Julian Fuks - Mercado - de - Argumentos

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

!"#$%&'(&"(%#)*+",-'./(0',.1&"#%23".(.'4#"(*+%(51-"#%-*#%(&'(,'6'(.

7$*5'

!"#$%&'(&"(%#)*+",-'./
0',.1&"#%23".(.'4#"(*+%(51-"#%-*#%(&'
,'6'(.7$*5'
8*519,(:*;.
$%&'(%)%*)+,'%(-'.(-)/,&0-12-*%(,3-1-)0%4-)5678)9&3(,'2()%):2(1-4,&'-8

!"#$%&'()*+

;,1<.=*)&.>%&',*%)-)?2(@-)A-&)4%,&)%&B.%3,A-&C)12),1&'-1'%)%*)B.%)DE)1F2)&%)%G04,3,'-*H
%*)B.%)DE)1F2)&%)B.%&',21-*H)A,'-*%&)-1',<2&)02A%*)'%()&%)%*>(%1I-A2)%1'(%)2&)IE>,'2&
A2)0(%&%1'%H)02A%*)&%)*2&'(-()J,<2(2&2&)%)3-1K1,32&H)02A%*)'%()-43-1@-A2)2)-.<%)A%
&%.) 02A%() ,*02&,',J28) L%) -4<.1&) A,&3.(&2&) -4',&&21-1'%&) A-) A=3-A-) A%) !#MNH) 2&) B.%
-0(%<2-J-*) .*) (%'2(12) A-&) -('%&) -) 0(E',3-&) (%*2'-&H) 2&) B.%) %G,<,-*) 2) ?,*) A-
%G0%(,*%1'-@F2)32*)-&)4%'(-&H)2&)B.%)&%)%(,<,-*)321'(-)2)(%,1-A2)A2)'%((2()12)O*>,'2)A-
4,1<.-<%*H) 2&) B.%) ,*042(-J-*) 2) (%&'->%4%3,*%1'2) ,*%A,-'2) A%) &.-) -132(-<%*) 1-
(%-4,A-A%) P) A%) '2A-) -) ,1?4-*-A-) J%(>2((%,-H) %1?,*H) A%) .1&) '-1'2&) &%(%&) 3-1&-A2&) A-
*2A%(1,A-A%)P)J%(,?,3-*Q&%)I2D%)02.32&)(%&B.R3,2&)12)3-*02)A-)'%2(,-8)9*)0-4%&'(-&H
%*)A%>-'%&H)%*)?%&',J-,&)%)321<(%&&2&)'F2)A,?.1A,A2&H)0-(%3%*)(-(2&)2&)?,4S&2?2&)%)3(R',32&
B.%)&%)?-@-*)-(-.'2&)A%&&%),A%E(,28)9&'-(F2)*-,&)'R*,A2&)B.%)12)0-&&-A2)2.)'%(F2)&%
(%',(-A2)0-(-)321'%*04-()-&)-*04-&)321B.,&'-&C)12)(%3-'2)A-&)3-&-&)4.G.2&-&)2.)&,*04%&H
12)&,4T13,2)A2&)>(-@2&)U)%&3(,J-1,1I-H)'2A2).*)%G=(3,'2)A%)?,33,21,&'-&)0(2A.V)2&)?(.'2&
?-('2&)A2)4%J-1'%)-1',*2A%(128
;F2)&%)2.J%*)34-*2(%&H)-3I-B.%&H)32134-*%&H)1%1I.*)(%J24'2&2)%&'(,>,4I2),13,'-1A2
U)2(A%*8)W&)(-,J2&2&)A%'(-'2(%&)A-&)J-1<.-(A-&)321'(-)2&)B.-,&)+X2'-(A)A%34-(-(-)<.%((-
3-4-(-*Q&%)'-1'2)B.-1'2)%4%)0(S0(,2H)?-4%3,A2)IE)*-,&)A%).*-)A=3-A-8)$-&)+X2'-(A)1F2
02A%(,-)-3I-(Q&%)J,'2(,2&2)%*)&.-)%*0(%,'-A-Y)1F2)321&%<.,.)&%B.%()-)-0-(%1'%)'(=<.-8
Z21&'-1'%)-2)421<2)A2&)-12&)2.)3(%&3%1'%)%*),1'%1&,A-A%H)2)*%&*2)A%&%D2)A%).1,A-A%
%) &%<.(-1@-) B.%) 2) ?,4S&2?2) ?(-13T&) A%'%3'-(-H) -) *%&*-) O1&,-) 02() .*-) -('%) B.%) 1F2
,132*2A%H)B.%)&S),1?2(*%)2.)-<(-A%H)A%&?%VQ&%)A%)'2A2)-4-(A%)%)A%,G2.Q&%),*0%(-()%*
&.(A,1-8)6%*)*-,&)&%)2&'%1'-()%*)&%.)3-(E'%()0(2<(-*E',32H)32*)-)A,&3(,@F2)B.%)&S)2>'T*
-&)'%1AT13,-&)I%<%*K1,3-&H)-)32*02('-A-)2>%A,T13,-)-)%&&-&)0(202&'-&)'-4J%V)1.13-
'%1I-)&,A2)'F2)&2>%(-1-8

