Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Influences of Heat Treatment On Fatigue Crack Growth Behavior of NiAl Bronze (NAB) Alloy
Influences of Heat Treatment On Fatigue Crack Growth Behavior of NiAl Bronze (NAB) Alloy
net/publication/283175280
CITATIONS READS
4 203
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Yuanfei Han on 15 November 2015.
Fatigue crack growth tests of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy heat treated at different temper
temperature after quenching at 920 °C are performed using direct current potential drop method.
The influences of heat treatment on the fatigue crack growth behavior of NAB alloy are
investigated. The results show that the fatigue crack growth rate (FCGR) of NAB alloy decreases
with the increase of temper temperature. A few large secondary cracks are obtained as the sample
is tempered at 350 °C and the secondary cracks diminish with the increase of temper temperature.
With further increasing temper temperature to 550 °C, a large number of small secondary cracks
are obtained, which is responsible for its lower FCGR. The as-cast NAB alloy has a lower FCGR
than that tempered at 550 °C at low stress intensity factor range (DK) region, and the lower
FCGR is attributed to the crack deflection effect of the as-cast microstructure. At high DK region,
the crack deflection effect diminishes, which leads to the higher FCGR of as-cast sample.
J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015 Ó Materials Research Society 2015 3041
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
Y. Lv et al.: Influences of heat treatment on fatigue crack growth behavior of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy
a significant influence on the fatigue crack growth are tempered at 350, 450, and 550 °C for 2 h, respectively,
behavior of materials.18,19 For titanium alloy, the thick and then air cooling (coded as QT-350, QT-450, and QT-
ɑ platelets can deflect the main crack and thus slow the 550, respectively). The samples for microstructure obser-
Fatigue crack growth rate (FCGR), while thin ɑ platelets vation are cut, cold mounted, grounded, polished, and then
can be cut easily by main crack.18 The acicular and etched by a solution of 5g FeCl312 ml HCl195 ml
lamellar ɑ phases are most favorable to deflecting the C2H5OH. Phase structure is identified by a D8 AD-
main crack and improve the fatigue crack growth VANCE x-ray diffractometere (XRD; D/max-IIIA,
resistance compared to large primary ɑ grains and smaller Rigaku, Tokyo, Japan) with Cu Ka radiation at room
transformed ɑ 1 b lamellae.19 However, the effects of temperature. Tensile samples with gauge section of 15 mm
microstructures on the fatigue crack growth behavior of 4 mm 1.5 mm are machined and then are tested on
NAB alloy have rarely been investigated. ZwickT1-Fr020 TN.A50 at the strain rate of 103 s1.
In this study, as-cast NAB alloy is heat treated at Fatigue crack growth tests are performed on a DLU-50
different temper temperatures after quenching at 920 °C test machine from Bairuo (Shanghai, China) using three-
and the fatigue crack growth tests are performed using point bending samples according to ASTM E399 and
direct current potential drop (DCPD) method. The fatigue ASTM E647 standards. Figure 2 shows the exact
crack growth behavior of heat treated NAB alloy is dimensions of test sample. “Uref” is the reference voltage
investigated, and then the effects of microstructures and drop, and “Uac” is the main voltage drop. All fatigue
secondary cracks on the fatigue crack growth behavior of crack growth tests are conducted at a stress ratio (R 5
heat treated NAB alloy are discussed. Kmin/Kmax) of 0.3 with a sine-wave loading frequency of
1 Hz at room temperature. DCPD crack length measure-
ment devices are used to monitor the crack propagation in
II. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
computer based on the finite element analysis of elec-
The NAB cast ingot with a dimension of f150 mm 200 tricity distribution. The stress intensity factor K is
mm is prepared by nonvacuum melting. The chemical controlled by a software in accordance with ASTM
composition of the cast NAB is determined by fluorescence E399. Fatigue fracture surface and crack propagation
spectrophotometer, as shown in Table I. The as-cast micro- path from side surface of heat treated samples are
structure of NAB alloy includes ɑ matrix phase, martensite observed by Sirion 200 scanning electron microscope
b phase (b9 phase), jⅱ, jⅲ and jⅳ phases (Fig. 1). The (SEM; JEM-2100F, JEOL, Tokyo, Japan).
samples for fatigue crack growth test are heated up to 920 °C
for 1 h followed by water quenching. After that, the samples III. RESULTS
A. Microstructure
TABLE I. The chemical composition of as-cast NAB alloy.
