Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Metal Architecture - Mixed Metal Symphony
Metal Architecture - Mixed Metal Symphony
com
Mixed Metal
Symphony
Pushing copper boundaries
Carbon neutrality with metals
Modern roofing solutions
We Turn Your Vision Into Reality
At SMART, we believe we succeed when your business
succeeds. Our values guide our strong relationships with
our signatory contractors and customers, whose projects
we proudly staff and deliver on-time and under budget.
Glam is Back
PRODUCTION OFFICES
15 Wertheim Court, Suite 710,
Richmond Hill, ON Canada L4B 3H7
EDITORIAL & PRODUCTION
Executive Editor, Jason Cramp, jcramp@kenilworth.com
Editor-in-Chief, Stacy Rinella, srinella@kenilworth.com
Associate Editor, Christopher Brinkerhoff, I love a good makeover story. Whether it be a fashion and
cbrinkerhoff@kenilworth.com beauty metamorphosis, a home or backyard reno, or an eatery
Associate Editor, Marika Gabriel, mgabriel@kenilworth.com
Production Coordinator, Falon Folkes, desperately in need of a rescue mission, give me a bowl of
ffolkes@kenilworth.com popcorn and a sparkling water and I’m in for the night. I keep
Senior Graphic Designer, Catherine Howlett,
chowlett@kenilworth.com the tissues handy because nothing tugs at the heartstrings more
BUSINESS & SALES than big-reveal reactions. There’s just something so genuine and
Vice-president of Sales, Joseph Galea, jgalea@kenilworth.com touching about the shock and awe on the recipient’s face, or the
Group Publisher, Construction and Metal Groups,
Melanie Kowal, mkowal@kenilworth.com gasps of excitement from their loved ones when they get a gander
Publisher, Metal Group, John Paul Lawrence, at the transformation.
jplawrence@kenilworth.com
National Sales Manager, Metal Group, Bob Higgins, While we’re on the topic of transformations, Metal Architecture
rhiggins@kenilworth.com has undergone one of its own, and we are debuting our
Operations Manager, Metal Group, Blanca Arteaga,
barteaga@kenilworth.com Stacy Rinella reimagining right here in this January 2024 issue.
Circulation Manager, Mei Hong, mhong@kenilworth.com So, what’s changed? Glad you asked. We’re still bringing you
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
the most innovative, brag-worthy, and show-stopping projects
Founding Publisher, John S. Lawrence in North America. You can still count on us for up-to-date
strategies, tips, and tricks to keep you in the know about all
things metal. But now it’s all coming at you bigger, bolder, and
more visually compelling than ever before. We’re also sporting
KENILWORTH MEDIA INC. a brand-new Metal Architecture logo you’ll see on the cover
Group Publisher/CEO, Erik Tolles
Chief Financial Officer, Philip Hartung and sprinkled throughout the magazine. Our art department
Senior Director of Operations, Krista Taylor has been working tirelessly to make these pages as elegant and
Editorial Director, Blair Adams
Director of Business Development, John MacPherson glamorous as the projects within them. Just like those makeover
stories, it brings a tear to my eye.
SUBSCRIPTIONS AND REPRINTS Continuing with the “makeover” theme, this month we’re
For subscription inquiries or changes of address, go to
www.metalarchitecture.com or contact Blanca Arteaga featuring Jackson Hole Airport’s Quick Turnaround Facility.
at barteaga@kenilworth.com or (847) 674-2200 Ext. 620 When the previous location no longer aligned with the airport’s
To order custom hard copy reprints or PDF eprints,
please contact: Nate Swailes, Mossberg & Co.,
environmental and sustainability goals, the transformation
(574) 347-4673, reprints@mossbergco.com commenced. Learn how the architecture team took on the
challenge of the only airport located within a national park
METAL ARCHITECTURE (ISSN-0885-5781) is published
10 times per year by Kenilworth Media Inc., 15 Wertheim
(more page 14.)
