Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IS4651 Part4 2023
IS4651 Part4 2023
Indian Standard
ICS 93.140
BIS 2023
FOREWORD
This Indian Standard (Part 4) (Fourth Revision) was adopted by the Bureau of Indian Standards, after the draft
finalized by the Ports, Harbours and Offshore Installations Sectional Committee had been approved by the Civil
Engineering Division Council.
Based on the need felt towards formulating Indian Standard, recommendations relating to various aspects
of waterfront structures, the IS 4651 series of standards were established. This standard is one of this
series formulated on this subject and deals with general design considerations. The other parts in the series are
given below:
a) Water level raised due to tsunami and the method of calculation of hydrostatic force due to tsunami
of vertical face structure have been included in Annex B.
b) Partial load factor for quick release mooring hook (QRMH) capacity has been included.
c) Transient load combination and sustained load combination for crack width check loading has been
included
d) Deflection limit for long term effect along with load combination has been included.
e) The load factors for foundation design has been included.
f) Crane/machine operating and extreme loads has been elaborated.
g) Operating and extreme mooring force while using QRMH has been included.
h) Existing clause of exposure zone and nominal thickness of cover has been elaborated for better
understanding.
j) Clause on reaction force of the fender has been modified.
k) Clause on Reinforcement detailing of pile has been elaborated as regards to provision of ductility
requirement.
The composition of the Committee responsible for the formulation of this standard is given in Annex C.
For the purpose of deciding whether a particular requirement of this standard is complied with, the final value,
observed or calculated, expressing the result of a test or analysis, shall be rounded off in accordance with
IS 2 : 2022 ‘Rules for rounding off numerical values (second revision)'. The number of significant places
retained in the rounded off value should be the same as that of the specified value in this standard.
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
Indian Standard
PLANNING AND DESIGN OF PORTS AND HARBOURS —
CODE OF PRACTICE
PART 4 GENERAL DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS
( Fourth Revision )
1
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
b) Static(LL)
1.0 0.5 1.5 1.2 1.2 0.9
iii) Earth pressure (EP) 1.0 1.0 1.2 1.0 1.0 1.0
2
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
Table 1 (Continued)
Sl Loading Partial Load Factor
No.
3
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
Table 1 (Concluded)
where IL is Imposed load such as weight of stairways, handrails, equipment reactions and super structures etc.
c) Extreme/Survival load condition
1) 1.2 (DL + DyL + LL) +1.0 (EP) +1.0 (HyF + WL + CL) +1.0 (BF/QC);
2) 1.2 (DL + DyL + LL) +1.0 (EP) +1.0 (HyF + WL + CL) +1.2 (EL);
3) 1.2 (DL + DyL + LL) +1.0 (EP) +1.0 (HyF + WL+ CL) +1.2 (TL); and
4) 1.2 (DL + DyL + LL) +1.0 (EP) +1.0 (HyF + WL + CL) + 1.2 (EWiF).
d) Temporary load condition
1) 1.2 (DL + DyL + LL) +1.0 (EP) +1.0 (HyF + WL + CL)
e) Reversal load condition
1) 0.9 (DL + DyL + LL) + 1.0 (EP) + 1.0 (HyF + WL + CL) +1.5 (BF or MF); A reversal load is a type of fatigue
loading where a material is loaded
2) 0.9 (DL + DyL + LL) + 1.0 (EP) + 1.0 (HyF + WL + CL) +1.5 (EWiF); and in tension and compression within
a single cycle.
3) 0.9 (DL + DyL + LL) + 1.0 (EP) + 1.0 (HyF + WL + CL) 1.5 (EL).
11 For Foundation design of piles adequate factor of safety for skin friction and end bearing should be considered as recommended in
IS 2911 (Parts 1 and 2) along with load factor of 1 for load combination of limit state of collapse.
5.2 Crane/machine operating loads [4.1 (b), 4.1 (d) 5.3 Crane/Machine Extreme Loads
and 4.1 (e)] along with dead load [4.1 (a)], combined
Load specified by manufacturer for storm condition
with wind load specified by the manufacturer for
shall be considered appropriately. Also the limiting
operation should be taken for design purposes.
deflection shall be as per manufacturer’s
4
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
specification or based on crane load capacity. 6.2.3 Partial Safety Factor for Material Strength
5.4 As berthing of vessel is deemed to be done in When assessing the strength of a structure or
relatively calm conditions, the berthing forces may structural member for the limit state of collapse, the
not be considered to occur simultaneously with values of partial safety factors shall be taken as 1.5
crane/machine operating load [4.1 (b), 4.1 (d)] and for concrete and 1.15 for steel.
