SAPL - KAFD-A0-GEN-SAP-DES-OCS-00020 - SAPL - WSP - Response

Programme: King Abdullah Financial District (KAFD)
Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)
PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

OCS NUMBER KAFD-A0-GEN-SAP-DES-OCS-00020 Rev. R00 DATE 28-May-23
WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
ORIGINATOR SAPL TRANSMITTAL No. / DATE
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23
DOCUMENT No. Multiple Drawings Rev. R00 DISCIPLINE DES
DOCUMENT TITLE TO 022 Groundwater Recycling and RO Plant Concept Design Drawings, Report and Specifications DOCUMENT TYPE DWG / RPT / SPE
Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

Comments / Replies Legends & Status Open / Closed
1 = Action Required; 2 = Note / Advisory / Recommendation i = Incorporated; ii = Not incorporated for reason stated in reply
Comment Reply Reply Status by
No. Initial Page / Section / Sheet Reviewer Comment Design Consultant Reply
Code Code Reviewer
ALL DATA CABLES CAT6 A must be including with DATA point price in B.O.Q , not per M/length
BILL NO. 6.3 - TREATMENT

1 H.M PLANT & PUMPING STATION 1 This comment was discussed in a workshop between SAPL & WSP and agreed to be closed.
ICA System
• KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-SPE- 3.9.4 Telecommunications

00003 Missing technical information for ICT systems as follows:
KAFDKING ABDULLAH 1-Data Center Firewall
Infomation is provided in specification under 'Section 27 20 00 Data Communications' & 'Section 27 11 16
FINANCIAL DISTRICT 2-server farm
Cabinets'
2 H.M FEASIBILITY STUDY OF 1 3-operating system, software application, license and
ICT schematic will be updated to include Firewall and Router as discussed during the meeting held on 5-June-
RECYCLING GROUND WATER IN all related accessories.
23.
KAFD 4-Data Rack /Cabinet
DEVELOPMENTPERFORMANCE
SPECIFICATIONS
* TO 22- FIRE ALARM LAYOUT Drawings to be stamped by Approved Agnese of Fire life safety (Firefighting, fire alarm and life safety) – FLS
AND SCHEMATIC DIGRAM
GROUND FLOOR
3 H.M KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX- 1 This work will be completed under the Detailed Design phase.
WSP-UTI-DWG-00114
SCADA 1.The dedicated space for PLC room is very small and will not be enough to accommodate the cabinet and the workstation. 1. PLC panel will be placed in the MCC room. The proposed control room space will be for SCADA servers and
2.RTU single line diagram, power and instrumentation cable schedules and I/O lists were not provided in the design package. workstation only. the minimum clearance between PLC panels and MCC/VFD has been considered.
3.P&ID diagram and operation philosophy was not included in the layout. 2. Noted, The drawing No.KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-UTI-DWG-00079 was updated.
4.Provide separate layout for the motorized penstock with narrative the basic operation control philosophy.SAPL Response: 3. P&ID diagram has been provided. The detailed operation philosophy shall be provided by D&B contractor as
5.P&ID layout shall include the following: mentioned in the performance specification clause 3.6. Kindly refer to the P&ID diagram drawings number
•The connection between the filed devices and RTUs KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00047 & KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-
•The connection between the RTU and the PLC/local SCADA system. DWG-00048 & KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00049
6.The proposed locations for the ultrasonic level transmitter will not be effective in terms of detecting the water level. 4. P&ID diagram has been provided. The detailed operation philosophy shall be provided by D&B contractor as
7.ICT system schematic diagram is missing a lot of basic information, like for example: I/O racks, PLC, switches, redundancy switches, CPU, workstation, HMI and , mentioned in the performance specification clause 3.6. Kindly refer to the P&ID diagram drawings number
ethernet switches., Etc. KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00047 & KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-
8.The layout for fiber optic cable routing and connection from RTU to SCADA system was not provided. DWG-00048 & KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00049
9.Provide in tabulated form along with P&ID layout the following: 5. the required detailed P&ID layout shall be provided by D&B contractor.
• the pipe pressure rating, 6. The RADAR level transmitter location shall be provided as guide to the contractor. The RADAR level
•the flow rate, transmitter have been moved by 1.50m away from the tank wall and to be in compliance with OEM
4 AS 1
•max flow & manufacturer recommendation, kindly refer to drawings number KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-
•operating pressure. MEC-DWG-00054 & KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00055
10.The operation control philosophy for the entire plant shall be submitted.
7.The SCADA architecture drawing has been provided which were included all required details see drawing No.
11.Surge vessel size shall be determined by specialized vendor based on the pumps selection profile
(KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-UTI-DWG-00079 )
12.Provide the chlorination system P&ID diagram layout and indicate the location of the tank in the plant general layout.
13.Elaborate the operation philosophy of the dosing system and explain the dosing operation control system, is it manually or automatically?
8.D&B contractor is in charge of the layout for fiber optic cable routing and connection from parcels RTU to
14.PLC cabinet, UPS panel and the workstation shall be in a dedicated control room.
SCADA system.
9. the required information is part of D&B contractor.
10. The entire operation and control philosophy is part of D&B contractor.
11. Noted, Surge vessel size shall be determined by specialized vendor based on the pumps selection profile
under D&B contractor SOW.
12. P&ID was included in the submission. Kindly refer to the P&ID diagram drawings number KAFD-A0-GEN-
COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00047 & KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00048 &
Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 1 of 12


