Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Article
Article
in Critical Care
PhD, MA,
RN
Department Editors
S usan is a nurse in the medical intensive care unit. For the past 3 days, she
has cared for Ms B, a 59-year-old woman admitted with pelvic pain. Ms B
was transferred to the medical intensive care unit because of hemodynamic
instability after vaginal blood loss. She has undergone diagnostic tests and has
a new diagnosis of uterine cancer. Ms B retains decision-making capacity but is
critically ill and decisions need to be made about her treatment. Ms B has not
yet been told her cancer diagnosis because she speaks Cantonese and the health
care team has been working to coordinate a meeting where a certified health
care interpreter can help deliver this news.
However, in the meantime, a medical intern has inadvertently disclosed Ms B’s
cancer diagnosis to Ms B’s aunt, Mei, while she was visiting the hospital one
afternoon. Mei, although devastated by the new cancer diagnosis, is even more
distraught at the thought of her niece living with the knowledge that she has
cancer. Mei explains, “Doctors in China don’t tell patients they have cancer and
my niece would lose hope if she learns of her diagnosis, become depressed, and
no longer want to live.” Yesterday, while talking with Susan through a telephone
interpreter, Ms B asked if something was seriously wrong with her. Susan was
unsure what to say, so quickly redirected the conversation when the phleboto-
mist came into the room to collect samples for laboratory tests. Susan feels Ms B
has a right to know her health information but also understands the concerns
of Ms B’s aunt. Today on rounds, Mei implored the health care team to conceal
Ms B’s new cancer diagnosis. The team explained that because Ms B has the
ability to make her own decisions, they need to inform Ms B that they have
new information about her health and ask if she wants to know more. Ms B’s
attending physician has several other patients to see and plans to fit the meet-
ing into his schedule late in the day, so he wants to use a telephone interpreter
instead of an in-person interpreter. The family has reluctantly agreed to attend
a meeting with the health care team and patient where, through an interpreter,
Melissa Kurtz Uveges is Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Center for Bioethics at Harvard Medical School,
641 Huntington Avenue, Boston, MA 02115 (Melissa_uveges@hms.harvard.edu).
Aimee Milliken is Wiese Postdoctoral Fellow in Clinical Ethics, Brigham and Women’s Hospital,
Brighton, Massachusetts.
Afi Alfred is Clinical Operations Manager, Bowdoin Street Health Center, Boston, Massachusetts.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4037/aacnacc2019436
287
ETHICS IN CRITICAL CARE W W W .AACN ACCON LIN E .ORG
they will explore Ms B’s preferences for learn- new cancer diagnosis.3 However, ICU nurses
ing her new health information. Susan, as part practicing at the bedside are integrally involved
of the health care team, feels she has a role to in the broader process of disclosure2,4,5 because
play in resolving the ethical dilemmas that disclosure of difficult news is not just a one-
have arisen around the possibility of disclosing time event when news about a diagnosis, prog-
Ms B’s new health information; however, she nosis, or treatment is given; it is a process.2 As
is unsure what her role is. Susan plans to have clinicians with considerable patient interac-
her nurse manager cover her patients while tion, ICU nurses are part of the events lead-
she attends the scheduled meeting for Ms B. ing up to the delivery of new and potentially
The case of Ms B involves the disclosure, or difficult information. They may also partici-
release, of important and sensitive health in- pate during the delivery of such news and are
formation to a patient and her family. In the present with patients after the delivery of this
midst of the disclosure process, several ethical news (Figure 1).2,4,5
288
VO L U M E 3 0 • N U MB E R 3 • FALL 2019 ETHICS IN CRITICAL CARE
Figure 1: Involvement of intensive care unit nurses throughout the disclosure of difficult news.
because of factors related to disclosure compe- meetings so they can accurately convey or rein-
tency. For example, ICU nurses may lack force information that is disclosed. However, to
knowledge of professional or ethical guide- participate, nurses need unit support. Receiv-
lines pertaining to disclosure, such as the Code ing such support may not be easy and may
of Ethics for Nurses, that inform nurses’ prac- even be impossible in some clinical settings.
tice. In addition, depending on the institution, Still other ICU nurses may fear consequences
ICU nurses will experience variable levels of that can come with delivering difficult news to
autonomy in practicing to the full extent of patients or families, such as the diminishing of
their professional knowledge base.10 The level hope or unpredictable responses such as anger,
of the nurse’s professional autonomy will influ- sadness, denial, or even silence.2,11,12 Susan may
ence his or her comfort with participating in have been worried that Ms B would lose hope
the disclosure process.7 For example, some if she were to learn about her diagnosis, just
nurses report not participating in the disclo- as family members feared. These examples
sure process because they fear being repri- highlight the challenge ICU nurses face when
manded for doing so (especially by physicians). trying to participate in disclosure cases, espe-
Other nurses report hesitancy to be involved cially when they lack training in communica-
because of lack of administrative or unit sup- tion skills. Susan was unsure how to explore
port.11,12 These examples highlight the chal- Ms B’s new diagnostic information, despite
lenge that some ICU nurses face in obtaining sensing that withholding such information
organizational support to exercise their pro- may be problematic. This sense of being unclear
fessional autonomy and participate in disclo- about how to act, in addition to the lack of
sure cases.13 In the case of Ms B, Susan received training in how to communicate in the con-
coverage support for her patient care assign- text of difficult news, can lead ICU nurses to
ment from her nurse manager so that she could experience moral distress, defined in this case
participate in Ms B’s family and team meet- as a feeling of disequilibrium arising from the
ing. It is important for nurses to attend such uncertainty characterizing Ms B’s case.14 Moral
289
ETHICS IN CRITICAL CARE W W W .AACN ACCON LIN E .ORG
Educator Supporter
• Establish patient understanding of and • Offer physical presence during key
preferences for receiving information conversations and meetings
• Create a space conducive for information • Provide emotional and practical support
exchange • Refer patient to other supportive care providers
• Work to level the power differential between (eg, social work, spiritual care personnel)
providers and patients
• Provide information and education to patients
and families
Advocate Facilitator
• Explore patient and family values and • Connect patient and family to other institutional
290
VO L U M E 3 0 • N U MB E R 3 • FALL 2019 ETHICS IN CRITICAL CARE
the health care team, and the ICU nurse may other family members and be unsure of how
lack knowledge about information discussed. to proceed.9 ICU nurses may also encounter
Therefore, it is important for ICU nurses to situations in which patients are not receiving
obtain a fuller picture of what has been dis- full and frank information about their health
cussed from the patient and/or family before from other providers, which can constrain the
offering additional education.16 An ICU nurse nurse-patient relationship and further contrib-
can inquire about what information patients ute to nurses’ moral distress.21
and families have received and the patient’s or Importantly, nurses in the ICU environment
family’s preference for obtaining information, do not have to face these uncertainties alone;
including the types and amount of informa- rather, they can help facilitate the incorpora-
tion desired, their preferred decision-making tion of other resources within the health care
style, and important persons to include in the setting that can provide additional consulta-
decision-making process. Nurses can also tion. Examples of resources that ICU nurses
291
ETHICS IN CRITICAL CARE W W W .AACN ACCON LIN E .ORG
patient rapport, especially in critical care set- view of the impact of such news and can sup-
tings.24 For instance, using the telephone as a port positive coping.6 ICU nurses are key sup-
means of communication prevents interpreters ports to families at the end of a patient’s life,26,27
from reading patient and family facial reactions providing emotional11,16 and practical sup-
and body language.24 However, when trained, port.6 In addition, the presence of ICU nurses
in-person health care interpreters are unavail- during disclosure conversations increases fami-
able, telephone or video-conferencing commu- lies’ trust of information.16 Patients who face
nication bridges are preferable to using family the disclosure of a new diagnosis such as can-
and friends as interpreters, because family or cer may newly require pain and symptom re-
friends can compromise patient confidential- lief. ICU nurses can support these needs by
ity and may filter communication according helping patients connect with palliative care
to their own understanding or values.24 or pain service providers. Many patients and
Finally, critical care nurses can highlight the families who receive difficult news turn to
292
VO L U M E 3 0 • N U MB E R 3 • FALL 2019 ETHICS IN CRITICAL CARE
risks of treatment options can help facilitate 9. Petronio S, Sargent J. Disclosure predicaments arising
during the course of patient care: nurses’ privacy man-
transparent conversations in which true ben- agement. Health Commun. 2011;26(3):255-266.
efits and burdens can be weighed. In the case 10. Skår R. The meaning of autonomy in nursing practice.
J Clin Nurs. 2010;19(15-16):2226-2234.
of Ms B, Susan may serve as an advocate for 11. Ehsani M, Taleghani F, Hematti S, Abazari P. Percep-
Ms B’s values and her wish for information tions of patients, families, physicians and nurses
related to her new diagnosis and potential regarding challenges in cancer disclosure: a descriptive
qualitative study. Eur J Oncol Nurs. 2016;25:55-61.
treatment options. 12. Newman AR. Nurses’ perceptions of diagnosis and
prognosis-related communication: an integrative review.
Conclusion Cancer Nurs. 2016;39(5):E48-E60. doi:10.1097
/NCC.0000000000000365
Disclosing difficult news to patients and 13. Rao AD, Kumar A, McHugh M. Better nurse autonomy
families can create situations in which nurses, decreases the odds of 30-day mortality and failure to
rescue. J Nurs Scholarsh. 2017;49(1):73-79.
particularly in the ICU setting, feel uncertain 14. Morley G, Ives J, Bradbury-Jones C, Irvine F. What is
about their role. Disclosure is viewed as a pro-
293