Court, Suite 710, Richmond Hill, ON L4B 3H7. Hands up if 2024 is the year you resolve to bring a little
Distributed in the U.S. by Kenilworth Media Services Corp.,
750 Commerce Dr. #1, Gulf Shores, AL 36542.
more serenity to your life? Start the infusion with Schuylkill
Subscriptions are free for those in the metal construction Sanctuary, a custom single-family residence outside of
industry in the United States. For those outside the industry,
the subscription price is $90 per year, in the United States;
Philadelphia, Pa. (page 8). Riverside living has never been more
$120, in Canada and Mexico; and $195 per year, in all other calming or inspiring.
countries. Periodicals class postage paid at Gulf Shores, AL,
Follow us on Happy New Year from all of us at Metal Architecture. Enjoy
and additional mailing offices.
POSTMASTER: Address service requested. METAL social media the issue!
ARCHITECTURE, P.O. Box 2267, Gulf Shores, AL 36547.
MEMBERSHIPS
Features
20 Perforation Panels
The visual appeal and practical benefits of copper
panels continue to spark interest from architects.
26 Reducing Emissions
Through Material Selection
Sonoran Desert, a building reflects a commitment
to sustainability.
32 (Re)new Manufacturing
Manufacturers have an opportunity to make
a significant difference.
14 26
Tech Reports
36 Energy Efficient Metal Roofing
38 Custom Roof Solution
40 Snow Retention January 2024 | metalarchitecture.com
On The Cover
Schuylkill Sanctuary
Department The design incorporated multiple types of metal
panels to accentuate its unique form. By arranging
3 Editor’s Corner these panels with staggered seams and an
overlap detail, the result was a seamless vertical
Mixed Metal
6 Constructive Insights Symphony appearance showcasing a tonal shift between the
two black colors. This created a deliberate rhythm,
42 Case Studies Pushing copper boundaries
Carbon neutrality with metals
adding a dramatic impact during daylight hours.
50 Top Honors
Modern roofing solutions
Risky Business
Climate-related finance risk and reporting
The recently released Fifth National Climate (SB 261)2 that apply to “covered entities” (corporation,
Assessment highlights that while U.S. greenhouse partnership, limited liability company, or other business
gas emissions have fallen since hitting a peak in 2007, entities) doing business in California. SB 253 requires
significantly deeper cuts are required to prevent businesses with more than $1 billion in annual revenues
catastrophic global climate change. It also notes that to disclose their Scope 1 and 2 GHG emissions (direct
we are already seeing an increasing frequency and emissions from energy use) starting in 2026, and Scope 3
severity of hazard events due to climate change, and (indirect emissions from transportation, supply chains,
that increased climate adaptation efforts are needed etc.) in 2027. SB 261 mandates that companies with more
to protect public health and life safety and to prevent than $500 million in revenue must biennially disclose
property damage and economic disruption. The world their financial risks associated with climate change and
suffered $313 billion in losses due to hazard events in natural hazards and what they are doing to mitigate the
2022, with 75 percent of these occurring in the United risks beginning on January 1, 2026. This regulation is
States. The U.S. set a record for natural hazard events closely aligned with the Taskforce for Climate-related
in 2023, with 25 separate events with losses of one Financial Disclosure (TCFD)3 and other established
billion dollars or more, breaking the previous record of disclosure regulations in Europe and elsewhere. While
22 set in 2020 and far exceeding annual averages from rules for implementation of these California laws are
previous decades. These impacts are rippling through being worked out, companies will want to start now, as it
the insurance industry with insurance companies will take time to prepare the disclosures. Fines for non-
pulling out of risky markets and defaulting at record compliance for SB 253 and SB 261 can be significant.
rates. State insurance agencies are battling insolvency As climate-related risk assessment is new for many
and property owners in certain areas are seeing eye- companies, the following is a review of what is required.
popping rate increases. First, what is meant by climate-related financial risk? SB
By Alan Scott These direct and indirect climate change impacts 261 defines it as “material risk of harm to immediate
and Albert Slap are creating risks for commercial real estate investors, and long-term financial outcomes due to physical and
building owners, and even lenders, with increasing transition risks, including, but not limited to, risks to
insurance costs, and potentially significant capital costs corporate operations, provision of goods and services,
for damage repair, extended business disruption, or supply chains, employee health and safety, capital
complete loss of property value after hazard events. With and financial investments, institutional investments,
insurance companies pulling back, and investors seeking financial standing of loan recipients and borrowers,
information on the climate-related financial risks, new shareholder value, consumer demand, and financial
regulations are beginning to require disclosures. markets and economic health.”