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
1- The tramsformer size shall be as per the standard size as per SEC.
2- The distance between the transformer and RMU is not acheive the minimum required clearance distance between the equipment.
3- VFD cubicle shall be located inside a complete one set MCC not indeviudaly. and the distance between MCC and MDB shall be as per NEC standard. 1. SEC Standards are not applicable here; SEC responsibility ends at the MRMU unit.
4- provide section details to verify the acheivement of the minimum required clearance and dimensions between the equipment. 2. The transformer clearance is achieved to ensure safe and trouble-free operation.; Please refer to SDCS--Part
5- MDBs shall be not located with transformer in the same location, it should be located in LV/MCC room with conisdering the required minimum clearance between the 09, and NEC CH5.
equipment as per NEC. 3. Keeping the VFD in individual panels is advisable as it is large, produces more heat, and thus needs to be
6- the dedicated space for MCC room seems less than the required diemsion.SAPL Response June,22 : kept outside.
7- the dedicated space for UPS equipment with battery rack is very small and can't accomdate it. 4. Our scope has been limited to the concept stage; thus, details can be obtained through the following stages.
KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-
8- provide generator sizing calculation with support document / catalgue from the manufacturer for the recommended room diemsion. 5. We do not have enough space inside the LV room to fit in the MDB, and no code restrictions require us to
WSP-UTI-DWG-00065 , KAFD-A0-
9- the genersator shall be outdoor type with sound proof enclosure in order to save the indoor area to acheive the minimum required clearance distance between the keep the LV dry transformer in a separate room.
GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-UTI-
5 AS 1 equipment. 6. Please provide your references for that.
DWG-00068 & KAFD-A0-GEN-
10- Provide electrical room arrangemnet layout with considering the minimum required clearance, dediacted equipment space, the door opening and diemension as per 7. Same point 6 reply.
COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-UTI-
NEC code. SAPL 8. contractor scope.
DWG-00069
9. Please provide the location of the allowable space for that.
10. already considered as per NEC.
General - At the concept stage. indicative equipment size are provided based on the worst case to confirm the
availability of spaces. However, the detail stage designer or contractor in the design and build stage shall
provide the actual sizes and builder/manufacturer drawings to achieve the required clearances.
1- the approach of design the MCC panel is not practical solution and not applicable, WSP segerate the main MCC to more than one MCC for easy installation and
arrangement inside electrical room and the operation philosophy. 1- The design is optimized for the available space. However, segregation will be taken into consideration for the
2- the total connected load, demand factor, demand load are missed from the drawing. next submission.
3- incorporate the disconnect switch and push button in the drawing for each motor. 2. TCL is shown on the layout; please refer to SLD.
4- incorporate the circuit breaker amper frame and ampere trip 3. The comment is related to the detailed design stage.
KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX- 5- the medium voltage cable size between the RMU and transformer shall be as per the relevant SEC standard (50-70mm2). 4. Comment needs to be clarified; AT&AF is shown on the layout.
WSP-UTI-DWG-00070 , KAFD-A0- 6- Incorporate the LV cable size. 5. SEC regulations are not applicable after MRMU. Selected cable based on calculations and factor.
6 AS 1
GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-UTI- 7- The legend shall be incorporated in each drawing seperately for easy reviewing and verification. 6. Noted; we will consider this for the next submission.
DWG-00072 7.Already there.
General - At the concept stage. indicative equipment size are provided based on the worst case to confirm the
availability of spaces. However, the detail stage designer or contractor in the design and build stage shall
provide the actual sizes and builder/manufacturer drawings to achieve the required clearances.
1- incorporate the size of the down conductor, the horizontal conductor shall be away one meter from the building,
1- Please refer to specification section 264100 part 2.3 D, Any additional information will be part of detailed
KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX- 2- the distance between the vertical down conductor shall be as the results of the risk assessment report
7 AS 1 design.
WSP-UTI-DWG-00116
2- It will be considered in the detailed design stage.
1- Doublication of earthing pit is not recommended, only doublicate the number of he earthing conductor from the busbar to the grround rod/pit.
2- the drawing containmnet shall be dedicated only for earthing ssytem.
1- Two earthing pits has been considered for each earth bar for MV/LV/ELV systems and generator set.
3- the horizontal conductor around the building is missed from the drawing.
2- The containment is part of the power and earthing systems, no containment has been considered for each
4- provide the arthing and lightning protection riser diagram.
system separately.
5- the horizontal conductor around the building shall be common for both earthing and lightning protection systems with incorporating the distance between the earthing pit.
3- It's covered in the specification section 260526 part 3.5 D
KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX- 6- Incorporate the size of the main earthing conductor and the equipment bonding conductor.
8 AS 1 4- Earthing and lightning protection riser diagram is part of detailed design stage.
WSP-UTI-DWG-00115 7- earth pits shall be spaced at minimum 6m interval.
5- Agreed.
6- Please refer to specification section 260526 part 2.9/2.10 F
7- Agreed, Earting system shall be based on BS7430 which has been mentioned in the specification. Any
additional information will be part of detailed design.
KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX- The lighting fixture's type shall be as per the dialux calculation considering the building height and the recommended LUX level as per the relevant standards.
9 AS 1 Dialux calculation and LUX level is part of detailed design stage.
WSP-UTI-DWG-00111
SECTION 260501 – TESTING OF Please add the testing for the earthing.
10 AS 1 Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.
LV ELECTRICAL SYSTEMS
SECTION 260519 - LV ELEC Please add the following statement:
CONDUCTORS & CABLES
11 AS 1 The Contractor shall ensure that no more than one phase will occur at switch lighting or power outlets where these outlets are less than 2.5m apart unless guarded by a wall Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.
partition or other barrier. If this is impracticable the Contractor shall obtain the advice of
the KAFD REPRESENTATIVE before proceeding.
SECTION 260519 - LV ELEC Please add the following statement:
12 AS CONDUCTORS & CABLES 1 Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.
The Conduits fill shall not be more than 60% full.
Please add the following references:
Section 260526 - Grounding and A. IEEE 81-2012 - IEEE Guide for Measuring Earth Resistivity, Ground Impedance, and
Bonding for Electrical Systems Earth Surface Potentials of a Grounding System
B. NFPA/NEC 70 (National Electrical Code)
C. NFPA 99 - Health Care Facilities.


