Professional Documents
Culture Documents
00-An Examination of Mental Health - Perceived Barriers - and Outreach Recommendations Amongrural C
00-An Examination of Mental Health - Perceived Barriers - and Outreach Recommendations Amongrural C
00-An Examination of Mental Health - Perceived Barriers - and Outreach Recommendations Amongrural C
To cite this article: Kristin Reid, N. Armstrong, D. Todd, L. Ballard, C. Szczepaniak & C. Tinsley
(2021) An Examination of Mental Health, Perceived Barriers, and Outreach Recommendations
amongRural College Students, American Journal of Health Education, 52:2, 101-110, DOI:
10.1080/19325037.2021.1877220
Background
the CCMH report suggested treatment sessions with
Mental health concerns for the collegial population are campus counseling ranges from 2–10 sessions with an
noted throughout the literature with a recent focus and average of 4.5 sessions.4
attention on assessment, interventions and outreach.1 Disparities among rural populations have long been
From a national perspective, suicide was the second established. Similarly, these disparities are also common
leading cause of death within the 10–34-year-old popu among rural college students. These disparities include
lation in 2016.2 In 2017, the Center for Collegiate Mental lower family incomes, poorer health status, and limited
Health (CCMH) reported that 34.2% of the collegial healthcare resources. Rural populations have higher
population have considered suicide.3 Additionally, it levels of poverty when compared to urban areas. It is
was reported in 2014 that approximately 86% of college estimated that 18% of rural populations live in poverty
students that completed suicide did not previously seek compared to 17% in urban populations.9
treatment from a college-based counseling service.4 The lower family incomes experienced among rural
Anxiety and depression have been reported as the college students often results in these students seeking
top two mental health concerns for this population.5,6 employment while enrolled in college full-time. It is
Other concerns reveal stressors related to academic estimated that 70% of college students work with vary
performance, and pressures to succeed are common.7 ing degrees of hours; however, 26% of low-income stu
Gibbons et al., identified the top mental health issues dents work full-time while in college compared to 22%
from a sample of 822 full time graduate and under of those students with high family incomes.10
graduate students and identified; work/school/social Working full time while juggling college may result in
balance (55.4%), stress management (52.7%), and higher levels of stress which may lead to an increased
depression/anxiety (46.9%) as the top three concerns; risk for mental health problems in rural college students.
however (32.5%) of the participants reported that they It is well known that mental health problems have
would “not likely” seek help.8 In reference to support, increased among college students. It is reported that
CONTACT Kristin Reid kreid3@murraystate.edu Murray State University, SONHP, Mason Hall, Murray, KY 42071
© 2021 SHAPE America
102 K. REID ET AL.
respond. None responded as Native Hawaiian or other interfered with daily activities in the past four weeks,
Pacific Islander. and how much time physical or emotional health pro
The majority of students that responded to the survey blems interfered with social activities in the past four
were majoring in education with 19.96% (n = 108) of the weeks. The coping and support systems assessment of
sample. Other majors that were represented included the survey consisted of questions that asked students
18.67% (n = 101) business majors; 13.49% (n = 73) how likely they were to seek help, where do they seek
agriculture; 17.01% (n = 92) science, engineering, and mental and/or emotional support, how much others care
technology; 21.07% (n = 114) humanities and fine arts; about them, and how they cope with stress. Campus
4.44% (n = 24) nursing; 5.36% (n = 29) health profes resources and recommendation questions included
sions; and 6 did not answer. campus mental health resources students were familiar
with, what mental health topics required more informa
tion and how the information should be shared, and
Procedures
what barriers students experienced when seeking mental
This study was designed to examine the perceived health assistance.
mental health concerns among college students, their
perceived barriers to access, and outreach recommenda
Results
tions. Permission was received from Gibbons et al to
adapt the original survey with minor revision which Participants ranked typical college stressors from the
included shortening of the survey (Appendix). The ter most to least stressful on an individual basis using
minology within the survey was modified to better fit a Likert scale from 1 (low stress) to 5 (most stress).
with a rural, public university. For example, the The stressors assessed were coping with roommates/
researchers were not interested in first generation col living conditions; living separate from family; balancing
lege students during this survey or what religious school work with job hours; making ends meet finan
denomination they were affiliated with currently. The cially; their academic load (grades, credits, exams,
study was reviewed by the institutional review board papers); social needs (friends, family, etc.); health sta
(IRB) and deemed exempt from IRB oversight. An tus/health issues; food, body image, and weight issues;
e-mail was sent to all students that included an explana transportation; parental issues/childcare issues; girl
tion of the purpose and methodology of the study with friend/boyfriend/other significant relationship issues;
an invitation to participate, as well as the link to access technology problems (Facebook updates, text messages,
the survey. The students accessed the survey through etc.); purpose-in-life issues/figuring out what to do for
a SurveyMonkey link. Participation was voluntary and a major or after graduation; and religion/spirituality.