[4.1 (e)], wind loads [4.1 (k)] or seismic forces
[4.1 (q)]. 6.3 Working Stress Method
5.5 Wind load [4.1 (k)] and seismic forces [4.1 (q)] Working stress method or permissible stress method
need not be deemed to act simultaneously. may also be adopted in the designs till such time the
complete changeover to the limit state method is
5.6 Seismic forces [4.1 (q)] need not be combined made in other relevant Indian Standards on the
with erection stage stresses [4.1 (n)], berthing forces subject. However, as the limit state method is more
[4.1 (h)] and mooring forces [4.1 (j)]. rational and adoptable, the designs may be carried
out by limit state method.
5.7 Tsunami forces [4.1 (r)] need not be combined
with erection stage stresses [4.1 (n)], berthing forces 7 PERMISSIBLE STRESSES
[4.1 (h)] or mooring forces [4.1 (j)] and secondary
stresses [4.1 (m)]. 7.1 The following permissible stresses shall be
adopted for the working load method of design:
5.8 For QRMH (quick release mooring hook),
Operating mooring force MF 7.1.1 When the load items mentioned in 4.1 (a) to
= 0.55 × n × SWL 4.1 (r) are considered for possible appropriate
Extreme mooring force MFE combination, the following shall be applicable,
= SWL+ (n ‒ 1) × 0.8 × SWL subject to the stipulations contained in 7.1.2:
where
a) For reinforced concrete structural
n = Number of hooks; and
members, the permissible stresses shall be
SWL = Safe working load of hook.
as specified in IS 456;
6 METHOD OF DESIGN b) For prestressed concrete structural
members, the permissible stresses shall
6.1 Structures and structural elements may be conform to those specified in IS 1343;
designed by limit state method.
c) For structural steel members, the
6.1.1 RCC and pre-stressed concrete members can permissible stresses shall be as specified in
be designed by limit state method whereas for IS 800;
designing structures with other material, working d) For timber structural members, the
stress method should be adhered to. permissible stresses shall be as specified in
IS 883; and
6.2 Limit State Method
e) For timber or concrete piles, the safe
In the limit state method of design, a structure is bearing capacity, and/or factor of safety
considered unfit for use when it reaches a particular shall be in accordance with
state called limit state at which it ceases to fulfill the IS 2911 (Part 2), IS 2911 (Part l/Sec 1 to 4).
function or satisfy the conditions for which it is
designed. The structure shall be designed to 7.1.2 Increase in Permissible Stresses
withstand safely all loads liable to act throughout its
Under various combinations of loading, for use in
life and it shall also satisfy the serviceability
working stress design, the partial load factor of 1.0
requirements, such as, limitations on deflection and
shall be used for loads given in Table 1. The
cracking, etc.
permissible stresses in normal loading may be
6.2.1 All relevant limit states shall be considered in exceeded up to the limit as indicated in Table 2
design to ensure an adequate degree of safety and provided in no case does the stress exceed the yield
serviceability. In general, the structure shall be stress or 0.2 percent of the proof stress of the
designed on the basis of the most critical limit state material concerned.
and shall be checked for other limit states.
8 CHOICE OF CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL
6.2.2 Partial Safety Factors for Loads
8.1 The basic criteria adopted in the general choice
The values for the partial safety factor given in of construction material, such as, easy availability,
Table 1 shall normally be used. easy working, mechanical properties suited to the
5
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
6
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
assessed surface width of cracks at points nearest to cover shall be 50 mm as specified in Table 4.
the main reinforcement should not exceed 0.004
times the cover of the main reinforcement or 8.3.6 The use of precast concrete elements is
maximum crack width in different zones given in preferred for marine structures as they are cast
Table 3, whichever is minimum. Limit state of under strict quality control and, therefore, are
serviceability load combinations shall be considered able to withstand the destructive influence of
for crack width calculation. marine environments better.
8.3.5 Nominal thickness of cover (cover is concrete 8.3.7 All the limit state of serviceability load
cover to all the reinforcement) is to be provided for combinations excepting the one under seismic
the structures in marine atmosphere. It is combination and long term deflection
recommended for structures immersed in sea water, combination shall be used for maximum crack
in splash zone nominal cover shall be 75 mm and for width check of structural members and not for
all other exposure conditions (the zones above deck checking the deflection. The permissible
level, immersed and below mud line), the nominal deflection of berthing structure need not be
i) Atmospheric zone — Above splash zone and where direct wave 0.2 0.3
or spray impingement is infrequent
ii) Splash zone — Zone between the chart datum and the design 0.1 0.2
wave height (1.6 times significant wave height) above the mean
high water springs
iii) Continuous seawater immersion zone — Below splash zone up 0.2 0.3
to seabed level
7
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
checked for berthing or mooring load Rubber has come into extensive use for fender
combinations. The seismic load combination for system. Amongst various types, there may be
limit state of serviceability shall be used for hollow-cylindrical or rectangular rubber fenders,
checking the deflection of the berthing structures sandwich type known as Raykin fender buffer, steel
near the expansion joints at the deck level. The spring fenders, wood-springing type fenders,
deflection for the berthing structure need not be horizontal and vertical timber fenders, fender piles,
controlled by limiting the deflection of pile at the brushwood fenders, gravity-type fenders, torsion
soil/dredge level. fenders, floating fenders, rolling fenders,
obstruction types, etc. The choice of material and
8.4 Timber the type of fender shall be judiciously made to
serve the specific purpose in the particular case.
8.4.1 Timber has wide use in dock and harbour
structures. It can be used for sheet piles, bearing
9.2.1 Fixed fenders are fixed or mounted to the
piles, structural members in jetties, fenders, rubbing
berthing structures. The fixed fenders are again sub
strips transit sheds and warehouses, as structural
divided into the following:
members and/or for door and window frames.
a) Buckling fenders
8.4.2 The hazards which face timber are the attack b) Non buckling fenders
by fungi and insecticides; and in sea water the attack
by the marine borers. When used in dockside 9.3 Design
buildings the design shall be primarily guided by
provisions of the relevant standards and protection The design of the fenders shall be dependent on the
against the attack of fungi and insecticides. The following parameters and they should be designed
timber used in marine structure, particularly if for berth loads from ships as specified in IS 4651
subjected to fluctuating tides, is prone to attacks by (Part 3):
marine borers and require preservative treatment.
a) Size of ship
8.4.3 An effective preservative treatment of timber The fender capacity shall depend upon the
is creosoting which is normally applied by pressure
impregnation (see IS 401). ship size.
b) Berthing velocity
9 FENDERS
The berthing velocity under various
9.1 Purpose conditions and type of vessel shall be
adopted as specified in IS 4651 (Part 3).
The fenders shall absorb the impact of berthing
vessel and also the chatter of the moored vessel in c) Importance of structure
order to avoid damages to the vessel and to the The design of the fenders shall take into
structure. Functionally, fenders shall accomplish the account the importance of consequences
following purposes: suffered by the ship and the berthing
structure in case of an eventual accident
a) Absorb the berthing energy or impact of due to insufficient energy absorption
vessels and transmit a designed or capacity.
calculated force to the structure, which
shall not exceed the allowable hull d) Energy absorption
pressure; Various types of fenders absorb energy in
various ways but in most of them, the
b) The pressure exerted from the fenders
kinetic energy of the ship is stored in
system does not exceed the ship’s hull
energy of strain. Shear permits the
pressure capacity. Hold the vessel off the
absorption of larger amount of energy than
face of the structure and avoid rubbing
tension and compression. Flexure does not
against the structure and consequent
permit an efficient use of material as only a
damages to the vessel and the structure; and
small percentage of the material of the
c) Impart the thrust from berthing loads to the fender may reach the allowable stresses.
structure at predetermined or design points. Torsion permits a good use of all the
materials of a fender, particularly if tubes
9.2 Type of Fenders with thin walls are used. The flexibility of
the berthing structure together with that of
The fenders may be made of rubber, steel, timber, the fendering system may be taken into
brushwood, rope, concrete and similar material. consideration in computing the total energy
8
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
absorption capacity of the whole system. however in general depending on type of structure,
Any accepted method of analysis (such as type of soil and deflection during earthquake. The
beams on elastic foundation) may be expansion gap shall be calculated considering limit
adopted for such computation. state of serviceability load combinations and
provide suitably. The crane track shall be designed
e) Reaction force and deflection of the suitably at expansion joints. For suspended deck
fender resting on flexible long piles, length of the
expansion joint shall be based on the detailed
The maximum amount of reaction force of
a fender system on ship shall be chosen analysis of the whole structure.
