Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Linzner p256
Linzner p256
net/publication/313299552
CITATIONS READS
14 677
2 authors, including:
Roland Ramusch
European Bank For Reconstruction And Development
44 PUBLICATIONS 455 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Sustainable Ship Recycling by Adopting Integrated Waste Management Approaches in China View project
Developing an e-waste implementation toolkit to support the recycling and the secondary raw material recovery strategy in metropolitan areas in Africa (EWIT) View
project
All content following this page was uploaded by Roland Ramusch on 06 April 2020.
SUMMARY: The present paper illustrates the analysis and evaluation of the current system for
the recycling of biowaste in the city of Vienna, with focus on composting based on a project
carried out by the Institute of Waste Management in 2004 (Linzner et al., 2005). Within this
system, emissions occur from the use of fossil fuels, electricity and from biodegradation
processes. However, the organic matter of the compost also offers the possibility of carbon
sequestration depending on the stability of the organic matter. The application of compost within
the scope of a humus-stimulating cultivation of land leads to a slowdown in the accumulation of
carbon dioxide in the atmosphere (Favoino, 2003). Presentation of the emissions of relevant
greenhouse gases as well as an estimation of a potential carbon sequestration due to the
application of compost is aimed at. The emissions are compared with the potential carbon
sequestration in order to calculate the net emissions and net sequestration, respectively.
1. INTRODUCTION
In terms of waste management, organic waste originating from municipalities, agriculture and
forestry as well as from the food processing industry represents an important component of solid
waste. The quantities, composition and characteristics of organic waste are crucial with regard to
waste treatment methods and climate protection. On the one hand, composted organic waste
represents a resource, while on the other hand greenhouse gases (e.g. CO2, CH4 and N2O) are
emitted during the biological degradation and conversion of organic matter depending on the
technology applied. In terms of a sustainable organic waste management, there is a need for the
quantification of material and energy flows related to the greenhouse effect. Biowaste
management will be increasingly influenced by decisions and the legislation within the EU.
Besides the Council Directive on the landfilling of waste (1999/31/EC) and the Council
Directive on the protection of the environment, in particular of the soil, when sewage sludge is
used in agriculture (86/278/EEC) as well as the proposed Directive on biological treatment of
biodegradable waste, which directly affects biowaste treatment in the EU, the topic of organic
waste is discussed in the Soil Protection Strategy of the European Commission as well as in the
European Climate Change Programme (ECCP).
In the communiqué “Towards a Thematic Strategy for Soil Protection” (2002) it is stated that
among other problems erosion and the decline in organic matter are considered as main threats to
soils in the EU. The “Working Group Sinks Related to Agricultural Soils” within the ECCP
reports that a decrease in organic matter content is an indicator of a lowered quality in most soils.
Utermann et al. (2004) point out that 22.6% of the agricultural areas in Austria show organic
carbon contents less than 2.4%. 45% of the European topsoils (0-30 cm) show an organic carbon
content less than 2% and are running the risk of desertification (Montanarella, 2002). In
Southern Europe 74% of the land contains less than 2% topsoil organic carbon content (Van-
Camp et al., 2004).
Beside these soil related issues, the application of compost as organic fertilizer promotes, over
time, a build up of carbon in the soil which could prove to be a powerful “sink” for the carbon
sequestered in the soil (Barth & Favoino, 2005). Soils play a major role in the global carbon
cycle and the application of compost can therefore mitigate climate change effects by retarding
the CO2 release into the atmosphere.
Another important effect of organic fertilization is the supply of nutrients, which implies the
potential replacement of synthetic fertilizers, and related savings on energy and fuels needed for
their production. Other potential advantages, such as improved workability and water retention,
better control on root pathogens (thereby leading to less use and production of pesticides), lower
erosion and loss of carbon, etc. are difficult to quantify, but may also contribute to a very wide
extent to the reduction of energy inputs to, and carbon losses from agriculture (Barth & Favoino,
2005).
INPUT OUTPUT
Processing
Electric energy Climate relevant
Composting emissions
Fuels
Residues
Compost (product)
Same benefit
(nutrient content)
Artificial fertiliser
(Equivalent product)
Primary production
Figure 1. System elements and system boundaries considered within the recycling of biowaste in
Vienna.
