Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Space Debris Tracking, Aadit Garg (22ba003)
Space Debris Tracking, Aadit Garg (22ba003)
Abstract
This study looks into the expanding business of detecting space debris. It investigates the
conflicts and collaborations occurring in this dynamic industry. We see the key intuitions and
forces involved, the rules which generate problems, and how everyone collaborates. By also
providing and analysing a case study, we may understand how nowadays businesses compete
for customers, argue over data ownership, and cope with government regulations. We will
also witness how they collaborate with each other to make space more secure by sharing
information and developing innovative techniques to monitor space debris. Finally, we offer
suggestions for how everyone involved should collaborate more effectively. We believe
businesses and governments must collaborate and come up with new ideas to maintain space
missions secure and successful.
Research Gap
Despite the thorough research on space debris tracking and economic impact studies, there is
still a lack of understanding among industry experts about dispute resolution tactics and
collaborative processes. While earlier studies have looked into the economic implications of
space debris and the role of collaborative initiatives in tackling these issues, there haven’t been
enough focus on the specific disputes and collaborations that have been forming within the
space debris tracking industry. This case study aims to address this problem by giving an in-
depth analysis of the conflicts, cooperation, and regulatory obstacles affecting the industry,
identifying insights into the dynamics of space debris tracking and mitigation activities.
Literature Review
As the human beings explore and use space, the issue posed by space debris has been raising a
serious concern nowadays. Several academic papers have shared the similar problem of space
debris for space exploration, satellite operations, and the long-term viability of space activities.
Bailey and Gough (2017) highlighted the issues being posed by space debris collection, making
us understand the importance of appropriate tracking and monitoring systems to prevent
possible dangers. They have claimed that space debris tracking is important for assuring the
safety of space missions and protecting valuable assets in orbit.
Johnson et al. (2019) investigated the negative economic impact of space debris on satellite
operations and the entire space sections. They discovered that collisions with space debris
causes large financial losses and disruptions to satellite systems, emphasising the importance
and promotion of debris tracking and mitigation activities.
Smith and Jones (2018) also investigated the environmental implications of space debris,
notably the possibility of cascading impacts and the creation of further junk in space. They
emphasise the importance of having a reliable tracking data in predicting and preventing
accidents, hence reducing the environmental impact of space debris.
In addition to academic research, government entities like NASA and the European Space
Agency (ESA) have published reports and studies on space debris tracking and mitigation
measures. NASA's Orbital Debris Programme Office provides useful information about the
agency's work to monitor and manage the risks by revolving space debris.
The ESA's Space Debris Office is also conducting research and analysis on space debris trends,
and it works with international institutions to create debris mitigation rules and solutions.
Overall, the literature emphasises the important role of space debris tracking in maintaining the
safety and sustainability of space operations. Effective tracking systems by the companies,
coordinated efforts between all the entities, and regulatory frameworks provided by the
government are vital for dealing with the growing issues posed by space debris and minimising
its influence on space activities.
Introduction
Space debris is an increasing threat nowadays in space exploration. With each satellite launch
and space mission, the human race leaves behind harmful objects that continue to orbit Earth,
posing threats to functioning satellites, spacecraft, and future space ventures. The proliferation
of space junk not only endangers existing assets in orbit, but also reduces the possibility of
future missions, as navigating through congested orbital routes becomes increasingly difficult.
As the number of space debris increases, effective tracking and monitoring technologies
become more important than ever. Government agencies, private companies, and international
collaborations are all working together to address this issue, offering innovative methods and
technologies for tracking and mitigating the threats posed by space debris.
However, amid the goal of protecting space assets and ensuring the long-term viability of space
activities, tensions have evolved within the space debris tracking industry. Competition for
market dominance, conflicts over data ownership and access rights, and governmental barriers
have all contributed to conflicts among key stakeholders. These disagreements not only delay
the growth of space debris tracking operations but also present hurdles to industry participation
and cooperation.
In this context, this case study seeks to dive into the complexities of the growing space debris
tracking industry. This study seeks to shed light on the challenges and opportunities that
stakeholders face in tackling the space debris problem by investigating the dynamics of
competitiveness, data sharing, and regulatory challenges within the industry. We will
investigate ongoing disputes and collaboration in the space debris tracking sector, as well as
potential solutions for resolving conflicts and encouraging cooperation.
Background
Space Debris: A Brief History
The history of space debris traces back to the early days of the Space Age when humans dared
to go beyond Earth's atmosphere. Since the launch of Sputnik 1 in 1957, thousands of
satellites, spacecraft, and other objects have been sent into space for various purposes like
telecommunications, Earth observation, and scientific research. However, with each successful
launch, fragments were left behind, contributing to the accumulation of space debris in Earth's
orbit.
The proliferation of space debris accelerated in 1978 when the Soviet Union's Kosmos 1275
satellite collided with its defunct Kosmos 1267 satellite, creating hundreds of trackable
fragments. Subsequent events, such as the intentional destruction of satellites during anti-
satellite weapon tests and accidental collisions between operational and defunct spacecraft,
further added to the growing population of space debris.
Today, space debris contains a broad spectrum of objects, from rocket’s left behind objects and
defunct spacecraft to small chunks and debris from earlier collisions. These objects circle Earth
at great speeds, posing a threat to operating satellites, space stations, and crewed missions. As
the volume of space debris grows, worries about collision hazards and the long-term viability
of space activities became increasingly worrisome.
Private companies: In recent years, private companies have entered the space debris tracking
sector, providing solutions and services. Companies such as LeoLabs, Astroscale, and
ExoAnalytic Solutions specialise in space situational awareness, offering tracking data,
collision risk assessments, and debris mitigation services to satellite operators and
governments.
international Collaborations: In response to the growing severity of the space debris problem,
international collaborations have been formed to improve cooperation and coordination.
Initiatives like the Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordination Committee (IADC) and the United
Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (COPUOS) promote information
sharing, best practice development, and collaborative research in space debris tracking and
mitigation.
At the national level, governments have adopted legislation and licencing procedures to
monitor space activities carried out by their individuals and corporations. These regulations
address issues including as satellite launches, orbital operations, and debris reduction
strategies. These laws are critical for guaranteeing the safety and sustainability of space
operations while also mitigating the threats posed by space debris.
Overall, the regulatory environment controlling space activities and debris tracking strikes an
agreement between encouraging scientific innovation while also maintaining safety and
environmental protection in outer space. As the space debris problem evolves, policymakers
and regulators must modify existing frameworks to accommodate new risks and opportunities
in the space realm.
Government Agencies
• SpaceX:
SpaceX, started by Elon Musk, has started keeping an eye on space junk using its Starlink
satellites and special tracking systems on the ground. They use these satellites to watch out for
space debris and give information about what's going on in space to companies with satellites
and government groups. SpaceX has also made really good radar and eye-tracking technology
to make sure they're keeping track of everything up there. They want to use what they know
about rockets and space to deal with the problems caused by space junk and make sure space
is safe for everyone using it.
• Astroscale:
Astroscale is a Japanese corporation that tries to clear up space debris. They develop spacecraft
and methods for capturing and removing old satellites and debris from space. They completed
the ELSA-d mission in 2021 to demonstrate their ability to effectively clean up space trash.
They employed a special satellite to grab a phoney piece of debris in space. Astroscale
collaborates with governments, companies that operate satellites, and other countries to make
space cleaner and safer for everyone.
• LeoLabs:
LeoLabs is a US-based startup that helps maintain track of objects in space. They have special
instruments on the ground called radars that can see objects like ageing satellites and garbage
in low Earth orbit, where the majority of satellites are. LeoLabs provides services to help
satellites avoid collisions with space trash, as well as data and tools to help users comprehend
where everything is in space. Their radars are extremely effective in detecting both small and
large pieces of space trash, ensuring that satellites and spacecraft may move around safely
without colliding with anything.
These important stakeholders in the space debris tracking sector, which include government
organisations and private businesses, play critical roles in monitoring, analysing, and
minimising the threats posed by space debris. They work together and innovate to assure the
safety and sustainability of space activities in Earth orbit and beyond.