taking into account:
10.3 The expansion joints in the sections shall be
i) The strength of hull; and keyed where horizontal forces are required to be
transferred to the adjoining section and shall be so
ii) The strength of the berthing structure. designed that changes in the length of the sections
The manufacturers of proprietary fenders are not hindered. The arrangement of keys for
usually supply the energy absorption, vertical support shall depend on the soil conditions,
deflection and reaction force the construction of the structure and the type of its
characteristics of the specific fenders. loading. The expansion joints shall be covered to
These should be adopted in design. It is, prevent the backfill from being washed out.
however, recommended that a factor of
safety of 2.0 should be applied over the 11 BERTHING STRUCTURE SPECIFICATIONS
calculated berthing energy.
11.1 Deck Elevation
f) Disposition of fenders
Deck elevation to be given based on extreme
The disposition of the fenders shall depend loading.
upon the location of the berths, the type of
berthing structure, conditions of berthing, 11.2 Bracing of the Piles and Temporary Bracings
etc. The longitudinal spacing for A pile driven at an inclination to the vertical to
continuous quay should not normally provide resistance to horizontal forces is known as
exceed 0.15 L where L is the length of the brace pile. Design of bracing must consider the
smallest ship. For Island berths spacing of lateral forces due to currents, waves, earthquake,
primary fenders should be in the range of berthing and mooring etc. Sometimes bracing of the
0.25 L to 0.4 L where L is the length of the piles shall be done to strengthen the structure. In the
smallest ship. If the range of design vessels case of temporary bracing, structure shall be
is large liner, an outer set of primary fender checked before and after the removal of temporary
would become necessary. The vertical as bracings.
well as horizontal disposition of fenders
shall be so designed as to prevent the ship’s 11.3 Reinforcement Detailing of Piles
hull and/or berthing structure being
The shear reinforcement need not be provided when
damaged under all tidal conditions. Ship’s
maximum shear stress calculated is less than half
bow radius and approach and flair angle
the permissible stress in accordance with 26.5.1.6
and in specific cases, may extend from the
of IS 456. For ductility requirement in piles, 12 mm
cope level to the low water level.
diameter stirrups shall be provided at a spacing of
10 EXPANSION JOINTS 150 mm c/c for distance of L/6 from the top for
piles in zone 4 and zone 5. Effective length of the
10.1 A sufficient number of expansion joints shall
pile, h shall be taken based on sway and non sway
be provided depending upon the type of the
frame condition as per Annex E of IS 456.
structure, the sub-soil and the atmosphere conditions
in order to accommodate movements arising from 12 INTEGRITY TEST/FREE VIBRATION
shrinkage, temperature changes and some yielding TEST OF BERTHING STRUCTURES
of the foundation. The steel reinforcement shall be
so designed that it also acts to provide the shrinkage The free vibration test shall be carried out to know
and temperature cracks. the natural frequency of the structure by pushing
the structure using a tug boat. The Free vibration
10.2 As a general rule, a length of 60 m to 300 m response of the structure can be recorded using three
between the expansion joints is recommended for acceleration pick-ups mounted orthogonally. This
structures, such as solid quay walls or pile supported test can be repeated after any natural calamity to
deck structures. Expansion gap shall be provided assess the damage of the structure.
9
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
ANNEX A
(Clause 2)
LIST OF REFERRED STANDARDS
IS 456 : Code for practice for plain and IS 2062 : Hot rolled low, medium and high
2000 reinforced concrete (fourth 2011 tensile structural steel –
revision) Specification (seventh revision)
IS 800 : Code of practice for use of IS 2911 Code of practice for design and
2007 structural steel in general building construction of pile foundation:
construction (third revision) (Part 1) Concrete piles,
IS 875 Code of practice for design loads (Sec 1) : Driven cast in-situ concrete piles
(other than earthquake) for 2010 (second revision)
buildings and structures:
(Sec 2) : Bored cast in-situ concrete piles
(Part 3) : Wind loads (third revision) 2010 (second revision)
2015
(Sec 3) : Driven precast concrete piles
(Part 5) : 1987 Special loads and load 2010 (second revision)
combination (Sec 4) : Precast concrete piles in prebored
IS 883 : Code of practice for design of 2010 holes ( first revision)
2016 structural timer in buildings (fifth (Part 2) : Timber piles (second revision)
revision) 2021
IS 1343 : Code of practice for prestressed IS 4651 Code of practice for planning and
2012 concrete (second revision) (Part 3) : design of ports and harbours:
2021 Part 3 Loading (second revision)
IS 1489 Specification for Portland
pozzolana cement: IS 7314 : Glossary of terms relating to port
2023 and harbour engineering (first
(Part 1) : Flyash based (fourth revision) revision)
2015
(Part 2) : Calcined clay based (fourth
2015 revision)
10
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
ANNEX B
(Clause 4.3)
FORCE DUE TO TSUNAMI
The hydrostatic force due to hydrostatic head and B -2 Th e ts una mi wave height at 10 m water depth
tsunami flow velocity can be estimated from, can be calculated as 1/3 times tsunami runup at the
coast as given Table 5. The above equation
1 𝑢𝑡2 calculates if the height of the wall is more than the
𝐹ℎ = 𝜌𝑔 [(ℎ + 3𝜂)2 + (ℎ + 3𝜂)]
2 2𝑔 tsunami run-up above the design water level.
However, if the wall height is less than (h + 3𝜂),
where
then suitably, the total hydrostatic force can be
ρ = density of seawater estimated. The static pressure force due to flow
g = acceleration due to earth gravity velocity head is adopted to be uniform throughout
h = depth of water at the toe of the structure the water depth. However, for transparent structures
η = 1/3 of the Tsunami run-up given in Table 5 such as open pile type structures, the hydrostatic
and is equal to the tsunami height at 10 m force can be neglected.
water depth
ut = velocity of water particle
B-3 The water level rise due to Tsunami shall be as
2
𝑢t = √𝑔(ℎ + 𝜂) per Table 5. The hydrostatic force due to Tsunami
of vertical face structure shall be calculated as per
where, 𝑢t is in m/s, g is in m/s2 and 𝜂 is in m. B-1 and for offshore berthing structures air gap
If the wave height is less than (ℎ + 3𝜂), suitable of 0.5 m shall be given above tsunami water level.
wall
11
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
Table 5 (Concluded)
12
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
ANNEX C
(Foreword)
COMMITTEE COMPOSTION
Ports, Harbours and Offshore Installations Sectional Committee, CED 47
Organization Representative(s)
In Personal Capacity (3353, Sector D, Pocket 3 DR M. HARIHARAN (Chairperson)
Vasant Kunj, New Delhi, 110070)
13
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
Organization Representative(s)
Institute of Engineering & Ocean Technology, Panvel SHRI DINESH GUPTA
(Part of ONGC)
Member Secretary
SHRI ABHISHEK PAL
SCIENTIST ‘D’/ JOINT DIRECTOR
(CIVIL ENGINEERING), BIS
14
IS 4651 (Part 4) : 2023
Organization Representative(s)
Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai DR R. SUNDARA VADIVELU (Convener)
15
Bureau of Indian Standards
BIS is a statutory institution established under the Bureau of Indian Standards Act, 2016 to promote harmonious
development of the activities of standardization, marking and quality certification of goods and attending to
connected matters in the country.
Copyright
BIS has the copyright of all its publications. No part of these publications may be reproduced in any form without
the prior permission in writing of BIS. This does not preclude the free use, in the course of implementing the
standard, of necessary details, such as symbols and sizes, type or grade designations. Enquiries relating to
copyright be addressed to the Head (Publication & Sales), BIS.
Amendments are issued to standards as the need arises on the basis of comments. Standards are also reviewed
periodically; a standard along with amendments is reaffirmed when such review indicates that no changes are
needed; if the review indicates that changes are needed, it is taken up for revision. Users of Indian Standards
should ascertain that they are in possession of the latest amendments or edition by referring to the website-
www.bis.gov.in or www.standardsbis.in.
This Indian Standard has been developed from Doc No.: CED 47 (18848).