Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cuvier's History of The Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications Scientifiques Du Muséum
Cuvier's History of The Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications Scientifiques Du Muséum
Publications
scientifiques
du
Muséum
Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences | Georges Cuvier
Full text
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 1/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 2/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
7 Like others I mentioned, this work has only the merit of its
plates, representing very beautiful ichthyolites.16 Four sites,
out of which Scheuchzer only knew three, are known in Europe
to contain these organic fragments in abundance: 1) the copper
mines of Thuringia where you can find, compressed between
strips of black slates, some fishes of species and genera that do
not exist anymore today;17 2) an extension of the Jura, near
Eichstedt, under the Pappenheim County, where a
considerable number of perfectly preserved fishes and other
marine animal skeletons are found in white marls; 3) Mount
Bolca, near Verona, with a large part of its layers containing
very large fishes, perfectly preserved but almost all unknown;
and 4) a small Swabian village named Öhningen, near Lake
Constance, with marly schist containing freshwater fish
skeletons, in great quantity and perfectly preserved. The latter
fossils are extensively found in cabinets of curiosity, and they
were best described by Scheuchzer. The figures appeared for
the first time in his Piscium querelae.
8 Scheuchzer published under the title Homo diluvii testis et
theoscopos18 a dissertation on a fossil with a head as big as a
child’s, two large cavities like eye sockets, and a partial
backbone. While he was a physician, and therefore an
anatomist, Scheuchzer thought the fossil was a fragment of a
human skeleton even if its aspect was enough to conclude that
these bones never belonged to our species. After Scheuchzer,
naturalists recognized his error; some claimed the skeleton
belonged to a fish, others that it was a mammal, but generally
it was still thought to be an anthropomorphite until I
recognized recently that it was a gigantic salamander, which
no longer exists. I did a prior drawing of the potential figure of
this animal. Once removed from the rock, the parts previously
hidden were exactly as I drew them. Since then, two other
complete salamanders were found and they are exactly the
same as the first one. Baier19 made an error similar to
Scheuchzer’s by mistaking ichthyosaur20 vertebrae for human
vertebrae.21
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 5/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
a piece of petrified wood, you can see the beams from the
center to the circumference, the circular fibers intersecting
with those beams, and the vessels, no matter how fine. Each
part still has different colors. In one word, the plant is
reproduced in its smallest details. It is assumed that the
mineral substance replaced the plant matter in the exact same
layout but we do not know how, under which law or influence.
16 I will end the history of mineralogy in the first half of the
eighteenth century with the most complete work on
petrifications, Georg Wolfgang Knorr’s Lapides diluvii testes,
published in installments between 1755 and 1772.41 Knorr was
an engraver and a painter in Nuremberg and only the
illustrations are from him. The text is from a professor at Jena,
Immanuel Walch.42 He had an extensive erudition on
mineralogy as he mentioned all authors preceding him.
17 Messieurs, we will now present the history of organized beings
in the first half of the eighteenth century. The history can be
general or specific. We will start with the general history of
physiology.
18 Etymologically, physiology means the science of nature. For
the Ancient Greeks, it often meant the science of nature in
general or physics. In our contemporary Europe, it only refers
to the science of organized beings considered in relationship
with life. The word life is vague and can have several meanings
and I will define it. Some metaphysicians infer the idea of life
from the identity of existence and activity. Others, like the
philosophers of nature, consider that life is the entire motion
of the universe. They recognize a global life, out of which each
being comes and which absorbs it at the end of its existence.
Each and every one of us for example is a phenomenon of
universal life in the same way that the internal and external
phenomena of our body belong to our specific life. Nothing can
be defined when relating our existence to a global life. While
we understand the relationships between our small bodily
phenomena and ourselves, the link between our individual
existence and a global life is only an abstraction. Therefore, we
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 9/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
Notes
1. Petrifications are also pseudomorphs because their inorganic matter
component usually has a different shape. [M. de St.-Agy]
2. [Carl Nicolaus Lang, Langius, or Caroli Nicolai Langii (born 18 February
1670, Lucerne; died 2 May 1741, Lucerne), a Swiss physician and naturalist,
known for his large and varied collection of petrifications and for his many
published works on minerals and fossils.]
3. [Historia lapidum figuratorum Helvetiae, ejusque viciniae: in quânon
solùm enarrantur omnia eorum genera, species et vires aeneisque tabulis
repraesentantur, sed insuper adducuntur eorum loca nativa, in quibus
reperiri solent, ut cuilibet facile sit eos colligere, modo adducta loca adire
libeat, Venice: Jacobi Tomasini, 1708, [30] + 165 p. + 53 pls, in-quarto.]
4. [Tractatus de origine lapidum figuratorum in quo diffuse disseritur,
utrum nimirum sint corpora marina a diluvio ad montes translata, &
tractu temporis petrificata vel an a seminio quodam e materia
lapidescente intra terram generentur, quibus accedit accurata diluvii,
Lucerne: Annae Felicitatis Hautt, 1709, [7] + 80 p., in-quarto.]