Table 1 presents an overview of the material and energy flows of the Viennese system of
biowaste management shown above in Figure 1. Besides the separate collection of biowaste,
citizens may also deliver their biowaste directly to collection centers. The collected biowaste is
then transported to the processing facility. Due to the fact that it was not possible to allocate any
fuel consumption to these transportation processes, a software tool was used. Based on the
number of transports, the distance and emission factors it was possible to calculate emissions
from this transportation process. The same procedure was carried out for the transport of
compost from the compost plant back to the collection centers. These emissions are included in
the overall balance.
One of the main questions is whether the CO2 formed during aerobic degradation should be
taken into account or not. Indeed, the latter represents a rather controversial issue. From the
viewpoint of the natural carbon cycle, biogenic carbon has to be regarded as climate-neutral, as
the equivalent amount of CO2 is bound during the plant growth by assimilation (Schneider et al.,
2003 and Denison, 1999). On the other hand, the production of minor amounts of methane (CH4)
and nitrous oxide (N2O) during the composting process cannot be avoided completely.
From the viewpoint of the balancing of the CO2-equivalents (see Figure 4) both trace gases
form a significant fraction of the climate-relevant emissions. In addition, the mass of diesel fuel
used during collection of biowaste, mechanical treatment and for the turning of the piles are also
of importance. The “Lobau” composting plant is characterized by passively aerated open piles
and frequent turning, with the advantage of a relatively low specific energy (or diesel fuel)
demand.
of well-stabilized compost will be mineralized in the first two or three years. It was more
difficult to assess the long-term carbon degradation or sequestration (decades, centuries,
millennia). Although at least 20 long-term test plots for organic fertilizer exist worldwide
(Powlson et al., 1998), the results of the corresponding studies have been published in fragments
only. Regarding agricultural test plots, some authors have provided coarse estimations of the
fraction of compost-derived carbon which is degraded (see Figure 2). These estimations have to
be considered with caution, because the TOC values in compost-amended soil do not reflect the
compost-derived carbon only, but the sum of the different carbon pools in the soil, which
interact in a complex network of soil processes (depending on climate, tillage, clay content of the
soil etc.).
4.3 Modeling
The aim of modeling was a rather generalized prediction of carbon sequestration over a time
span of 50 years. This time span was chosen due to the fact that in many European soils the
carbon content has been on a decrease over the last decades, because synthetic fertilizers are
preferred by the farmers.
It is not advisable to use pronounced physical models for this purpose, e.g. taking into account
also factors such as soil temperature, humidity, physical protection (“encapsulation”) of
degradable carbon pools etc., since no extreme climatic conditions exist in Vienna, and a rather
simple, coarse estimation of the medium-term (=decades) carbon sequestration was the main
goal. Nevertheless, at least three carbon pools have to be discerned, according to the general
knowledge of the behavior of biogenic carbon in soils (see, for example, Shaffer & Hansen,
2001), and reliable models have to be calibrated with field data. Figure 3 gives a general
description of the model we used (3-pool-model).
Initially, the halfing time of the active carbon pool was not established, but a wide range of
halfing times (10-100 years) was assumed, reflecting different methods of soil treatment and
fertilizing strategies. In a second step, we calibrated the model with field data from Garcia-Gil et
al, 2000. After calibration, the turnover time for the active pool “SOM1” was set to 19 years.
Sequestration of compost carbon - field plots
100%
HARTL & ERHART, 2002,
Biowaste compost
90%
70%
AICHBERGER & WIMMER,
1999, Biowaste compost
60%
DIEZ & KRAUSS, 1997,
50% MSW compost
Figure 2. Results of some long-term studies. Data from: (Diez & Kraus, 1997, Aichberger &
Wimmer, 1999, Reider et al, 2000, Hartl & Erhart, 2002, Hartmann, 2002 , Körschens,
2003).
Finally we also compared our prediction of the carbon sequestration with an estimation made on
the basis of the “Bad Lauchstädt” long-term test plots (Körschens, 2003).
In total, our estimations for the compost-derived organic carbon remaining after 50 years
were:
A) 40% (derived from the 3-pool model, t½SOM1=19 years) and
B) 25% (derived from the data reported by Körschens, 2003).
With a TOC content of the compost of 24.6% DM and a mean water content of 41%, the
compost contains 145 kg organic C per tonne. Multiplied with the predicted sequestration rates
(40% and 25%) and with a stoichiometric factor of 44/12, the sequestered amount of CO2 is 213
kg/t CO2-equivalents or 133 kg/t CO2-equivalents, respectively.
