Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 19

EVALUATING THE QUALITY OF INFORMATION TO MAKE BETTER DECISIONS

CONTRIBUTING QUALITY INFORMATION TO HELP PEOPLE MAKE BETTER DECISIONS

Part
Part II:
II: Intelligence
Intelligence

Monday & Wednesday Lectures Friday Lab


CVR Calculations and
Week 6 Using Descriptive Statistics to Evaluate the Quality of Info
Method Section

Week 7 Using Inferential Statistics to Make Better Decisions Stats Introduction

Week 8 Defining and Evaluating Intelligence: Binet and Spearman Time for Questions

Week 9 Defining and Evaluating Intelligence: Wechsler Results Section

Week 10 Defining and Evaluating Achievement Tests Discussion Section


LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Last Time
What is meant by inferential statistics?

Today’s Focus:
Defining and Evaluating Intelligence: Binet and Spearman
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Defining Intelligence
1. What were the three independent research traditions identified by Taylor to study human intelligence?

Binet
2. Through what 3 facilities did Binet believe intelligence expressed itself?
3. What two major concepts guided Binet?
4. Know age differentiation, mental age, general mental ability.
5. Binet searched for tasks that could be completed by what percentage of children in a particular age group?

Spearman
6. How did Spearman define intelligence?
7. What concept did Spearman introduce? What does this concept mean?
8. What statistical method did Spearman develop to support his notion of g? How does it work?
9. What is positive manifold?
10. According to gf-gc theory, what are the two basic types of intelligence? How do they differ?
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Imagine you are given the job to create a national gifted program and a national
learning disability program. How would you do it?

Write/Pair/Share

Step 1: How would you define intelligence? What is your theory? How would you
operationally define intelligence?

Step 2: What specific questions would you ask to measure intelligence?


LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Large number of definitions of intelligence in psychology

Textbook definition: “general potential, independent of previous learning”

How independent of previous learning?


• Should we assume that they can read?
• Has gone to school?
• How easy is it to independently measure achievement, intelligence, and
aptitude?
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

3 Independent Research Traditions


Psychometric Approach
• Oldest approach and focus of chapter
• Examines the elemental structure of a test
• Examines test properties through evaluating its correlates and
underlying dimensions

Information-Processing Approach
• Examines the processes that underlie how we learn and solve problems

Cognitive Approach
• Focuses on how humans adapt to real-world demands
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Discuss

Compare/contrast 3 approaches
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

It all began one day in 1904 when…


the French minister of public instruction appoints a commission to recommend a
procedure for how to identify a ‘subnormal child’

Binet appointed.

Defined intelligence as the capacity to:


• Find and maintain a definite direction or purpose
• Make necessary adaptations to achieve that purpose
• Engage in self-criticism so necessary adjustments in strategy can be made

• (definition not used in psychology today)


LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Binet's operational definitions:

Believed intelligence expressed itself through these facilities:


• Judgment
• Attention
• Reasoning

Guided by 2 principles that underlie modern intelligence theories


• Age Differentiation
• General Mental Ability

• (what Binet is still most famous for)


LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Principle 1: Age Differentiation


• Differentiating older from younger children by the former’s greater capacities
• Goal was to find tasks in which the age group completion would be 66.67 to 75%
among older kids (an increase in age results in an increasing proportion of success)
• Mental age: Equivalent age capabilities of a child regardless of his/her
chronological age. Obtained through age differentiation
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Principle 2: General Mental Ability


• General mental ability: a term for what we now call IQ or intelligence
• ”Sum of the parts”
• Problematic because don’t know the parts
• This restricted his search and judged the value of particular tasks in terms of its
correlations with the total score
• Eliminate tasks with low correlations
• Retain tasks with high correlations
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Write/Pair/Share

What are the two key principles Binet built his theory on?
Why are they important?
Is this intelligent… or is this intelligent?
Hugging Cats
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Spearman
• Intelligence consists of one general factor (g) plus a large number of specific factors
• Spearman’s psychometric g was based on on idea of positive-manifold- all tests
no matter how diverse, measure g (general intelligence)

To support the notion of g he developed factor analysis


• Reducing a set of variables to a smaller number of factors
• As a rule, approximately half of the variance in a set of diverse mental
ability tests is represented in the g factor.
LAST TIME / TODAY DEFINING INTELLIGENCE BINET SPEARMAN

Defining Intelligence
1. What were the three independent research traditions identified by Taylor to study human intelligence?

Binet
2. Through what 3 facilities did Binet believe intelligence expressed itself?
3. What two major concepts guided Binet?
4. Know age differentiation, mental age, general mental ability.
5. Binet searched for tasks that could be completed by what percentage of children in a particular age group?

Spearman
6. How did Spearman define intelligence?
7. What concept did Spearman introduce? What does this concept mean?
8. What statistical method did Spearman develop to support his notion of g? How does it work?
9. What is positive manifold?

You might also like