5. [David Sigismund Büttner (born 30 August 1660, Lichtenstein; died 25
September 1719, Querfurt, Germany), a German Protestant clergyman,
geologist and paleontologist, who interpreted fossils as remains of marine
animals victimized and transported to unlikely places by the Biblical Flood.
He maintained a large collection of petrifications and attempted to equate
presentday marine organisms with their fossilized counterparts.]
6. [Rudera diluvii testes, Zeichen und Zeugen der Sündfluth, in Ansehung
des itzigen Zustandes unserer Erd-und Wasser-Kugel, insonderheit der
darinnen vielfältig auch zeither in Querfurtischen Revier unterschiedlich
angetroffenen, ehemahls verschwemten Thiere und Gewächse, Leipzig:
Johann Friedrich Braunen, 1710, viii + 314 + 20 p. + 31 pls.]
7. [Johann Wilhelm Baier (born 12 June 1675, Jena; died 11 May 1729,
Altdorf), brother of Johann Jakob Baier (see note 8, below) and not to be
confused with his father of the same name (Lutheran theologian, born 11
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 10/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
era; based on fossil evidence, they first appeared approximately 250 million
years ago and at least one species survived until about 90 million years ago,
into the Late Cretaceous. During the early Triassic Period, ichthyosaurs
evolved from a group of unidentified land reptiles that returned to the sea,
in a development parallel to that of the ancestors of modern-day dolphins
and whales, which they gradually came to resemble.]
21. [Baier (see note 9, above), in his Oryctographia norica of 1708 (see
note 10, above), correctly identified the fossils in question as vertebrae, but
he insisted they belonged to a human victim of the Flood.]
22. [Cette-Eygun is a commune in the Pyrénées-Atlantiques department in
south-western France.]
23. [Herbarium diluvianum collectum, Zürich: Davidis Gessneri, 1709, 44
p. + 10 pls, ills, in-folio; a second edition was published in Leiden (Petri
Vander Aa, 1723, [6] + 123 p. + 14 pls, ills, 1 port., in-folio).]
24. [Adolphe-Théodore Brongniart (born 14 January 1801, Paris; died 18
February 1876, Paris), a French botanist whose pioneering work on the
relationships between extinct and existing plants earned him the title of
Father of Paleobotany. His major contribution on plant fossils is titled
Histoire des végétaux fossiles, ou, Recherches botaniques et géologiques
sur les végétaux renfermés dans les diverses couches du globe (Paris: E. J.
Bailly), an unfinished work, originally planned to be published in 24 parts,
but only 15 parts were printed, between 1828 and 1837, the last ending
abruptly in the middle of a sentence.]
25. [Museum Diluvianum quod possidet, Tiguri [Zürich]: Typis Henrici
Bodmeri, 1716, [12] + 107 + [5] p. + [1] leaf of pls, ill., in-8°.]
26. [George Ludwig Hueber, student and collaborator of Johann
Bartholomeus Beringer (see note 27, below) in producing Lithographiae
Wirceburgensis, ducentis lapidum figuratorum, a potiori insectiformium,
prodigiosis imaginibus exornatae specimen primum, quod in
dissertatione inaugurali physico-historica, cum annexis corollariis
medicis, authoritate et consensu inclytae facultatis medicae, in alma Eoo-
Francica wirceburgensium universitate, Würzburg: Prostat Wirceburgi,
apud Philippum Wilhelmum Fuggart, 1726, [12] + 137 p. + 21 pls.]
27. [Johann Bartholomeus Adam Beringer (born 1667, died 1740), a
German physician and dean of the Faculty of Medicine at the University of
Würzburg who described pieces of limestone (that came to be called
Beringer’s Lying Stones), formed in the shape of various animals, such as
birds, lizards, frogs, and spiders on their webs, claiming them to be fossils.
Because some of them also bore the name of God in Hebrew, he thought
they might be of divine origin, calling them “capricious fabrications of
God.” In fact, he was the victim of a cruel hoax, perpetrated on him by his
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 12/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
colleagues. Upon discovering the truth, Beringer took his hoaxers to court,
and the scandal that followed left all three of them in disgrace. Some of the
stones are now on display at the Oxford University Museum, and Teylers
Museum in the Netherlands.]
28. [Peter Wohlfahrt or Wolfart (born 11 July 1675, Hanau; died 3
December 1726, Cassell), a German physician and academician, author of
Amoenitates Hassiae inferioris subterraneae (Cassell: Johann Henrich
Herbst, 1711) and Historia naturalis Hassiae inferioris (Cassell: Henrich
Harmes, 1719, 52 p. + 25 pls.)]
29. [Johann Georg Liebknecht (born 23 April 1679, Wasungen, Thuringia;
died 17 September 1749, Giessen), a German theologian and naturalist,
professor of mathematics and theology at the Ludoviciana University in
Giessen, Germany, and author of Discursus de diluvio maximo occasione
inventi nuper in comitatu laubacensi et ex mira metamorphosi in
mineram ferri mutati ligni, cum observationibus geodaeticis,
aeroscopicis, hydrographicis et aliis, Giessae; Francofurti: J. O. Meyeri &
J. T. Nockeri, 1714, [3] + 374 p.]
30. [Antoine de Jussieu (born 6 July 1686, Lyon; died 22 April 1758, Paris),
a French physician and naturalist, not to be confused with his better-
known nephew, Antoine Laurent de Jussieu (born 12 April 1748, Lyon; died
17 September 1836), or with his brother, Bernard de Jussieu (born 17
August 1699, Lyon; died 6 November 1777, Paris), author of “Recherches
physiques sur les pétrifications qui se trouvent en France de diverses
parties des plantes et d’animaux étrangers”, Mémoires de l’Académie des
Sciences de Paris, 1721, pp. 69-75.]
31. [Charles Plumier, see Volume 2, Lesson 8, note 83.].
32. [Antoine-Joseph Dezallier d’Argenville (born 1 July 1680, Paris; died
29 November 1765, Paris), not to be confused with his architect son,
Antoine-Nicolas Dezallier d’Argenville (born 27 August 1723, Paris; died 26
September 1796, Paris), was a French avocat to the Parlement de Paris and
secretary to the king —a connoisseur of gardening, with an interest in
natural history that resulted in several treatises on shells, minerals, and
fossils.]
33. [L’histoire naturelle éclaircie dans une de ses parties principales,
l’oryctologie: qui traite des terres, des pierres, des métaux, des minéraux,
et autres fossiles: ouvrage dans lequel on trouve un nouvelle méthode
latine & françoise de les diviser, & une notice critique des principaux
ouvrages qui ont paru sur ces matières, Paris: De Bure l’Aîné, 1755, [23] +
560 + [2] p.]
34. [Antoine de Jussieu, see note 30, above.]
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 13/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
35. [Samuel Thomas von Sömmerring, see Volume 2, Lesson 14, note 98.]
36. [Jacob Theodor Klein (born 15 August 1685, Gdañsk, Poland; died 27
February 1759, Königsberg, Prussia), a German jurist, historian, botanist,
zoologist, mathematician, and diplomat, who in natural history dealt with
matters of zoological nomenclature and set up his own system of
classification of animals, which was based on the number, shape, and
position of the limbs. He is the author of Sciagraphia lithologica curiosa,
seu, Lapidum figuratorum nomenclator, Gdañsk: Thomae Johannis
Schreiberi, 1740, 77 p.]
37. [Johann Jakob Scheuchzer, see Lesson 4, note 23.]
38. [Louis Bourguet (see Lesson 4, note 26, above), author of Traité des
pétrifications, Paris: Briasson, 1742, xvi + 91 + [3] p. + 60 pls.]
39. [René Antoine Ferchault de Réaumur, see Volume 2, Lesson 16, note
31.]
40. [Johannes Gessner (born 18 March 1709, Zürich; died 6 May 1790,
Zürich), a Swiss mathematician, physicist, botanist, mineralogist and
physician, and the author of Tractatus physicus de petrificatis, in duas
partes distinctus, quarum prior agit de petrificatorum differentiis &
eorum varia origine, Leiden: Theodorum Haak, 1758, 137 p.]
41. [Georg Wolfgang Knorr (see Volume 2, Lesson 8, note 53), author (with
Johann Ernst Immanuel Walch; see note 42, below) of Lapides ex
celeberrimorum virorum sententia diluvii universalis testes, quos in
ordines ac species distribuit, suis coloribus expremit, Nuremberg: Gustav
Philipp Jakob Bieling, published in installments between 1755 and 1773
and later bound in 4 folio vols., with 272 pls.]
42. [Johann Ernst Immanuel Walch (born 29 August 1725, Jena; died 1
December 1778, Jena), a German theologian, linguist, and naturalist who
over his life time produced more than 80 publications on various topics in
the humanities and about 50 publications in natural history, particularly on
geology and fossils, perhaps the most significant being the beautifully
illustrated, four-volume Die Naturgeschichte der Versteinerungen zur
Erläuterung der Knorrischen Sammlung von Merckwürdigkeiten der
Natur herausgegeben (Nuremberg: Felsecker, 1768-1773, a German edition
of Lapides diluvii universalis testes, which he continued after Knorr’s
death in 1761 (see note 41, above). A comprehensive chapter on trilobites in
1771 contains the first use of the word “trilobite” and predates other equally
comprehensive treatments by 50 years.]
The text and other elements (illustrations, imported files) may be used
under OpenEdition Books License, unless otherwise stated.
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 14/15
11/7/23, 3:27 PM Cuvier’s History of the Natural Sciences - 10. The Beginnings of Paleontology - Publications scientifiques du Muséum
https://books.openedition.org/mnhn/3525 15/15