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
Please add the following references:
The resistance of any point in the earth continuity system to the main earth mass shall
not exceed 2 ohms.
Section 260526 - Grounding and
14 AS 1 1. Measure grounding resistance at each electrode location Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.
Bonding for Electrical Systems
2. Measure overall grounding resistance of the complete system.
3. Install additional earth electrodes if these figures are not met.
Please add the following:
Locations of labels:
1. Each electrical distribution and control equipment compartment - Title Label.
2. Each door mounted component - Function Label.
Section 260553 - Identification for 3. Every internal component - Identification Label.
15 AS 1 4. Each Fuse - Identification Label (Fuse type, rating). Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.
Electrical Systems
5. Communication cabinets - Title Label.
6. Compartments with doors and covers not electrically interlocked to an isolator,
external label - “DANGER, LIVE TERMINALS” with flash and voltage in red letters
on white background in Arabic and English.
7. Each group of terminal blocks - Function description Label.
APPLICATION
Section 260553 - Identification for A. Install nameplate and label parallel to equipment lines.
Electrical Systems B. Secure nameplate to equipment front as specified.
C. Secure nameplate to inside surface of door on panel board that is recessed in finished locations.
D. Identify underground conduits using underground warning tape. Install one tape per trench at 150mm below finished grade.
Submit dimensional drawings of all the switchgears, switchboards and motor control centers, including sections and elevations, showing the following:
a. Arrangement of all components, instruments, indication and dimensions of all busbars.
b. Positions and method of fixing cables and boxes.
c. Location of Terminal blocks.
d. Single line diagram of the circuits showing the rating of all components, the type and size of the incoming and outgoing feeders.
Section 262400 - Switchboards, e. Schematic and elementary wiring diagrams, for each control unit, showing numbered terminal points, numbered wires and numbered interconnections to other
Panel Boards and Switchgear equipment’s and remote devices.
f. Connection wiring diagrams, for each control unit, showing numbered terminal points, numbered wires and numbered interconnections to other equipment’s and remote
devices.
g. Complete catalog information for all components.
h. A complete list of parts, with prices, that would be necessary to maintain and/or
modify the equipment.
i. Other relevant data.
Overcurrent Protective Device