1. Heat treatments of NAB alloy
Elements (wt%) Al Fe Ni Mn Cu
Figure 3 shows the microstructure of NAB alloy with
As-cast NAB 10.05 3.74 3.55 0.83 Balanced different heat treatments. It can be seen that the
microstructure of heat treated NAB alloy is signifi-
cantly different from that of the as-cast one (Fig. 1).
For QT-350 sample, the microstructures include a, jⅡ,
and b9 phases [Fig. 3(a)]. The jⅡ and b9 phases are
formed during quenching. The present result is consis-
tent with Anantapong’s study,15 which reports that a,
jⅡ, and b9 phases are formed when NAB alloy is cooled
from peak temperature of 860–930 °C at a high cooling
rate. Figure 3(b) shows the microstructure of QT-450
sample. In comparison with lower temper temperature
(350 °C), the amount of acicular martensite phase
decrease and that of jⅡ phase increase. This indicates
that acicular martensite phase decomposes and jⅡ
phase is precipitated during tempering treatment. With
further increasing temper temperature to 550 °C, acic-
ular martensite phase disappears totally and more j
grains are formed. It is suggested that acicular mar-
tensite phase is transformed to a (Cu) and j phases
completely when the quenched sample is tempered at
FIG. 1. SEM micrograph of as-cast NAB alloy microstructure. 550 °C.
3042 J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
Y. Lv et al.: Influences of heat treatment on fatigue crack growth behavior of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy
FIG. 3. SEM images of NAB alloy with different heat treatment. (a) QT-350, (b) QT-450, (c) QT-550 and (d) Enlarged image of the area inside the
square frame shown in Fig. 3(c).
2. X-ray diffraction pattern analysis comparison with as-cast sample, quenched sample shows
Figure 4 shows the x-ray diffraction patterns of NAB lower a (Cu) phase peaks and the (Fe, Ni) Al peaks
alloy with different heat treatments. The curve of sample disappear. It is indicated that the solution of (Fe, Ni) Al
quenched at 920 °C is also included. As can be seen, in phases and a (Cu) phase into b phase occurs and large
J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015 3043
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
Y. Lv et al.: Influences of heat treatment on fatigue crack growth behavior of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy
quantity of b phase are formed when the NAB alloy is The QT-350 sample exhibits highest ultimate tensile
heated to 920 °C. The quenching treatment leads to the strength and lowest elongation. The ultimate tensile
formation of acicular b9 martensitic phase, which is strength decreases and the elongation increases with
consistent with SEM observation results [Fig. 3(a)]. increase of temper temperature. With further increasing
The peaks of b9 martensitic phase decrease and that of the temper temperature to 550 °C, the ultimate tensile
a (Cu) and (Fe, Ni) Al phases increase with increase of strength and elongation are 730.2 6 13 and 9.3 6 0.8,
temper temperature (see QT-350 and QT-450 curves). respectively.
This indicates that b9 phase transfers to a (Cu) phase and
(Fe, Ni) Al phases during tempering. With further C. Fatigue crack growth rate
increasing the temper temperature to 550 °C, the peaks Figure 6 shows the FCGR for the heat treated NAB alloy
of b9 martensite phase disappear completely, which in log–log coordinate. A distinct Paris’ regime with different
indicates that b9 martensitic phase transfers to a (Cu) microstructures is illustrated followed this relationship:
and (Fe, Ni) Al phases totally.
da
B. Tensile properties ¼ CðDK Þn ; ð1Þ
dN
Figure 5 shows the stress–strain curves of NAB alloy at
different heat treatment. The tensile properties are shown where C and n are the constants related with material
in Table II. As can be seen, the mechanical properties variables, environment, frequency, temperature, and
change significantly after different heat treatments. stress ratio. DK is the stress intensity factor range in
MPa m1/2 and da/dN is the FCGR in mm/cycle. It can be
found that the FCGR of as-cast and the QT-550 samples
is lower than that of QT-350 and QT-450 samples. At
low DK-levels, as-cast sample has a higher FCGR than
QT-550 sample and opposite result is obtained at high
DK-levels. The material related constants C and n
obtained from the intersections and slopes of log–log
plots (Fig. 6) are shown in Table III. C and n values of
the Paris modal are significantly different for various heat
treatments, indicating that these parameters are closely
related to the microstructure of materials.
3044 J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
Y. Lv et al.: Influences of heat treatment on fatigue crack growth behavior of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy
J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015 3045
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
Y. Lv et al.: Influences of heat treatment on fatigue crack growth behavior of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy
FIG. 7. SEM images of fatigue crack propagation paths of NAB alloy with different heat treatment at lower DK region. (a) As-cast, (b) QT-350,
(c) QT-450, (d) QT-550.
FIG. 8. SEM images of the fracture surfaces for the heat treated NAB alloy at low DK region. (a) As-cast, (b) QT-350, (c) QT-450, (d) QT-550.
be found that as-cast sample exhibits a flat fracture deflection effect of as-cast microstructure diminishes at
surface, while the as-cast sample shows a rough fracture high DK region. Moreover, large quantity observations of
surface at low DK region. This indicates that the striations on the fracture surfaces of as-cast and QT-550
3046 J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
Y. Lv et al.: Influences of heat treatment on fatigue crack growth behavior of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy
FIG. 9. SEM images of fractography and crack profile and for NAB alloy. (a) As-cast, (b) Magnified image of the area inside square frame shown
in Figs. 9(a), (c) QT-550, (d) The crack profile of QT-550 sample.
samples indicate that the fatigue crack mechanism is dislocation density and stored energy may be higher than
controlled by striation crack. Therefore, we believe that the as-cast and QT-550 samples. As the fatigue cracks
crack tip plastic zone size increases with increase of DK propagate, the movement of dislocations and release of
and the fatigue striation mechanism becomes a main stored energy are beneficial to the formation of secondary
fracture mechanism when the crack tip plastic zone reach cracks. The secondary cracks diminish with increase of
a critical value. Thus, the crack deflection effect caused temper temperature due to the release of stored energy
by microstructure can exert little influence on the FCGR [Figs. 7(a)–7(c)]. Figure 9(d) shows detailed observation
resistance, which leads to a higher FCGR of as-cast of crack propagate path of QT-550 sample. A large
sample at high DK region. In addition, the martensite number of small secondary cracks can be found, which
transformation products of QT-550 sample contain large can consume the energy of crack tip and slow the FCGR.27
amount of finer j phases [Fig. 9(d)]. These finer j phases Moreover, when the sample is tempered at 550 °C, the
can increase the fatigue crack growth resistance because martensite phase transforms to a (Cu) phase and j phases
the dislocations can be shared by small-coherent precip- totally. The martensite transformation products are
itates which are localized in different width planar bands, tougher, and thereby effectively reduce the crack tip
then make glide more or less reversible during cyclic driving force by mechanisms of crack tip blunting and
loading. This planar reversible slip is claimed to decrease deflection.27 Therefore, QT-550 sample has lowest FCGR
the FCGR by increasing tip deflection and reducing although the main crack propagates in a flat way.
damage accumulation.23,25,26
V. CONCLUSIONS
B. Effect of secondary crack The main conclusions drawn on the basis of the
Secondary cracks are observed in fatigue fracture experimental results are summarized as follows:
surface of all samples, as shown in Fig. 7. A few large (1) The microstructure of NAB alloy heat treated by
secondary cracks can be seen in the QT-350 sample and quenching followed tempering contains a, jⅡ, and b9
the secondary cracks diminish with increase of temper phases. The b9 phase transforms to a (Cu) and j phases
temperature [Seen in Figs. 7(b)–7(d)]. The secondary with the increase of temper temperature. When temper
cracks are responsible for the deceleration of crack temperature is increased to 550 °C, the martensite phase
growth by consuming the energy of crack tip.27 However, disappears.
the FCGR of heat treated samples decrease with increase (2) The FCGR of heat treated NAB alloy decreases
of temper temperature. This is because of the high with increase of temper temperature. The as-cast sample
dislocation density and deformation potency of heat has a lower FCGR than QT-550 sample at low DK region
treated samples with lower temper temperature.27 When and the opposite results are obtained at high DK region.