#%8.9&1% !"#
()*'+,-.)/$

$%&'%()*%+%,-./+0+12-340+&%**0250+6/4+7(%+*%+&%*8(0&'0504+/*+9:*)4/'%&,/*;+</
-%49/+ %4+ 7(%+ 03,'0+ *%+ 09&%*%,-0504+ 6/4=0-35/*>+ %4+ 7(%+ *%+ 3,*(&8304+ 6/,-&0+ 0
43*0,-&/930+%+0+'3**390?./+'07(%2%*+7(%+9&%-%,'304+*(9%&0&>+,%**%+-%49/+03,'0+@0530
,%80?./+%+&0'36023*4/A+03,'0+@0530+4/'%&,3'0'%;+B/C%+,./+@D+4/'%&,3'0'%+9/&7(%+/
*32E,63/+F+'%+0,(E,630+%+6/,*%,*/G+@/C%+*%+'32(3+0+'3*6(**./+%*-F-360>+9/&+3,:6(0+%+%*-F&32;
<%,@(40+-&0'3?./+0+*%&+,%80'0>+,%,@(4+6/,H23-/+'%+8%&0?./>+,%,@(40+/=C%?./+'%+%*-32/A
/+%IF&63-/+'%+H3663/,3*-0*+503+0+91=236/+90&0+09&%630&+/*+%49%,@/*+'/*+0,-%90**0'/*>
*%(*+&/490,-%*+'%+6&30-353'0'%+'%*4%'3'0;+<./+*%+%I6%'%4+%4+2/(5/&+/(+,/*-02830>+,./
'3*6&343,04+%,-&%+/*+*F6(2/*+9&%-F&3-/*;+<%,@(4+%4=0-%+%,-&%+,/5/+%+0,-38/>+%,-&%
/=*6(&/+%+2J493'/>+%,-&%+*(C/+%+3,*J93'/G+/+6049/+'%+=0-02@0+%*-D+'%*%&-/;

!"#$%&'()*+

<%*-%+9&%*%,-%+7(%+*%+9&%-%,'%+'%+-/2%&K,630+%+92(&023'0'%>+&%**02-0)*%+/+6/,-&0*-%+6/4
0+&37(%L0+H/&402+7(%+*%+053*-050+,0+23-%&0-(&0+'/+*F6(2/+MM;+N+%I9%&34%,-0?./+6/4+0
90205&0>+6/4+0+H&0*%>+6/4+0+9D83,0>+*(6%'%)*%+/+%49&%8/+'%+4/'%2/*+CD+-%*-0'/*>+'%
*/2(?O%*+6/,@%63'0*>+'%+,0&&0-350*+6/49/&-0'0*+6(C/+EI3-/+*%+*0=%+80&0,-3'/;+N+/9060+%
3,%I0(&J5%2+535E,630+'/+3,'3LJ5%2>+535E,630+7(%+*%+%I-%&,050+%4+-0,-0*+5%&-38%,*+'0+%*6&3-0>
*/=&%9O%)*%+ (40+ *(6%**./+ '%+ %I9%&3E,630*+ -&0,*90&%,-%*>+ (,35%&*03*>+ -&0'(LJ5%3*;
P%=%2/()*%+0+'%*6/,H30,?0+7(%+*(*9%,'30+7(027(%&+'3*6(&*/+/=C%-35/>+'%*6/,H30,?0+/=-3'0
0+6(*-/+,(4+2/,8/+0=0-%+'%+3,8%,(3'0'%*G+%4+*%(+2(80&+*/=&%5F4+(40+6&%,?0+&%,/50'0>
%43,%,-%4%,-%+ 9&084D-360>+ ,0*+ 9/**3=323'0'%*+ 3,H3,'0*+ '0+ 6/4(,360?./>+ ,/+ -&K,*3-/
34%'30-/+%,-&%+23,8(08%4+%+&%023'0'%;
Q+-./+9&%L0'/+%62%-3*4/+7(%+7(023H360&30+,/**/+-%49/+2343-0)*%+0/+6049/+&0*/+'0*
-%4D-360*>+'/*+%,&%'/*+50&3%80'/*+%+'3*-3,-/*;+P%+-/'0*+90&-%*>+'/+6%,-&/+'0*+4%-&:9/2%*
7(0'&36(20'0*+0/*+'%*/&'%3&/*+8&/-O%*+'0+@(40,3'0'%>+'%+-/'0*+90&-%*>+40*+*/=&%-('/
'/+%3I/+0,82/**0IR,36/+7(%+*%+4/*-&0+-./+9&/HJ6(/>+9&%6393-0)*%+(40+9&/H(*./+'%+@3*-:&30*
,/50*;+ S,-%&%**0+ 7(%+ *%C04+ 9%6(230&%*>+ 7(%+ &%5%2%4+ (40+ H06%-0+ '%*6/,@%63'0+ '0
@(40,3'0'%>+7(%+6/,-&3=(04+6/4+620&%L0+90&0+(4+6/,@%634%,-/+6/2%-35/;+S,-%&%**0
7(%+%,*3,%4>+%,-&%-%,@04+/(+'353&-04>+%+F+,%**%*+-%&4/*+9&D-36/*+7(%+%,H34+*%+3,*-3-(3
/+5%2@/+6@040'/+T+/&'%4+'/*+9:*)4/'%&,/*;+P3**%43,04)*%+*%4+'3H36(2'0'%+028(,*+'%
*%(*+&%-/&,/*+-./+=%,7(3*-/*A+/+&%-/&,/+'0+&%9&%*%,-0?./+'3&%-0>+/+&%-/&,/+'/+0&8(4%,-/
5D23'/>+/+&%-/&,/+'/+'&04D-36/>+'/+6R436/>+'/+F936/>+'/+05%,-(&%*6/>+'/+0,%':-36/;
U('/+502%>+'/+403*+4%*7(3,@/+0/+403*+93-/&%*6/>+'%*'%+7(%+%,6/,-&%+*%(+2(80&+,0+/&'%4>
'%*'%+7(%+/+4%&60'/+*03=0+620**3H36D)2/;

!"#$%&'" !"#
!"#$%&'(&"(%#)*+",-'./(0',.1&"#%23".(.'4#"(*+%(51-"#%-*#%(&'(,'6'(.7$*5'

#$%&'()*)+,$-+.+/*)*$0$)(1+%23&$)&$4&%5+6)&,$&7+)+4+$*$+25-(5&2$4-(58-(&2$9&-%*.:25(4&2
;$&$9&-%*.,$)+$<=*.<=+-$1&)&,$8$&$1*(&-$*'*.(*)&-$)&$2=4+22&$&=$(%2=4+22&$)+$4*)*$&7-*>
?&1$2+=$*=@:.(&$5*1781$'3&$2+$4-(*%)&$A*1:.(*2$)+$.('-&2,$-+=%()*2$B&-$2=*2$4*B*2$+
4&%5-*4*B*2$ 2=4(%5*2,$ 2=*2$ 5-*1*2$ <=+$ -+.*5*1$ (%AC%4(*2$ 2&A-()*2,$ <=+$ )+%=%4(*1$ *
'(&.D%4(*$)*2$=-7+2>$E*--*5('*2$2&7-+$*$)+24&7+-5*$)*$2+@=*.()*)+,$2&7-+$2+@=*.()*)+2
(%4+-5*2,$2&7-+$B&.D1(4*2$-+.(/(&2*2,$2&7-+$*2$1*F+.*2$)*$B&7-+F*,$2&7-+$&2$)+24*.*7-&2
)&$%*F(21&>$E*--*5('*2$2&7-+$*./=1*$4&(2*,$%*--*5('*2$<=+$B&22*1$-+%)+-$=1*$7&*$2:%5+2+>
G&25&=$)+25+$.('-&H,$B+-/=%5*1$*2$B-*5+.+(-*2$)*2$.('-*-(*2,$+$.&/&$*B&%5*1$*$B-I@(1*
*<=(2(J3&$+1$4*2&$)+$-+2B&25*$*A(-1*5('*>$E3&$+--*1$%&2$B*.B(5+2$B&-<=+$*$(%)625-(*$)K
2=*2$/*-*%5(*2,$-+4(4.*%)&$&2$'+.L&2$2=4+22&2$%*$A&-9*$)&2$.*%J*1+%5&2$%&':22(1&2>
M(4*1$+2<=+4()*2$5&)*2$*2$B-K5(4*2$<=+$2+$4&%4+7*1$4&1&$*.5+-%*5('*2N$*.7+-/*O2+$*
B&+2(*$+$5=)&$&$<=+$)+.*$2+$*B-&@(1+$+1$*./=1$4*%5&$1+%&2$4&%2B:4=&>$P+$LK$2=7'+-23&,
<=+$%3&$2+9*$*$)&$<=+25(&%*1+%5&$K-()&,$<=+$%3&$2+9*$*$)&$-(/&-$4-:5(4&,$<=+$%3&$2+9*$*
)&$4L&<=+N$<=+$2+9*$*$2=7'+-23&$B-&5&4&.*-$)*$2=-B-+2*,$A*4(.1+%5+$*B-+2*)*$B+.&$2(25+1*
)+$+@B+45*5('*2>$P+$LK$5-*%2/-+223&$)+$A-&%5+(-*2,$<=+$2+9*$)*$A-&%5+(-*$+%5-+$A(4J3&$+
-+*.()*)+,$B*-*$<=+$1*(2$2+$*22+'+-+$*$%*5=-+F*$(%25-=5('*$)*$.(5+-*5=-*>
$Q%4+%2*)&$B&-$=1*$(%)625-(*$+)(5&-(*.$1*(2$-&7=25*$*$4*)*$)(*,$&$<=+$5-(=%A*$8$&
-&1*%4+,$1*2$&$-&1*%4+$+1$2=*$4&%4+BJ3&$1*(2$-+)=F()*>$?&%5-*-(*%)&$*$'&4*J3&$)&
/D%+-&$0$(%)+A(%(7(.()*)+$+$*&$(%*4*7*)&,$4&%5-*-(*%)&$2=*$5-*)(J3&$*=5&4-:5(4*$+$2+=
*B+/&$ 0$ (1B+-A+(J3&,$ +22+$ -&1*%4+$ )&$ %&'&$ 284=.&$ 1&25-*O2+$ 1=(5&$ 1*(2$ '&.5*)&$ 0
-+B+5(J3&$)+$AI-1=.*2,$0$-+B-&)=J3&$)+$A&-1*2$4&%2*7()*2,$0$4&%2&.()*J3&$)+$=1$1&)+.&
<=+$/*-*%5*$2=*$-+4+BJ3&$1*22('*$B&-$=1$B67.(4&$(-*24:'+.>$R+22*$1*%+(-*,$*&$2+$B-&B&-
4&1$(%/+%=()*)+$*$)+'&.'+-$0$*-5+$2+=$'*.&-$5+--+%&,$*&$5+%5*-$-+5-*5*-$&$1=%)&$B*-*
)+%=%4(KO.&$+$)+2*%4*-$2=*2$1*F+.*2,$*4*7*$4&1B*45=*%)&$4&1$&$1+21&$2(25+1*$*&
<=*.$<=+-$2+$1&25-*-$(%A+%2&,$B&(2$2+$-+4=2*$*$-+2/=*-)*-$2+=$4*-K5+-$(%25K'+.$+$*$4&%5-*-(*-
*$.I/(4*$)&$2(25+1*$;$4&%'+-5+%)&O2+,$(%+'(5*'+.1+%5+,$+1$1+-4*)&-(*>$#1&%5&*)*2$+1
.('-*-(*2,$5*(2$B-&)=JS+2$9K$%3&$B*-+4+1$4&%25(5=(-$=1$4&-B=2$*-5:25(4&,$+$2(1$=1$1+-&
1+-4*)&$)+$*-/=1+%5&2>

!"#$%&'()*+

T*2$4&1&$5+-K$2+$B-&)=F()&$5*.$A+4=%)()*)+$)+$()+(*2$+1$=1*$5+--*$<=+$LK$B&=4&2$*%&2
B*-+4(*$53&$(%A8-5(.H$R+$&%)+$5+-3&$2=-/()&$5*%5&2$+%-+)&2$(%8)(5&2,$2+$&$<=+$)+1*-4*'*