The Supplier of the overcurrent protective devices shall prepare a coordination study to verify the above stated performance requirements. The study shall be documented
by the Supplier and the documents shall include but not be limited to the following:
a-A composite drawing or drawings (on full size, reproducible, log-log paper) showing the entire new electrical system (including the first upstream protective device of the
existing system) showing all protective device curves (including motor overloads), short circuit duties, motor starting curves and damage curves for motors, equipment and
Section 262400 - Switchboards, conductors. This drawing or drawings shall show that all protective devices are properly coordinated to perform as stated above.
Panel Boards and Switchgear b-Manufacturer’s overcurrent operating curves (on full size, reproducible, log-log paper) for each overcurrent device. In the case of fuses, both minimum melt and maximum
clearing time curves shall be included.
c-Reproducible copies of all projects single line diagrams so marked to show short circuit duties at all switchboards and motor control centers, and which operating curve
applies to each overcurrent device on the diagram (the operating curves shall also be correspondingly marked);
d-A tabulation of the short circuit duties at all switchboards and motor control centers, sizes and ratings of all overcurrent protective devices and the required settings of all
of the adjustable overcurrent protective devices so that the performance requirements are met. Protective devices which have earth fault protection features are specifically
required to meet this performance requirement.
e-This documented coordination study shall be submitted for review before the overcurrent devices are supplied for the project


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
The Below highlighted does not reflect the Existing Riyadh Weather Conditions:
KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-RPT-
00015
19 MS 1 Noted and corrected as per ASHREA general guidelines 50% +/- 5%. Refer to the updated report section 2.3.
2.3 Local Conditions.
Page No 9 & 10
The Below highlighted does not reflect the Existing Riyadh Weather Conditions:
00015 Section has been omitted in concept report and updatd in the performance specifications. Please refer to the
20 MS 1
3.2.2.1 Air Conditioning works Performance spefication Section 3.9.2 Ventilation/HVAC sections for the information on air conditioning works.
Page No 49
21 MS 00015 1 The site visit pictures are old shall be replaced with the new ones. Updated site visit reports are included in Revision 1 of the Concept Design Report.
Appendix D - Site Visit Photographs


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
The below highlighted example is not relevant with regards to the proposed RO Plant Design Drawings :
KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-SPE-
00001
/ Division 21 Fire Suppression /
These are general specification provided to the Contractor for guidance, the Contractor will need to refer to the
Section 210500
22 MS 1 specification of the relevant system as required, based on the confirmed FLS strategy during the detailed design
Part 2 products
stage.
C.System Description
Page 761 to 767 of 2191