the NAB alloy are tempered at 350 and 450 °C, the The deflection effect of microstructure makes a main
J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015 3047
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
Y. Lv et al.: Influences of heat treatment on fatigue crack growth behavior of NiAl bronze (NAB) alloy
attribution to the lower FCGR of as-cast alloy at low DK 11. J.Q. Su, S. Swaminathan, S.K. Menon, and T.R. Mcnelley: The
region, while the deflection effect diminishes at high DK effect of Concurrent straining on phase transformations in NiAl
bronze during the friction stir processing thermomechanical cycle.
region, which leads to the higher FCGR of as-cast alloy. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 42, 2420 (2011).
(3) The main cracks of QT-350 and QT-450 samples 12. D.R. Ni, P. Xue, D. Wang, B.L. Xiao, and Z.Y. Ma: In-
propagate toward a phase due to the higher hardness of homogeneous microstructure and mechanical properties of
martensite phase. The crack of QT-350 sample prefers to friction stir processed NiAl bronze. Mater. Sci. Eng., A 524,
propagate along the a/b9 boundaries due to the diversity 119 (2009).
13. Q.N. Song, Y.G. Zheng, D.R. Ni, and Z.Y. Ma: Studies of the
of these phases. As the temper temperature is increased to nobility of phases using scanning Kelvin probe microscopy and its
450 °C, the crack prefers to pass through a grains. With relationship to corrosion behaviour of Ni–Al bronze in chloride
further increasing the temper temperature to 550 °C, the media. Corros. Sci. 92, 95 (2014).
crack propagates in a flat way. 14. R.P. Chen, Z.Q. Liang, W.W. Zhang, D.T. Zhang, Z.Q. Luo, and
(4) A few large secondary cracks are obtained at L.Y. Li: Effect of heat treatment on microstructure and properties
of hot-extruded nickel-aluminum bronze. Trans. Nonferrous Met.
QT-350 sample and the secondary cracks diminish with Soc. China 17, 1254 (2007).
increase of temper temperature. The QT-550 sample has 15. J. Anantapong, V. Uthaisangsuk, S. Suranuntchai, and
a large number of small secondary cracks, which is A. Manonukul: Effect of hot working on microstructure evolution
responsible for higher fatigue crack growth resistance. of as-cast nickel aluminum bronze alloy. Mate. Des. 60, 233
(2014).
16. A. Chakrabarti, A. Sarkar, T. Saravanan, A. Nagesha, R. Sandhya,
and T. Jayakumar: Influence of mean stress and defect distribution
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS on the high cycle fatigue behaviour of cast Ni–Al bronze.
Financial support of this research provided by 973 Procedia Eng. 86, 103 (2014).
17. E.J. Czyryca: Corrosion fatigue crack for cast nickel–aluminium
Program under Grant No. 2014CB046701, National bronze and welds. In Fatigue Crack Growth Thresholds, Endur-
Science Foundation under Grant No. 51302168, ance Limits, and Design, ASTM STP 1372, J.C. Newman, Jr. and
Shanghai Postdoctoral Sustentation Fund under Grant R.S. Piascik eds.; American Society for Testing and Materials:
No. 14R21410900, China Postdoctoral Science Foundation West Conshohocken, PA, 2000; p. 319.
(Grant No. 2014M561471, 2014M550235). 18. X.H. Shi, W.D. Zeng, C.L. Shi, H.J. Wang, and Z.Q. Jia: Study on
the fatigue crack growth rates of Ti–5Al–5Mo–5V–1Cr–1Fe
titanium alloy with basket-weave microstructure. Mater. Sci.
REFERENCES Eng., A 621, 143 (2015).
19. N. Verdhan, D.D. Bhende, R. Kapoor, and J.K. Chakravartty:
1. A. Jahanafrooz, F. Hasan, G.W. Lorrmer, and N. Ridley: Micro- Effect of microstructure on the fatigue crack growth behaviour of
structural development in complex nickel aluminum bronzes. a near-a Ti alloy. Int. J. Fatigue 74, 46 (2015).
Metall. Mater. Trans. A 14A, 1951 (1982). 20. A.L. Pilchak: Fatigue crack growth rates in alpha titanium:
2. F. Hasan, A. Jahanafrooz, G.W. Lorimer, and N. Ridley: The Faceted vs. striation growth. Scr. Mater. 68, 277 (2013).
morphology, crystallography and chemistry of phases in as cast 21. H. Ghonem: Microstructure and fatigue crack growth mechanisms
nickel aluminum bronze. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 13, 1337 (1982). in high temperature titanium alloys. Int. J. Fatigue 32, 1448
3. E.A. Culpan and G. Rose: Microstructural characterization of cast (2010).
nickel aluminium bronze. J. Mater. Sci. 13, 1647 (1978). 22. S.K. Li, B.Q. Xiong, S.X. Hui, W.J. Ye, and Y. Yang: Effects of
4. D. Nakhaie, A. Davoodi, and A. Imani: The role of constituent microstructure on fatigue crack growth behavior of Ti–6Al–2Zr–
phases on corrosion initiation of NiAl bronze in acidic media studied 1Mo–1V ELI alloy. Mater. Charact. 59, 397 (2008).
by SEM-EDS, AFM and SKPFM. Corros. Sci. 80, 104 (2014). 23. Y.L. Wang, Q.L. Pan, L.L. Wei, B. Li, and Y. Wang: Effect of
5. J.A. Wharton and K.R. Stokes: The influence of nickel–aluminium retrogression and reaging treatment on the microstructure and
bronze microstructure and crevice solution on the initiation of fatigue crack growth behavior of 7050 aluminum alloy thick plate.
crevice corrosion. Electrochim. Acta 53, 2463 (2008). Mater. Des. 55, 857 (2014).
6. S. Neodo, D. Carugo, J.A. Wharton, and K.R. Stokes: Electrochemical 24. X.H. Shi, W.D. Zeng, C.L. Shi, H.J. Wang, and Z.Q. Jia: The
behaviour of nickel–aluminium bronze in chloride media: Influence of effects of colony microstructure on the fatigue crack growth
pH and benzotriazole. J. Electroanal. Chem. 695, 38 (2013). behavior for Ti–6A1–2Zr–2Sn–3Mo–1Cr–2Nb titanium alloy.
7. L.L. Gao and X. Cheng: Microstructure and mechanical properties Mater. Sci. Eng., A 621, 252 (2015).
of Cu–10%Al–4%Fe alloy produced by equal channel angular 25. A. Chakrabarti, A. Sarkar, T. Saravanan, A. Nagesha, R. Sandhya,
extrusion. Mater. Des. 29, 904 (2008). and T. Jayakumar: Influence of mean stress and defect distribution
8. L.L. Gao and X.H. Cheng: Microstructure and dry sliding wear on the high cycle fatigue behaviour of cast Ni–Al bronze.
behavior of Cu–10%Al–4%Fe alloy produced by equal channel Presented at the 1st International Conference on Structural
angular extrusion. Wear 265, 986 (2008). Integrity, Madeira Island, Portugal, 2014.
9. S. Hanke, A. Fischer, M. Beyer, and J. Santos: Cavitation erosion 26. L.P. Borrego, J.M. Costa, S. Silva, and J.M. Ferreira: Microstruc-
of NiAl-bronze layers generated by friction surfacing. Wear 273, ture dependent fatigue crack growth in aged hardened aluminium
32 (2011). alloys. Int. J. Fatigue 26, 1321 (2004).
10. D.R. Ni, B.L. Xiao, Z.Y. Ma, Y.X. Qiao, and Y.G. Zheng: 27. S.C. Li, Y.L. Kang, and S. Kuang: Effects of microstructure on
Corrosion properties of friction–stir processed cast NiAl bronze. fatigue crack growth behavior in cold-rolled dual phase steels.
Corros. Sci. 52, 1610 (2010). Mater. Sci. Eng., A 612, 153 (2014).
3048 J. Mater. Res., Vol. 30, No. 20, Oct 28, 2015
http://journals.cambridge.org Downloaded: 15 Nov 2015 IP address: 202.120.55.159
View publication stats