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Many companies subject to SB 261 do not know
is expected to release rules in 2024 that will require which of their “core” portfolio assets have the greatest
public companies to disclose GHG emissions and risks and, whether taken individually or together,
climate-related financial risks. More immediately, the which ones represent potential significant financial
State of California adopted two related laws last fall, the risks. Companies with multiple assets will want to start
Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act (SB 253)1 and with a risk assessment across their entire portfolio. Initial
the Greenhouse Gases: Climate-related Financial Risk Act portfolio risk scoring allows a company to discover
Rhythm in hues
The client’s desire for modern, low-maintenance, and
durable led to the decision to go with a metal clad house.
The design incorporated multiple types of metal panels
to accentuate its unique form. These panels consist of
three different widths in two contrasting colors: matte
black and gloss black. By arranging these panels with
staggered seams and an overlap detail, the result was a
WO O D CO L L E C T I O N
BARNBOARD RUSTIC
B u i l d i n g a p p l i c a t i o n s a r e s i m u l a t e d a n d a c t u a l c o l o r s m a y v a r y. © 2 0 2 4 T h e S h e r w i n - W i l l i a m s C o m p a n y
EMULATE
MADE TO MIMIC
coil.sherwin.com/Emulate
seamless vertical appearance showcasing a tonal shift soffits and ceiling grid inserts. These panels provided
Above left: The
between the two black colors. This created a deliberate a clean and crisp backdrop, drawing attention to the
exterior also features
boysenberry and blue rhythm, adding a subtle yet dynamic touch making a intricate architectural details which continue around to
corrugated metal dramatic impact during daylight hours. the side of the house, facing the river.
cladding, adding a pop Additionally, metal panels require minimal upkeep, A unique spiral staircase provides not only visual
of color to the otherwise allowing homeowners to focus on enjoying their interest and charm but serves a purpose for a second
monochromatic palette. property rather than be burdened by maintenance tasks. means of egress if the house floods. An exterior stair is a
Above right: By arranging
The use of aluminum panels is particularly beneficial due common design on new houses along the river and the
these panels with
staggered seams and an to their exceptional resistance to environmental elements, flooding from Hurricane Ida proved the point.
overlap detail, the result including water. This ensures the cladding can endure The main living space is enclosed by glass on three
was a seamless vertical seasonal flooding without experiencing issues like rust or sides, blurring the lines between the indoors and
appearance showcasing delamination, which are common with other materials. outdoors. Bringing the outside in is a consistent theme
a tonal shift between the with this residence. There is the metal railing on the
two black colors.
The metal touch patio deck, and these touches continue inside with
The exterior also features a vibrant boysenberry and handrails, stainless steel work surfaces in the butler’s
blue corrugated metal cladding. These exposed fastener pantry, and metal bathroom fixtures and accents.
panels add a pop of color to the mostly monochromatic The serenity also continues through the home as one
palette of black, gray, and white. To emphasize the can enjoy the views along with a soak in the metal-
bend plate and folded form of the house, the team adorned tub. “The goal was to have views of the river
employed white flat aluminum sheet panels for the from as many rooms as possible,” says Wischmeyer.
Schuylkill Sanctuary
Location: Philadelphia, Pa.
The design team
Size: 362 m2 (3,900 sf) incorporated additional
Architect: OW3 Architects, Oliver W. Wischmeyer III, AIA height to the main
General contractor: Schwartz Remodeling & Fine Home Building, Joseph Schwartz floor, ensuring
Metal installer(s): Schwartz Remodeling & Fine Home Building, Joseph Schwartz resiliency and views.
Building owner: Barry Rucks
MCA member company: ATAS International
Sensitive
Facility
Rusted metal contributes
to environmental initiatives
By Stacy Rinella
Seasonally sensitive
The QTA is located on the south edge of the airport;
its orientation derived from the existing east access
road and the west row of buildings and hangars.
Overall site planning and space program information
was provided by the Jackson Hole Airport based on
existing constraints, increasing demand, as well as
future phasing and growth of airport development.
The three program spaces all reside under one large,
heroic low-sloped roof. Every winter Jackson Hole gets
an average snowfall of approximately 10 m (32.7 ft),
and the continuous roof provides overhead protection
from snow and rain in between the two buildings
and at the exterior fuel island. Hobson says this is a
direct response to providing shelter for the employees
to efficiently do their jobs outside during Wyoming’s
varied seasons.
The complex is
wrapped in a
perforated, rusted Rustic details
metal screen. The complex is wrapped in a perforated, rusted metal
screen with washing and fueling functions hidden from
© 2023 DuPont.
public view. Each of the three components are organized
into three independent bays to service the three different
rental car companies.
“The material palette came from the desire to maintain
a sense of cohesion and consistency with the airport
campus overall,” explains Hobson. “There is an identity
which has already been successfully established at the
main terminal so the goal is and will continue to be
to align with this aesthetic that is associated with the
Jackson Hole Airport.”
Hobson says the other reasoning behind the material
palette is to draw from the beautiful context in which
the airport campus resides. “CLB feels strongly about
our projects being ‘Inspired by Place’ which can come to
fruition through form and materiality. This is the only
airport located within a national park so there is also
a responsibility and stewardship that were inherent in
the decision to blend with the surroundings.” Hobson
adds “The materials need to be timeless and very low
maintenance in this environment. So, metal with a live
finish was a sensible solution.”
Blending in
Exposed steel adds
to the complex’s
Operationally, the facilities are sequenced from south
industrial aesthetic to north, staring with fueling, then washing, and then
detailing. The wash building is 429-m2 (4,620-sf), while
the detail building is 831 m2 (8,950-sf) including a
The visual appeal and practical benefits Innovative perforation approaches generate nearly
of copper panels continue to spark interest from infinite customization possibilities. Architects and
architects and building owners who appreciate this designers can use perforated copper panels not
distinctive, high-performing material. Copper’s only to enhance the aesthetic intent of a project, but
exceptional workability enables design teams to also to serve practical purposes such as allowing
add unique perforated patterns to elements such ventilation, managing daylight and solar heat gain,
as textured exterior rain screens and decorative and establishing privacy.
interior panels. Further, the proven durability and Academic, institutional, religious, and residential
low maintenance requirements of copper materials structures in particular feature complex architectural
provide the potential for a service life measured elements that need to last for decades. Several winners
in centuries. of North American Copper in Architecture (NACIA)
Colorful metal fa
façade generates school pride
PAC-CLAD Flush panels in shades of gray form a lively abstract of the
Millennium High School mascot's tiger stripes, topped by the school's
signature purple to emphasize the building's interior volume.
Millennium High School, AZ Installer: Progressive Roofing Architect: BWS Architects Profile: Flush panel Colors: Weathered Zinc, Silver, Cityscape, Musket Gray, Custom Nike Purple
A blend of opaque
copper panels and
perforated, semi-
transparent screens
preserve the intimacy
of the interiors.
Photos courtesy
Adrien Williams
Custom-perforated square
and rectangle pattern: Wood House
The visual impact of copper combines with a custom-
perforated pattern of squares and rectangles to define
a unique aesthetic for this residence in Chicago, Ill.
Architects Brininstool + Lynch worked with Chicago
Copper & Iron Works to design and fabricate the
panels, some of which also included embossed designs.
The team then hand-treated the panels to create a
patina that blends hues of blue, green, and bronze,
complementing the brick, steel, and glass structure.
Additional considerations for selecting copper included
its corrosion resistance and low maintenance needs;
both are a particular benefit for perforated surfaces.
In the heart of the Sonoran Desert, where the A sustainable design choice
TSG Foundation’s Center for Spiritual Development The exterior of the TSG building uses RHEINZINK
now stands as a testament to thoughtful design and diamond-shaped zinc tiles, drawing inspiration from the
construction, the choice of materials go beyond region’s native rattlesnake, blending seamlessly with the
aesthetics. The team behind this Scottsdale, Ariz. desert landscape. However, the decision to use zinc extends
project included the architectural firm Orcutt | Winslow beyond its visual appeal. As Charles “Chip” McGowan,
and design-build firm 180 Degrees Design + Build. president of RHEINZINK America, Inc., emphasizes,
The building reflects a commitment to sustainability, “Today, architectural zinc can be manufactured with
extending to every facet of the structure. Central to this energy-efficient, low-carbon processes, validated with
commitment is the use of zinc cladding, specifically product-specific documentation. Installed as roofing,
tailored to not only withstand the desert’s harsh wall cladding, and other building products, architectural
conditions but also to contribute significantly to the zinc supports climate-resilient, low-maintenance
reduction of carbon emissions. performance, and occupants’ safety and health.
Carbon-reduced, high-quality
zinc production
Architectural zinc, used in projects like the TSG building,
undergoes a meticulous production process. Special high-
grade (SHG) zinc, composed of 99.995 percent pure zinc
alloyed with minute quantities of copper, titanium, and
aluminum, is used to create sheets with the necessary
strength while maintaining ease of shaping.
Zinc's sustainable life cycle: emissions in the build environment by 2030. Currently,
A cradle-to-cradle approach more than 1,100 architectural firms in the United States
Zinc’s sustainability extends beyond the construction have made this commitment.
phase. Unlike asphalt shingles, which contribute As the urgency for climate action intensifies,
significantly to construction and demolition debris, industry professionals find themselves at the forefront
zinc is 100 percent recyclable. The recycling process of sustainable design. The projects they design and
retains the material’s original quality, adhering to specify today will shape the operational lifecycles of
the cradle-to-cradle (C2C) principle. This approach buildings well into the future. The call to action is
emphasizes upcycling, converting materials and their clear—select materials that align with sustainability
residual materials back into new products without any goals, and architectural zinc is an example of a versatile
loss of quality. building material that can assist with the goals of
Asphalt shingles, with a lifespan of approximately 20 moving toward a more sustainable future.
years, end up in landfills, with more than 90 percent In the pursuit of a sustainable tomorrow, architectural
contributing to environmental harm. In contrast, zinc, zinc emerges not just as a material choice but as a
with a lifespan of 100 years or more, not only minimizes commitment to a circular economy, where resources are
the need for replacements but also offers a sustainable continually reused and recycled without compromising
solution for rainwater collection and harvesting systems. quality. The TSG building stands as a testament to the
power of thoughtful material selection in achieving
Today's projects shape the future a harmonious blend of aesthetics, functionality, and
building lifecycles environmental responsibility.
The global conversation on climate change has led to
international agreements and national commitments. Justin Stephenson is the marketing director of 180
For example, AIA has established a “2030 Commitment” Degrees Design + Build, an award-winning architectural
that asks architectural firms throughout the United and construction firm based in Phoenix, Ariz. He
States to create and commit to a sustainability action specializes in elevating the firm’s projects through
plan that will support the goal of reaching zero net strategic marketing initiatives.
(Re)new School
Manufacturing
Helping manufacturers deliver sustainable solutions
By Maggie Sexton
Energy Efficient
and Solar Ready
Metal Roofing With increasing installation of rooftop solar while maintaining cooler surface temperatures.
By Lee Ann arrays, a “solar ready” metal roofing system is These coatings meet national energy standards and
M. Slattery the ideal choice for both crystalline and building guidelines, and many comply with stringent California
Photos courtesy ATAS integrated photovoltaic (BIPV) solar systems, because Title 24 Building Energy Efficiency Standards.
of its long service life. When installing a crystalline Numerous LEED credits can be acquired, contingent
system (typically warranted for 25 years of power on the roof ’s solar reflectance index, and solar-ready
generation), a building owner benefits from a roofing capabilities play a significant role.
substrate that has a greater life expectancy than
the solar panels. Standing seam metal panels also Urban heat island
provide a natural platform for attaching crystalline According to the U.S. Environmental Protection
systems without any roof penetrations with the use of Agency (EPA), daytime temperatures in urban areas are
special attachment clamps that grip the metal seams. about -17 to -13 C (1 to 7 F) higher than temperatures
Additionally, highly reflective roofs with cooler in outlying areas, with nighttime temperatures about
rooftop temperature result in better performance of -16 to -15 C (2 to 5 F) higher. This is caused by the
solar panels. urban heat island (UHI) effect. The UHI effect is caused
The reason the standing seam metal roof systems are by a concentration of dark, impervious surfaces such
considered “solar ready” is that even if it is not in the as roofs, walls, roads, and parking lots that retain
project’s budget to install both a standing seam metal heat from the sun, combined with a lack of trees and
roof and the solar panels at the same time, the addition green space. Waste heat released by vehicles and air
of the solar panels can easily be done later. With the conditioning units also contribute to UHIs.