00001
/ Division 21 Fire Suppression / Programme: King Abdullah Financial District (KAFD)
These are general specification provided to the Contractor for guidance, the Contractor will need to refer to the
Section 210500
22 MS 1 specification of the relevant system as required, based on the confirmed FLS strategy during the detailed design
Part 2 products Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS) stage.
C.System Description
Page 761 to 767 of 2191
WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
The below highlighted sections are not relevant with regards to the proposed RO Plant Design Drawings :
KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-SPE- These are general specification provided to the Contractor for guidance, the Contractor will need to refer to the
23 MS 00001 1 specification of the relevant system as required, based on the confirmed FLS strategy during the detailed design
/ Division 21 Fire Suppression / stage.


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
The below highlighted sections are not relevant with regards to the proposed RO Plant Design Drawings :
00001
/ Division 22 Plumbing /
24 MS
1 Sections are required for piping from pump to toilet fixtures & bib taps proposed within RO plant


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
1. The below highlighted sections are not relevant with regards to the proposed RO Plant Design Drawings :
12.2: Noted
12.3 Section 220553 is relevant: as it address the Identification tag/markings for HVAC Piping/equipments e.g.
for referigernat Piping and ducts. the tag plate for the HVAC equipments ( indoor, outdoor) containing
information which shall be aligned with the Asset register during Handover documentation of the project
12.11 Section 238129 is relevant : HVAC system scheme is Direct expansion (refrigernat based). and the
specification is relevant if the proposal for VRF is considered at DD/tender stage.
25 MS 00001
2. PACU: Specification included in Rev 01 pacakge.
/ Division 23 HVAC /
2.1 Duct identification tag: already covered in the submitted speficcations DIV 23, Section 230553
IDENTIFICATION FOR HVAC section 2.2
Note: WSP specifications are comprehensive and covers all details. Contractor to read the full specification and
submit the compliance of relevant sections and applicable to materials for Supervision consultant for final
review and approval.
2. PACU & Duct Identification Specs are missing.
Provide layout and details for construction joints ( HZ & VL )

Please refer to Note #15 of drawing no. KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-STL-DWG-00068 for the
26 MD Structural package 1 horizontal construction joints. Also on the same drawing, a typical horizontal construction detail has been
included as per reveiwer comment.
The concept structural design of the raw and treated water underground tanks is not viable due to the following concerns:
The Design calculation for the RO plant in included in the revised submission for the element sizing and satbility
27 MD Structural package 1 -The basic calculations of the concrete sizing and reinforcements are not included in the design package.
checks. Midas model is provided for information only in the revised submission.
-Concept FEM modelling was not submitted along with the design package.
Add Note that allow to DB contractor to propose new structrual system instead of prestressed Box grider and huge conrete columns as it may be steel structure .
28 MD Structural package 1 Please refer to Note #19 of drawing no. KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-STL-DWG-00075.
Please refer to Note #14 of drawing no. KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-STL-DWG-00066. Also

29 MD Structural package 2 Add Cross bracing system to the shoring system as it shall be retained during excavation and construction of the tank proposed shoring layout has been included in construction sequence drawing KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-
XXXXX-WSP-STL-DWG-00066 for information.
30 PD General 1 There is no drawing list included in the drawing package submission. Refer to Dwg No KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-LST-00001 for list of drawings
The drawing package should include Architectural drawings that includes plans, elevation, sections and schedules that suit the required information.
31 PD Architectural 1 This work is not within WSP's scope and shall be developed in the next stage by D&B contractor.


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
Include the specifications for architectural materials for finishings, openings (doors&windows), steel ladder, access covers, etc…
32 PD Specifications 1 That has been included in the CSI specifications.
33 PD General 1 The drawings do not include information on building heights. WSP checked the drawings and confirmed building heights are provided.
The designs must include at least the basic minimum of information about the gate and the boundary wall/fence. Sections and specification to be provided.
34 PD Boundary 1 This work shall be completed in the next stage by the D&B Contractor.
In order to discern the design intent, the finishes in each room should be defined in principle. Finishes schedule shall be provided.
35 PD Finishes 1 This work shall be completed in the next stage by the D&B Contractor.
To identify the design objective, the finishes in each room should be defined in concept.
36 PD Electrical room / General 1 Consider the requirement for a landing and handrail on the ramp for all structures. Notes are added to KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-LST-00050.
37 PD Landscape Landscape and hardscape must be specified in concept design. No available areas for hardscape and landscape. Just pavement is needed.
WSP didn’t submit a list of darwings for each package

38 MI Drawings 1 Drawings numbers are missed up, need to sepaarte Refer to Dwg No KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-LST-00001 for list of drawings
Hydraulic models Hydraulic models

- SewerGEMS model does not match the report in terms of flow. - SewerGEMS model flows has been updated (Rfer to Appendix E
- Pipes are fully submerged in teh SewerGEMS model - yes as per the simulation scenarioes pipes were considered to be submerged during over flow casses, while
- Ground elevations does not match the as built running partially during low flow considtions (refer to appendix E for updated Model)
- WaterGEMS model does not match the folow form SewerGEMS and the report - Ground elevations is matching with the grating levels of the existing storm gullies
- Pumps data does not match the report - WaterGEMS model has been updated to have matched flows with the Sewer Gems and data (refer to
- parcels 2.09 and 2.15 were not considered in the hydraulic model appendix F)
39 MI Hydraulic models 1 - some flows does not match between sewerGEMS and WaterGEMS - Pumps data has been updated to match with the report data
- parcels 2.09 and 2.15 has been considered as per data receievd from SAPL via email dated 2nd June 2023.
WSP to create the drawings in packages per discipline.

40 MI Drawings 1 There is no drawing list submitted The layout drawing has been updated in the revised report
As per the 2.6.4: the volume of the raw water tank was detemrined as 8250 (2 chambers). The supporting calcultions were not provides.
41 MI Report 1 Refer to Report for detailed calculation of the RAW water tank volume.


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
Figures are low resolution and legends are not readable or matching the drawings colors
42 MI Report 1 The layout drawing has been updated in the revised report
20230622 Still have low resolution figures
Ro plant capacity is 30,000 m3/day while the raw water volume (0.55 of the daily flow) is 8250 m3/day
43 MI Report 1 It is a typo error, same has been updated in the revised report
3.2..5 why 1 pump with 15000 m3/day not 3 pump
One pump can deliver the required flow especially the pumping system operates based on level control and not
incoming flow rates in the wet well and hence having one duty pump will reduce the wet well floor area since the
44 MI Report 1
allocated plot area is tight. In addition we have added a provisional future pump to cater for the future flow
rates.
WSP attached the site visits conducted as in 2022. The site vosit reports took place as part of this exercise should be attached to the report
45 MI Report 1 Updated site visit reports are included in Revision 1 of the Concept Design Report.
There is no architectural package submitted for the RO plant

The architectural requirements, including specifications, necessary to move to the Detailed Design phase are
46 MI Darwings 1
provided in the package.
All NWC sould be replace with SIO, NWC is not in charge of the TSE system in Riyadh any more
47 MI Report 1 Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.
The elevation of the incoming gravity line invert level is on negative which is not matching the site conditions
48 MI Report table 3-1 1 Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
Legend is not reADABLE
comments in the attached PDF

50 MI Report 1 Comments noted and addressed in Revision 1.
th ereport is not consistent
The RO capacity should be 55% of the 30000 which is 16500, this contradicts 2-11 & 2-12 & 213 RO units capacity
52 MI Report 1 This is a typo error, same has been addressed and updated in revised report


WSP-WTRAN-000072 / 30-Apr-23
WSP-WTRAN-000071 / 20-Apr-23

Code Code Reviewer
The intermediate pump station should be underground. Superstructure is not allowd.
We don't recommend to have MCC room below ground. However as per the Clients' instructions the design was
53 MI Report, darwings, and specs 1
amended accordingly.
It was stated that based on the waterquality, the treated portion will be 55%. WSP need to elaborate more on how this conclusion was reached and to add different
scenarios (groundwater, and TSE from SIO) The percentage of blending and by pass has been approximately calculated based on the water quality results
54 MI Report point 2.6.4 1 from various parcels, however in case of watr from extrenal sources other than parcels have to be tested, and
accordingly percentage of blending can be adjusted by contractor
WSP didn’t check the effect of water hummer for all transmission lines from parcels to the RO plant and from the intermediate pump station to the RO plant The Trnsimission Line water hammer study will be part of the Deatailed design stage done by the contractor as
55 MI Rport and Drawings 1
per the specifications submitted within the project
Please note future pumps is not part of the contractor scope of work as we don't want the contractor to procure
The pumping station in the leaf area shall all be underground with minimum impact on the public realm's final look. Final location to be coordinated with public realm the pumps then install them after long period of time. Kindly refer to the design report where it is stated the
enhancement current and future pumping arrangement. Also the pump list is provided in drawing number (KAFD-A0-GEN-
COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-UTI-DWG-00139)
56 H.E Rport and Drawings WSP to add a provision of design and build for aluminum cladding of the building to match the surrounding theme 3- The scope of this contract does not include procurment of any future pump since the future flows is unknown
when to occur as it is not recomended to store the future pump for long time.
WSP to provide some information regarding the future to help with the pre-tender estimate 4- Pumps scheduale were provided, refer to drawings KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-
00042 & KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-MEC-DWG-00065
WSP to make sure that a complete list of equipment is provided.
A - Approved B - Approved with Comments C - Objection

Review Status Code: C
Design Consultant (DC) Project Management-Construction Management (PMCM) Development and Management Company Originator
Reviewer Name(s) / COMMENTS / STATUS COMMENTS / STATUS COMMENTS / STATUS
Position REPLY APPROVED BY
Initials RECOMMENDED BY SC RECOMMENDED BY PMCM ADVISED BY KAFD-DMC
Ali Sorour (AS) Lead Electrical Name: Peter Gayed Name: Paris Harmandas Name: Name:
Mohamed Ibrahim (MI) Lead Wet Utilities Position: Senior Project Manager Position: Position: Position:
Mohamed Dora (MD) Lead Structual Signature: Signature: Signature:
Amohamed Shoeb (MS) Lead Mechanical Signature:

Date: Date:
Husam Malo Elain (HM) Lead ELV Date: Date:

Philip Doctor
(PD)
Rani Elkhatib Sr. Engineering Manager Date: 7/11/2023 Date: 28-May-23 Date: Date:

SAPL - KAFD-A0-GEN-SAP-DES-OCS-00020 - SAPL - WSP - Response

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

You might also like

SAPL - KAFD-A0-GEN-SAP-DES-OCS-00020 - SAPL - WSP - Response

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

SAPL - KAFD-A0-GEN-SAP-DES-OCS-00020 - SAPL - WSP - Response

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Programme: King Abdullah Financial District (KAFD)

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

BILL NO. 6.3 - TREATMENT

• KAFD-A0-GEN-WSP-DES-SPE- 3.9.4 Telecommunications

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 1 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 2 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

Please add the following:

Please add the following:

Overcurrent Protective Device

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 3 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 4 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 5 of 12

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 6 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 7 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

2. PACU & Duct Identification Specs are missing.

Provide layout and details for construction joints ( HZ & VL )

Please refer to Note #14 of drawing no. KAFD-A0-GEN-COMN-NSF-XXXXX-WSP-STL-DWG-00066. Also

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 8 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

32 PD Specifications 1 That has been included in the CSI specifications.

WSP didn’t submit a list of darwings for each package

Hydraulic models Hydraulic models

WSP to create the drawings in packages per discipline.

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 9 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend:

20230622 Still have low resolution figures

3.2..5 why 1 pump with 15000 m3/day not 3 pump

There is no architectural package submitted for the RO plant

48 MI Report table 3-1 1 Noted & addressed in Revision 1 submission.

Form No. KAFD-AL-GEN-SAP-QMS-FRM-00071 R00 02 Feb 2022 Page 10 of 12

Observation & Comments Sheet (OCS)

PROJECT / PARCEL Sitewide PROGRAMME No.

Comment Code Legend (for individual comments): Reply Code Legend: