GALGOTIAS UNIVERSITY

GREATER NOIDA, UTTAR PRADESH

MBA DUAL SPECIALIZATION

FALL 2023-2024

GROUP – 3

SECTION- 9

PROJECT REPORT ON

“MOBILE INDUSTRY- APPLE”

SUBMITTED IN THE PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF THE
GALGOTIAS UNIVERSITY

SUBMITTED TO- Dr. Rashi Mittal ma’am

SUBMITTED BY-

MAYANK SINGH-23GSOB2010366

MEGHNA HAZARIKA-23GSOB2010418

BISWAJIT SAU-23GSOB2010074

AKARSH VERMA- 23GSOB2010466

1
ANNEXURE 1

I. INTRODUCTION
 SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDYING OLIGOPOLY
 OVERVIEW OF MOBILE
2. OBJECTIVES
 ANALYSIS OF OLIGOPOLY MARKET
 UNDERSTANDING PRODUCT DIFFERENTIATION STRATEGIES
 BRANDING STRATEGIES
 QUALITY AS A COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE
 PRICING STRATEGIES
 FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO PRICE STABILITY
1. BACKGROUND
 BACKGROUND ON APPLE INC.
 HISTORICAL CONTEXT
 OVERVIEW OF OLIGOPOLY IN CONTEXT OF MOBILE INDUSTRY
 BRIEF HISTORY
2. PRODUCT DIFFERENTIATION OF APPLE
 BRANDING
 PRICE
 QUALITY
 ADVERTISING
3. FACTORS FOR PRICING STABILITY WHEN DEMAND AND COST CHANGES
 INELASTIC DEMAND AND BRAND LOYALTY
 PREMIUM BRAND IMAGE
 CONTROLLED DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS
 LIMITED PRICE WARS
 COST EFFICIENCY AND ECONOMIES OF SCALE
 STRATEGIC PRODUCT DIFFERENTIATION

ANNEXURE 2

4. METHODOLODY
 PRIMARY DATA
 SECONDARY DATA
5. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS
6. FINDINGS
7. LIMITATION OF THE PROJECT
 QUESTIONNAIRE ERROR
 RESPONDENT ERROR
 SAMPLING ERROR
8. CONCLUSION

2
 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

A work is never a work of an individual. We owe a sense of gratitude to the

intelligence and co-operation of those people who had been so easy to let us
understand what we needed from time to time for completion of this exclusive
project. We want to express our gratitude towards Dr. Rashi Mittal Ma’am for
giving us an opportunity to do this project.
Last but not the least, we would like to forward our gratitude to our friends &
other faculty members who always endured us and stood by us and without whom
we could not have envisaged the completion of our project.

3
INTRODUCTION
In the dynamic landscape of the mobile industry, oligopoly emerges as a predominant
market structure, characterized by a small number of influential firms dominating the
market. Unlike perfect competition or monopolistic markets, oligopolies involve intense
competition among a limited number of key players. Understanding the implications of
oligopoly in the mobile industry is crucial for unraveling the complex web of market
dynamics.

Significance of Studying Oligopoly:

Studying oligopoly is imperative as it unveils the intricate interplay between major

players, such as Apple, and their impact on market behavior. Oligopolistic markets often
exhibit unique characteristics, including strategic decision-making, interdependence
among firms, and significant barriers to entry. The study of oligopoly sheds light on how
these features shape competition, pricing strategies, and innovation within the mobile
industry.

Overview of the Mobile Industry:

The mobile industry stands at the forefront of technological innovation, influencing

global communication and connectivity. Major players in this industry, including Apple,
Samsung, and Google, play pivotal roles in shaping consumer preferences and market
trends. The convergence of hardware, software, and services has created a highly
competitive environment where differentiation becomes a key strategy for sustaining
market share.

As consumers increasingly rely on mobile devices for a myriad of purposes, ranging

from communication to entertainment and productivity, understanding the strategies
employed by major players is paramount. Apple, with its iconic iPhones and ecosystem,
stands out as a prime example of a company shaping the industry's trajectory.

By delving into the oligopolistic nature of the mobile industry, this study aims to dissect
the strategies adopted by major players like Apple, focusing on product differentiation
through branding, quality, and pricing. Additionally, the examination of factors

4
contributing to price stability in the face of fluctuating demand and costs will provide
insights into the resilience of these oligopolistic structures. This exploration is not merely
an academic exercise but a practical endeavor to comprehend the intricate dynamics
that influence consumers, competitors, and the broader market.

OBJECTIVE OF THIS PROJECT:-

The primary objectives of the project are:

Comprehensive Analysis of Oligopoly Market Structure:

Conduct an in-depth examination of the oligopoly market structure in the mobile

industry.

Identify and define the key characteristics of oligopoly that shape the competitive
landscape in the mobile sector.

Understanding Product Differentiation Strategies, with a Focus on Apple:

Investigate how firms, particularly Apple, differentiate their products in the oligopolistic
mobile industry.

Analyze the significance of branding, quality, pricing, and other factors in the product
differentiation strategies of Apple.

Branding Strategies in the Mobile Industry:

Explore and analyze how branding contributes to the market position of firms in the
mobile industry.

Assess the role of branding in creating a distinctive identity for Apple and influencing
consumer preferences.

Quality as a Competitive Advantage:

Examine the importance of product quality in Apple's competitive strategy within the
mobile industry.

Investigate how Apple maintains and enhances the perceived quality of its mobile
products.

5
Pricing Strategies in Oligopoly:

Analyze the pricing strategies adopted by Apple and other major players in the
oligopolistic market structure.

Identify factors influencing pricing decisions, such as production costs, competition, and
perceived value.

Factors Contributing to Price Stability:

Investigate the factors that contribute to price stability in the mobile industry, focusing on
cases where prices remain relatively constant despite changes in demand and costs.

Explore the role of strategic interactions among firms in maintaining price stability.

BACKGOUND OF THE STUDY:-

Background on Apple Inc.:

Apple Inc., founded on April 1, 1976, by Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, and Ronald
Wayne, started as a computer company. Initially known for its innovative personal
computers like the Apple II and Macintosh, Apple experienced significant ups and
downs in the 1980s and 1990s. In 1997, with Steve Jobs returning as CEO, the
company underwent a revitalization.

Apple diversified its product line to include consumer electronics, software, and
services. Iconic products such as the iPod, iPhone, iPad, and MacBook propelled Apple
to become one of the world's most valuable and influential technology companies.

Historical Context of Apple's Entry into the Mobile Industry:

Apple's entry into the mobile industry is marked by the launch of the first iPhone on
June 29, 2007. The iPhone revolutionized the smartphone market by combining a
phone, music player, and internet communicator into a single device. Its touchscreen
interface, sleek design, and the introduction of the App Store set new standards for the
industry.

The success of the iPhone transformed Apple from a computer-focused company to a

major player in the consumer electronics and mobile technology sectors. Subsequent
iPhone releases and innovations solidified Apple's position as a leading force in the
global mobile industry.

Overview of Oligopoly Market in the Context of the Mobile Industry:

6
In the mobile industry, an oligopoly market structure prevails, characterized by a handful
of dominant firms that wield substantial influence over market dynamics. Apple,
Samsung, and a select few others compete intensely, shaping the industry's trajectory.
Oligopoly engenders an environment where strategic decision-making and
interdependence among major players are paramount. Product differentiation becomes
a linchpin strategy, with companies like Apple distinguishing themselves through
innovative branding, superior product quality, and carefully calibrated pricing strategies.
This competitive landscape fosters a delicate balance, as firms navigate strategic
interactions to maintain market share. The oligopolistic nature of the mobile industry
underscores the significance of understanding how major players, particularly Apple,
employ various tactics to set themselves apart and influence consumer preferences.

Brief History and Evolution of the Mobile Industry:

Early Days: The mobile industry traces its roots to the 1970s and 1980s when the first
commercially available mobile phones were introduced. These devices were large,
bulky, and primarily used for voice communication.

Digital Era: The transition to digital technology in the 1990s brought about smaller,
more portable phones. The introduction of SMS (Short Message Service) and mobile
data services marked a significant shift in functionality.

Smartphone Revolution: The 2000s saw the rise of smartphones, with companies like
BlackBerry and Nokia leading the way. However, Apple's iPhone in 2007 marked a
paradigm shift, introducing a touchscreen interface and a wide range of applications.

Android and Market Diversity: The subsequent years witnessed the emergence of
Android-based smartphones, creating a diverse market with multiple operating systems.
Companies like Samsung, Huawei, and Google became key players in the industry.

Current Landscape: Today, the mobile industry is characterized by intense

competition, rapid technological advancements, and a wide array of devices offering
diverse features. 5G technology, artificial intelligence, and other innovations continue to
shape the industry's evolution.

7
PRODUCT DIFFRENTIATION OF APPLE:-
BRANDING:-

Branding plays a crucial role in the success of any company, and Apple Inc. is a prime
example of a brand that has achieved remarkable recognition and loyalty. Apple’s branding
strategy revolves around creating a distinctive brand image, conveying a strong sense of
innovation, and building an emotional connection with consumers. In this article, we will
explore the key elements of Apple’s branding strategy and how they have contributed to the
company’s iconic status.

1. Consistent Brand Identity: Apple has meticulously crafted and maintained a

consistent brand identity throughout its existence. The company’s logo, the bitten
apple, is instantly recognizable worldwide. The logo represents simplicity, elegance,
and the brand’s dedication to cutting-edge technology. From product design to
marketing materials, Apple ensures that its brand identity remains consistent,
reinforcing its position as a leader in innovation and design.

Expert Opinion: According to Forbes, Apple’s consistent branding has contributed to its
brand value, making it the most valuable brand in the world for several years.

2. Focus on Innovation: Apple’s branding strategy revolves around positioning itself as

an innovative company that pushes the boundaries of technology. By consistently
introducing groundbreaking products and features, such as the iPhone, iPad, and
Apple Watch, Apple has established itself as a pioneer in the tech industry. The
company’s commitment to innovation creates an aura of excitement and anticipation
around its products, reinforcing its brand image as an industry trendsetter.

Expert Opinion: In an interview with CNN, brand strategist Allen Adamson stated, “Apple is
the ultimate innovator and that’s one of the reasons why it’s such a successful brand. Apple
has been consistently successful at being at the forefront of new product innovation.”

3. Emotional Connection with Customers: Apple understands the importance of forging

an emotional connection with its customers. The company’s branding strategy
focuses on appealing to consumers’ aspirations, desires, and values. Apple’s
marketing campaigns often evoke emotions and tell compelling stories that resonate
with its target audience. By creating a sense of belonging and personal attachment to

8
 the brand, Apple cultivates a loyal customer base that goes beyond mere product
functionality.

Expert Opinion: According to a study published in the Journal of Business Research,

emotional branding leads to stronger brand loyalty and positive word-of-mouth
recommendations, ultimately driving customer retention and brand growth.

PRICE:-
Apple company successfully differentiates its product, it creates a perception of higher
value in the minds of consumers, allowing them to charge a premium price. This power
enables companies to increase their profit margins and gain a competitive advantage.

Apple Inc., a renowned technology company, has successfully differentiated its

products, such as the iPhone and MacBook, through sleek design, user-friendly
interfaces, and innovative features. As a result, Apple can charge premium prices
compared to its competitors who offer similar products without the same level of
differentiation.

QUALITY:-

Apple can continue to differentiate its products through a relentless commitment to

quality across various dimensions. First and foremost, maintaining the high standards of
material selection and manufacturing processes is paramount. By consistently using
premium materials, such as aluminum and glass, and employing precision engineering
in the production of its devices, Apple can ensure that its products not only exude a
sense of durability and sophistication but also deliver a superior user experience.
Additionally, a continued emphasis on rigorous quality control measures at every stage
of production, including thorough testing for durability and reliability, would reinforce
Apple's reputation for producing products that stand the test of time. Furthermore, Apple
can differentiate itself by addressing user feedback promptly, ensuring that any reported
issues are swiftly resolved through software updates or product improvements. By
upholding a strong focus on quality, Apple can reinforce customer trust, loyalty, and
satisfaction, positioning its products as benchmarks of excellence in the market.

ADVERTISING:-

Apple’s advertising strategy is renowned for its creativity, simplicity, and ability to capture
consumers’ attention. The company has produced iconic ad campaigns that have become
part of popular culture. Apple’s advertising strategy focuses on highlighting product features,
emphasizing user experiences, and creating an emotional connection with the audience.
Let’s explore the key elements of Apple’s advertising strategy.

9
 1. Product-centric Approach: Apple’s advertising strategy centers around showcasing
its products and their unique features. The company highlights the design,
functionality, and user-friendly interfaces of its devices in a visually appealing
manner. Apple’s ads often feature close-ups of the products, emphasizing their sleek
designs and cutting-edge technology. This approach allows consumers to envision
themselves using the products and experiencing the benefits they offer.

In an interview with The New York Times, Ken Segall, the creative director behind Apple’s
iconic “Think Different” campaign, stated, “Apple’s ads have always been about the product.
It’s always been about the experience of using the product, not about the product itself.”

2. Storytelling and Emotion: Apple’s advertising strategy effectively uses storytelling to

create an emotional connection with the audience. The company’s commercials
often tell compelling narratives that resonate with consumers on a deeper level.
These stories often highlight how Apple products enhance people’s lives, evoke
emotions, or solve problems. By engaging viewers emotionally, Apple ads leave a
lasting impression and strengthen the brand-consumer relationship.

According to a study conducted by Nielsen, ads with high emotional impact are more likely
to be remembered and positively influence purchase intent. Apple’s storytelling approach in
advertising helps create a lasting impact on consumers.

3. Simplicity and Minimalism: Apple’s advertising stands out for its simplicity and
minimalistic approach. The company embraces clean visuals, concise messaging,
and a minimalist design aesthetic. By keeping the focus on the product and reducing
clutter, Apple’s ads deliver a clear and memorable message. This simplicity not only
aligns with the brand’s core values but also allows the audience to easily understand
the product’s value proposition.

10
 FACTORS FOR PRICING STABILITY OF APPLE WHEN
DEMAND AND COST CHANGES:-
Several factors contribute to the price stability of Apple mobile devices within the
oligopoly market structure, where prices remain relatively constant despite changes in
demand and costs:

1. Inelastic Demand and Brand Loyalty:

 Apple enjoys a highly loyal customer base, and demand for its products tends to be
inelastic. Even with changes in demand, Apple customers are often willing to pay a
premium for the brand, contributing to price stability.

2. Premium Brand Image:

 Apple has cultivated a premium brand image associated with innovation, quality, and
design. This premium positioning allows Apple to maintain stable prices as consumers
associate higher prices with superior product value.

3. Controlled Distribution Channels:

 Apple exercises strict control over its distribution channels, ensuring uniform pricing
across various retailers. This control minimizes the impact of fluctuations in demand and
costs on the final retail prices.

4. Limited Price Wars in Oligopoly:

 Oligopolistic markets often experience limited price wars due to the interdependence of
major players. Apple, along with other key competitors, recognizes the importance of
maintaining stable prices to sustain profitability, contributing to overall price stability.

5. Cost Efficiency and Economies of Scale:

 Apple's efficient supply chain management and economies of scale enable the company
to negotiate favorable terms with suppliers and control production costs effectively. This
cost efficiency helps Apple absorb changes in costs without passing them on to
consumers through price fluctuations.

6. Strategic Product Differentiation:

11
 Apple strategically differentiates its products through design, features, and ecosystem
integration. This differentiation allows Apple to position its products uniquely, reducing
the direct impact of cost changes on consumer pricing.

7. Tiered Pricing Strategy:

 Apple employs a tiered pricing strategy, offering a range of devices at different price
points. This approach allows Apple to cater to diverse consumer segments and adjust
prices strategically without significant impact on overall price stability.

8. Long Product Life Cycles:

 Apple tends to maintain stable prices for an extended period, particularly during the life
cycle of a specific product. Prices remain constant, even as demand and costs may
fluctuate, providing a sense of consistency to consumers.

9. Continuous Innovation and Value Addition:

 Apple's commitment to continuous innovation and value addition contributes to price

stability. As the company introduces new features and technologies, consumers
perceive ongoing value in Apple products, justifying stable prices despite changing
market conditions.

10. Market Positioning and Exclusivity:

 Apple strategically positions itself as a provider of exclusive, high-end products. This

positioning, combined with a focus on creating a sense of exclusivity, contributes to
stable prices as consumers are willing to pay for the perceived unique value offered by
Apple.

12
METHODOLOGY
A research process consists of stages or steps that guide the projects from its
conception through the final analysis, recommendations and ultimate actions. The
research process provides a systematic planned approach to the research project and
ensures that all the aspects of research process are consistent with each other.
Research studies evolve through a series of steps, each representing the answer to a
key question.

Introduction:

This chapter aims to understand the research methodology establishing a framework of

evaluation and revaluation of secondary research. This technique and concepts used
during Secondary research in order to arrive at findings, which are also dealt with and
lead to a logical deduction towards the analysis and results.

Exploratory Research:

The method I used for exploratory reseach was Primay Data and Secondary Data.

Primary Data:

New data gathered to help solve the problem at hand. As compared to secondry data
which is previously gathered data. An example is information gathered by questionnaire.
Qualitative or quantitative data that are newly collected in course of research, consists
of original information that comes from people and includes information gathered from
surveys, focus groups, independent observations and test results. Data gathered by the
researchers in the act of conducting research. This is contrasted to the secondary data,
which entails the use of data gathered by someone other than the researcher
information that is obtained directly from first hand sources by means of surveys,
observations or experimentation. Primary data is basically collected by getting
questionnaire filled by the respondents

Secondry Data:

Information that already exists somewhere, having been collected for another purpose.
Sources includes census reports, trade publications and subscription services. There

13
are two types of secondary data: internal and external secondary data. Information
compiled inside or outside the organization for some purpose other than the current
investigation, researching information which has already been published? Market
information compiled for purposes other than the current research effort, It can be
Secondary source of data used consists of books and websites. conduct a intensive
secondary research to understand the full impact and implication of the industry, to
review and critique the industry norms and reports, on which certain issues shall be
selected, which I feel remain unanswered or liable to change this shall be further taken
up in the next stage of exploratory research.

Data Collection:-

Data collection took place with the help of filling of questionnaires. The questionnaire
method has come to the more widely used and economical means of data collection.
The common factor in all varieties of the questionnaire method is this reliance on verbal
responses to questions, written . I found it essential to make sure the questionnaire was
easy to read and understand to all spectrums of people in the sample. It was also
important as researcher to respect the samples time and energy hence the
questionnaire was design in such a way, that its administration would not exceeds 4-5
minutes. This questionnaire was personally administered. The first hand information
was collected by making the people to fill the questionnaires. The data was collected by
interacting with 10 respondent who filled the questionnaire and gave me the required
necessary information.

14
DATA COLLECTION AND DATA ANALYSIS:-

15
16
17
18
FINDINGS:-
Majority of peoples about 60% said that Innovations and Thinking are the key
element of Apple's product differentiation strategy.

70% Respondent said that Memorable logo and Marketing campaign are the main
way of Differentiation its product through Branding.

80% of Respondents think that Brand loyalty and Perceived value is a significant
factor contributing to Apple's premium pricing strategy.

50% said Offering generic feature and 50% said Quality control measure is the Apple
ensure product quality differentiation.

According to survey 55.6% of the respondent said that In an oligopoly market, firms
like Apple might engage in Perfect Competition

60% of the people said that A Strict Control distribution channel make the price
stable.