60%
Fast degrading
Crop organic substance
residues t1/2= 2y
40
%
CO2
Mature
%
compost
Passive pool
“SOM 2”
t1/2=3000y
The climate relevant emissions within the considered system boundaries are outlined in Table 2.
As it is shown in Table 2, in the year 2003 approx. 172 kg CO2-equivalents per tonne mature
compost were emitted. Without considering the upstream process emissions from the crude oil
production, the emissions decrease to approx. 165 kg CO2-equivalents.
The major source of the emissions is the biodegradation process (CH4 and N2O) with approx.
58% of the overall emissions. The share of the separate collection of biowaste is approx. 18% of
the overall emissions and the total share of the emissions resulting from the processing facility
and the composting plants is approx. 17% of the total emissions. Beside the separate collection,
about 7% of the overall emissions result from other transportation processes.
Finally, the climate relevant emissions were compared with the potential carbon sequestration
(-213 and -133 kg CO2-equivalents/t compost, respectively) and with the negative (avoided)
emissions due to the substitution of synthetic fertilizer (-46 kg CO2-equivalents/t compost). The
emissions presented in Table 2 are grouped and outlined in Figure 4.
The left part of Figure 4 shows the results without taking into account upstream processes.
Assuming a 25% carbon sequestration, the emissions within the biowaste management system of
Vienna exceed the sequestration, so that the net balance show emissions of +32 kg CO2-
equivalents/t compost. A C-sequestration of 40% leads to a net sequestration of -48 kg CO2-
equivalents/t compost.
Table 2 - Climate relevant emissions of the Viennese biowaste management system (including
upstream process emissions from the crude oil production).
Emissions
System element [%]
[kg CO2-equiv./t compost]
Separate collection of biowaste 31.7 18.4
Delivery of biowaste: Collection centers to processing
0.9 0.5
facility
Transportation processes 6.6 3.8
Processing facility – Consumption of electricity 2.7 1.6
Processing facility – Consumption of diesel fuel 8.2 4.8
Composting plant “Lobau” – Consumption of diesel fuel 13.3 7.8
Composting plant “Schafflerhof” - Consumption of
4.6 2.7
diesel fuel
Delivery of compost: Composting plants to direct
3.4 2.0
application within Viennese agriculture
Delivery of compost: Composting plants to collection
1.2 0.7
centers
Composting process: Emissions due to biodegradation
99.2 57.7
processes
Total climate relevant emissions 171.9 100.0
In the right part of Figure 4 the upstream processes are included. The upstream process of the
crude oil production increases the emissions from +165 to +172 kg CO2-equivalents/t compost.
It is assumed, that the compost application can substitute the production of synthetic fertilizer
Overall balance of emissions, C-sequestration and avoided emissions
[kg CO2-eqiv. per t compost WS]
165 165 172 172
150
100
32
50
0
-7
-50
-133 -48 -133
<--- ---> <--- --->
-100 -213 With upstream -213
Without upstream -87
processes and
-150 processes and -46 negative emissions
negative emissions
-200 from substitution of
from the substitution
synthetic fertilizer
of synthetic fertilizer -46
-250
-300
25% carbon 40% carbon 25% carbon 40% carbon
sequestr. sequestr. sequestr. sequestr.
Biowaste collection Transport of compost Composting plant: Electricity Composting plant: Diesel
(+29,3 / UP:+32,5) raw material & compost (+2,7) fuel (+23,6 / UP:+26,2)
(+10,1 / UP:+11,2)
Composting plant: N2O, CH4 C sequestration in soil Substitution of UP denotes that upstream
(+99,2) (-133 / -213) synthetic fertilizer (0 / -46) processes are taken
into account
Figure 4. Overall balance of climate relevant emissions, C-sequestration and avoided emissions
(with and without upstream processes) for a 25% and 40% carbon sequestration.
and therefore saves energy and fuel. This is reflected in considering negative emissions of -46 kg
CO2-equivalents/t compost in the net balance. It can be seen, that presuming a 25% sequestration
the emissions are almost equalizing the sequestration and the avoided emissions, respectively
(net sequestration -7 kg CO2-equivalents/t compost). A net sequestration of -87 kg CO2-
equivalents/t compost can be achieved under taking into account a 40% C-sequestration.
6. CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES