Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dissertation BA19ARC076 AK
Dissertation BA19ARC076 AK
Trauma-Informed Shelters
Bachelor of Architecture
by
Anshika Khandelwal
BA19ARC076
DECLARATION
I, Anshika Khandelwal, hereby declare that this project work titled “Rebuilding Lives:
Architectural Intervention for Psychological Rehabilitation in Trauma-Informed Shelters”
is carried out by me in the Department of Architecture of Visvesvaraya National Institute of
Technology, Nagpur. The work is original and has not been submitted earlier whole or in part for
the award of any degree/diploma at this or any other Institution / University.
Anshika Khandelwal
BA19ARC076
Date: 00.00.2024
1
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the project titled “Rebuilding Lives: Architectural Intervention for
Psychological Rehabilitation in Trauma-Informed Shelters”, submitted by Anshika
Khandelwal in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree of Bachelor of
Architecture, VNIT Nagpur. The work is comprehensive, complete and fit for final evaluation.
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to express my gratitude to all those who have helped me prepare this architectural
dissertation. I am thankful to my guide, Dr Sameer Deshkar whose timely guidance and
understanding helped me in working out this dissertation. I would also like to thank Dr Pankaj
Bahadure, Dr Pankaj Verma, and Prof. Rakesh Parmar for their inputs.
I would also like to thank my parents, friends and mentors for their unconditional support and
love.
3
ABSTRACT
The research highlights the importance of holistic design approaches that prioritise comfort,
accessibility, and inclusivity. From courtyard planning to interactive spaces, water features, and
sensory design elements, each aspect is meticulously examined for its potential to contribute to
psychological well-being. Furthermore, the study explores the significance of healing gardens
and open spaces in promoting physical activity, social interaction, and connection with nature.
By proposing practical design guidelines and recommendations, this dissertation seeks to inform
future architectural practices, emphasising the need for trauma-informed design solutions that
address the evolving needs of survivors. Ultimately, the research endeavours to transform
shelters into nurturing environments where trauma survivors can rebuild their lives with dignity,
resilience, and hope.
4
LIST OF FIGURES
3.2.3 Zoning 25
3.2.4 Circulation 25
3.2.8 View 27
3.3.3 Zoning 28
5
LIST OF FIGURES
6.1.2 Findings 39
6
TABLE OF CONTENT
Declaration 1
Certificate 2
Acknowledgement 3
Abstract 4
List of Figures 5
Table of Content 7
Introduction 11
1.1 Introduction 12
1.2 Study Area 12
1.3 Aim 13
1.4 Objectives 13
1.5 Methodology 13
1.6 Scope and Limitations 14
Understanding the Subject Matter 16
2.1 Human Trafficking 17
2.2 Human Trafficking in India 17
2.3 History of Human Trafficking in India 19
2.4 Trauma Response of Human Trafficking Survivors 20
Case Study Analysis 22
3.1 Case Study 1: Bal Sahyog, New Delhi 23
3.2 Case Study 2: Ada and Tamar House, Tel Aviv, Israel 26
3.3 Case Study 3: All India Women’s Conference Campus, New Delhi 29
Literature Review 32
4.1 Government Reports 33
4.2 Existing Literature 33
Research 36
5.1 User Experience Research 37
5.2 Survivor Story and Importance of Built Environment 38
Analysis 40
6.1 Survey 41
6.2 Research Findings: 42
6.3 Rehabilitation Support and Intervention 42
6.4 Inferences 43
7
Design Guidelines 44
7.1 Site Selection 44
7.2 Building Type 45
7.3 Planning 45
7.4 Finishes 46
7.5 Colours 46
Design Recommendations 48
8.1 Courtyard Planning 50
8.2 Horizontal Planning 51
8.3 Interactive Spaces 52
8.4 Water Features 53
8.5 Sensory Design 54
8.6 Healing Gardens & Open Spaces 55
8.7 Landscaping and Open Spaces 56
8.8 Community Integration and Support Spaces 57
Conclusions 59
References 60
8
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Introduction
1.2 Study Area
1.3 Aim
1.4 Objectives
1.5 Methodology
1.6 Scope and Limitations
9
1.1 Introduction
In a world where the shadows of human trafficking loom large, countless women and girls endure
unimaginable suffering as victims of horrendous crimes. Emerging from fractured homes and scarred by
childhood abuse, they become vulnerable targets for traffickers, trapped in a cycle of torment and despair.
Within the confines of captivity, they endure unspeakable horrors—forced marriage, torture,
starvation,forced labour, rape—stripped of their humanity and robbed of their innocence. Even upon
escape or rescue, the trauma inflicted during their time in bondage leaves an indelible mark, distorting
their perception of the world and perpetuating a cycle of anguish.
This thesis endeavours to challenge this narrative of despair by harnessing the transformative potential of
architecture. Through an exploration of psychological rehabilitation and environmental behavioural
science, this dissertation seeks to conceive a rehabilitation shelter specifically tailored to the needs of
trafficking survivors. This shelter is envisioned as a beacon of hope, offering not only physical refuge but
also a sanctuary where survivors can find solace, solidarity, and healing in the company of others who
share their pain.
Central to the shelter's design philosophy is the concept of empowerment through communal living and
holistic support. Drawing upon principles of environmental psychology and trauma-informed design, the
shelter will provide a nurturing environment conducive to healing and recovery. Here, survivors will have
access to comprehensive support services, including psychological counselling, life skills training, and
academic education, empowering them to reclaim their autonomy and rebuild their lives.
By fostering a sense of community and empowerment, the shelter aims to interrupt the cycle of trauma
that has defined these girls' existence, offering them a pathway towards a brighter, more resilient future.
While the scars of their past may never fully fade, the shelter endeavours to provide a safe haven where
survivors can forge a new sense of normalcy and resilience. Through thoughtful design and
compassionate care, the shelter aspires to instil hope and agency in those who have endured unimaginable
suffering, guiding them towards a future defined by dignity, opportunity, and renewed purpose.
10
1.3 Aim
The aim of this dissertation is to investigate the intersection of architectural design and psychological
rehabilitation, with a specific focus on trauma victims. Through a thorough exploration of evidence-based
design strategies, spatial interventions, and sensory considerations, the research seeks to establish
effective principles for creating environments that contribute to the psychological healing and well-being
of trauma survivors.
1.4 Objectives
1.5 Methodology
1. Literature review
● Conduct a thorough review of existing literature related to architectural design, psychological
rehabilitation, and trauma survivors.
● Identify key theories, principles, and empirical studies relevant to the intersection of these fields.
2. User Experience Research
● Conduct interviews, surveys, or focus groups with trauma survivors who have experienced
designed spaces.
● Explore their subjective experiences, perceptions, and preferences regarding the architecture and
design of rehabilitation spaces.
3. Sensory Design Assessment
● Investigate the impact of sensory design on psychological well-being through literature review
and case study analysis.
● Develop a framework for assessing how sensory elements contribute to the therapeutic
environment.
11
4. Design Recommendations
● Based on the research findings, propose recommendations for future architectural design practices
that prioritise psychological rehabilitation.
● Consider emerging trends and evolving needs in both architectural design and trauma
rehabilitation.
1.6.1 Scope
Multidisciplinary Approach:
The research will incorporate insights from psychology, healthcare, and sociology to provide a holistic
understanding of the psychological rehabilitation process.
Global Perspectives:
The scope includes a consideration of architectural design solutions for trauma survivors on a global
scale, acknowledging cultural diversity and varying socio-economic contexts.
User-Centred Focus:
The study will prioritise a user-centred approach, actively involving trauma survivors in the research
process to understand their needs, preferences, and experiences.
Practical Guidelines:
The dissertation aims to contribute practical and actionable design guidelines for architects and
practitioners involved in designing spaces for psychological rehabilitation.
12
1.6.2 Limitations
Resource Constraints
Limited resources, including time and permissions, may restrict the depth of the case studies and data
collection efforts.
Ethical Considerations
Ethical concerns may limit the extent to which trauma survivors can be directly involved in the research
process, necessitating careful and respectful methodologies.
Interdisciplinary Complexity
The interdisciplinary nature of the study may present challenges in synthesising information from diverse
fields and ensuring a comprehensive understanding of both architectural and psychological aspects.
13
Chapter 2
14
2.1 Human Trafficking
The recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use
of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a
position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a
person having control over another person, for the purpose of exploitation.
Human trafficking is a grave violation of human rights that affects millions of people worldwide,
exploiting them for labour, sex, or other forms of exploitation. It is often described as modern-day slavery,
involving the recruitment, transportation, harbouring, or exploitation of individuals through force, fraud,
or coercion. Victims of human trafficking come from diverse backgrounds and may be subjected to
various forms of exploitation, including forced labour in industries such as agriculture, construction,
domestic work, and manufacturing, as well as commercial sexual exploitation in brothels, massage
parlours, and other illicit venues.
Human trafficking is a highly profitable criminal enterprise, generating billions of dollars in illicit profits
for traffickers each year. Vulnerable populations, including women, children, migrants, refugees, and
individuals living in poverty or facing discrimination, are particularly at risk of falling prey to traffickers.
Trafficking operations often exploit systemic vulnerabilities, such as lack of legal protections, economic
inequality, political instability, and social marginalisation, to coerce and control victims.
India, with its vast population and complex social landscape, faces significant challenges in combating
human trafficking. The country serves as a source, transit, and destination for trafficked persons, with
various forms of exploitation prevalent across different regions. Here's an overview of the situation in
India:
Aspect Overview
Forms of Trafficking for forced labour, sexual exploitation, bonded labour, child labour, and
Exploitation organ trade are prevalent in India.
15
The Indian government has enacted legislation such as the Immoral Traffic
Government
(Prevention) Act and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act to
Response
address trafficking.
Human trafficking remains a significant challenge in India despite being outlawed under Indian
legislation. Individuals are often illegally trafficked through the country, primarily for commercial sexual
exploitation and forced or bonded labour. While precise figures are elusive, non-governmental
organisations estimate that between 20 to 65 million Indians are affected by forced and bonded labour.
Trafficking affects men, women, and children for various purposes.
Women and girls are frequently trafficked within India for commercial sexual exploitation and forced
marriage, particularly in regions where the gender ratio is heavily skewed in favour of men. On the other
hand, men and boys are trafficked for labour purposes and may also face sexual exploitation in roles such
as gigolos, massage experts, and escorts. Children make up a significant portion of those subjected to
forced labour, employed in factories, as domestic servants, beggars, agricultural workers, and sometimes
coerced into armed combat by terrorist groups.
India also serves as a destination for women and girls trafficked from neighbouring countries like Nepal
and Bangladesh for commercial sexual exploitation. Nepali children, for instance, are trafficked into India
for forced labour in circus shows. Moreover, Indian women are trafficked to the Middle East for similar
purposes. Additionally, Indian migrants who voluntarily migrate to the Middle East and Europe for
domestic service or low-skilled labour may fall victim to trafficking.