About 40% Respondent said that Monopolist Competition is a economic concept

suggests that no firm has an incentive to unilaterally change its strategy, contributing
to price stability.

19
 LIMITATIONS OF THE PROJECT:-
Questionnaire Error
 The questionnaire designing has to be careful so that only required data is
concisely revealed and there is no redundant data generated. The questions have
to be worked carefully so that the questions are not loaded and does not lead to a
bias in the respondents mind.

Respondent Error

 The respondent selected to be interviewed were not always available and willing
to cooperate also in the most cases the respondent were found to not have the
knowledge, opinion, attitudes or facts required additionally uninformed resonse
errors and response styles also lead to survey error.
Sampling Error
 We have taken the sample size of 14, which cannot determine the buying
behavior of the total population.

20
Conclusion

In conclusion, Apple operates in an oligopoly market structure, where a small number of

dominant firms wield considerable market influence. The tech giant differentiates its
products through a multifaceted approach, combining strong branding, emphasis on
quality, strategic pricing strategies, and innovation. Apple's brand image, characterized
by sleek design and user-friendly interfaces, sets it apart in the competitive landscape.
The commitment to high-quality materials and cutting-edge technology further enhances
product differentiation. Pricing strategies, such as maintaining premium prices for
flagship devices, contribute to the perception of exclusivity and superior value. Despite
fluctuations in demand and production costs, Apple has demonstrated a remarkable
ability to maintain price stability. This can be attributed to brand loyalty, perceived
product value, and the company's strategic control over supply chains. Apple's success
in achieving price stability amid changing market conditions serves as a testament to
the effectiveness of its differentiation strategies and market positioning.

21
References:-

www.wikipediaapple.com

WWW.GOOGLE.COM

WWW.HUL.COM

www.thegef.org

www.writtingbros.com

22
Synopsis of Managerial Economics

Title:-
Oligopoly market structure ofmobile industry on APPLE .lnc
Company Profile:

Provide an in-depth overview of APPLE INC, exploring its history, mission, vision, and
current standing in the mobile industry.

Introduction:

As we delve into the company's profile within this oligopolistic environment, key
elements emerge, highlighting Apple's strategic position, competitive dynamics, and
influential role in shaping the trajectory of the industry.

Objectives:

The primary objectives of the industry APPLE Inc are: Comprehensive analysis of
oligopoly market structure, Understanding product differentiation strategies with a focus
on APPLE, Quality, Branding strategy, Factors contributing to price stability.

Background of The Study:

Apple Inc., founded in 1976 by Steve Jobs, Steve Wozniak, and Ronald Wayne, is a
multinational technology company headquartered in Cupertino, California. Renowned
for its innovative and design-focused approach, Apple has become a global leader in
consumer electronics, producing iconic products such as the iPhone, iPad, Mac, and
Apple Watch.

Methodology:

A concise overview of Apple Inc.'s methodology, highlighting its commitment to

innovation, design, user experience, and strategic decision-making within the
competitive landscape.

Data Collection:

Detail the sources and techniques used to collect primary and secondary data, focusing
on aspects such as market trends, consumer preferences, and technological
advancements.

Data Analysis and Interpretation:

23
Present the analytical tools and methods applied to interpret the collected data.Apple
Inc. strategically employs data analysis across diverse aspects of its business,
emphasizing the role of data-driven decision-making in enhancing customer
experiences, optimizing operations, and driving innovation within the technology sector.

Findings:

Report the key findings related to Apple Inc., offering insights into the company's
financial strength, strategic focus on innovation, ecosystem integration, global
leadership, and commitment to sustainability and social responsibility.

Conclusion:

As a prominent player in the oligopoly market structure, Apple Inc. leverages its market
power, brand strength, and innovative prowess to shape industry dynamics. The
company's ability to maintain a stable market position, set premium prices, and
influence technological trends underscores its significance within the oligopolistic
landscape. Ongoing challenges and adaptive strategies highlight the dynamic nature of
Apple's role in this competitive environment.

24
25