Professional Documents
Culture Documents
11 Chapter 2
11 Chapter 2
The first generation derivatives of ART are some successful drugs that have been
found effective against multi-drug resistant P. falciparum malaria. These drugs are
used to treat uncomplicated and complicated (P. falciparum and P. vivax) cases of
resistant malaria. They represent a novel class of antimalarial drugs and their
pharmacokinetics of the parent, naturally occurring ART molecule. They are usually
administered by oral or parenteral route. Artemether and arteether are more potent than
ART, but have shorter biological half-lives, and may produce fatal toxicities such as
hematopoetic, cardiac and CNS toxicities. The sodium salt of artesunic acid (water-
complicated malaria (e.g. cerebral malaria). But, because of the high recrudescence
usually given in combination with slowly eliminating potent drugs from different
antimalarial classes like CQ, MQ, AQ, SP and pyronaridine. Artemether is usually
65
the sodium salt of artelinic acid, is sometimes used in place of artesunate to overcome
the hydrolytic instability experienced with the later. In comparison to oil soluble
analogues (artemether and arteether), sodium artelinate is not only more stable in
aqueous solution but also has a much longer biological half-life (1.5-3.0 h) with less
CNS toxicity. The water soluble ART derivatives have, therefore, rapid onset of action
which makes them especially effective against severe malaria. At the same time, rapid
disappearance from the blood may be a key reason behind their slow development of
resistance against malaria parasites. The problems associated with ART derivatives
properties1-3.
Hundreds of natural and synthetic peroxide compounds were developed from the
possess good clinical efficacy against drug-resistant strains of P. falciparum, and also
have better metabolic stability than first generation analogues. The second generation
drugs include C(10) aryloxy derivatives (a-d) of artelinic acid, deoxyartemisinin (e)
66
H H H
O O O
H H H
O O O
O O O
H H H
O O O
R
O R
R
ART are also included in this category. Some novel candidates are arteflene (b),
artemisinic acid (c), artemisitene (d), SM905 (e) arterolane (OZ277, f), artemeside (i),
artemisone (BAY449585, l), RW1777 (n), and artefenomel (OZ439, p)5,6. These drugs
are highly effective against P. falciparum resistant severe malaria like cerebral
malaria. Arteflene is a stable, safe and effective drug, but it shows a certain degree of
67
O
H
O H
O
O
O O
O
O
O H
H
OH HO O
OH
O
O
F3C CF3
a b c d
H
H
O O
O
O H
O
O O NH O
O
H O NH2 H
O
O
OH
H O
O N R
R=CH2CH2C6H4C6H5, g
e f
R= COC6H4C6H5, h
H
H O O
O
O H
O O O
O O
O
H H
O
O
N N
N
X= NH, i R= CH2-Ph, m p
R= CONH-Ph, n O
X= O, j N
X X= S, k R= pyrimidin-2-yl, o
X= SO2, l R
orally active and rapidly acting blood schizonticide against all blood stages of P.
falciparum without any effect on liver stages and acts by inhibition of Pf ATP6, a
tested in combination with piperaquine in areas of ART resistance (under TRAC II).
68
The discovery of OZZ277 was continued with the development of OZ439
In vitro data on the early ring stages confirmed that OZ439 is active on ART-resistant
strains of P. falciparum. It also showed good efficacy against resistant malaria when
(artemisone) which cures malaria in Aotus monkeys infected with P. falciparum with a
single dose at 10 mg/kg body weight when combined with mefloquine (5 mg/kg).
Artemisone also showed resistant preventing activity against P. falciparum when used
analogues (Figure 2.3). Aza dvts. (a-f) are more stable anactive than ART. Fluorinated
analogues have good oral bioavailability (due to increased lipophilicity) and high
O O O O
O O O O
O O O O
H H H H
N O O R O
R
O R1 R2
CF3
F F
R= H, a R1= H, R2= CF3, g, i j
R= NH2, b R1= OH, R2= CF3, h
R= OH, c
R= CH2CH2OH, d
R= CH2CHO, e
R= CH2-(pyridin-2-yl), f
69
2.1.2 Developmeent of 1,2,4-Trioxane-based and related peroxide antimalarials
1,2,4-Trioxane-based antimalarials
Among the 1,2,4-trioxane derivatives (a-l) depicted below (Figure 2.4), the 2-
adamantyl derivatives (j-l) have been reported to be the most active compounds. These
O R R H
H
H
O O H
O H
O O
R O O
O O H3CO
OCH3
c R= alkyl
a R=H/aryl/heteroaryl b R= alkyl OH
O O O O O O OH
O NHR
R O R O R O R'
f
d R= aryl e R= aryl
R=aryl, R'= H/CH3
Cl '
O O OH O O
CCO2C2H5 R O R2
R O R O
CH2CO2C2H5 R'
O2S O O R1
g R= aryl h R= aryl, R'= H/CH3 i
R=aryl, R1= R2=alkyl
O O O O O O
HO
R O O O
R
R
k R= CH3/
j R= cycloalkyl/aryl cyclopropyl/n-Pr l R= aryl
class of organic peroxides. They exhibit excellent activity against malaria parasite like
70
structurally similar 1,2,4-trioxanes. Their activities are comparable to artesunate and
artemether, both in vivo and in vitro, but with improved pharmacokinetic (oral
O O O O O O
NH2 NH2
O O N
O NH2
O
b c
a
O O
O O O O
O O
O N
O O N S
OEt O
d CO2H e f
O O
O O
O O
O
O O NH NH2
OH
O
g h i
O O N H2N
O O
O O
N
O NH O
O N
O
N
j k l
N
1,2,4,5-Tetraoxane-based antimalarials
antimalarial compounds which are under clinical phase of development. The role of
71
adamantyl substituent is that it stabilizes the structure and improves the antimalarial
activity. Some derivatives (e) that contain polar sulphonamide groups at one end and a
highly lipophilic adamantly group at the other end also possess potent antimalarial
activity4,12-19.
O O O O O
O O
O O O O
O O R R
R
O
a R=NHCH2CH2N(CH3)2 b R= OH/NH2/NHPr/NHCH2Ph c
O O
O O O O O O
O O O O O O
R
R= OCH3/NH2/NHCH2/CH2N(CH3)2 f
e
d
O O O
O O O R
O O
N O O
N S R
O O R
O O
O
H N N N
R=Et/Pr/Cyclopropyl N f O
R= h
e R=
O
N O g
N F
i
To overcome the problem of drug resistance, combination therapy has been used
for over years, but with limited success, and therefore, the concept of hybrid molecules
has recently been introduced for the development of new drugs for treating resistant
single molecular entity (hybrid molecule) that exhibit dual modes of action which
known as chimeric peroxides, the quinoline and peroxide moieties are the contributing
72
pharmacophoric groups. Such hybrid analogues are attributed to have the property of
pharmacokinetic properties over traditional drugs such as QN, CQ, MQ, ART and also
Some ART endoperoxide-based hybrid compounds are ART-QN (a), ART-MQ (b),
(Figure 2.7). They possess higher activity than ART and QN or MQ or CQ4,27,28.
H H
O O
H H
O O
O O
O O
O O CF3
O
O O
N O N
H
HO O
O
N CF3
CF3
a b
H H H
O
H
O
H
O R3 O H
O
O O O S O O
O
n=2/3/4/5
O O R2
H
O N O N O Cl
N H H
HN nN H R1 N N
O O
H n
Cl e N
c n=2/3 d
73
entity of trioxaquine is responsible for the activity of ART, whereas, the
the drug within the parasite. The antimalarial activities of trioxaquines (a-h) depicted
in Figure 2.8 are significantly higher than the activity of each of the individual
components4,29-34.
Ph
O O
Cl N H Ph
H O
O N O
CH3 H O
O HN HN nN
O N H
HN HN H O O CH3
H n= 2/3/4
b Cl N c
a
H
N
O Ar
O O
O
O O HN
O O
HN nN O
HN nN H
H
Cl N
n=2/3/4 n=2/3/4, O O
Cl N Ar= phenyl/biphenyl
Cl N f R1
e O O
d Ph
R
H O
O N
Ph HN H O O
O O O
O O
HN nN Fe
H Cl N
n=2
R1=R2=R3=alkyl
Cl N g R2
h i
falciparum in blood stage malaria infection with well defined safety and tolerability.
74
Some of these hybrid analogues show excellent oral effectiveness, but some molecules
suffer from limitations such as poor stability and poor solubility. Trioxaquines are
trioxane hybrids (i) have been reported to possess good antimalarial activity both in
Cl
Cl
O O H O O
N
O n N N N
n=2/3 O
N
Cl
a b
Cl
O O H O O
N
N N N
O n O
N
n=2/3
O O
c d
HN
NH O O R2 O
H O
O O N S
O X
R R= R3
O O R1
Cl
X= CONH
e
f
75
Quinoline-Linker-Trioxolane). These hybrid analogues exhibit potent antimalarial
or MQ against the P. falciparum strain and possess higher activity than CQ against
CQ-resistant strains27,36.
O HN NH
O O O O
R=
O O R O O R
Cl
a b
O O R2 O O R2 O
H O O H O
N S N S
X X
O O R3 O O R3
O R1 O R1
During the past few decades, the emergence of multi-drug resistant strains of P.
prevention worldwide. This has limited the use of currently available drugs, especially
non-quinolines like antifolates, atovaquone and antibiotics, and the novel ART
derivatives, in the treatment of resistant malaria6,7. WHO has recommended ACTs for
76
ACTs (for example, artemether + lumefantrine, artesunate + mefloquine,
cardiac and CNS), and treatment (non-compliance with repeated regimens and
synthetic derivatives of ART2,4,36. Because of the above challenging issues, the clinical
effectiveness of ACTs used in the treatment of resistant malaria has been seriously
77
ART have gained significant interest, in recent years, for the development of
antimalarial drugs that are structurally simpler, synthetically accessible and at the
same time potent and cost-effective. Pharmacodynamic study suggests that the
and its semi-synthetic analogues5. Although the 1,2,4-trioxane ring system is the
about desired antimalarial efficacy as most synthetic 1,2,4-trioxanes are less active
Several design strategies have already been initiated by MMV (Medicines for
Malaria Venture) program for the development of effective, safe and affordable
effective and alternative approach for the treatment of resistant malaria. It would thus
offer simple peroxide molecules based on single drug conjugate structure that may be
used in single drug conjugate therapy rather than hybrid drug analogues or drug
78
2.3 Project aims
Based on background information obtained from recent literature reports, our study
against resistant P. falciparum malaria. The objectives of the project are summarized
below:
derivatives
patentable. Novel trioxane molecules may not only be an alternative, but effective
approach in the treatment of malaria with resistant preventing action and ready
79
2.5 References
4. Opsenica DM, Šolaja BA. Antimalarial peroxides (Review). J Serb Chem Soc.
2009;74(11):1155-1187.
6. Luo XD, Shen CC. The Chemistry, Pharmacology, and Clinical Applications
Pharmacol. 1998;46:521-529.
10. Wang X, Creek DJ, Schiaffo CE, Chollet J, et al. Spiroadamantyl 1,2,4-
80
peroxide bond iron(II) reactivity, heme alkylation efficiency, and antimalarial
11. Dong Y, Chollet J, Matile H, Brun R, Vennerstrom JL. Spiro and Dispiro-
4961.
12. Vennerstrom JL, Hong-Ning FJ, Ellis WY, Ager AL, Wood JK, et al. Dispiro-
1992;35:3023-3027.
13. Vennerstrom JL, Dong Y, Andersen SL, Ager AL, Fu H, Miller RE. Synthesis
2000;43:2753-2758.
14. Amewu RK, Chadwick J, Hussain A, et al. Synthesis and evaluation of the
16. O’Neill PM, Ellis GL, Amewu R, Sabbani RS, Stocks PA, Shone A, et al.
2008;51:2170-2177.
81
17. Kumar N, Singh R, Rawat DS. Tetraoxanes: Synthetic and medicinal chemistry
18. Opsenica I, Opsenica D, Smith KS, Milhous WK, Solaja BA. Chemical
19. O’Neill PM, Amewu RK, Nixon GL, et al. Identification of a 1,2,4,5-
21. Walsh JJ, Bell A. Hybrid drugs for malaria. Curr Pharm Des. 2009;15(25):
2970-85.
22. Sashidhara KV, Avula SR, Palnati GR, et al., Synthesis and in vitro evaluation
23. Sashidhara KV, Kumar A, Kumar M, Sarkar J, Sinha S. Synthesis and in vitro
24. Manohar S, Rajesh UC, Khan SI, Tekwani BL, Rawat DS. Novel 4-
25. Kumar A, Srivastava K, Raja Kumar S, Puri SK, Chauhan PM. Synthesis of 9-
82
26. Chadwick J, Amewu RK, Marti F, et al. Antimalarial Mannoxanes: Hybrid
27. Chauhan SS, Sharma M, Chauhan PM. Trioxaquines: hybrid molecules for the
28. Posner GH, McRiner AJ, Paik IH, et al. Anticancer and Antimalarial Efficacy
2004;47:1299-1301.
29. Singh C, Malika H, Puri SK. Orally active amino functionalized antimalarial
1,2,4-trioxanes. 2004;14:459-462.
30. Singh C, Malika H, Puri SK. Synthesis and antimalarial activity of a new series
34. Araújo NCP, Barton V, Jones M, et al. Semi-synthetic and synthetic 1,2,4-
83
comparison with acridine endoperoxide conjugates. Bioorg Med Chem Lett.
2009;19:2038-2043.
Chem. 2012;22:3926-3930.
Chem. 2013;8:1528-1536.
37. Balint GA. Artemisinin and its derivatives: An important new class of
38. Meshnick SR. Artemisinin: mechanisms of action, resistance and toxicity. Int J
Parasitol. 2002;32:1655-1660.
39. Garner P, Graves PM. The benefits of artemisinin combination therapy for
40. Mott BT, Tripathi A, Siegler MA, Moore CD, Sullivan DJ, Posner GH.
84