Many of these cases involve fraudulent recruitment practices, leading individuals into situations of forced
labour or debt bondage. Workers often accrue high debts to pay recruitment fees, leaving them vulnerable
16
to exploitation by employers in destination countries. Exploitative conditions may include non-payment
of wages, restricted movement, passport confiscation, and physical or sexual abuse.
The history of human trafficking in India is deeply intertwined with the country's social, economic, and
cultural dynamics, spanning centuries of exploitation and vulnerability. While the specific manifestations
and scale of trafficking have evolved over time, the roots of this issue can be traced back to various
historical factors:
Colonial Era:
The colonial period, marked by British rule in India, significantly impacted patterns of exploitation and
trafficking. The British East India Company's economic interests fueled the demand for cheap labor,
leading to the systematic exploitation of Indian labourers in various industries, including agriculture,
mining, and construction. The indentured labour system, under which millions of Indians were forcibly
transported to British colonies as cheap labourers, further entrenched the exploitation of vulnerable
populations.
Post-Independence Period:
Following India's independence in 1947, the country continued to grapple with entrenched inequalities,
poverty, and social injustices, which created fertile ground for various forms of exploitation and
trafficking. Rapid urbanisation, industrialization, and migration patterns further exacerbated
vulnerabilities, particularly among marginalised communities in rural areas.
Modern Era:
In contemporary times, human trafficking in India has taken on diverse forms, including forced labor,
commercial sexual exploitation, bonded labour, child labour, and organ trafficking. Vulnerable
populations, including women, children, and marginalised communities, are disproportionately affected
by trafficking, with factors such as poverty, lack of education, caste discrimination, gender inequality, and
social exclusion contributing to their vulnerability.
Government Response:
Over the years, the Indian government has taken steps to address human trafficking through legislation,
policy initiatives, and law enforcement efforts. The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956, and its
subsequent amendments, along with other relevant laws, provide a legal framework to combat trafficking
and protect the rights of victims. Additionally, various government agencies, NGOs, and civil society
organisations are actively engaged in prevention, rescue, rehabilitation, and prosecution efforts.
17
2.4 Trauma Response of Human Trafficking Survivors
Human trafficking survivors often endure severe and prolonged trauma resulting from their exploitation
experiences. The trauma response of survivors is multifaceted and can manifest in various physical,
psychological, and emotional symptoms. Understanding these trauma responses is crucial for providing
effective support and interventions to help survivors heal and rebuild their lives.
Bruises and injuries Resulting from physical abuse, beatings, or forced labour.
Malnutrition and dehydration Due to inadequate food, water, and poor living conditions.
Reproductive health issues Including sexually transmitted infections and unwanted pregnancies.
Physical Trauma of Human Trafficking Survivors
18
2.4.3 Emotional Trauma
Trafficking survivors often experience intense emotional distress resulting from their exploitation
experiences. Table 3 illustrates common emotional trauma responses observed in survivors:
Fear and Mistrust Fear of traffickers, authorities, and difficulty trusting others.
Grief and Loss For lost opportunities, relationships, and sense of identity.
In conclusion, human trafficking survivors often experience a complex array of trauma responses
resulting from their exploitation experiences. Understanding these responses is essential for providing
survivors with the support, interventions, and resources they need to heal and rebuild their lives
effectively.
19
Chapter 3
20
3.1 Case Study 1: Bal Sahyog, New Delhi
Established in 1954
21
Planning is introverted. There are 4 building blocks.
The first block has the administration and the library on the ground floor
and the school rooms on the first floor. Connected to the school building
through a semi-enclosed staircase is the dining hall, kitchen and
counselling facilities.
The hall is also used as a multi-purpose room for games, T.V. etc. are
adjacent to five dormitories each having 14 to 20 students crammed in it.
Natural light and ventilation is not adequate. Each dormitory is divided into
two areas - bed space and storage and clothes drying space.
The toilets are not attached to the dormitory but are opposite it. The health
clinic and staff quarters are also opposite it. The dormitories and the staff
quarters were barracks initially.
22
Rooms are entered through a doubly loaded corridor. The buildings have north south orientation. Except
for the vocational training centre, the site planning leaves much to be desired for.
Hierarchy of spaces
The staff directs the movement of the students
through rigid rules. There is no concept of
private space.
Open spaces
There are two major open spaces:
i. The courtyard in the centre of the building
blocks which is used for parking, assembly,
sleeping on hot summer nights and informal
games.
ii. The playgrounds at the back of the complex
which are used for organised games like
basketball and cricket.
Architectural aesthetics
The buildings are rectangular shaped. Each building is painted a different colour. Due to this there is no
progression of spaces and no unity in the design, all the buildings except the training institute are single or
double storey.
The Bal Sahyog Home is a physical structure which is not related to the needs of the child or the
community. It is just a shelter from the basic elements and nothing more.
23
Ventilation and lighting
Natural
The spaces had very small windows which resulted in dark and dingy spaces. The space was not at all
pleasant to live in.
Artificial
The lighting is not adequate in any of the spaces except for the dining hall. Overall, almost all the spaces
inside the shelter were dark and dingy and did not have a very welcoming feel to them.
3.2 Case Study 2: Ada and Tamar House, Tel Aviv, Israel
User Group Women and child victims of Domestic Violence Staff Workers
FAR 0.7
24
Program Components
The shelter houses a diverse range of
functions:
● Communal Areas
● Kindergarten
● Counselling
● Computer room and Classrooms
● Laundry Facilities, kitchens and a
refectory
● Independent living quarters for each
family Staff Accommodation
● Office areas for the shelter's manager
and staff (including social workers, a
child psychologist, housemothers, a
child care worker, and a part- time
lawyer).
Conceptual Underpinnings
Led by pioneering human rights activists, the facility provides a
refuge for distressed and abused women and children from all
localities and backgrounds (ArchDaily, 2018). This shelter is one of
only a handful in the world which has been designed and built in
consultation with the staff who will occupy and run it.
The architect conjured up the idea of stone, hollowed out from the
inside, leaving it with two surfaces: a rough external one, while the
inner would be smooth and delicate. This analogy became the main
concept for the building which has two facades - the secure and
protective exterior, and the inner façade, the therapeutic "heart" of
the shelter" (ArchDaily, 2018).
25
Access-Control: The built works in a manner to become the security of
the complex. The inward looking space allows for little permeability
which assures privacy and control.
Levels of Publicness: This shelter opens itself to the public only via the
function of the nursery, which functions both separately and as a part of
the site.
Quality of Space: The space keeps in mind the turbulent history of its
users, designed to preserve their privacy and peace of mind while giving
complete freedom within the complex. The central green lends a healing
vibe to the space.
Pedestrian Movement
The site does not have a clear pedestrian movement, but the
circulation creates a loop situation between all major functions which
feeds into their cores.
Vehicular Movement
The site has maximum vehicular penetration. The road loops around
the main building for a drop-off to the hostel at the north-end of the
site. It has two gates, but only one remains functional and serves as
both entry and exit. There is no separate service movement.
The shelter uses calm, muted, grey tones and textures to convey a sense of peace, which are
complemented by the greens of the central space. The juxtaposition of glass, steel and grey linear textures
gives a modern, stern yet reassuring, solid eel to the space.
The fort-like built also lends a sense of protection and security to the people who have been victims of
violence and often fear further such attacks by the perpetrators.
26
3.3 Case Study 3: All India Women’s Conference Campus, New Delhi
Arithmetic Data
FAR 1
27
Connectivity
Bus Stop: Aga Khan Hall, 10 m
Metro Station: Mandi House, 650 m
Railway Station: NDLS, 2.7 km
Airport: IGI Airport, 16 km
Program Components
The complex currently consists of the following
elements:
● Working Women's Hostel Short Stay Home
● Skill Development
● Bank Office
● AIWC Office
● Aga Khan Hall
● Eco-Measures
Areas
Conceptual
Underpinnings
The All India Women's
Conference is a
non-governmental
organisation based in
Delhi. It was founded 1 1927 by Margaret Cousins in
order to improve educational efforts for women and
children and has expanded its scope to also tackle other
women's rights issues. It aims at Emancipation,
Education and Empowerment of Women. The complex
is situated in a city with a record-high crime rate
against women, seeking to serve their needs in a
multitude of ways, and its location in the capital is
representative of women's rights across the country.
Access-Control
AIWC is a secure campus with multiple manual checkpoints, and electronic surveillance. They're
extremely strict about access to the hostels, and visiting the short-stay is close to impossible. However,
the residents retain the right to roam the site.
28
Levels of Publicness
The privacy and security of the campus increases as you go towards the rear and vertically upwards. The
public interface is at the foremost for ease of access and to ensure privacy of the residents.
Quality of Space
The indoor spaces are adequate with decent daylight penetration for
the hostels. The short-stay home has been built more like a plotted
residence which lends a home-like feeling, but the interior spaces are
confined and dingy.
Typology
Hostels- Linear, double-loaded corridor, facing an open space
Short Stay Home- Plotted house type
Offices and Skill Development- Mid-Rise
Building with large floorplate
Staff Housing- Informal low-rise development
29
Chapter 4
Literature Review
30
4.1 Government Reports
Human trafficking remains a pressing issue globally, with India being no exception. This literature review
aims to examine the status of human trafficking in India based on government reports, focusing on data
presented by the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) in response to parliamentary inquiries. By analyzing
trends in reported cases, arrests, charge-sheets, convictions, and acquittals, this review seeks to shed light
on the complexities and challenges surrounding combating human trafficking in India.
31
Biological factors play a significant role in the development of mental health issues among sex-trafficked
individuals. Chronic stress associated with sexual exploitation induces neurochemical and structural
changes in the brain, particularly impactful in child victims. These changes involve alterations in gene
expression and dysregulation of stress hormones, contributing to conditions such as depression, anxiety,
and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Fig 4.2.1 - Social causes for Human Trafficking according to Levine, 2016
Genetic predisposition further exacerbates the vulnerability of sex-trafficked individuals to mental illness.
Victims often come from families with high prevalence of depression, schizophrenia, and substance
abuse, suggesting a genetic link to their susceptibility. Additionally, epigenetic influences, such as
maternal substance abuse during pregnancy, further compound the risk of mental health issues in
survivors.
Psychosocial factors, including exposure to crime, drug abuse, and poverty, create a detrimental social
ecology for sex-trafficked individuals. These factors contribute to a cycle of violence, independently
impacting mental health. The social stigma and isolation faced by survivors post-rescue exacerbate their
psychological distress, highlighting the need for comprehensive mental health interventions.
Prevalence data on mental health issues among sex-trafficked individuals vary due to methodological
disparities and sample heterogeneity. However, studies consistently report high rates of anxiety,
depression, and PTSD among survivors. Moreover, survivors often experience secondary physical
illnesses, such as sexually transmitted diseases, malnutrition, and cardiovascular issues, stemming from
the mental trauma endured.
Effective mental health treatment for survivors necessitates early detection and comprehensive
intervention. Trauma-focused cognitive behavioural therapy is commonly utilised, but emerging research
suggests the inadequacy of PTSD diagnosis in capturing the complex trauma experienced by survivors.
32
Long-term support, multidisciplinary care, and consideration of Disorders of Extreme Stress are crucial in
addressing the mental health needs of survivors.
Healthcare organisations play a pivotal role in supporting victims of sex trafficking. Protocols for
identifying and managing victims, collaboration with law enforcement and social services, and provision
of comprehensive care are essential in addressing the multifaceted needs of survivors.
However, research in this field faces significant limitations. Sample representativeness, missing data, and
ethical concerns hinder progress in understanding the mental health implications of sex trafficking.
Moreover, limited funding and low priority exacerbate the challenges in addressing this pervasive issue
effectively.
In conclusion, the mental health consequences of sex trafficking demand urgent attention and
comprehensive research efforts. Addressing the complex interplay of biological, genetic, and
psychosocial factors, alongside enhancing healthcare organisation and research methodologies, is
essential in mitigating the profound suffering endured by survivors of sex trafficking.
While the paper primarily focuses on the mental health implications of sex trafficking, it provides
valuable insights that can inform the understanding of the built environment's role in the psychological
rehabilitation of survivors.
33
Chapter 5
RESEARCH
34
5.1 User Experience Research
What features would you envision in a mental health facility to prioritise healing?
● The internal ambiance should promote tranquillity and approachability.
● Maintain comfortable temperatures year-round and ensure fresh air quality.
● Architectural design should align with therapeutic goals, fostering well-being and uplifting
patients' and visitors' moods.
What about the kind of materials and textures you find work best?
● Aim for coordinated finishes, fittings, furniture, and colours to minimise clutter.
● Employ a neutral colour palette and select materials with infection control in mind.
35
Interview with an NGO Staff
A brief interview was conducted with the staff member of a Delhi-based NGO fighting against human
trafficking called Empower People.
Do you have any thoughts about the private vs. public spaces in your facility?
For the Privacy, isolation and communality:
● Requirements of visual and acoustic privacy
● Requirements for gender segregation
● Infection control regimes including isolation rooms and beds.
● Reception areas should enable confidential conversations without embarrassment.
● The design should help avoid unintended isolation, allowing patients to communicate with staff
when needed.
Do you have any thoughts on natural lighting vs artificial lighting, the use of colour and shading
based on patient responses?
Colour:
The contribution of colour to providing continuity and variety, stimulation and calmness should be
thought through. Colour schemes should assist way-finding.
Daylight:
Maximise the use of natural light to improve the environment for patients, staff, and visitors. Design
internal spaces and courtyards to optimise sunlight exposure.
Artificial light :
Lighting should be used creatively and sensitively to enhance the use and experience of the
Interiors.
From the design of buildings to the layout of neighbourhoods and cities, architectural decisions can have
profound effects on various aspects of health, including physical, mental, and social well-being. This
report aims to explore the relationship between architecture and health, highlighting key findings from
research in the field and providing insights for architects and urban planners to promote healthier
environments (Ranganathan, 2021).
36
Fig 5.1.1 -Survivor’s Journey
1. Physical Health:
One of the primary ways in which architecture influences physical health is through its impact on indoor
air quality, thermal comfort, and access to natural light. Poor indoor air quality, inadequate ventilation,
and exposure to pollutants can lead to respiratory problems and other health issues. Conversely,
well-designed buildings with proper ventilation systems and ample natural light can promote better
respiratory health and overall well-being.
2. Mental Health:
Architecture also plays a crucial role in shaping mental health outcomes. Research has shown that access
to green spaces, natural elements, and views of nature can have a positive effect on mental health,
reducing stress, anxiety, and depression. Additionally, the design of spaces can influence social
interactions and feelings of connectedness, which are important determinants of mental well-being.
3. Social Health:
The design of neighbourhoods and urban environments can impact social health by either fostering or
hindering social connections and community engagement. Walkable streets, mixed-use developments, and
well-designed public spaces encourage physical activity and social interaction, which are essential for
building strong communities and reducing feelings of isolation and loneliness.
37
Chapter 6
ANALYSIS
6.1 Survey
6.2 Research Findings
6.3 Rehabilitation Support
and Intervention
6.4 Inferences
38
6.1 Survey
Expanding on Nightingale's insights, modern research continues to unveil the multifaceted ways in which
light influences our health. From its impact on vitamin D synthesis to its role in regulating hormone
levels, light serves as a vital component in our biological processes. Moreover, studies have linked
exposure to natural light with reduced stress, improved cognitive function, and faster recovery times from
illness or surgery.
39
6.2 Research Findings
Indoor Air Quality Poor indoor air quality is linked Buildings should prioritise
to respiratory problems and proper ventilation and air
decreased productivity. filtration systems to improve
indoor air quality and promote
occupant health.
Access to Nature Exposure to green spaces and Incorporating green spaces and
natural elements is associated biophilic design principles into
with reduced stress and architectural projects can
improved mental well-being. enhance the health and
well-being of occupants.
Addressing the trauma response of human trafficking survivors requires a comprehensive and
trauma-informed approach. Table 5 outlines key principles and strategies for supporting survivors in their
recovery journey:
Mental health support Access to counseling, therapy, and psychiatric care to address
trauma-related symptoms.
Empowerment and autonomy Supporting survivors in regaining control over their lives and
decision-making.
Peer support Connecting survivors with peer networks for validation, understanding,
and support.
40
6.4 Inferences
Architecture holds immense potential in shaping human health outcomes, from enhancing indoor air
quality to fostering social connections and promoting mental well-being. This potential becomes
particularly crucial in the context of trauma-informed shelters for human trafficking survivors, where the
physical environment plays a vital role in supporting psychological rehabilitation and healing.
41
Chapter 7
DESIGN GUIDELINES
42
7.1 Site Selection
To ensure the optimal construction of these buildings, it is essential to select locations in pristine,
unpolluted environments rich in vegetation. The chosen site should offer ample space to accommodate a
pleasant atmosphere that evolves with the changing seasons.
Selecting areas free from pollution preserves the integrity of the environment and enhances the overall
aesthetic appeal. The presence of dense vegetation not only adds visual charm but also contributes to air
purification and biodiversity conservation, thereby promoting sustainable practices.
Furthermore, the generous size of the site facilitates the creation of a welcoming environment conducive
to relaxation and contemplation. The survivors can immerse themselves in the tranquillity of the
surroundings, appreciating the natural beauty that unfolds with each passing season.
Simplicity and organic design approaches are highly valued, aiming to create spaces that resonate with
users. Embracing basic forms such as circles and squares fosters a sense of familiarity and comfort,
facilitating ease of use and navigation within the built environment. By incorporating these elemental
shapes, users can quickly understand and engage with the surroundings, promoting a sense of belonging
and connection.
Moreover, a deliberate avoidance of overly institutional aesthetics is prioritized, ensuring that structures
do not appear imposing or sterile. Instead, the focus is on imbuing the built environment with warmth and
humanity, evoking a sense of approachability and inclusivity.
Central to this ethos is the notion of human-scale design, where the proportions of structures and spaces
are tailored to accommodate the needs and preferences of individuals. This entails creating environments
that feel inviting and accommodating, promoting a sense of well-being and belonging among users.
In essence, by prioritizing simplicity, organic forms, and human-scale design principles, the aim is to
cultivate environments that resonate with users on a personal level, fostering a sense of comfort,
connection, and community.
7.3 Planning
Opting for low-rise structures that harmonize with nature is essential, fostering a seamless connection
between the built environment and the surrounding landscape. Embracing a scattered approach to building
placement has demonstrated its efficacy, yielding a diverse array of high-quality spaces in between. This
43
strategy not only enhances the aesthetic appeal but also promotes the creation of dynamic and engaging
environments.
Central to this approach is the incorporation of various elements that enhance the overall experience.
Internal and external courtyards, water features, gazebos, and meticulously landscaped gardens should be
integral components of the design. These elements not only add visual interest but also provide
opportunities for relaxation, recreation, and contemplation, enriching the overall ambiance of the space.
By strategically integrating these features, the aim is to create a holistic environment that encourages
interaction with nature while simultaneously fostering a sense of serenity and well-being. This thoughtful
combination of low-rise structures and natural elements ensures that the built environment complements
and enhances the beauty of its surroundings, creating a harmonious and inviting atmosphere for all who
inhabit or visit the space.
7.4 Finishes
Prioritising warmth and natural aesthetics, both internal and external finishes should steer clear of a cold,
clinical, or institutional look. Instead, embracing locally-sourced materials like stone, wood, bamboo, and
mud bricks is favoured over synthetic alternatives, as they foster a stronger connection to the surrounding
environment.
By opting for these organic materials, the built environment seamlessly blends with the natural landscape,
creating a sense of harmony and tranquillity. Moreover, using materials sourced from the local region not
only reduces environmental impact but also supports the local economy and cultural identity.
The essence of this approach lies in creating spaces that feel familiar and inviting, evoking a sense of
comfort and belonging in users. As the environment becomes more natural and reflective of its
surroundings, users are more likely to feel at ease and connected to their surroundings, promoting a sense
of well-being and harmony.
7.5 Colours
Colors play a significant role in influencing human emotions and perceptions, eliciting various feelings
and energies. Warm and luminous colors tend to promote increased activity, alertness, and participation.
These hues can create a vibrant and energizing atmosphere within a space. On the other hand, pure colors,
which are bold and intense, can evoke drama and cheerfulness, adding dynamism and excitement to an
environment.
In addition to the emotional impact, the choice of colours should be tailored to the intended use and time
spent in a room. Different activities and times of day call for specific colour treatments to optimise
functionality and ambiance. For instance, large surfaces benefit from soft and soothing pastel hues, which
help create a sense of spaciousness and tranquillity. Conversely, small surfaces can be painted with bright
and vivid colours to inject personality and vitality into confined spaces.
44
By carefully considering the psychological effects of colours and aligning them with the purpose and
scale of each space, designers can craft environments that not only look visually appealing but also
support the intended activities and enhance the overall well-being of occupants. This thoughtful approach
to color treatment ensures that rooms are not only aesthetically pleasing but also functional and conducive
to specific moods and activities.
45
Chapter 8
DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONS
46
8.1 Courtyard Planning
Courtyard planning stands as a cornerstone in the
architectural intervention for the psychological
rehabilitation of survivors of human trafficking. It
transcends mere spatial optimization, embodying a
profound commitment to fostering community,
promoting well-being, and ensuring holistic recovery
within shelter environments. At its essence, courtyard
planning embodies the harmonious integration of natural
elements and human habitation, creating spaces that
resonate with tranquillity, vitality, and purpose.
The significance of courtyards lies in their ability to optimise space while nurturing a sense of connection
with the surrounding environment. By harnessing natural light and ventilation, courtyards infuse shelter
interiors with a sense of openness and vitality, counteracting the potential claustrophobia often associated
with enclosed spaces. This infusion of natural elements not only enhances the aesthetic appeal of shelters
but also contributes to the psychological well-being of survivors, offering a refuge of serenity amid
tumultuous circumstances.
Incorporating courtyard planning into shelter architecture represents a commitment to the holistic
well-being of survivors, recognizing that true healing encompasses not only physical safety but also
emotional, social, and spiritual restoration. By embracing the principles of courtyard design— optimizing
space, fostering community, and enhancing well-being—architects can create environments that serve as
sanctuaries of healing and renewal for survivors of human trafficking.
47
8.2 Horizontal Planning
Horizontal planning emerges as a paradigm of architectural intervention aimed at nurturing a sense of
community, fostering individual agency, and promoting holistic recovery among survivors of human
trafficking. Unlike its vertical counterpart, which often evokes connotations of institutionalisation and
hierarchy, horizontal planning prioritises inclusivity, accessibility, and human-centred design principles.
At its core, horizontal planning embodies a commitment to breaking down physical and metaphorical
barriers within shelter environments, creating spaces that encourage collaboration, connection, and
empowerment. By dispersing communal areas, living quarters, and support services across a single level,
horizontal layouts facilitate seamless interaction among survivors, fostering a sense of belonging and
shared purpose.
Moreover, horizontal planning affords survivors a greater degree of autonomy and control over their
living environment, empowering them to navigate their recovery journey on their own terms. Rather than
being confined to designated areas or subjected to strict rules and regulations, survivors are encouraged to
explore, express themselves, and participate actively in shaping their communal space.
From a psychological perspective, horizontal planning represents a departure from the regimented
routines and spatial constraints characteristic of institutional settings, offering survivors the freedom to
reclaim their individual identities and exercise agency over their lives. By fostering a sense of community
ownership and collective responsibility, horizontal layouts create fertile ground for healing, resilience, and
social integration.
Incorporating horizontal planning principles into shelter architecture thus represents a profound
commitment to the holistic well-being of survivors, recognizing that true recovery encompasses not only
physical safety but also emotional, social, and psychological restoration. By embracing the principles of
inclusivity, accessibility, and empowerment, architects can create environments that serve as catalysts for
transformation and renewal, laying the foundation for a brighter, more hopeful future for survivors of
human trafficking.
48
8.3 Interactive Spaces
Interactive spaces play a pivotal role in the architecture of psychological rehabilitation for survivors of
human trafficking, providing environments that facilitate engaged learning, healing, and personal growth.
Departing from traditional lecture-based approaches, interactive spaces are designed to promote active
participation, experiential learning, and peer support within shelter settings.
These spaces serve as incubators for innovation and creativity, offering survivors opportunities to explore
new skills, hobbies, and interests in a supportive and nurturing environment. Whether through art therapy
sessions, vocational training workshops, or group therapy activities, interactive spaces empower survivors
to reclaim their sense of agency, discover their strengths, and envision a brighter future beyond the
shadows of their past.
Moreover, interactive spaces serve as catalysts for personal transformation and self-discovery, providing
survivors with the tools, resources, and encouragement they need to embark on a journey of healing and
growth. Whether through individual counselling sessions, peer support groups, or mindfulness
workshops, survivors are empowered to explore their inner landscapes, confront their past traumas, and
chart a course toward a brighter, more hopeful future.
Incorporating interactive spaces into shelter architecture thus represents a commitment to the holistic
well-being of survivors, recognizing that true healing encompasses not only physical safety but also
emotional, social, and spiritual restoration. By embracing the principles of engagement, empowerment,
49
and community-building, architects can create environments that serve as incubators for resilience,
renewal, and empowerment for survivors of human trafficking.
Beyond their aesthetic appeal, water features serve as catalysts for environmental sustainability,
promoting biodiversity, and ecological balance within shelter landscapes. By creating habitats for aquatic
life, supporting native plant species, and conserving water resources, these features contribute to the
creation of resilient, regenerative ecosystems that enrich the lives of survivors and foster a sense of
stewardship for the environment.
From a psychological standpoint, water features have been shown to have a calming effect on the mind
and body, reducing stress, anxiety, and promoting emotional well-being. The sight and sound of flowing
water evoke a sense of serenity and tranquility, creating a refuge of peace and solace amid the challenges
of the recovery journey.
Moreover, water features offer survivors opportunities for recreation, reflection, and contemplation,
providing spaces for meditation, yoga, and other mindfulness practices that promote healing and
self-discovery. Whether by a tranquil pond or a bubbling fountain, survivors can find moments of respite
and renewal, reconnecting with themselves and the natural world in profound and meaningful ways.
50
Incorporating water features into shelter architecture thus represents a commitment to the holistic
well-being of survivors, recognizing that true healing encompasses not only physical safety but also
emotional, social, and ecological restoration. By embracing the principles of sustainability, serenity, and
stewardship, architects can create environments that serve as sanctuaries of healing and renewal for
survivors of human trafficking, fostering resilience, and empowerment for generations to come.
Furthermore, sensory design encompasses considerations for sight, sound, touch, smell, and taste,
ensuring that all aspects of the built environment contribute to a positive and enriching experience for
survivors. Whether through the use of soothing colours, natural materials, or ambient lighting, sensory
design seeks to create environments that promote relaxation, reduce stress, and enhance overall
well-being.
By engaging the senses in this way, sensory design fosters a sense of connection to the environment and
to oneself, empowering survivors to reclaim their sense of agency and autonomy in their recovery
journey. Whether through the soft touch of a cosy blanket, the gentle glow of a candle, or the calming
sound of nature, sensory design offers survivors opportunities for self-soothing and self-expression,
promoting healing and empowerment in profound and meaningful ways.
Incorporating sensory design into shelter architecture thus represents a commitment to creating
environments that are not only functional and aesthetically pleasing but also therapeutic and healing for
survivors of human trafficking. By embracing the principles of sensory engagement, empathy, and
51
inclusivity, architects can create spaces that honour the lived experiences of survivors and support their
journey towards recovery and resilience.