completion of the survey implied consent. The survey The findings revealed that 28.81% (n = 157) of partici
took approximately 10 minutes to complete and was pants reported making ends meet as a 5 (most stressful),
completed anonymously. There were no incentives to with another 24.22% (n = 132) rating it as a 4. Results
complete the survey. also showed academic load to be stressful, with 27.66%
(n = 151) rating it as a 5, and 32.23% (n = 176) rating it
as a 4. Other factors with high stress ratings included
Study questionnaire
food/body image/weight issues, balancing school work
The survey tool used was adapted from an untitled with job hours, and social needs.
survey developed by Gibbons, et al and had a reported Participants were also asked questions regarding their
Cronbach’s alpha score of 0.75.8 The survey consisted of mental health. Participants were asked to select their
four sections that included perceptions of mental health, perceptions of the most common mental and emotional
self-reported mental or emotional health problems, cop health issues on campus. The choices were: stress, anxi
ing and support systems, and campus resources and ety, depression, pornography, addictions, eating disor
recommendations. Perceptions of mental health ders, perfectionism, financial stress, PTSD, transitioning
included questions that required the students to rank into adulthood/college, and other. The results revealed
their typical life stressors and the biggest mental and that students perceived stress at 77.80% (n = 424) and
emotional health issues on campus. Self-reported mental anxiety at 76.70% (n = 418) as the top perceived mental
or emotional health problems were assessed through health conditions on campus. Additionally, 65.87%
a series of questions that asked the student to self- (n = 359) of participants felt that depression and finan
report mental or emotional problems that persisted for cial stress at 42.02% (n = 229) were common among
more than two weeks, when the mental or emotional college peers. Participants were also asked if they have
problems began, if the mental or emotional problems ever experienced mental or emotional problems that
104 K. REID ET AL.
persisted for more than two weeks. An overwhelming “I sometimes go to,” and “I usually go to.” Participants
72.71% (n = 397) responded yes followed by 18.68% were most likely to go to family or roommates/friends,
(n = 102) responding no, 8.61% (n = 47) responding with 31.71% (n = 156) responding that they usually go to
unsure, and one did not respond. When asked when family and 31.02% (n = 152) usually going to friends.
they first remember experiencing mental or emotional They were unlikely to go to any counseling or
problems that persisted more than two weeks, 396 par a professor/staff member, with 82.89% (n = 407)
ticipants responded. The majority of students 63.89% responding that they would never go to on campus
(n = 253) responded that they had experienced mental counseling, 77.64% (n = 382) would never go to off
or emotional problems before college, 32.07% (n = 127) campus counseling, and 81.26% (n = 399) would never
while at college, and 4.04% (n = 16) were unsure. go to a professor/staff member.
Another mental health question participants were A Likert scale was created to determine how much
asked was, “During the past four weeks, have you had they think family, friends, roommates, teachers/profes
any of the following mental health problems with your sors/advisers, spiritual/religious leaders, employer/boss/
work or other regular daily activities as a result of any supervisor at an on-campus job, and employer/boss/
emotional problems (such as feeling depressed or supervisor at an off-campus job care about them as
anxious)?” Given the options, 61.51% (n = 302) reported a person, with 1 being low interest and 5 being high
cutting down the amount of time they spent on school, interest. Participants rated family as having the most
work, or other activities; 80.20% (n = 393) accomplished interest in them with 69.11% (n = 340) rating family at
less than they would like; and 62.86% (n = 308) did not a 5 (high interest). They rated teachers/professors/advi
do school, work, or other activities as carefully as usual sers as neutral, with 34.08% (n = 167) rating them at a 3
as a result of emotional problems. out of 5.
The survey also questioned how their physical health Participants were asked what mental health/potential
or emotional problems had interfered with social activ stressors topics they would like more information about
ities, such as visiting with friends or relatives, in the past and allowed to choose all that apply from a list of:
four weeks. 37.22% (n = 182) responded some of the balancing finances; balancing work, school, and family
time; 23.31% (n = 114) a little of the time; 17.59% life; managing stress associated with school; dating,
(n = 86) most of the time; 14.11% (n = 69) none of the social, and/or romantic relationships; religion/spiritual
time, 7.77% (n = 38) all of the time; and 58 did not ity; physical health; sexual assault prevention; how to
respond. Participants were also asked how they usually support a family member or friend with a mental/emo
cope with stress/psychological issues, being instructed to tional health issue; coping strategies for mental and/or
check all that apply. They were given the options for emotional health; understanding depression, stress, and/
coping skills of sleep, exercise, eat, cry, spend money, or anxiety; how to overcome addictions; understanding
hold things in, yell at or blame others, ignore the feelings mental health problems; and other(Table 2). The top five
and hope they pass, talk to friends/family, avoid friends choices for participants were managing stress associated
(social isolation), stop attending school/work, negative with school at 56.79% (n = 230); coping strategies for
self-talk, listen to music, clean their house, do nothing, mental and/or emotional health at 56.54% (n = 229);
and crafting. They responded in regards to how often balancing work, school, and family life at 52.59%
they use these coping skills: never, sometimes, and (n = 213); understanding depression, stress, and/or anxi
usually. The most commonly “usually” used coping ety at 51.60% (n = 290); and balancing finances at
skills were holding things in at 55.69% (n = 274); listen 47.41% (n = 192). They were also offered to report how
ing to music at 45.82% (n = 225); ignore the feelings and they would like to receive this information, with options
hope they will pass at 40.45% (n = 199); cry at 30.08% of e-mailed newsletters, on campus seminars, campus
(n = 148); and sleep at 34.35% (n = 169). activities, a campus course, webinar or Youtube, social
Participants were also asked if they have a mental/ media, or other. They were asked to select up to three
emotional health concern, how likely they are to seek (Table 3). The three most popular choices were e-mail
help. 15.24% (n = 75) participants said they were very
likely, 43.29% (n = 211) were somewhat likely, 34.55%
(n = 170) were unlikely, and 6.91% (n = 34) would never Table 2. Top five topic students reported they would like more
seek help. 55 participants did not respond. To assess information about.
where participants go for help, they were asked, Managing stress associated with school 56.79% (n = 230)
Coping strategies for mental and/or emotional health 56.54% (n = 229)
“Which of the following best describes who/where you Balancing work, school, and family life 52.59% (n = 213)
go when in need of mental and/or emotional support?” Understanding depression, stress, and/or anxiety 51.60% (n = 290)
They were given options with answers of “I never go to,” Balancing finances 47.41% (n = 192)
AN EXAMINATION OF MENTAL HEALTH, PERCEIVED BARRIERS, AND OUTREACH RECOMMENDATIONS 105
Table 3. Top three outreach methods reported. stress often have a negative impact on academic
E-Mail newsletter 61.90% (n = 247) performance.7,20 The most common coping mechan
Social media 45.11% (n = 180)
Webinar or Youtube 36.59% (n = 146) isms that the participants reported that they used to
deal with stressors were “holding things in,” and “ignor
ing feelings and hoping that they go away.”
newsletter at 61.90% (n = 247), social media at 45.11% Unfortunately, these strategies are generally considered
(n = 180), and webinar or Youtube at 36.59% (n = 146). deleterious and may result in feeling a loss of control.20
Finally, participants were asked about barriers which Most of the participants reported limited awareness of
students who are seeking help for psychological issues mental health resources on campus. This occurred despite
face (Figure 1). The options were: not sure of available efforts by the university to make students aware of available
resources, too ashamed, worried about what other people resources through content inclusion in new student orien
will think, no support from friends and family to get treat tation and various forms of advertisement. When the par
ment, cost associated with treatment, and not enough time. ticipants were given an opportunity to select mental health
Participants were given the option of “this is not a major and wellness education topics of which they would like
barrier” or “this is a major barrier.” The top three reported more information, the top selected items included financial
barriers were worried about what other people think at management and budgeting, maintaining a work-life-
86.91% (n = 425), too ashamed at 86.50% (n = 423), and school balance, managing stress, developing coping strate
not enough time at 81.07% (n = 394). gies, and understanding depression and anxiety. These
subjects correlated well with the most commonly reported
sources of stress and the most common mental health and
Discussion
emotional issues reported by the participants. The partici
This study sought to discover the mental health and well pants reported that they preferred that this information be
ness issues affecting students at one rural university in the shared via electronic resources, such as e-mail, webinars,
United States. Study participants reported that their major and less commonly, social media. Electronic delivery meth
sources of stress were financial strains and academic per ods have been found to be effective in promoting student
formance pressures, along with body image and food mental health and wellness.21,22
related issues to a lesser degree. These sources of stress are One of the main limitations of this study is that it was
consistent with findings in other studies of college students conducted at one university, using a convenience sample
in the United States.16–18 The most common mental and of students. As well, the study relied on self-reported
emotional health issues affecting the participants included data, which may not match the true mental health issues
stress, anxiety, depression, and financial strain. These find and lifestyles of the students. It would be helpful to see
ings are similar to those found in previous studies.7,19 this study expanded to generalize the results. However,
Around half of the participants had experienced emo the survey has been used in another study at a separate
tional problems that had caused a reduced performance university, which was not rural and in a different region
at work or school. Past studies focused on college stu of the United States.8 The findings in the original study
dent mental health found that anxiety, depression, and were consistent with the findings in this study in many
Figure 1. Barriers.
106 K. REID ET AL.
areas. Similarities between the two studies included the a mental health course create short educational videos
most prevalent items reported as: sources of stress, discussing some of the areas of concern for this popula
mental health and emotional issues, and the delivery tion of college students, such as managing stress or
methods in which the students would like to receive dealing with anxiety, and provide information about
mental health education. This strengthens the findings campus and vetted outside resources that can help stu
of this study. dents manage common mental health concerns and
other social stressors. The videos will also assist students
in finding assistance if their personal resources are insuf
Translation to Health Education Practice ficient to deal with stressors or mental health issues. The
This study, in combination with the outcomes from the plan is to complete a pilot study sharing this information
original study using the survey developed by Gibbons and with nursing students only, eventually expanding the
colleagues, can assist mental health professionals and release to students campus wide. Health educators and
health educators in focusing their resources in working Certified Health Education Specialists can conduct simi
with college students.8 Many of the students in this study lar research with their patient populations, so that they
reported that they were dealing with a variety of stressors can create a similar advocacy program, based on the best
and mental health issues to varying degrees. However, available evidence and the needs of the specific popula
there was a general lack of unawareness of the mental tion that they serve.
health resources available on campus. Health educators The students in this study stated that they would most
who work within institutions of higher education, or with like to receive information about topics related to mental
the college student population, need to make every effort to health and wellness, such as financial budgeting and
ensure that students are aware of the mental health and managing stress, through electronic methods. Campus
wellness resources that are available to students, utilizing health educators and mental health professionals should
effective methodologies. To reach students and assist them consider providing information on a routine basis about
in feeling more comfortable about using their services, The maintaining mental health and wellness through elec
College Marketing group recommends that health educa tronic resources, such as electronic newsletters, e-mails,
tors and mental health specialists use social media out or webinars. Electronic mental health education videos
reach, create videos with the assistance of marketing that are readily accessible to students as needed, such as
specialists, normalize mental health struggles in their con through a cell phone app, have been found to be useful
tent, and utilize student ambassadors.23 Whatever the in reaching students and assisting them in reducing
method, health educators in the college or university set stress, as well as responding to other common mental
ting need to make sure that students are aware of the health issues.25 In addition, health educators who work
mental health resources that are available to students. within universities or colleges might consider conduct
Health Educators and Certified Health Education ing their own yearly mental health surveys with stu
Specialists who work with the college student population dents, in order to tailor their health education to best
can use this study as a framework for discerning the meet the needs of their student population. Finally,
health needs of the populations that they serve. This health educators might find it helpful to provide educa
study focused on the Assessment of Needs and tion to professors and staff about common mental health
Capacity from the Eight Areas of Responsibility for issues and stressors in college students to increase aware
Health Educator Specialists from the National ness, as well as to ensure that faculty and staff are aware of
Commission for Health Education Credentially resources that are available to help students develop skills
(NCHEC).24 The researchers obtained data from the to respond to these stressors and issues. As previously
college student population about their perceived mental discussed, rates of depression and anxiety, as well as
health issues and social stressors. This included obtain suicide rates in college students have been increasing at
ing data from sources, analyzing the health of priority alarming rates in the United States. It is imperative that
populations, and synthesizing the findings to inform the universities develop tools to evaluate and respond to
planning process, which are all subheadings of the stressors and mental health issues in a manner that is
Assessments of Needs and Capacity area. In addition, effective and ensures that college students in need of
the area of Advocacy was a focus of this research, as it help are aware of how to access those resources.
helped to identify current or emerging health issues that
require change within this population of students.
Disclosure statement
The researchers plan to use the data from this study
to create an intervention, in which nursing students in No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
AN EXAMINATION OF MENTAL HEALTH, PERCEIVED BARRIERS, AND OUTREACH RECOMMENDATIONS 107
● Yes (1) If Yes Is Not Selected, Skip to Q12 “During the past
● No (2) 4 weeks, have you had . . . ”
Q11 When do you first remember experiencing mental
Q7 What ethnicity do you identify with most? or emotional problems that persisted for more than
2 weeks?
● White/Caucasian (1)
● Black/African American (2) ● Before college (1)
● Asian (3) ● At college (2)
● Hispanic/Latino (4) ● Unsure (3)
● Pacific Islander (5)
● Native American (6) Q12 During the past 4 weeks, have you had any of the
● Multiracial (7) following mental health problems with your work or
● Other (8) ____________________ other regular daily activities as a result of any emotional
● Prefer not to answer (9) problems (such as feeling depressed or anxious)?
AN EXAMINATION OF MENTAL HEALTH, PERCEIVED BARRIERS, AND OUTREACH RECOMMENDATIONS 109
I sometimes use Q17 Which of the following best describes who/where you
I never use this this method to I usually use this go when in need of mental and/or emotional support?
method to cope cope with stress method to cope
with stress (1) (2) with stress (3)
Sleep (1) ● ● ● I never go I sometimes go I usually go
to (1) to (2) to (3)
Exercise (2) ● ● ●
Eat (3) ● ● ● Spiritual/religious leader ● ● ●
(1)
Cry (4) ● ● ●
Family (2) ● ● ●
Spend money ● ● ●
(5) Roommates/friends (3) ● ● ●
Hold things in ● ● ● On campus counseling (4) ● ● ●
(6) Off campus counseling (5) ● ● ●
Yell at or blame ● ● ● Professor or other staff ● ● ●
others (7) member (6)
Ignore the ● ● ● Other (7) ● ● ●
feelings and
hope they
will pass (8)
Talk to friends/ ● ● ●
family (9)
Avoid friends ● ● ●
(social Q18 How much do you think the following individuals
isolation) (10) or groups care about you as a person (1 being low interest
Stop attending ● ● ● in you as a person and 5 being high interest in you as
school/work a person)
(11)
Negative self- ● ● ● Not
talk (12) (Low) 2 3 4 (High) Applicable
Listen to music ● ● ● 1 (1) (2) (3) (4) 5 (5) (6)
(13) Family (1) ● ● ● ● ● ●
Clean my house ● ● ● Roommates (2) ● ● ● ● ● ●
(14) Friends (3) ● ● ● ● ● ●
Do nothing (15) ● ● ● Teachers/professors/advisors ● ● ● ● ● ●
Crafting (16) ● ● ● (4)
Other (17) ● ● ● Spiritual/religious leader (5) ● ● ● ● ● ●
Please Define Employer/boss/supervisor of ● ● ● ● ● ●
Other, list up an on-campus job (6)
to 3 items Employer/boss/supervisor of ● ● ● ● ● ●
(18) an off-campus job (7)
110 K. REID ET AL.
Q19 What mental health (or potential stressors) topics do ● Campus activities (3)
you want more information about? (Choose all that apply.) ● Campus course (4)
● Webinar or YouTube video (5)
● Balancing finances (1) ● Social media (6)
● Balancing work, school, and family life (2) ● Other (7) ____________________
● Managing stress associated with school (3)
● Dating, social, and/or romantic relationships (4) Q21 What are some barriers that students who are seeking
● Religion/spirituality (5) help for psychological issues face?
● Physical health (6)
● Sexual assault prevention (7)
● How to support a family member or friend with a mental/ This is NOT This IS a major
emotional health issue (8) a major barrier (1) barrier (2)
● Coping strategies for mental and/or emotional health (9) Not sure of available resources (1) ● ●
● Understanding depression, stress, and/or anxiety (10) Too ashamed (2) ● ●
● How to overcome addictions (11) Worried about what other people ● ●
will think (3)
● Understanding mental health problems (12)
● Other (13) ____________________ No support from friends and ● ●
family to get treatment (4)
Cost associated with treatment (5) ● ●
Q20 How would you like to hear about these topics?
Not enough time (6) ● ●
Check up to three (3) responses.
Other (7) ● ●
● E-Mail newsletters (1)
● On campus seminars (2) Survey modified with permission from Gibbons et al.8