#%8.9&1% !"!
()*'+,-.)/$

$% &'()$*$% &(+,-$% '(.% .% -/0$/123/0-.% *.1% '4&'(-5/0-.1% 1-6/-7-0.2-,.18% 1'9% 0.(:2'(


-/.&(''/1),';8%.%-/'4-125/0-.%*'%7.2$1%.<1$;92$1%=9'%.0'-2.11'>%1'(%2(./1&$(2.*$1%?1
&:6-/.1@%A%=9'%'12(./B$%7'/C>'/$%2'(:%&$11-<-;-2.*$%.$1%./6;$D1.4C/-0$1%.%('2$>.*.
*'%1'9%&($2.6$/-1>$%1'%E912.>'/2'%';'18%*'&$-1%*'%1'91%'4&'(->'/2$1%'42('>$1%0$>%.
;-/69.6'>8%&.('0-.>%1'(%$1%>.-1%.2-/6-*$1%&';$%19&$12$%'16$2.>'/2$%*$%7.F'(%;-2'(:(-$@
G>.%*.1%('1&$12.1%&$11),'-18%9>%*$1%1-/2$>.1%*'11'% *'1.&'6$%?1%-/2'(*-HI'1
('19;2./2'1%*$%&($0'11$%B-12J(-0$8%+%$%=9'%K.;%L$12'(%.,'/2$9%&.(.%$%0.>&$%*.1%.(2'1
,-19.-18%*-.6/$12-0./*$%$%19(6->'/2$%*'%9>%/$,$%&.(.*-6>.M%$%*$%.(2-12.%0$>$%'2/J6(.7$!N
O.;%=9.;%$%.(2-12.8%$%'10(-2$(%0$>$%'2/J6(.7$%('>'2'%1'91%./1'-$1%0(-.2-,$1%.%9>.%.;2'(-*.*'
*-12./2'8%-*'.;-F.*.8%0$/7-./*$%=9'%'11.%.;2'(-*.*'%'12.(:%.%1.;,$%*.%0(-1'%=9'%$%.2-/6-(.
.2(.,+1%*'%1'91%&('*'0'11$('1N%P'%19.1%&(J&(-.1%'4&'(-5/0-.1%/Q$%;B'%1Q$%197-0-'/2'18%1'
19.%'4-125/0-.%&$(%*'>.-1%0$/7$(2:,';%'%.11'69(.*.%/Q$%0$/7$(>.%9>%*(.>.%$9%9>.
.,'/29(.8%9>.%<$.%1-/$&1'%*'%;-,($8%<.12.%.&';.(%.%<-$6(.7-.1%.;B'-.1%=9'%1'%>$12('>
>.-1%.2(.'/2'1%'%*'1->&'*-*.1N%R(-.D1'8%&.(.%92-;-F.(%$1%2'(>$1%*'%L$12'(8%.%S7./2.1-.
&(->-2-,-12.T%*'%=9'%$%$92($%B.<-2.(-.%.%,'(*.*'8%*'%=9'%$%$92($%2'(-.%S.0'11$%'1&'0-.;%.
&($0'11$1%&1)=9-0$1%'%1$0-.-1T%=9'%.$%'10(-2$(8%&($*92$%*.%0-,-;-F.HQ$%('6(.*.8%'12.(-.>
,'*.*$1N
U6'/2'1%*.%/$,.%6;$<.;-*.*'8%'9($&'91%'%'12.*9/-*'/1'1%2(./1&I'>%.1%7($/2'-(.1
*'%1'91%&.)1'1%'>%<910.%*.1%B-12J(-.1%69.(*.*.1%/$%2'>&$%&(->-2-,$%*$1%0$/2-/'/2'1
.2(.1.*$1N%R$>$%&.(2'>%&.(.%*.(%2'12'>9/B$%*.%>-1+(-.8%*.%69'((.8%*$1%-/7$(2V/-$1%*$
'42('>-1>$8% 1'91% *'12-/$1% >.-1% *-;'2$1% 2.><+>% 1'69'>% &.(3>'2($1% E$(/.;)12-0$1M
2'((-2J(-$1%=9'%1'E.>%7'(-*.1%.<'(2.18%.%W7(-0.%P9<1..(-./.8%.%X/*-.%2Q$%&$&9;$1.8%.%U>+(-0.
,-$;'/2.8%$%Y(-'/2'%Z+*-$N%[.1%;-,(.(-.1%.1%1'HI'1%*'%($>./0'18%=9'%&.('0'>%'>9;.(
0.2:;$6$1%6'$6(:7-0$1%'%1$0-$;J6-0$18%,Q$%.$1%&$90$1%*./*$%0$/2.%*'%2$*$%$%>.&.D>V/*-N
A>%0$>&(''/1),';%*'7'1.%.92$-(C/-0.8%$%>'(0.*$%09-*.%*'%(-(%*'%1'91%&(J&(-$1%2('E'-2$1M
'>%';$6-$1%(.16.*$1%*'%0$/2(.0.&.8%.%&('F.*.%.92$(.%*'%\(','%B-12J(-.%*$1%2(.2$('1%/.
G0(3/-.%('0$>'/*.%U%&'10.%*$%1.;>Q$%/$%]5>'/N
^.(.%$1%&.)1'1%=9'%&($,$0.>%&.(2-09;.(%-/2'('11'%B:%0$/2(.&.(2-*.1N%P'91%.92$('1
;$0.-1%1Q$%.0'-2$1%'%.11->-;.*$1%.>&;.>'/2'8%1Q$%;-*$1%0$>%.2'/HQ$%'%09(-$1-*.*'8%*'1*'
=9'% $<'*'H.>% .$% >$*';$% &('0$/0'<-*$% *'% /.((.2-,.% '% /Q$% 7(912('>% .% '4&'02.2-,.
-/,'12-*.N%U7(-0./$18%.1-:2-0$1%'%;.2-/$D.>'(-0./$1%1'(Q$%&('F.*$1%1'>&('%=9'%('2(.2.('>
$%.2(.1$8%.%>-1+(-.8%.%,-$;5/0-.8%.%69'((.8%$%'42('>-1>$_%1'91%0$/2'((3/'$1%=9'%796-('>

! %L$12'(8%K.;N%SA;%.(2-12.%0$>$%'2/J6(.7$T8%'>%A;%('2$(/$%*'%;$%('.;8%&&N%!`aD#b`

!"#$%&'" !"#
!"#$%&'(&"(%#)*+",-'./(0',.1&"#%23".(.'4#"(*+%(51-"#%-*#%(&'(,'6'(.7$*5'

#$%%$%&'$()%&$&*+,%$-$(&'-)')-&#$&)%%+.'/%&/+'-/%0&*+$&1/.2)(&$(&-$%%)34)&)%&./56$%
$7,%'$.'$%& #$& %+)& %/8,$#)#$0& %$-9/& #$.%)($.'$& ,:./-)#/%;& <9/& =& +(& $71$#,$.'$
#$%8/.2$8,#/>& /& ($%(/& 1-,.8?1,/& /1$-)4)& 2@& )3:+()%& #=8)#)%0& *+).#/& $+-/1$+%& $
$%')#+.,#$.%$%0&,(/A,3,B)#/%&$(&%$+&,(1)%%$&$%'=',8/0&)A-,)(&/%&A-)5/%&1)-)&/&-$)3,%(/
(@:,8/&#$&C)-3/%&D+$.'$%0&E)-:)%&F3/%)&$&G)-8?)&H@-*+$B0&$%'-).2).#/&)&8/(13$7,#)#$
'-).%8+3'+-)3&#$&I-:+$#)%0&$%*+$8$.#/&)&(/#$-.,#)#$&#$&J.$'',;
J& -,%8/& ,.8/.4$.,$.'$& #$& '/#)& $%%)& '$.#K.8,)& =& +()& 1$-#)& :$.$-)3,B)#)& #$
)+'$.',8,#)#$;&J&$%8-,'/-&L@&.9/&-$%1/.#$&)&+()&.$8$%%,#)#$&?.',()&#$&$71-$%%)-M%$0
.9/&16$&$(&*+$%'9/&%+)&1-N1-,)&2,%'N-,)&$&%+)&1-N1-,)&8+3'+-)0&.9/&#$4/34$&)/&(+.#/
%+)%&-+(,.)56$%&1$%%/),%&1)-)&)&+(&%N&'$(1/&)O-/.'@M3/&$&8/.O-/.')-M%$;&P(&4$B&#,%%/
).+3)&)&%,&($%(/&$(&%$+&/O?8,/&,(1$-,/%/0&O)BM%$&1-/O,%%,/.)3&8/(/&.+.8)&).'$%;&Q$
$%8-,'/-&)&,.'=-1-$'$&%+1/%')($.'$&1-,4,3$:,)#/&#$&%+8$%%,4)%&#$%:-)5)%R&#$&$%8-,'/-&)
$%8-,49/&*+$&$(1-$%')&%+)&(9/&#$&/A-)&S&$3)A/-)59/&#$&2,%'N-,)%&$%1$-)#)%0&S&8/.%'-+59/
#$&3,4-/%&8+L/&$.:$.#-/&%,%'K(,8/&-$,'$-)&$&1$-1$'+)&4$32/%&#/:()%;

!"#$%&'()*+

Q)&(/#$-.,#)#$&)&$%')&./4)&=1/8)&*+$&4,4$.8,)(/%&/&*+$&%$&1$-#$&=&)&)(A,59/&#/
1)-)#/7/>& )& )%1,-)59/& #$& T)1-$%$.')-& /& *+$& 2@& #$& ,.)1-$%$.'@4$3U0& .)%& 1)3)4-)%& #$
FV/')-#WR& )& ,.'$.59/& #$& T$.8/.'-)-& /& 1/.'/& #$& ,.#,O$-$.5)& $(& *+$& %$& $%8/.#$& )
1/%%,A,3,#)#$&#/&,(1/%%?4$3U0&.)&O/-(+3)59/&#$&I#/-./";&J&*+$&%$&$3,#$0&1)-)&8,')-&)
-$O$-K.8,)&8/(+(&)&)(A/%0&=&)&$'$-.)&'$.')',4)&#/&%+A3,($&X).',)./0&)&'$.')',4)&#$
'-).%1/-&)&#,%'Y.8,)&,.'-).%1/.?4$3&$.'-$&)&8/.8$159/&#$&)3:+()&8/,%)&$&)&8)1)8,#)#$
#$&#,%1/-&#$3)0&#$&#,%1ZM3);&[+).#/&2/L$&1/+%)(&%$+%&A-)5/%&S&$%8-,4).,.2)0&/%&$%8-,'/-$%
'K(&/%&1=%&A$(&)%%$.')#/%&)/&829/&$&)&8)A$5)&)3',4);&Q,%1$.%)(&)&+(&%N&'$(1/&)&)(A,59/
$&)&2+(,3#)#$>&.9/&)3($L)(&/&,(1/%%?4$30&.9/&8-$$(&,(1/%%?4$3&)*+,3/&*+$&)3($L)(;
Q$,7)(M%$&8/.%+(,-&1$3/&#$%$L/&#$&$O,8,K.8,)&#/&(+.#/&8/-1/-)',4/0&$4,').#/&/&3)1%/
'9/&.$8$%%@-,/&$.'-$&/&*+$&82)()(&#$&/AL$',4/%&$&/&*+$&82)()(&#$&-$%+3')#/%;
\/+8/&)&1/+8/&49/&%$&#$%)-',8+3).#/&/%&:-).#$%&#$%)O,/%0&4),&#$%)1)-$8$.#/&#/
Y(A,'/& #)& 3,'$-)'+-)& +(& #$& %$+%& $3$($.'/%& (),%& -$3$4).'$%0& +(& #/%& O)'/-$%& *+$
2,%'/-,8)($.'$&32$&-$.#$-)(&:-).#$&$%',()&$.'-$&/%&#$(),%&$.:$.2/%&2+()./%>&/&'/+-
#$&O/-8$&]&1)-)&I#/-./0&)&8/.#,59/&,(1-$%8,.#?4$3&1)-)&*+$&+(&'$7'/&3,'$-@-,/&1/%%)&%$-

W &FV/')-#0&^$).MD-).5/,%;&F)&1/%(/#$-.,#)#&_$713,8)#)&)&3/%&.,`/%a0&1;&!b;
" &I#/-./0&c2$/#/-&d;&c$/-?)&$%'=',8)0&1;&!eb;

#%8.9&1% !""
()*'+,-.)/$

$%&'()*('&+*,(-$.'./0*(1$.$()')'0('0()*.'&1'23*0()'(45678'7*.9('0($&+$)$:5'0()$
)515$6;&5$9($0()5+'.*0()'(7&'.;+51'9('0(<&'0*0(=8*(1')'(4>678'(1$.?$&+'9($(*0?'2$(56)51')$
'$(?'&;7&'<$9(@(?;756'9('$(1'?>+84$9('()50+A615'('1*5+;B*4(*6+&*(1'?'(*(1$6+&'1'?',(C0
45.5+*0(*:D7*6$09(.$&'509(?$4>+51$09(0$15'509(=8*('478.()5'(1'%5'(@(45+*&'+8&'('00'4+'&9($8
$0(45.5+*0('8+$5.?$0+$0(=8*(0*(*&575&'.(6$()*1$&&*&()*(8.'(4$67'(+&'E*+D&5'(184+8&'49(E;
6F$(*0+F$(?'&'(0*&(0$6)')$09(?*&01&8+')$09(*:?'6)5)$0,(C(.86)$()50?$65%545G'(08'0
<*&&'.*6+'09('6+57'0($8(+*16$4D751'09('(?'4'B&'9('(+*4'(*('0(+*14'09(*(1'%*('$('8+$&(0*
B'4*&()*4'0(?'&'(B*&+*&(0$%&*($(?'?*49(0*.(.*6*5$09(08'(5)*5'(?'&+5184'&,
H'0(8.'(5)*5'(?$)*(6F$(0*&(08<515*6+*9(?$)*(6F$(&*6)*&($('47$(561*&+$(=8*($0
*01&5+$&*0()*(=8'4=8*&(+*.?$(=8*&*.('41'62'&9(*(0*('(+*$&5'(6F$($0(1$6B*61*(+'4B*G(4I*0
B'4I'($(*:*.?4$()*(8.()$0('8+$&*0(=8*9(*.(08'0('?'&523*0(?J%451'09($0(*01&5+$&*0('+8'50
6F$(0*(1'60'.()*(*4$75'&,(K.(!LML9(N&'6G(O'<P'(*01&*B*8(8.(?*=8*6$(1$6+$(56+5+84')$
QR6+*('(4*5S9(8.(+*:+$(=8*(?'00$8()*0?*&1*%5)$(1$.$(+$)$0($0($8+&$0(=8*(?8%451$8(*.
B5)',(T'0()8'0(.D)51'0(?;756'0(=8*($(1$60+5+8>'.(*0+'B'(1$6+5)$($('&78.*6+$(1*6+&'4
)$(=8*(+&*G*('6$0(.'50(+'&)*(B5&5'('(0*&(C(1'0+*4$9('(I50+D&5'()*(8.(I$.*.(=8*(6F$(.*)*
*0<$&2$0( ?'&'( $%+*&( '1*00$( '( 8.( *)5<>15$( $<515'49( )'6)$( 0*.?&*( *.( 5.?*)5.*6+$0
560+5+815$6'50,(U(8.(%$.(1$6+$9(.'0(6F$(V()*.'50()5G*&(=8*(O'<P'(6F$(0*&5'(O'<P'(0*(6F$
$(I$8B*00*(&*+$.')$9(0*(6F$(I$8B*00*(<*5+$()'('<452F$(*()'(4$67'(*0?*&'()*00*(I$.*.('
'<452F$(*('(4$67'(*0?*&'()*(0*8(4*5+$&9(0*(6F$(I$8B*00*(+&'60<$&.')$($(*07$+'.*6+$()*
0*8(?*&0$6'7*.(*.(8.(*07$+'.*6+$()$(?&D?&5$(6'&&'&9(0*(6F$(I$8B*00*(*&785)$(6'0
?;756'0()*(0*8(&$.'61*(8.(.$68.*6+$9(*+*&6$(*(56*07$+;B*49(@(5.?*&>15'(I8.'6'(*(@
%8&$1&'15'(*0+'+'4,

!"#$%&'()*+

TF$(I;9(1$.$(V(D%B5$9(4*50(?&*01&5+'09(6$&.'0(&*)575)'09(&*1$.*6)'23*0('00*&+5B'0,(TF$
I;(560+5+852F$($8(<$&2'(.'5$&(=8*(1*)'(08'0(I5&+'0(.F$0(@(&*7W615'()*00*0(.$B5.*6+$0X
<'4'&(*.(.*&1')$(0*.?&*(5.?451'&;(8.'(05.?45<51'2F$(56)*B5)',
K)5+$&'0(*(0*80(1&5+V&5$0(1$.*&15'50(561$.?'00>B*509(45B&'&5'0(*(0*8(+&'+$(%54'+*&'4(1$.
'0(450+'0()*(.'50(B*6)5)$09(1')*&6$0()*(184+8&'(=8*(0*78*.('(.*0.'(4D751'(?&*15?5+')'
*(6$15B'()*($8+&$0(1')*&6$09(*6+5)')*0(=8*($&7'65G'.(1$618&0$0(*(?&W.5$0('&%5+&;&5$0
?$&(*:1*4W615',(Y&>+51$0(=8*(576$&'.('0(1$.?4*:5)')*0()*1$&&*6+*0()$(75&$(45678>0+51$
=8*(+&'60<578&$8('(<54$0$<5'()$(0V184$(ZZ9(*6+&*($8+&$0(75&$0()'(<54$0$<5'9(I50+$&5')$&*0
=8*(6F$(0*(561$.$)'.(*.(&*4'+5B5G'&('(5.?$&+A615'()'(I50+D&5'9(4*5+$&*0(*('(1'&W615'()*
56<$&.'2F$(=8*(V(1$6+&'<'1*()*(0*8(5.*)5'+50.$,([$&(N$81'84+(56<*&5.$0(=8*(*00'0(*
$8+&'0(560+A615'0(1$6<$&.'.(8.(?$)*&(=8*(6')'(+*.()*('%0$48+$9(8.(?$)*&(560+;B*4(*

!"#$%&'" !"#
!"#$%&'(&"(%#)*+",-'./(0',.1&"#%23".(.'4#"(*+%(51-"#%-*#%(&'(,'6'(.7$*5'

$%&'()* +* %,,+$%+,-(.* $.* /0,%)(* 1)23)(* .* 4'.5* 2)* .23+23)5* 6)7)* 3)$)* 1)$.,5* (.* &+8
1,).7%2.23.*.*)1,%7.9
:+(*;<0*)2$.*=0*1)$.,*=0*,.(%(3>26%+?@5*+<.,3+*A)'6+'<35*.*('+*.7.2$+*2)(*+B,.*)(
)<=)(*1+,+*3)$)*'7*6+71)*+<3.,2+3%/)9*C'%D0*2E)*.F%(3+*+*'2%&),7%$+$.*1,.3.2$%$+*2)
3+<*.FG,6%3)*$.*&%66%)2%(3+(9*H.6.,3)*'7+*%2&%2%$+$.*$.*.(6,%3),.(*(.*%()<+*.7*('+(*6+(+(
1+,+*B',<+,*.((+(*.F%I>26%+(5*1+,+*$.(1.J+,*()B,.*+*10I%2+*('+*6)23,+,%.$+$.*%26)23%$+9
A)'6+'<3*2E)*)*$%85*7+(*+<I'G7*1)$.,%+*,.7+3+,*4'.5*4'+23)*7+%),*)*1)$.,5*7+%),*+
,.(%(3>26%+5*.*+((%7*.(3.*3.71)*$.%F+,%+*$.*(.,*)*$)*7+,+(7)*1,+I7+3%(3+5*)*3.71)*$+
,.1.3%DE)*.*$)*,.3),2)*+*&K,7'<+(*()1),L&.,+(5*1+,+*(.,*)*3.71)*$.*'7*2)/)*,+$%6+<%(7)5
,.(%(3.23.*M*)2%1,.(.2D+*$)*7.,6+$)*$.*+,I'7.23)(9
N+B.,%+*.23E)*'7+*,.<.%3',+*=%(3K,%6+O*+*%23.23)2+*6)2(.,/+$),+*$+*$G6+$+*$.*!PQR
2E)*6)7)*%,,'1DE)*$.*'7*1.,L)$)*I)/.,2+$)*1.<)*6)2(.2()*&06%<5*)'*2E)*+1.2+(*%(()5
7+(*6)7)*1)23)*$.*1+,3%$+*$.*'7*,.6,'$.(6%7.23)*6,L3%6)5*$.*'7+*.,+*.7*4'.*)*%23.,.((.
,.6+%*()B,.*)(*$%/.,()(*$%((.23%7.23)(9*S.(3+,E)5*(.*+((%7*&),5*'7+(*3+23+(*4'.(3T.(*.7
+B.,3)9*U23,.*.<+(5*(.*+*,.(%(3>26%+*G*7+%(*&),3.*2)*6.23,)5*)*1)23)*.7*4'.*+*$)7%2+DE)
.(3G3%6+*.(30*7+%(*.(3+B.<.6%$+5*'7+*/.8*4'.*3+<*,.+DE)*;2'26+*(.*.26)23,+*.7*1)(%DE)
$.* .F3.,%),%$+$.* .7* ,.<+DE)* +)* 1)$.,?#* V* )* 4'.* ,.$%7%,%+5* 4'.7* (+B.5* .',)1.'(* .
.(3+$'2%$.2(.(9*W'*(.*G*7+%(*&),3.*2+*1.,%&.,%+5*2)(*1+L(.(*.7*4'.*+*%2$X(3,%+*.$%3),%+<*G
1,.60,%+* )'* %26%1%.23.5* 1),* +((%7* )&.,.6.,* 7+%(* B,.6=+(* +)(* .(6,%3),.(* .* 1),4'.* +
$)7%2+DE)*4'.*(.*<=.(*+1,.(.23+*'<3,+1+((+*.7*7'%3)*+(*4'.(3T.(*.(3G3%6+(5*+<%+2$)-(.
+*1)$.,.(*()B,.J+6.23.(5*(.2$)*+*,.(%(3>26%+*<%3.,0,%+*+1.2+(*7+%(*'7+*.23,.*+(*3+23+(
,.J.%DT.(*+)*6.23,)9
YE)*=0*$.*(.,*3E)*%71),3+23.5*J0*4'.*(E)*/0,%+(*+(*,.(%(3>26%+(*1<+'(L/.%(*.*2.6.((0,%+(5
J0*4'.*;2E)*.F%(3.5*6)7*,.(1.%3)*+)*1)$.,5*'7*<'I+,*$+*I,+2$.*S.6'(+*V*+<7+*$+*,./)<3+5
&)6)* $.* 3)$+(* +(* ,.B.<%T.(5* <.%* 1',+* $)* ,./)<'6%)20,%)?Z9* [.* G* 1)((L/.<5* .23,.3+23)5
+$%/%2=+,*+<I'7+*6+,+63.,L(3%6+*6)26.,2.23.*+*3)$+(*.<+(5*4'+<%$+$.*$+*<%3.,+3',+*4'.*(.
4'.%,+*$%&.,.23.5*(.,%+*)*%23'%3)*$.*,.(I'+,$+,-(.*&,.23.*+)*B+,+3.+7.23)*$+*6'<3',+*.*$+
<%2I'+I.7*+<+/+26+$)*1),*.((.(*1,)6.(()(*=)7)I.2.%8+23.(9*:),+$+*$)*$%(()2+23.*.
$)*=.3.,)I>2.)5*<%/,)*,.(%(3.23.*(.,%+*)*4'.*('1.,+((.*('+*6)2$%DE)*$.*)BJ.3)*M*/.2$+*.
(.*6)26.B.((.*3E)-()7.23.*6)7)*)BJ.3)9*\,,.$'3L/.<5*6)23,0,%)*+)(*=0B%3)(*6)7.8%2=)(5

@ *A)'6+'<35*:%6=.<9*;:G3)$)?5*.2*]%(3K,%+*$+*(.F'+<%$+$.5*119*!R^-!!"9
# *\$.79
Z *\$.79

#%8.9&1% !"#
()*'+,-.)/$

$%&'()*++%,-.+/0+(0,+102+,)*')3,$4'501(0+%4+0)*'6/+(74$&'081+0,+09,,+%490(9/0%9,
/$.*9*$9,0 2+0 9+*')'*4'50 %9,0 69%&9,50 %9,0 :9*(7&$9,50 %',0 ,1)+*(+*&92',;0 1(9
9%4$(+*&92'*$9501(90&'$,90+%$<(74$&90+%4*+049%4',0)*'214',04='02$,)'%-.+$,>

!"#"$%&'()*+,(-.(/0$1#(')*2

?@ABCA50DE+'2'*0F>0C'49,0,'6*+0/$4+*941*90G4*92>0?/:*+2'0H*'4'%,I>0J92*$2K0?L9/50MNN">0
GA6*90&'()/+490!!I

OOOOOO>0D+'*-90+,4P4$&90G4*92>0Q+*%9%2'0B$9R9I>0J92*$2K0ST,)9(+*$&950!UVW>

H?XSDYC50J$LE9$/>0Z[)',0+0*'(9%&+\50$%0]1+,4^+,02+0/$4+*941*90+02+0+,4P4$&90G4*92>0?1*'*9
Q'*%'%$0H+*%9*2$%$I>0_='0`91/'K0S1&$4+&50!UVV>

H[Ca?JYC50F9/4+*>0[/0914'*0&'('0)*'21&4'*0G4*92>0a+,b,0?<1$**+I>0J92*$2K0D91*1,50!Ucd>

OOOOOO>0 0 Z[/0 %9**92'*K0 &'%,$2+*9&$'%+,0 ,'6*+0 /90 '6*90 2+0 C$&'/9$0 e+,L'.\50 $%0 _'6*+0 +/
)*'<*9(902+0/90:$/',':-90:141*90T0'4*',0+%,9T',0G4*92>0B'6+*4'0a>0f+*%+%<'I>0g9*9&9,K
J'%4+0?.$/950!UcN>

QAhg?heD50J$&E+/>0S$,4'*$902+0/90,+i19/$2920!0j0e90.'/1%49202+0,96+*>0JPi$&'K0_$</'0kkY5
!UVc>

QA_D[B50S9/>0[/0*+4'*%'02+0/'0*+9/0G4*92>0?/:*+2'0H*'4'%0J1l',I>0J92*$2K0?L9/50MNN!>

S?H[BJ?_50a1*<+%>0Ze90('2+*%$292K01%0)*'T+&4'0$%9&9692'\50$%0[%,9T',0)'/-4$&',0G4*92>
B9(3%0m9*&-90g'49*+/'I>0H9*&+/'%9K0`+%-%,1/950!UVV>

a?J[_AC50Q*+2*$&>0[%,9T',0,'6*+0+/0)',('2+*%$,('0G4*92>0[,4E+*0`P*+R50g*$,4$9%0Q+**+*
T0_'%$90J9RR&'I>0H1+%',0?$*+,K0Y(9<'50!UU!>

X?QX?50Q*9%R>0e90&'%2+%90G4*92>0a>0B>0F$/&'&LI>0J92*$2K0?/$9%R950MNNV>

!"#$%&'" !"#
!"#$%&'(&"(%#)*+",-'./(0',.1&"#%23".(.'4#"(*+%(51-"#%-*#%(&'(,'6'(.7$*5'

$%&$%'(&)*+,-(./(0*123//4(52)*6-(74)63(8)49(:(%/;<)24(=*>)<+2?-(@*)0</4+*A(%;)*B*1'(CDD"-

=E$FGH'(8<4)I-(J<4)K*(6<(/*(+4L</*-(@><+41(%3)<1A(H3I/4(M<3+2<'(!NNO-

=PQJ%RS'(7<*+T&)*+U431-(=*(V41W46<)+36*6(5<BV/30*6*(*(/41(+3X41?'(52)*6-(.+)3Y><(=:+09?-
@*)0</4+*A(8<631*'(!NNO-

#%8.9&1% !"#

You might also like