“ara 2.10 DISCLOSURE OF ACCOUNTING POLICIES 22
2.8-2. Substance: over form + It means that transaction should be
: . al happening and econom
accounted for in accordance ‘with actu: Like in hire purchaew<
reality of the transactions not by its legal aa ) the hire burke af
the assets are purchased on hire purchase by Sete goog fact | ae
assets are shown in the books of hire purchesst ne ee Ui den
the hire purchaser is not the legal owner of the, a8 owner only on de
the hire purchase the purchaser, becomes | form of the transactig,
Payment of last instalment. Therefore the we er its substance. cH
is ignored and the transaction is accounte is lose all the ite: ,
2.8-3 Materiality - Financial Statement tee p ilecisions of Weadeears
facts which are sufficient enough to influence the i
user of financial statement.
Changes in Accounting Policies i
2.9 A change in accounting policies should be made in the following
conditions : seat see
Adoption of different accounting policies is required by statute or
for compliance with an Accounting Standard.
It is considered that change would result in more appropriate
presentation of financial statement.
If there is any change in accounting policies in preparation of financial
statement from one period to subsequent period, and such change
affects the state of affairs of balance sheet and profit and loss account
of current period or such change affects the financial statement of later
period, then such change must be disclosed in financial statement. The
amount, by which the financial statement is affected should be disclosed
to the extent ascertainable,
Example : Consequent upon the issuance of mandatory Accounting Standard-2
(AS 2) by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India, the company has revised
its accounting policy relating to valuation of inventories to include applicable fixed
Production overheads. The change has resulted in increase in value of inventory and
profit before tax by Rs. 252.79 million.
2.10 Comparison of AS-1 with Ind AS-1
ae ‘Disclosure of Accounting | Ind AS-1 ‘Presentation of Financial
olicies' Statements’
AS-1 deals with disclosure of | iad ASA deals with presentation of
accounting policies financial statements,
Scope is comparatively narrow,
Scope is wider.
No Such requirement
Explicit statement in the financial state-
ments of compliance with all the Indian
Accounting Standards, Further, Ind AS-1AS-1 ‘Disclosure of Accounting
Policies’
Ind AS-1 ‘Presentation of Financial
Statements’
allows deviation from a requirement of
an accounting standard.
Such bifurcation is not required
However it is required as per
the Schedule II of the Com-
panies Act, 2013
Requires presentation and provides crite-
ria for classification of Current/Non-
Current assets/liabilities—
No such prohibition. However
AS-5S requires presentation of
extraordinary item
Prohibits presentation of any item as
extraordinary Item in,the statement of
| profit and loss or in the notes.
No such requirement
Requires disclosure of judgments made
by management while framing of
accounting policies. Also, it requires
disclosure of key assumptions about the
future and other sources of measurement
uncertainty. ;
No specific restriction.
Requires classification of e
presented based on nature of expenses.
No such requirement
Requires presentation of balance sheet
as at the beginning of the earliest period
when an entity applies an accounting
policy retrospectively or makes a
retrospective restatement of items in the
financial statements, or when it
reclassifies items in its financial
statements.
No such requirement
Requires the financial statements to
includea Statement of Changes in ity
to beshown sa part of the balance sheet.
a ILLUSTRATIONS
Company follows the following policy for retirement benefits:
Contribution to pension fund is made based on actuarial valuation at the ‘year-end
in respect of employees who have opted for pension scheme. Contribution to the
gratuity fund is made based on actuarial valuation at the ‘year-end. Leave encashment
is accounted for on Pay AS YOU GO Method. Comment.
As per para 10(c) of AS-1 (refer point 2.5-3) : The “Accrual”
is fundamental
accounting assumptions, therefore, any accounting policy cannot be contrary to
fundamental accounting assumption. Policy followed for leave encashment onthe
basis of
‘PAY AS YOU GO’ is not in accordance with acct
Therefore, the accounting policy as regards leave encashme
fact it is contrary to AS-15 “Employee Benefits”,
a ee
rual assumptions.
nt is not correct, in3.14 Comparison of AS-2 with Ind AS-2
AS-2 ‘Valuation of Inventories’
Ind AS-2 ‘Inventories’
AS-2 does not contain such an
| Explains that inventories do not
include machinery spares which
can be used only in connection
with an item of fixed asset and
whose use is expected to be
irregular.
| Does not contain the definition
of fair value.
explanation of service providers,
Provides explanation with regard to in-
ventories of service providers.
Does not contain specific explanation in |
respect of such Spares.
Ind AS-2 defines fair value and provides
an explanation in respect of distinction
between ‘net realizable value’ and ‘fair
value’.
Does not deal with reversal of
write-down.
Provides detailed guidancein case of sub-
sequent assessment of net realizable
value. Also deals with the reversal of the
write-down of inventories tonet realizable
-value to the extent of the amount of
original write-down, and the recognition
and disclosure thereof in the financial
statements
Excludes from its scope the
inventories held by producers
of Agricultural and forest pro-
ducts.
Excludes from its scope only the measu-
rement of inventories held by producers
of agricultural and forest products, agri-
cultural produce after harvest, and
minerals and mineral products though it
provides guidance on measurement of
such inventories.
Comparatively requires less
disclosure
Requires more disclosuresTreatment of inter-divisional transfers
8.14 ICAI has announced that inter-divisional transfers/sales are not the
revenue as per AS-9 “Revenue Recognition”.
Since in case of inter-divisional transfers, risks and rewards remain
within the enterprise and also there is no consideration from the point of
view of the enterprise as a whole, the recognition criteria for revenue
recognition are also not fulfilled in respect of inter-divisional transfers.
8.15 Comparison of AS-9 with Ind AS-18
AS-9 ‘Revenue Recognition’ Ind AS-18 ‘Revenue’
Revenue is gross inflow of cash, | Definition of ‘revenue’ is broad compared
receivables or other considera- | to the definition of ‘revenue’ given in
tion arising in the course of the | existing AS-9 because it covers all189
ginary activities of an
wr erprise from the sale of goods,
ent the rendering of services,
or rom the use by others of
erprise resources Yielding
rest, royalties and dividends,
an
ent
intel
pristing AS 9 does not exclude
the specifically real estate
development
—