long lifespan of a metal roof, building owners can add The Cool Roof Rating Council (CRRC) on UHI
solar panels to their metal roof 10 or 20 years later, mitigation states passive cooling strategies such as
and the roof will still outlive the performance life of reflective “cool” roofs and walls provide immediate
the solar panels. heat relief, improve health outcomes, reduce air-
Even without the addition of solar panels to a conditioning use, and lower energy bills. UHIs are
roof, building owners can benefit from choosing commonly found within cities and contribute to heat-
a metal roof with a high-performance 70 percent vulnerable communities, which experience heightened
polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) paint coating with risk and increased sensitivity to extreme heat. They
cool pigment paints. These “cool roofs” reflect infrared also have less capacity and fewer resources to cope
radiation, allowing colors to resist chalking and fading, with, adapt to, or recover from heat-related impacts,
Custom
Roof
Solution
How a unique roof
shape created snow
guard challenges
When Yankee Construction was approached by “The issue was with the angles of the seams on the
By Carroll Marston Architect Robert Gabalski of Lothrop Associates LLC roof and the roof lines,” says Smith. There was no way to
Photos courtesy ACECLAMP for an upcoming building addition project, they were make a straight snow guard work.
faced with a challenge. Lothrop Associates envisioned The Hendrick Hudson Free Library’s new metal roof
a sweeping, non-traditional, single planar roof where has a 1,066.8-mm (42-in.) spread between these brackets
standing seams are laid out in a pattern, where the pitch and an angle open 165 degrees. It was immediately clear
of the seam is not perpendicular to the roof edge. The a standard snow guard system which could maintain the
new expansion was part of the children’s room addition angles of the new addition, while also leaving enough room
for the Hendrick Hudson Free Library in Montrose, N.Y. for the number of specified solar panels, did not exist.
and was designed to reflect and inspire the artistic spirit
of the community. With the new roof meeting up with Teamwork makes the roof work
the previous fascia, this presented challenges. Searching for a solution, Yankee Construction presented
their dilemma to a snow guard manufacturer. Gary
Safety first Dinnebeil, president of Yankee Construction, recalls
The library addition also features a walkway around how there was only one roofing snow guard company
the perimeter of the building. For safety reasons, the willing to approach the problem, and invent a new
original specification called for snow guards; however, product tailored to address this unique challenge.
this was another obstacle as the team was without exact The engineers envisioned a brand-new product called
specs on the type, or brand which would best match the variable angled bracket (VAB) for inclined roofs that could
angles of the new roof. solve the issue Yankee Construction was facing with the
One of the most substantial problems, besides the library addition. Co-engineer Bob Mercier says where
angles, was the Hendrick Hudson Free Library’s traditional metal roof snow guards can only be installed 90
requirements called for a significant amount of the degrees to the seam, a VAB allows for installation of snow
roof ’s usable square footage to be allocated towards the retention rails within a variable range, making it possible
installation of photovoltaic panels. to match up with more exotic architectural angles.
The VAB’s added flexibility allows roofing contractors to
Thinking outside the guards accommodate many more types of roofing designs.
Traditional snow guards often present the problem of
forcing installers to adhere to angles which are way out Carroll Marston, is a sales engineer with AceClamp. For
of sync with the architect’s vision. more information visit www.aceclamp.com.
LEARN MORE!
Exteriors Pavilion, an innovative addition dedicated to residential exterior projects
and products. Explore the latest in siding, windows, weather barriers, exterior trim,
and more. theroofingexpo.com
Our dedication to excellence goes beyond the exhibits. We’ve invested in additional
on-floor education and live, hands-on building clinics, resulting in exceptional
outcomes. The journey continues in 2024 as we expand our offerings even further.
Don’t miss this incredible opportunity to be part of the future of residential exteriors.
Join us in Las Vegas!
Get a FREE expo hall pass or 10% off a super pass with code ROOF24METAL*.
*Discounts not applicable to Non-Exhibiting Manufacturers or Exhibiting Manufacturers. Discounts apply to
new registrations only. No refunds will be issued for pre-existing registrations.
OFFICIAL SHOW SPONSOR OFFICIAL SHOW PUBLICATION OFFICIAL DIGITAL MEDIA BRAND
Tech Report
Snow
Retention
Considerations for
metal roof projects
When snow melts on a metal roof, snowpack can Both continuous and discontinuous types are usually
By Rob Haddock suddenly release, dumping snow below the eaves in a installed at or near the eaves and may be repeated at
Photos courtesy S-5!
matter of seconds. Such a rooftop avalanche,1 presents parallel intervals going up toward the ridge but with
a life-safety issue, which can cause personal injury and greater concentration near the eave area. Frequency
even death to pedestrians, not to mention hundreds of (population density) is determined by specific job
millions of dollars in property damage annually. conditions and load-to-failure characteristics of the
Posting a sign “Beware of Melting Snow & Ice” specific devices used.
or “Caution! Snow & Ice May Fall! Do Not Stand Both rely upon the compressive strength of the snow
Directly Under Roof ” may be an attention grabber, but blanket at its interface with the snowguard devices. This
it certainly does not protect the architect, designer, or strength is greatest at the base of the blanket—that is
building owner from liability. In fact, it is in many ways the portion toward the eave and immediately adjacent
an admission of a known hazard. to the roof surface. The snow blanket is considered
The best way to mitigate rooftop avalanche danger and a monolithic slab with significant cohesive strength
reduce potential liability caused by sliding snow and ice within itself. Both types also rely on the cohesive and
is by installing a scientifically tested, engineered, and shear strength of the snow blanket to “bridge” between
certified snow retention system2 specific to the snow rows or laterally from one discontinuous unit to the next
loads expected on a metal roof project. adjacent one.
Chemical attachment
While adhesives may seem convenient, these
bonds degrade over time with exposure A “fence” (continuous)
to temperature change, light, moisture, and type snow guard.
ozone, so the holding capacity is constantly
dropping as the chemistry breaks down. The
failure strength within two or three years may
be a fraction of what it was at the time of testing
under ideal conditions prior to exposure. The
Metal Construction Association (MCA) has
published a technical report titled Qualifying
Snow Retention Systems for Metal Roofing (at
www.metalconstruction.org) and strongly
cautions against the use of non-mechanically
fastened snow retention systems.
Mechanical Attachment
As the holding strength of preferred mechanical 2
www.metalconstruction.org/index.php/ Rob Haddock, CEO and founder of S-5!, is a
attachments does not change with age, their online-education/Snow-Retention. former contractor, award-winning roof forensics
performance is measurably predictable for the 3
https://blog.s-5.com/blog/why-do- expert, author, lecturer and building envelope
long haul. There are two methods of mechanical exposed-fastened-metal-roofs-need- scientist who has worked in various aspects of
attachment—one for standing seam profiles continuous-snow-bars. metal roofing for five decades.
and another for exposed-fastened metal
roofs. The distinction between them involves
clamping, which grips the standing seam in
some fashion without puncturing the panel
material (non-penetrating) versus fastening
screws through the roof material and into the
structure (penetrating).
In either case, the mechanical attachment
should have appropriate failure load testing
documented by lab reports from an ASTM
1703-qualified independent lab so the complete
system can be engineered to withstand the
service loads to which it is exposed.
Other considerations are materials
compatibility, appropriate factors of safety,
prudent waterproofing for penetrative
attachments and proven durability that lasts
the life of the roof—to name a few.
For more on the science of snow
retention, visit www.s-5.com or find the
MCA technical bulletin referenced at
www.metalconstruction.org.
NOTES
1
https://blog.s-5.com/blog/benefits-install-
snowguards-metal-roof.
Metal Architecture 41
MCN Square.indd 1 4/18/2022 11:58:22 AM
Case Study
Ensuring
Fire Station
Longevity Project goals for Mowbray Volunteer Fire
Department’s station in Soddy-Daisy, Tenn.,
included an exterior that gives the building a clear
visual identity. Metal roofing and metal wall accents
on masonry walls were specified to contribute to the
Photos courtesy hortonphotoinc.com solution. Additionally, equipment is visible from the
exterior via glass bay doors.
Ronny Rahm, AIA, principal at MBI Cos., says, “We
wanted people to know it’s a fire station.”
The project faced some challenges, in part, due to
long, single-sloped roofs that required rollforming on
site. Davis Brothers Roofing and Sheet Metal Fabricators
Inc. fabricated and installed Petersen Aluminum Corp.’s
24-gauge steel Tite-Loc Plus standing seam roof system
in Slate Gray.
At soffits, Davis Brothers installed Petersen’s PAC-
CLAD aluminum, fully face-lanced Flush panels in
Granite. On walls, Davis Brothers installed Petersen’s
24-gauge steel HWP wall panels in Black.
Besides aesthetic goals, metal panels met project
requirements for longevity as well.
“[The owner] wanted a building that would function
and be durable enough to last 50 years,” Rahm says.
“[Metal panels] give it that feeling that this building is
going to be around for a while.”
Importantly, the new fire station houses all of the
department’s equipment, which was not possible at its
previous facility.
Design
Oceola Township’s Oceola Community Center in
Howell, Mich., was constructed with a metal building
system, and houses offices for the recreation authority,
multipurpose rooms, two fitness and workout
Integrates
areas, locker rooms and showers, and a mezzanine.
Additionally, there is an elevated walking track above
the perimeter of three full-sized basketball/volleyball/
Suspended
pickleball courts.
Matt Vetter, president at Schafer Construction Inc.,
says, “Loading was a challenge due to the suspended
walking track. The goal was to maintain an affordable
Walking Track
building for our client while keeping necessary
clearances beneath the track to allow for proper runoff
space from the ball courts. This meant no structural
support beneath the track, so everything is hanging
from the structure above. There were lots of point
loads to deal with without blowing the budget out of
Photos courtesy Schaffer Construction Inc. the water.
BOLD
DURABILITY
THE MATERIAL CHOICE FOR SOME
OF THE WORLD’S MOST ICONIC
STRUCTURES AND DESIGNS.
Anodized aluminum from Lorin Industries delivers stunning dimensional elements
C LE A R M AT T ®
to architectural projects, while providing a unique, signature look, that’s durable,
customizable, and consistent in appearance. Available in a variety of colors and
finishes, Lorin anodized aluminum is perfect for making a new and bold statement.
CO LO R I N ® B L AC K M AT T
Fire Station
Blends Classic
Design with
Metal Resilience
Photos courtesy www.hortonphotoinc.com
System Covers
Playground
Photo courtesy Matix Inc.
YOUR IDEAL
ROOFING SOLUTION
To complete Fred Ayres Memorial Playground at Pineapple Park in FALK SSR 42 FALK RRP 40
Jensen Beach, Fla., Ahrens Companies designed a metal building system with
a 418 m2 (4,500 sf) multi-age play area covered by metal roofing.
The building is an open structure without full length walls. To construct it,
Metallic Building Systems supplied its clear span metal building system. It has
a double-sloped roof and straight columns. Metallic Building also supplied
galvanized steel PBR roof panels and galvanized steel PBR wall panels.
FOR TPO MEMBRANE ROOFS:
Project goals included creating a cost-efficient, covered playground for
the community to enjoy. The use of a metal building system met the project’s FALK MRP 44 FALK RDEK 40
design, construction, and budget requirements, and the community’s
objective to incorporated more energy efficient buildings.
www.metallic.com products, and more. Visit our website now for details
and inquiries!
falk.com
metalarchitecture.com January 2024 Metal Architecture 49
Top Honors
D•F®
Butyl Tape
D•F® DROP-STOP® D•F® SCREWS
D•F® ULTRA-PREMIUM
IMPACT-TESTED™
D•F METAL CUTTING BLADE
®
NUT RUNNERS D•F® DYNA-CLAMPS®