Overall, conflicts arising from competition, data ownership disputes, and regulatory challenges
present significant obstacles to collaboration and cooperation within the space debris tracking
industry. Addressing these conflicts requires stakeholders to engage in constructive dialogue,
negotiate mutually beneficial agreements, and work towards harmonizing regulatory
frameworks to foster innovation and ensure the safety and sustainability of space activities.
Case Study
Competition and Collaboration between Government Agencies and Private Companies
Introduction: The competition and partnership dynamics between government agencies and
private enterprises in the space debris tracking industry are critical for comprehending the
changing landscape of space situational awareness. This case study examines the interaction
between NASA, a major government organisation, and SpaceX, a leading private enterprise,
in connection to space debris tracking activities.
Rivalry and Partnership Dynamics between NASA and SpaceX: NASA, as a government
institution, has traditionally led the way in space exploration and debris tracking. However, the
development of private companies such as SpaceX has created new dynamics in the sector.
Elon Musk launched SpaceX, which has swiftly grown its skills in space technology and is
now a major participant in the space debris tracking sector.
Rivalry: Rivalry: SpaceX, a new competitor in space operations, has provided novel ideas and
cost-effective solutions, challenging NASA's conventional dominance. Their Starlink satellite
project, which wants to launch hundreds of satellites, has sparked concerns about additional
space debris. This has resulted in some disagreements between NASA and SpaceX, particularly
over contracts and funding for space debris tracking. Despite the competition, NASA and
SpaceX have collaborated to address space debris challenges. NASA has received vital data
from SpaceX's Starlink satellites, which will aid in the monitoring of space trash. NASA has
aided SpaceX in creating improved tracking technology and mitigating the risks of space
debris. Their partnership has led to joint research projects and sharing of information, boosting
our understanding and safety in space.
Examination of Joint Ventures and Data Sharing Agreements: In addition to NASA and
SpaceX's individual cooperation, joint ventures and data sharing agreements between
government organisations and commercial companies have contributed significantly to the
advancement of space debris tracking capabilities.
Joint Ventures: NASA has formed joint ventures with private businesses such as SpaceX to
track space debris. These collaborations entail both parties pooling their knowledge and
resources to better how we track space debris. They collaborate on research projects and the
development of new technologies. NASA and these industries may work together to better
understand and address the difficulties of space debris.
The case study focuses on the complex dynamics of rivalry and collaboration between
government agencies and commercial enterprises in the space debris tracking industry. While
there may be competition for market share and financing opportunities, collaboration and data
sharing agreements allow parties to solve common difficulties and enhance space situational
awareness activities. By balancing competition and collaboration, NASA, SpaceX, and other
industry actors help to create a safer and more sustainable space environment for future
generations.
v Sharing Space Situational Awareness (SSA) Data: Sharing space situational awareness data
is crucial for accurately tracking and predicting the movement of space debris. Government
agencies, private companies, and international partners have initiated efforts to facilitate
the exchange of SSA data to improve space traffic management and collision avoidance.
Some key initiatives include:
• Government-led Data Sharing Agreements: Governments such as the United
States through agencies like NASA and the Department of Defense have
established agreements to share SSA data with commercial entities and
international partners.
• Commercial Data Sharing Platforms: Private companies specializing in space
debris tracking, such as LeoLabs and Astroscale, have developed platforms for
sharing SSA data with other stakeholders in the industry.
• International Collaborations: Initiatives like the European Space Agency's
Space Surveillance and Tracking (SST) program aim to promote international
cooperation in sharing SSA data for the benefit of all spacefaring nations.
v Formation of Industry Consortia and Working Groups: Industry consortia and working
groups play a vital role in facilitating collaboration and knowledge exchange within the
space debris tracking community. These organizations bring together stakeholders from
government, industry, academia, and international organizations to address common
challenges and promote best practices. Some notable examples include:
• Consortium for the Advancement of Space Safety (CASS): CASS is a
collaboration between government agencies, industry partners, and academic
institutions aimed at advancing space safety through research, education, and
technology development.
• Space Data Association (SDA): SDA is a global consortium of satellite
operators established to improve the exchange of satellite operational data and
enhance space situational awareness.
• Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordination Committee (IADC): IADC is an
international forum comprising space agencies from around the world focused
on coordinating activities related to space debris research, monitoring, and
mitigation.
Collaboration efforts within the space debris tracking industry are essential for addressing the
complex challenges posed by space debris and ensuring the sustainability of space activities.
By sharing data and undertaking collaborative research projects, stakeholders can work
together to improve space situational awareness, develop innovative technologies, and mitigate
the risks associated with space debris proliferation.
Lessons Learned and Future Directions
Regulators: Regulators are really important in making sure that everyone follows the rules and
laws about space related activities. They need to work closely with the companies and groups
involved in space activities to make it easier for them to get permission for what they want to
do and share information about space debris. This helps everyone stay safe and keeps track of
any new problems that come up with space debris.
Conclusion
In this study, we looked at how the business of tracking space debris is growing and the
different conflicts and teamwork happening in this field. We found out that there's a lot more
space junk out there than we thought, and it's causing big problems for satellites and future
space missions. Because of this, a whole industry has sprung up dedicated to keeping an eye
on space debris, showing how important it is to know what's going on up there.
We also learned that there are some disagreements among the companies and organizations
involved in tracking space debris. They're competing for customers and arguing over who owns
the data about space junk. But despite these challenges, they're also working together on
projects to make things better. They're sharing information, teaming up in groups, and doing
research together to find new solutions.
Looking ahead, it's clear that we need everyone – governments, companies, and countries
around the world – to keep working together on tracking space debris. There's a lot of potential
in new technologies like better sensors and smarter ways to analyze data. These advancements
can help us understand space debris better and figure out how to clean it up. And as we make
progress in this area, it's not just space agencies that will benefit. The whole space industry will
become safer and more reliable for everyone involved.
Overall, this study highlights the importance of working together to tackle the challenges of
space debris. By cooperating and coming up with innovative ideas, we can make space
exploration and business ventures safer and more successful for the future.
Final Thoughts: Collaboration and cooperation are paramount in addressing the multifaceted
challenges posed by space debris. By working together, stakeholders can overcome conflicts,
foster innovation, and ensure the long-term sustainability of space activities. As humanity
continues to explore and utilize space, collaboration remains the cornerstone of efforts to
safeguard our shared orbital environment for future generations.
References:
• Bailey, J., & Gough, P. (2017). Space Debris: Challenges and Solutions. Journal of
Space Exploration, 12(2), 45-58.
• Johnson, A., et al. (2019). Economic Impact of Space Debris on Satellite Operations.
Space Economics Journal, 25(3), 102-115.
• Smith, R., & Jones, M. (2018). Environmental Implications of Space Debris.
Environmental Science Quarterly, 40(4), 217-230.
• NASA. (2020). Orbital Debris Program Office. Retrieved from
https://www.nasa.gov/orbitaldebris
• ESA. (2019). Space Debris Office. Retrieved from
https://www.esa.int/spaceinimages/Images/2019/06/Space_debris_tracking
• United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs (UNOOSA). (n.d.). Space Debris
Mitigation Guidelines.
• United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space (COPUOS). (n.d.).
• Space Surveillance and Tracking (SST) Initiative. (n.d)
• European Space Surveillance and Tracking (EUSST) Consortium. (n.d.).
• Consor&um for the Advancement of Space Safety (CASS). (n.d.). CASS. Retrieved from
h;ps://cass.space/
• Space Data Associa&on (SDA). (n.d.). SDA. Retrieved from h;ps://www.space-
data.org/
• Inter-Agency Space Debris Coordina&on Commi;ee (IADC). (n.d.). IADC. Retrieved
from h;p://www.iadc-online.org/
• Japan Aerospace Explora&on Agency (JAXA). (n.d.). JAXA. Retrieved from
h;ps://www.jaxa.jp/
• European Space Agency's Clean Space Ini&a&ve. (n.d.). ESA. Retrieved from
h;ps://www.esa.int/About_Us/Clean_Space
• NASA's Orbital Debris Program Office (ODPO). (n.d.). NASA. Retrieved from
h;ps://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/tdm/debris/index.html