Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Advanced Studies in Efficient Environmental Design and City Planning 1St Edition Ferdinando Trapani Online Ebook Texxtbook Full Chapter PDF
Advanced Studies in Efficient Environmental Design and City Planning 1St Edition Ferdinando Trapani Online Ebook Texxtbook Full Chapter PDF
https://ebookmeta.com/product/passive-house-design-planning-and-
design-of-energy-efficient-buildings-1st-edition-gonzalo-roberto/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/landscapes-of-housing-design-and-
planning-in-the-history-of-environmental-thought-1st-edition-
jeanne-haffner/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/american-city-planning-mel-scott/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/zero-to-mastery-in-environmental-
studies-no-1-environmental-studies-book-to-become-zero-to-hero-
in-environmental-studies-arnold-neel/
Environmental and Planning Law in New South Wales 4th
Edition Rosemary Lyster
https://ebookmeta.com/product/environmental-and-planning-law-in-
new-south-wales-4th-edition-rosemary-lyster/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/case-studies-in-advanced-
engineering-design-proceedings-of-the-1st-international-
symposium-1st-edition-c-spitas/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/environmental-strategy-and-
planning-in-china-1st-edition-jinnan-wang-xiahui-wang-jun-wan/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/environmental-strategy-and-
planning-in-china-1st-edition-jinnan-wang-xiahui-wang-jun-wan-2/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/solving-urban-infrastructure-
problems-using-smart-city-technologies-handbook-on-planning-
design-development-and-regulation-1st-edition-john-r-vacca/
Advances in Science, Technology & Innovation
IEREK Interdisciplinary Series for Sustainable Development
Advanced Studies
in Efficient
Environmental Design
and City Planning
Advances in Science, Technology & Innovation
IEREK Interdisciplinary Series for Sustainable
Development
Editorial Board
Anna Laura Pisello, Department of Engineering, University of Perugia, Italy
Dean Hawkes, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
Hocine Bougdah, University for the Creative Arts, Farnham, UK
Federica Rosso, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy
Hassan Abdalla, University of East London, London, UK
Sofia-Natalia Boemi, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece
Nabil Mohareb, Faculty of Architecture - Design and Built Environment,
Beirut Arab University, Beirut, Lebanon
Saleh Mesbah Elkaffas, Arab Academy for Science, Technology, Egypt
Emmanuel Bozonnet, University of la Rochelle, La Rochelle, France
Gloria Pignatta, University of Perugia, Italy
Yasser Mahgoub, Qatar University, Qatar
Luciano De Bonis, University of Molise, Italy
Stella Kostopoulou, Regional and Tourism Development, University of Thessaloniki,
Thessaloniki, Greece
Biswajeet Pradhan, Faculty of Engineering and IT, University of Technology Sydney,
Sydney, Australia
Md. Abdul Mannan, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, Malaysia
Chaham Alalouch, Sultan Qaboos University, Muscat, Oman
Iman O. Gawad, Helwan University, Egypt
Anand Nayyar , Graduate School, Duy Tan University, Da Nang, Vietnam
Series Editor
Mourad Amer, International Experts for Research Enrichment and Knowledge Exchange
(IEREK), Cairo, Egypt
Advances in Science, Technology & Innovation (ASTI) is a series of peer-reviewed books
based on important emerging research that redefines the current disciplinary boundaries in
science, technology and innovation (STI) in order to develop integrated concepts for
sustainable development. It not only discusses the progress made towards securing more
resources, allocating smarter solutions, and rebalancing the relationship between nature and
people, but also provides in-depth insights from comprehensive research that addresses the
17 sustainable development goals (SDGs) as set out by the UN for 2030.
The series draws on the best research papers from various IEREK and other international
conferences to promote the creation and development of viable solutions for a sustainable
future and a positive societal transformation with the help of integrated and innovative
science-based approaches. Including interdisciplinary contributions, it presents innovative
approaches and highlights how they can best support both economic and sustainable
development, through better use of data, more effective institutions, and global, local and
individual action, for the welfare of all societies.
The series particularly features conceptual and empirical contributions from various
interrelated fields of science, technology and innovation, with an emphasis on digital
transformation, that focus on providing practical solutions to ensure food, water and energy
security to achieve the SDGs. It also presents new case studies offering concrete examples of
how to resolve sustainable urbanization and environmental issues in different regions of the
world.
The series is intended for professionals in research and teaching, consultancies and industry,
and government and international organizations. Published in collaboration with IEREK, the
Springer ASTI series will acquaint readers with essential new studies in STI for sustainable
development.
ASTI series has now been accepted for Scopus (September 2020). All content published
in this series will start appearing on the Scopus site in early 2021.
123
Editors
Ferdinando Trapani Nabil Mohareb
Department of Architecture Faculty of Architectural Engineering
University of Palermo Beirut Arab University
Palermo, Italy Beirut, Lebanon
© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature
Switzerland AG 2021
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the Publisher, whether the whole or
part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation,
broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in any other physical way, and transmission or information storage and
retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter
developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publication does not
imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and
regulations and therefore free for general use.
The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book are believed
to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or the editors give a warranty,
expressed or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been
made. The publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional
affiliations.
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Switzerland AG
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Series Editor’s Foreword
The world is in the midst of a disturbance of growth, consuming populations, and environ-
mental degradation which produces many environmental challenges such as global climate
change, excessive fossil fuel dependency, and the growing demand for energy. All of these are
likely to be major challenges and one of the greatest problems facing humanity, nowadays.
The majority of the world cities are confronted with similar and comparable challenges,
including—for instance—increases in resource consumption, mobility demand, pollution,
urban sprawl, social inequities, water degradation, recycling issues, erosion of fertile topsoil,
and depletion of ecosystems. Since its early days, the discourse around “smart cities” has
included environmental sustainability as one of its core principles.
In this context, environmental design is the fundamental principle of how to shape our
cities. Almost half of the energy consumed is used in cities and urban built-up areas, that’s
why it is necessary to avoid mistakes in urban design at early stages in order to retain more
sustainable cities. City planning within the approach of Green Urbanism reflects upon practical
strategies focusing on increasing sustainability beyond and within the scope of individual
buildings.
This book on Advanced Studies in Efficient Environmental Design and City Planning
discusses how urbanism is affected by the paradigms of ecology and how smart and green
concepts, systems, and interventions could truly contribute to the construction, management,
operation, adaptation and maintenance of sustainable and resilient cities, in the framework of
both new urban developments and the transformation of existing urban environments.
The significance of this book lies within the pressing need for the integration of sustain-
ability principles in the urban design process of cities and the general need for a sustainable
city development. It will be of particular relevance to the rapid urban growth of developing
cities. As within the book’s theme, the metaphor of Green Urbanism should inspire our
imagination and reflection toward sustainable and resilient urbanism. It is a reference for those
interested in taking an action toward the environmental issues, helping them to develop their
proposals in city planning and its revolutions to be more sustainable.
v
Scientific Committee
vii
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the authors of the research papers that were selected for addition in this
book. We would also like to thank the reviewers who contributed with their knowledge and
constructive feedback in hopes of ensuring the manuscript is of the best quality possible.
A special thanks goes to the Editors of this book for their foresight in organizing this volume
and diligence in doing a professional job in editing it. Finally, we would like to express our
appreciation to the IEREK team for supporting the publication of the best research papers
submitted to the conference.
ix
Introduction
It is safe to acknowledge that the field of sustainability, a newly emergent and multidisci-
plinary field, is rapidly evolving. Having gained momentum and proved its standing over the
years, it is a pivotal response to rapid urbanization, specifically in cities of the developing
world, in addition to utter dependence on finite energy supply with an ever-increasing demand,
combined with potential damage to the world’s environmental health through effluent gas
emissions and climate change. Consequently, the world is left with an urgent need to address
energy efficiency related issues by presenting the combined strategies and management
frameworks of urban planning, architecture and construction to overcome challenges of
mobility demand, pollution, urban sprawl, social inequities, water degradation, recycling
issues, fertile topsoil erosion, and ecosystem exhaustion.
Thus, to deem a successful city as such, it must respond to the needs of the economy,
environment, and society by offering resilient infrastructure, security, and efficiency. In this
publication, the authors explore the relationship between city planning and energy con-
sumption, identifying, as a result, the factors affecting energy efficiency at, both, the micro-
and macro-levels. As main components of energy-efficient cities, energy-efficient buildings
and systems represent a key area for climate change mitigation and reduction of global energy
consumption. In part one of this book on Energy and Smart Systems, the authors present
comprehensive and significant research on passive and active design technologies, smart
automation technologies, and shading device systems; all of which lay a solid foundation for
green building and environmental efficiency. The chapters titled “Multivariable Coupling
Influence on Energy-Efficient Skylight Design”, “Performance of L-shaped Mini Louvers in
Tropical Cities in Cooling Energy Reduction: Case Study of Mumbai, Mexico City, and
Lagos” and “The Effect of Shading Devices with Integrated Photovoltaics on Energy
Efficiency of Buildings” demonstrate multiple and diverse energy efficiency measures, coupled
with renewable energy sources, such as photovoltaic integrated shading devices, simple
L-shaped mini louvers, design of skylights with exterior shades, which could significantly
improve energy performance and reduce electricity consumption and carbon emissions in
residential and office buildings.
This book further delves into strategies and measures taken to advance into efficient
environmental design, planning and sustainable development at a city-scale level. In its
chapters, authors set conditions for the governance of megaprojects to ensure their sustain-
ability as they focus on environmental, socio-economic, institutional sustainable strategies.
That being said, and with the existence of various urban sustainability measurements and
indicators, questions relating to the accuracy of these methods and their limitations cannot be
overlooked and may deliver useful insight into the assessment of city performance. Thus,
analyses of informal settlements in Africa and Asia are undertaken with the aim to develop a
more comprehensive understanding of informal settlements, establish an understanding of the
community’s needs and how addressing those needs can eventually contribute to the
achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals and advise future development strategies
in developing countries.
xi
xii Introduction
Through international case studies from Libya, India, New York, London, Paris, Tokyo,
Algiers, Amman, and more, the authors develop plans and propose strategies to contribute to
the achievement of Sustainable Development Goals. In the chapter titled “The Sustainable
Strategy to Create Decentralized Economic Hubs for Regional Development”, the decentral-
ization strategy is put forward which is based on providing economic hubs to support and
integrate with the medium- and small-scale cities by providing the missing core services for
the region, while the chapter on “Innovative Sustainable Strategies to Mobility and Urban
Transport Problems in Benghazi”, the ASI (Avoid, Shift and Improve) and TOD
(Transit-Oriented Development), aims to help cut down transport costs, reduce pollution, and
achieve high quality and sustainable mobility and urban transport systems.
In an endeavor to respond to major urban environmental and societal challenges, through a
reduction of the ecological footprint, adaptation to climate change and promotion of health,
Urban Green Infrastructure (GI) has been developed as a strategic planning approach. In
Urban Landscapes and Green Infrastructure, the authors examine current inequalities in the
distribution and access to green spaces, innovate processes of transforming green waste, and
attempt to integrate informal settlements through the use of landscape. The aforementioned, in
realizing current pressures on green spaces due to urban sprawl, derelict land, and infill
development, concluded a major contribution to the conservation and enhancement of bio-
diversity and environmental quality, promotion of social cohesion and adaptation of cities to
climate change—an inevitable and global phenomenon with impact on urban life.
In exploring the role of green infrastructures and the environment in adapting cities for
climate change, the importance and functionality of urban green spaces, often overlooked and
undervalued, are highlighted. The impact of climate change has already become more
noticeable over the years. Endured by the people and the built infrastructure, the damage of
heat waves, flooding, physical illnesses, wildfires and more, also disrupted the built envi-
ronment. The Climate and the Environment explores the potential of greening, urban climate
modeling and building thermal performance enhancement and efficiency in supporting climate
change adaptation of urban environments. In this section, the need to work at local levels to
develop Climate Action Plans and take community-wide action is discussed. Not only a
contributor to waste heat, CO2 emissions and climate change, the vast expansion of the global
urban population accompanied by the dynamic growth of cities has resulted in implications
and environmental degradation, in part, due to the unbalanced urban integration of urban
infrastructure into the urban fabric. Furthermore, these impacts may be further aggravated by
poorly ventilated urban fabrics and dense morphologies making it a necessity to address
current environmental implications, explore new and innovative mitigation strategies, and alter
the way cities are evolving.
Existing theories of sustainable development, in their journeys toward the sustainable city,
have failed to address human-oriented transportation systems which consists of healthy
neighborhoods, integrated public-soft transportation networks, and transit-oriented develop-
ment. For this reason, researchers in this volume come up with branding strategies for cities in
rural areas and develop models for integrating human-oriented transportation system frame-
works as regeneration tools for healthy neighborhoods and communities.
xiii
xiv Contents
advances made in studies dealing with the influence of
Multivariable Coupling influence Energy-efficient variable parameters on energy performance, the effect of
Skylights Optimization Simulation multivariable interactions—the ordinary state in architectural
design—has been largely neglected. This is mainly because
they employ the single-variable method of discussing one
F. Yu J. Leng (&) variable at a time or the bivariate-orthogonal method of
School of Architecture, Southeast University, Sipailou, Nanjing, analyzing interactions two by two as cross-comparison.
210018, People’s Republic of China
e-mail: jw_leng@seu.edu.cn
The bivariate-orthogonal method is one of the most pop- To address the limitations in current studies relating to
ular methods when facing multiple variables. The method multivariable interaction analysis, the response surface
simplifies the entire work into several bivariable discussions methodology (RSM) is applied in this research. RSM ana-
by means of the control variate method and to discuss the lyzes the recorded value of response metrics with process
interactions between variables in pairs (Jaber & Ajib, 2011). factors changing by design so as to make the conclusion
For example, Goia et al. (2013) discussed the influence of more objective and effective (Teglia et al., 2015). It was
WWR (5 values) combined with different orientations tested by Zhang et al. (2018) and proved to work effectively
(4 values), building scales (3 values), and HVAC systems in the nearly/net zero building energy prediction. All the
(4 values) on total energy demand in Pairs. As the variables attempts involving the RSM demonstrate its ability to
of the research are discussed two by two and shown in line describe multivariable interactions in the form of fitting
charts to make comparisons, the discussion tends to become formulas and graphs after regression analysis is performed
unclear and the multiple trends hard to discover. on groups of designed experiments. In addition, for opti-
Another way to deal with the discussion of multivariable mization where the suggested optimal solutions should not
combinations is to combine different variables together as a just be selected based on limited experiments but rather a
nominal unit and make comparison without analyzing the range of settings, this approach has been found to be effec-
quantified tendency of each parameter. The nominal unit tive (Baş & Boyacı, 2007).
may vary from structures such as complex glazing systems To present how RSM can cope with building energy
(Buratti et al., 2013) to building cases (Boyano et al., 2013). simulation for multivariable research, a sample research is
By combining the variables together, less simulation work proposed in this paper focused on strip skylights with
was required. In this way, the researchers could easily exterior shades on the roof of an atrium in Nanjing, China.
choose the cases with the best/worst performance and The framework of an RSM-based study is given, after which
compare different design strategies (Grynning et al., 2014). factor parameterization, model prediction, interaction anal-
However, the levels of each variable were rather limited— ysis, and the optimization process are presented step by
sometimes even less than three (Wang et al., 2013). As a step. A predictive model between multiple factors and
result, the conclusions of the trend analysis for a general or a energy demand is proposed to measure the effect and
specific variable could hardly be clearly defined, let alone interrelationship of factors, while optimal solutions are given
predictability and scalability. for energy-saving design strategies. Stressing the substitute
In addition, with advances in computer science, there are relations between factors and response, this paper not only
various intelligent algorithms that could be applied for shows how quantified multivariable research in the building
simulation, prediction, and optimization (Amasyali & simulation field could be carried out with the application of
El-Gohary, 2018), e.g., genetic algorithms (GA) and particle RSM, but also indicates that architects could reach similar
swarm optimization (PSO). These algorithms have been energy-efficient goals with more design choices. This may,
proved beneficial in optimizing different building compo- to some extent, change traditional attitudes toward the goal
nents where multiple variables are involved. By integrating of energy saving, which is often regarded as merely a design
these algorithms, the simulation time cost could be dropped, restriction.
and more energy could be saved in the optimal results Based on preliminary results, in Sect. 2, the theory and
(Magnier & Haghighat, 2010). However, these methods are the application of RSM are introduced. In Sect. 3, simulation
black box models with particular outputs as the optimal input settings for a sample study are constructed. Section 4
results (Machairas et al., 2014). The interaction relationship demonstrates the quantified simulation results, including the
between multiple variables was still hard to be described predictive model and optimal solutions. Section 5 discusses
(Coakley et al., 2014). the implications and limitations of the research and the
Admittedly, statistic equations with multiple variables method. Finally, Sect. 6 ends with our main conclusions.
could be formed to correlate data. There are studies working
on this with the aim of energy consumption prediction and
effect estimation (Foucquier et al., 2013). Thus, they pay 2 Methodology
more attention to the precision of the prediction and the
coupling influence was less concerned. For example, Kor- 2.1 Response Surface Methodology Working
olija et al. (2013) developed regression models to predict Steps
office building annual energy consumption. Although vari-
ous factors were involved, including built forms, orienta- RSM is a mathematic quantification approach with graphics
tions, and glazings, the effect of building parameter coupling technology to form the statistic relation between factors and
influence was not investigated. responses (Baş & Boyacı, 2007). Using DesignExpert, a
Multivariable Coupling Influence on Energy-Efficient … 5
commonly used RSM software (Kumar et al., 2007), the “predictive models” for further trend analysis and
steps of RSM can be described as follows: optimization. If the statistical adequacy test failed, the
fitting formula would be rejected. Then, the form of the
(a) Variable definition factors needs to be changed and the rest procedure
This step primarily defines the type and value range of would be circulated.
research factors. They can be either numerical or (d) Trend analysis
nominal, with the ranges set by the researchers. The With the predictive models, the general disciplines of
names of the responses are also listed in this stage. multiple variables can be analyzed. Contour graph, a
(b) Representative point selection two-dimensional display of the surface plots with lines
There are several sampling methods suitable for mul- of constant response, was used for visualizing a
tiple response optimization that have a different two-factor coupling. Thus, the influence of the factor
required number of experiments. For higher precision couplings could be investigated.
and fewer trials, D-optimality is suggested to work (e) Optimization
efficiently for multiple factors (Fang et al. 2005). By setting an optimization goal and conditions, opti-
(c) Mathematical model generation mization points for each independent variable could be
Mathematical models in the form of polynomial equa- obtained based on the predictive models. The numerical
tions, describing the relation between factors and optimization in DesignExpert uses a desirability func-
responses, could be formed after a series of tests tion, from 0 to 1, to measure the proximity of the
(Fig. 1) to check the models’ degree of fitting, relia- solution to the optimal goal. The goal-seeking process
bility, and predictability (Baş & Boyacı, 2007). First, was from several random starting points to find the
the fitting degrees of four classical models—linear, 2FI, “best” maximum of the desirability function.
full quadratic, and cubic—are analyzed after regression
analysis. The one which is statistically significant (at
0.05 level) with the highest coefficients of determina-
tion (R2) is detected and noted as “suggested.” Based on 2.2 RSM for Energy-Saving Building Design
the suggested model, stepwise regression analysis is
made for each response, where unsignificant terms (p The concept of the RSM used in studies of building energy
0.05) can be eliminated. The fit and the statistical simulation can be written as
adequacy of the model could be tested after ANOVA
and graphical diagnostic analysis. The ones pass the Rj ¼ f Xj1 ; Xj2 ; . . .Xji ð1Þ
statistical examinations could be identified as Xji is the element in design states that architects can
adjust; Rj is any independent response that can be measured
by all factors; and f is the “predictive models” between one
response and several factors.
To find the relationship f, groups of corresponding Xji and
Rj values are needed. The value groups of Xji are chosen
within their own ranges set by the researchers. Each
response Rj is an evaluation index of the research, the values
of which are measured by simulation software after imputing
the values of factors. It should be declared that the mapping
relationship f is a mathematic result of regression analysis
with probably no physical meaning. Even so, the fitting
formulas in the form of multinomial equations are useful in
gaining an overall understanding of tendency, quick simu-
lations, prediction, and optimization.
were parameterized with the decision of their value ranges in model creation. The base model settings as well as
considering the need in architecture design. Using the research factor parameterization were decided based on the
D-optimality method in RSM, an input list was defined. The use of the software and its database.
third step was creating the building simulation for each
simulation and recording the value of responses together
with the factors as a data list. Afterward, by applying RSM, 3.1 Base Model Settings
mathematic models were generated for each response, and
trend analysis and optimization were then carried out based The location was in Nanjing (N32.83°, E118.8°), Jiangsu
on the models. Finally came the stage where some strategies Province, a hot summer–cold winter climate city in China.
and tips could be concluded. The atrium space was 20 m 20 m 25 m (Tao & Bin,
During this process, the software DesignExpert V8.0 was 2004) oriented north–south. It was around with a 6-layer,
used for the application of RSM (Kumar et al., 2007), while 12-m-deep functional space, in which the height of the first
EnergyPlus was chosen as the building energy simulation layer was 5 m while the rest were 4 m (see Fig. 3). The
software, considering its widely accepted accuracy (Zhao & façade construction (e.g., roofs, floors, and walls) was based
Magoulès, 2012). Discussions on descriptive statistics, cor- on the EnergyPlus material library (see Table 1).
relation analysis and factor elimination, trend analysis, and According to the specifications of the local standard
optimal solutions led to our conclusions about energy-saving (GB50034-2013), the illumination requirement of the atrium
design strategies. should be set as 200 lx, while the unified glare value should
be 22. The artificial lighting control type was continuous
dimming with 4 reference points (see Fig. 4) for daylighting
3 Simulation Settings and glare calculation.
For each thermal zone, there was a calculation point in
Widely recognized for its accuracy, the energy consumption the center. The occupant density and activity levels were the
simulation software EnergyPlus (Version 8.6) was chosen as standard settings in EnergyPlus library according to ASH-
the computer simulation approach in this research. It was RAE Standard 189.1. The cooling and heating thermostat
supplemented by the OpenStudio (Version 8.6) modeling setpoint values were 28 and 18 °C according to the local
plug-in for SketchUp (Version 8.0) to reduce the difficulties standard (DGJ32J96-2010). To simulate energy requirement,
Multivariable Coupling Influence on Energy-Efficient … 7
n d ¼ WFR l ð2Þ
Table 2 Statistical analysis on No. Minimum Maximum Mean Mode Standard deviation
206 groups of glazing materials
from EnergyPlus database U 206 0.785 5.894 2.72194 5.778 1.28666
SHGC 206 0.107 0.905 0.42456 0.426 0.216745
Tvis 206 0.045 0.913 0.42716 0.073a 0.285975
a
Represents there is more than one mode and the value shown in the table is the minimum mode
(a) Output of Ec, Eh, and El in descending order of Et; other factors. This may have been due to the coupling
(b) input of WFR and n in descending order of Et; (c) input influence between factors.
of U and Tvis in descending order of Et; (d) input of Rb,
Direction, and SlatType in descending order of Et.
4.2 Mathematical Model Generation for Et
With the coded model term coefficients (Table 5), the Et ¼ 92:18 59:29 WFR þ 0:14 n þ 1:51 U
predictive model with uncoded (actual) factors for Et could 82:85 Tvis þ 0:90 Rb þ 25:28 WFR U
be expressed as follows.
þ 33:65 WFR Tvis 1:67 U Tvis 3:31 U Rb
When Direction = E–W, SlatType = Small,
þ 10:53 Tvis Rb þ 33:73 WFR2 þ 44:64 Tvis2
ð9Þ
Multivariable Coupling Influence on Energy-Efficient … 11
Table 5 ANOVA test for the Source F-value p-value Coefficient Standard 95% CI 95% CI
predictive model of Et Prob > F estimate error low high
Model 539.07 <0.0001
A-WFR 3709.89 <0.0001 32.1681 0.5281 31.1190 33.2172
B-n 6.21 0.0145 1.3378 0.5370 0.2712 2.4044
C-U 3115.01 <0.0001 29.8802 0.5354 28.8167 30.9436
D-Tvis 162.44 <0.0001 −6.7616 0.5305 −7.8154 −5.7078
E-Rb 23.85 <0.0001 −2.5897 0.5302 −3.6430 −1.5365
F- 6.71 0.0112 −1.2304 0.4751 −2.1740 −0.2867
Direction
G- 90.34 <0.0001 4.5108 0.4746 3.5681 5.4534
SlatType
AC 1904.25 <0.0001 25.8314 0.5920 24.6555 27.0072
AD 100.66 <0.0001 5.8425 0.5823 4.6857 6.9992
AG 16.87 <0.0001 2.1743 0.5294 1.1227 3.2258
CD 9.91 0.0022 −1.8476 0.5868 −3.0133 −0.6819
CE 18.84 <0.0001 −2.5341 0.5839 −3.6940 −1.3743
DE 5.56 0.0205 1.3710 0.5813 0.2163 2.5257
DG 42.34 <0.0001 3.4637 0.5323 2.4064 4.5211
EG 4.02 0.0480 −1.0608 0.5292 −2.1120 −0.0096
2
A 17.05 <0.0001 5.3968 1.3071 2.8004 7.9932
E2 41.72 <0.0001 8.4074 1.3016 5.8220 10.9928
Intercept 96.3790 1.4321 93.5344 99.2236
When Direction = S–N, SlatType = Small, values of total energy demand from 53 GJ (blue) to 224 GJ
(red).
Et ¼ 89:72 59:29 WFR þ 0:14 n þ 1:51 U According to the graphs in Fig. 8, the values of total
82:85 Tvis þ 0:90 Rb þ 25:28 WFR U energy demand varied greatly in the simulation region and
þ 33:65 WFR Tvis 1:67 U Tvis 3:31 U Rb could reach a relatively small value of less than
60GJ. Moreover, the responses corresponding to the contour
þ 10:53 Tvis Rb þ 33:73 WFR2 þ 44:64 Tvis2
plots indicated that differences occurred between categories.
ð10Þ When the SlatType changed, the trend of the response var-
When Direction = E–W, SlatType = Big, ied. In addition, the value of total energy demand tended to
be smaller when the category Small was chosen for SlatType.
Et ¼ 91:65 48:42 WFR þ 0:14 n þ 1:51 U As for numerical factors, the changing tendency of the
66:89 Tvis 6:17 Rb þ 25:28 WFR U response was affected by interactions. For WFR-U (Fig. 8a,
b), the trend was unidirectional. The total energy demand
þ 33:65 WFR Tvis 1:67 U Tvis 3:31 U Rb
decreased when the WFR or U became small, regardless of
þ 10:53 Tvis Rb þ 33:73 WFR2 þ 44:64 Tvis2 the categories. For WFR-Tvis (Fig. 8c, d), when a small
ð11Þ SlatType was chosen, the trend was unidirectional with a
negative relation between the response and the factor Tvis
When Direction = S–N, SlatType = Big, (Fig. 8c). When the SlatType was big, however, the trend
became symmetrical (Fig. 8d). At high Tvis, the relation
Et ¼ 89:19 48:42 WFR þ 0:14 n þ 1:51 U
between total energy demand and Tvis was positive. But at
66:89 Tvis 6:17 Rb þ 25:28 WFR U low Tvis, the relation became negative. The minimum of the
þ 33:65 WFR Tvis 1:67 U Tvis 3:31 U Rb contour could be achieved when Tvis was around 0.53, while
þ 10:53 Tvis Rb þ 33:73 WFR2 þ 44:64 Tvis2 the value of WFR was the minimum. As for Rb-U (Fig. 8e,
f), it can be observed that the factor Tvis was less effective
ð12Þ
than the factor U, since the contour lines were more parallel
to the y-axis.
According to the predictive model generated in Sect. 4.2, The variety of factors together with interactions involved in
comparisons between the equations could be made to the predictive model made it hard to determine the settings in
understand the impact of the categorical factors Direction and which minimal total energy response could be obtained.
SlatType. For factor Direction, the only difference between Thus, optimization was carried out based on the predicted
the expressions is the constant term. When the value of fac- formulas. The objective was the minimum of the response,
tors WFR, n; U; Tvis; Rb remained unchanged, there is while the factors were remained in the simulation region.
Eq. (9) – Eq. (10) = Eq. (11) – Eq. (12) = 2:46 [ 0. This The searches began with 100 random starting points and
means the total energy demand of E–W direction stripes ended with 50 optimal solutions (desirability from 0.8 to 1).
would be always larger that of S–N direction stripes when The optimal results with the highest desirability obtained by
under the same circumstance. On the other hand, since the DesignExpert’s in-built optimizer are listed in Table 6.
interactions between categorical factor SlatType and numer- According to the table, ten optimal solutions were offered
ical ones WFR, Tvis, and Rb occurred, the tendency was hard with their desirability equal to 1. Although the predicted
to conclude. value of the optimal response varied, they all fluctuated
To understand the impact of interactions, contour plots around 53 GJ. Considering the deviation of the predictive
were drawn in Fig. 8 illustrating the most significant inter- model was inevitable, all the nine optimal solutions were
actions in the predictive model with p-values less than regarded as substitutes for each other. As for the setting of
0.0001: WFR-U (Fig. 8a, b), WFR-Tvis (Fig. 8c, d), and factors, the categorical factors were the same among the nine
Rb-U (Fig. 8e, f). The impact of the categorical factor optimal solutions, while the values of numerical factors
SlatType was also compared for the discussion of each differed. The Direction was S–N (south–north) for every
interaction. For each contour graph, the factors not in the solution, and a small SlatType was favored.
discussion were set constant to the average value in the To visualize the tendency of the numerical factors’ value
simulation region while the Direction was set as S–N. The settings, a transformed radio map was drawn (Fig. 9). The
different colors in each graph represent different response polylines represent different solutions, while the round
Multivariable Coupling Influence on Energy-Efficient … 13
Fig. 8 Contour plots of total energy demand depending on interac- Direction = E–W; d WFR-Tvis interaction, when SlatType = Big,
tions. a WFR-U interaction, when SlatType = Small, Rb = 0.5, n = 11, Rb = 0.5, n = 11, U = 3.34, Direction = E–W; e Rb–U interaction,
Tvis = 0.48, Direction = E–W; b WFR-U interaction, when SlatType = when SlatType = Small, WFR = 0.5, n = 11, Tvis = 0.48, Direc-
Big, Rb = 0.5, n = 11, Tvis = 0.48, Direction = E–W; c WFR-Tvis tion = E–W; f Rb–U interaction, when SlatType = Big, WFR = 0.5,
interaction, when SlatType = Small, Rb = 0.5, n = 11, U = 3.34, n = 11, Tvis = 0.48, Direction = E–W.
14 F. Yu and J. Leng
boundary shows the simulation region of the factors. Clearly which fluctuated from 0.83 to 0.91 with a tendency to reach
from the graph, in general, the ranges covering the solution its maximum. Among all the numerical factors, the U-value
settings were all relatively small and close to the low seemed to be the most strictly limited, while the values of
boundary of their own experiment region except for Tvis, Tvis and number were more likely to fluctuate.
Multivariable Coupling Influence on Energy-Efficient … 15
prediction: a review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, Machairas, V., Tsangrassoulis, A., & Axarli, K. (2014). Algorithms for
23, 272–288. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2013.03.004 optimization of building design: a review. Renewable and Sustain-
Goia, F., Haase, M., & Perino, M. (2013). Optimizing the configuration able Energy Reviews, 31, 101–112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.
of a façade module for office buildings by means of integrated 2013.11.036
thermal and lighting simulations in a total energy perspective. Magnier, L., & Haghighat, F. (2010). Multiobjective optimization of
Applied Energy, 108, 515–527. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy. building design using TRNSYS simulations, genetic algorithm, and
2013.02.063 artificial neural network. Building and Environment, 45(3), 739–
Grynning, S., Time, B., & Matusiak, B. (2014). Solar shading control 746. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2009.08.016
strategies in cold climates—heating, cooling demand and daylight Tao, L., & Bin, Y. (2004). Approaches to the atrium space design in
availability in office spaces. Solar Energy, 107, 182–194. https:// ecological buildings. Architectural Journal, 68–69 (in Chinese).
doi.org/10.1016/j.solener.2014.06.007 Teglia, C. M., Montemurro, M., De Zan, M. M., & Cámara, M. S.
Harish, V. S. K. V., & Kumar, A. (2016). A review on modelling and (2015). Multiple responses optimization in the development of a
simulation of building energy systems. Renewable and Sustainable headspace gas chromatography method for the determination of
Energy Reviews, 56, 1272–1292. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser. residual solvents in pharmaceuticals. Journal of Pharmaceutical
2015.12.040 Analysis, 5, 296–306. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpha.2015.02.004
Jaber, S., & Ajib, S. (2011). Thermal and economic windows design for Wang, W., Tian, Z., & Ding, Y. (2013). Investigation on the
different climate zones. Energy and Buildings, 43(11), 3208–3215. influencing factors of energy consumption and thermal comfort
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2011.08.019 for a passive solar house withwater thermal storage wall. Energy
Korolija, I., Zhang, Y., Marjanovic-Halburd, L., & Hanby, V. I. (2013). Build, 64, 218–223. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2013.05.007
Regression models for predicting UK office building energy Zhang, S., Sun, Y., Cheng, Y., Huang, P., Oladokun, M. O., & Lin, Z.
consumption from heating and cooling demands. Energy and (2018). Response-surface-model-based system sizing for Nearly/Net
Buildings, 59, 214–227. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enbuild.2012.12. zero energy buildings under uncertainty. Applied Energy, 228,
005 1020–1031. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2018.06.156
Kumar, T. A., Kumar, A., & Raheman, H. (2007). Biodiesel production Zhao, H., & Magoulès, F. (2012). A review on the prediction of
from jatropha oil (Jatropha curcas) with high free fatty acids: an building energy consumption. Renewable and Sustainable Energy
optimized process. Biomass and Bioenergy, 31(8), 569–575. https:// Reviews, 16(6), 3586–3592. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2012.02.
doi.org/10.1016/j.biombioe.2007.03.003 049
Performance of L-shaped Mini Louvers
in Tropical Cities in Cooling Energy
Reduction: Case Study of Mumbai, Mexico
City, and Lagos
Abstract Keywords
energy is the fastest growing end-use energy in buildings. window-to-wall ratio, and window positioning to propose a
This condition is driven by warmer temperatures, increased new shading design. They tested their new shading design in
human’s activities, population and economic development. Kolkata, India, and evaluated in Naples and Hanoi.
Since many researches focus on large-scale and more Suryandono et al. (2018a) simulated the comparison of L-
business-oriented buildings, this paper aim to open the shaped mini louvers of solar radiation reduction in Singapore
possibilities of introducing sustainable issues in household and Sydney. The simulation results showed that the pro-
level. It means that everyone can be more aware on energy posed model can reduce up to 75% and 85% annual total
efficiency in the built environment, even such at a small direct and indirect solar radiation in Singapore and Sydney
space. Using a simple building element, such as L-shaped accordingly in North orientation. Suryandono et al. (2018b)
mini louvers that are studied in this paper, people can par- also conducted simulation of solar radiation and cooling
ticipate to make more optimized and energy-efficient energy reduction using these mini louvers in three different
buildings. cities in Japan: Sapporo, Tokyo, and Naha from July 1 to
August 31, the hottest period in Japan. These louvers work
best for south orientation by reducing around 83% solar
2 Previous Researches radiation in Naha and 85% in Sapporo using their proposed
model. It leads to annual cooling energy reduction 13% in
Openings in buildings such as windows and door design Naha and 43% in Sapporo.
must be taken into consideration. Shading device is one of
the strategies to optimize the functions of building opening
while maintaining sustainability issues. Shading devices are 3 Research Methods
used for controlling the sun exposure to the buildings.
Hariyadi et al. (2017) noted that sudare blinds reduce 5% This study used simulation to analyze several shading device
Overall Thermal Transfer Value (OTTV) in Jakarta, designs for dealing with the problem of cooling energy
Indonesia. These blinds also reduce 6% of office buildings consumption in buildings. The idea of proposing sun shad-
thermal energy in the same location. Sudare is Japanese ing devices comes from previous researches as well as
traditional outdoor blinds that are similar with small external awareness of available building materials in the market that
louvers. Kohler et al. (2017) showed that awning as an might be used. The shading devices were simulated in the
external shading device can reduce more than 50% of annual computer. Rhinoceros version 5 is three-dimensional soft-
solar heat gains. They conduct the simulation test using ware that is used for the main environment for this study. It
EnergyPlus and Berkeley Lab Window 2016 in Delhi. They has Grasshopper as graphical algorithm plug-in that contains
also conducted simulations in Denver, USA, to show their ladybug and honeybee. Ladybug and Honeybee are two
awning’s performance in a different location. Dutta et al plug-ins that act as EnergyPlus interface simulation engine
(2017) concluded that moveable external window shading in software.
tropical climate of northern hemisphere can reduce annual To do simulation, building models, completed with its
cooling energy. The south-oriented window has maximum material properties and proposed shading design, were made
energy consumption followed by east, west, and north in in Rhinoceros using parametric Grasshopper scripts.
Kolkata, India. The simulations using TRNSYS software Weather data for three selected locations were directly
show that 9.8% annual cooling energy can be saved by downloaded from onebuilding.org in using Grasshopper
putting their shading into a building. The maximum energy script. Energy simulations were done using Honeybee, with
savings occur in June by cutting 14.9%. Not only for new its EnergyPlus simulation engines. The results are analyzed
buildings, El-Darwish and Gomaa (2017) showed that ret- to show the performance of each model in all locations and
rofitting old building can also save energy. They compared orientations. The research workflow in this paper is pre-
many design strategies to save energy by applying solar sented in Fig. 1.
shading, adding air tightness, and changing glazing on
windows. The solar shading device was the best by cutting
up to 23% energy, followed by 8% energy savings of glazing 4 Simulations
strategies, and 2% lowering energy consumption using air
tightness. Their experiments were done in a building in All the building models were made parametrically in Rhi-
Northern Egypt. Idchabani et al. (2017) compared two noceros using Grasshopper scripts. Simulations were also
shading device types: overhangs and fins in Morocco. Their done in Rhinoceros software, along with its plug-ins
research showed that overhangs work better than fins in that Grasshopper to run EnergyPlus-based simulation using
specific area. Ghosh and Neogi (2018) simulated strategies Ladybug and Honeybee. First, model 1 serves as base case
using EnergyPlus for energy-efficient buildings such as the study in this paper. The size of the models is 3000 mm
Performance of L-shaped Mini Louvers in Tropical Cities … 19
by 3000 mm with one 2000 mm by 2000 mm single glass shading placement in their performance of cooling energy
window in the middle of one side. All other three sides are consumption. This 50 mm distance from exterior glass
walls, with flat roof, and flat floor. All the constructions are window surface similar to the condition when the exterior L-
default properties from EnergyPlus materials. The details of shaped mini louvers is attached to window frame rather than
these constructions are as follows: Roof constructions con- directly to the glass. The entire three-dimensional model and
sist of 100 mm lightweight concrete, ceiling air space the simulation environment setting can be seen in Fig. 2.
resistance, and acoustic tile. Exterior wall constructions All the models use midrise apartment zone programs
consist of 100 mm brick, 200 mm heavyweight concrete, 50 schedule on zone usage for one-year circle simulation from
mm insulation board, wall air space resistance, and 19 mm EnergyPlus. The weather data is opened using Ladybug. The
gypsum board. Window constructions consist of double 3 Honeybee software is used to run EnergyPlus simulation in
mm clear glass with 13 mm air space in between. Floor Grasshopper using Rhinoceros interface. The simulation
constructions consist of 50 mm insulation board and 200 mm output is four-zone energy uses: lights electric, equipment
heavyweight concrete. Grasshopper plug-in in Rhinoceros electric, total heating, and total cooling. This paper shows
allows parametric design; so, using modifications of the cooling energy reductions in three selected locations for all
same script, six other designs are made. Model 1, which is eight orientations so only annual cooling energy are pre-
used for base case in this study, consists of one single pane sented in tables. However, Mexico City is chosen to show
glass window without any shading device. L-shaped mini sun shading’s performance in subtropical area which is not
louvers with 12 mm size are placed in exterior surface of the only effecting the cooling but also heating energy con-
window in model 2a. Model 2b has 25 mm L-shaped mini sumption. For Mexico City, annual heating energy are also
louvers with 25 mm gap among the louvers. The length of presented in table, complete with total annual energy, which
these L-shaped mini louvers is 2000 mm, the same as win- are the combined annual cooling and heating energy con-
dow’s width. Instead of louvers, model 2c has additional sumption altogether. Total simulations for all models and
horizontal shading devices in front of glass window with the orientations in this study are 168 simulations. One simula-
same length with the window (2000 mm) and 1000 mm tion generates energy consumptions every hour in one year.
depth. The gap among the horizontal shading is 1000 mm. In There are 8760 hourly based simulations. These annual
the three-dimensional models, all the shading devices are energy are analyzed and compared among them to explore
placed 1 mm outside exterior surface window. This 1 mm shading device performance in every locations for all eight
gap outside glass window surface is needed to avoid over- building orientations.
lapping surface that might affect simulation. Moreover, the 1
mm gap mimics the presence of adhesive or bonding agent
to attach the L-shaped mini louvers at the exterior window 5 Results
surface. Model 3a, 3b, and 3c has the same properties and
design with model 2a, 2b, and 2c. However, instead of The first location in this paper case study is Lagos, Nigeria.
placed 1 mm outside exterior surface, all the model 3s have The weather files exact location is at Murtala Muhammed
50 mm distance from the window to find the effect of International Airport (Onebuilding, n.d.-a). Model 1
20 A. R. Suryandono et al.
simulation results of annual cooling energy for eight orien- the north, northwest, southwest, south, southeast, and
tations or the base case are shown at Table 1. In all eight northeast façade. Model 2b reduces annual cooling energy
orientations, west facade opening leads the highest cooling consumption 19% in the north façade, 20% in the northwest
energy for the simulated zone. In total, 15,479,254.68 kJ is facade, 13% in the southwest facade, 13% in the south
consumed. North orientation building consumes lowest façade, 12% in the southeast facade, and 20% in the north-
cooling energy 12,848,523.51 kJ in a year. It is 17% lower east facade. Highest amount annual cooling energy saving
than cooling energy for opening at the west side of the by model 2b is in the southwest orientation by reducing
building. The results of all simulated models are presented in 3413.82 mJ. Model 2c performs best to lower annual cool-
Table 2. Table 2 is presented in percentage in radar Chart 1. ing energy consumption in the west, southwest, and east
When the shading devices are placed at 1 mm outside the facade by 14, 13 and 13% accordingly. Model 2c can save
exterior surface of the glass window, model 2b work best in highest annual cooling energy of 3663.09 mJ in the west
Performance of L-shaped Mini Louvers in Tropical Cities … 21
southeast southwest
south
façade. Model 2a cannot perform better than the two pre- The situations are significantly different when all the
vious models to diminish cooling energy in all eight orien- shading devices are placed 50 mm in front of the exterior
tations. However, in comparison with model 1 as base case, surface of the glass window. L-shaped mini louvers show
they significantly reduce 16% of annual cooling energy in performances which are better than common horizontal
the west, southwest, and south façade. Even in the worse shading device in all building orientations. Model 3b shows
orientations in north orientation building, model 2a still can best performance in comparison with other model. By uti-
cut 11% of annual cooling energy which is around lizing model 3b, annual cooling energy consumption can be
1392.97 mJ. lowered to 75% (north orientation), 70% (northwest and
22 A. R. Suryandono et al.
south orientation), 66% (southwest orientation), 67% orientation), 66% (west orientation), 64% (south and
(southeast orientation), 65% (east orientation), and 69% southeast orientation), 67% (east orientation), and 76%
(northeast orientation). They work best on west façade by (northeast orientation). Notably, model 3b reduces 37% of
cutting 36% of annual building cooling energy which is annual cooling energy on southwest façade, which has the
around 5510.20 mJ. Model 3a also shows better perfor- highest consumption without additional shading devices. It
mance than model 2a. This shading design works best for means that around 6547.92 mJ of annual cooling energy can
west orientation by cutting 33% of annual cooling energy or be saved.
around 5164.71 mJ in comparison with the base case. Model Mexico City is chosen to explore the performance of
3c performance is worse than model 2c in all building proposed shading devices in subtropical climate. Shading
orientations. device blocks sunlight which may affect heating energy
Mumbai, India, is the second chosen location for this during colder condition. Specific weather data at Ciudad
paper case study. The weather data at Chhatrapati Shivaji Juarez International Airport, Mexico City, is used for sim-
Maharaj International Airport, Mumbai, is used for running ulation (n.d.). The base case model 1 simulation results are
the simulations (Onebuilding, n.d.-b). The model 1 as base given in Table 5. The highest cooling energy, 2536.23 mJ,
case simulation results for eight orientations is presented in occurs in the southwest façade. Meanwhile, the north façade
Table 3. The southwest orientation has the highest building is the lowest one with its only 38% in comparison with the
annual cooling energy consumption by 17,790.91 mJ. North southwest facade. However, north façade has the highest
façade opening uses the lowest annual cooling energy in heating energy with 928.27 mJ annual heating energy. The
comparison with the other 7 facades by 12,881.26 mJ or southeast and east façade similarly consumes 72% of heating
only 72% of south west’s highest. The results of all simu- energy in comparison with the highest one. The southwest
lated models are presented in Table 4. Table 4 is presented in façade consumes the highest 3296.32 mJ, while north is the
percentage in radar Chart 2. lowest by consuming 1903.25 mJ or only around 58% of the
Similar with simulation results in Lagos, Nigeria, model highest annual cooling and heating energy altogether. The
2b and 2c showing best performance in several façade, results of all simulated models are presented in Table 6.
meanwhile model 2a cannot perform similarly with model Table 6 is presented in percentage at radar Charts 3 for
2b and 2c. Model 2b cuts 13% and 18% of annual cooling annual cooling energy, annual heating energy, and total
energy in the north and northwest façade. Highest amount annual cooling plus heating energy.
annual cooling energy saving by model 2b is in the south Model 3b performs best in eight building orientations
orientation by reducing 4579.41 mJ. In the south, southeast, among other models, followed by model 3a. The L-shaped
east, and northeast façade, 73, 75, 78, 83% of annual cooling mini louvers of model 3b cut 65% in the north façade, 74%
energy is consumed in comparison with model 1 base case. in the northwest façade, 81% in the west façade, 82% in the
Model 2c performs best among other models 2 in the west, southwest façade, 83% in the south façade, 79% in the
southwest, southeast, and east faced by consuming 77, 74, southeast façade, 76% in the east façade, and 70% in the
75, and 78% of annual cooling energy accordingly. Model northeast façade of annual cooling energy. Model 3b works
2c can save highest annual cooling energy of best by saving around 2089.44 mJ in the southwest façade.
4544,641.32 kJ in the southwest façade. Best cooling energy saving for model 3a is also in the
Moving the shading device away from glass window southwest façade by around 2003.44 mJ of annual cooling
exterior surface makes the L-shaped mini louvers performs energy reduction.
significantly better. Similar with the condition in Lagos, the However, reverse condition happen for annual heating
model 2c and 3c shows no significant changes of cutting energy. Model 3b performs worst among other models.
annual cooling energy. Model 3b achieves the best results in Model 1 as base case, which is a glass window without
all eight orientations. In comparison with base case, model shading devices performs best by allowing sunlight to help
3b consumes 83% (north orientation), 75% (northwest heating room space during colder condition. Model 3b
southeast southwest
south
Table 5 Model 1 simulation result of annual cooling, heating, and total cooling plus heating energy in Mexico City
North Northwest West Southwest South Southeast East Northeast
Model 1/base case cooling energy 974.97 1420.88 2267.94 2536.23 2140.88 1810.69 1532.90 1197.11
(mJ)
Cooling energy percentage in 38 56 89 100 84 71 60 47
comparison with southwest façade
(%)
Model 1/base case heating energy 928.27 883.87 770.02 760.09 726.92 666.93 664.60 799.06
(mJ)
Heating energy percentage in 100 95 83 82 78 72 72 86
comparison with north façade (%)
Model 1/base case total cooling and 1903.25 2304.75 3037.97 3296.32 2867.81 2477.62 2197.51 1996.18
heating energy (mJ)
Total cooling and heating energy 58 70 92 100 87 75 67 61
percentage in comparison with north
façade (%)
24 A. R. Suryandono et al.
Table 6 Simulation results of annual cooling, heating, and total cooling plus heating energy in Mexico City
Annual cooling energy (mJ) North Northwest West Southwest South Southeast East Northeast
1 Model 1/Base case 974.98 1420.88 2267.95 2536.23 2140.89 1810.69 1532.91 1197.12
2 Model 2a 761.34 891.22 1292.90 1354.47 1081.02 1033.85 968.79 854
3 Model 2b 499.82 633.79 981.71 1016.98 745.69 704.42 677.92 581.48
4 Model 2c 635.76 732.39 906.21 937.71 823.47 790.16 759.16 707.24
5 Model 3a 407.26 442.59 508.67 532.79 450.19 455.62 448.91 430.72
6 Model 3b 337.92 371.61 430.21 446.79 369.68 375.56 374.03 360.91
7 Model 3c 656.16 768.83 953.44 987.08 888.96 831.21 806.52 735.53
Annual heating energy (mJ) North Northwest West Southwest South Southeast East Northeast
1 Model 1/base case 928.27 883.88 770.03 760.1 726.93 666.94 664.6 799.07
2 Model 2a 1048.02 1020.92 928.59 950.06 922.77 799 765.32 930.79
3 Model 2b 1253.06 1205.43 1093.71 1130.31 1092.21 912.33 859.74 1093.25
4 Model 2c 1134.64 1122.95 1067.77 1085.99 1032.49 910.28 879.36 1006.79
5 Model 3a 1429.79 1432.40 1390.93 1411.76 1393.97 1252.02 1212.56 1358.61
6 Model 3b 1546.20 1543.85 1499.98 1526.67 1513.50 1357.92 1316.00 1472.92
7 Model 3c 1118.04 1105.65 1050.01 1067.15 1002.93 892.44 858.4 986.64
Total annual cooling and North Northwest West Southwest South Southeast East Northeast
heating energy (mJ)
1 Model 1/base case 1903.25 2304.76 3037.98 3296.33 2867.82 2477.63 2197.51 1996.19
2 Model 2a 1809.36 1912.15 2221.49 2304.54 2003.79 1832.84 1734.11 1784.79
3 Model 2b 1752.88 1839.22 2075.42 2147.29 1837.90 1616.75 1537.66 1674.72
4 Model 2c 1770.40 1855.34 1973.99 2023.70 1855.96 1700.45 1638.51 1714.03
5 Model 3a 1837.05 1874.99 1899.60 1944.54 1844.17 1707.64 1661.46 1789.34
6 Model 3b 1884.12 1915.47 1930.19 1973.46 1883.18 1733.48 1690.03 1833.83
7 Model 3c 1774.21 1874.48 2003.45 2054.24 1891.89 1723.65 1664.92 1722.17
makes the room consumes more than twice heating energy in heating energy results from the simulation in Mexico City
the southwest, south, and southeast by 201%, 208%, and can be seen in Chart 3.
204% accordingly. The worst condition occurs in the
southwest orientation. Building with model 3b shading
device attached consumes 766.57 mJ higher than building 6 Discussion
without shading device as base case. The smallest annual
heating energy addition is in the north orientation with From the three selected locations, all simulation results show
model 2a attached by around 119.74 mJ. that shading devices have impact to reduce buildings’ energy
The total combination of annual cooling and heating consumptions, especially in lowering cooling energy. In
energy is needed to show the performance of shading tropical cities: Lagos and Mumbai, the average percentage of
devices during one-year cycle. However, even though annual cooling energy consumption for all building orien-
annual heating energy of the glass window without shading tations are presented in Table 7. It is clearly seen that in both
is the lowest for all building orientations, it still consumes locations model 3b performs best and followed by model 3a.
the highest total combination of annual cooling and heating Model 3b has 25 mm L-shaped mini louvers with 25 mm
energy. Model 2b performs best for the north, northwest, gap among louvers. The mini louvers are attached 50 mm
south, southeast, east and northeast orientation by only outside exterior surface of glass window. Model 3a has
consumes 92, 80, 64, 65, 70, and 84% in comparison with significantly smaller 12 mm L-shaped mini louvers with
the base case. Model 3a shows the best results for the west, 12 mm gap among them. Like model 3b, these mini louvers
southwest, and south orientation by consuming 63, 59, and are also attached 50 mm outside exterior surface of glass
64% of total annual cooling and heating energy in compar- window.
ison with base case building. All of the annual cooling and
Performance of L-shaped Mini Louvers in Tropical Cities … 25
20% model 2b
east 0% west model 2c
model 3a
model 3b
model 3c
southeast southwest
south
north
250%
100% model 2a
50% model 2b
east 0% west model 2c
model 3a
model 3b
model 3c
southeast southwest
south
north
100%
70% model 2a
60% model 2b
east 50% west model 2c
model 3a
model 3b
model 3c
southeast southwest
south
26 A. R. Suryandono et al.
Table 8 Average of annual Annual cooling energy Annual heating energy Total annual energy
cooling, heating, and total cooling (%) (%) (%)
plus heating energy in Mexico
City Model 1/base 100 100 100
case
Model 2a 62 118 79
Model 2b 43 139 74
Model 2c 48 133 74
Model 3a 28 176 75
Model 3b 24 190 76
Model 3c 50 130 75
In Lagos, Nigeria, model 3b can cut 32% of annual Based on simulation results, the optimized shading device
cooling energy. Model 3a performs 3% worse than model 3b combination is presented in Table 6. It is seen that the
by cutting 29% of annual cooling energy. In Mumbai, India, average 28% of total annual cooling and heating energy can
model 3b can save annual cooling energy to 70% while be cut in comparison with model 1 as base case.
model 3a save 72%.
Different conditions occur in locations which have cool-
ing and heating period throughout the whole year. Mexico 7 Conclusions and Further Researches
City is an example in this paper shows that shading device
design strategy has positive impact of total annual cooling Based on the three locations chosen for the simulation study,
and heating energy reductions. It can be seen in Table 8. shading devices have positive impact on cooling energy
Model 2b and 2c works best in average for all orientations. reduction in tropical countries. It also shows positive impact
Model 3a and model 3c performs slightly worse than the best in sub-tropical country. Even though the annual heating
options by only around 1% differences. It is seen that even energy increased, but overall cooling and heating energy can
though small in size, L-shaped mini louvers showing good be reduced. Even though the size is small, L-shaped alu-
performance of reducing the annual total cooling and heating minum profile can be used as mini louvers to reduce
energy consumptions. However, if the right shading device building energy consumptions, notably cooling energy in
is chosen the result is better. From Table 9, if the designer tropical climate. L-shaped mini louvers performance is the
choose combination among six proposed designs, the result best among proposed design, even in comparison with more
will be better than using just single solution for all façade. commonly used horizontal overhang as shading device.
Table 9 Selected shading devices to optimize total annual cooling and heating energy in Mexico City
Orientation North Northwest West Southwest South Southeast East Northeast Average
Chosen shading device Model Model 2b Model Model 3a Model Model 2b Model Model 2b
model 2b 3a 2b/model 2b
3a
Total annual cooling 92 80 63 59 64 65 70 84 72
and heating energy (%)
Performance of L-shaped Mini Louvers in Tropical Cities … 27
In Lagos, Nigeria, model 3b works best in average by Education (LPDP) scholarship. Participation on 3rd GU conference is
reducing 32% (36,793.77 mJ) of annual cooling energy funded by the University of Kitakyushu, Japan, and Fukuda
Laboratory.
followed by model 3a by 29% (33,989.92 mJ). In Mumbai,
India, model 3b also shows better performance among other
models by cutting 30% (39,819.26 mJ) of annual cooling
References
energy followed by model 3a by 28% (36,795.68 mJ). In
Mexico City, Mexico, using one shading device model for
Dutta, A., Samanta, A., & Neogi, S. (2017). Influence of orientation
all building orientations, 26% annual total cooling and and the impact of external window shading on building thermal
heating energy can be saved. Both model 2b and 2c can be performance in tropical climate. Energy and Buildings, 139, 680–
used to achieve it. Model 2b saves 5599.61 mJ while model 689.
2c cuts 5549.08 mJ of total annual cooling and heating El-Darwish, I., & Gomaa, M. (2017). Retrofitting strategy for building
envelopes to achieve energy efficiency. Alexandria Engineering
energy. However, using different types of shading device in
Journal, 56(4), 579–589. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aej.2017.05.011
this paper, total annual cooling and heating energy saving Energyplus. (n.d.). Mexico weather data. Ciudad Juarez International
can be up to 28% (5978.17 mJ). Combination of model 2b Airport, Mexico City. https://www.energyplus.net/weather-
and 3a is used to achieve this condition. download/north_and_central_america_wmo_region_4/MEX//
MEX_Mexico.City.766790_IWEC/all
This research shows that even though L-shaped mini
Ghosh, A., & Neogi, S. (2018). Effect of fenestration geometrical
louvers have relatively small sizes, their application as factors on building energy consumption and performance evaluation
shading device can save energy in buildings. They even of a new external solar shading device in warm and humid climatic
perform better than more common shading devices, such as condition. Solar Energy, 169, 94–104. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
solener.2018.04.025
horizontal overhangs that are used in this paper simulation.
Gore, A. (2006). An inconvenient truth: The planetary emergency of
This research offers L-shaped aluminum profiles as basic global warming and what we can do about it. Rodale.
elements to create simple mini louvers rather than uses Gore, A. (2017). An inconvenient sequel: Truth to power. Rodale.
custom sun shading or complicated technologies to reduce Hansen, J., Sato, M., & Ruedy, R. (2012). Perception of climate
change. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109, 37.
cooling energy consumptions. L-shaped aluminum profile
https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1205276109
has many advantages. They are easy to be obtained. L-shape Hariyadi, A., Qingsong, M., & Hiroatsu, F. (2017). The effectiveness of
profile is available in many sizes, from as small as 5 mm by the parametric design ‘Sudare’ blind as external shading for energy
5 mm to 30 mm by 300 mm. It is easy to be attached in new efficiency and visibility quality in Jakarta. Architectural Engineer-
ing and Design Management, 13(5), 384–403.
or retrofitting old projects. The aluminum itself is
Idchabani, R., Ganaoui, M. E., & Sick, F. (2017). Analysis of exterior
self-cleaning and requires low or almost no maintenance. shading by overhangs and fins in hot climate. Energy Procedia,
Aluminum is also lightweight. It means that once they are 139, 379–384
used as louvers, they do not need additional support and International Energy Agency. (n.d.). Market report series: Energy
efficiency 2018. https://webstore.iea.org/download/direct/2369?
even can be put directly at the exterior surface of glass
fileName=Market_Report_Series_Energy_Efficiency_2018.pdf
window using outdoor weather resistance double-faced tape. International Energy Agency. (n.d.). World energy outlook 2016.
Other than gravitational load, the small size of the louvers https://webstore.iea.org/download/direct/202?fileName=WEO2016.
also reduces the building load cause by wind in comparison pdf
Kohler, C., Shukla, Y., & Rawal, R. (2017). Calculating the effect of
with larger shading devices.
external shading on the solar heat gain coefficient of windows.
This paper shows only the beginning of L-shaped mini Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, CEPT University. Energy
louvers more comprehensive research. Further research can Technologies Area.
be done to show L-shaped mini louvers performance in dif- Onebuilding. (n.d.-a). Nigeria weather data. Muhammed Murtala
International Airport, Lagos. https://climate.onebuilding.org/
ferent locations. Other possible architecture-related research
WMO_Region_1_Africa/NGA_Nigeria/NGA_LA_Lagos-
topics are visibility, daylight study, thermal comfort, and user Muhammed.Intl.AP.652010_TMYx.2003-2017.zip
preferences of the design and application. Construction Onebuilding. (n.d.-b). India weather data. Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj
research can also be accomplished regarding louvers addi- International Airport, Mumbai. https://climate.onebuilding.org/
tional load to the building, louvers window or frame attach- WMO_Region_2_Asia/IND_India/MH_Maharashtra/IND_MH_
Mumbai-Shivaji.Intl.AP.430030_TMYx.2003-2017.zip
ment, as well as their durability. Economical approach Suryandono, A. R., Hariyadi, A., & Fukuda, H. (2018a). L-shaped mini
research can also be executed to show the possibility of louvers performance of solar radiation reduction in glass windows.
applying L-shaped mini louvers to save energy and users’ In The 12th Seatuc Symposium: Engineering Education for
money. More researches on this object will give broader and Sustainable Development. OS02-10.
Suryandono, A. R., Hariyadi, A., & Fukuda, H. (2018b). Mini louvers
holistic performance of possible application in the real world. performance of building cooling load energy reduction. In Grand
Renewable Energy 2018: How to Accelerate Renewable Energy
Acknowledgements First author study at The University of Kita- Integration, P-At-16.
kyushu is financially funded by Indonesia Endowment Fund for
User Perception of Energy Efficiency
in School of Architecture and Built
Environment (SABE) Building, Kigali,
RWANDA
Abstract 1 Introduction
The faculty building of School of Architecture and Built
Environment (SABE) at University of Rwanda was The issue of building design in the twenty-first century has
designed based on volcano form and volcano stones taken a different approach with specific reference and con-
was used as part of its external finish. This was done for sideration for sustainability. The issue of sustainability is a
aesthetic purposes and also to ensure that the building fits recurring point in every building design as it relates to
into the environment. The design was based on the environmental sustainability, with many architects striving
principle of energy efficiency in terms of lighting and to ensure that their designs fit into the environment as much
thermal considerations. The observable problem is the as possible (Schluter & Thesseling, 2009). A key design
effectiveness of the design provision in meeting the users’ consideration in the new buildings particularly as it relates to
needs and aspirations within the building. The aim of this public buildings is that of energy efficiency, with the
paper is to examine the perception of the users of SABE architects doing everything possible to achieve maximum
building regarding the passive design considerations. The passive energy control within the buildings. The other issue
study made use of direct observation of the design of sustainability is the management of resources available to
features of the building using an observation checklist, man and this cuts across various facets of man’s existence,
while the opinion of the users was obtained using an be it built environment, consumer industry or production
interview guide and questionnaire. The results were (Carlan, 2015; Khan, 2008; Manning, 2013; Morelli, 2011).
analysed using descriptive statistics and presented as It is therefore common to find many establishments and
tables, charts and figures. The study concluded that the government authorities giving serious attention to environ-
design features and concept adopted for the building were mental concerns as it affects the infrastructural development
adequate in terms of lighting for the offices and inade- of their country. There is growing competition for the lim-
quate in terms of thermal considerations. The paper ited resources (finance) for the running and management of
concluded that there is need to introduce additional government institutions, and this is often attributed to the
openings that would allow for controlled lighting in the growing population and the competing demand for infras-
classrooms, and there is need to make fixed lighting tructure. In an attempt to reduce the running costs of these
windows operable. There is also need to examine the institutions, issues related to environmental sustainability
issues of privacy when considering lighting of the interior have become the focus with specific reference to energy cost
spaces as users preferred to have opaque glass and savings. In existing buildings, care is taken to undertake
window blinds at openings. energy audits with view of reducing the cost, while in the
case of new buildings, such costs cuts are examined and
Keywords built-in at the design stage (Jansson et al., 2013; Sonetti,
2013; Sozer, 2010).
Education buildings Design Efficiency Energy Education is believed to be the bedrock of any nation’s
Users development, hence the huge investments in education by
many African countries; these investments range from the
construction of buildings, provision of infrastructure and
M. Michieletto (&) O. F. Adedayo development of the teachers. The design and construction of
Department of Architecture, School of Architecture and Built educational buildings have shifted towards energy efficiency
Environment (SABE), University of Rwanda, Kigali, Rwanda
in order to fit into the environmental sustainability require- that originality of this study was drawn, and the study
ments and also mitigate the challenges of climate change showed that the passive design considerations implemented
(Adeleke, 2011; Nisha & Jayasudha, 2016). It is now com- in the building were negated because they did not meet the
mon to find institutions demanding building designs that aspirations of the users’ given the strategies adopted by the
would reduce the cost of energy consumption so that they users.
could invest the savings in other aspects of the institutions.
The SABE building was designed and built as a sustainable
building by offering energy savings in terms of lighting and 1.1 Sustainability in Building Designs and Users
cooling through the use of passive design elements and
choice of building forms. Observing how the building has It had been established that POE gives the designer a
been put to use by the users showed some conflict between mechanism for evaluating the building from the users’ per-
intention of the architects and adaptation of the users. The spective; it is therefore imperative to examine issues of
motivation for this study was the adaptation strategies by the building sustainability and the user’ as proposed in this
users that negated the passive sustainability design consid- section. The importance of sustainability in the building
erations. The objective of this study is to determine the industry is no longer a new development as there has been a
users’ perception regarding the passive design consideration steady movement towards achieving efficient energy reduc-
for energy efficiency and the basis for the adaptive strategies tion in operation and maintenance of buildings (Khosla &
they evolved in the course of using the SABE building. Singh, 2014). In achieving the sustainability during the use
The selling point of many architectural designs aside of the building, the users become key to the efficient running
from the aesthetic value is the amount of energy savings the of the energy saving considerations, hence their importance
design would yield (Naboni et al., 2015). The most common from the design stage. According to Harputlugil (2017), the
feature is the application of the courtyard, the atrium, ori- belief that the buildings in the world account for 35–40% of
entation, the glazing and the response to climatic factors the energy consumption is seen as a basis for ensuring
such as temperature regulation. The success of any building sustainability right from the building design stage and its
design is the satisfaction of the users achieving the stated subsequent usage. The approach is to ensure that the
goals at the conception stage, in this case the energy effi- building design and its subsequent construction fit into the
ciency. It implies that the users are key towards achieving climatic conditions of the place where it is situated.
the set objectives of the architects and the client, if the user The success of the design can only be measured when the
fails to achieve the set objectives or even use the building in users begin to utilise the building and try to adapt to the
a different way from the manner intended then the design provisions within the building. In order to achieve sustain-
could be considered a failure. According to Jason et al. able energy building, Chwieduk (2003) stated that the most
(2013), buildings are often designed and constructed to meet important step towards this goal was to strive for energy
the needs and desires of the users, clients and the society at efficiency in the buildings. There is the need to ensure that
large, and these are expressed in terms of either regulations the user of such buildings understands and makes use of the
or codes which should be adhered to. It implies that any building appropriately. This includes using artificial lighting
energy efficient building design of which educational and cooling systems only when necessary.
buildings are inclusive should also meet the needs of the It is well known that users’ comfort is an integral part of
users (staff and students). The SABE building at the the architectural designs, and when buildings are con-
University of Rwanda is an example of educational building structed, the users will always try to ensure they are com-
in Rwanda that sought to achieve energy efficiency from the fortable within the building. This assumption is not different
design and construction perspective. The design sought to from those of the users of the SABE building. The improper
reduce energy consumption in terms of thermal and light use of any building that has been designed to be sustainable
design considerations; through the use of several design defeats the sustainability provision of the buildings (Chenari
elements, this was according to the design concept proposed et al., 2016). Examples of activities by users that could affect
by the architect. the sustainability intent in a building include but not limited
Post-occupancy evaluation (POE) is believed as the to;
mechanism for determining if the objectives set out in the
building design is achieved when the building is put to use in 1. The use of artificial lighting during the day.
terms of judging aspirations of the users (Vischer, 2002). 2. The use of artificial cooling system to ventilate a space.
POE equally assists in determining the building quality from 3. Lighting up multiple lighting units than required within a
the users’ perspective which would assist in documenting space.
the success of the building and also aspects for improvement 4. Closing of windows simply to run the air conditioners.
according to Watson (2003). It is against this background 5. The use of window blinds or coverings.
User Perception of Energy Efficiency in School of Architecture … 31
These activities oftentimes cannot be completely envis- was however defeated because of the further sub-division of
aged by the architects, particularly as the attitude of students the building into smaller individual units of which some
and staff often varied and difficult to generalise. Their spaces have a long part of the building along the East–West
actions however often give an inkling of how to respond to axis. This sub-division affected the respondents as they
some of their basic actions when designing similar buildings could only respond to their experiences within these indi-
in future. vidual spaces rather than the overall building. The building
envelope is made up of concrete roofing and sandcrete
hollow block infill that is finished with volcano stones used
2 Research Method as a local building material. The walls were rendered using
cement and sand mix internally and externally in some areas
This study comes under descriptive survey which can be of the building.
achieved using the post-occupancy evaluation (POE) meth- The building is also divided into two separate wings
ods which is considered adequate for such studies according connected by an open bridge which was done to reduce the
to Adedeji and Fadamiro (2012) and Zimmerman and Martin overall mass of the building by breaking the building into
(2001). Direct observation was conducted on the building two and creating several corridors that link the different
and the results are presented in tables. The design elements bridges thereby ensuring good flow of air around the
applied in the building design to ensure the energy efficiency building. The planning was such that the office spaces were
were examined. A total of 96 respondents (16 Staff and 80 located at the same area on the ground floor and the design
Students) were selected for the study from a total population concept adopted for the offices was open plan system which
of 850 users (47 Staff and 803 Students). The students were affected the number of facilities and fittings required. The
selected across the four levels of study, equally giving a offices are connected using corridors and courtyards with an
distribution of 20 students per level of study. The implica- office located in the centre of the courtyard which serves as
tion of some of these design considerations is discussed the boardroom for the school. All the offices had windows
based on interviews conducted with some selected users of on one side of the wall while the other openings by the
the building which include student and staff. The analysis of corridors had fixed glass; hence, they could only admit either
their opinion is presented under specific sub-headings which direct sunlight or reflected light depending on the location
specifically examines the aspect related to energy efficiency within the building. Two of the three offices located within
in terms of lighting and thermal considerations within the the courtyard had their windows opening only to the
building. The building plans and images are presented as courtyard while the boardroom had windows on both sides
figures to further illustrate the findings. The elements used in of the walls. The classroom areas on the ground floor which
providing a passive energy efficient building were identified are at the same wing as the offices are connected by a large
and discussed. The selection of the respondents was based lobby with a small courtyard. Three of the classrooms within
on purposive sampling method to ensure that all categories this particular area had windows on adjacent walls, while the
of users were represented as their use and need varied. fourth classroom had windows on only one side of the wall.
The use of iron grill gates as doors ensured that that there
was free flowing air around and within the corridors which provision of lighting for interior spaces, which was expected
was expected to cool the building. to reduce the need for artificial lighting. The location of
The ground floor of the second building is made up of an these glazing within areas adjoining the courtyard was
exhibition hall that is lighted using fixed glazing at one expected to reduce the direct effect of glare which was
section of the wall and rectangular-shaped openings for the achieved in areas with overhangs on the ground floor. The
only source of air into the large space. This same concept low number of windows and the use of large wall areas on
was used for the auditorium which extended into the base- the exteriors of the building were expected to assist in reg-
ment; the access into this hall is from a large opening ulating thermal balance of the building given the infill
expected to serve as the dining area for the kitchen. The material of sandcrete hollow blocks. The use of courtyards
dining area also connects to a large lobby that links the and the separation of the unit spaces (classrooms, studios
corridor to the classrooms; these classrooms have windows and offices) was to ensure that air could circulate around the
open on one side of the wall with glazing on another side building adequately thereby reducing the overall massing of
solely for the purpose of lighting. The workshop is con- the building. The use of the high-level windows in the
nected using an open courtyard accessible from outside; the classrooms and studios was to improve the ventilation within
workshop has a glazed side visible to the courtyard while the such spaces. The provided flowerbeds was expected to
rectangular-shaped openings are located within two adjacent provide some form of cooling during hot periods and also
walls as shown in Fig. 4. improve the ventilation in terms of quality of air around the
The first floor of the school building as shown in Fig. 3 is building (see Fig. 5). It is expected that stack effect would be
such that it accommodates only classroom and studio spaces. achieved when the foldable walls are left open in combi-
The basic design for the spaces was adjacent walls to the nation with the roof windows. These are some of the per-
external part of the building with provision of windows and ceived objectives of the building design based on the
provision for one foldable glazed wall for the admittance of observation of the users. These design features employed by
light whenever the need arose. In cases where the classrooms the architect were expected to ensure the sustainability of the
were adjoined by a corridor, the foldable glazed wall was building passively; however, with the introduction of the key
provided in opposite sides of the wall with windows in only element (users) in a successful building development, the
one side of the wall. The use of high-level windows made of objectives of the building considerations were affected.
glass louvers was adopted in each of the classrooms and
studios; this was achievable given the nature of the roofing
concept adopted for the building which was done on the 3.2 User Perception on Thermal Considerations
volcano idea. The volcano concept is based on the aesthetic
design concept of the mountains believed to have resulted The average temperature range in Kigali is at between 16
from the eruptions of volcanoes in Rwanda, and it allowed and 28 °C; this is considerably cool when compared with
the users to be able to relate such buildings to the local other hot regions within Africa such as West Africa (Nige-
environment. The smoke is usually seen as rising through ria) 28 °C and 40 °C and North Africa (Algeria) 23 and 45 °
the top of the volcano eruptions, and this idea was incor- C; hence, it is understandable that the majority of the
porated in the design of the roof with the introduction of the buildings in Rwanda do not make artificial cooling system.
louver windows at the roof top where hot air is expected to The design of the SABE building is equally based on such
rise through. consideration with no provision for fans or air conditioners;
The design considerations for the lighting in the building the building is expected to be self-regulating. The stone
were hinged on the use of extensive glazing in terms of its finishing is believed to have contributed to the heat gain
The story of Callirrhoë comes from Pausanias; but our poet has modified
the original by basing the motive of the plot upon the origin of the worship
of Dionysos, which, as she admits, must have been much earlier. The
anachronism is deliberate, however, and does not vitiate the theme, which is
already un-Greek in its preoccupation with romantic passion. For
Callirrhoë, a maiden of Calydon, is beloved to distraction by the Dionysiac
priest Coresus. She loves him in return (or at least our poet makes us
suspect so), but will not marry him because she cannot worship the new
god. He thereupon calls down a curse upon her city, and the people begin to
sicken and die of the plague. They send to consult the oracle at Dodona, and
it is decreed that Callirrhoë must be sacrificed to Dionysos unless some one
else will die in her stead. No one offers, however, and she goes to the altar
prepared to die. Coresus makes ready to slay her, but when the moment
comes to strike he kills himself instead of her. His sacrifice convinces
Callirrhoë of the truth of his religion. Now that he is dead she realizes that
she had loved him, and she kills herself as an offering to his god.
The play is a living work despite its ancient theme, its rather cumbrous
machinery, and its mixed elements. But apart from certain passages of great
imaginative beauty, its chief interest lies in the fact that its motives—;love,
self-sacrifice, enthusiasm—;were the ruling motives of the poets’ lives and
a frequent theme of their art. Therein, of course, lies the significance of
their modification of the old story. Love they always saw as the greatest
good of life, self-sacrifice as the dearest end of life, and enthusiasm (here
enters Dionysos) as the means to life’s noblest expression. In this last
element the work remains Greek, though Englished in so much else.
Michael was, in that sense, a Thracian born, and she had compelled a peace
with Apollo. She infused the play with the spirit of Dionysiac worship
because that spirit was her own. And when one remembers the spiritual
truth that was implicit in the cult of Dionysos, its contribution to the world’s
growing belief in immortality, and its connexion with the origins of tragedy,
there is peculiar appropriateness in such a subject for Michael Field’s first
essay in drama. Thus the key-pieces to the poet’s meaning are found where
Coresus is pleading with Callirrhoë for his love and his religion. He has
begged her to join the Maenads’ revel, and so set her spirit free; and he
declares of his god:
He came to bring
Life, more abundant life, into a world
That doled its joys as a starved city doles
Its miserable scraps of mummying bread.
He came to gladden and exalt, all such
Must suffer....
Callirrhoë. ... Of old the gods
Gave culture by the harp, the helm, the plough,
Not by the ivy-wand.
Coresus. Seems it so strange
That Semele’s sublime audacity
Should be the origin of life urbane?
We must be fools; all art is ecstasy,
All literature expression of intense
Enthusiasm: be beside yourself.
If a god violate your shrinking soul,
Suffer sublimely.
Callirrhoë. Yet I hold it true,
Divinity oft comes with quiet foot.
Coresus. To give a moment’s counsel or to guard
From instant peril. When a god forsakes
Olympus to infuse divinity
In man’s mean soul, he must confound, incite,
O’erwhelm, intoxicate, break up fresh paths
To unremembered sympathies. Nay, more,
Accompany me further in my thought—;
Callirrhoë, I tell you there are hours
When the Hereafter comes and touches me
O’ the cheek.
. . . . .
. . . . .
Coresus. Turn not away, Callirrhoë; by goads
The ox-souled must be driven; yield response
To Heaven’s desire of thee; love humanly.
Love is the frenzy that unfolds ourselves;
Before it seize us we are ignorant
Of our own power as reed-bed of the pipe.
The rushes sang not; from Pan’s burning lips
Syrinx sucked music. Wert thou lute to love,
There were a new song of the heaven and earth.
Callirrhoë. ... I will not yield my love
To Bacchic priest....
Coresus. ... As unseasoned wood
That smokes and will not kindle is flung by
For any refuse purpose, while the train
Of torchlight sinuous winds among the hills,
A starry serpent, so art thou cast out,
An apathetic slave of commonplace,
Sluggish and irreceptive of true life,
From all high company of heavenly things.
Go to your home.
There is much that one would like to quote from this play, including the
faun scenes (written by Henry) that have already been adopted into certain
anthologies. Machaon, too, sceptic and humorist, might be used to
confound the dullards who said that Michael Field had no humour. There is
salt enough in him to give the whole tragedy another flavour, and he breaks
at least one of the precious unities. His rationalism is away in a much colder
region (he usually speaks in prose); and his conversion to the cult at the end
is out of character. But though one may not linger on him, one must stop for
a moment at Henry’s faun song. For here, very delicately and quietly, a
greater theme is stated. And if we seek in this first work for an early
glimpse of the larger vision which the poets attained at last, seeing the
tragic element of life as life’s inescapable shadow, it will be found, quite
unself-conscious, in this playful song.
Dear, my lord,
There are some thoughts
That through this stormy weather of my soul
Cannot now travel toward you.
Act II, Scene 5
In Act I, Scene 3, spies have just informed Queen Elinor of the King’s
love for Rosamund, and of the place where he has hidden her:
Q. Elinor. Thank God for boys!
To have reared a treasonous brood from his own blood,
To have it at my call!
[Sings.
. . . . .
I cannot think at all. How beautiful
This gold made silver in the moonlight! What!
Would Heaven age me for my Love? Let’s look
In the mirror. Rosamund, you’re worshipful.
[Starting back.] ’Tis thus,
Even thus, he swore that he should come to me.
His very words! The prophecy’s fulfilled,—;
I’ll comb my hair down to my very feet.
A step!—;my heart, some patience. Henry, speak;
Bid it take courage! [Enter Elinor.] God! the Queen!
But coming now to the plays which are completely representative of the
poets in this period, we may glance at The Father’s Tragedy, William Rufus,
Canute the Great, The Cup of Water, and The Tragic Mary. These, with
three others, appeared within the dates 1885 and 1890—;not a poor record
of five years’ work, and one which reminds us that our poets laboured at
their art as only the genuine artist does. They drew the themes of these
plays mainly from English history and Scottish chronicles; and they
selected them, all except that of The Tragic Mary, ultimately for an idea that
lay behind them. Obviously, therefore, this work is not entirely disinterested
art: it anticipates, to that extent, the problem-play, the intellectual drama,
and even (so far as concerns his influence in this country) Ibsen. Indeed, a
remarkable aspect of the group is the way in which, despite its romantic
tone and its Elizabethan form, it yet foreshadows the movement that
English drama was about to make toward a ‘realistic’ presentment of life.
There may be a piquancy in thinking of Michael Field the romantic as the
forerunner of Mr Bernard Shaw and Mr John Galsworthy: and it is not
certain which would be the less pleased at the comparison, ancestress or
descendants. The latter, following a poetic age with inevitable comedy
—;inevitable if only from reaction—;were compelled to decline upon prose
as their medium; and the great merit of Michael Field is that, belonging to
the poetic age and possessed of the poet’s ardour and imagination, she yet
kept near enough to the actual world to see the evils that existed there.
Happily removed from them by circumstance and temperament, she yet
kept her eyes clear and her sympathies alert. Her prologue to The Father’s
Tragedy is apt to this point, for there she warns
to turn to more congenial pages than her tragedies. It is evident that she was
concerned, thus early, with the joyless truth which was to take possession
—;absolute and somewhat depressing possession—;of the dramatists who
came after her. Unlike them, however, by giving her truth the form of
poetry she endowed it with the joyousness of art. She saw it, too, in the
round: there is a largeness in her conception of it which gives her
‘intellectual drama’ greater dignity, and one would suppose greater
permanence, than later ‘realistic’ work. Yet when one observes the ideas
that govern some of her plays in this kind—;parental tyranny, the land
question, marriage, or the conflict between an older and a newer order of
civilization—;one recognizes at once the likeness to the motives of much
more recent drama. Indeed, we might go further and demonstrate a rather
later play—;Attila—;as an anticipation of Freud and the psycho-analysts.
The Father’s Tragedy, a play in five acts and a great many scenes, was
written almost entirely by the younger of the two poets. Some parts of it
were composed by her at the age of sixteen, and were in fact the means by
which Michael discovered her dramatic talent. At the date of its publication
(1885) Henry was only twenty-three, and it had been completed some
months before. The play is, therefore, the work of a very young mind, and
one is not surprised that its main feature is a vigorous and sympathetic
study of youth. What does surprise one, however, is that the study of age in
this struggle between a father and a son is also sympathetic; and although it
is the son who is the victim of the father, the play is called, significantly, the
father’s tragedy. Which is to say that the profoundest depth of the tragedy is
seen to be the moral defeat (one ought rather to say the moral annihilation)
of the father. That is a conception not so youthful, perhaps, as the age of the
author; just as the fierce dark strength of the drama would not appear to
accord with her sex. There is something Brontesque in the sombre power of
this tragedy; something too much of horror, barely relieved by two or three
short scenes of hectic gaiety when the young prince has escaped
temporarily to his boon companions. But only imagination of the highest
kind could have conceived it.
The plot comes from Scotichronicon and the old chronicler Wyntoun,
whose words are in one place almost exactly quoted. Robert III is shown to
be pious, weak, superstitious, affectionate, desiring only the ‘good’ of his
heir, the young Prince David, Duke of Rothsay. But David, intensely alive
in his buoyant young manhood, loathes the dour ‘good’ that is forced upon
him, and combats it. He has, in fact, more strength than his father, and the
struggle becomes bitter and tragic only when Albany, the King’s brother,
backs the King with a strength equal to David’s own, overbears the father’s
weakness and perverts his affection, and eventually compasses the Prince’s
death. The crisis is the enforced marriage of David to a bride whom he
detests, he having been literally sold to her father as the highest bidder for a
great match. He breaks into the council-chamber at the moment when the
King and Albany are settling the price that the bride is to pay for him.
Albany bids him be seated.
. . . . .
Rothsay. Nothing glorious
Is marketable—;fame, nor love, nor deeds
Of any virtue, youth nor happiness;
Nothing, oh nothing, but the meanest things,
Of which I am the meanest. On my soul,
You drag me in the dirt, and there I’ll lie
And dash it in your faces....
. . . . .
. . . . .
I ever thought
Death was a shadow.—;I myself am Death.
I fed and never knew it: now I starve.
Here is the skeleton I’ve seen in books!
’Tis I—;the knarled and empty bones. Here—;Here—;
The grinning dints! I thought Death anywhere
But near my life; and it is in the pith
And centre of my body. Horrible!
Act IV, Scene 2
King Robert does not know that David is dying, and the tragic irony of
Scene 5 of this act is masterly. It is a wild night, and the King, crouching
over the fire of a room high up in the castle, hears the wind shriek outside
and thinks of his boy, whom he believes to be merely shut up like a naughty
child to recover from his rage:
Beowulf. Do you think the Earth’s a thing that makes your flesh
Soft for the worms?—;the harvests lie asleep
Upon her bosom; she has reared the spring;
The seasons are her change of countenance;
She lives, and now for many thousand years
Hath ruled the toiling and the rest of men.
... She’ll judge.
The people of this drama are vigorous creatures, as sharply drawn and
clear-cut as types, but very far from the merely typical. The poet has
created, and not constructed, them; and each one possesses his own soul.
Rufus is a credible villain, a man and not a monster. He can melt at the sight
of filial piety, unbend to a jest, warm to affection. Anselm may stand as a
figure which shall represent the insulted Church, but he is a very holy and
gentle old priest. Philosopher and saint, he was, of course, historically
studied; but he is, despite verisimilitude, an almost complete embodiment
of the two qualities of our poet’s mind which make so rare a combination
—;her religious temper and her philosophic intellect. Two short quotations
from him may help to illustrate this:
But of all the characters, one supposes Leofric to have engaged the
poets’ affection most. He is a ‘mason’: which is to say he is the architect,
sculptor, and builder all in one who was the medieval artist. It is evident
that the poets had particular joy in imagining him, absorbed and happy in
his real world of art, with the actual world as mere stuff for his modelling.
If Leofric ever allows himself to be disturbed by the King’s greedy inroads,
it is from no ‘political’ reason, but simply that the noisy hunters make such
havoc of the woodland peace:
The motive of Canute the Great (1887) presents a curious difficulty. For
if we are to accept the poet’s own statement of what she meant by the play
(and it does seem as if she ought to have known), then we are forced to
conclude that she attempted the impossible, and therefore failed. But one
has the suspicion that she did not quite know what she meant by it—;which
is not so impertinent as it sounds, and only means that her artistic instinct
was stronger and truer in this case than her philosophy. For in the preface
she declares that she is here dealing with the theory of evolution; and she
elaborates an idea which, had it really operated as a motive force, would
surely have paralysed her Muse and struck it dumb. Canute, however, is no
paralytic: on the contrary, he has his creator’s vehement life and passion, at
least for the first half of the drama. But in those scenes he is far enough
from any abstract theory. Yet when his vitality flags, as it does sometimes,
and when the play becomes, as a consequence, to that extent unsuccessful,
the cause lies in a certain resemblance which the theme does bear to the
poet’s definition of it. For it is possible to regard the character of Canute in
the abstract as a transition between two ages and a link between two orders
of civilization. That is, of course, the meaning which the poet saw in it
—;when she was writing her preface. But in the process of making the
drama the wise æsthetic impulse seized and worked upon something
simpler, more definite, and more moving—;the potential conflict that exists
everywhere and always among human creatures between their instincts and
their reason. That, surely, is a tragic motive of universal validity; and it may
precipitate at any moment, and at any stage of civilization, the revolt of the
half-tamed instincts which is true stuff of tragedy, whether it be enacted
within the small orbit of an individual soul or in the insane immensity of a
world-war. So long as Canute is at grips with the rebel powers
—;dramatized in his struggle with Edmund—;he is a great dramatic figure;
but when his creator raises the conflict—;with his penitence for Edmund’s
death—;to the plane of pure thought, the life goes out of him and he
becomes but a type, though a very noble one, of spiritual struggle. Even at
those moments, however, one may find passages where the æsthetic sense
has subdued theory to itself with fine effect. Thus the poet has touched
Canute’s love for Emma with symbolism, seeing her as the gentler and riper
civilization into which Canute is adopted; and again, the wild Northern land
of his origin, the elements which went to the making of his race, the secret
compulsive urge of heredity, are embodied in the figure of a weird
prophetess who is to him his other self, the incarnate spirit of those ancient
forces. The speech which follows is made by Canute when he is recalling
his first meeting with Emma. There are passages with her, love-scenes
between the young sea-king and the mature queen, which are adroitly and
boldly handled, and are drama in essence and in fact. But here, in a reverie,
is the poet’s opportunity for putting her theory into a symbol: