscape Structures, Inc. playlsi.com 888-438-6574 17, 127
Madrax madrax.com 800-448-7931 128
Maglin Site Furniture Inc. maglin.com 800-716-5506 35
mmcité street furniture mmcite.com 704-576-2224 2-3
Most Dependable Fountains mostdependable.com 800-552-6331 121
Nitterhouse Masonry Products, LLC nitterhouse.com 717-267-4500 41
Paloform paloform.com 888-823-8883 9
Permaloc Aluminum Edging permaloc.com 800-356-9660 55, 128
Petersen Concrete Leisure Products petersenmfg.com 800-832-7383 121
Pine Hall Brick Co., Inc. americaspremierpaver.com 800-334-8689 53, 128
Proven Winners® ColorChoice® provenwinners.com 800-633-8859 43
Public Restroom Company publicrestroomcompany.com 888-888-2060 116
Riverside Plastics, Inc. riverside-plastics.com 800-493-4945 129
Salsbury Industries mailboxes.com 800-624-5269 119, 129
Shade Systems, Inc. shadesystemsinc.com 800-609-6066 13
Sitecraft site-craft.com 800-221-1448 27
Sitescapes, Inc. sitescapesonline.com 402-421-9464 125
Soil Retention Products soilretention.com 760-966-6090 120
Solistone solistone.com 800-758-2119 129
Streetlife streetlife.nl 646-583-2937 45
Sure-Loc Aluminum Edging surelocedging.com 800-787-3562 128
The Belden Brick Co. beldenbrick.com 330-456-0031 81, 125
The Chandler Company thechandlercompany.com 714-979-4212 117
The Cultural Landscape Foundation tclf.org 202-483-0553 113
Thomas Steele thomas-steele.com 800-448-7931 46
Tournesol Siteworks tournesolsiteworks.com 800-542-2282 21, 128
Uline uline.com 800-295-5571 121
Unilock, Ltd. unilock.com 416-646-3452 29
U.S. Green Building Council usgbc.org 202-552-1369 111
Victor Stanley, Inc. victorstanley.com 301-855-8300 126, C3

122 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


THE BACK /ADVERTISERS BY PRODUCT CATEGORY
ASSOCIATION/FOUNDATION PARKS AND RECREATION PLANTS/SOILS/PLANTING MATERIALS

ASLA Corporate Membership 202-216-2326 114-115 APE Studio c/o Richter Spielgeräte 212-213-6694 56 Archatrak, Inc. 406-551-7482 107

ASLA EXPO Promotion 202-216-2326 130-131 BCI Burke Co. Inc. 920-921-9220 25, 128 Ernst Conservation Seeds 800-873-3321 124

ASLA Fund 202-216-2366 76 Berliner 864-627-1092 33, 125 Proven Winners® ColorChoice® 800-633-8859 43

The Cultural Landscape Foundation 202-483-0553 113 Dogipot, a PlayCore company 800-364-7681 120

U.S. Green Building Council 202-552-1369 111 Earthscape 877-269-2972 51, 126 STREET FURNISHINGS
Freenotes Harmony Park 833-262-1569 14 Columbia Cascade Company 800-547-1940 125, 127,

BUSINESS SERVICES Gyms For Dogs - 800-931-1462 127 129, C4

Uline 800-295-5571 121 Natural Dog Park Products Doty & Sons Concrete Products 800-233-3907 126

Landscape Structures, Inc. 888-438-6574 17, 127 DuMor, Inc. 800-598-4018 31, 128

DRAINAGE AND EROSION Public Restroom Company 888-888-2060 116 Forms+Surfaces 800-451-0410 7, 124

Cell-Tek Geosynthetics, LLC 410-721-4844 128 Huntco Supply, LLC 503-224-8700 39

Iron Age Designs 206-276-0925 105, 126 PAVING/SURFACING/MASONRY STONE/METALS Landscape Forms 800-430-6205 11, 23

Ironsmith, Inc. 800-338-4766 37, 129 Hanover Architectural Products, Inc. 717-637-0500 47 Madrax 800-448-7931 128

Nitterhouse Masonry Products, LLC 717-267-4500 41 Maglin Site Furniture Inc. 800-716-5506 35

GREEN ROOFS/LIVING WALLS Pine Hall Brick Co., Inc. 800-334-8689 53, 128 mmcité street furniture 704-576-2224 2-3

greenscreen 800-450-3494 41, 208 Soil Retention Products 760-966-6090 120 Petersen Concrete Leisure Products 800-832-7383 121

Solistone 800-758-2119 129 Salsbury Industries 800-624-5269 119, 129

LIGHTING The Belden Brick Co. 330-456-0031 81, 125 Sitecraft 800-221-1448 27

Axis Lighting 514-948-6272 119 Unilock, Ltd. 416-646-3452 29 Sitescapes, Inc. 402-421-9464 125

Streetlife 646-583-2937 45

LUMBER/DECKING/EDGING PLANTERS/SCULPTURES/GARDEN ACCESSORIES Thomas Steele 800-448-7931 46


Permaloc Aluminum Edging 800-356-9660 55, 128 Campania International, Inc. 215-541-4627 C2-1, 124 Victor Stanley, Inc. 301-855-8300 126, C3

Sure-Loc Aluminum Edging 800-787-3562 128 DeepStream Designs 305-857-0466 117

Form and Fiber 888-314-8852 116, 127 STRUCTURES

OUTDOOR FIRE AND WATER FEATURES Green Theory Design Inc. 604-475-7002 124 Gothic Arch Greenhouses 251-471-5238 118

Most Dependable Fountains 800-552-6331 121 Riverside Plastics, Inc. 800-493-4945 129 Shade Systems, Inc. 800-609-6066 13

Paloform 888-823-8883 9 The Chandler Company 714-979-4212 117

Tournesol Siteworks 800-542-2282 21, 128 WATER MANAGEMENT AND AMENITIES

Atomizing Systems, Inc. 888-265-3364 118

LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024 / 123


ASLA SPONSORED CONTENT

MINNEAPOLIS
CONFERENCE AND EXPO
A SHOW OF PROGRESS
AND TRENDS
The strong attendance and large showing of
exhibitors at the 2023 ASLA Conference and
EXPO are good signs for 2024—with technology
and fitness making noteworthy gains.
BY RUSS K LET TKE

Executive Summary

▶ Landscape architecture The EXPO is a two-way street, with attendees


achieves elevated stature and learning from exhibitors and vice versa.
Photo by ASLA
increased demand.

▶ Climate action advances with help


from industry partners.
ASLA CEO Torey Carter-Conneen shared in Carter-Conneen also credited the ASLA Climate
his keynote address that landscape architecture Action Committee for achieving measurable
▶ Technology and fitness is now recognized by the federal government progress toward its goals, “advancing this work
exhibitors offer new tools for as a STEM discipline. This acknowledges the by increasing its collaboration with vendors and
profession’s long-standing expertise in hydrology, product manufacturers through the newly formed
landscape architects.
drainage, grading, environmental science, ASLA Corporate Member Committee,” he said.
horticulture, and site design—disciplines that “Industry partners are key players to reducing

I
f the 2023 ASLA Conference on Landscape can fight climate change, increase demand for the embodied emissions from landscape architecture
Architecture and EXPO in Minneapolis is profession, and bolster compensation. He cited projects and helping scale up sequestration.”
any indicator, 2024 is going to be a time research coming out of landscape architecture
for rapid discovery and growth in the industry p r o g r a m s a t Au b u r n U n ive r s i t y, P u r d u e Technology increasingly important in landscape
and profession. University, Michigan State University, and architecture
Texas A&M—plus academic leaders working with
The numbers tell part of the story. There were grants from the ASLA Fund— that contribute to At least two categories of exhibitors—technology
more than 5,200 registered attendees and 250 progress in what landscape architecture can do. and outdoor fitness—increased their numbers on
exhibitors, defying notions that an autumn meeting It includes such things as using AI and machine the EXPO floor in 2023.
in the upper Midwest might fail to attract strong learning, and ways to address the biodiversity
participation. Exhibitors tell us their interactions crisis and urban disaster resilience. This will Chris Landau, principal at LANDAU Design+
with landscape architects provided fruitful dialog continue to elevate the profession and its work Technology, which provides tools (e.g., Land
on what’s possible now and where new ideas and with policymakers, community groups, allied Kit) to landscape architects using computation
products might be welcome in the future. professionals, and the public. in their design work, found it beneficial to meet
ASLA SPONSORED CONTENT

in person is a real pleasure,” says Gronquist. Her


observation was that sessions and events on the
EXPO floor enhanced the experience. “I was able to
attend more sessions and see friends on the design
side frequently during the day. There’s no substitute
for coming together in the same place.”

Outdoor fitness a growing industry

The pandemic drove a surge of installations of


outdoor fitness equipment, a trend that continues
according to Recreation Management magazine.
“Some communities tout the ability for adults to
use the fitness zones adjacent to the playgrounds so
they can keep their kids in sight,” says one article,
which also reports the American Society of Sports
Medicine’s market research shows outdoor exercise
as their number 6 trend in 2023, up from number
17 in 2019.

Present in Minneapolis on the EXPO floor were


seven purveyors of this kind of equipment and
playing surfaces—including Gyms for Dogs, a
crowd pleaser—the most ever at an ASLA event.
Jenny Lewis, vice president of sales and marketing
for Outdoor-Fit Exercise Systems, notes they
returned for their second year with ASLA because
the conference broadens their exposure to markets.
“Landscape architects grow our awareness of new
applications,” she says. “That includes multifamily
with landscape architects at their booth and other Longtime exhibitor Vectorworks promotes housing, senior centers, and high-rise rooftops.
exhibitors. “The folks who attend are very serious the benefits of working with BIM for landscape Attendees tell me new product information on
about their work,” he observed. “There were so solutions, particularly in how it “fosters the EXPO floor adds a lot to what they learn in
many great sessions and things to do and see, and collaboration across multiple disciplines,” says educational sessions.”
not enough time to see them all. It really is an Laura Bucci, marketing specialist. “Our biggest
embarrassment of riches.” takeaway from Minneapolis was attendees’ insights Other companies with exhibits in this niche
into how landscape architects and other site design were Greenfields Outdoor Fitness, Trekfit,
Representatives f rom another technology professionals benefit from technologies that include Agorespace SAS, Envirotech Outdoor, and Target
exhibitor, Environment for Revit, talked AI, AR/VR, and drone scanning in their day-to- Technologies. Several of the children’s playground
about the growing importance of landscape day design workflows. They can be proactive in suppliers (Landscape Structures, PlayCore, BCI
architects being technologically in sync with their projects as they combat climate change and Burke, Kompan, etc.) have divisions or partners
project partners. “It’s gratifying to witness this
remarkable discipline embrace BIM technology,
advocate for better landscape performance with
intelligent design and analysis tools.”
in adult outdoor fitness as well. ■
closing the technological gap with the rest of the
AEC industry,” says Yotam Ashkenazi, chief Making a first-time appearance at the ASLA EXPO
marketing officer for the firm. “The enthusiasm was SGLA Technical Training and chief instructor
for adopting innovative solutions was truly Sarah Gronquist, CA PLA. An educational entity,
inspiring.” Based in Israel, it was the company’s SGLA prepares budding landscape architects for
second year with ASLA. “The event allowed us to the Landscape Architect Registration Examination
gather invaluable feedback and insights directly (LARE). “Most of our work takes place through No endorsement of products or suppliers mentioned is
from our American clientele.” remote Zoom meetings so getting to meet people intended or implied.
THE BACK /
BACKSTORY
TOPOPHYLA’S EXPLORATIONS IN AI
HEAD DOWN THE GARDEN PATH.
The fascinating thing about this one is that it kind of does look like the finished project,
and the layering of the plants is pretty appropriate. The context trees are actually fairly
accurate. I don’t know how it got that there were conifers in the background, but it did.
—ERIC ARNESON

ERIC ARNESON AT TOPOPHYLA. IMAGE GENERATED BY CHATGPT-4.

E ric Arneson likes to play with new technol-


ogy. Along with Nahal Sohbati, Arneson
is one-half of Topophyla Landscape Design, a
where he shares the firm’s design
process through a mix of rapid-fire
tutorials, memes, and AI-generated
playing around with planting plans.
He uploaded a screenshot of a plan
from a finished project, and after a
California-based design firm, but he’s probably images. The recent addition of a mul- few tries, he got the image above—
better known online as @pangeaexpress, the timodal feature to OpenAI’s chatbot, hypervivid, but not too far off from the
95K-followers-and-counting Instagram account ChatGPT, prompted Arneson to start real thing.

132 / LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE MAGAZINE JAN 2024


US Patent D904,712 S.

Connecting since 1962.


T H E S T E L L A O F S U N N E™ C O L L E C T I O N .

Celebrating over 60 years, Victor Stanley designs, engineers and manufactures timeless site furnishings so you can
bring communities to life. Our Stella of Sunne collection features a classic, minimalist look inspired by Scandinavian

design aesthetics. Its eased edges and clean lines transform any environment into a comfortable and inviting space.

V ICTOR STA N L EY.COM


TimberForm
®

“The first name in wood for play”


SM

www.TimberForm.com
1-800/547-1940 | asla@timberform.com

You might also like