Healing gardens are intentionally designed to promote physical, emotional, and spiritual well-being,
incorporating elements such as sensory plants, therapeutic landscapes, and healing rituals that engage the
senses and nourish the soul. By creating spaces that invite survivors to connect with nature, themselves,
and others, healing gardens offer opportunities for relaxation, rejuvenation, and self-discovery in a
supportive and nurturing environment.
Open spaces, meanwhile, serve as catalysts for community-building, socialisation, and empowerment,
providing survivors with opportunities for recreation, exercise, and meaningful interaction with their
peers. Whether through outdoor fitness classes, group picnics, or gardening workshops, open spaces offer
survivors a sense of belonging and camaraderie, fostering connections that transcend the boundaries of
trauma and adversity.
52
Moreover, healing gardens and open spaces offer survivors a sense of agency and autonomy in their
recovery journey, providing them with opportunities to make choices, take risks, and explore new
possibilities in a safe and supportive environment. Whether by tending to a garden bed, practising yoga on
the lawn, or simply enjoying a moment of quiet contemplation under the shade of a tree, survivors can
reclaim their sense of control and empowerment in profound and meaningful ways.
Incorporating healing gardens and open spaces into shelter architecture thus represents a commitment to
the holistic well-being of survivors, recognizing that true healing encompasses not only physical safety
but also emotional, social, and spiritual restoration. By embracing the principles of nature, nurture, and
empowerment, architects can create environments that serve as havens of healing and hope for survivors
of human trafficking, fostering resilience, and renewal for generations to come.
Moreover, open spaces offer survivors opportunities for physical movement, exercise, and recreation,
supporting their physical health and vitality while providing outlets for self-expression and empowerment.
Whether through walking paths, outdoor fitness areas, or communal gathering spaces, open spaces foster
a sense of belonging and community among survivors, creating opportunities for socialisation, support,
and solidarity in their recovery journey.
Furthermore, landscaping and open spaces play a crucial role in promoting environmental sustainability
and resilience within shelter environments, contributing to biodiversity, ecosystem health, and climate
mitigation efforts. By incorporating native plants, rain gardens, and green infrastructure into shelter
53
landscapes, architects can create environments that are not only beautiful and functional but also
environmentally sustainable and resilient to the impacts of climate change.
Incorporating landscaping and open spaces into shelter architecture thus represents a commitment to
creating environments that are not only safe and supportive but also healing and empowering for
survivors of human trafficking. By embracing the principles of nature, nurture, and resilience, architects
can create outdoor spaces that serve as havens of healing and hope, fostering connection, renewal, and
empowerment for survivors as they rebuild their lives and reclaim their futures.
Support services, meanwhile, encompass a wide range of resources and interventions aimed at addressing
the complex needs of survivors, including counselling, legal advocacy, healthcare, education, and
vocational training. By incorporating spaces for support services into shelter design, architects can create
environments that offer survivors access to the care, resources, and opportunities they need to heal, thrive,
and rebuild their lives after trafficking.
Moreover, community integration and support services play a crucial role in promoting long-term
recovery and resilience among survivors, providing them with the tools, connections, and support they
need to navigate the challenges of reintegration and rebuild their lives on their own terms. By creating
54
environments that prioritise community engagement, social support, and holistic care, architects can help
survivors develop the skills, confidence, and resilience they need to overcome trauma, achieve
independence, and pursue their goals and dreams for the future.
Incorporating community integration and support services into shelter architecture thus represents a
commitment to creating environments that are not only safe and supportive but also empowering and
transformative for survivors of human trafficking. By embracing the principles of collaboration, inclusion,
and empowerment, architects can create environments that serve as beacons of hope and healing,
fostering resilience, recovery, and renewal for survivors as they embark on the journey of rebuilding their
lives and reclaiming their futures.
55
CONCLUSION
By analysing case studies and engaging with professionals and trauma survivors, the research has
identified key spatial interventions and sensory considerations crucial for fostering feelings of safety,
empowerment, and community within shelter settings. From the thoughtful planning of courtyards to the
integration of interactive spaces, water features, and sensory design elements, each aspect has been
scrutinised for its capacity to enhance psychological well-being and promote healing.
Furthermore, the exploration of healing gardens and open spaces has underscored their significance in
facilitating physical activity, encouraging social interaction, and nurturing a profound connection with
nature—a fundamental aspect of the healing journey.
Through the proposal of practical design guidelines and recommendations, this dissertation aims to
inform future architectural practices, advocating for trauma-informed design solutions that cater to the
evolving needs of survivors. By prioritising comfort, accessibility, and inclusivity, the research
endeavours to transform shelters into nurturing environments where trauma survivors can rebuild their
lives with dignity, resilience, and hope.
In essence, this dissertation serves as a clarion call for architects and designers to recognize their role as
facilitators of healing and social progress, championing environments that not only provide shelter but
also foster healing, empowerment, and recovery for individuals impacted by trauma.
56
REFERENCES
- https://ncrb.gov.in/uploads/nationalcrimerecordsbureau/custom/1702037086Table145-2022.
pdf
- https://prsindia.org/billtrack/the-trafficking-of-persons-prevention-protection-and-rehabilit
ation-bill-2018#:~:text=The%20Bill%20provides%20for%20the,rehabilitation%20to%20t
he%20rescued%20victims
- https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Publications/Traffickingen.pdf
- Rachel Lloyds, Girls Are Us
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7698595/
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8125471/
- https://www.unodc.org/documents/human-trafficking/An_Introduction_to_Human_Traffick
ing_-_Background_Paper.pdf
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7357858/
- https://scholarworks.smith.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1966&context=theses
- https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09737030211003657
57